Dante Cisterna
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Dante Cisterna has a total of 53 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Hui Jin
Middle Grades and Secondary Education College of Education Georgia Southern University 11935 Abercorn St Savannah Georgia 31419 United States
5 shared publications - Amelia Wenk Gotwals
Michigan State University
3 shared publications Kelsey Lipsitz
Educational Testing Service, Princeton, New Jersey, USA
3 shared publications- Cory T. Forbes
University of Texas at Arlington, USA
2 shared publications - Deborah Hanuscin
Western Washington University
2 shared publications - Hyo Jeong Shin
Sogang University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research
- Vol. 7 (1)
Collaboration with ChatGPT: preservice elementary teachers analyzing and interpreting student responses
This study investigated how Preservice Elementary Teachers (PETs) collaborated with ChatGPT on Analyzing and Interpreting Student Responses (AISR) tasks. These tasks required PETs to analyze and interpret K–12 students’ responses to items targeting counterintuitive scientific mechanisms. This study yielded three findings. First, as PETs gained experience, they developed more positive views of ChatGPT as a pedagogical tool. Second, PETs employed prompt-engineering strategies in three categories, including contextualization, iteration, and decomposition. Third, based on PETs’ task responses, we developed an AISR proficiency model to evaluate three key dimensions—understanding of disciplinary knowledge, understanding of student ideas, and recognizing the value of students’ intuitive ideas. Analyses of PETs’ task responses and their exchanges with ChatGPT showed the following: for understanding of disciplinary knowledge, PETs often struggled to make sense of ChatGPT’s lengthy outputs, which obscured the central scientific idea with extraneous details; for understanding of student ideas, both PETs and ChatGPT tended to adopt an evaluative orientation, classifying student responses by their degree of correctness and completeness; for recognizing the value of students’ intuitive ideas, designing instruction that productively uses these ideas remained challenging for both PETs and ChatGPT. This study’s implications for teacher education are twofold. First, PETs’ effective use of ChatGPT depends on their knowledge of Large Language Models (LLMs), disciplinary content, and pedagogical content knowledge. Second, LLM-supported, task-based learning shows promise as a personalized approach for developing formative assessment and lesson-planning practices in preservice teacher education.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research
- Vol. 7 (1)
Open AccessCollaboration with ChatGPT: preservice elementary teachers analyzing and interpreting student responses
This study investigated how Preservice Elementary Teachers (PETs) collaborated with ChatGPT on Analyzing and Interpreting Student Responses (AISR) tasks. These tasks required PETs to analyze and interpret K–12 students’ responses to items targeting counterintuitive scientific mechanisms. This study yielded three findings. First, as PETs gained experience, they developed more positive views of ChatGPT as a pedagogical tool. Second, PETs employed prompt-engineering strategies in three categories, including contextualization, iteration, and decomposition. Third, based on PETs’ task responses, we developed an AISR proficiency model to evaluate three key dimensions—understanding of disciplinary knowledge, understanding of student ideas, and recognizing the value of students’ intuitive ideas. Analyses of PETs’ task responses and their exchanges with ChatGPT showed the following: for understanding of disciplinary knowledge, PETs often struggled to make sense of ChatGPT’s lengthy outputs, which obscured the central scientific idea with extraneous details; for understanding of student ideas, both PETs and ChatGPT tended to adopt an evaluative orientation, classifying student responses by their degree of correctness and completeness; for recognizing the value of students’ intuitive ideas, designing instruction that productively uses these ideas remained challenging for both PETs and ChatGPT. This study’s implications for teacher education are twofold. First, PETs’ effective use of ChatGPT depends on their knowledge of Large Language Models (LLMs), disciplinary content, and pedagogical content knowledge. Second, LLM-supported, task-based learning shows promise as a personalized approach for developing formative assessment and lesson-planning practices in preservice teacher education.
- 10 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 22 (8) , 1885
Correction to: Systematic Validation in Science Learning Progression Research
- 10 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 22 (8) , 1885
Correction to: Systematic Validation in Science Learning Progression Research
- 30 March 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Diaspora, Indigenous, and Minority Education
- Vol. 18 (3) , 160-181
Cultural validity: Promoting cultural responsiveness in classroom assessment
Drawing on a scoping-review methodology, this study aimed to map extant literature to conceptualize cultural validity in assessment. Three themes emerged from this review: (a) conceptualization of cultural validity, (b) promoting cultural validity in assessment, and (c) challenges to cultural validity in assessment. The review showed that culturally valid assessment ensures that assessment instruments and practices, assessment decision-making processes, and use of assessment scores in instructional and eligibility decisions are culturally responsive. Cultural validity should be considered as a core component of validity issues in the initial assessment-development process. To promote cultural validity in assessment, teachers/assessment developers should (a) develop awareness of cultural diversities, (b) leverage students’ everyday-life experiences, (c) allow students’ agency in assessment, (d) use collaborative-/participatory-assessment design, and (e) pay critical attention to language use. Standardization, lack of awareness of available research, paucity of resources on culturally responsive assessment practices, and limited professional-development-training opportunities on culturally responsive assessment were found to be the major threats to implementation of culturally responsive assessment practices. This review provides a foundation for better supporting teachers and assessment developers to effectively implement and engage in culturally responsive assessment.
- 30 March 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Diaspora, Indigenous, and Minority Education
- Vol. 18 (3) , 160-181
Cultural validity: Promoting cultural responsiveness in classroom assessment
Drawing on a scoping-review methodology, this study aimed to map extant literature to conceptualize cultural validity in assessment. Three themes emerged from this review: (a) conceptualization of cultural validity, (b) promoting cultural validity in assessment, and (c) challenges to cultural validity in assessment. The review showed that culturally valid assessment ensures that assessment instruments and practices, assessment decision-making processes, and use of assessment scores in instructional and eligibility decisions are culturally responsive. Cultural validity should be considered as a core component of validity issues in the initial assessment-development process. To promote cultural validity in assessment, teachers/assessment developers should (a) develop awareness of cultural diversities, (b) leverage students’ everyday-life experiences, (c) allow students’ agency in assessment, (d) use collaborative-/participatory-assessment design, and (e) pay critical attention to language use. Standardization, lack of awareness of available research, paucity of resources on culturally responsive assessment practices, and limited professional-development-training opportunities on culturally responsive assessment were found to be the major threats to implementation of culturally responsive assessment practices. This review provides a foundation for better supporting teachers and assessment developers to effectively implement and engage in culturally responsive assessment.
- 10 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 22 (1) , 189-209
Systematic Validation in Science Learning Progression Research
- 10 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 22 (1) , 189-209
Systematic Validation in Science Learning Progression Research
- 9 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Science Teacher Education
- Vol. 33 (8) , 910-937
Elementary Preservice Teachers’ Perceptions of Assessment Tasks that Measure Content Knowledge for Teaching about Matter
Developing knowledge about science instruction is critical for preservice teachers. This study explores how 79 elementary preservice teachers perceive the relevance and importance of assessment task scenarios designed to elicit information about content knowledge for teaching (CKT) about matter and its interactions—a foundational topic for teaching physical science. Participants completed practice-based assessment tasks that described teaching scenarios about elementary science teaching and that addressed five matter topics: properties of matter, changes in matter, the model of matter, materials, and conservation of matter. We aimed to explore how relevant preservice teachers felt these task scenarios were to their teaching experience and how important knowing how to answer these tasks was for the work of elementary teachers. Findings suggest that preservice teachers tended to recognize the centrality of these task scenarios for the work typically done in elementary classrooms, even if they do not report having firsthand experience with the content and practices represented in the scenarios. Moreover, participants tended to provide a general rationale about why these scenarios were important for the work of teaching science, but a limited number of responses made explicit connections between a task scenario and the specific instructional practice related to elementary teachers’ work. This study poses implications for the use of CKT tasks in elementary education programs.
- 9 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Science Teacher Education
- Vol. 33 (8) , 910-937
Elementary Preservice Teachers’ Perceptions of Assessment Tasks that Measure Content Knowledge for Teaching about Matter
Developing knowledge about science instruction is critical for preservice teachers. This study explores how 79 elementary preservice teachers perceive the relevance and importance of assessment task scenarios designed to elicit information about content knowledge for teaching (CKT) about matter and its interactions—a foundational topic for teaching physical science. Participants completed practice-based assessment tasks that described teaching scenarios about elementary science teaching and that addressed five matter topics: properties of matter, changes in matter, the model of matter, materials, and conservation of matter. We aimed to explore how relevant preservice teachers felt these task scenarios were to their teaching experience and how important knowing how to answer these tasks was for the work of elementary teachers. Findings suggest that preservice teachers tended to recognize the centrality of these task scenarios for the work typically done in elementary classrooms, even if they do not report having firsthand experience with the content and practices represented in the scenarios. Moreover, participants tended to provide a general rationale about why these scenarios were important for the work of teaching science, but a limited number of responses made explicit connections between a task scenario and the specific instructional practice related to elementary teachers’ work. This study poses implications for the use of CKT tasks in elementary education programs.
- 1 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 110
Formative assessment practice progressions for teacher preparation: A framework and illustrative case
- 1 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Teaching and Teacher Education
- Vol. 110
Formative assessment practice progressions for teacher preparation: A framework and illustrative case
- 13 April 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 41 (1) , 306-325
New aspects of working with scientific data: a study with practicing scientists and science teachers
Background: New technology and increased collaboration have revolutionized how scientists work with data. This creates a need to identify new aspects of working with scientific data that are important for K-12 students to learn. Purpose: To address this need, we conducted a study with practicing scientists and K-12 science teachers. The purpose of the study is to identify new aspects of working with scientific data and the strategies involved in those aspects, which are potentially important for students to learn. The research questions are: (1) How do scientists work with data in their scientific inquiry? (2) What strategies used by scientists to work with data do not commonly appear in the science teachers’ class? Sample: In the study, 15 practicing scientists and 11 science teachers each participated in a one-on-one interview; and 40 practicing scientists and 175 science teachers each completed a survey. Design and methods: We first developed an initial model of working with data based on relevant literature. Next, we conducted a two-stage sequential study. At the exploration stage, we interviewed 15 practicing scientists and 11 science teachers and used the interview data to revise the initial model. At the investigation stage, we conducted surveys with 40 practicing scientists and 175 science teachers. Based on the survey data, we revised and finalized the model. Results: The study generated an empirically grounded model that contains five aspects of working with scientific data: purposes of data analysis, planning data collection, organizing and reducing data, representing data, and interpreting analysis results. For each aspect, we identified the strategies used by scientists and investigated whether and how those strategies were taught in science classrooms. Conclusion: The results provide a foundation for future research on whether and how the new aspects of working with data can be taught in K-12 science classrooms.
- 13 April 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research in Science & Technological Education
- Vol. 41 (1) , 306-325
New aspects of working with scientific data: a study with practicing scientists and science teachers
Background: New technology and increased collaboration have revolutionized how scientists work with data. This creates a need to identify new aspects of working with scientific data that are important for K-12 students to learn. Purpose: To address this need, we conducted a study with practicing scientists and K-12 science teachers. The purpose of the study is to identify new aspects of working with scientific data and the strategies involved in those aspects, which are potentially important for students to learn. The research questions are: (1) How do scientists work with data in their scientific inquiry? (2) What strategies used by scientists to work with data do not commonly appear in the science teachers’ class? Sample: In the study, 15 practicing scientists and 11 science teachers each participated in a one-on-one interview; and 40 practicing scientists and 175 science teachers each completed a survey. Design and methods: We first developed an initial model of working with data based on relevant literature. Next, we conducted a two-stage sequential study. At the exploration stage, we interviewed 15 practicing scientists and 11 science teachers and used the interview data to revise the initial model. At the investigation stage, we conducted surveys with 40 practicing scientists and 175 science teachers. Based on the survey data, we revised and finalized the model. Results: The study generated an empirically grounded model that contains five aspects of working with scientific data: purposes of data analysis, planning data collection, organizing and reducing data, representing data, and interpreting analysis results. For each aspect, we identified the strategies used by scientists and investigated whether and how those strategies were taught in science classrooms. Conclusion: The results provide a foundation for future research on whether and how the new aspects of working with data can be taught in K-12 science classrooms.
- 7 July 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Science Teacher Education
- Vol. 31 (7) , 780-801
The Re-Novicing of Elementary Teachers in Science? Grade Level Reassignment and Teacher PCK
There is growing recognition of the prevalence of “within school churn”, a phenomenon in which teachers remain within a school but are assigned a new grade level or course. In this study we examine the consequences of within-school churn for the pedagogical content knowledge of elementary teacher participants in an NSF-funded science PD program. We argue grade-level reassignment is akin to out-of-field science teaching for elementary teachers, as they encounter a new set of grade-specific standards, new subject matter topics, and new curricula. We observed that elementary teachers can be “re-noviced” when assigned to a new grade level, in that they may lack content knowledge and/or pedagogical content knowledge for teaching their new science topics. Nonetheless, we argue there are important similarities between experienced and reassigned teachers that merit consideration of their unique professional learning needs in comparison to novice teachers.
- 7 July 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Science Teacher Education
- Vol. 31 (7) , 780-801
The Re-Novicing of Elementary Teachers in Science? Grade Level Reassignment and Teacher PCK
There is growing recognition of the prevalence of “within school churn”, a phenomenon in which teachers remain within a school but are assigned a new grade level or course. In this study we examine the consequences of within-school churn for the pedagogical content knowledge of elementary teacher participants in an NSF-funded science PD program. We argue grade-level reassignment is akin to out-of-field science teaching for elementary teachers, as they encounter a new set of grade-specific standards, new subject matter topics, and new curricula. We observed that elementary teachers can be “re-noviced” when assigned to a new grade level, in that they may lack content knowledge and/or pedagogical content knowledge for teaching their new science topics. Nonetheless, we argue there are important similarities between experienced and reassigned teachers that merit consideration of their unique professional learning needs in comparison to novice teachers.
- 27 November 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Science & Education
- Vol. 28 (9-10) , 1181-1208
A Hypothetical Learning Progression for Quantifying Phenomena in Science
- 27 November 2019
- Published by Springer Nature in Science & Education
- Vol. 28 (9-10) , 1181-1208
A Hypothetical Learning Progression for Quantifying Phenomena in Science