Marie Elisabeth Herberstein
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Marie Elisabeth Herberstein has a total of 367 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gregory Ian Holwell
School of Biological Sciences University of Auckland Auckland New Zealand
18 shared publications - Mark Adrian Elgar
School of BioSciences The University of Melbourne Parkville Victoria Australia
17 shared publications - Darrell J. Kemp
School of Natural Sciences, Macquarie University , Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
11 shared publications - Anne E. Wignall
Macquarie University
9 shared publications Jutta M. Schneider
Department of Biological Sciences Macquarie University North Ryde New South Wales Australia
9 shared publications- Anne. C. Gaskett
School of Biological Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 241
Increased response latency in Araneus diadematus (Araneidae) during putative sleep in the wild
- 24 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 241
Open AccessIncreased response latency in Araneus diadematus (Araneidae) during putative sleep in the wild
- Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (5)
Crab spider vision improves their prey capture despite low visual system investment
Crab spiders (Thomisidae) are well-known predators, typically ambushing prey upon flowers and other plants. This style of predation suggests a potential benefit from vision in prey capture by crab spiders despite their comparatively small eyes. However, behavioural evidence on the impact of vision on prey capture success by crab spiders is currently lacking. To address this knowledge gap, we assessed predatory performance in blinded and unblinded crab spiders (Sidymella rubrosignata) co-housed with fruit flies as prey. The results indicate that a lack of visual cues significantly hindered prey capture success. We contextualize this finding using micro-computed X-ray tomography to quantitatively compare the visual optics and central nervous system of S. rubrosignata to other spider species with known hunting strategies (both visual and non-visual). We find that neither high levels of visual system investment nor interocular volumetric specialization are evident in crab spiders, despite the implied contribution of vision to prey capture. Presenting evidence that vision impacts hunting by crab spiders has important implications for our understanding of the elaborate visual ecology of these animals as well as providing key information for future studies on the comparative evolution of eyes and their underlying nervous systems.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (5)
Open AccessCrab spider vision improves their prey capture despite low visual system investment
Crab spiders (Thomisidae) are well-known predators, typically ambushing prey upon flowers and other plants. This style of predation suggests a potential benefit from vision in prey capture by crab spiders despite their comparatively small eyes. However, behavioural evidence on the impact of vision on prey capture success by crab spiders is currently lacking. To address this knowledge gap, we assessed predatory performance in blinded and unblinded crab spiders (Sidymella rubrosignata) co-housed with fruit flies as prey. The results indicate that a lack of visual cues significantly hindered prey capture success. We contextualize this finding using micro-computed X-ray tomography to quantitatively compare the visual optics and central nervous system of S. rubrosignata to other spider species with known hunting strategies (both visual and non-visual). We find that neither high levels of visual system investment nor interocular volumetric specialization are evident in crab spiders, despite the implied contribution of vision to prey capture. Presenting evidence that vision impacts hunting by crab spiders has important implications for our understanding of the elaborate visual ecology of these animals as well as providing key information for future studies on the comparative evolution of eyes and their underlying nervous systems.
- Open Access
- 13 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
- Vol. 80 (5) , 68
Context-dependent abdomen bobbing in a jumping spider: a dynamic visual signal
Signals function in intra- and inter-specific communication across several different contexts, such as predation, foraging, competition and mate choice. Static signals including shape or color are well-studied, whereas locomotion-related signals remain less understood despite being particularly intriguing as they can be controlled by the animal’s perception of danger or competition. In this study, we explore the potential function of a highly conspicuous dynamic behavior—abdomen bobbing—exhibited by the diurnal jumping spider Heliophanus cf. cupreus during locomotion. Due to the high conspicuousness, we hypothesized that abdomen bobbing could function as a visual signal, specifically as an anti-predatory signal. To test this hypothesis, we first analyzed the behavior and found that bobs occurred almost exclusively during gait stops (98.5%) with 83.5% of gait stops entailing abdomen bobbing. We then examined its context-dependency, measuring the prevalence of abdomen bobbing under five conditions: (1) control, (2) in darkness, (3) during prey encounters, (4) during simulated conspecific encounters (i.e. mirror), and (5) during predator encounters. Abdomen bobbing was virtually absent in darkness and during prey encounters, but significantly increased during conspecific and predator encounters, suggesting active control. The increase in abdomen bobbing when confronted with a predator supports an anti-predatory signaling function, potentially a form of locomotion mimicry. We equally found support for an intra-specific signaling function, which might indicate the co-option of this signal from one context (predatory) to another (conspecific). Our study opens new avenues for investigating the role of motion in spiders for both inter- and intraspecific signaling.
- 13 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
- Vol. 80 (5) , 68
Open AccessContext-dependent abdomen bobbing in a jumping spider: a dynamic visual signal
Signals function in intra- and inter-specific communication across several different contexts, such as predation, foraging, competition and mate choice. Static signals including shape or color are well-studied, whereas locomotion-related signals remain less understood despite being particularly intriguing as they can be controlled by the animal’s perception of danger or competition. In this study, we explore the potential function of a highly conspicuous dynamic behavior—abdomen bobbing—exhibited by the diurnal jumping spider Heliophanus cf. cupreus during locomotion. Due to the high conspicuousness, we hypothesized that abdomen bobbing could function as a visual signal, specifically as an anti-predatory signal. To test this hypothesis, we first analyzed the behavior and found that bobs occurred almost exclusively during gait stops (98.5%) with 83.5% of gait stops entailing abdomen bobbing. We then examined its context-dependency, measuring the prevalence of abdomen bobbing under five conditions: (1) control, (2) in darkness, (3) during prey encounters, (4) during simulated conspecific encounters (i.e. mirror), and (5) during predator encounters. Abdomen bobbing was virtually absent in darkness and during prey encounters, but significantly increased during conspecific and predator encounters, suggesting active control. The increase in abdomen bobbing when confronted with a predator supports an anti-predatory signaling function, potentially a form of locomotion mimicry. We equally found support for an intra-specific signaling function, which might indicate the co-option of this signal from one context (predatory) to another (conspecific). Our study opens new avenues for investigating the role of motion in spiders for both inter- and intraspecific signaling.
- Open Access
- 6 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (4)
Are Toxic Butterflies More Easily Detected by Human ‘Predators’?
Butterfly colours often signal unprofitability due to toxicity to predators, with more conspicuous colour signals increasing predator avoidance learning. These signals can be on the dorsal and/or ventral wing surfaces, which are more visible during flight or at rest respectively. Here we are interested in the relationship between toxicity and conspicuousness in Australian butterflies. We use detectability as a proxy for conspicuousness and test whether toxic butterflies are more detectable on both the dorsal and ventral wing sides using a computer game where humans hunt butterflies against multiple backgrounds. The game was played by over 1700 players who collectively reacted to over 67,000 images of butterflies. Toxicity was assessed using Daphnia mortality assays on over 420 individuals from 61 species. Specifically, we tested (1) if the detectability of dorsal or ventral butterfly wings was related to toxicity, and (2) if butterflies that were more toxic had similar dorsal and ventral detectability. For dorsal surfaces, we found that the more toxic butterflies were detected faster than less toxic butterflies, whereas there was no relationship between toxicity and detection time for ventral surfaces. These findings are consistent with previous work that suggests aposematic signals are particularly relevant when animals are in motion, since the dorsal wing surface of butterflies—the more detectable side—is usually visible during flight rather than at rest. We also found that more toxic butterflies were more similar between dorsal and ventral detection, suggesting that greater levels of toxicity are communicated both ventrally and dorsally.
- 6 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (4)
Open AccessAre Toxic Butterflies More Easily Detected by Human ‘Predators’?
Butterfly colours often signal unprofitability due to toxicity to predators, with more conspicuous colour signals increasing predator avoidance learning. These signals can be on the dorsal and/or ventral wing surfaces, which are more visible during flight or at rest respectively. Here we are interested in the relationship between toxicity and conspicuousness in Australian butterflies. We use detectability as a proxy for conspicuousness and test whether toxic butterflies are more detectable on both the dorsal and ventral wing sides using a computer game where humans hunt butterflies against multiple backgrounds. The game was played by over 1700 players who collectively reacted to over 67,000 images of butterflies. Toxicity was assessed using Daphnia mortality assays on over 420 individuals from 61 species. Specifically, we tested (1) if the detectability of dorsal or ventral butterfly wings was related to toxicity, and (2) if butterflies that were more toxic had similar dorsal and ventral detectability. For dorsal surfaces, we found that the more toxic butterflies were detected faster than less toxic butterflies, whereas there was no relationship between toxicity and detection time for ventral surfaces. These findings are consistent with previous work that suggests aposematic signals are particularly relevant when animals are in motion, since the dorsal wing surface of butterflies—the more detectable side—is usually visible during flight rather than at rest. We also found that more toxic butterflies were more similar between dorsal and ventral detection, suggesting that greater levels of toxicity are communicated both ventrally and dorsally.
- Open Access
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Database: The Journal of Biological Databases and Curation
- Vol. 2026
OzButterflies – a high quality open database of multispectral images and spectra of tropical to temperate Australian butterflies
Butterflies have been a model system for studying the evolution of colour. This is partly due to their complex patterns that reflect human-visible (VIS) and ultraviolet (UV) light, which are perceived by conspecifics and predators. Many studies have sourced data from publicly available images, but most of these images only consider the visible spectrum of light. Including the UV spectrum is crucial for fully understanding the evolution of butterfly morphology and behavioural ecology. Here we provide standardized images (VIS and UV) of over 4 000 individuals from 16 communities of Australian butterflies. These communities represent different climates and urbanization levels spanning over 2 500 km. The dataset contains at least one individual of 125 different species from five families, constituting over one quarter of Australian butterfly diversity. In addition to photographs, we provide spectral measurements of butterfly wings for at least one individual of each species and sex, and Cytochrome Oxidase subunit 1 (CO1) sequences of 1 635 individuals. All these data are accessible in Zenodo and an associated R package simplifies the download of subsets of the database. This database will be of use to evolutionary biologists and ecologists interested in a broad range of topics related to phenotypic variation.
- 15 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Database: The Journal of Biological Databases and Curation
- Vol. 2026
Open AccessOzButterflies – a high quality open database of multispectral images and spectra of tropical to temperate Australian butterflies
Butterflies have been a model system for studying the evolution of colour. This is partly due to their complex patterns that reflect human-visible (VIS) and ultraviolet (UV) light, which are perceived by conspecifics and predators. Many studies have sourced data from publicly available images, but most of these images only consider the visible spectrum of light. Including the UV spectrum is crucial for fully understanding the evolution of butterfly morphology and behavioural ecology. Here we provide standardized images (VIS and UV) of over 4 000 individuals from 16 communities of Australian butterflies. These communities represent different climates and urbanization levels spanning over 2 500 km. The dataset contains at least one individual of 125 different species from five families, constituting over one quarter of Australian butterfly diversity. In addition to photographs, we provide spectral measurements of butterfly wings for at least one individual of each species and sex, and Cytochrome Oxidase subunit 1 (CO1) sequences of 1 635 individuals. All these data are accessible in Zenodo and an associated R package simplifies the download of subsets of the database. This database will be of use to evolutionary biologists and ecologists interested in a broad range of topics related to phenotypic variation.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (10)
Complementary approaches to measure predation pressure on butterfly populations in Australia
Predation pressure is a major force driving the evolution of anti-predatory traits, yet quantifying its intensity in the wild remains difficult. In this study, we combined three complementary methods to evaluate predation risk in Australian butterfly communities: assessing wing damage on wild butterflies, monitoring attacks on artificial butterfly replicas, and surveying bird communities. Across eight sites in Sydney, Australia, we recorded wing damage on 1070 free-living butterflies from five families, assessed attacks on 1600 butterfly replicas, and surveyed local bird diversity. Of the wild butterflies, 807 showed wing damage, with 169 individuals (16% of all butterflies) exhibiting patterns consistent with bird attacks. Among replicas, 114 (7%) showed evidence of predation, of which 31 (2% of all replicas) were likely to be attacked by birds. Predation on wild butterflies was most strongly associated with bird community composition, bird density, and butterfly size (wingspan), while replica attacks were influenced primarily by bird community composition and density. Our results suggest that butterfly wing damage and replica attacks data provide complementary, but not interchangeable, insights into predation risk. When integrated, they offer a more robust picture of true predation pressure. Our results underscore the critical role of bird community structure in shaping predation risk—an important consideration for any method used to assess predation in natural prey communities.
- 29 October 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (10)
Open AccessComplementary approaches to measure predation pressure on butterfly populations in Australia
Predation pressure is a major force driving the evolution of anti-predatory traits, yet quantifying its intensity in the wild remains difficult. In this study, we combined three complementary methods to evaluate predation risk in Australian butterfly communities: assessing wing damage on wild butterflies, monitoring attacks on artificial butterfly replicas, and surveying bird communities. Across eight sites in Sydney, Australia, we recorded wing damage on 1070 free-living butterflies from five families, assessed attacks on 1600 butterfly replicas, and surveyed local bird diversity. Of the wild butterflies, 807 showed wing damage, with 169 individuals (16% of all butterflies) exhibiting patterns consistent with bird attacks. Among replicas, 114 (7%) showed evidence of predation, of which 31 (2% of all replicas) were likely to be attacked by birds. Predation on wild butterflies was most strongly associated with bird community composition, bird density, and butterfly size (wingspan), while replica attacks were influenced primarily by bird community composition and density. Our results suggest that butterfly wing damage and replica attacks data provide complementary, but not interchangeable, insights into predation risk. When integrated, they offer a more robust picture of true predation pressure. Our results underscore the critical role of bird community structure in shaping predation risk—an important consideration for any method used to assess predation in natural prey communities.
- Open Access
Context-dependent abdomen bobbing in a jumping spider: a dynamic visual signal
Anti-predatory visual signals play a key role in deterring predatory attacks, and can include crypsis, warning colors or visual mimicry. Static traits such as shape or color are well-studied, whereas locomotion-related signals remain less understood despite being particularly intriguing as they can be controlled by the animal’s perception of danger. In this study, we explore the potential function of a highly conspicuous dynamic behavior—abdomen bobbing—exhibited by the diurnal jumping spider Heliophanus cf. cupreus during locomotion. Due to the high conspicuousness, we hypothesized that abdomen bobbing could function as a visual signal, specifically as an anti-predatory signal. To test this hypothesis, we first analyzed the behavior and found that bobs occur almost exclusively during gait stops (98.5%) with 83.5% of gait stops entailing abdomen bobbing. We then examined its context-dependency, measuring the prevalence of abdomen bobbing under four conditions: 1) control, 2) in darkness, 3) during prey encounters, 4) during simulated conspecific encounters (i.e. mirror), and 5) during predator encounters. Abdomen bobbing was virtually absent in darkness and during prey encounters, but significantly increased during conspecific and predator encounters, suggesting active control. The increase in abdomen bobbing when confronted with a predator strongly supports an anti-predatory signaling function, potentially a form of locomotion mimicry. We equally found support for an intra-specific signaling function, which might indicate the co-option of a signal from one context (predatory) to another (conspecific). Our study opens new avenues for investigating the role of motion in both inter- and intraspecific signaling.
Open AccessContext-dependent abdomen bobbing in a jumping spider: a dynamic visual signal
Anti-predatory visual signals play a key role in deterring predatory attacks, and can include crypsis, warning colors or visual mimicry. Static traits such as shape or color are well-studied, whereas locomotion-related signals remain less understood despite being particularly intriguing as they can be controlled by the animal’s perception of danger. In this study, we explore the potential function of a highly conspicuous dynamic behavior—abdomen bobbing—exhibited by the diurnal jumping spider Heliophanus cf. cupreus during locomotion. Due to the high conspicuousness, we hypothesized that abdomen bobbing could function as a visual signal, specifically as an anti-predatory signal. To test this hypothesis, we first analyzed the behavior and found that bobs occur almost exclusively during gait stops (98.5%) with 83.5% of gait stops entailing abdomen bobbing. We then examined its context-dependency, measuring the prevalence of abdomen bobbing under four conditions: 1) control, 2) in darkness, 3) during prey encounters, 4) during simulated conspecific encounters (i.e. mirror), and 5) during predator encounters. Abdomen bobbing was virtually absent in darkness and during prey encounters, but significantly increased during conspecific and predator encounters, suggesting active control. The increase in abdomen bobbing when confronted with a predator strongly supports an anti-predatory signaling function, potentially a form of locomotion mimicry. We equally found support for an intra-specific signaling function, which might indicate the co-option of a signal from one context (predatory) to another (conspecific). Our study opens new avenues for investigating the role of motion in both inter- and intraspecific signaling.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (9)
A parasitic or mutualistic conundrum: can symbiotic protists increase thermal tolerance in a semi-aquatic insect?
Rising temperatures and frequent heatwaves pose a major threat to ectotherms due to their reliance on environmental temperature for physiological processes. Thermal tolerance, the ability to withstand varying temperature, determines how effectively and efficiently individuals can survive under extreme conditions. Host–microbial symbiotic interactions can influence thermal tolerance in insects; however, we have limited information especially for some endosymbionts such as gregarines, a group of apicomplexan endoparasites, which are commonly found in the guts of many aquatic and terrestrial insects. Gregarines are often considered parasitic, while a few recent studies have shown beneficial effects on hosts. Here, we tested the impact of gregarines on thermal tolerance in Ischnura heterosticta damselflies. We found that damselflies naturally infected with gregarines had higher thermal tolerance than damselflies without gregarine infections. Our findings provide evidence in support of gregarines as an endosymbiont of I. heterosticta damselfly. Our study indicates that gregarine endosymbionts may assist damselfly and possibly other semi-aquatic insects to sustain extreme heat and highlights the importance of understanding host–symbiont interactions in the context of climate change and species conservation.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (9)
Open AccessA parasitic or mutualistic conundrum: can symbiotic protists increase thermal tolerance in a semi-aquatic insect?
Rising temperatures and frequent heatwaves pose a major threat to ectotherms due to their reliance on environmental temperature for physiological processes. Thermal tolerance, the ability to withstand varying temperature, determines how effectively and efficiently individuals can survive under extreme conditions. Host–microbial symbiotic interactions can influence thermal tolerance in insects; however, we have limited information especially for some endosymbionts such as gregarines, a group of apicomplexan endoparasites, which are commonly found in the guts of many aquatic and terrestrial insects. Gregarines are often considered parasitic, while a few recent studies have shown beneficial effects on hosts. Here, we tested the impact of gregarines on thermal tolerance in Ischnura heterosticta damselflies. We found that damselflies naturally infected with gregarines had higher thermal tolerance than damselflies without gregarine infections. Our findings provide evidence in support of gregarines as an endosymbiont of I. heterosticta damselfly. Our study indicates that gregarine endosymbionts may assist damselfly and possibly other semi-aquatic insects to sustain extreme heat and highlights the importance of understanding host–symbiont interactions in the context of climate change and species conservation.
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Behavioral Ecology
- Vol. 36 (4)
Behavior across time and space – how large scale “trait-based” approaches can shape behavioral ecology
Understanding the responses of organisms to environmental change is critical to tackling the grand challenges of 21st century biology. Fields such as ecophysiology and ecology have embraced these challenges and “re-invented” themselves in part by shifting the scale of scientific enquiry and utilizing large-scale comparative approaches. Behavioural research has not yet realized this potential to the same extent. In this paper, we argue that adopting a trait-based approach at large spatial, temporal and taxonomic scales can advance the field of behavioral ecology and address emerging questions in biology. We surveyed the literature in relevant ecology and behavior journals between 1981 and 2020 and found that ecological journals have changed markedly over time, specifically in their focus on understanding interspecific trait variation at broad taxonomic, spatial and temporal scales. This pattern is not apparent for animal behavior, where intra-specific and often intra-population scale of scientific enquiry has mostly been the focus over the last four decades. We argue that behavioral plasticity can be a critical first response to environmental change that might buffer or even lower the risk of extinction. To estimate the capacity of populations or species to respond to change behaviorally, we propose a comparative approach- spatially, temporally or taxonomically- that systematically captures variation in key traits with broad implications for conservation and community ecology. Further, we provide guidance in the methods and resources required to apply a trait-based approach to animal behavior.
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Behavioral Ecology
- Vol. 36 (4)
Behavior across time and space – how large scale “trait-based” approaches can shape behavioral ecology
Understanding the responses of organisms to environmental change is critical to tackling the grand challenges of 21st century biology. Fields such as ecophysiology and ecology have embraced these challenges and “re-invented” themselves in part by shifting the scale of scientific enquiry and utilizing large-scale comparative approaches. Behavioural research has not yet realized this potential to the same extent. In this paper, we argue that adopting a trait-based approach at large spatial, temporal and taxonomic scales can advance the field of behavioral ecology and address emerging questions in biology. We surveyed the literature in relevant ecology and behavior journals between 1981 and 2020 and found that ecological journals have changed markedly over time, specifically in their focus on understanding interspecific trait variation at broad taxonomic, spatial and temporal scales. This pattern is not apparent for animal behavior, where intra-specific and often intra-population scale of scientific enquiry has mostly been the focus over the last four decades. We argue that behavioral plasticity can be a critical first response to environmental change that might buffer or even lower the risk of extinction. To estimate the capacity of populations or species to respond to change behaviorally, we propose a comparative approach- spatially, temporally or taxonomically- that systematically captures variation in key traits with broad implications for conservation and community ecology. Further, we provide guidance in the methods and resources required to apply a trait-based approach to animal behavior.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Systematic Biology
- Vol. 74 (6) , 967-984
Batesian Mimicry Converges toward Inaccuracy in Myrmecomorphic Spiders
Batesian mimicry is an impressive example of convergent evolution driven by predation. However, the observation that many mimics only superficially resemble their models despite strong selective pressures is an apparent paradox. Here, we tested the “perfecting hypothesis”, that posits that inaccurate mimicry may represent a transitional stage at the macroevolutionary scale by performing the hereto largest phylogenetic analysis (in terms of the number of taxa and genetic data) of ant-mimicking spiders across two speciose but independent clades, the jumping spider tribe Myrmarachnini (Salticidae) and the sac spider subfamily Castianeirinae (Corinnidae). We found that accurate ant mimicry evolved in a gradual process in both clades, by an integration of compound traits contributing to the ant-like habitus with each trait evolving at different speeds. Accurate states were highly unstable at the macroevolutionary scale likely because strong expression of some of these traits comes with high fitness costs. Instead, the inferred global optimum of mimicry expression was at an inaccurate state. This result reverses the onus of explanation from inaccurate mimicry to explaining the exceptional evolution and maintenance of accurate mimicry and highlights that the evolution of Batesian mimicry is ruled by multiple conflicting selective pressures.
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Systematic Biology
- Vol. 74 (6) , 967-984
Open AccessBatesian Mimicry Converges toward Inaccuracy in Myrmecomorphic Spiders
Batesian mimicry is an impressive example of convergent evolution driven by predation. However, the observation that many mimics only superficially resemble their models despite strong selective pressures is an apparent paradox. Here, we tested the “perfecting hypothesis”, that posits that inaccurate mimicry may represent a transitional stage at the macroevolutionary scale by performing the hereto largest phylogenetic analysis (in terms of the number of taxa and genetic data) of ant-mimicking spiders across two speciose but independent clades, the jumping spider tribe Myrmarachnini (Salticidae) and the sac spider subfamily Castianeirinae (Corinnidae). We found that accurate ant mimicry evolved in a gradual process in both clades, by an integration of compound traits contributing to the ant-like habitus with each trait evolving at different speeds. Accurate states were highly unstable at the macroevolutionary scale likely because strong expression of some of these traits comes with high fitness costs. Instead, the inferred global optimum of mimicry expression was at an inaccurate state. This result reverses the onus of explanation from inaccurate mimicry to explaining the exceptional evolution and maintenance of accurate mimicry and highlights that the evolution of Batesian mimicry is ruled by multiple conflicting selective pressures.