SCStephen Conley

Stephen Conley

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Stephen Conley has a total of 250 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Quantitative estimate of several sources of uncertainty in drone-based methane emission measurements

    by Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan J. Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett, Rutger Ijzermans

    Site-level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness, and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as “drones”) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the “mass balance method” to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled-release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2024) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett and Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analyzed individually, and it must be realized that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition, as a coarse spacing can result in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. What is learned from our theoretical error analysis is then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled-release setting. We show how what is learned about the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasion, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The Discussion section provides some guidelines for industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.


  • Open Access

    Airborne in situ quantification of methane emissions from oil and gas production in Romania

    by Hossein Maazallahi, Foteini Stavropoulou, Samuel Jonson Sutanto, Michael Steiner, Dominik Brunner, Mariano Mertens, Patrick Jöckel, Antoon Visschedijk, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Stijn Dellaert, et al.

    Production of oil and gas in Romania, one of the largest producers in the European Union (EU), is associated with substantial emissions of methane to the atmosphere and may offer high emission mitigation potential to reach the climate objectives of the EU. However, comprehensive quantification of emissions in this area has been lacking. Here we report top-down emission rate estimates derived from aircraft-based in situ measurements that were carried out with two aircraft during the 2019 ROmanian Methane Emissions from Oil and gas (ROMEO) campaign, supported by simulations with atmospheric models. Estimates from mass balance flights at individual dense production clusters and around larger regions show large variations between the clusters, supporting the important role of individual super-emitters, and possibly show variable operation practices or maintenance states across the production basin. Estimated annual total emissions from the southern Romanian oil and gas (O&G) infrastructure are 227 ± 86 kt CH4 yr−1, consistent with previously published estimates from ground-based site-level measurements during the same period. The comparison of individual plumes between measurements and atmospheric model simulations was complicated by unfavorable low-wind conditions. Similar correlations between measured and simulated CH4 enhancements during large-scale raster flights and mass balance flights suggest that the emission factor determined from a limited number of production clusters is representative of the larger regions. We conclude that ground-based and aerial emission rate estimates derived from the ROMEO campaign agree well, and the aircraft observations support the previously suggested large under-reporting of CH4 emissions from the Romanian O&G industry in 2019 to United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). We also observed large underestimation from O&G emissions in the Emissions Database for Global Atmospheric Research (EDGAR) v7.0 for our domain of study.


  • Open Access

    Reply on RC1

    by Rutger Ijzermans, Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.

  • Open Access

    Reply on RC2

    by Rutger Ijzermans, Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2024-2135

    by Hossein Maazallahi, Foteini Stavropoulou, Samuel Jonson Sutanto, Michael Steiner, Dominik Brunner, Mariano Mertens, Patrick Jöckel, Antoon Visschedijk, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Stijn Dellaert, et al.

    Production of oil and gas in Romania, one of the largest producers in the EU, is associated with substantial emissions of methane to the atmosphere and may offer high emission mitigation potential to reach the climate objectives of the EU. However, comprehensive quantification of emissions in this area has been lacking. Here we report top-down emission rate estimates derived from aircraft-based in-situ measurements that were carried out with two aircraft during the ROMEO 2019 campaign, supported by simulations with atmospheric models. Estimates from mass balance flights at individual dense production clusters, and around larger regions, show large variations between the clusters, supporting the important role of individual super emitters, and possibly variable operation practices or maintenance state across the production basin. Estimated annual total emissions from the Southern Romanian O&G infrastructure are 227 ± 86 kt CH4 yr-1, consistent with previously published estimates from ground-based site-level measurements during the same period. The comparison of individual plumes between measurements and atmospheric model simulations was complicated by unfavorable low wind conditions. Similar correlations between measured and simulated CH4 enhancements during large-scale raster flights and mass balance flights suggest that the emission factor determined from a limited number of production clusters is representative for the larger regions. We conclude that ground-based and aerial emission rate estimates derived from the ROMEO campaign agree well, and the aircraft observations support the previously suggested large under-reporting of CH4 emissions from the Romanian O&G industry in 2019 to UNFCCC.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2024-2135

    by Hossein Maazallahi, Foteini Stavropoulou, Samuel Jonson Sutanto, Michael Steiner, Dominik Brunner, Mariano Mertens, Patrick Jöckel, Antoon Visschedijk, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Stijn Dellaert, et al.

    Production of oil and gas in Romania, one of the largest producers in the EU, is associated with substantial emissions of methane to the atmosphere and may offer high emission mitigation potential to reach the climate objectives of the EU. However, comprehensive quantification of emissions in this area has been lacking. Here we report top-down emission rate estimates derived from aircraft-based in-situ measurements that were carried out with two aircraft during the ROMEO 2019 campaign, supported by simulations with atmospheric models. Estimates from mass balance flights at individual dense production clusters, and around larger regions, show large variations between the clusters, supporting the important role of individual super emitters, and possibly variable operation practices or maintenance state across the production basin. Estimated annual total emissions from the Southern Romanian O&G infrastructure are 227 ± 86 kt CH4 yr-1, consistent with previously published estimates from ground-based site-level measurements during the same period. The comparison of individual plumes between measurements and atmospheric model simulations was complicated by unfavorable low wind conditions. Similar correlations between measured and simulated CH4 enhancements during large-scale raster flights and mass balance flights suggest that the emission factor determined from a limited number of production clusters is representative for the larger regions. We conclude that ground-based and aerial emission rate estimates derived from the ROMEO campaign agree well, and the aircraft observations support the previously suggested large under-reporting of CH4 emissions from the Romanian O&G industry in 2019 to UNFCCC.

  • Open Access

    Supplementary material to "Airborne in-situ quantification of methane emissions from oil and gas production in Romania"

    by Hossein Maazallahi, Foteini Stavropoulou, Samuel Jonson Sutanto, Michael Steiner, Dominik Brunner, Mariano Mertens, Patrick Jöckel, Antoon Visschedijk, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Stijn Dellaert, et al.


  • Open Access

    Airborne in-situ quantification of methane emissions from oil and gas production in Romania

    by Hossein Maazallahi, Foteini Stavropoulou, Samuel Jonson Sutanto, Michael Steiner, Dominik Brunner, Mariano Mertens, Patrick Jöckel, Antoon Visschedijk, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Stijn Dellaert, et al.

    Production of oil and gas in Romania, one of the largest producers in the EU, is associated with substantial emissions of methane to the atmosphere and may offer high emission mitigation potential to reach the climate objectives of the EU. However, comprehensive quantification of emissions in this area has been lacking. Here we report top-down emission rate estimates derived from aircraft-based in-situ measurements that were carried out with two aircraft during the ROMEO 2019 campaign, supported by simulations with atmospheric models. Estimates from mass balance flights at individual dense production clusters, and around larger regions, show large variations between the clusters, supporting the important role of individual super emitters, and possibly variable operation practices or maintenance state across the production basin. Estimated annual total emissions from the Southern Romanian O&G infrastructure are 227 ± 86 kt CH4 yr-1, consistent with previously published estimates from ground-based site-level measurements during the same period. The comparison of individual plumes between measurements and atmospheric model simulations was complicated by unfavorable low wind conditions. Similar correlations between measured and simulated CH4 enhancements during large-scale raster flights and mass balance flights suggest that the emission factor determined from a limited number of production clusters is representative for the larger regions. We conclude that ground-based and aerial emission rate estimates derived from the ROMEO campaign agree well, and the aircraft observations support the previously suggested large under-reporting of CH4 emissions from the Romanian O&G industry in 2019 to UNFCCC.


  • Open Access

    Quantitative estimate of sources of uncertainty in drone-based methane emission measurements

    by Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett, Rutger Ijzermans

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady.In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.


  • Reconciling Multiple Methane Detection and Quantification Systems at Oil and Gas Tank Battery Sites

    by Shannon Stokes, Erin Tullos, Linley Morris, Felipe J. Cardoso-Saldaña, Mackenzie Smith, Stephen Conley, Brendan Smith, David T. Allen

    Emission rates were estimated for >100 oil and gas production sites with significant liquid-handling equipment (tank battery sites) in the Permian Basin of west Texas. Emission estimates based on equipment counts and emission factors, but not accounting for large uninventoried emission events, led to ensemble average emission rates of 1.8-3.6 kg/h per site. None of the site-specific emission estimates for individual sites, based on equipment counts, exceeded 10 kg/h. On-site drone-based emission measurements led to similar emission estimates for inventoried sources. Multiple aircraft measurement platforms were deployed and reported emissions exceeding 10 kg/h at 14-27% of the sites, and these high-emission rate sites accounted for 80-90% of total emissions for the ensemble of sites. The aircraft measurement systems were deployed asynchronously but within a 5 day period. At least half of the sites with emission rates above 10 kg/h detected by aircraft had emissions that did not persist at a level above 10 kg/h for repeat measurements, suggesting typical high-emission rate durations of a few days or less for many events. The two aircraft systems differed in their estimates of total emissions from the ensembles of sites sampled by more than a factor of 2; however, the normalized distributions of emissions for sites with emission rates of >10 kg/h were comparable for the two aircraft-based methods. The differences between the two aircraft-based platforms are attributed to a combination of factors; however, both aircraft-based emission measurement systems attribute a large fraction of emissions to sites with an emission rate of >10 kg/h.