Thomas H. Burbine
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Thomas H. Burbine has a total of 56 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Richard C. Greenwood
School of Physical Sciences, The Open University, Milton Keynes, UK
5 shared publications - Andrew S. Rivkin
Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory
3 shared publications - Cristina A. Thomas
Northern Arizona University
3 shared publications - Paul C. Buchanan
Department of Geology Kilgore College Kilgore Texas USA
3 shared publications - Richard P. Binzel
Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences, MIT
3 shared publications - Benoit Carry
Université Côte d’Azur, Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur, CNRS, Laboratoire Lagrange
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in The European Physical Journal Plus
- Vol. 141 (2) , 175
No exotic matter in asteroids
Solar System bodies have similar abundances of non-volatile elements. Asteroids are categorized as unmelted chondritic bodies or as differentiated bodies formed by extensive to global melting of chondritic progenitors. Reflectance spectra show asteroids are compositionally similar to meteorites (which are composed of non-exotic materials—mainly silicates, metallic Fe–Ni, sulfides, oxides, and organic matter). Dense refractory siderophile elements (e.g., Re, Os, Ir, Pt) are present in iron meteorites in total concentrations < 0.05 wt%. The upper limit on the density of an asteroid is ~ 8 g cm −3 for a zero-porosity core fragment composed of ~ 90 wt% Fe and ~ 10 wt% Ni. Carry (Planet Space Sci 73:98–118, 2012) compiled asteroid densities and included some anomalous values (caused by uncertainties in measurement) that he characterized as unrealistic and non-physical. One such value for asteroid (33) Polyhymnia (75.3 ± 9.7 g cm −3 ) was accepted by LaForge et al. (Eur Phys J Plus 138: 812, 2023) who characterized Polyhymnia as a compact ultradense object (CUDO) perhaps composed of stable superheavy elements (SHEs) or alpha matter (alpha particles in a Bose–Einstein condensate). Kiren et al. (Eur Phys J Plus 139: 547, 2024) proposed Polyhymnia could consist of degenerate dark matter. It is exceedingly unlikely that Polyhymnia or other asteroids contain exotic matter: (1) The listed bulk density of Polyhymnia is characterized as “unrealistic.” (2) Meteorites (~ 98.5% are from asteroids) are composed of non-exotic materials. (3) The spectra of “CUDO” asteroids do not differ from other asteroids of their taxonomic class. (4) SHEs and degenerate dark matter have not yet been shown to exist. (5) Alpha matter may occur naturally only in extreme astrophysical environments.
- 17 February 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in The European Physical Journal Plus
- Vol. 141 (2) , 175
Open AccessNo exotic matter in asteroids
Solar System bodies have similar abundances of non-volatile elements. Asteroids are categorized as unmelted chondritic bodies or as differentiated bodies formed by extensive to global melting of chondritic progenitors. Reflectance spectra show asteroids are compositionally similar to meteorites (which are composed of non-exotic materials—mainly silicates, metallic Fe–Ni, sulfides, oxides, and organic matter). Dense refractory siderophile elements (e.g., Re, Os, Ir, Pt) are present in iron meteorites in total concentrations < 0.05 wt%. The upper limit on the density of an asteroid is ~ 8 g cm −3 for a zero-porosity core fragment composed of ~ 90 wt% Fe and ~ 10 wt% Ni. Carry (Planet Space Sci 73:98–118, 2012) compiled asteroid densities and included some anomalous values (caused by uncertainties in measurement) that he characterized as unrealistic and non-physical. One such value for asteroid (33) Polyhymnia (75.3 ± 9.7 g cm −3 ) was accepted by LaForge et al. (Eur Phys J Plus 138: 812, 2023) who characterized Polyhymnia as a compact ultradense object (CUDO) perhaps composed of stable superheavy elements (SHEs) or alpha matter (alpha particles in a Bose–Einstein condensate). Kiren et al. (Eur Phys J Plus 139: 547, 2024) proposed Polyhymnia could consist of degenerate dark matter. It is exceedingly unlikely that Polyhymnia or other asteroids contain exotic matter: (1) The listed bulk density of Polyhymnia is characterized as “unrealistic.” (2) Meteorites (~ 98.5% are from asteroids) are composed of non-exotic materials. (3) The spectra of “CUDO” asteroids do not differ from other asteroids of their taxonomic class. (4) SHEs and degenerate dark matter have not yet been shown to exist. (5) Alpha matter may occur naturally only in extreme astrophysical environments.
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 9 (4) , 487-492
Overview of the findings for samples returned from Ryugu and implications for early Solar System processes
- 11 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Astronomy
- Vol. 9 (4) , 487-492
Overview of the findings for samples returned from Ryugu and implications for early Solar System processes
- Open Access
- 1 September 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 5 (9) , 194
Testing the Bus–DeMeo Asteroid Taxonomy Using Meteorite Spectra
The most widely used method to spectrally classify asteroids is the Bus–DeMeo taxonomy. To test how well the Bus–DeMeo taxonomy groups asteroids on the basis of their mineralogy, we have classified ∼1500 meteorite spectra using this Bus–DeMeo system. Some asteroid classes group together meteorites with similar compositions better than others. Howardite, eucrite, and diogenite spectra tend to be classified as V-types, while ordinary chondrite spectra tend to be classified as S-complex or Q-type bodies. The relatively featureless D- and X-types tend to be dominated by CM carbonaceous chondrites but with a substantial number of matches also with iron meteorites. The large proportion of CM chondrite matches for the D- and X-classes is most likely due to the large number of CM chondrite spectra and the rarity of spectra of more fragile carbonaceous chondrites in our data set. A number of relatively featureless asteroid classes like the C-, B-, L-, and Xc-types group meteorite types together with a wide variety of mineralogies and thermal histories. Visual albedos are vital for distinguishing between many of these assemblages. The Bus–DeMeo taxonomy does have trouble classifying olivine-dominated meteorites that do not have red-sloped spectra because this type of spectrum is rare among asteroids. For many asteroid classes, care must be used when making mineralogical interpretations based solely on spectral type.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 5 (9) , 194
Open AccessTesting the Bus–DeMeo Asteroid Taxonomy Using Meteorite Spectra
The most widely used method to spectrally classify asteroids is the Bus–DeMeo taxonomy. To test how well the Bus–DeMeo taxonomy groups asteroids on the basis of their mineralogy, we have classified ∼1500 meteorite spectra using this Bus–DeMeo system. Some asteroid classes group together meteorites with similar compositions better than others. Howardite, eucrite, and diogenite spectra tend to be classified as V-types, while ordinary chondrite spectra tend to be classified as S-complex or Q-type bodies. The relatively featureless D- and X-types tend to be dominated by CM carbonaceous chondrites but with a substantial number of matches also with iron meteorites. The large proportion of CM chondrite matches for the D- and X-classes is most likely due to the large number of CM chondrite spectra and the rarity of spectra of more fragile carbonaceous chondrites in our data set. A number of relatively featureless asteroid classes like the C-, B-, L-, and Xc-types group meteorite types together with a wide variety of mineralogies and thermal histories. Visual albedos are vital for distinguishing between many of these assemblages. The Bus–DeMeo taxonomy does have trouble classifying olivine-dominated meteorites that do not have red-sloped spectra because this type of spectrum is rare among asteroids. For many asteroid classes, care must be used when making mineralogical interpretations based solely on spectral type.
- Open Access
- 24 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 59 (4) , 878-894
How many Vesta‐like bodies existed in the asteroid belt?
Asteroid 4 Vesta is typically thought to be the parent body of the HED (howardite, eucrite, and diogenite) meteorites due to spectral similarities. The discovery of asteroids far from Vesta with HED‐like spectra like (1459) Magnya and HED‐like meteorites (e.g., NWA 011) with anomalous oxygen isotopic values compared to typical HEDs is evidence that other Vesta‐like bodies formed. We broadly define a Vesta‐like body as a differentiated object with a crust composed primarily of low‐Ca pyroxene and plagioclase feldspar. We estimate the number of Vesta‐like bodies that did form by looking at the astronomical evidence; the oxygen isotopic, chemical, and petrologic evidence; and the iron meteorite evidence. Assuming that fragments of Vesta were scattered from Vesta by giant planet migration, we conservatively estimate that at least two Vesta‐like bodies (Vesta and the Magnya parent bodies) existed. From the oxygen isotopic, chemical, and petrologic evidence, we also conservatively estimate that seven Vesta‐like bodies formed. Analyses of iron meteorites indicate that there may be as many as 23 Vesta‐like bodies (Vesta, 10 magmatic iron groups, South Byron trio, Emsland/Mbosi duo, 10 ungrouped irons). This estimate from iron meteorites is most certainly an overestimation due to the existence of a number of non‐HED crustal/mantle fragments that potentially originated from bodies with magmatic iron cores. Using our three estimates as a guide, we predict that there were ~10 Vesta‐like bodies (including Vesta) that formed in the early solar system. Only Vesta remains intact with the others being disrupted early in solar system history.
- 24 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 59 (4) , 878-894
Open AccessHow many Vesta‐like bodies existed in the asteroid belt?
Asteroid 4 Vesta is typically thought to be the parent body of the HED (howardite, eucrite, and diogenite) meteorites due to spectral similarities. The discovery of asteroids far from Vesta with HED‐like spectra like (1459) Magnya and HED‐like meteorites (e.g., NWA 011) with anomalous oxygen isotopic values compared to typical HEDs is evidence that other Vesta‐like bodies formed. We broadly define a Vesta‐like body as a differentiated object with a crust composed primarily of low‐Ca pyroxene and plagioclase feldspar. We estimate the number of Vesta‐like bodies that did form by looking at the astronomical evidence; the oxygen isotopic, chemical, and petrologic evidence; and the iron meteorite evidence. Assuming that fragments of Vesta were scattered from Vesta by giant planet migration, we conservatively estimate that at least two Vesta‐like bodies (Vesta and the Magnya parent bodies) existed. From the oxygen isotopic, chemical, and petrologic evidence, we also conservatively estimate that seven Vesta‐like bodies formed. Analyses of iron meteorites indicate that there may be as many as 23 Vesta‐like bodies (Vesta, 10 magmatic iron groups, South Byron trio, Emsland/Mbosi duo, 10 ungrouped irons). This estimate from iron meteorites is most certainly an overestimation due to the existence of a number of non‐HED crustal/mantle fragments that potentially originated from bodies with magmatic iron cores. Using our three estimates as a guide, we predict that there were ~10 Vesta‐like bodies (including Vesta) that formed in the early solar system. Only Vesta remains intact with the others being disrupted early in solar system history.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 4 (5) , 96
Determining the Pyroxene Mineralogies of Vestoids
Bulk pyroxene compositions were calculated for a number of V-type asteroid spectra using formulae derived by Burbine et al. These formulae were derived by analyzing HED (howardite, eucrite, and diogenite) meteorites and calculate bulk Fs (mol%) and Wo (mol%) contents using derived band centers. Using HEDs with known bulk pyroxene compositions, the uncertainty in the predicted Fs contents was determined to be ±3 mol%, and the uncertainty in the predicted Wo contents was ±2 mol%. V-type asteroids tend to have interpreted pyroxene mineralogies consistent primarily with eucrites and howardites. We investigate why diogenitic mineralogies appear so rare among ∼5–10 km V-type asteroids but are much more commonly present among HED meteorites. One possibility is that diogenitic intrusions are extremely “thin” but widespread in Vesta’s eucritic crust. In this scenario, Vestoids (V-type asteroids thought to be derived from Vesta) would be expected to be solid fragments of Vesta. Another possibility is that Vesta’s upper crust has been significantly shattered and diogenitic material would be much less common than the eucritic material in the crust. Vestoids would then be expected to be rubble piles. The belief that most asteroid families were shattered at least twice would argue that Vesta’s crust is also shattered and that Vestoids are rubble piles.
- 1 May 2023
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 4 (5) , 96
Open AccessDetermining the Pyroxene Mineralogies of Vestoids
Bulk pyroxene compositions were calculated for a number of V-type asteroid spectra using formulae derived by Burbine et al. These formulae were derived by analyzing HED (howardite, eucrite, and diogenite) meteorites and calculate bulk Fs (mol%) and Wo (mol%) contents using derived band centers. Using HEDs with known bulk pyroxene compositions, the uncertainty in the predicted Fs contents was determined to be ±3 mol%, and the uncertainty in the predicted Wo contents was ±2 mol%. V-type asteroids tend to have interpreted pyroxene mineralogies consistent primarily with eucrites and howardites. We investigate why diogenitic mineralogies appear so rare among ∼5–10 km V-type asteroids but are much more commonly present among HED meteorites. One possibility is that diogenitic intrusions are extremely “thin” but widespread in Vesta’s eucritic crust. In this scenario, Vestoids (V-type asteroids thought to be derived from Vesta) would be expected to be solid fragments of Vesta. Another possibility is that Vesta’s upper crust has been significantly shattered and diogenitic material would be much less common than the eucritic material in the crust. Vestoids would then be expected to be rubble piles. The belief that most asteroid families were shattered at least twice would argue that Vesta’s crust is also shattered and that Vestoids are rubble piles.
- Open Access
- 18 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Space Science Reviews
- Vol. 216 (4) , 1-27
Exploring the Bimodal Solar System via Sample Return from the Main Asteroid Belt: The Case for Revisiting Ceres
Sample return from a main-belt asteroid has not yet been attempted, but appears technologically feasible. While the cost implications are significant, the scientific case for such a mission appears overwhelming. As suggested by the “Grand Tack” model, the structure of the main belt was likely forged during the earliest stages of Solar System evolution in response to migration of the giant planets. Returning samples from the main belt has the potential to test such planet migration models and the related geochemical and isotopic concept of a bimodal Solar System.Isotopic studies demonstrate distinct compositional differences between samples believed to be derived from the outer Solar System (CC or carbonaceous chondrite group) and those that are thought to be derived from the inner Solar System (NC or non-carbonaceous group). These two groups are separated on relevant isotopic variation diagrams by a clear compositional gap. The interface between these two regions appears to be broadly coincident with the present location of the asteroid belt, which contains material derived from both groups.The Hayabusa mission to near-Earth asteroid (NEA) (25143) Itokawa has shown what can be learned from a sample-return mission to an asteroid, even with a very small amount of sample. One scenario for main-belt sample return involves a spacecraft launching a projectile that strikes an object and flying through the debris cloud, which would potentially allow multiple bodies to be sampled if a number of projectiles are used on different asteroids. Another scenario is the more traditional method of landing on an asteroid to obtain the sample.A significant range of main-belt asteroids are available as targets for a sample-return mission and such a mission would represent a first step in mineralogically and isotopically mapping the asteroid belt. We argue that a sample-return mission to the asteroid belt does not necessarily have to return material from both the NC and CC groups to viably test the bimodal Solar System paradigm, as material from the NC group is already abundantly available for study. Instead, there is overwhelming evidence that we have a very incomplete suite of CC-related samples.Based on our analysis, we advocate a dedicated sample-return mission to the dwarf planet (1) Ceres as the best means of further exploring inherent Solar System variation. Ceres is an ice-rich world that may be a displaced trans-Neptunian object. We almost certainly do not have any meteorites that closely resemble material that would be brought back from Ceres. The rich heritage of data acquired by the Dawn mission makes a sample-return mission from Ceres logistically feasible at a realistic cost. No other potential main-belt target is capable of providing as much insight into the early Solar System as Ceres. Such a mission should be given the highest priority by the international scientific community.
- 18 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Space Science Reviews
- Vol. 216 (4) , 1-27
Open AccessExploring the Bimodal Solar System via Sample Return from the Main Asteroid Belt: The Case for Revisiting Ceres
Sample return from a main-belt asteroid has not yet been attempted, but appears technologically feasible. While the cost implications are significant, the scientific case for such a mission appears overwhelming. As suggested by the “Grand Tack” model, the structure of the main belt was likely forged during the earliest stages of Solar System evolution in response to migration of the giant planets. Returning samples from the main belt has the potential to test such planet migration models and the related geochemical and isotopic concept of a bimodal Solar System.Isotopic studies demonstrate distinct compositional differences between samples believed to be derived from the outer Solar System (CC or carbonaceous chondrite group) and those that are thought to be derived from the inner Solar System (NC or non-carbonaceous group). These two groups are separated on relevant isotopic variation diagrams by a clear compositional gap. The interface between these two regions appears to be broadly coincident with the present location of the asteroid belt, which contains material derived from both groups.The Hayabusa mission to near-Earth asteroid (NEA) (25143) Itokawa has shown what can be learned from a sample-return mission to an asteroid, even with a very small amount of sample. One scenario for main-belt sample return involves a spacecraft launching a projectile that strikes an object and flying through the debris cloud, which would potentially allow multiple bodies to be sampled if a number of projectiles are used on different asteroids. Another scenario is the more traditional method of landing on an asteroid to obtain the sample.A significant range of main-belt asteroids are available as targets for a sample-return mission and such a mission would represent a first step in mineralogically and isotopically mapping the asteroid belt. We argue that a sample-return mission to the asteroid belt does not necessarily have to return material from both the NC and CC groups to viably test the bimodal Solar System paradigm, as material from the NC group is already abundantly available for study. Instead, there is overwhelming evidence that we have a very incomplete suite of CC-related samples.Based on our analysis, we advocate a dedicated sample-return mission to the dwarf planet (1) Ceres as the best means of further exploring inherent Solar System variation. Ceres is an ice-rich world that may be a displaced trans-Neptunian object. We almost certainly do not have any meteorites that closely resemble material that would be brought back from Ceres. The rich heritage of data acquired by the Dawn mission makes a sample-return mission from Ceres logistically feasible at a realistic cost. No other potential main-belt target is capable of providing as much insight into the early Solar System as Ceres. Such a mission should be given the highest priority by the international scientific community.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
- Vol. 277, 377-406
Linking asteroids and meteorites to the primordial planetesimal population
- 1 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
- Vol. 277, 377-406
Open AccessLinking asteroids and meteorites to the primordial planetesimal population
- 1 April 2020
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 247 (2) , 73
Twenty Years of SpeX: Accuracy Limits of Spectral Slope Measurements in Asteroid Spectroscopy
We examined two decades of SpeX/NASA Infrared Telescope Facility observations from the Small Main-Belt Asteroid Spectroscopic Survey (SMASS) and the MIT–Hawaii Near-Earth Object Spectroscopic Survey (MITHNEOS) to investigate uncertainties and systematic errors in reflectance spectral slope measurements of asteroids. From 628 spectra of 11 solar analogs used for calibration of the asteroid spectra, we derived an uncertainty of on slope measurements over 0.8–2.4 μm. Air mass contributes to −0.92% μm−1 per 0.1 unit air mass difference between the asteroid and the solar analog and therefore for an overall 2.8% μm−1 slope variability in SMASS and MITHNEOS designed to operate within 1.0–1.3 air mass. No additional observing conditions (including the parallactic angle, seeing, and humidity) were found to contribute systematically to slope change. We discuss implications for asteroid taxonomic classification works. Uncertainties provided in this study should be accounted for in future compositional investigation of small bodies to distinguish intrinsic heterogeneities from possible instrumental effects.
- 1 April 2020
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 247 (2) , 73
Twenty Years of SpeX: Accuracy Limits of Spectral Slope Measurements in Asteroid Spectroscopy
We examined two decades of SpeX/NASA Infrared Telescope Facility observations from the Small Main-Belt Asteroid Spectroscopic Survey (SMASS) and the MIT–Hawaii Near-Earth Object Spectroscopic Survey (MITHNEOS) to investigate uncertainties and systematic errors in reflectance spectral slope measurements of asteroids. From 628 spectra of 11 solar analogs used for calibration of the asteroid spectra, we derived an uncertainty of on slope measurements over 0.8–2.4 μm. Air mass contributes to −0.92% μm−1 per 0.1 unit air mass difference between the asteroid and the solar analog and therefore for an overall 2.8% μm−1 slope variability in SMASS and MITHNEOS designed to operate within 1.0–1.3 air mass. No additional observing conditions (including the parallactic angle, seeing, and humidity) were found to contribute systematically to slope change. We discuss implications for asteroid taxonomic classification works. Uncertainties provided in this study should be accounted for in future compositional investigation of small bodies to distinguish intrinsic heterogeneities from possible instrumental effects.