Vincent Hoogerheide
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Vincent Hoogerheide has a total of 35 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Andreas Lachner
University of Tübingen
7 shared publications - Leonie Sibley
Leibniz‐Institut für Wissensmedien Tübingen Germany
5 shared publications - Katharina Scheiter
University of Potsdam, Potsdam, Germany
4 shared publications - Salome Flegr
Chair of Physics Education, Faculty of Physics, TU Dresden University of Technology, Dresden, Germany
4 shared publications - Heike Russ
Institute of Education, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany
3 shared publications - Jochen Kuhn
LMU Munich, Munich, Germany
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Instruction
- Vol. 107
Happy or redundant? Retrieval practice enhances lasting learning in non-interactive teaching for low-quality explanations
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Instruction
- Vol. 107
Open AccessHappy or redundant? Retrieval practice enhances lasting learning in non-interactive teaching for low-quality explanations
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 118 (3) , 345-367
Combining non-interactive teaching and drawing fosters conceptual knowledge but not monitoring accuracy from guided inquiry in science learning.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 118 (3) , 345-367
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessCombining non-interactive teaching and drawing fosters conceptual knowledge but not monitoring accuracy from guided inquiry in science learning.
- Open Access
- 7 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Happy or Redundant? Retrieval Practice Enhances Lasting Learning in Non-Interactive Teaching for Low-Quality Explanations
Background: Supporting lasting learning is a central goal in education, particularly in schools where long-term retention is crucial for students' academic success. Generative learning helps construct meaningful mental representations, while retrieval practice supports consolidation and long-term retention. Combining both strategies may foster learning; however, research remains scarce.Aims: We investigated how combining generative activities and retrieval practice affects students’ conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy in authentic school settings for immediate and lasting learning. Additionally, we explored associations between generation, retrieval, and explanation quality (i.e., completeness, elaboration, correctness).Sample: The classroom experiment was conducted in authentic physics lessons with N = 344 secondary students.Methods: Students participated in a physics teaching unit about converging lenses and were randomly assigned within each class to one of four combinations of sequential learning activities crossing two factors (non-generation vs. generation; non-retrieval vs. retrieval). Conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy were measured immediately and after eight weeks.Results: Conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy did not significantly differ between generation, retrieval, or their sequential combination at either test. However, exploratory analyses revealed that retrieval practice supported lasting learning only when prior generative processing was of low quality—that is, when students’ explanations were incomplete, less elaborated, or inaccurate.Conclusions: Combining generation and retrieval does not universally enhance learning. Its effectiveness appears to depend on the quality of prior generative processing. In this sense, retrieval practice may serve a happy role—compensating fragile knowledge—or a redundant one, offering no added benefit when prior understanding is already strong.
- 7 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessHappy or Redundant? Retrieval Practice Enhances Lasting Learning in Non-Interactive Teaching for Low-Quality Explanations
Background: Supporting lasting learning is a central goal in education, particularly in schools where long-term retention is crucial for students' academic success. Generative learning helps construct meaningful mental representations, while retrieval practice supports consolidation and long-term retention. Combining both strategies may foster learning; however, research remains scarce.Aims: We investigated how combining generative activities and retrieval practice affects students’ conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy in authentic school settings for immediate and lasting learning. Additionally, we explored associations between generation, retrieval, and explanation quality (i.e., completeness, elaboration, correctness).Sample: The classroom experiment was conducted in authentic physics lessons with N = 344 secondary students.Methods: Students participated in a physics teaching unit about converging lenses and were randomly assigned within each class to one of four combinations of sequential learning activities crossing two factors (non-generation vs. generation; non-retrieval vs. retrieval). Conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy were measured immediately and after eight weeks.Results: Conceptual knowledge and monitoring accuracy did not significantly differ between generation, retrieval, or their sequential combination at either test. However, exploratory analyses revealed that retrieval practice supported lasting learning only when prior generative processing was of low quality—that is, when students’ explanations were incomplete, less elaborated, or inaccurate.Conclusions: Combining generation and retrieval does not universally enhance learning. Its effectiveness appears to depend on the quality of prior generative processing. In this sense, retrieval practice may serve a happy role—compensating fragile knowledge—or a redundant one, offering no added benefit when prior understanding is already strong.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Education
- Vol. 237
Learning by explaining through digital devices: The role of the modality of oral explaining and extraversion
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Education
- Vol. 237
Open AccessLearning by explaining through digital devices: The role of the modality of oral explaining and extraversion
- Open Access
- 4 April 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Individual Differences
- Vol. 120
Does distributing non-interactive teaching contribute to learning? Students' academic self-concept and work ethic matter
- 4 April 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Learning and Individual Differences
- Vol. 120
Open AccessDoes distributing non-interactive teaching contribute to learning? Students' academic self-concept and work ethic matter
- Open Access
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1715-1738
When is observing failure productive? Investigating the role of solution diversity in vicarious failure
Prior research has shown that Productive Failure (PF), where learners attempt (and fail) to solve a problem prior to receiving instruction, is more effective for conceptual knowledge acquisition than receiving instruction first (Direct Instruction; DI). Higher diversity in generated solution attempts seemed positively associated with conceptual knowledge acquisition. The present study investigated whether observing another student’s attempts to solve the problem prior to receiving instruction (i.e., Vicarious Failure; VF) is as beneficial as PF for conceptual knowledge acquisition in mathematics and whether this depends on the diversity in the observed solution attempts. In the high solution diversity condition (VF-high), students observed five solution attempts that (taken together) included all four components of the to-be-learned canonical solution, while in the low diversity condition (VF-low), the solution attempts included only two of these components. Secondary education students ( n = 152) were randomly assigned to one of four conditions: PF, VF-high, VF-low, and Direct Instruction (DI). As expected, students in the VF-high condition significantly outperformed students in the VF-low and DI conditions and performed as well as students in the PF condition on the conceptual knowledge posttest. Surprisingly, the PF effect found in previous studies was not replicated, i.e., the PF condition descriptively seemed to outperform the DI condition, but this difference was not statistically significant. Our findings provide further insight into the mechanisms that explain why engaging with problems prior to instruction is effective, suggesting that students’ activation of prior knowledge is more critical than whether they experience failure first hand.
- 6 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1715-1738
Open AccessWhen is observing failure productive? Investigating the role of solution diversity in vicarious failure
Prior research has shown that Productive Failure (PF), where learners attempt (and fail) to solve a problem prior to receiving instruction, is more effective for conceptual knowledge acquisition than receiving instruction first (Direct Instruction; DI). Higher diversity in generated solution attempts seemed positively associated with conceptual knowledge acquisition. The present study investigated whether observing another student’s attempts to solve the problem prior to receiving instruction (i.e., Vicarious Failure; VF) is as beneficial as PF for conceptual knowledge acquisition in mathematics and whether this depends on the diversity in the observed solution attempts. In the high solution diversity condition (VF-high), students observed five solution attempts that (taken together) included all four components of the to-be-learned canonical solution, while in the low diversity condition (VF-low), the solution attempts included only two of these components. Secondary education students ( n = 152) were randomly assigned to one of four conditions: PF, VF-high, VF-low, and Direct Instruction (DI). As expected, students in the VF-high condition significantly outperformed students in the VF-low and DI conditions and performed as well as students in the PF condition on the conceptual knowledge posttest. Surprisingly, the PF effect found in previous studies was not replicated, i.e., the PF condition descriptively seemed to outperform the DI condition, but this difference was not statistically significant. Our findings provide further insight into the mechanisms that explain why engaging with problems prior to instruction is effective, suggesting that students’ activation of prior knowledge is more critical than whether they experience failure first hand.
- 29 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 75-89
Six Evidence-Informed Tips on How to Optimize Learning from Instructional Videos
Learning from instructional video (IV) is popular for people of all ages and at all educational levels. The effects of studying IVs on learning outcomes have traditionally been examined by two main research traditions. Research inspired by social-cognitive theories has focused mostly on the effects of video modelling examples, which are how-to demonstration videos in which a person shows how to complete a task or solve a problem. Research inspired by cognitive theories has predominantly examined the effects of other types of videos, such as short videos explaining a concept or longer recordings of lectures. In this chapter, we synthesize the findings from both research lines and provide six evidence-informed tips that can help educators and educational content developers decide how to design their IVs and how to support IV learning. Based on the available evidence, we suggest to (1) only present information relevant to learning, (2) provide cues to direct attention, (3) segment and pause (longer) videos, (4) show the presenter of the video on the screen, (5) show a demonstration from a first-person perspective, and (6) encourage generative learning activities. The chapter concludes with a discussion that details several suggestions for future IV research.
- 29 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 75-89
Six Evidence-Informed Tips on How to Optimize Learning from Instructional Videos
Learning from instructional video (IV) is popular for people of all ages and at all educational levels. The effects of studying IVs on learning outcomes have traditionally been examined by two main research traditions. Research inspired by social-cognitive theories has focused mostly on the effects of video modelling examples, which are how-to demonstration videos in which a person shows how to complete a task or solve a problem. Research inspired by cognitive theories has predominantly examined the effects of other types of videos, such as short videos explaining a concept or longer recordings of lectures. In this chapter, we synthesize the findings from both research lines and provide six evidence-informed tips that can help educators and educational content developers decide how to design their IVs and how to support IV learning. Based on the available evidence, we suggest to (1) only present information relevant to learning, (2) provide cues to direct attention, (3) segment and pause (longer) videos, (4) show the presenter of the video on the screen, (5) show a demonstration from a first-person perspective, and (6) encourage generative learning activities. The chapter concludes with a discussion that details several suggestions for future IV research.
- Open Access
- 23 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Applied Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 38 (3)
Training task‐selection skills: The effect of prompts and explicit instruction on transfer
For effective self‐regulated learning with problem‐solving tasks, students must accurately assess their performance and select a suitable next learning task. However, most students struggle with this. Recent research shows that self‐assessment and task‐selection skills can be trained through video modeling examples (SATS‐training). However, the limited research available suggests that students struggle to transfer trained task‐selection skills to other problem‐solving contexts. We investigated whether guidance in the form of prompts (stating that the task‐selection procedure can be adapted and used) or explicit instruction (on how the procedure can be adapted) would improve task‐selection accuracy on transfer tasks with this guidance available and on later, unguided transfer tasks. Explicit instruction significantly enhanced task‐selection accuracy compared to prompts and a no‐guidance control condition on guided transfer tasks, but not on unguided transfer tasks. Thus, it remains a question how to lastingly improve transfer of task‐selection skills also in the absence of guidance.
- 23 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Applied Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 38 (3)
Open AccessTraining task‐selection skills: The effect of prompts and explicit instruction on transfer
For effective self‐regulated learning with problem‐solving tasks, students must accurately assess their performance and select a suitable next learning task. However, most students struggle with this. Recent research shows that self‐assessment and task‐selection skills can be trained through video modeling examples (SATS‐training). However, the limited research available suggests that students struggle to transfer trained task‐selection skills to other problem‐solving contexts. We investigated whether guidance in the form of prompts (stating that the task‐selection procedure can be adapted and used) or explicit instruction (on how the procedure can be adapted) would improve task‐selection accuracy on transfer tasks with this guidance available and on later, unguided transfer tasks. Explicit instruction significantly enhanced task‐selection accuracy compared to prompts and a no‐guidance control condition on guided transfer tasks, but not on unguided transfer tasks. Thus, it remains a question how to lastingly improve transfer of task‐selection skills also in the absence of guidance.
- Open Access
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Who Are the 50 Most Productive Researchers in Top-Tier Educational Psychology Journals From 2017 to 2022? A New Perspective with a Focus on Publication Trends and Diversity
The present study identified the most productive researchers in educational psychology by analyzing the number of published articles in top-tier, topic-general educational psychology journals between 2017 and 2022. Our study aimed to advance prior productivity research in various ways. We increased the sample of most productive researchers (i.e., top 50), used three different scoring methods, and relied on a more extensive list of journals identified in an objective manner (i.e., based on the Web of Science “Psychology, Educational” list). In addition, we conducted an online survey to shed light on characteristics of highly productive researchers and examined their publications in the target journals in terms of research topics, open science practices, collaboration, and internationalization of research. Our results showed that three senior researchers consistently appeared in the top 5 of the rankings (i.e., Richard E. Mayer, Reinhard Pekrun, and Herbert W. Marsh) and that the top 50 contained a relatively high percentage of early-career researchers (between 25% and 40%). The diversity of the most productive researchers was poor in that most of them self-identified as White (86%), male (59%), did not have a first-generation student status (60%), had a first-generation faculty status (86%), and had either European (46%) or North American nationalities (39%). As for the publication trends, we observed that most articles were quantitative in nature and that publications on average reported 1.2 studies and had 4.2 authors. Research topics were diverse, with the most frequent top 3 keywords used for publications being motivation, quantitative methods, and multimedia learning.
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessWho Are the 50 Most Productive Researchers in Top-Tier Educational Psychology Journals From 2017 to 2022? A New Perspective with a Focus on Publication Trends and Diversity
The present study identified the most productive researchers in educational psychology by analyzing the number of published articles in top-tier, topic-general educational psychology journals between 2017 and 2022. Our study aimed to advance prior productivity research in various ways. We increased the sample of most productive researchers (i.e., top 50), used three different scoring methods, and relied on a more extensive list of journals identified in an objective manner (i.e., based on the Web of Science “Psychology, Educational” list). In addition, we conducted an online survey to shed light on characteristics of highly productive researchers and examined their publications in the target journals in terms of research topics, open science practices, collaboration, and internationalization of research. Our results showed that three senior researchers consistently appeared in the top 5 of the rankings (i.e., Richard E. Mayer, Reinhard Pekrun, and Herbert W. Marsh) and that the top 50 contained a relatively high percentage of early-career researchers (between 25% and 40%). The diversity of the most productive researchers was poor in that most of them self-identified as White (86%), male (59%), did not have a first-generation student status (60%), had a first-generation faculty status (86%), and had either European (46%) or North American nationalities (39%). As for the publication trends, we observed that most articles were quantitative in nature and that publications on average reported 1.2 studies and had 4.2 authors. Research topics were diverse, with the most frequent top 3 keywords used for publications being motivation, quantitative methods, and multimedia learning.
- Open Access
- 25 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 35 (2) , 1-37
Comparing Mental Effort, Difficulty, and Confidence Appraisals in Problem-Solving: A Metacognitive Perspective
It is well established in educational research that metacognitive monitoring of performance assessed by self-reports, for instance, asking students to report their confidence in provided answers, is based on heuristic cues rather than on actual success in the task. Subjective self-reports are also used in educational research on cognitive load, where they refer to the perceived amount of mental effort invested in or difficulty of each task item. In the present study, we examined the potential underlying bases and the predictive value of mental effort and difficulty appraisals compared to confidence appraisals by applying metacognitive concepts and paradigms. In three experiments, participants faced verbal logic problems or one of two non-verbal reasoning tasks. In a between-participants design, each task item was followed by either mental effort, difficulty, or confidence appraisals. We examined the associations between the various appraisals, response time, and success rates. Consistently across all experiments, we found that mental effort and difficulty appraisals were associated more strongly than confidence with response time. Further, while all appraisals were highly predictive of solving success, the strength of this association was stronger for difficulty and confidence appraisals (which were similar) than for mental effort appraisals. We conclude that mental effort and difficulty appraisals are prone to misleading cues like other metacognitive judgments and are based on unique underlying processes. These findings challenge the accepted notion that mental effort appraisals can serve as reliable reflections of cognitive load.
- 25 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 35 (2) , 1-37
Open AccessComparing Mental Effort, Difficulty, and Confidence Appraisals in Problem-Solving: A Metacognitive Perspective
It is well established in educational research that metacognitive monitoring of performance assessed by self-reports, for instance, asking students to report their confidence in provided answers, is based on heuristic cues rather than on actual success in the task. Subjective self-reports are also used in educational research on cognitive load, where they refer to the perceived amount of mental effort invested in or difficulty of each task item. In the present study, we examined the potential underlying bases and the predictive value of mental effort and difficulty appraisals compared to confidence appraisals by applying metacognitive concepts and paradigms. In three experiments, participants faced verbal logic problems or one of two non-verbal reasoning tasks. In a between-participants design, each task item was followed by either mental effort, difficulty, or confidence appraisals. We examined the associations between the various appraisals, response time, and success rates. Consistently across all experiments, we found that mental effort and difficulty appraisals were associated more strongly than confidence with response time. Further, while all appraisals were highly predictive of solving success, the strength of this association was stronger for difficulty and confidence appraisals (which were similar) than for mental effort appraisals. We conclude that mental effort and difficulty appraisals are prone to misleading cues like other metacognitive judgments and are based on unique underlying processes. These findings challenge the accepted notion that mental effort appraisals can serve as reliable reflections of cognitive load.