Flavie Goutard
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Flavie Goutard has a total of 268 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- François Roger
CIRAD, UMR ASTRE, Montpellier, France
16 shared publications - Marisa Peyre
CIRAD, UMR ASTRE
10 shared publications - Alexis Delabouglise
CIRAD, UMR ASTRE
5 shared publications - Julien Cappelle
ASTRE, Université de Montpellier, CIRAD, INRAE, Montpellier, France
5 shared publications - Marion Bordier
ASTRE, University of Montpellier, CIRAD, INRAE, Montpellier, France; CIRAD, UMR ASTRE, Dakar, Senegal
5 shared publications Marisa Peyre
CIRAD, UMR ASTRE
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 6
Comparative risk-assessment of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 viruses spread in French broiler and layer sectors
Since 2015, French poultry production is threatened almost every year by a reintroduction of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 viruses. The duck sector was the most concerned by this crisis but other sectors such as broiler, layer and turkey were also affected by outbreaks. The objective of this work was to assess the risk of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 virus transmission from one farm to another within the French broiler and layer production network. This study used the WOAH risk assessment framework. After drawing up a scenario tree of virus transmission from one farm to another, data were collected through a literature review or through experts’ elicitation. Three questionnaires were developed according to the experts’ field of expertise: avian influenza, broiler and layer sectors. The experts’ estimates were combined using a beta distribution weighted by their confidence level. A Monte Carlo iteration process was used to combine the different probabilities of the scenario tree and to assess the transmission risk. In the broiler sector, the highest transmission probabilities were observed if the exposed farm was an indoor broiler farm and the source a broiler farm (indoor or free-range). The high transmission probability between broiler farms integrated within the same association suggests that integration is an important risk factor. Person movement, transport of feed and manure management were the pathways with the highest transmission probabilities between two integrated indoor broiler farms with good biosecurity levels. In the layer sector, the highest transmission probabilities were observed if the source farm was a free-range farm and the exposed farm a production farm (indoor or free-range). The pathways with the highest transmission probabilities were egg transport and person movement. The sensitivity analysis showed that the exposed farm's biosecurity had a significant impact on the transmission probability. Our results provide an insight on the role of each type of farms in the virus spread within the French broiler and layer production sectors and will be useful for the implementation of control measures such as movement restriction or vaccination.
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 6
Comparative risk-assessment of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 viruses spread in French broiler and layer sectors
Since 2015, French poultry production is threatened almost every year by a reintroduction of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 viruses. The duck sector was the most concerned by this crisis but other sectors such as broiler, layer and turkey were also affected by outbreaks. The objective of this work was to assess the risk of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5 virus transmission from one farm to another within the French broiler and layer production network. This study used the WOAH risk assessment framework. After drawing up a scenario tree of virus transmission from one farm to another, data were collected through a literature review or through experts’ elicitation. Three questionnaires were developed according to the experts’ field of expertise: avian influenza, broiler and layer sectors. The experts’ estimates were combined using a beta distribution weighted by their confidence level. A Monte Carlo iteration process was used to combine the different probabilities of the scenario tree and to assess the transmission risk. In the broiler sector, the highest transmission probabilities were observed if the exposed farm was an indoor broiler farm and the source a broiler farm (indoor or free-range). The high transmission probability between broiler farms integrated within the same association suggests that integration is an important risk factor. Person movement, transport of feed and manure management were the pathways with the highest transmission probabilities between two integrated indoor broiler farms with good biosecurity levels. In the layer sector, the highest transmission probabilities were observed if the source farm was a free-range farm and the exposed farm a production farm (indoor or free-range). The pathways with the highest transmission probabilities were egg transport and person movement. The sensitivity analysis showed that the exposed farm's biosecurity had a significant impact on the transmission probability. Our results provide an insight on the role of each type of farms in the virus spread within the French broiler and layer production sectors and will be useful for the implementation of control measures such as movement restriction or vaccination.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Methods to improve zoonotic disease surveillance in poor rural settings : the example of highly pathogenic avian influenza (A) H5N1 in Southeast Asia
Comment améliorer l'efficacité de la surveillance passive des zoonoses en zones rurales : exemple de la grippe avaire H5N1 en Asie du Sud-Est: La propagation en Asie, Europe et Afrique du virus Influenza Aviaire hautement pathogène (IAHP) H5N1, l'épidémie de A/H1N1pdm en 2009, l'émergence de l'Influenza faiblement pathogène (IAFP), mais zoonotique, H7N9 en Chine en 2013 et la circulation récente de l'IAHP H5N8 en Europe, montrent que l'évolution permanente de ces virus chez les oiseaux, les humains et les porcs, pause un risque en santé humaine et animale au niveau mondial. Au cours des 10 dernières années, des efforts ont été fait pour renforcer les capacités en santé publique et vétérinaire. Malgré tout, le virus IAHP H5N1 reste endémique dans certains pays où il peut passer inaperçu dans les populations de volailles mais provoquent des cas humains. Ces pays sont caractérisés par une majorité de leur population vivant en zones rurales, une absence de systèmes de santé primaire et des secteurs de santé inefficaces.La surveillance passive (évènementielle) des maladies animales et humaines est souvent la seule méthode réalisable dans les milieux ruraux. Produisant une information incomplète, biaisée ou transmise avec des délais importants, elle a besoin d'être amélioré par des approches nouvelles mis en œuvre dans un cadre « One Health » prenant en compte les interfaces entre humains, animaux et environnement. Nous avons donc dans cette thèse conçu et/ou appliqué de nouvelles méthodes d'évaluation, de conception ou d'amélioration de la notification des cas d'IAHP H5N1 chez l'animal et chez l'homme en Asie du sud-est.Nous avons en premier examiné différentes alternatives d'évaluation. Nous avons appliqué des arbres de scénario (stochastique) pour modéliser et évaluer le système de surveillance de l'IAHP H5N1 en Thaïlande dans les systèmes traditionnels de productions avicoles. Nous avons estimé la sensibilité de la surveillance passive à 50 % (IC95 % 0,04-0,75) pour une détection maximale de 3 fermes infectées. Cela a montré l'utilité de cette méthode pour prouver l'absence de maladie dans les pays à ressources limitées. Par des méthodes participatives, nous avons impliqué les « agents communautaires de santé animale » dans leur propre évaluation et développé une nouvelle grille, qui comprend des indicateurs de succès utilisés par les agents eux-mêmes.Dans la seconde partie, nous avons examiné les méthodes pour améliorer la conception et l'efficacité de la surveillance passive. Nous avons appliqué la grille, pour évaluer 251 agents villageois dans trois provinces du Cambodge. La grille nous a permis de noter leur niveau d'activité et d'analyser, par régression logistique, les facteurs qui influencent l'obtention d'un score élevé. Puis, nous avons mis en place une étude pilote pour tester la déclaration par texto (SMS) auprès de 112 participants de 68 villages. L'objectif était de détecter des pics de mortalité et d'identifier plus rapidement les foyers de maladies infectieuses. Nous avons enfin utilisé l'analyse décisionnelle multicritère (MCDA) pour cartographier les risques de diffusion de l'IAHP H5N1 chez les volailles et les populations humaines en Thaïlande et au Cambodge, afin de renforcer la surveillance dans les zones à risque.En conclusion de ce travail, nous avons effectué une analyse comparative de deux environnements socio-économiques contraints : le Cambodge et Madagascar. Nous avons analysé les recherches mises en œuvre par le CIRAD (Centre Français de recherche pour le développement International) et ses partenaires dans ces 2 pays au cours de projets effectués ces 10 dernières années. L'objectif était de montrer comment de nouvelles approches pour les systèmes de surveillance peuvent être transférées entre différents pays aux contextes difficiles. A partir de cela, de nouvelles perspectives sont proposées.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Methods to improve zoonotic disease surveillance in poor rural settings : the example of highly pathogenic avian influenza (A) H5N1 in Southeast Asia
Comment améliorer l'efficacité de la surveillance passive des zoonoses en zones rurales : exemple de la grippe avaire H5N1 en Asie du Sud-Est: La propagation en Asie, Europe et Afrique du virus Influenza Aviaire hautement pathogène (IAHP) H5N1, l'épidémie de A/H1N1pdm en 2009, l'émergence de l'Influenza faiblement pathogène (IAFP), mais zoonotique, H7N9 en Chine en 2013 et la circulation récente de l'IAHP H5N8 en Europe, montrent que l'évolution permanente de ces virus chez les oiseaux, les humains et les porcs, pause un risque en santé humaine et animale au niveau mondial. Au cours des 10 dernières années, des efforts ont été fait pour renforcer les capacités en santé publique et vétérinaire. Malgré tout, le virus IAHP H5N1 reste endémique dans certains pays où il peut passer inaperçu dans les populations de volailles mais provoquent des cas humains. Ces pays sont caractérisés par une majorité de leur population vivant en zones rurales, une absence de systèmes de santé primaire et des secteurs de santé inefficaces.La surveillance passive (évènementielle) des maladies animales et humaines est souvent la seule méthode réalisable dans les milieux ruraux. Produisant une information incomplète, biaisée ou transmise avec des délais importants, elle a besoin d'être amélioré par des approches nouvelles mis en œuvre dans un cadre « One Health » prenant en compte les interfaces entre humains, animaux et environnement. Nous avons donc dans cette thèse conçu et/ou appliqué de nouvelles méthodes d'évaluation, de conception ou d'amélioration de la notification des cas d'IAHP H5N1 chez l'animal et chez l'homme en Asie du sud-est.Nous avons en premier examiné différentes alternatives d'évaluation. Nous avons appliqué des arbres de scénario (stochastique) pour modéliser et évaluer le système de surveillance de l'IAHP H5N1 en Thaïlande dans les systèmes traditionnels de productions avicoles. Nous avons estimé la sensibilité de la surveillance passive à 50 % (IC95 % 0,04-0,75) pour une détection maximale de 3 fermes infectées. Cela a montré l'utilité de cette méthode pour prouver l'absence de maladie dans les pays à ressources limitées. Par des méthodes participatives, nous avons impliqué les « agents communautaires de santé animale » dans leur propre évaluation et développé une nouvelle grille, qui comprend des indicateurs de succès utilisés par les agents eux-mêmes.Dans la seconde partie, nous avons examiné les méthodes pour améliorer la conception et l'efficacité de la surveillance passive. Nous avons appliqué la grille, pour évaluer 251 agents villageois dans trois provinces du Cambodge. La grille nous a permis de noter leur niveau d'activité et d'analyser, par régression logistique, les facteurs qui influencent l'obtention d'un score élevé. Puis, nous avons mis en place une étude pilote pour tester la déclaration par texto (SMS) auprès de 112 participants de 68 villages. L'objectif était de détecter des pics de mortalité et d'identifier plus rapidement les foyers de maladies infectieuses. Nous avons enfin utilisé l'analyse décisionnelle multicritère (MCDA) pour cartographier les risques de diffusion de l'IAHP H5N1 chez les volailles et les populations humaines en Thaïlande et au Cambodge, afin de renforcer la surveillance dans les zones à risque.En conclusion de ce travail, nous avons effectué une analyse comparative de deux environnements socio-économiques contraints : le Cambodge et Madagascar. Nous avons analysé les recherches mises en œuvre par le CIRAD (Centre Français de recherche pour le développement International) et ses partenaires dans ces 2 pays au cours de projets effectués ces 10 dernières années. L'objectif était de montrer comment de nouvelles approches pour les systèmes de surveillance peuvent être transférées entre différents pays aux contextes difficiles. A partir de cela, de nouvelles perspectives sont proposées.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by CIRAD (Centre de Cooperation Internationale en Recherche Agronomique Pour le Developpement) in Perspective
- No. 71,p. 1-4
Engaging communities to put disease prevention and the One Health approach into practice
In the face of the global rise in health crises, a consensus is emerging: prevention is better than cure. In this context, the One Health approach, as defined internationally and adopted by the Quadripartite (WHO, OIE, FAO and UNEP), offers an integrated framework based on the interdependence of animal, human and ecosystem health. It aims to act upstream of crises, addressing the systemic determinants of health risks and strengthening the resilience of regions. This approach explicitly recognises the role of local actors and communities in preventive actions, including early detection and measures to reduce risks and risky practices. Beyond acute crises, strengthening community-based surveillance and prevention systems facilitates alerts to health services, the continuity of awareness-raising activities, and local ownership of health measures.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by CIRAD (Centre de Cooperation Internationale en Recherche Agronomique Pour le Developpement) in Perspective
- No. 71,p. 1-4
Open AccessEngaging communities to put disease prevention and the One Health approach into practice
In the face of the global rise in health crises, a consensus is emerging: prevention is better than cure. In this context, the One Health approach, as defined internationally and adopted by the Quadripartite (WHO, OIE, FAO and UNEP), offers an integrated framework based on the interdependence of animal, human and ecosystem health. It aims to act upstream of crises, addressing the systemic determinants of health risks and strengthening the resilience of regions. This approach explicitly recognises the role of local actors and communities in preventive actions, including early detection and measures to reduce risks and risky practices. Beyond acute crises, strengthening community-based surveillance and prevention systems facilitates alerts to health services, the continuity of awareness-raising activities, and local ownership of health measures.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by CIRAD (Centre de Cooperation Internationale en Recherche Agronomique Pour le Developpement) in Perspective
- No. 71,p. 1-4
Engager les communautés pour opérationnaliser la prévention des maladies et l’approche One Health
Face à l’accélération globale des crises sanitaires, un consensus s’impose : il faut prévenir plutôt que subir. Dans ce contexte, l’approche One Health, dans sa définition internationale, adoptée par la Quadripartite (OMS, OMSA, FAO et UNEP), propose un cadre intégré fondé sur l’interdépendance des santés des animaux, des humains et des écosystèmes. Elle vise à agir en amont des crises, sur les déterminants systémiques des risques sanitaires, et en renforçant la résilience des territoires. Cette approche reconnait explicitement le rôle des acteurs locaux et des communautés dans les actions de prévention dont la détection précoce et les mesures de réduction des risques et pratiques à risque. Au-delà des crises aiguës, le renforcement des systèmes communautaires de surveillance et de prévention facilite les alertes aux services de santé et la continuité des actions de sensibilisation et l’appropriation locale des mesures sanitaires.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by CIRAD (Centre de Cooperation Internationale en Recherche Agronomique Pour le Developpement) in Perspective
- No. 71,p. 1-4
Open AccessEngager les communautés pour opérationnaliser la prévention des maladies et l’approche One Health
Face à l’accélération globale des crises sanitaires, un consensus s’impose : il faut prévenir plutôt que subir. Dans ce contexte, l’approche One Health, dans sa définition internationale, adoptée par la Quadripartite (OMS, OMSA, FAO et UNEP), propose un cadre intégré fondé sur l’interdépendance des santés des animaux, des humains et des écosystèmes. Elle vise à agir en amont des crises, sur les déterminants systémiques des risques sanitaires, et en renforçant la résilience des territoires. Cette approche reconnait explicitement le rôle des acteurs locaux et des communautés dans les actions de prévention dont la détection précoce et les mesures de réduction des risques et pratiques à risque. Au-delà des crises aiguës, le renforcement des systèmes communautaires de surveillance et de prévention facilite les alertes aux services de santé et la continuité des actions de sensibilisation et l’appropriation locale des mesures sanitaires.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (10) , e0335184
Participatory process to design community-driven solutions for reducing antibiotic use in chicken production in Vietnam
International organizations emphasize the urgent need to reduce antibiotic use to combat antimicrobial resistance, including in livestock farming. Technical, regulatory, and awareness-raising strategies exist, but they often fail due to a misalignment with farmers’ realities. We hypothesize that actively engaging communities in the design of solutions will more effectively reduce antibiotic usage. We have therefore adapted and applied the ImpresS ex ante approach (impact of research in the South), to co-design solutions with stakeholders from the chicken and veterinary value chain at a local level in Vietnam. Eighteen participants (chicken farmers, drug sellers’ representatives, public and private veterinarians, a chicken retailer, and academic staff), working at the communal, district, or provincial level, were involved in three half-day workshops organized in Thai Nguyen province in April 2022. Through this participatory process, participants collectively envisioned a 10-year future with reduced antibiotic use in chicken farms. They identified barriers including the lack of outlets for organic meat products, lack of knowledge and awareness of biosecurity and organic farming, low compliance of small-scale farms with biosecurity, and lack of science and technology related to alternative products. Participants decided to address “knowledge gaps” barrier. They have designed two strategies to improve the training of farmers and drug sellers, so that it is closer to the chicken value chain realities and reaches a greater audience. In this study, we identify systemic barriers to reducing antibiotic use, while recommending practical solutions. We also advocate the need to include locally-developed solutions in the national action plan on antimicrobial resistance in Vietnam and to involve policy-makers in participatory processes to design effective strategies.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (10) , e0335184
Open AccessParticipatory process to design community-driven solutions for reducing antibiotic use in chicken production in Vietnam
International organizations emphasize the urgent need to reduce antibiotic use to combat antimicrobial resistance, including in livestock farming. Technical, regulatory, and awareness-raising strategies exist, but they often fail due to a misalignment with farmers’ realities. We hypothesize that actively engaging communities in the design of solutions will more effectively reduce antibiotic usage. We have therefore adapted and applied the ImpresS ex ante approach (impact of research in the South), to co-design solutions with stakeholders from the chicken and veterinary value chain at a local level in Vietnam. Eighteen participants (chicken farmers, drug sellers’ representatives, public and private veterinarians, a chicken retailer, and academic staff), working at the communal, district, or provincial level, were involved in three half-day workshops organized in Thai Nguyen province in April 2022. Through this participatory process, participants collectively envisioned a 10-year future with reduced antibiotic use in chicken farms. They identified barriers including the lack of outlets for organic meat products, lack of knowledge and awareness of biosecurity and organic farming, low compliance of small-scale farms with biosecurity, and lack of science and technology related to alternative products. Participants decided to address “knowledge gaps” barrier. They have designed two strategies to improve the training of farmers and drug sellers, so that it is closer to the chicken value chain realities and reaches a greater audience. In this study, we identify systemic barriers to reducing antibiotic use, while recommending practical solutions. We also advocate the need to include locally-developed solutions in the national action plan on antimicrobial resistance in Vietnam and to involve policy-makers in participatory processes to design effective strategies.
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 5
Understanding the implementation of antimicrobial resistance policies in Vietnam: a multilayer analysis of the veterinary drug value chain
Reducing antibiotic use in livestock production has been a target for national action plans worldwide. The Vietnamese livestock plan issued in 2017 has, among other objectives, strengthened the regulatory framework for antibiotic use. While a progressive ban on prophylactic antibiotics in feed and the introduction of mandatory prescriptions have been introduced, the level of implementation of these measures remains unknown. This study explores the level of understanding, acceptance, and application of these regulations among veterinary drug value chain stakeholders. An iterative stakeholder mapping and analysis of the veterinary drug value chain was conducted in North and South Vietnam. We organized one focus group discussion in Hanoi with 12 participants and conducted 39 semi-structured interviews with governmental authorities, national research centers, foreign partners, and private stakeholders along the value chain. The discourses were analyzed to (1) map the veterinary drug value chain and interactions among stakeholders, (2) analyze stakeholder’s technical and social capital regarding regulations, and (3) identify factors influencing their implementation. From the map of the veterinary drug value chain, we identified 30 categories of stakeholders. Based on the map, the capital, and the analysis of the discourse, we identified 10 factors that could influence their implementation. These factors included stakeholder perception of the new regulations, their level of knowledge, the availability of technical guidance, conflict of economic interest between stakeholders, scale-related management discrepancies, the technical and financial barriers to the implementation of the regulations at the local level, the presence of an informal distribution channel, international influence, consumer demand for food safety, and the willingness to reduce the burden of antibiotic resistance. It was clearly identified that new regulations are a necessary step to reducing antibiotic usage in Vietnam, but that the lack of local stakeholder involvement combined with technical constraints were barriers to their implementation. The study underlined the need for greater involvement of local stakeholders in the development of regulations as well as the need to mainstream innovations developed by small producers.
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 5
Understanding the implementation of antimicrobial resistance policies in Vietnam: a multilayer analysis of the veterinary drug value chain
Reducing antibiotic use in livestock production has been a target for national action plans worldwide. The Vietnamese livestock plan issued in 2017 has, among other objectives, strengthened the regulatory framework for antibiotic use. While a progressive ban on prophylactic antibiotics in feed and the introduction of mandatory prescriptions have been introduced, the level of implementation of these measures remains unknown. This study explores the level of understanding, acceptance, and application of these regulations among veterinary drug value chain stakeholders. An iterative stakeholder mapping and analysis of the veterinary drug value chain was conducted in North and South Vietnam. We organized one focus group discussion in Hanoi with 12 participants and conducted 39 semi-structured interviews with governmental authorities, national research centers, foreign partners, and private stakeholders along the value chain. The discourses were analyzed to (1) map the veterinary drug value chain and interactions among stakeholders, (2) analyze stakeholder’s technical and social capital regarding regulations, and (3) identify factors influencing their implementation. From the map of the veterinary drug value chain, we identified 30 categories of stakeholders. Based on the map, the capital, and the analysis of the discourse, we identified 10 factors that could influence their implementation. These factors included stakeholder perception of the new regulations, their level of knowledge, the availability of technical guidance, conflict of economic interest between stakeholders, scale-related management discrepancies, the technical and financial barriers to the implementation of the regulations at the local level, the presence of an informal distribution channel, international influence, consumer demand for food safety, and the willingness to reduce the burden of antibiotic resistance. It was clearly identified that new regulations are a necessary step to reducing antibiotic usage in Vietnam, but that the lack of local stakeholder involvement combined with technical constraints were barriers to their implementation. The study underlined the need for greater involvement of local stakeholders in the development of regulations as well as the need to mainstream innovations developed by small producers.
- 1 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Eurochoices
- Vol. 23 (2) , 72-77
AMR as a Global and One Health Issue: the Challenge to Adapt a Global Strategy in Two Low‐ and Middle‐income Countries, Mozambique and Vietnam
Summary: Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is framed by international organisations as a global threat requiring a One Health (OH) approach. This raises challenges for adapting a global strategy to national contexts and sectorial policies. In the agricultural sector, another challenge is to avoid stigmatization of farmers’ behaviours and to pay more attention to other stakeholders and systemic drivers of antibiotic (AB) use. We examine the case of two low‐ and middle‐income countries (LMICs): Mozambique and Vietnam, with different levels of veterinary AB consumption (respectively lower and higher than the world average), accessibility to alternatives to veterinary AB (non‐existent in Mozambique) and veterinary medicines and services (very unequal in Mozambique), and opportunities to value higher‐standard products on domestic markets (emerging in Vietnam). The differences between these two LMICs challenges current ‘one size fits all’ strategies. We recommend embedding better national AMR strategies into sectorial agricultural policies and country‐specific contexts (i.e. by considering the functioning of the drugs markets and livestock value chains; resistance to other veterinary medicines, such as trypanocide), and to address the observed contradictions with national agricultural policies which, in order to face the growing consumption of animal products, encourage the development of livestock systems that are technically and economically dependent on the use of AB.
- 1 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Eurochoices
- Vol. 23 (2) , 72-77
AMR as a Global and One Health Issue: the Challenge to Adapt a Global Strategy in Two Low‐ and Middle‐income Countries, Mozambique and Vietnam
Summary: Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is framed by international organisations as a global threat requiring a One Health (OH) approach. This raises challenges for adapting a global strategy to national contexts and sectorial policies. In the agricultural sector, another challenge is to avoid stigmatization of farmers’ behaviours and to pay more attention to other stakeholders and systemic drivers of antibiotic (AB) use. We examine the case of two low‐ and middle‐income countries (LMICs): Mozambique and Vietnam, with different levels of veterinary AB consumption (respectively lower and higher than the world average), accessibility to alternatives to veterinary AB (non‐existent in Mozambique) and veterinary medicines and services (very unequal in Mozambique), and opportunities to value higher‐standard products on domestic markets (emerging in Vietnam). The differences between these two LMICs challenges current ‘one size fits all’ strategies. We recommend embedding better national AMR strategies into sectorial agricultural policies and country‐specific contexts (i.e. by considering the functioning of the drugs markets and livestock value chains; resistance to other veterinary medicines, such as trypanocide), and to address the observed contradictions with national agricultural policies which, in order to face the growing consumption of animal products, encourage the development of livestock systems that are technically and economically dependent on the use of AB.
- Open Access
Understanding the implementation of antimicrobial resistance policies in Vietnam: a multilayer analysis of the veterinary drug value chain
A bstract: Reducing antibiotic use in livestock production has been a target for national action plans worldwide. The Vietnamese livestock plan issued in 2017 has, among other objectives, strengthened the regulatory framework for antibiotic use. While a progressive ban on prophylactic antibiotics in feed and the introduction of mandatory prescriptions have been introduced, the level of implementation of these measures remains unknown. This study explores the level of understanding, acceptance, and application of these regulations among veterinary drug value chain stakeholders. An iterative stakeholder mapping and analysis of the veterinary drug value chain was conducted in north and south Vietnam. We organized one focus group discussion in Hanoi with 12 participants and conducted 39 semi-structured interviews with governmental authorities, national research centers, foreign partners, and private stakeholders along the value chain. The discourses were analyzed to (1) map the veterinary drug value chain and interactions among stakeholders, (2) analyze stakeholder’s technical and social capital regarding regulations, and (3) identify factors influencing their implementation. From the map of the veterinary drug value chain, we identified 30 categories of stakeholders. Based on the map, the capital, and the analysis of the discourse, we identified 10 factors that could influence their implementation. These factors included stakeholder perception of the new regulations, their level of knowledge, the availability of technical guidance, conflict of economic interest between stakeholders, scale-related management discrepancies, the technical and financial barriers to the implementation of the regulations at the local level, the presence of an informal distribution channel, international influence, consumer demand for food safety, and the willingness to reduce the burden of antibiotic resistance. It was clearly identified that new regulations are a necessary step to reducing antibiotic usage in Vietnam, but that the lack of local stakeholder involvement combined with technical constraints were barriers to their implementation. The study underlined the need for greater involvement of local stakeholders in the development of regulations as well as the need to mainstream innovations developed by small producers.
Open AccessUnderstanding the implementation of antimicrobial resistance policies in Vietnam: a multilayer analysis of the veterinary drug value chain
A bstract: Reducing antibiotic use in livestock production has been a target for national action plans worldwide. The Vietnamese livestock plan issued in 2017 has, among other objectives, strengthened the regulatory framework for antibiotic use. While a progressive ban on prophylactic antibiotics in feed and the introduction of mandatory prescriptions have been introduced, the level of implementation of these measures remains unknown. This study explores the level of understanding, acceptance, and application of these regulations among veterinary drug value chain stakeholders. An iterative stakeholder mapping and analysis of the veterinary drug value chain was conducted in north and south Vietnam. We organized one focus group discussion in Hanoi with 12 participants and conducted 39 semi-structured interviews with governmental authorities, national research centers, foreign partners, and private stakeholders along the value chain. The discourses were analyzed to (1) map the veterinary drug value chain and interactions among stakeholders, (2) analyze stakeholder’s technical and social capital regarding regulations, and (3) identify factors influencing their implementation. From the map of the veterinary drug value chain, we identified 30 categories of stakeholders. Based on the map, the capital, and the analysis of the discourse, we identified 10 factors that could influence their implementation. These factors included stakeholder perception of the new regulations, their level of knowledge, the availability of technical guidance, conflict of economic interest between stakeholders, scale-related management discrepancies, the technical and financial barriers to the implementation of the regulations at the local level, the presence of an informal distribution channel, international influence, consumer demand for food safety, and the willingness to reduce the burden of antibiotic resistance. It was clearly identified that new regulations are a necessary step to reducing antibiotic usage in Vietnam, but that the lack of local stakeholder involvement combined with technical constraints were barriers to their implementation. The study underlined the need for greater involvement of local stakeholders in the development of regulations as well as the need to mainstream innovations developed by small producers.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in JAC-Antimicrobial Resistance
- Vol. 6 (3) , dlae089
Evaluation of screening algorithms to detect rectal colonization with carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales in a resource-limited setting
To improve and rationalize the detection of carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) in rectal swabs in a high-prevalence and resource-constrained setting, addressing surveillance challenges typically encountered in laboratories with limited resources. A point prevalence survey (PPS) was conducted on 15 August 2022, in a provincial children’s hospital in northern Vietnam. Rectal swab samples of all admitted children were collected and plated on a selective medium for carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales (CRE). Species identification and antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) were performed by MALDI-TOF, and VITEK2 XL and interpreted according to CLSI breakpoints (2022). Carbapenemases were detected by the carbapenem inactivation method (CIM) and quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). Rectal swab samples were obtained from 376 patients. Of 178 isolates growing on the CRE screening agar, 140 isolates were confirmed as Enterobacterales of which 118 (84.3%) isolates were resistant to meropenem and/or ertapenem. CIM and PCR showed that 90/118 (76.3%) were carbapenemase producers. Overall, 83/367 (22.6%) were colonized by CPE. Klebsiella pneumoniae, Escherichia coli and Enterobacter cloacae complex were the most common CPE detected, with NDM as the predominant carbapenemase (78/90; 86.7%). Phenotypic resistance to meropenem was the best predictor of CPE production (sensitivity 85.6%, specificity 100%) compared with ertapenem resistance (95.6% sensitivity, 36% specificity). CIM was 100% concordant with PCR in detecting carbapenemases. These findings underscore the effectiveness of meropenem resistance as a robust indicator of the production of carbapenemases and the reliability of the CIM method to detect such carbapenemases in resource-limited settings where the performance of molecular methods is not possible.
- 6 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in JAC-Antimicrobial Resistance
- Vol. 6 (3) , dlae089
Open AccessEvaluation of screening algorithms to detect rectal colonization with carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales in a resource-limited setting
To improve and rationalize the detection of carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) in rectal swabs in a high-prevalence and resource-constrained setting, addressing surveillance challenges typically encountered in laboratories with limited resources. A point prevalence survey (PPS) was conducted on 15 August 2022, in a provincial children’s hospital in northern Vietnam. Rectal swab samples of all admitted children were collected and plated on a selective medium for carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales (CRE). Species identification and antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) were performed by MALDI-TOF, and VITEK2 XL and interpreted according to CLSI breakpoints (2022). Carbapenemases were detected by the carbapenem inactivation method (CIM) and quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). Rectal swab samples were obtained from 376 patients. Of 178 isolates growing on the CRE screening agar, 140 isolates were confirmed as Enterobacterales of which 118 (84.3%) isolates were resistant to meropenem and/or ertapenem. CIM and PCR showed that 90/118 (76.3%) were carbapenemase producers. Overall, 83/367 (22.6%) were colonized by CPE. Klebsiella pneumoniae, Escherichia coli and Enterobacter cloacae complex were the most common CPE detected, with NDM as the predominant carbapenemase (78/90; 86.7%). Phenotypic resistance to meropenem was the best predictor of CPE production (sensitivity 85.6%, specificity 100%) compared with ertapenem resistance (95.6% sensitivity, 36% specificity). CIM was 100% concordant with PCR in detecting carbapenemases. These findings underscore the effectiveness of meropenem resistance as a robust indicator of the production of carbapenemases and the reliability of the CIM method to detect such carbapenemases in resource-limited settings where the performance of molecular methods is not possible.
- 2 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 163-177
The Use of Participatory Methods in the Evaluation of Health Surveillance Systems
- 2 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 163-177
The Use of Participatory Methods in the Evaluation of Health Surveillance Systems