Jerry Diamond
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Jerry Diamond has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Henry Latimer
Tetra Tech Inc
3 shared publicationsDebra L. Denton
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 9 Sacramento , California , USA
2 shared publicationsG. Allen Burton
School for Environment and Sustainability and Department of Earth & Environmental Science University of Michigan Ann Arbor Michigan USA
2 shared publicationsJaime Gilliam
Tetra Tech, Inc
2 shared publications- Jonathan B. Butcher
Tetra Tech, Inc., Research Triangle Park, North Carolina
2 shared publications - Karen A. Kidd
McMaster University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 15 November 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 43 (3) , 488-501
What Approaches Should be Used to Prioritize Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products for Research on Environmental and Human Health Exposure and Effects?
Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) are released from multiple anthropogenic sources and thus have a ubiquitous presence in the environment. The environmental exposure and potential effects of PPCPs on biota and humans has aroused concern within the scientific community and the public. Risk assessments are commonly conducted to evaluate the likelihood of chemicals including PPCPs that pose health threats to organisms inhabiting various environmental compartments and humans. Because thousands of PPCPs are currently used, it is impractical to assess the environmental risk of all of them due to data limitations; in addition, new PPCPs are continually being produced. Prioritization approaches, based either on exposure, hazard, or risk, provide a possible means by which those PPCPs that are likely to pose the greatest risk to the environment are identified, thereby enabling more effective allocation of resources in environmental monitoring programs in specific geographical locations and ecotoxicological investigations. In the present review, the importance and current knowledge concerning PPCP occurrence and risk are discussed and priorities for future research are proposed, in terms of PPCP exposure (e.g., optimization of exposure modeling in freshwater ecosystems and more monitoring of PPCPs in the marine environment) or hazard (e.g., differential risk of PPCPs to lower vs. higher trophic level species and risks to human health). Recommended research questions for the next 10 years are also provided, which can be answered by future studies on prioritization of PPCPs. Environ Toxicol Chem 2024;43:488–501. © 2022 SETAC
- 15 November 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 43 (3) , 488-501
What Approaches Should be Used to Prioritize Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products for Research on Environmental and Human Health Exposure and Effects?
Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) are released from multiple anthropogenic sources and thus have a ubiquitous presence in the environment. The environmental exposure and potential effects of PPCPs on biota and humans has aroused concern within the scientific community and the public. Risk assessments are commonly conducted to evaluate the likelihood of chemicals including PPCPs that pose health threats to organisms inhabiting various environmental compartments and humans. Because thousands of PPCPs are currently used, it is impractical to assess the environmental risk of all of them due to data limitations; in addition, new PPCPs are continually being produced. Prioritization approaches, based either on exposure, hazard, or risk, provide a possible means by which those PPCPs that are likely to pose the greatest risk to the environment are identified, thereby enabling more effective allocation of resources in environmental monitoring programs in specific geographical locations and ecotoxicological investigations. In the present review, the importance and current knowledge concerning PPCP occurrence and risk are discussed and priorities for future research are proposed, in terms of PPCP exposure (e.g., optimization of exposure modeling in freshwater ecosystems and more monitoring of PPCPs in the marine environment) or hazard (e.g., differential risk of PPCPs to lower vs. higher trophic level species and risks to human health). Recommended research questions for the next 10 years are also provided, which can be answered by future studies on prioritization of PPCPs. Environ Toxicol Chem 2024;43:488–501. © 2022 SETAC
- Open Access
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 40 (6) , 1527-1529
Moving Beyond the Term “Contaminants of Emerging Concern”
The term “contaminants of emerging concern” (CECs) has become a catchall for hundreds of chemicals, many of which we know very little about except that they can be detected in certain water samples, typically at very low concentrations. In most cases, it is not clear whether these chemicals are emerging or a concern to biota or people. We believe this term only furthers a chemical by chemical approach which does not help identify potential mixture effects nor does it help us prioritize those chemicals which are truly a potential concern deserving further attention. We believe environmental resource agencies, water utilities, and the public would be better served by focusing on an exposure‐effects driven approach in which diagnostic analyses at multiple levels of biological organization are used to identify exposure of certain types of chemicals and mechanisms of action that could result in undesirable effects on biota or people. This approach should strive to group chemicals in terms of their intended use and their fate properties, as opposed to a chemical by chemical approach, using many of the diagnostic exposure‐effects analyses now available to help address mixture effects. Unlike the CEC paradigm, which depends on chemicals detected, an exposure‐effects approach can be used prospectively as well as retrospectively, which could help prioritize the groups of chemicals that are likely to pose the highest potential concern based on their intended use, fate, and transport. This approach could also help identify those types of chemicals (including ones we may not know about currently) that should be high priority for examination
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 40 (6) , 1527-1529
Open AccessMoving Beyond the Term “Contaminants of Emerging Concern”
The term “contaminants of emerging concern” (CECs) has become a catchall for hundreds of chemicals, many of which we know very little about except that they can be detected in certain water samples, typically at very low concentrations. In most cases, it is not clear whether these chemicals are emerging or a concern to biota or people. We believe this term only furthers a chemical by chemical approach which does not help identify potential mixture effects nor does it help us prioritize those chemicals which are truly a potential concern deserving further attention. We believe environmental resource agencies, water utilities, and the public would be better served by focusing on an exposure‐effects driven approach in which diagnostic analyses at multiple levels of biological organization are used to identify exposure of certain types of chemicals and mechanisms of action that could result in undesirable effects on biota or people. This approach should strive to group chemicals in terms of their intended use and their fate properties, as opposed to a chemical by chemical approach, using many of the diagnostic exposure‐effects analyses now available to help address mixture effects. Unlike the CEC paradigm, which depends on chemicals detected, an exposure‐effects approach can be used prospectively as well as retrospectively, which could help prioritize the groups of chemicals that are likely to pose the highest potential concern based on their intended use, fate, and transport. This approach could also help identify those types of chemicals (including ones we may not know about currently) that should be high priority for examination
- 20 June 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 15 (5) , 808-818
Integrating Aquatic Designated Use Protection and Restoration Strategies Using an Ecosystem Goods and Services Framework
Water quality standards programs in the United States and other countries are based on designated uses (DUs), which are linked to criteria that specify maximum pollutant levels and other characteristics that are thresholds for waterbody compliance with regulatory goals. Most DUs are similar to certain provisioning ecosystem goods and services (EGS), such as drinking water supply and recreation (e.g., boating, fishing). Absent in the DU concept are supporting or regulating services, which results in disjointed and often ineffective aquatic ecosystem protection and restoration strategies. The focus on discrete sets of water quality parameters in the DU concept can often result in the appearance of conflicting DUs, resulting in poor provisioning of certain DUs. We present a framework that uses EGS to provide a more holistic assessment of DUs and to help inform best management practices that could result in fuller attainment of DUs while providing greater provisioning of desired goods and services. Two case studies are discussed, demonstrating some of the issues with the DU concept, how it is implemented in the United States, and how the EGS framework can provide a crosswalk between the DU paradigm and stakeholder goals for a watershed. A process is presented that could help regulatory agencies and stakeholders make better use of the EGS framework in DU decisions, including watershed protection and restoration. The EGS framework presented here, coupled with a watershed stakeholder process focused on developing an integrative management strategy based on the framework, could help achieve multiple beneficial uses in an aquatic system. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2019;15:808–818. © 2019 SETAC.
- 20 June 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 15 (5) , 808-818
Integrating Aquatic Designated Use Protection and Restoration Strategies Using an Ecosystem Goods and Services Framework
Water quality standards programs in the United States and other countries are based on designated uses (DUs), which are linked to criteria that specify maximum pollutant levels and other characteristics that are thresholds for waterbody compliance with regulatory goals. Most DUs are similar to certain provisioning ecosystem goods and services (EGS), such as drinking water supply and recreation (e.g., boating, fishing). Absent in the DU concept are supporting or regulating services, which results in disjointed and often ineffective aquatic ecosystem protection and restoration strategies. The focus on discrete sets of water quality parameters in the DU concept can often result in the appearance of conflicting DUs, resulting in poor provisioning of certain DUs. We present a framework that uses EGS to provide a more holistic assessment of DUs and to help inform best management practices that could result in fuller attainment of DUs while providing greater provisioning of desired goods and services. Two case studies are discussed, demonstrating some of the issues with the DU concept, how it is implemented in the United States, and how the EGS framework can provide a crosswalk between the DU paradigm and stakeholder goals for a watershed. A process is presented that could help regulatory agencies and stakeholders make better use of the EGS framework in DU decisions, including watershed protection and restoration. The EGS framework presented here, coupled with a watershed stakeholder process focused on developing an integrative management strategy based on the framework, could help achieve multiple beneficial uses in an aquatic system. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2019;15:808–818. © 2019 SETAC.
- 18 February 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 38 (3) , 511-523
Comparison of false-positive rates of 2 hypothesis-test approaches in relation to laboratory toxicity test performance
We compared 2 statistical hypothesis‐test approaches (no‐observed‐effect concentration [NOEC] and test of significant toxicity [TST]) to determine the influence of laboratory test performance on the false‐positive error rate using the US Environmental Protection Agency's Ceriodaphnia dubia reproduction whole‐effluent toxicity (WET) test endpoint. Simulation and power calculations were used to determine error rates based on observed control coefficients of variation (CV) for 8 laboratories over a range of effect levels. Average C. dubia control reproduction among laboratories was 20 to 40 offspring per female, and the 75th percentile CV was 0.10 to 0.31, reflecting a range in laboratory performance. The 2 approaches behave similarly for CVs of 0.2 to 0.3. At effects CV decreases, TST is less likely to declare toxicity and NOEC is more likely to do so. Laboratory performance affects whether a sample is declared toxic and influences the probability of false‐positive (and −negative) error rates using either approach. At the 75th percentile control CV observed for each laboratory, 4 laboratories would achieve approximately a 5% false‐positive rate using 13 or fewer replicates for this test method. For the remaining 4 laboratories, more replicates would be needed to achieve a 5% false‐positive rate. The present analyses demonstrate how false‐positive rates are influenced by laboratory performance and WET test design. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;9999:1–13. Published 2019 Wiley Periodicals Inc. on behalf of SETAC. This article is a US government work and, as such, is in the public domain in the United States of America.
- 18 February 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 38 (3) , 511-523
Comparison of false-positive rates of 2 hypothesis-test approaches in relation to laboratory toxicity test performance
We compared 2 statistical hypothesis‐test approaches (no‐observed‐effect concentration [NOEC] and test of significant toxicity [TST]) to determine the influence of laboratory test performance on the false‐positive error rate using the US Environmental Protection Agency's Ceriodaphnia dubia reproduction whole‐effluent toxicity (WET) test endpoint. Simulation and power calculations were used to determine error rates based on observed control coefficients of variation (CV) for 8 laboratories over a range of effect levels. Average C. dubia control reproduction among laboratories was 20 to 40 offspring per female, and the 75th percentile CV was 0.10 to 0.31, reflecting a range in laboratory performance. The 2 approaches behave similarly for CVs of 0.2 to 0.3. At effects CV decreases, TST is less likely to declare toxicity and NOEC is more likely to do so. Laboratory performance affects whether a sample is declared toxic and influences the probability of false‐positive (and −negative) error rates using either approach. At the 75th percentile control CV observed for each laboratory, 4 laboratories would achieve approximately a 5% false‐positive rate using 13 or fewer replicates for this test method. For the remaining 4 laboratories, more replicates would be needed to achieve a 5% false‐positive rate. The present analyses demonstrate how false‐positive rates are influenced by laboratory performance and WET test design. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;9999:1–13. Published 2019 Wiley Periodicals Inc. on behalf of SETAC. This article is a US government work and, as such, is in the public domain in the United States of America.
- 1 March 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 14 (2) , 300-302
Ecosystem services rather than designated uses should be the backbone of United States Clean Water Act programs
- 1 March 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Vol. 14 (2) , 300-302
Ecosystem services rather than designated uses should be the backbone of United States Clean Water Act programs
- Open Access
- 25 October 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 37 (3) , 690-702
Use of prospective and retrospective risk assessment methods that simplify chemical mixtures associated with treated domestic wastewater discharges
: A framework is presented that is intended to facilitate the evaluation of potential aquatic ecological risks resulting from discharges of down-the-drain chemicals. A scenario is presented using representatives of many of the types of chemicals that are treated domestically. Predicted environmental chemical concentrations are based on reported loading rates and routine removal rates for 3 types of treatment: trickling filter, activated sludge secondary treatment, and activated sludge plus advanced oxidation process as well as instream effluent dilution. In tier I, predicted effluent concentrations were compared with the lowest predicted-no-effect concentration (PNEC) obtained from the literature using safety factors as needed. A cumulative risk characterization ratio (cumRCR) < 1.0 indicates that risk is unlikely and no further action is needed. Otherwise, a tier 2 assessment is used, in which PNECs are based on trophic level. If tier 2 indicates a possible risk, then a retrospective assessment is recommended. In tier 1, the cumRCR was > 1.0 for all 3 treatment types in our scenario, even though no chemical exceeded a hazard quotient of 1.0 in activated sludge or advanced oxidation process. In tier 2, activated sludge yielded a lower cumRCR than trickling filter because of higher removal rates, and the cumRCR in the advanced oxidation process was << 1.0. Based on the maximum cumulative risk ratio (MCR), more than one-third of the predicted risk was accounted for by one chemical, and at least 90% was accounted for by 3 chemicals, indicating that few chemicals influenced the mixture risk in our scenario. We show how a retrospective assessment can test whether certain chemicals hypothesized as potential drivers in the prospective assessment could have, or are having, deleterious effects on aquatic life. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:690–702. © 2017 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of SETAC.
- 25 October 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 37 (3) , 690-702
Open AccessUse of prospective and retrospective risk assessment methods that simplify chemical mixtures associated with treated domestic wastewater discharges
: A framework is presented that is intended to facilitate the evaluation of potential aquatic ecological risks resulting from discharges of down-the-drain chemicals. A scenario is presented using representatives of many of the types of chemicals that are treated domestically. Predicted environmental chemical concentrations are based on reported loading rates and routine removal rates for 3 types of treatment: trickling filter, activated sludge secondary treatment, and activated sludge plus advanced oxidation process as well as instream effluent dilution. In tier I, predicted effluent concentrations were compared with the lowest predicted-no-effect concentration (PNEC) obtained from the literature using safety factors as needed. A cumulative risk characterization ratio (cumRCR) < 1.0 indicates that risk is unlikely and no further action is needed. Otherwise, a tier 2 assessment is used, in which PNECs are based on trophic level. If tier 2 indicates a possible risk, then a retrospective assessment is recommended. In tier 1, the cumRCR was > 1.0 for all 3 treatment types in our scenario, even though no chemical exceeded a hazard quotient of 1.0 in activated sludge or advanced oxidation process. In tier 2, activated sludge yielded a lower cumRCR than trickling filter because of higher removal rates, and the cumRCR in the advanced oxidation process was << 1.0. Based on the maximum cumulative risk ratio (MCR), more than one-third of the predicted risk was accounted for by one chemical, and at least 90% was accounted for by 3 chemicals, indicating that few chemicals influenced the mixture risk in our scenario. We show how a retrospective assessment can test whether certain chemicals hypothesized as potential drivers in the prospective assessment could have, or are having, deleterious effects on aquatic life. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:690–702. © 2017 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of SETAC.
- Open Access
- 28 August 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 37 (3) , 715-728
Prospective mixture risk assessment and management prioritizations for river catchments with diverse land uses
Ecological risk assessment increasingly focuses on risks from chemical mixtures and multiple stressors because ecosystems are commonly exposed to a plethora of contaminants and nonchemical stressors. To simplify the task of assessing potential mixture effects, we explored 3 land use–related chemical emission scenarios. We applied a tiered methodology to judge the implications of the emissions of chemicals from agricultural practices, domestic discharges, and urban runoff in a quantitative model. The results showed land use–dependent mixture exposures, clearly discriminating downstream effects of land uses, with unique chemical “signatures” regarding composition, concentration, and temporal patterns. Associated risks were characterized in relation to the land‐use scenarios. Comparisons to measured environmental concentrations and predicted impacts showed relatively good similarity. The results suggest that the land uses imply exceedances of regulatory protective environmental quality standards, varying over time in relation to rain events and associated flow and dilution variation. Higher‐tier analyses using ecotoxicological effect criteria confirmed that species assemblages may be affected by exposures exceeding no‐effect levels and that mixture exposure could be associated with predicted species loss under certain situations. The model outcomes can inform various types of prioritization to support risk management, including a ranking across land uses as a whole, a ranking on characteristics of exposure times and frequencies, and various rankings of the relative role of individual chemicals. Though all results are based on in silico assessments, the prospective land use–based approach applied in the present study yields useful insights for simplifying and assessing potential ecological risks of chemical mixtures and can therefore be useful for catchment‐management decisions. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:715–728. © 2017 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology Chemistry Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
- 28 August 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 37 (3) , 715-728
Open AccessProspective mixture risk assessment and management prioritizations for river catchments with diverse land uses
Ecological risk assessment increasingly focuses on risks from chemical mixtures and multiple stressors because ecosystems are commonly exposed to a plethora of contaminants and nonchemical stressors. To simplify the task of assessing potential mixture effects, we explored 3 land use–related chemical emission scenarios. We applied a tiered methodology to judge the implications of the emissions of chemicals from agricultural practices, domestic discharges, and urban runoff in a quantitative model. The results showed land use–dependent mixture exposures, clearly discriminating downstream effects of land uses, with unique chemical “signatures” regarding composition, concentration, and temporal patterns. Associated risks were characterized in relation to the land‐use scenarios. Comparisons to measured environmental concentrations and predicted impacts showed relatively good similarity. The results suggest that the land uses imply exceedances of regulatory protective environmental quality standards, varying over time in relation to rain events and associated flow and dilution variation. Higher‐tier analyses using ecotoxicological effect criteria confirmed that species assemblages may be affected by exposures exceeding no‐effect levels and that mixture exposure could be associated with predicted species loss under certain situations. The model outcomes can inform various types of prioritization to support risk management, including a ranking across land uses as a whole, a ranking on characteristics of exposure times and frequencies, and various rankings of the relative role of individual chemicals. Though all results are based on in silico assessments, the prospective land use–based approach applied in the present study yields useful insights for simplifying and assessing potential ecological risks of chemical mixtures and can therefore be useful for catchment‐management decisions. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:715–728. © 2017 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology Chemistry Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
- 25 November 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 34 (12) , 2671-2681
A framework for screening sites at risk from contaminants of emerging concern
Trace levels of a variety of currently unregulated organic chemicals have been detected in treated wastewater effluents and surface waters that receive treated effluents. Many of these chemicals of emerging concern (CECs) originate from pharmaceuticals and personal care products that are used widely and that frequently are transported “down the drain” to a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). Actual effects of CECs on aquatic life have been difficult to document, although biological effects consistent with effects of some CECs have been noted. There is a critical need to find appropriate ways to screen wastewater sites that have the greatest potential of CEC risk to biota. Building on the work of several researchers, the authors present a screening framework, as well as examples based on the framework, designed to identify high-risk versus lower-risk sites that are influenced by WWTP effluent. It is hoped that this framework can help researchers, utilities, and the larger water resource community focus efforts toward improving CEC risk determinations and management of these risks. Environ Toxicol Chem 2015;34:2671–2681. © 2015 SETAC
- 25 November 2015
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 34 (12) , 2671-2681
A framework for screening sites at risk from contaminants of emerging concern
Trace levels of a variety of currently unregulated organic chemicals have been detected in treated wastewater effluents and surface waters that receive treated effluents. Many of these chemicals of emerging concern (CECs) originate from pharmaceuticals and personal care products that are used widely and that frequently are transported “down the drain” to a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). Actual effects of CECs on aquatic life have been difficult to document, although biological effects consistent with effects of some CECs have been noted. There is a critical need to find appropriate ways to screen wastewater sites that have the greatest potential of CEC risk to biota. Building on the work of several researchers, the authors present a screening framework, as well as examples based on the framework, designed to identify high-risk versus lower-risk sites that are influenced by WWTP effluent. It is hoped that this framework can help researchers, utilities, and the larger water resource community focus efforts toward improving CEC risk determinations and management of these risks. Environ Toxicol Chem 2015;34:2671–2681. © 2015 SETAC
- 11 February 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 32 (5) , 1101-1108
EVALUATION OF THE TEST OF SIGNIFICANT TOXICITY FOR DETERMINING THE TOXICITY OF EFFLUENTS AND AMBIENT WATER SAMPLES
: The test of significant toxicity (TST) is a hypothesis-testing approach based on bioequivalence developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) for analyzing whole-effluent toxicity (WET) and ambient toxicity data. The present study compares results of acute and chronic toxicity tests of effluent, storm-water, and ambient (i.e., receiving-water) samples using both the TST and the standard no-observed-effect concentration (NOEC) approach. Valid WET data were analyzed from 890 tests provided by more than 25 dischargers in California and Washington, USA, representing the majority of test methods used in the U.S. WET program. An additional 3,201 freshwater chronic toxicity tests, obtained from ambient monitoring programs in California, were also analyzed. The TST and NOEC approaches both declared a low number (<6.5%) of tests toxic if effects were below the unacceptable toxicity regulatory management decision (RMD) of 25% effect in chronic tests or 20% effect in acute tests. However, those test methods having generally lower within-test variability and greater test power (e.g., urchin fertilization test) had a much lower percentage of tests declared toxic than the NOEC approach when effects were below the unacceptable toxicity RMD. In addition, the TST showed fewer tests to be nontoxic than NOEC if the test exhibited effects greater than the toxicity RMD (0.1 and 9.6% for TST and NOEC, respectively, for effluents and 0 and 9.5%, respectively, for ambient samples). Our results demonstrate that the TST is more likely to identify a toxic sample when effects are fairly substantial (≥25% effect in chronic testing and ≥20% effect in acute tests) and less likely to identify a sample as toxic when effects are negligible (≤10% effect). Furthermore, these results demonstrate that appropriate WET data interpretation benefits from having well-designed test methods with sufficient power to identify significant toxicity or biologically insignificant effects when they occur. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013;32:1101–1108. © 2013 SETAC
- 11 February 2013
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 32 (5) , 1101-1108
EVALUATION OF THE TEST OF SIGNIFICANT TOXICITY FOR DETERMINING THE TOXICITY OF EFFLUENTS AND AMBIENT WATER SAMPLES
: The test of significant toxicity (TST) is a hypothesis-testing approach based on bioequivalence developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) for analyzing whole-effluent toxicity (WET) and ambient toxicity data. The present study compares results of acute and chronic toxicity tests of effluent, storm-water, and ambient (i.e., receiving-water) samples using both the TST and the standard no-observed-effect concentration (NOEC) approach. Valid WET data were analyzed from 890 tests provided by more than 25 dischargers in California and Washington, USA, representing the majority of test methods used in the U.S. WET program. An additional 3,201 freshwater chronic toxicity tests, obtained from ambient monitoring programs in California, were also analyzed. The TST and NOEC approaches both declared a low number (<6.5%) of tests toxic if effects were below the unacceptable toxicity regulatory management decision (RMD) of 25% effect in chronic tests or 20% effect in acute tests. However, those test methods having generally lower within-test variability and greater test power (e.g., urchin fertilization test) had a much lower percentage of tests declared toxic than the NOEC approach when effects were below the unacceptable toxicity RMD. In addition, the TST showed fewer tests to be nontoxic than NOEC if the test exhibited effects greater than the toxicity RMD (0.1 and 9.6% for TST and NOEC, respectively, for effluents and 0 and 9.5%, respectively, for ambient samples). Our results demonstrate that the TST is more likely to identify a toxic sample when effects are fairly substantial (≥25% effect in chronic testing and ≥20% effect in acute tests) and less likely to identify a sample as toxic when effects are negligible (≤10% effect). Furthermore, these results demonstrate that appropriate WET data interpretation benefits from having well-designed test methods with sufficient power to identify significant toxicity or biologically insignificant effects when they occur. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013;32:1101–1108. © 2013 SETAC
- Open Access
- 21 November 2012
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 32 (2) , 468-474
Evaluation of whole effluent toxicity data characteristics and use of Welch's T-test in the test of significant toxicity analysis
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) and state agencies evaluate the toxicity of effluent and surface water samples based on statistical endpoints derived from multiconcentration tests (e.g., no observed effect concentration, EC25). The test of significant toxicity (TST) analysis is a two-sample comparison test that uses Welch's t test to compare organism responses in a sample (effluent or surface water) with responses in a control or site sample. In general, any form of t test (Welch's t included) is appropriate only if the data meet assumptions of normality and homogeneous variances. Otherwise, nonparametric tests are recommended. TST was designed to use Welch's t as the statistical test for all whole effluent toxicity (WET) test data. The authors evaluated the suitability of using Welch's t test for analyzing two-sample toxicity (WET) data, and within the TST approach, by examining the distribution and variances of data from over 2,000 WET tests and by conducting multiple simulations of WET test data. Simulated data were generated having variances and nonnormal distributions similar to observed WET test data for control and the effluent treatment groups. The authors demonstrate that (1) moderately unequal variances (similar to WET data) have little effect on coverage of the t test or Welch t test (for normally distributed data), and (2) for nonnormally distributed data (similar in distribution to WET data) TST, using Welch's t test, has close to nominal coverage on the basis of simulations with up to a ninefold difference in variance between the effluent and control groups (∼95th percentile based on observed WET test data). Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013;32:468–474. © 2012 SETAC
- 21 November 2012
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
- Vol. 32 (2) , 468-474
Open AccessEvaluation of whole effluent toxicity data characteristics and use of Welch's T-test in the test of significant toxicity analysis
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) and state agencies evaluate the toxicity of effluent and surface water samples based on statistical endpoints derived from multiconcentration tests (e.g., no observed effect concentration, EC25). The test of significant toxicity (TST) analysis is a two-sample comparison test that uses Welch's t test to compare organism responses in a sample (effluent or surface water) with responses in a control or site sample. In general, any form of t test (Welch's t included) is appropriate only if the data meet assumptions of normality and homogeneous variances. Otherwise, nonparametric tests are recommended. TST was designed to use Welch's t as the statistical test for all whole effluent toxicity (WET) test data. The authors evaluated the suitability of using Welch's t test for analyzing two-sample toxicity (WET) data, and within the TST approach, by examining the distribution and variances of data from over 2,000 WET tests and by conducting multiple simulations of WET test data. Simulated data were generated having variances and nonnormal distributions similar to observed WET test data for control and the effluent treatment groups. The authors demonstrate that (1) moderately unequal variances (similar to WET data) have little effect on coverage of the t test or Welch t test (for normally distributed data), and (2) for nonnormally distributed data (similar in distribution to WET data) TST, using Welch's t test, has close to nominal coverage on the basis of simulations with up to a ninefold difference in variance between the effluent and control groups (∼95th percentile based on observed WET test data). Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013;32:468–474. © 2012 SETAC