Philip Kinghorn
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Philip Kinghorn has a total of 109 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Joanna Coast
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
16 shared publications - Cara Bailey
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Health Sciences, College of Medicine and Health, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
6 shared publications Cara Bailey
School of Nursing, Institute of Clinical Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
5 shared publications- Tracy Elizabeth Roberts
Institute for Applied Health Research, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
5 shared publications - Alastair Canaway
Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
4 shared publications - Denise Tanner
Department of Social Work and Social Care, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 July 2026
- Published by LSE Press in Journal of Long-Term Care
- p. 240-255
An Exploration of the Costs of Residential Care Home Closures: A Mixed Method Approach
Context: Between 2015 and 2020, 1,578 care homes in England closed, affecting 48,600 individuals. The financial and economic impact of such closures on various stakeholders remains largely unquantified. Objective: To develop pathways for care home closures from key stakeholders’ perspectives, quantify associated costs, and explore the economic implications to key stakeholders. Methods: A mixed-methods approach was adopted across three stages: qualitative analysis of stakeholder interviews, development of care home closure pathways, and cost analysis, including sensitivity analyses. Findings: The public sector cost for a single care home closure over 12 months was estimated at £30,550 (2021/22 prices) or £34,185 (2023/24 prices). Sensitivity analyses showed costs could range from £4,400 to £66,490 (£4,924 to £74,398 in 2023/24 prices). Qualitative findings indicated various financial implications for residents, families, and care staff, including top-up fees and increased travel costs. Limitations: The study relied on assumptions and proxy costs due to limited data availability, potentially increasing uncertainty in cost estimates. Whilst methods are transferable, findings relate specifically to England. Implications: The findings highlight the need for careful planning and resource allocation in managing care home closures. Future research should explore the association between costs and outcomes through economic evaluation to inform cost-effective strategies for addressing care home closures.
- 23 July 2026
- Published by LSE Press in Journal of Long-Term Care
- p. 240-255
Open AccessAn Exploration of the Costs of Residential Care Home Closures: A Mixed Method Approach
Context: Between 2015 and 2020, 1,578 care homes in England closed, affecting 48,600 individuals. The financial and economic impact of such closures on various stakeholders remains largely unquantified. Objective: To develop pathways for care home closures from key stakeholders’ perspectives, quantify associated costs, and explore the economic implications to key stakeholders. Methods: A mixed-methods approach was adopted across three stages: qualitative analysis of stakeholder interviews, development of care home closure pathways, and cost analysis, including sensitivity analyses. Findings: The public sector cost for a single care home closure over 12 months was estimated at £30,550 (2021/22 prices) or £34,185 (2023/24 prices). Sensitivity analyses showed costs could range from £4,400 to £66,490 (£4,924 to £74,398 in 2023/24 prices). Qualitative findings indicated various financial implications for residents, families, and care staff, including top-up fees and increased travel costs. Limitations: The study relied on assumptions and proxy costs due to limited data availability, potentially increasing uncertainty in cost estimates. Whilst methods are transferable, findings relate specifically to England. Implications: The findings highlight the need for careful planning and resource allocation in managing care home closures. Future research should explore the association between costs and outcomes through economic evaluation to inform cost-effective strategies for addressing care home closures.
- Open Access
- 18 May 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Aging
- Vol. 9, e87577
Supervised and Self-Directed Technology-Based Dual-Task Exercise Training Program for Older Adults With a History of Falls: Mixed Methods Feasibility Study
Background: Older adults who have fallen are at an increased risk of future falls. Training cognitive and physical functions simultaneously, known as dual-task (DT) training, has been shown to improve mobility and reduce fall risks. With appropriate digital tools, such as smartphones and mobile apps, it is possible to deliver DT training in unsupervised, home-based settings, thereby increasing accessibility beyond the clinical environment. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of a technology-based DT training program delivered through a blended model of supervised and self-directed sessions for older adults with a history of falls. Perspectives of health care professionals working in fall-prevention services were also explored. Methods: A single-arm, nonrandomized feasibility study was conducted with 45 community-dwelling adults aged 65 years or older with a history of falls. Participants were recruited through primary care practices, secondary care fall-prevention services, and community outreach. The 24-week DT program, which integrated balance and strength exercises with cognitive training using a mobile app, was delivered in two phases: (1) for12 weeks, weekly 50-minute physiotherapist-led group classes in the community, and 2 additional 50-minute self-directed sessions at home, and (2) for 12 weeks, 3 weekly 50-minute self-directed sessions at home. Feasibility and acceptability were assessed through recruitment and retention rates, adherence, app usage, and self-reported satisfaction. Qualitative data were obtained from focus groups with 28 participants who completed the program and 16 health care professionals. Quantitative data were analyzed descriptively, and qualitative data were analyzed thematically. Results: We recruited 45 of the target 50 participants, with most participants (n=41) recruited through community pathways; 4 were recruited via National Health Service (NHS) pathways. Adherence was 64%, with higher adherence during phase 1 (81%) than phase 2 (50%). App usage was high (95%), and self-reported program satisfaction was moderate to high. Retention at 24 weeks was 76%, and no adverse events occurred. The qualitative findings supported the program’s feasibility and acceptability, emphasizing social connection and tailored exercises as key to adherence—especially in home-based sessions. Health care professionals identified community organizations and referral pathways as the most practical routes for implementation. Conclusions: A blended, technology-based DT training program is both feasible and acceptable for older adults at risk of falling and can be effectively delivered beyond clinical settings. Community-based recruitment outperformed NHS pathways, highlighting the value of community engagement. These findings support the feasibility and acceptability of a full-scale trial, with targeted refinements to recruitment, support structures, and delivery to maximize scalability and impact.
- 18 May 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Aging
- Vol. 9, e87577
Open AccessSupervised and Self-Directed Technology-Based Dual-Task Exercise Training Program for Older Adults With a History of Falls: Mixed Methods Feasibility Study
Background: Older adults who have fallen are at an increased risk of future falls. Training cognitive and physical functions simultaneously, known as dual-task (DT) training, has been shown to improve mobility and reduce fall risks. With appropriate digital tools, such as smartphones and mobile apps, it is possible to deliver DT training in unsupervised, home-based settings, thereby increasing accessibility beyond the clinical environment. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of a technology-based DT training program delivered through a blended model of supervised and self-directed sessions for older adults with a history of falls. Perspectives of health care professionals working in fall-prevention services were also explored. Methods: A single-arm, nonrandomized feasibility study was conducted with 45 community-dwelling adults aged 65 years or older with a history of falls. Participants were recruited through primary care practices, secondary care fall-prevention services, and community outreach. The 24-week DT program, which integrated balance and strength exercises with cognitive training using a mobile app, was delivered in two phases: (1) for12 weeks, weekly 50-minute physiotherapist-led group classes in the community, and 2 additional 50-minute self-directed sessions at home, and (2) for 12 weeks, 3 weekly 50-minute self-directed sessions at home. Feasibility and acceptability were assessed through recruitment and retention rates, adherence, app usage, and self-reported satisfaction. Qualitative data were obtained from focus groups with 28 participants who completed the program and 16 health care professionals. Quantitative data were analyzed descriptively, and qualitative data were analyzed thematically. Results: We recruited 45 of the target 50 participants, with most participants (n=41) recruited through community pathways; 4 were recruited via National Health Service (NHS) pathways. Adherence was 64%, with higher adherence during phase 1 (81%) than phase 2 (50%). App usage was high (95%), and self-reported program satisfaction was moderate to high. Retention at 24 weeks was 76%, and no adverse events occurred. The qualitative findings supported the program’s feasibility and acceptability, emphasizing social connection and tailored exercises as key to adherence—especially in home-based sessions. Health care professionals identified community organizations and referral pathways as the most practical routes for implementation. Conclusions: A blended, technology-based DT training program is both feasible and acceptable for older adults at risk of falling and can be effectively delivered beyond clinical settings. Community-based recruitment outperformed NHS pathways, highlighting the value of community engagement. These findings support the feasibility and acceptability of a full-scale trial, with targeted refinements to recruitment, support structures, and delivery to maximize scalability and impact.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Programme Grants for Applied Research
- p. 1-38
Improving outcomes when care homes close: NIHR Programme Grant multi-methods study
Background: When care homes close, it can be detrimental to older people’s well-being. However, there is little formal evidence to guide services when undertaking such important work. Objectives: This study explores what happens when homes close, how best to minimise negative outcomes for older people and families, and key lessons for councils as they manage future closures. Methods: Background literature review, national survey of Director(s) of Adult Social Services and analysis of national Care Quality Commission data. Interviews with older people, families, care staff, social workers and broader managers/partners in four case study sites, together with outcomes data (EQ-5D, ICEpop CAPability measure for Older people and outcomes from the literature on what older people value about care services) at initial assessment, 28 days’ review and 1 year. Survey of care staff (Professional Quality of Life survey) before and after closures, supplemented with individual interviews; interviews with commissioners and service providers. Preliminary model-based economic evaluation comparing the costs and consequences of care home closures. Distillation of key messages into a national policy guide, an accessible guide for older people/families and a guide/free training video for care staff. Findings: People assume that a care home is a home for life – but this is sadly not always the case. Care homes can close for all kinds of reasons (e.g. to do with funding, buildings, care quality, etc., but also due to broader factors beyond the control of the care sector). There can be significant differences between emergency closures (which can be especially traumatic) and more planned closures (when at least in principle there is more time to work at the pace of individual residents). Local policies vary significantly, and there may be scope for a more evidence-informed, consistent approach. Closures can be extremely difficult for everyone involved – and should perhaps only ever be a last resort. Closures are particularly traumatic for residents, who are losing their home and valued relationships. For some people, this may be similar to a bereavement. The needs of care staff – in terms of meaningful information, emotional and financial well-being and employment support – are often overlooked. This leaves people unsupported and might also reduce their ability to support others. Councils seeking to shape local care markets often lack the levers to be able to do this effectively. Care home closures can create financial pressures on the public sector, costing around £1500 per resident, while families and staff may face varying expenses, such as top-up fees and travel costs. Unplanned and emergency closures are slightly more expensive, and result in poorer outcomes for residents. We have limited long-term data, but it may sometimes be possible to manage closures in a way that minimises negative outcomes for some (especially if existing services were less than optimal and where closures are well planned). Limitations: Collecting data from older people, families and staff during care home closures, and in a challenging policy context, is complex, and the amount of data it is possible to collect in such circumstances is inevitably limited in a number of ways. In reflecting on this, we nonetheless draw attention to: The novel nature of the research, filling key gaps in knowledge around such a significant topic. The diverse and multifaceted perspectives which only a programme of research could hope to include. The importance of our policy and practice materials, given the significance of the issues at stake and the lack of previous evidence on which to draw. Conclusions: Care home closures can happen for many different reasons, and are always a logical possibility in a ‘care market’, which seeks to use choice and competition to keep costs down and promote quality. This study has identified a series of practical lessons and experiences shared by participants which might help others in future – made available to different audiences via a series of policy, practice and training materials. However, none of this should, in any way, minimise the distress experienced by residents, which can be very significant and may well be long lasting. Moving beyond the specific focus of this research, insights from interviews with local commissioners and providers may have broader implications for the extent to which local authorities have sufficient powers and practical tools to be able to deliver on their ‘market shaping’ responsibilities under the Care Act. Future research on care home closures could usefully focus on: The needs/experiences of people who may have additional or specific needs that might otherwise be overlooked, such as people living with dementia and people from minority ethnic communities or different faith groups. The knock-on effect that care home closures may have on partner agencies. More effective ways of managing emergency closures, and how best to support people after the closure with the trauma they may have experienced. Larger sample sizes might also generate additional insights around individual outcomes and around the implications of particular resident/staff characteristics or types of closure – but this may need to be balanced against the difficulty of conducting such research and the cost to funders of even larger studies. Study registration: This study is registered as IRAS project ID: 297258. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research Programme (NIHR award ref: NIHR201585) and is published in full in Programme Grants for Applied Research ; Vol. 14, No. 2. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Programme Grants for Applied Research
- p. 1-38
Open AccessImproving outcomes when care homes close: NIHR Programme Grant multi-methods study
Background: When care homes close, it can be detrimental to older people’s well-being. However, there is little formal evidence to guide services when undertaking such important work. Objectives: This study explores what happens when homes close, how best to minimise negative outcomes for older people and families, and key lessons for councils as they manage future closures. Methods: Background literature review, national survey of Director(s) of Adult Social Services and analysis of national Care Quality Commission data. Interviews with older people, families, care staff, social workers and broader managers/partners in four case study sites, together with outcomes data (EQ-5D, ICEpop CAPability measure for Older people and outcomes from the literature on what older people value about care services) at initial assessment, 28 days’ review and 1 year. Survey of care staff (Professional Quality of Life survey) before and after closures, supplemented with individual interviews; interviews with commissioners and service providers. Preliminary model-based economic evaluation comparing the costs and consequences of care home closures. Distillation of key messages into a national policy guide, an accessible guide for older people/families and a guide/free training video for care staff. Findings: People assume that a care home is a home for life – but this is sadly not always the case. Care homes can close for all kinds of reasons (e.g. to do with funding, buildings, care quality, etc., but also due to broader factors beyond the control of the care sector). There can be significant differences between emergency closures (which can be especially traumatic) and more planned closures (when at least in principle there is more time to work at the pace of individual residents). Local policies vary significantly, and there may be scope for a more evidence-informed, consistent approach. Closures can be extremely difficult for everyone involved – and should perhaps only ever be a last resort. Closures are particularly traumatic for residents, who are losing their home and valued relationships. For some people, this may be similar to a bereavement. The needs of care staff – in terms of meaningful information, emotional and financial well-being and employment support – are often overlooked. This leaves people unsupported and might also reduce their ability to support others. Councils seeking to shape local care markets often lack the levers to be able to do this effectively. Care home closures can create financial pressures on the public sector, costing around £1500 per resident, while families and staff may face varying expenses, such as top-up fees and travel costs. Unplanned and emergency closures are slightly more expensive, and result in poorer outcomes for residents. We have limited long-term data, but it may sometimes be possible to manage closures in a way that minimises negative outcomes for some (especially if existing services were less than optimal and where closures are well planned). Limitations: Collecting data from older people, families and staff during care home closures, and in a challenging policy context, is complex, and the amount of data it is possible to collect in such circumstances is inevitably limited in a number of ways. In reflecting on this, we nonetheless draw attention to: The novel nature of the research, filling key gaps in knowledge around such a significant topic. The diverse and multifaceted perspectives which only a programme of research could hope to include. The importance of our policy and practice materials, given the significance of the issues at stake and the lack of previous evidence on which to draw. Conclusions: Care home closures can happen for many different reasons, and are always a logical possibility in a ‘care market’, which seeks to use choice and competition to keep costs down and promote quality. This study has identified a series of practical lessons and experiences shared by participants which might help others in future – made available to different audiences via a series of policy, practice and training materials. However, none of this should, in any way, minimise the distress experienced by residents, which can be very significant and may well be long lasting. Moving beyond the specific focus of this research, insights from interviews with local commissioners and providers may have broader implications for the extent to which local authorities have sufficient powers and practical tools to be able to deliver on their ‘market shaping’ responsibilities under the Care Act. Future research on care home closures could usefully focus on: The needs/experiences of people who may have additional or specific needs that might otherwise be overlooked, such as people living with dementia and people from minority ethnic communities or different faith groups. The knock-on effect that care home closures may have on partner agencies. More effective ways of managing emergency closures, and how best to support people after the closure with the trauma they may have experienced. Larger sample sizes might also generate additional insights around individual outcomes and around the implications of particular resident/staff characteristics or types of closure – but this may need to be balanced against the difficulty of conducting such research and the cost to funders of even larger studies. Study registration: This study is registered as IRAS project ID: 297258. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research Programme (NIHR award ref: NIHR201585) and is published in full in Programme Grants for Applied Research ; Vol. 14, No. 2. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0326829
An exploration of the costs of family and group conferencing pathways in adult social care and mental health: A scenario-based cost analysis
Context: Family and Group Conferencing (FGC) is a strengths-based approach to social work, originating from New Zealand and now used internationally. Previous research on FGC has focused largely on the context of children’s services but, FGC also aligns with the principle of the Care Act in England to prevent, reduce or delay the need for long-term (and potentially costly) adult care services. Limited previous research has tended to explore potential cost savings associated with FGC, without accounting for the cost of the intervention itself, risking biased results. Objective: This paper aims to identify resource use and associated monetary costs associated with FGC services in English adult social care and mental health settings. Methods: Framework development was informed by previously published work establishing programme theory for FGC, extended by expert opinion and published sources of monetary costs. The framework used scenario-based analysis and a bottom-up costing approach, with sensitivity analysis. Results: Estimated costs of conducting a standard full FGC (excluding referral) range from £1,455 to £2,043 (adjusted from 2022–2023–2025 prices) from a local authority and National Health Service (NHS) perspective. Costs can vary depending on the involvement of an advocate or interpreter, network size and the complexity of issues being addressed. We report overall costs with and without resource use specifically related to referral. Discussion: Higher staff costs account for slightly higher intervention costs in an NHS mental health setting, compared to adult social care settings. Conclusion: Reallocating scarce public resources with the intention of preventing, reducing or delaying use of costly future care must be evidence-based as pressures build to meet acute needs. Accurate per-case costing of FGC is a necessary preliminary step towards exploring the cost-effectiveness of FGC. A full economic evaluation will account for costs, outcomes, and alternative options (uses of limited resources).
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0326829
Open AccessAn exploration of the costs of family and group conferencing pathways in adult social care and mental health: A scenario-based cost analysis
Context: Family and Group Conferencing (FGC) is a strengths-based approach to social work, originating from New Zealand and now used internationally. Previous research on FGC has focused largely on the context of children’s services but, FGC also aligns with the principle of the Care Act in England to prevent, reduce or delay the need for long-term (and potentially costly) adult care services. Limited previous research has tended to explore potential cost savings associated with FGC, without accounting for the cost of the intervention itself, risking biased results. Objective: This paper aims to identify resource use and associated monetary costs associated with FGC services in English adult social care and mental health settings. Methods: Framework development was informed by previously published work establishing programme theory for FGC, extended by expert opinion and published sources of monetary costs. The framework used scenario-based analysis and a bottom-up costing approach, with sensitivity analysis. Results: Estimated costs of conducting a standard full FGC (excluding referral) range from £1,455 to £2,043 (adjusted from 2022–2023–2025 prices) from a local authority and National Health Service (NHS) perspective. Costs can vary depending on the involvement of an advocate or interpreter, network size and the complexity of issues being addressed. We report overall costs with and without resource use specifically related to referral. Discussion: Higher staff costs account for slightly higher intervention costs in an NHS mental health setting, compared to adult social care settings. Conclusion: Reallocating scarce public resources with the intention of preventing, reducing or delaying use of costly future care must be evidence-based as pressures build to meet acute needs. Accurate per-case costing of FGC is a necessary preliminary step towards exploring the cost-effectiveness of FGC. A full economic evaluation will account for costs, outcomes, and alternative options (uses of limited resources).
- Open Access
- 17 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Social Policy & Administration
- Vol. 60 (4) , 640-650
Continued Policy Drift on the Funding of Adult Social Care in England: What Can Be Learned From the Shelving of Proposed Charging Reforms?
In 2021 the UK Government announced charging reforms relating to adult social care in England. The reforms would have ended a prolonged period of policy drift but were postponed in 2022 and cancelled in 2024. This paper reports on how different stakeholder groups perceived the reforms (and their delay), how they had been preparing for the implementation of the reforms, and identifies lessons for the future. Semi‐structured interviews were conducted with care providers, those giving independent advice to the public, and those working in (and representing) local authorities. We identified no objection to the pillars underpinning charging reforms, although the implementation of the reforms would have been challenging, given the proposed timescale and workforce capacity in local authorities. Understanding of the reforms by the public and across some groups in the social care sector was generally poor. There was fear that elements of the planned reforms would simply have been unaffordable and that the implementation of fair cost of care in particular would be damaging for care providers. As one loser from prolonged policy drift and austerity, local authorities appear to have been backed into a position of being veto‐players, due to their fears that funding from central government would be insufficient to implement and sustain the charging reforms, leaving them with crippling financial exposure. There has been no apparent benefit from preparatory work completed prior to the halting of the charging reforms. Deep‐rooted cynicism and strained relations between stakeholder groups are likely to make implementation of any future reforms more challenging.
- 17 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Social Policy & Administration
- Vol. 60 (4) , 640-650
Open AccessContinued Policy Drift on the Funding of Adult Social Care in England: What Can Be Learned From the Shelving of Proposed Charging Reforms?
In 2021 the UK Government announced charging reforms relating to adult social care in England. The reforms would have ended a prolonged period of policy drift but were postponed in 2022 and cancelled in 2024. This paper reports on how different stakeholder groups perceived the reforms (and their delay), how they had been preparing for the implementation of the reforms, and identifies lessons for the future. Semi‐structured interviews were conducted with care providers, those giving independent advice to the public, and those working in (and representing) local authorities. We identified no objection to the pillars underpinning charging reforms, although the implementation of the reforms would have been challenging, given the proposed timescale and workforce capacity in local authorities. Understanding of the reforms by the public and across some groups in the social care sector was generally poor. There was fear that elements of the planned reforms would simply have been unaffordable and that the implementation of fair cost of care in particular would be damaging for care providers. As one loser from prolonged policy drift and austerity, local authorities appear to have been backed into a position of being veto‐players, due to their fears that funding from central government would be insufficient to implement and sustain the charging reforms, leaving them with crippling financial exposure. There has been no apparent benefit from preparatory work completed prior to the halting of the charging reforms. Deep‐rooted cynicism and strained relations between stakeholder groups are likely to make implementation of any future reforms more challenging.
- Open Access
An Exploration of the Costs of Family and Group Conferencing Pathways in Adult Social Care and Mental Health: A Mixed Methods Approach
Context Family and Group Conferencing (FGC) is a strengths-based approach to social work, originating from New Zealand and now used internationally. Previous research on FGC has focused largely on the context of children’s services but, FGC also aligns with the principle of the Care Act in England to prevent, reduce or delay the need for long-term (and potentially costly) adult care services. Limited previous research has tended to explore potential cost savings associated with FGC, without accounting for the cost of the intervention itself, risking biased results. Objective This paper aims to identify resource use and associated monetary costs associated with FGC services in English adult social care and mental health settings. Methods Framework development was informed by previously published work establishing programme theory for FGC, extended by expert opinion and published sources of monetary costs. The framework used scenario-based analysis and a bottom-up costing approach, with sensitivity analysis. Results Estimated costs of conducting a standard full FGC (excluding referral) range from £1,455 to £2,043 (adjusted from 2022-2023 to 2025 prices) from a local authority and National Health Service (NHS) perspective. Costs can vary depending on the involvement of an advocate or interpreter, network size and the complexity of issues being addressed. Discussion Higher staff costs in the UK account for slightly higher intervention costs in an NHS mental health than in an adult social care context. Conclusion Reallocating scarce public resources with the intention of preventing, reducing or delaying use of costly future care must be evidence-based as pressures build to meet acute needs. Accurate per-case costing of FGC is a necessary preliminary step towards exploring the cost-effectiveness of FGC. A full economic evaluation will account for costs, outcomes, and alternative options (uses of limited resources). Ethics Statement Using the UK Health Research Authority (HRA) screening tool, it was determined that the wider research project did not constitute research for which HRA approval was necessary, and therefore ethical approval (for the wider research project) was obtained from the University of Birmingham Humanities and Social Sciences Ethical Review Committee (ERN_22-0818). Research reported in this paper did not involve any human participants, or the processing or analysis of any human/personal data. Our research was informed by published sources (including grey literature) and expert opinion from practitioners partnering with us to deliver the research.
Open AccessAn Exploration of the Costs of Family and Group Conferencing Pathways in Adult Social Care and Mental Health: A Mixed Methods Approach
Context Family and Group Conferencing (FGC) is a strengths-based approach to social work, originating from New Zealand and now used internationally. Previous research on FGC has focused largely on the context of children’s services but, FGC also aligns with the principle of the Care Act in England to prevent, reduce or delay the need for long-term (and potentially costly) adult care services. Limited previous research has tended to explore potential cost savings associated with FGC, without accounting for the cost of the intervention itself, risking biased results. Objective This paper aims to identify resource use and associated monetary costs associated with FGC services in English adult social care and mental health settings. Methods Framework development was informed by previously published work establishing programme theory for FGC, extended by expert opinion and published sources of monetary costs. The framework used scenario-based analysis and a bottom-up costing approach, with sensitivity analysis. Results Estimated costs of conducting a standard full FGC (excluding referral) range from £1,455 to £2,043 (adjusted from 2022-2023 to 2025 prices) from a local authority and National Health Service (NHS) perspective. Costs can vary depending on the involvement of an advocate or interpreter, network size and the complexity of issues being addressed. Discussion Higher staff costs in the UK account for slightly higher intervention costs in an NHS mental health than in an adult social care context. Conclusion Reallocating scarce public resources with the intention of preventing, reducing or delaying use of costly future care must be evidence-based as pressures build to meet acute needs. Accurate per-case costing of FGC is a necessary preliminary step towards exploring the cost-effectiveness of FGC. A full economic evaluation will account for costs, outcomes, and alternative options (uses of limited resources). Ethics Statement Using the UK Health Research Authority (HRA) screening tool, it was determined that the wider research project did not constitute research for which HRA approval was necessary, and therefore ethical approval (for the wider research project) was obtained from the University of Birmingham Humanities and Social Sciences Ethical Review Committee (ERN_22-0818). Research reported in this paper did not involve any human participants, or the processing or analysis of any human/personal data. Our research was informed by published sources (including grey literature) and expert opinion from practitioners partnering with us to deliver the research.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Quality of Life Research
- Vol. 33 (4) , 1051-1061
Is well-becoming important for children and young people? Evidence from in-depth interviews with children and young people and their parents
Purpose: This study explores how important well-becoming factors appear to be to children during childhood. We define well-becoming as the indicators which predict children and young people’s future wellbeing and opportunities. The priority for this work was to explore whether well-becoming might be an important factor to include in outcome measures for children and young people. The inclusion of well-becoming indicators could ensure that opportunities to invest in promoting wellbeing in children’s futures are not missed. Methods: In-depth, qualitative interviews (N = 70) were undertaken with children and young people aged 6–15 years and their parents. Analysis used constant comparison and framework methods to investigate whether well-becoming factors were considered important by informants to children and young people’s current wellbeing. Results: The findings of the interviews suggested that children and young people and their parents are concerned with future well-becoming now, as factors such as future achievement, financial security, health, independence, identity, and relationships were identified as key to future quality of life. Informants suggested that they considered it important during childhood to aspire towards positive outcomes in children and young people’s futures. Conclusion: The study findings, taken alongside relevant literature, have generated evidence to support the notion that future well-becoming is important to current wellbeing. We have drawn on our own work in capability wellbeing measure development to demonstrate how we have incorporated a well-becoming attribute into our measures. The inclusion of well-becoming indicators in measures could aid investment in interventions which more directly improve well-becoming outcomes for children and young people.
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Quality of Life Research
- Vol. 33 (4) , 1051-1061
Open AccessIs well-becoming important for children and young people? Evidence from in-depth interviews with children and young people and their parents
Purpose: This study explores how important well-becoming factors appear to be to children during childhood. We define well-becoming as the indicators which predict children and young people’s future wellbeing and opportunities. The priority for this work was to explore whether well-becoming might be an important factor to include in outcome measures for children and young people. The inclusion of well-becoming indicators could ensure that opportunities to invest in promoting wellbeing in children’s futures are not missed. Methods: In-depth, qualitative interviews (N = 70) were undertaken with children and young people aged 6–15 years and their parents. Analysis used constant comparison and framework methods to investigate whether well-becoming factors were considered important by informants to children and young people’s current wellbeing. Results: The findings of the interviews suggested that children and young people and their parents are concerned with future well-becoming now, as factors such as future achievement, financial security, health, independence, identity, and relationships were identified as key to future quality of life. Informants suggested that they considered it important during childhood to aspire towards positive outcomes in children and young people’s futures. Conclusion: The study findings, taken alongside relevant literature, have generated evidence to support the notion that future well-becoming is important to current wellbeing. We have drawn on our own work in capability wellbeing measure development to demonstrate how we have incorporated a well-becoming attribute into our measures. The inclusion of well-becoming indicators in measures could aid investment in interventions which more directly improve well-becoming outcomes for children and young people.
- Open Access
- 26 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Health & Social Care in the Community
- Vol. 2023, 1-18
A Scoping Review of the Costs, Consequences, and Wider Impacts of Residential Care Home Closures in a UK Context
Background. Between 2015 and 2020, 1,578 care homes in the UK closed, displacing nearly 50,000 older and disabled people with very significant care and support needs. It is widely thought that relocation can have a significant impact on the health and well-being of older people. Yet, evidence is limited due to sensitivity and logistical difficulties with data collection. This study aimed to review the published literature in order to (i) identify evidence on the costs, consequences, and wider impacts of care home closures, for older people, family members, care home staff, and local authorities and (ii) understand the causes of and processes surrounding the closure of residential care homes in the UK. Methods. Eight electronic databases (Medline, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, ASSIA, HMIC, AgeInfo, and SPP) were searched from 1st January 2000 to 9th February 2023; Google and Google Scholar were searched for guidance/policy documents from the grey literature. Data on the objectives, methods, and main results were extracted, and the findings were narratively reported. Results. Eighteen records, comprising guidance documents and academic publications (quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-method approaches), met the inclusion criteria. We found a lack of good quality evidence on costs of closure and no consideration of outcomes for staff. Studies reporting on outcomes for residents suggest there may not be any long-term adverse effects on their health, in contrast to often-expressed views that care home closures result in harm. Conclusion. Future research should consider the stress and anxiety experienced by staff and families as relevant outcomes and show caution with respect to the use of proxy reporting of resident health outcomes. Given that a sizable portion of the costs associated with care home closure falls on local authorities, an evidence-based approach to closures that includes an assessment of cost-effectiveness will help to improve future outcomes and guide the most efficient use of limited public resources.
- 26 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Health & Social Care in the Community
- Vol. 2023, 1-18
Open AccessA Scoping Review of the Costs, Consequences, and Wider Impacts of Residential Care Home Closures in a UK Context
Background. Between 2015 and 2020, 1,578 care homes in the UK closed, displacing nearly 50,000 older and disabled people with very significant care and support needs. It is widely thought that relocation can have a significant impact on the health and well-being of older people. Yet, evidence is limited due to sensitivity and logistical difficulties with data collection. This study aimed to review the published literature in order to (i) identify evidence on the costs, consequences, and wider impacts of care home closures, for older people, family members, care home staff, and local authorities and (ii) understand the causes of and processes surrounding the closure of residential care homes in the UK. Methods. Eight electronic databases (Medline, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, ASSIA, HMIC, AgeInfo, and SPP) were searched from 1st January 2000 to 9th February 2023; Google and Google Scholar were searched for guidance/policy documents from the grey literature. Data on the objectives, methods, and main results were extracted, and the findings were narratively reported. Results. Eighteen records, comprising guidance documents and academic publications (quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-method approaches), met the inclusion criteria. We found a lack of good quality evidence on costs of closure and no consideration of outcomes for staff. Studies reporting on outcomes for residents suggest there may not be any long-term adverse effects on their health, in contrast to often-expressed views that care home closures result in harm. Conclusion. Future research should consider the stress and anxiety experienced by staff and families as relevant outcomes and show caution with respect to the use of proxy reporting of resident health outcomes. Given that a sizable portion of the costs associated with care home closure falls on local authorities, an evidence-based approach to closures that includes an assessment of cost-effectiveness will help to improve future outcomes and guide the most efficient use of limited public resources.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Palliative Medicine
- Vol. 36 (10) , 1559-1569
A think-aloud study of the feasibility of patients with end-stage organ failure completing the ICECAP-SCM
Background: The ICECAP-Supportive Care Measure (SCM) is a self-complete measure developed to inform economic decision making at the end-of-life. Previous research has demonstrated its feasibility in hospice and nursing home settings. This is the first study of its use with patients on the organ failure trajectory. Aim: To determine the feasibility of using the ICECAP-SCM with patients experiencing end-stage organ failure in a hospital setting. Design: Participants were asked to ‘think aloud’ when completing the ICECAP-SCM, ICECAP-A and EQ-5D-5L measures. The interviews were transcribed verbatim and examined for errors in comprehension, retrieval, judgement, and response by five raters. Qualitative data were collected to explore reasons for errors in completing the measures and participants’ views about the measures. Setting/participants: Sixty patients (with end-stage renal failure n = 18; end-stage heart failure n = 21; end-stage chronic obstructive pulmonary disease n = 21) participated. Senior clinicians applied prognostic criteria to determine eligibility. Results: Participants reported that the measures were acceptable, clear, and easy to complete. Error rates in completing the measures were low (ICECAP-A = 3%,and ICECAP-SCM = 5.7% and EQ-5D-5L = 6.3%). There was some variation in responses between patients with different end-stage conditions, particularly those with symptom fluctuation. Some patients had not considered their end-of-life (i.e. advance care planning) and reported finding questions about this difficult to answer. Conclusion: It is feasible to use the ICECAP-SCM with patients with end-stage organ failure receiving care in hospital settings. This study provides evidence for researchers and policy makers involved in measuring end-of-life care globally. The ICECAP-SCM can be recommended for research with patients in end-stage organ failure to appropriately capture the broader benefits of end-of-life care.
- 16 September 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Palliative Medicine
- Vol. 36 (10) , 1559-1569
Open AccessA think-aloud study of the feasibility of patients with end-stage organ failure completing the ICECAP-SCM
Background: The ICECAP-Supportive Care Measure (SCM) is a self-complete measure developed to inform economic decision making at the end-of-life. Previous research has demonstrated its feasibility in hospice and nursing home settings. This is the first study of its use with patients on the organ failure trajectory. Aim: To determine the feasibility of using the ICECAP-SCM with patients experiencing end-stage organ failure in a hospital setting. Design: Participants were asked to ‘think aloud’ when completing the ICECAP-SCM, ICECAP-A and EQ-5D-5L measures. The interviews were transcribed verbatim and examined for errors in comprehension, retrieval, judgement, and response by five raters. Qualitative data were collected to explore reasons for errors in completing the measures and participants’ views about the measures. Setting/participants: Sixty patients (with end-stage renal failure n = 18; end-stage heart failure n = 21; end-stage chronic obstructive pulmonary disease n = 21) participated. Senior clinicians applied prognostic criteria to determine eligibility. Results: Participants reported that the measures were acceptable, clear, and easy to complete. Error rates in completing the measures were low (ICECAP-A = 3%,and ICECAP-SCM = 5.7% and EQ-5D-5L = 6.3%). There was some variation in responses between patients with different end-stage conditions, particularly those with symptom fluctuation. Some patients had not considered their end-of-life (i.e. advance care planning) and reported finding questions about this difficult to answer. Conclusion: It is feasible to use the ICECAP-SCM with patients with end-stage organ failure receiving care in hospital settings. This study provides evidence for researchers and policy makers involved in measuring end-of-life care globally. The ICECAP-SCM can be recommended for research with patients in end-stage organ failure to appropriately capture the broader benefits of end-of-life care.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Human Development and Capabilities
- Vol. 23 (3) , 455-476
A Deliberative Approach to Valuing Capabilities: Assessing and Valuing Changes in the Well-Being of those Close to Patients Receiving Supportive End of Life Care
Aim: Explore the use of deliberative valuation to elicit relative weights for a set of capabilities identified as being important and relevant to those close to patients receiving supportive care at the end of life. Methods: Focus groups, involving the general UK population (n = 38) and policy-makers (n = 29) with experience of, and influence on, priorities for end of life care. Public participants completed two valuation tasks (budget pie and visual analogue scale (VAS)) individually, discussed their responses, and then recorded a final (individual) response. Policy-makers completed the VAS tasks in a separate series of focus groups. Quantitative and qualitative analyses of participants’ responses are reported. Results: Individual values were aggregated to form relative weights for the capabilities. Capabilities given greatest weighting were “good communication between care providers and close persons” and “practical support for close persons”. The quantitative impact of deliberation on weights overall was negligible, but qualitative findings indicated that disclosure of personal experiences did appear to prompt others to consider issues from new perspectives. Discussion: Deliberative valuation was found to be a potentially feasible method for generating weights. However, further consideration needs to be given as to how to optimise recruitment whilst ensuring that participants actively engage with the task.
- 1 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Human Development and Capabilities
- Vol. 23 (3) , 455-476
Open AccessA Deliberative Approach to Valuing Capabilities: Assessing and Valuing Changes in the Well-Being of those Close to Patients Receiving Supportive End of Life Care
Aim: Explore the use of deliberative valuation to elicit relative weights for a set of capabilities identified as being important and relevant to those close to patients receiving supportive care at the end of life. Methods: Focus groups, involving the general UK population (n = 38) and policy-makers (n = 29) with experience of, and influence on, priorities for end of life care. Public participants completed two valuation tasks (budget pie and visual analogue scale (VAS)) individually, discussed their responses, and then recorded a final (individual) response. Policy-makers completed the VAS tasks in a separate series of focus groups. Quantitative and qualitative analyses of participants’ responses are reported. Results: Individual values were aggregated to form relative weights for the capabilities. Capabilities given greatest weighting were “good communication between care providers and close persons” and “practical support for close persons”. The quantitative impact of deliberation on weights overall was negligible, but qualitative findings indicated that disclosure of personal experiences did appear to prompt others to consider issues from new perspectives. Discussion: Deliberative valuation was found to be a potentially feasible method for generating weights. However, further consideration needs to be given as to how to optimise recruitment whilst ensuring that participants actively engage with the task.