Mohamed Salum Msoroka
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Mohamed Salum Msoroka has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Diana Amundsen
University of Waikato, New Zealand
3 shared publications - Cosmas Mnyanyi
The Open University of Tanzania
2 shared publications - Marystella Baynit
The Open University of Tanzania
2 shared publications Brian Findsen
Professor, University of Waikato
1 shared publication- Charles Michael Sumuni
The Open University of Tanzania
1 shared publication - Faith Matowo
Faculty of Education, The Open University of Tanzania, Dodoma, Tanzania
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in the Education of Adults
- p. 1-20
Digital literacy among adults: a bibliometric analysis
1. Originally, literacy is associated with the 3Rs (reading, writing, and numeracy). Digital literacy, on the other hand, is often presented as a contemporary extension of traditional literacy; how...
- 17 October 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in the Education of Adults
- p. 1-20
Digital literacy among adults: a bibliometric analysis
1. Originally, literacy is associated with the 3Rs (reading, writing, and numeracy). Digital literacy, on the other hand, is often presented as a contemporary extension of traditional literacy; how...
- Open Access
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Academy of Cognitive and Natural Sciences in Educational Technology Quarterly
- Vol. 2026 (2) , 129-151
Barriers to digital inclusion in Africa: a systematic review
This study employed a systematic review to determine the barriers to digital inclusion in Africa. A total of 522 documents published between 2012 and 2024 were analysed. The PRISMA flow guidelines explained the inclusion and exclusion criteria for the journal articles. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) was used to assess the methodological quality of each selected article. Data were analysed using thematic analysis, which allowed for the systematic identification and interpretation of recurring themes related to digital inclusion in Africa. The analysis revealed eight key barriers to digital inclusion: digital illiteracy, inadequate ICT infrastructure, high costs and limited accessibility, poor Internet connectivity, rural-urban disparities, cybercrime, computer phobia, and language and literacy barriers. The study recommends that policies to tackle digital exclusion in Africa must be holistic. In particular, investment in digital infrastructures and lower ICT service costs may alleviate issues that relate to access and connectivity; improved programmes around the building of digital skills may mitigate the impact of digital illiteracy and computer anxiety; the development of rural areas can reduce geographical inequalities; and cybersecurity policies could generate higher levels of confidence and greater security among users. Additionally, local-language digital content can be supported to circumvent linguistic and literacy barriers.
- 20 June 2026
- Published by Academy of Cognitive and Natural Sciences in Educational Technology Quarterly
- Vol. 2026 (2) , 129-151
Open AccessBarriers to digital inclusion in Africa: a systematic review
This study employed a systematic review to determine the barriers to digital inclusion in Africa. A total of 522 documents published between 2012 and 2024 were analysed. The PRISMA flow guidelines explained the inclusion and exclusion criteria for the journal articles. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) was used to assess the methodological quality of each selected article. Data were analysed using thematic analysis, which allowed for the systematic identification and interpretation of recurring themes related to digital inclusion in Africa. The analysis revealed eight key barriers to digital inclusion: digital illiteracy, inadequate ICT infrastructure, high costs and limited accessibility, poor Internet connectivity, rural-urban disparities, cybercrime, computer phobia, and language and literacy barriers. The study recommends that policies to tackle digital exclusion in Africa must be holistic. In particular, investment in digital infrastructures and lower ICT service costs may alleviate issues that relate to access and connectivity; improved programmes around the building of digital skills may mitigate the impact of digital illiteracy and computer anxiety; the development of rural areas can reduce geographical inequalities; and cybersecurity policies could generate higher levels of confidence and greater security among users. Additionally, local-language digital content can be supported to circumvent linguistic and literacy barriers.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (2) , 144-156
Possible Measures to Improve the Performance of the Tanzania Teachers' Union (TTU) and Their Influence on Teachers' Job Satisfaction in Tanzania
This study is about the possible measures to improve the performance of the Tanzania Teachers' Union (TTU) on teachers' job satisfaction in Tanzania. This study was conducted in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts, Mwanza, Tanzania. The objective of this study was to investigate the possible measures to improve the performance of TTU in ensuring teachers' job satisfaction. The study was guided by Webb's theory of trade unions. The study employed a pragmatic research paradigm, mixed-methods research approach, and explanatory sequential design. The targeted population of the study was 2672 teachers from public secondary schools in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts who are TTU members and 4TTU district leaders in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. This population was represented by a sample of 348 teachers and four TTU district leaders from Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. Simple random sampling was used to obtain 348 teachers from 58 public secondary schools in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. Each school served 6 teachers who are TTU members while the 4TTU district leaders were obtained through purposive sampling. Quantitative data were collected through descriptive survey in which closed ended questionnaire were administered to teacher respondents. While qualitative data were collected through individual interviews and documentary review. Individual interviews were administered to 4 TTU district leaders. Furthermore, quantitative data were analysed by using descriptive analysis while qualitative data employed thematic analysis. Findings of the study revealed that there is low performance of TTU on ensuring teachers' job satisfaction in public secondary schools. There is poor working environment, low involvement of teachers' in decision making, low salaries, low teachers' promotion, delayed allowances and low teachers' professional development. Therefore, to improve the performance of TTU, it was recommended that TTU should be reformed and made one of the education policy-making organ. Reformation of TTU will make it independent and more powerful in fighting for teachers' rights. Also, making TTU one of the education policy making organ will facilitate implementation of the education policies among teachers.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (2) , 144-156
Open AccessPossible Measures to Improve the Performance of the Tanzania Teachers' Union (TTU) and Their Influence on Teachers' Job Satisfaction in Tanzania
This study is about the possible measures to improve the performance of the Tanzania Teachers' Union (TTU) on teachers' job satisfaction in Tanzania. This study was conducted in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts, Mwanza, Tanzania. The objective of this study was to investigate the possible measures to improve the performance of TTU in ensuring teachers' job satisfaction. The study was guided by Webb's theory of trade unions. The study employed a pragmatic research paradigm, mixed-methods research approach, and explanatory sequential design. The targeted population of the study was 2672 teachers from public secondary schools in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts who are TTU members and 4TTU district leaders in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. This population was represented by a sample of 348 teachers and four TTU district leaders from Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. Simple random sampling was used to obtain 348 teachers from 58 public secondary schools in Ilemela and Nyamagana districts. Each school served 6 teachers who are TTU members while the 4TTU district leaders were obtained through purposive sampling. Quantitative data were collected through descriptive survey in which closed ended questionnaire were administered to teacher respondents. While qualitative data were collected through individual interviews and documentary review. Individual interviews were administered to 4 TTU district leaders. Furthermore, quantitative data were analysed by using descriptive analysis while qualitative data employed thematic analysis. Findings of the study revealed that there is low performance of TTU on ensuring teachers' job satisfaction in public secondary schools. There is poor working environment, low involvement of teachers' in decision making, low salaries, low teachers' promotion, delayed allowances and low teachers' professional development. Therefore, to improve the performance of TTU, it was recommended that TTU should be reformed and made one of the education policy-making organ. Reformation of TTU will make it independent and more powerful in fighting for teachers' rights. Also, making TTU one of the education policy making organ will facilitate implementation of the education policies among teachers.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (2) , 96-112
Digital Learning in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Insights from Selected Higher Learning Institutions in Tanzania
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies is reshaping education globally, with it is significant implications on teaching, learning and administrative processes in higher learning institutions. The higher learning institutions in Tanzania are increasingly adopting digital learning solutions powered by AI to address challenges such as limited teaching resources, less interactive delivery approaches, lengthy assessment approaches and the need for personalized education. This study explores the integration of AI in digital learning within the selected Tanzanian higher learning institutions (HLIs), highlighting its opportunities, challenges, and impact on educational outcomes. Although existing research has produced several contributions on both topics, the knowledge generated in the field appears fragmented and the findings are sometimes ambiguous. This study aims to consolidate the state of art of scholarly research published over the past 36 years at the intersection of the AI tools in Tanzania higher Learning Institutions. The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) was employed to guide this study. The model explains how perceived usefulness and ease of use influence the adoption of technology. To this aim, we carried out a systematic literature review by retrieving a set of 117 papers which was later limited to time, English language and key words as inclusion criteria only 45 papers were utilized and complemented with key informant interviews.The reviewed documents were strategically selected from the Scopus and web of science scholarly journals. The data were extracted and synthesised into sub themes. The findings reveal that a proportion of HLIs instructors are adopting AI tools in their teaching and learning activities. The common AI-driven tools employed by instructors include; ChatGPT, Grammarly, intelligent tutoring systems, automated grading platforms, and data analytics. It has been further noted that the AI tools have significantly impact in teaching and learning by providing personalized feedback, improving learning resources accessibility and in turn improving students’ academic performance. However, the study identifies several challenges, including inadequate infrastructure, high implementation costs and limited technical expertise. There is also concern over data privacy, ethical considerations, and the potential for reduced human interaction in education. This paper concludes that while AI integration in Tanzanian higher education is in its early stages, it offers immense opportunities for improving educational outcomes and institutional efficiency. Recommendations are provided to address challenges, emphasizing policy development, capacity building and increased investment in AI infrastructure to enhance effective educational outcomes.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (2) , 96-112
Open AccessDigital Learning in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Insights from Selected Higher Learning Institutions in Tanzania
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies is reshaping education globally, with it is significant implications on teaching, learning and administrative processes in higher learning institutions. The higher learning institutions in Tanzania are increasingly adopting digital learning solutions powered by AI to address challenges such as limited teaching resources, less interactive delivery approaches, lengthy assessment approaches and the need for personalized education. This study explores the integration of AI in digital learning within the selected Tanzanian higher learning institutions (HLIs), highlighting its opportunities, challenges, and impact on educational outcomes. Although existing research has produced several contributions on both topics, the knowledge generated in the field appears fragmented and the findings are sometimes ambiguous. This study aims to consolidate the state of art of scholarly research published over the past 36 years at the intersection of the AI tools in Tanzania higher Learning Institutions. The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) was employed to guide this study. The model explains how perceived usefulness and ease of use influence the adoption of technology. To this aim, we carried out a systematic literature review by retrieving a set of 117 papers which was later limited to time, English language and key words as inclusion criteria only 45 papers were utilized and complemented with key informant interviews.The reviewed documents were strategically selected from the Scopus and web of science scholarly journals. The data were extracted and synthesised into sub themes. The findings reveal that a proportion of HLIs instructors are adopting AI tools in their teaching and learning activities. The common AI-driven tools employed by instructors include; ChatGPT, Grammarly, intelligent tutoring systems, automated grading platforms, and data analytics. It has been further noted that the AI tools have significantly impact in teaching and learning by providing personalized feedback, improving learning resources accessibility and in turn improving students’ academic performance. However, the study identifies several challenges, including inadequate infrastructure, high implementation costs and limited technical expertise. There is also concern over data privacy, ethical considerations, and the potential for reduced human interaction in education. This paper concludes that while AI integration in Tanzanian higher education is in its early stages, it offers immense opportunities for improving educational outcomes and institutional efficiency. Recommendations are provided to address challenges, emphasizing policy development, capacity building and increased investment in AI infrastructure to enhance effective educational outcomes.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (1) , 148-159
The Influence of Instructors Employed Digital Pedagogies on Students’ Learning Outcomes: The Case of Selected Higher Learning Institutions in Tanzania
Higher learning institutions in Tanzania is among the sectors that has started capitalizing on digital technology in the course of delivering their training programs. In coping with the digital technology dynamics instructors are at the centres of realizing the change and harnessing its potentials in the learning process. The instructors’ employed digital pedagogy is of great concern in the process of achieving the desired students learning outcomes. This research article therefore, assessed the influence of instructors’ digital pedagogies on students learning outcomes among the selected higher learning institutions in Tanzania. The study is guided by two theoretical models which include Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) as developed and Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK).The study employed cross- sectional design where data were collected once from two different regions. 583 academic staff population with designation starting from tutorial assistant to full professor who are currently engaging in teaching and research activities in the were identified from two selected higher learning institutions in Tanzania. A sample of 237 instructors were selected randomly for this study. Self-administered questionnaire, key informants interview and focus group discussion were employed as data collection tools. The descriptive and structural equation model (SEM) were performed to analyse the data. The findings indicate statistically positive significant influence’ of digital pedagogy on students learning outcomes. Specifically the path model analysis indicates that the employment of digital pedagogy contributed the students learning outcomes by 36% s. It is concluded that the digital pedagogy employed by instructors improves students learning outcomes. No significant differences in terms of instructors’ digital pedagogy were noticed across institutions and gender and age. However, the instructors’ use of some specific digital pedagogy recommended for further improvement as it has little contribution to students learning outcomes.
- 8 January 2025
- Published by AJER Publishing in African Quarterly Social Science Review
- Vol. 2 (1) , 148-159
Open AccessThe Influence of Instructors Employed Digital Pedagogies on Students’ Learning Outcomes: The Case of Selected Higher Learning Institutions in Tanzania
Higher learning institutions in Tanzania is among the sectors that has started capitalizing on digital technology in the course of delivering their training programs. In coping with the digital technology dynamics instructors are at the centres of realizing the change and harnessing its potentials in the learning process. The instructors’ employed digital pedagogy is of great concern in the process of achieving the desired students learning outcomes. This research article therefore, assessed the influence of instructors’ digital pedagogies on students learning outcomes among the selected higher learning institutions in Tanzania. The study is guided by two theoretical models which include Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) as developed and Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK).The study employed cross- sectional design where data were collected once from two different regions. 583 academic staff population with designation starting from tutorial assistant to full professor who are currently engaging in teaching and research activities in the were identified from two selected higher learning institutions in Tanzania. A sample of 237 instructors were selected randomly for this study. Self-administered questionnaire, key informants interview and focus group discussion were employed as data collection tools. The descriptive and structural equation model (SEM) were performed to analyse the data. The findings indicate statistically positive significant influence’ of digital pedagogy on students learning outcomes. Specifically the path model analysis indicates that the employment of digital pedagogy contributed the students learning outcomes by 36% s. It is concluded that the digital pedagogy employed by instructors improves students learning outcomes. No significant differences in terms of instructors’ digital pedagogy were noticed across institutions and gender and age. However, the instructors’ use of some specific digital pedagogy recommended for further improvement as it has little contribution to students learning outcomes.
- Open Access
- 6 September 2024
- Published by Science Publishing Group in Education Journal
- Vol. 13 (5) , 311-317
Examining Stakeholders’ Prospects on the Implementation of Equity-Based Strategies in Public Secondary Schools in Tanzania
The desire to address equity issues in the education sector is a shared philosophy by a number of countries, including Tanzania. As a result, Tanzania as a country is striving to address the issue of equity in its education system through the implementation of various equity strategies. This paper therefore sought to examine stakeholders’ prospects on the implementation of equity-based strategies in public secondary schools in Tanzania. Precisely, the interest of the researchers was to explore what was being done in the selected public secondary schools to implement equity-based strategies. A mixed-methods research approach combining both qualitative and quantitative analysis approaches was employed. The study also used a multiple case study design, which allowed the selection of two case study areas i.e. Dodoma City representing the urban setting, and Kondoa district representing the rural setting. A total of One Hundred Forty-Four (144) participants from seven (7) public secondary schools were involved in the study. Data were collected through interviews and questionnaires. Quantitative data were analyzed through descriptive analysis and presented in numerical and graphical form while qualitative data were analyzed through inductive content analysis and presented in thematic form and narratives. Study findings revealed that the selected study schools were indeed implementing a number of activities towards the realization of equity and thus the prospects for implementing equity based strategies in these schools was found to be positive. For instance, activities such as the use of common and understandable language i.e., English and Kiswahili; ensuring that schools have qualified teaching staff, ensuring a supportive learning environment as well as strengthening and supporting school leadership were being implemented. Nevertheless, the study also noted that the implementation of some key factors critical for realization of equity in the schools such as incentive provision to teachers, use of appropriate technology and use of different learning styles was still weak and thus needed improvement.
- 6 September 2024
- Published by Science Publishing Group in Education Journal
- Vol. 13 (5) , 311-317
Open AccessExamining Stakeholders’ Prospects on the Implementation of Equity-Based Strategies in Public Secondary Schools in Tanzania
The desire to address equity issues in the education sector is a shared philosophy by a number of countries, including Tanzania. As a result, Tanzania as a country is striving to address the issue of equity in its education system through the implementation of various equity strategies. This paper therefore sought to examine stakeholders’ prospects on the implementation of equity-based strategies in public secondary schools in Tanzania. Precisely, the interest of the researchers was to explore what was being done in the selected public secondary schools to implement equity-based strategies. A mixed-methods research approach combining both qualitative and quantitative analysis approaches was employed. The study also used a multiple case study design, which allowed the selection of two case study areas i.e. Dodoma City representing the urban setting, and Kondoa district representing the rural setting. A total of One Hundred Forty-Four (144) participants from seven (7) public secondary schools were involved in the study. Data were collected through interviews and questionnaires. Quantitative data were analyzed through descriptive analysis and presented in numerical and graphical form while qualitative data were analyzed through inductive content analysis and presented in thematic form and narratives. Study findings revealed that the selected study schools were indeed implementing a number of activities towards the realization of equity and thus the prospects for implementing equity based strategies in these schools was found to be positive. For instance, activities such as the use of common and understandable language i.e., English and Kiswahili; ensuring that schools have qualified teaching staff, ensuring a supportive learning environment as well as strengthening and supporting school leadership were being implemented. Nevertheless, the study also noted that the implementation of some key factors critical for realization of equity in the schools such as incentive provision to teachers, use of appropriate technology and use of different learning styles was still weak and thus needed improvement.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2023
- Published by The Open University of Tanzania in JOURNAL OF ISSUES AND PRACTICE IN EDUCATION
- Vol. 14 (2)
The Influence of Learning Environment in the Mastering of 3rs in Public Primary Schools in Nyang’hwale District – Tanzania
This study investigated the influence of the learning environment in the mastering 3Rs in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District, Tanzania. The study was guided by three objectives namely: factors that lead to pupils’ failure to master 3Rs from standard one up to standard three in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District, Tanzania, how school environment supports pupils to master 3Rs in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District. The other objective was to find out the solutions on how we can improve the mastering of the 3Rs to secondary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. The study used a mixed research approach where both qualitative and quantitative approaches approach were applied. The sample size of the study was 106 respondents, who were obtained through percentages. The participants were selected using simple random sampling stratified sampling and purposive sampling while data of the study were collected through questionnaires and interview guides. Quantitative data were coded through Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 20 edition and were analysed by thematic analysis technique. On their part, qualitative data were analysed through content after being grouped. The analysed data were presented in charts, graphs, Tables and explanations. The findings of the study show that there was poor mastery of the 3Rs among primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. Most of the primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District were found to have the problem of poor mastering of the 3Rs. In addition, the findings indicate that the teaching and learning environment had a great influence on the mastering of the 3Rs to primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. The study recommends that Teachers should implement strategic teaching methodologies and apply current teaching and learning materials.
- 14 May 2023
- Published by The Open University of Tanzania in JOURNAL OF ISSUES AND PRACTICE IN EDUCATION
- Vol. 14 (2)
Open AccessThe Influence of Learning Environment in the Mastering of 3rs in Public Primary Schools in Nyang’hwale District – Tanzania
This study investigated the influence of the learning environment in the mastering 3Rs in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District, Tanzania. The study was guided by three objectives namely: factors that lead to pupils’ failure to master 3Rs from standard one up to standard three in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District, Tanzania, how school environment supports pupils to master 3Rs in public primary schools in Nyang’hwale District. The other objective was to find out the solutions on how we can improve the mastering of the 3Rs to secondary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. The study used a mixed research approach where both qualitative and quantitative approaches approach were applied. The sample size of the study was 106 respondents, who were obtained through percentages. The participants were selected using simple random sampling stratified sampling and purposive sampling while data of the study were collected through questionnaires and interview guides. Quantitative data were coded through Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 20 edition and were analysed by thematic analysis technique. On their part, qualitative data were analysed through content after being grouped. The analysed data were presented in charts, graphs, Tables and explanations. The findings of the study show that there was poor mastery of the 3Rs among primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. Most of the primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District were found to have the problem of poor mastering of the 3Rs. In addition, the findings indicate that the teaching and learning environment had a great influence on the mastering of the 3Rs to primary school pupils in Nyang’hwale District. The study recommends that Teachers should implement strategic teaching methodologies and apply current teaching and learning materials.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 428-441
Prison Education for Industrialisation
This qualitative study explores how prison education can provide necessary work skills to prisoners to enable them to become employable, and hence reduce recidivism rates. The chapter addresses two research questions: What is the link between prison education and industrialisation? and How relevant is prison education in reducing recidivism among the Tanzanian prisoners? The data were collected through documentary analysis. The findings suggest that there is a close relationship between prison education and industrialization. The chapter also suggests that prison education is a relevant approach in reducing recidivism rates among prisoners. This chapter argues that providing prisoners with relevant educational programmes might equip them with proper skills to become productive in society, and hence become employable after their release. Thus, giving prisoners a chance to education is like killing two birds with a single stone – developing a skilled labour force for industrial development and reducing recidivism rates.
- 1 January 2021
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 428-441
Prison Education for Industrialisation
This qualitative study explores how prison education can provide necessary work skills to prisoners to enable them to become employable, and hence reduce recidivism rates. The chapter addresses two research questions: What is the link between prison education and industrialisation? and How relevant is prison education in reducing recidivism among the Tanzanian prisoners? The data were collected through documentary analysis. The findings suggest that there is a close relationship between prison education and industrialization. The chapter also suggests that prison education is a relevant approach in reducing recidivism rates among prisoners. This chapter argues that providing prisoners with relevant educational programmes might equip them with proper skills to become productive in society, and hence become employable after their release. Thus, giving prisoners a chance to education is like killing two birds with a single stone – developing a skilled labour force for industrial development and reducing recidivism rates.
- 21 August 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Review
- Vol. 73 (5) , 563-579
Responsive Ethics: navigating the fluid research space between HREC ethics, researcher ethics and participant ethics
Challenges of applying universal ethics principles in research practice are widely discussed among educational researchers. Scholars have suggested different approaches to improve research practices, including acknowledging cultural relativism and practicing situated ethics. This article argues that more meaningful research processes and outcomes may be achieved by responding to three similar, yet potentially different “sets” of ethical principles: a) institutions’ (universal) research ethics; b) participants’ ethics and; c) researchers’ personal ethics. We discuss and present our exploration of these three aspects through an approach which enables more flexibility for education researchers in practice. Responsive Ethics embraces the interplay of these three aspects. We suggest that the “research ethics space” generated from response to and negotiation among these three aspects has potential for more meaningful and transparent education research outcomes. By establishing a comfortable middle ground between sometimes extreme positions of the ethical principles of the participants, researcher, and the institution (universal research ethics), Responsive Ethics contributes to discussions on improving ethical research practices in education contexts.
- 21 August 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Review
- Vol. 73 (5) , 563-579
Responsive Ethics: navigating the fluid research space between HREC ethics, researcher ethics and participant ethics
Challenges of applying universal ethics principles in research practice are widely discussed among educational researchers. Scholars have suggested different approaches to improve research practices, including acknowledging cultural relativism and practicing situated ethics. This article argues that more meaningful research processes and outcomes may be achieved by responding to three similar, yet potentially different “sets” of ethical principles: a) institutions’ (universal) research ethics; b) participants’ ethics and; c) researchers’ personal ethics. We discuss and present our exploration of these three aspects through an approach which enables more flexibility for education researchers in practice. Responsive Ethics embraces the interplay of these three aspects. We suggest that the “research ethics space” generated from response to and negotiation among these three aspects has potential for more meaningful and transparent education research outcomes. By establishing a comfortable middle ground between sometimes extreme positions of the ethical principles of the participants, researcher, and the institution (universal research ethics), Responsive Ethics contributes to discussions on improving ethical research practices in education contexts.
- Open Access
- 13 December 2017
- Published by University of Waikato
- Vol. 22 (4)
“It’s a case of access.” The problematics of accessing research participants
The problematics of accessing research participants have been largely under-stated in the education research literature. This article discusses two case studies which illustrate the complexity of the process of access. This is complexity beyond ethical consent; it is the complexity of gaining access to research sites and participants and of ongoing negotiation concerning aspects of access, especially when the stakes are high for participants. In this article we first set out what is already known in the literature about challenges and strategies of access. Next, we evaluate our own experiences of access with others. Our analysis reveals key findings: a) the relevance of insider/outsider status; b) the need to engage in repeated negotiations to obtain the agreement and consent of gatekeepers; c) the value of identifying kaiārahi (guides) and building relationships; d) the importance of understanding organisational culture, power dynamics of relationships and of knowledge production; and e) the significance of operating in a transparent manner around researcher identity and the nature of the specific study. A research plan may be approved as ethical but may not prove to be practical when the researcher tries to enact it, thus necessitating modification. The challenge becomes finding a practice that is ethical for a particular group and context. Lastly, we propose that education researchers who have negotiated the power dynamics to build relationships among kaiārahi, gatekeepers and participants need to communicate their knowledge and experiences of accessing research participants with other researchers.
- 13 December 2017
- Published by University of Waikato
- Vol. 22 (4)
Open Access“It’s a case of access.” The problematics of accessing research participants
The problematics of accessing research participants have been largely under-stated in the education research literature. This article discusses two case studies which illustrate the complexity of the process of access. This is complexity beyond ethical consent; it is the complexity of gaining access to research sites and participants and of ongoing negotiation concerning aspects of access, especially when the stakes are high for participants. In this article we first set out what is already known in the literature about challenges and strategies of access. Next, we evaluate our own experiences of access with others. Our analysis reveals key findings: a) the relevance of insider/outsider status; b) the need to engage in repeated negotiations to obtain the agreement and consent of gatekeepers; c) the value of identifying kaiārahi (guides) and building relationships; d) the importance of understanding organisational culture, power dynamics of relationships and of knowledge production; and e) the significance of operating in a transparent manner around researcher identity and the nature of the specific study. A research plan may be approved as ethical but may not prove to be practical when the researcher tries to enact it, thus necessitating modification. The challenge becomes finding a practice that is ethical for a particular group and context. Lastly, we propose that education researchers who have negotiated the power dynamics to build relationships among kaiārahi, gatekeepers and participants need to communicate their knowledge and experiences of accessing research participants with other researchers.