RTRobert Brian Thorpe

Robert Brian Thorpe

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Robert Brian Thorpe has a total of 97 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Seal population recovery and conservation can be reconciled with viable commercial fisheries in the North Sea, although both may be threatened by climate change

    by Robert B Thorpe, Mike Heath

    Seals are key predators in the North Sea, with the potential to exert top-down control on commercial fish populations and reshape energy flows throughout the foodweb. Grey seal numbers have increased considerably, leading to the worry that they might adversely impact the North Sea fishery. We use the StrathE2E2 model to investigate the joint effects of climate change and seal populations on an idealized 12-fleet North Sea fishery. StrathE2E2 is an end-to-end model of intermediate complexity which has been designed as a big-picture model of the ecosystem from nutrients to top predators, with the ability to look at bottom-up effects in a rigorous manner alongside the top-down impacts of fishing. We consider effects on the seal population for the reference climate period of today and for RCP8.5 around 2050. We do this through Management Strategy evaluation (MSE), which is a powerful way of simulation-testing management procedures and can allow the incorporation of ecosystem considerations via a suitable choice of operating model. Our MSE considers a range of possible management options using (a) common rules for the fleets and (b) emergent fleet dynamics based on regulated catch-maximization fleet behaviour. Hitherto most MSEs have considered a single stock, although there have been some multispecies studies. Other novel features of the study include the use of multi-functional-group harvest control rules for the fleet segments and application of an integrated risk measure of the impact of functional group depletion across the foodweb. We find that (a) there is a modest cost associated with larger seal populations, although healthy seal populations can co-exist with viable commercial fisheries at the ecosystem level; (b) climate change is expected to result in decreased foodweb productivity, leading to reduced fisheries yields and lower seal biomass, other things being equal. We find that the optimum mix of fleet segments is sensitive to minimum required biomasses for seals, indicating the importance of stakeholder participation in objective-setting. Our methods can readily be applied to other ecosystems where suitable modelling tools are available, and can help to inform fisheries management plans and associated tradeoffs.


  • Open Access

    Biodiversity, food webs and an ecologically safe space for fisheries

    by Christopher Philip Lynam, Robert B. Thorpe, Murray S. A. Thompson

    Ecosystem overfishing impacts biodiversity and threatens food security. Fishing pressure originates from a mosaic of fishing fleets which deploy a range of gears, each with unique ecosystem impacts, culminating in complex effects across food webs. A suite of ecological indicators, capable of detecting ecosystem responses to different kinds of fishing pressure, is needed to identify the primary drivers of change and determine appropriate limits for exploitation. However, such indicators often lack adequate quantitative thresholds for the current environmental conditions because comparable but unfished ecosystems no longer exist. We refine a multispecies model of the North Sea food web and simulate different fishing strategies to identify an ecological ‘safe space’ in the current conditions. We define this safe space as one that provides sustainable yields for fisheries, maintains ecosystem function and leads to low risk of overexploitation of multiple species. We delineate this safe space based on a range of indicators, which measure species composition and size structure, and the distribution of biomass across trophic guilds. We find that high values of size-based indicators correspond to high diversity of demersal fish and the diversity of the ecosystem is greatest when the biomass of piscivorous species is high and fishing pressure is low. We demonstrate that indicators with associated thresholds coupled with model forecasts can guide decision-makers toward effective management options. For the North Sea, reductions in otter trawling can lead reduce the likelihood of depletion risk and enable fisheries to operate within this safe space.

  • From bycatch to litter: a systematic map of the ecological impacts of fishing in European seas

    by Esther D. Beukhof, Sven Sebastian Uhlmann, Karin J. van der Reijden, Aikaterini Anastasopoulou, Miren Altuna-Etxabe, Amaia Astarloa, Oihane C. Basurko, Logan Binch, Joanna K. Bluemel, Pierluigi Carbonara, et al.


  • Open Access

    We need to talk about the role of zooplankton in marine food webs

    by Robert B. Thorpe

    Zooplankton are the key intermediary between primary production and the fish community and a cornerstone of marine food webs, but they are often poorly represented in models that tend to focus on fish, charismatic top predators, or ocean biogeochemistry. In this study, we use an intermediate complexity end‐to‐end food web model of the North Sea with explicit two‐way coupling of zooplankton to phytoplankton and higher trophic levels to ask whether this matters. We vary the metabolic rate of omnivorous zooplankton (OZ) as a proxy for uncertainties in our understanding and modeling of zooplankton form and function, and moving beyond previous studies we look at the impacts on the food web in concert with climate warming and fishing. We consider impacts on food web state and time to recover the relevant unfished state after fishing ceases. We also consider potential impacts on pelagic and demersal fishing fleets if we assume that they are constrained by the requirement to allow recovery to an unfished state within a certain period of time as a way of ensuring consistency with Good Environmental Status as required by EU and UK legislation. We find that all three aspects considered are highly sensitive to changes in the treatment of zooplankton, with impacts being larger than for warming of 2 or 4°C across most food web functional groups, particularly for apex predators. We call for a programme of research aimed at improving our understanding of zooplankton ecology and its relationship to the wider food web, and we recommend that improved representations of zooplankton are incorporated in future modeling studies as a priority.


  • Open Access

    Can we use recovery timescales to define Good Environmental Status?

    by Robert B. Thorpe, Michael Heath, Christopher P. Lynam


  • Open Access

    The Response of North Sea Ecosystem Functional Groups to Warming and Changes in Fishing

    by Robert B. Thorpe, Nina L. Arroyo, Georges Safi, Nathalie Niquil, Izaskun Preciado, Michael Heath, Matthew C. Pace, Christopher P. Lynam

    Achieving Good Environmental Status (GES) requires managing ecosystems subject to a variety of pressures such as climate change, eutrophication, and fishing. However, ecosystem models are generally much better at representing top-down impacts from fishing than bottom-up impacts due to warming or changes in nutrient loading. Bottom-up processes often have to be parameterised with little data or worse still taken as a system input rather than being represented explicitly. In this study we use an end-to-end ecosystem model (StrathE2E2) for the North Sea with 18 broad functional groups, five resource pools, and representations of feeding, metabolism, reproduction, active migrations, advection, and mixing. Environmental driving data include temperature, irradiance, hydrodynamics, and nutrient inputs from rivers, atmosphere, and ocean boundaries, so the model is designed to evaluate rigorously top-down and bottom-up impacts and is ideal for looking at possible changes in energy flows and “big picture” ecosystem function. In this study we considered the impacts of warming (2 and 4°C) and various levels of fishing, by demersal and pelagic fleets, on the structure and function of the foodweb. A key aim is to demonstrate whether monitoring of broad ecosystem groups could assist in deciding whether GES was being achieved. We found that warming raised primary productivity and increased the size (total biomass) of the ecosystem. Warming raised metabolic demands on omnivorous zooplankton and reduced their abundance, thus favouring benthivorous and piscivorous demersal fish at the expense of planktivorous pelagic fish but otherwise had modest effects on energy pathways and top predators, whereas changes in fishing patterns could materially alter foodweb function and the relative outcomes for top predators. We suggest that GES should be defined in terms of an unfished state and that abundances of broad groupings and the balance between them can help to assess whether indicator outcomes were consistent with GES. Our findings underwrite the need for an ecosystem approach for the management of human activities supported by relevant monitoring. We also highlight the need to improve our basic understanding of bottom-up processes, improve their representation within models, and ensure that our ecosystem models can capture growth limitation by nitrogen and other elements, and not just food/energy uptake.


  • Open Access

    Commentary: Combining Ecosystem and Single-Species Modeling to Provide Ecosystem-Based Fisheries Management Advice Within Current Management Systems

    by Robert B. Thorpe, Michael A. Spence, Paul J. Dolder, Richard D. M. Nash

    Commentary: Combining Ecosystem and Single-Species Modeling to Provide Ecosystem-Based Fisheries Management Advice Within Current Management Systems


  • Open Access

    The Use of a Length-Structured Multispecies Model Fitted Directly to Data in Near-Real Time as a Viable Tool for Advice

    by Michael A. Spence, Paul J. Dolder, Richard Nash, Robert B. Thorpe

    Fish communities are multispecies assemblages, so ideally multispecies models should be used directly for assessing this resource. However, progress in this direction has been slow, partly because these models are often more complex and take longer to fit, rendering them too slow to demonstrate near-real-time utility, and thus creating a perception that they are opaque to stakeholders. In this study we implemented a multispecies assessment for the Irish Sea, fitting a model of eight key stocks directly to catch and survey data. Two novel features of our approach allowed the multispecies model to be fitted within a few hours. Firstly, by using size-based theory and life-history invariants to specify many of the required properties of stocks, we reduced the number of general parameters that needed to be fitted directly to a more manageable 25. Secondly, by using state-of-the-art fitting methods, we found acceptable solutions quickly enough to provide assessments within the timescale of an advisory meeting. The outcomes were compared with the standard single species assessments of the same eight species. Model fits were generally good for either catch or at least one of the surveys, but not for all data sources at the same time, illustrating the challenges of fitting multiple stocks to different data sources simultaneously. Estimates of SSB and F agreed qualitatively with the assessments for most stocks with the exception of whiting. Estimates of natural mortality showed modest year to year variability, suggesting that single species assessments may be appropriate for short term tactical management. This method shows great promise for making multispecies assessments as a complement to existing assessments because of the rapid turnaround time and ability to respond at meetings to the requests of stakeholders. In addition, because these models avoid our current dependence on existing single species models they can be used to provide boundary conditions in natural mortality for standard assessment models and check for internal consistency in the assessment process. Furthermore, they are easily accessible because they are based upon freely available code.


  • Quantifying uncertainty and dynamical changes in multi‐species fishing mortality rates, catches and biomass by combining state‐space and size‐based multi‐species models

    by Michael A. Spence, Robert B. Thorpe, Paul G. Blackwell, Finlay Scott, Richard Southwell, Julia L. Blanchard

    In marine management, fish stocks are often managed on a stock‐by‐stock basis using single‐species models. Many of these models are based upon statistical techniques and are good at assessing the current state and making short‐term predictions; however, as they do not model interactions between stocks, they lack predictive power on longer timescales. Additionally, there are size‐based multi‐species models that represent key biological processes and consider interactions between stocks such as predation and competition for resources. Due to the complexity of these models, they are difficult to fit to data, and so many size‐based multi‐species models depend upon single‐species models where they exist, or ad hoc assumptions when they do not, for parameters such as annual fishing mortality. In this paper, we demonstrate that by taking a state‐space approach, many of the uncertain parameters can be treated dynamically, allowing us to fit, with quantifiable uncertainty, size‐based multi‐species models directly to data. We demonstrate this by fitting uncertain parameters, including annual fishing mortality, of a size‐based multi‐species model of the Celtic Sea, for species with and without single‐species stock assessments. Consequently, errors in the single‐species models no longer propagate through the multi‐species model and underlying assumptions are more transparent. Building size‐based multi‐species models that are internally consistent, with quantifiable uncertainty, will improve their credibility and utility for management. This may lead to their uptake by being either used to corroborate single‐species models; directly in the advice process to make predictions into the future; or used to provide a new way of managing data‐limited stocks.