Roman Tikhonov
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Roman Tikhonov has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nadezhda V. Moroshkina
Bechtereva Institute of the Human Brain, Russian Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia
6 shared publications - Ivan I. Ivanchei
Department of Experimental Psychology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
3 shared publications - Irina V. Ovchinnikova
Saint-Petersburg State University
2 shared publications - Olga Bogolyubova
Leiden University
2 shared publications - Polina Panicheva
Voronezh State Pedagogical University
2 shared publications St. Petersburg State University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Prediction, Explanation, and Control: The Use of Mental Models in Dynamic Environments
The abilities to predict, explain, and control might arise out of operations on a common underlying representation or, conversely, from independent cognitive processes. We developed a novel experimental paradigm to explore how individuals might use probabilistic mental models in these three tasks, under varying levels of complexity and uncertainty. Participants interacted with a simple chatbot defined by a finite-state machine, and were then tested on their ability to predict, explain, and control the chatbot’s responses. When full information was available, performance varied significantly across the tasks, with control proving most robust to increased complexity, and explanation being the most challenging. In the presence of hidden information, however, performance across tasks equalized, and participants demonstrated an alternative neglect bias, i.e., a tendency to ignore less likely possibilities. A second, within-subject experimental design then looked for correlations between abilities. We did not find strong correlations, but the challenges of the task for the subjects limited our statistical power. To understand these effects better, a final experiment investigated the possibility of cross-training, skill transfer, or “zero-shot” performance: how well a participant, explicitly trained on one of the three tasks, could perform on the others without additional training. Here we found strong asymmetries: participants trained to control gained generalizable abilities to both predict and explain, while training on either prediction or explanation did not lead to transfer. This cross-training experiment also revealed correlations in performance; most notably between control and prediction. Our findings highlight the complex role of mental models, in contrast to task-specific heuristics, when information is partially hidden, and suggest new avenues for research into situations where the acquisition of general purpose mental models may provide a unifying explanation for a variety of cognitive abilities.
Open AccessPrediction, Explanation, and Control: The Use of Mental Models in Dynamic Environments
The abilities to predict, explain, and control might arise out of operations on a common underlying representation or, conversely, from independent cognitive processes. We developed a novel experimental paradigm to explore how individuals might use probabilistic mental models in these three tasks, under varying levels of complexity and uncertainty. Participants interacted with a simple chatbot defined by a finite-state machine, and were then tested on their ability to predict, explain, and control the chatbot’s responses. When full information was available, performance varied significantly across the tasks, with control proving most robust to increased complexity, and explanation being the most challenging. In the presence of hidden information, however, performance across tasks equalized, and participants demonstrated an alternative neglect bias, i.e., a tendency to ignore less likely possibilities. A second, within-subject experimental design then looked for correlations between abilities. We did not find strong correlations, but the challenges of the task for the subjects limited our statistical power. To understand these effects better, a final experiment investigated the possibility of cross-training, skill transfer, or “zero-shot” performance: how well a participant, explicitly trained on one of the three tasks, could perform on the others without additional training. Here we found strong asymmetries: participants trained to control gained generalizable abilities to both predict and explain, while training on either prediction or explanation did not lead to transfer. This cross-training experiment also revealed correlations in performance; most notably between control and prediction. Our findings highlight the complex role of mental models, in contrast to task-specific heuristics, when information is partially hidden, and suggest new avenues for research into situations where the acquisition of general purpose mental models may provide a unifying explanation for a variety of cognitive abilities.
- 12 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 35 (5) , 578-593
The social verification of implicit knowledge in dyads: the mediating role of confidence
- 12 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 35 (5) , 578-593
The social verification of implicit knowledge in dyads: the mediating role of confidence
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Prediction, explanation, and control under free exploration
Prediction, explanation, and control are basic cognitive abilities. Here we show how they can arise, simultaneously, from underlying mental models built during unstructured, exploration-based learning. Our experimental paradigm, involving interaction with a symbolic "chatbot", allows us to vary the relative difficulty of the tasks, and to measure how participants leverage the Bayesian evidence of their mental models for decision-making. Our experimental manipulation focuses on hidden information and task complexity. With full information, there are significant differences between the three tasks: for example, people are more sensitive to Bayesian evidence in prediction than in control or explanation. When information is hidden, however, performance equalizes. Taken together, our results suggest that, while specific heuristics may lead to different levels of performance in cases with full information, more fundamental forms of reasoning, based on an underlying mental model, and less sensitive to the specific task, come into play when pieces are missing.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessPrediction, explanation, and control under free exploration
Prediction, explanation, and control are basic cognitive abilities. Here we show how they can arise, simultaneously, from underlying mental models built during unstructured, exploration-based learning. Our experimental paradigm, involving interaction with a symbolic "chatbot", allows us to vary the relative difficulty of the tasks, and to measure how participants leverage the Bayesian evidence of their mental models for decision-making. Our experimental manipulation focuses on hidden information and task complexity. With full information, there are significant differences between the three tasks: for example, people are more sensitive to Bayesian evidence in prediction than in control or explanation. When information is hidden, however, performance equalizes. Taken together, our results suggest that, while specific heuristics may lead to different levels of performance in cases with full information, more fundamental forms of reasoning, based on an underlying mental model, and less sensitive to the specific task, come into play when pieces are missing.
- 30 June 2022
- Published by The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science in The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science
- Vol. 9 (1-2) , 44-52
How others change our memories: The effect of exposure to anonymous opinions
A number of studies have demonstrated the memory conformity effect: interactions and discussions with other people affect remembering and provoke errors in memory reports in the direction of the opinions of others. Nowadays, communication via online social networks, where people read and leave comments on different facts, is of particular importance. The present study focuses on how evaluations and comments provided by anonymous others affect the memory of one’s initial opinion. The research aims to clarify new specific conditions under which memory conformity may occur. We conducted a laboratory experiment. Participants had to evaluate the IQ of a person in a photo. Then, we made the participants believe that they would see the evaluations and comments of three anonymous participants who completed the same task previously. For some photos, we presented evaluations and comments that supported the participants’ initial opinion. For some other photos, we presented estimations and comments that were conflicting (i.e., opposite to the participants’ initial decision). Then, we tested the participants’ memories of the initial evaluations and compared them to the control condition with no comments and evaluations from others. The results demonstrated that conflicting opinions were a predictor of a memory change towards the values inserted in the comments of others, whereas congruent opinions were a predictor of the initial evaluations’ replication. These results suggest that memory conformity may be evoked indirectly, without real social interactions and social pressure and without information about the reliability of the sources
- 30 June 2022
- Published by The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science in The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science
- Vol. 9 (1-2) , 44-52
How others change our memories: The effect of exposure to anonymous opinions
A number of studies have demonstrated the memory conformity effect: interactions and discussions with other people affect remembering and provoke errors in memory reports in the direction of the opinions of others. Nowadays, communication via online social networks, where people read and leave comments on different facts, is of particular importance. The present study focuses on how evaluations and comments provided by anonymous others affect the memory of one’s initial opinion. The research aims to clarify new specific conditions under which memory conformity may occur. We conducted a laboratory experiment. Participants had to evaluate the IQ of a person in a photo. Then, we made the participants believe that they would see the evaluations and comments of three anonymous participants who completed the same task previously. For some photos, we presented evaluations and comments that supported the participants’ initial opinion. For some other photos, we presented estimations and comments that were conflicting (i.e., opposite to the participants’ initial decision). Then, we tested the participants’ memories of the initial evaluations and compared them to the control condition with no comments and evaluations from others. The results demonstrated that conflicting opinions were a predictor of a memory change towards the values inserted in the comments of others, whereas congruent opinions were a predictor of the initial evaluations’ replication. These results suggest that memory conformity may be evoked indirectly, without real social interactions and social pressure and without information about the reliability of the sources
- 30 June 2021
- Published by The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science in The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science
- Vol. 8 (1-2) , 53-59
Online Experiment Hackathon
The Cognitive Hackathon, dedicated to the creation of online experiments, took place in an online format in February 2021. The event was a blending of a conference, school and case tournament. In the master classes, participants became acquainted with the specifics of creating online experiments using PsychoPy with subsequent posting on Pavlovia, mastered the practice of posting materials in the public domain on the Open Science Framework (OSF) platform, and also learned how to use crowdsourcing services to recruit subjects. In the conference part of the event, the challenges of online research and ways to solve them were discussed at the round table, and session talks highlighted the methodological aspects of conducting online experiments. The present paper provides an overview of the hackathon and summarizes the main conclusions of the educational and conference parts of the event.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science in The Russian Journal of Cognitive Science
- Vol. 8 (1-2) , 53-59
Online Experiment Hackathon
The Cognitive Hackathon, dedicated to the creation of online experiments, took place in an online format in February 2021. The event was a blending of a conference, school and case tournament. In the master classes, participants became acquainted with the specifics of creating online experiments using PsychoPy with subsequent posting on Pavlovia, mastered the practice of posting materials in the public domain on the Open Science Framework (OSF) platform, and also learned how to use crowdsourcing services to recruit subjects. In the conference part of the event, the challenges of online research and ways to solve them were discussed at the round table, and session talks highlighted the methodological aspects of conducting online experiments. The present paper provides an overview of the hackathon and summarizes the main conclusions of the educational and conference parts of the event.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Moscow State University of Psychology and Education in Experimental Psychology (Russia)
- Vol. 14 (4) , 164-181
Theory and Practice of Awareness Measurement in Experimental Cognitive Research
Measurement of consciousness is one of the key methodological problems of cognitive experiments. The choice of method is often made without reference to a specific theory or the explication of the underlying assumptions about the nature of the phenomenon being measured. It is suggested that the lack of theoretical justification of the employed methods leads to unconstructive criticism and disagreement among researchers. We discussed the most common awareness measures in research on learning, memory, perception, and the underlying assumptions about the nature of consciousness and their relationship to theories of consciousness. The degree of theoretical justification of consciousness measures was assessed in a sample of 179 experimental articles. It was shown that in only a quarter of cases, the researchers linked the methods with corresponding assumptions about the nature of consciousness. In the rest of the cases, the choice of method was not theoretically justified.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Moscow State University of Psychology and Education in Experimental Psychology (Russia)
- Vol. 14 (4) , 164-181
Open AccessTheory and Practice of Awareness Measurement in Experimental Cognitive Research
Measurement of consciousness is one of the key methodological problems of cognitive experiments. The choice of method is often made without reference to a specific theory or the explication of the underlying assumptions about the nature of the phenomenon being measured. It is suggested that the lack of theoretical justification of the employed methods leads to unconstructive criticism and disagreement among researchers. We discussed the most common awareness measures in research on learning, memory, perception, and the underlying assumptions about the nature of consciousness and their relationship to theories of consciousness. The degree of theoretical justification of consciousness measures was assessed in a sample of 179 experimental articles. It was shown that in only a quarter of cases, the researchers linked the methods with corresponding assumptions about the nature of consciousness. In the rest of the cases, the choice of method was not theoretically justified.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 148 (9) , 1505-1516
Implicit learning in attractiveness evaluation: The role of conformity and analytical processing.
We address the question how people's opinion and features of information interact in the process of indirect social influence. Implicit learning was considered as a mechanism for conformity in social perception. We carried out 2 experiments using a hidden covariation detection paradigm. In a learning phase, participants memorized a set of female photographs presented together with their attractiveness ratings. The ratings correlated with the hairstyle of the photographed women. The participants who did not consciously detect this correlation demonstrated a systematic bias toward the correlation when evaluating the new stimulus persons. Information about the source of the ratings in the learning phase (other people's opinions or nonsocial sources) did not modulate learning. Learning was not observed when participants critically evaluated the ratings during the memorization phase. The study shows that (a) conformity may be based not only on reinforcement learning mechanism (as was previously suggested) but also on unsupervised implicit learning; (b) implicit learning occurs automatically irrespective of the context (social or not); and (c) a critical attitude toward learned material may prevent implicit learning from being manifested in a test phase. We conclude that indirect social influence may be affected by people's opinion toward the provided information. The study contributes to both implicit learning and social perception research. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 September 2019
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
- Vol. 148 (9) , 1505-1516
Implicit learning in attractiveness evaluation: The role of conformity and analytical processing.
We address the question how people's opinion and features of information interact in the process of indirect social influence. Implicit learning was considered as a mechanism for conformity in social perception. We carried out 2 experiments using a hidden covariation detection paradigm. In a learning phase, participants memorized a set of female photographs presented together with their attractiveness ratings. The ratings correlated with the hairstyle of the photographed women. The participants who did not consciously detect this correlation demonstrated a systematic bias toward the correlation when evaluating the new stimulus persons. Information about the source of the ratings in the learning phase (other people's opinions or nonsocial sources) did not modulate learning. Learning was not observed when participants critically evaluated the ratings during the memorization phase. The study shows that (a) conformity may be based not only on reinforcement learning mechanism (as was previously suggested) but also on unsupervised implicit learning; (b) implicit learning occurs automatically irrespective of the context (social or not); and (c) a critical attitude toward learned material may prevent implicit learning from being manifested in a test phase. We conclude that indirect social influence may be affected by people's opinion toward the provided information. The study contributes to both implicit learning and social perception research. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior
- Vol. 78, 151-159
Dark personalities on Facebook: Harmful online behaviors and language
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior
- Vol. 78, 151-159
Dark personalities on Facebook: Harmful online behaviors and language
- Open Access
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Saint Petersburg State University in Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Psychology
- Vol. 8 (3)
The variety of metacognitive feelings: Different phenomena or different terms?
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Saint Petersburg State University in Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Psychology
- Vol. 8 (3)
Open AccessThe variety of metacognitive feelings: Different phenomena or different terms?
- Open Access
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Moscow State University of Psychology and Education in Experimental Psychology (Russia)
- Vol. 11 (2) , 34-49
Development and Approbation of The Russian Database of Neutral and Smiling Female Faces (RuNeS Faces)
The article presents a database of women’s faces for research in the field of social perception. Each of 55 models was photographed full-face under four conditions: with a neutral or smiling face with hair up or down. The database includes the results of facial morphometry (relative positions of homologous points), expert ratings of appearance style, scores of perceived intelligence and attractiveness. The peculiarity of the database is that, unlike the others, we preserved the natural style featured on the models: clothes, jewelry, and makeup. The database was approbated in the study of physiognomic and appearance style predictors of perceived intelligence and attractiveness. It expands the variety of stimulus images available for researchers and can be used in different studies of social perception.
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Moscow State University of Psychology and Education in Experimental Psychology (Russia)
- Vol. 11 (2) , 34-49
Open AccessDevelopment and Approbation of The Russian Database of Neutral and Smiling Female Faces (RuNeS Faces)
The article presents a database of women’s faces for research in the field of social perception. Each of 55 models was photographed full-face under four conditions: with a neutral or smiling face with hair up or down. The database includes the results of facial morphometry (relative positions of homologous points), expert ratings of appearance style, scores of perceived intelligence and attractiveness. The peculiarity of the database is that, unlike the others, we preserved the natural style featured on the models: clothes, jewelry, and makeup. The database was approbated in the study of physiognomic and appearance style predictors of perceived intelligence and attractiveness. It expands the variety of stimulus images available for researchers and can be used in different studies of social perception.