Wojciech W. Grabowski
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Wojciech W. Grabowski has a total of 63 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Hanna Pawlowska
Institute of Geophysics, Faculty of Physics, University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
10 shared publications Hugh Morrison
MMM Laboratory, NSF National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, Colorado
7 shared publications- Bipin Kumar
Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, Ministry of Earth Sciences, Government of India, Pune, India
4 shared publications Lois Thomas
HPCS, Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, Ministry of Earth Sciences, Pune, India
4 shared publications- Lulin Xue
NSF National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder CO USA
4 shared publications - Shin-Ichiro Shima
Graduate School of Information Science, University of Hyogo, Kobe, Japan
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 August 2025
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 82 (8) , 1585-1599
Untangling the Broadening of Adiabatic Cloud Droplet Spectra through Eddy Hopping in a High-Resolution Cumulus Congestus Simulation
Turbulence has long been considered an important source of droplet spectral broadening in adiabatic volumes of warm convective clouds. The key idea is that, in a turbulent environment, droplets follow different trajectories, and this leads to wide droplet spectra for droplets arriving at a given location inside a cloud. This has been referred to as eddy hopping. Past theoretical studies and idealized turbulence simulations applying direct numerical simulation (DNS)-like approaches suggested that eddy hopping can potentially explain the difference between the observed droplet spectra and those predicted from adiabatic ascent in a nonturbulent volume. This paper considers droplet spectra in an adiabatic volume not far from the cloud base in an unprecedented high-resolution (7.5-m grid length) three-dimensional (3D) simulation of a warm turbulent cumulus congestus cloud applying Lagrangian particle–based microphysics. The spectral width approaches several tenths of 1 µm in the 3D simulation versus only up to 0.2 µm in a reference nonturbulent adiabatic parcel. We apply an idealized one-dimensional stochastic cloud updraft model that either excludes or includes turbulent vertical velocity fluctuations to show how the fluctuations affect cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and subsequent growth of cloud droplets. Droplet spectra are significantly wider when effects of turbulence are included. The more complete droplet growth equation that includes kinetic, surface tension, and solute effects above the cloud base significantly adds to the variability of cloud droplet growth in the turbulent flow and thus to the adiabatic spectral width at a given height within the simulated cloud. Significance Statement: The width of cloud droplet spectra has a significant impact on radiative transfer through a cloudy atmosphere and on drizzle and rain formation in natural clouds. Aircraft observations show that droplet spectra in undiluted or weakly diluted cloudy volumes are often wider than expected in an adiabatic parcel rising from the cloud base. In turbulent clouds, cloud droplets growing by the diffusion of water vapor experience different growth histories while following different turbulent eddies. This is what we mean by the eddy-hopping mechanism. This paper discusses eddy hopping as seen in a turbulence-resolving three-dimensional cloud simulation and in idealized one-dimensional cloud updraft simulations that provide context for the three-dimensional cloud model results.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 82 (8) , 1585-1599
Untangling the Broadening of Adiabatic Cloud Droplet Spectra through Eddy Hopping in a High-Resolution Cumulus Congestus Simulation
Turbulence has long been considered an important source of droplet spectral broadening in adiabatic volumes of warm convective clouds. The key idea is that, in a turbulent environment, droplets follow different trajectories, and this leads to wide droplet spectra for droplets arriving at a given location inside a cloud. This has been referred to as eddy hopping. Past theoretical studies and idealized turbulence simulations applying direct numerical simulation (DNS)-like approaches suggested that eddy hopping can potentially explain the difference between the observed droplet spectra and those predicted from adiabatic ascent in a nonturbulent volume. This paper considers droplet spectra in an adiabatic volume not far from the cloud base in an unprecedented high-resolution (7.5-m grid length) three-dimensional (3D) simulation of a warm turbulent cumulus congestus cloud applying Lagrangian particle–based microphysics. The spectral width approaches several tenths of 1 µm in the 3D simulation versus only up to 0.2 µm in a reference nonturbulent adiabatic parcel. We apply an idealized one-dimensional stochastic cloud updraft model that either excludes or includes turbulent vertical velocity fluctuations to show how the fluctuations affect cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and subsequent growth of cloud droplets. Droplet spectra are significantly wider when effects of turbulence are included. The more complete droplet growth equation that includes kinetic, surface tension, and solute effects above the cloud base significantly adds to the variability of cloud droplet growth in the turbulent flow and thus to the adiabatic spectral width at a given height within the simulated cloud. Significance Statement: The width of cloud droplet spectra has a significant impact on radiative transfer through a cloudy atmosphere and on drizzle and rain formation in natural clouds. Aircraft observations show that droplet spectra in undiluted or weakly diluted cloudy volumes are often wider than expected in an adiabatic parcel rising from the cloud base. In turbulent clouds, cloud droplets growing by the diffusion of water vapor experience different growth histories while following different turbulent eddies. This is what we mean by the eddy-hopping mechanism. This paper discusses eddy hopping as seen in a turbulence-resolving three-dimensional cloud simulation and in idealized one-dimensional cloud updraft simulations that provide context for the three-dimensional cloud model results.
- Open Access
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (10) , 5273-5285
Technical note: Phase space depiction of cloud condensation nuclei activation and cloud droplet diffusional growth
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict (in a straightforward way) key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation as well as haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (10) , 5273-5285
Open AccessTechnical note: Phase space depiction of cloud condensation nuclei activation and cloud droplet diffusional growth
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict (in a straightforward way) key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation as well as haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Reply on RC2
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 4 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Open AccessReply on RC2
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- Open Access
- 2 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Comment on egusphere-2024-4104
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 2 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-4104
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- Open Access
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Reply on RC1
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 17 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Open AccessReply on RC1
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- Open Access
- 9 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Comment on egusphere-2024-4104
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 9 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-4104
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 1 February 2025
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 82 (2) , 443-453
Broadening of Cloud Droplet Spectra through Eddy Hopping: Why Did We All Have It Wrong?
In situ aircraft observations in adiabatic and close-to-adiabatic cloudy volumes suggest that cloud droplet spectra are often broader than predicted by growth of a droplet population rising from the cloud base. Cloud turbulence has been suggested as one of the possible mechanisms for the observed spectral broadening. This paper reviews computational studies of the impact of cloud turbulence on the diffusional growth of cloud droplets in adiabatic cloudy volumes. These studies typically apply direct numerical simulation (DNS) or scaled-up DNS approach to represent diffusional growth of cloud droplets embedded within homogeneous isotropic air turbulence. There is also a theory that predicts that the droplet spectral width continuously increases in time because of the individual droplet growth or evaporation within turbulent eddies. This mechanism has been referred to as eddy hopping. This paper expands the discussion in Prabhakaran et al. and illustrates the fundamental flaw of past computational and theoretical studies. These studies do not consider vertical dispersion of droplet positions that leads to growth of droplets that in the mean move upward and to evaporation of those that move downward. The theoretical prediction comes from confusing spectral broadening with the vertical dispersion of droplet positions when periodic lateral boundaries are used in DNS. Computational examples using a stochastic model mimicking eddy hopping show that droplet spectral width does not continuously increase in time, but it saturates at a small spread. Methodologies for appropriate numerical studies of the adiabatic spectral width evolution in natural clouds are discussed. Significance Statement: The width of the cloud droplet spectrum is an important parameter affecting radiative transfer through a cloudy atmosphere as well as drizzle and rain formation in natural clouds. Past in situ observations over the last several decades show that droplet spectra in undiluted or weakly diluted cloudy volumes are often wider than expected in an adiabatic parcel rising from the cloud base. Cloud turbulence can impact diffusional growth of cloud droplets through the mechanism we refer to as eddy hopping, that is, droplets growing and evaporating in turbulent eddies. That mechanism attracted attention in the last two decades and has been investigated in computational studies of droplet diffusional growth in a turbulent environment. We document a fundamental flaw of those previous studies and suggest a way forward to understand the impact of turbulence on droplet diffusional growth.
- 1 February 2025
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 82 (2) , 443-453
Broadening of Cloud Droplet Spectra through Eddy Hopping: Why Did We All Have It Wrong?
In situ aircraft observations in adiabatic and close-to-adiabatic cloudy volumes suggest that cloud droplet spectra are often broader than predicted by growth of a droplet population rising from the cloud base. Cloud turbulence has been suggested as one of the possible mechanisms for the observed spectral broadening. This paper reviews computational studies of the impact of cloud turbulence on the diffusional growth of cloud droplets in adiabatic cloudy volumes. These studies typically apply direct numerical simulation (DNS) or scaled-up DNS approach to represent diffusional growth of cloud droplets embedded within homogeneous isotropic air turbulence. There is also a theory that predicts that the droplet spectral width continuously increases in time because of the individual droplet growth or evaporation within turbulent eddies. This mechanism has been referred to as eddy hopping. This paper expands the discussion in Prabhakaran et al. and illustrates the fundamental flaw of past computational and theoretical studies. These studies do not consider vertical dispersion of droplet positions that leads to growth of droplets that in the mean move upward and to evaporation of those that move downward. The theoretical prediction comes from confusing spectral broadening with the vertical dispersion of droplet positions when periodic lateral boundaries are used in DNS. Computational examples using a stochastic model mimicking eddy hopping show that droplet spectral width does not continuously increase in time, but it saturates at a small spread. Methodologies for appropriate numerical studies of the adiabatic spectral width evolution in natural clouds are discussed. Significance Statement: The width of the cloud droplet spectrum is an important parameter affecting radiative transfer through a cloudy atmosphere as well as drizzle and rain formation in natural clouds. Past in situ observations over the last several decades show that droplet spectra in undiluted or weakly diluted cloudy volumes are often wider than expected in an adiabatic parcel rising from the cloud base. Cloud turbulence can impact diffusional growth of cloud droplets through the mechanism we refer to as eddy hopping, that is, droplets growing and evaporating in turbulent eddies. That mechanism attracted attention in the last two decades and has been investigated in computational studies of droplet diffusional growth in a turbulent environment. We document a fundamental flaw of those previous studies and suggest a way forward to understand the impact of turbulence on droplet diffusional growth.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Technical note: Phase space depiction of CCN activation and cloud droplet diffusional growth
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 21 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-19
Open AccessTechnical note: Phase space depiction of CCN activation and cloud droplet diffusional growth
A novel way to represent cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activation and cloud droplet growth by the diffusion of water vapor is introduced. The key is to apply a phase space diagram that plots the radius of a liquid droplet (deliquesced CCN or cloud droplet) versus the difference between the ambient supersaturation and the equilibrium supersaturation corresponding to the droplet radius. The latter combines the droplet and environmental characteristics, and it determines whether a droplet grows or evaporates. The diagram can be used to depict in a straightforward way key microphysical processes of CCN activation and deactivation, as well as a haze or cloud droplet transition from growth to evaporation. To show its utility, the diagram is applied to an idealized simulation of CCN activation and cloud droplet growth inside a rising turbulent air parcel and to simulations of microphysical processes inside a laboratory apparatus, the Pi cloud chamber. The adiabatic parcel mimics microphysical processes near the base of a natural cumulus or stratocumulus cloud. The Pi chamber simulations represent microphysical transformations in moist turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection with CCN proceeding through cycles of activation, growth, evaporation, and deactivation. A more general version of the phase diagram that is independent of the CCN dry radius is also developed. The phase diagram allows simple interpretations of key microphysical processes and highlights differences between droplet formation in natural and laboratory clouds.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 81 (7) , 1201-1212
CCN Activation and Droplet Growth in Pi Chamber Simulations with Lagrangian Particle–Based Microphysics
Numerical simulations of turbulent moist Rayleigh–Bénard convection driving CCN activation and droplet growth in the laboratory Pi chamber are discussed. Supersaturation fluctuations come from isobaric mixing of warm and humid air rising from the lower boundary with colder air featuring lower water vapor concentrations descending from the upper boundary. Lagrangian particle–based microphysics is used to represent the growth of haze CCN and cloud droplets with kinetic, solute, and surface tension effects included. Dry CCN spectra in the range between 2- and 200-nm radii from field observations are considered. Increasing the total CCN concentration from pristine to polluted conditions results in an increase in the droplet concentration and reduction in the mean droplet radius and spectral width. These are in agreement with Pi chamber observations and numerical simulations, as well as with numerous past studies of CCN cloud-base activation in natural clouds. The key result is that a relatively small fraction of the available CCN is activated in the Pi chamber fluctuating supersaturations, from about a half in the pristine case to only a 10th in the polluted case. The activation fraction as a function of the dry CCN radius is similar in all simulations, close to zero at the CCN small end, increasing to a maximum at CCN radius around 50 nm, and decreasing to close to zero at the large CCN end. This is explained as too small supersaturations to activate small CCN as in natural clouds and insufficient time to allow large CCN reaching the critical radius. Significance Statement: Impact of turbulence on the formation and growth of cloud droplets is an important cloud physics problem. Laboratory experiments in the Michigan Technological University cloud chamber provide key insights into this problem. Numerical simulations of cloud chamber processes discussed in this paper complement laboratory experiments by providing insights difficult or impossible to obtain in the laboratory. The study contrasts the formation and growth of cloud droplets in the laboratory cloud chamber with processes taking place in natural clouds. The differences documented in this paper pose questions concerning the impact of turbulence on the formation and growth of cloud droplets as a result of interactions of clouds with their environment.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Vol. 81 (7) , 1201-1212
CCN Activation and Droplet Growth in Pi Chamber Simulations with Lagrangian Particle–Based Microphysics
Numerical simulations of turbulent moist Rayleigh–Bénard convection driving CCN activation and droplet growth in the laboratory Pi chamber are discussed. Supersaturation fluctuations come from isobaric mixing of warm and humid air rising from the lower boundary with colder air featuring lower water vapor concentrations descending from the upper boundary. Lagrangian particle–based microphysics is used to represent the growth of haze CCN and cloud droplets with kinetic, solute, and surface tension effects included. Dry CCN spectra in the range between 2- and 200-nm radii from field observations are considered. Increasing the total CCN concentration from pristine to polluted conditions results in an increase in the droplet concentration and reduction in the mean droplet radius and spectral width. These are in agreement with Pi chamber observations and numerical simulations, as well as with numerous past studies of CCN cloud-base activation in natural clouds. The key result is that a relatively small fraction of the available CCN is activated in the Pi chamber fluctuating supersaturations, from about a half in the pristine case to only a 10th in the polluted case. The activation fraction as a function of the dry CCN radius is similar in all simulations, close to zero at the CCN small end, increasing to a maximum at CCN radius around 50 nm, and decreasing to close to zero at the large CCN end. This is explained as too small supersaturations to activate small CCN as in natural clouds and insufficient time to allow large CCN reaching the critical radius. Significance Statement: Impact of turbulence on the formation and growth of cloud droplets is an important cloud physics problem. Laboratory experiments in the Michigan Technological University cloud chamber provide key insights into this problem. Numerical simulations of cloud chamber processes discussed in this paper complement laboratory experiments by providing insights difficult or impossible to obtain in the laboratory. The study contrasts the formation and growth of cloud droplets in the laboratory cloud chamber with processes taking place in natural clouds. The differences documented in this paper pose questions concerning the impact of turbulence on the formation and growth of cloud droplets as a result of interactions of clouds with their environment.
- 1 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 149 (756) , 2800-2819
Daytime convective development over land: The role of surface forcing
Water availability at the Earth surface determines the portioning of the surface heat flux into its sensible and latent components, that is, the surface heat flux Bowen ratio. The two components affect differently the surface buoyancy flux and thus the development and growth of the convective boundary layer. As a result, the Bowen ratio has a strong impact on the daytime development of dry and moist convection over land. We use two canonical modeling test cases, one for the shallow convection and one for the shallow‐to‐deep convection transition, to document the impact of the surface Bowen ratio on daytime convection development. A simple approach is used where results from simulations featuring the original setup are contrasted with simulations where the surface‐sensible heat flux takes on values of the latent heat flux and vice versa. Such a change illustrates the key impact of the surface water availability without changing the total surface heat flux. Because of the larger surface buoyancy flux, simulations with the reversed surface heat fluxes feature faster deepening of the convective boundary layer and wider clouds once moist convection develops. Mean cloud‐base width of cumulus clouds increases with the boundary‐layer depth. For shallow‐to‐deep convection transition, comparison of simulations with the observed large‐scale flow that feature substantial lower‐tropospheric shear with simulations with no mean horizontal flow suggests that the organization of convective circulations within the boundary layer strongly affects initial size and organization of shallow convection, as well as the subsequent width increase once convection deepens and eventually transitions to deep precipitating convection. A simple explanation is provided of why a deeper well‐mixed convective subcloud layer results in wider clouds. The key is the larger width of boundary‐layer coherent updraft structures when the mixed layer is deeper.
- 1 August 2023
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 149 (756) , 2800-2819
Daytime convective development over land: The role of surface forcing
Water availability at the Earth surface determines the portioning of the surface heat flux into its sensible and latent components, that is, the surface heat flux Bowen ratio. The two components affect differently the surface buoyancy flux and thus the development and growth of the convective boundary layer. As a result, the Bowen ratio has a strong impact on the daytime development of dry and moist convection over land. We use two canonical modeling test cases, one for the shallow convection and one for the shallow‐to‐deep convection transition, to document the impact of the surface Bowen ratio on daytime convection development. A simple approach is used where results from simulations featuring the original setup are contrasted with simulations where the surface‐sensible heat flux takes on values of the latent heat flux and vice versa. Such a change illustrates the key impact of the surface water availability without changing the total surface heat flux. Because of the larger surface buoyancy flux, simulations with the reversed surface heat fluxes feature faster deepening of the convective boundary layer and wider clouds once moist convection develops. Mean cloud‐base width of cumulus clouds increases with the boundary‐layer depth. For shallow‐to‐deep convection transition, comparison of simulations with the observed large‐scale flow that feature substantial lower‐tropospheric shear with simulations with no mean horizontal flow suggests that the organization of convective circulations within the boundary layer strongly affects initial size and organization of shallow convection, as well as the subsequent width increase once convection deepens and eventually transitions to deep precipitating convection. A simple explanation is provided of why a deeper well‐mixed convective subcloud layer results in wider clouds. The key is the larger width of boundary‐layer coherent updraft structures when the mixed layer is deeper.