Shiloh Deitz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Shiloh Deitz has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Victoria Fast
University of Calgary
2 shared publications Amy Lobben
Department of Geography, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA
1 shared publicationArielle Alferez
Department of Geography, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA
1 shared publication- Katie Meehan
Department of Geography King's College London London UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes
- Vol. 70 (3)
Mapping the edges of inclusive cities and societies
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes
- Vol. 70 (3)
Mapping the edges of inclusive cities and societies
- Open Access
- 26 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Progress in Human Geography
- Vol. 50 (2) , 242-252
GIScience II: Disability GIS
This second progress report critically reviews the intersection of GIS and disability, tracing its evolution from a few isolated studies toward modest growth in recent scholarship. Through a contemporary literature analysis (N = 240) structured around four themes—wayfinding, spatial accessibility, cartography, and spatial epidemiology—we identify persistent conceptual and methodological gaps, including differing terminology and limited representation in leading journals. The advancement of disability GIS requires not a retrofit but a redesign that hinges upon explicitly integrating embodiment, participation, intersectionality, and meaningful engagement with disability studies.
- 26 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Progress in Human Geography
- Vol. 50 (2) , 242-252
Open AccessGIScience II: Disability GIS
This second progress report critically reviews the intersection of GIS and disability, tracing its evolution from a few isolated studies toward modest growth in recent scholarship. Through a contemporary literature analysis (N = 240) structured around four themes—wayfinding, spatial accessibility, cartography, and spatial epidemiology—we identify persistent conceptual and methodological gaps, including differing terminology and limited representation in leading journals. The advancement of disability GIS requires not a retrofit but a redesign that hinges upon explicitly integrating embodiment, participation, intersectionality, and meaningful engagement with disability studies.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes
- Vol. 69 (4)
A humble proposal for GeoAI: Epistemology, methodology, and relevance in curb ramp classification
This paper critically examines how data availability and algorithmic constraints reshape research design, relevance, and outcomes in GIScience. Through a case study of automated curb ramp detection in Seattle, Washington, I demonstrate how the limitations of data, tools, and computational frameworks frequently shape the ambitions of early‐stage geographic inquiry. While GeoAI and machine learning offer new possibilities for spatial analysis, they also embed assumptions, value hierarchies, and technical limitations that influence what questions can be asked and what answers can be obtained. Using a random forest model and open‐source LiDAR and imagery data, I show how data sparsity, class imbalance, and aspatial training techniques complicate both accuracy and utility. Drawing on visual methods and explainable AI, I interrogate how the algorithm “learned” patterns and where it failed, revealing that AI‐identified relevance often diverges from socially meaningful goals. I argue for a reflexive approach to GeoAI—one that embraces error, foregrounds relevance, and resists the allure of algorithmic objectivity. The paper ultimately calls for centering research relevance alongside reproducibility and replicability in spatial data science, advocating for humility in the face of technological complexity .
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes
- Vol. 69 (4)
A humble proposal for GeoAI: Epistemology, methodology, and relevance in curb ramp classification
This paper critically examines how data availability and algorithmic constraints reshape research design, relevance, and outcomes in GIScience. Through a case study of automated curb ramp detection in Seattle, Washington, I demonstrate how the limitations of data, tools, and computational frameworks frequently shape the ambitions of early‐stage geographic inquiry. While GeoAI and machine learning offer new possibilities for spatial analysis, they also embed assumptions, value hierarchies, and technical limitations that influence what questions can be asked and what answers can be obtained. Using a random forest model and open‐source LiDAR and imagery data, I show how data sparsity, class imbalance, and aspatial training techniques complicate both accuracy and utility. Drawing on visual methods and explainable AI, I interrogate how the algorithm “learned” patterns and where it failed, revealing that AI‐identified relevance often diverges from socially meaningful goals. I argue for a reflexive approach to GeoAI—one that embraces error, foregrounds relevance, and resists the allure of algorithmic objectivity. The paper ultimately calls for centering research relevance alongside reproducibility and replicability in spatial data science, advocating for humility in the face of technological complexity .
- Open Access
- 1 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 10 (2)
Outlier bias: AI classification of curb ramps, outliers, and context
Technologies in the smart city, such as autonomous vehicles and delivery robots, promise to increase the mobility and freedom of people with disabilities. These technologies have also failed to “see” or comprehend wheelchair riders, people walking with service animals, and people walking with bicycles—all outliers to machine learning models. Big data and algorithms have been amply critiqued for their biases—harmful and systematic errors—but the harms that arise from AI's inherent inability to handle nuance, context, and exception have been largely overlooked. In this paper, I run two machine learning models across nine cities in the United States to attempt to fill a gap in data about the location of curb ramps. I find that while curb ramp prediction models may achieve up to 88% accuracy, the rate of accuracy varied in context in ways both predictable and unpredictable. I look closely at cases of unpredictable error (outlier bias), by triangulating with aerial and street view imagery. The sampling of cases shows that while it may be possible to conjecture about patterns in these errors, there is nothing clearly systematic. While more data and bigger models might improve the accuracy somewhat, I propose that a bias toward outliers is something fundamental to machine learning models which gravitate to the mean and require unbiased and not missing data. I conclude by arguing that universal design or design for the outliers is imperative for justice in the smart city where algorithms and data are increasingly embedded as infrastructure.
- 1 July 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 10 (2)
Open AccessOutlier bias: AI classification of curb ramps, outliers, and context
Technologies in the smart city, such as autonomous vehicles and delivery robots, promise to increase the mobility and freedom of people with disabilities. These technologies have also failed to “see” or comprehend wheelchair riders, people walking with service animals, and people walking with bicycles—all outliers to machine learning models. Big data and algorithms have been amply critiqued for their biases—harmful and systematic errors—but the harms that arise from AI's inherent inability to handle nuance, context, and exception have been largely overlooked. In this paper, I run two machine learning models across nine cities in the United States to attempt to fill a gap in data about the location of curb ramps. I find that while curb ramp prediction models may achieve up to 88% accuracy, the rate of accuracy varied in context in ways both predictable and unpredictable. I look closely at cases of unpredictable error (outlier bias), by triangulating with aerial and street view imagery. The sampling of cases shows that while it may be possible to conjecture about patterns in these errors, there is nothing clearly systematic. While more data and bigger models might improve the accuracy somewhat, I propose that a bias toward outliers is something fundamental to machine learning models which gravitate to the mean and require unbiased and not missing data. I conclude by arguing that universal design or design for the outliers is imperative for justice in the smart city where algorithms and data are increasingly embedded as infrastructure.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 8 (2)
Squeaky wheels: Missing data, disability, and power in the smart city
Data about the accessibility of United States municipalities is infrastructure in the smart city. What is counted and how, reflects the sociotechnical imaginary (norms and values) of a time or place. In this paper we focus on features identified by people with disabilities as promoting or hindering safe pedestrian travel. We use a regionally stratified sample of 178 cities across the United States. The municipalities were scored on two factors: their open data practices (or lack thereof), and the degree to which they cataloged the environmental features that persons with disabilities deemed critical for safe movement through urban spaces. In contradiction to the dominating narrative of too much data and not enough analyses, we find that when it comes to data points that might be useful to persons with disabilities, data are lacking. This data gap has consequences both politically and materially—on one hand data could help enforce compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, on the other they would allow for safe route planning. We find that reading these data formats and collection patterns from the perspective of critical disability studies—particularly those whose work disrupts notions of “normal” —helps answer questions about potential benefits and harms of data practices. This lens has the potential to promote analysis that is as disruptive to injustices as it is practical.
- 1 July 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 8 (2)
Open AccessSqueaky wheels: Missing data, disability, and power in the smart city
Data about the accessibility of United States municipalities is infrastructure in the smart city. What is counted and how, reflects the sociotechnical imaginary (norms and values) of a time or place. In this paper we focus on features identified by people with disabilities as promoting or hindering safe pedestrian travel. We use a regionally stratified sample of 178 cities across the United States. The municipalities were scored on two factors: their open data practices (or lack thereof), and the degree to which they cataloged the environmental features that persons with disabilities deemed critical for safe movement through urban spaces. In contradiction to the dominating narrative of too much data and not enough analyses, we find that when it comes to data points that might be useful to persons with disabilities, data are lacking. This data gap has consequences both politically and materially—on one hand data could help enforce compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, on the other they would allow for safe route planning. We find that reading these data formats and collection patterns from the perspective of critical disability studies—particularly those whose work disrupts notions of “normal” —helps answer questions about potential benefits and harms of data practices. This lens has the potential to promote analysis that is as disruptive to injustices as it is practical.
- Top Cited Papers
- 8 March 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 109 (4) , 1092-1109
Plumbing Poverty: Mapping Hot Spots of Racial and Geographic Inequality in U.S. Household Water Insecurity
Household water insecurity is a global threat to human health and development, yet existing metrics lack a systematic consideration of geographic inequality and spatial variation. In this article, we introduce the notion of plumbing poverty as a conceptual and methodological heuristic to examine the intersectional nature of infrastructure, space, and social inequality. Plumbing poverty is understood in a dual sense: first, as a material and infrastructural condition produced by social relations that fundamentally vary through space and, second, as a methodology that operationalizes the spatial exploration of social inequality. Drawing on millions of census records, we strip household water security down to a single vital measure—the presence of complete household plumbing—to assess its spatial and sociodemographic trends. We identify distinct hot spots (geographic clusters of higher than average values) of plumbing poverty, track its social and spatial variance, and expose its fundamentally racialized nature. Our study finds that plumbing poverty is neither spatially nor socially random in the United States. Rather, plumbing incompleteness is spatially clustered in certain regions of the country and is clearly racialized: Living in an American Indian or Alaskan Native, black, or Hispanic household increases the odds of being plumbing poor, and these predictors warp and woof through space. In considering who experiences the slow violence of infrastructural dysfunction, a geography that is simultaneously ignored and unevenly expressed in the United States, we argue that analyses of space and social difference are central to understanding household water insecurity and must be prioritized in the development of cross-comparable metrics and global measurement tools. Key Words: census microdata, hot spot analysis, household water insecurity, infrastructural geographies, IPUMS. 家户水资源不安全,是对人类健康与发展的全球危害,但既有的度量,却缺乏对地理不均和空间变异的系统性考量。我们于本文中引入“配管贫穷”一词,作为概念与方法论上的启发,以检视基础建设、空间与社会不均之间的相互交织本质。配管贫穷以双重观念进行理解:首先作为由根本上具有空间变异的社会关系所生产的物质与基础建设条件,再者,作为操作社会不均的空间探索之方法。运用数以百万计的人口普查纪录,我们将家户水资源安全拆解成单一的重要测量——完整家户配管的存在——以评估其空间和社会人口趋势。我们指认配管贫穷的显着热点(较平均值为高的地理群聚), 追溯其社会和空间变异,并揭露其根本上的种族化本质。我们的研究发现,在美国,配管贫穷在空间或社会上并非具任意性。反之,配管不全在空间上集中于美国的若干区域,并明显是种族化的:居住于美国印地安人或阿拉斯加原住民族、黑人或西裔的家户中,增加了配管不足的机会,且这些预测指标随着空间经纬而异。在考量什麽人经历基础建设功能障碍的慢性暴力中——一种在美国同时受到忽略并不均展现的地理——我们主张,空间与社会差异的分析,是理解家户水资源不安全的核心,并且必需在建立横跨可比较的度量和全球测量工具时给予优先顺序。关键词:人口普查微观数据,热点分析,家户水资源不安全,基础建设地理学,微观共享整合数据库(IPUMS)。 La inseguridad en la disponibilidad de agua potable para uso doméstico es una amenaza global para la salud y el desarrollo humano, aunque las métricas existentes adolecen de la falta de consideración sistemática de la desigualdad geográfica y la variación espacial. En este artículo presentamos la noción de pobreza de plomería como heurística conceptual y metodológica para examinar la naturaleza interseccional de la infraestructura, el espacio y la desigualdad social. La pobreza de plomería se entiende en un sentido dual: primero, como una condición material e infraestructural producida por las relaciones sociales que fundamentalmente varían a través del espacio, y, segundo, como una metodología que operacionaliza la exploración espacial de la desigualdad social. Basándonos en millones de registros censales, desnudamos la seguridad del agua para uso doméstico, hasta convertirla en una sencilla medida vital—la presencia de una cabal plomería en el hoga—para evaluar sus tendencias espaciales y sociodemográficas. Identificamos puntos calientes perceptibles (agrupamientos geográficos con valores más altos que el promedio) de pobreza de plomería, rastreamos su varianza social y espacial, y exponemos su naturaleza fundamentalmente racializada. Nuestro estudio establece que la pobreza de plomería en los Estados Unidos no es ni espacial ni socialmente aleatoria. En vez de eso, la plomería deficiente se presenta agrupada espacialmente en ciertas regiones del país y es claramente racializada: Vivir en un hogar de indígenas americanos o nativos de Alaska, negro o hispánico, incrementa las posibilidades de ser pobre en plomería, y tales predictores campean a través del espacio. Al considerar quién experimenta la lenta violencia de la disfunción estructural, una geografía que es simultáneamente ignorada y expresada de manera desigual en los Estados Unidos, consideramos que los análisis de espacio y de diferencia social son centrales para entender la inseguridad del agua para uso doméstico y debe tener prioridad en el desarrollo de métricas comparables y herramientas de medición de uso global. Palabras clave: análisis de puntos calientes, geografías infraestructurales, inseguridad de agua potable, microdatos censales, IPUMS.
- 8 March 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 109 (4) , 1092-1109
Top Cited PapersPlumbing Poverty: Mapping Hot Spots of Racial and Geographic Inequality in U.S. Household Water Insecurity
Household water insecurity is a global threat to human health and development, yet existing metrics lack a systematic consideration of geographic inequality and spatial variation. In this article, we introduce the notion of plumbing poverty as a conceptual and methodological heuristic to examine the intersectional nature of infrastructure, space, and social inequality. Plumbing poverty is understood in a dual sense: first, as a material and infrastructural condition produced by social relations that fundamentally vary through space and, second, as a methodology that operationalizes the spatial exploration of social inequality. Drawing on millions of census records, we strip household water security down to a single vital measure—the presence of complete household plumbing—to assess its spatial and sociodemographic trends. We identify distinct hot spots (geographic clusters of higher than average values) of plumbing poverty, track its social and spatial variance, and expose its fundamentally racialized nature. Our study finds that plumbing poverty is neither spatially nor socially random in the United States. Rather, plumbing incompleteness is spatially clustered in certain regions of the country and is clearly racialized: Living in an American Indian or Alaskan Native, black, or Hispanic household increases the odds of being plumbing poor, and these predictors warp and woof through space. In considering who experiences the slow violence of infrastructural dysfunction, a geography that is simultaneously ignored and unevenly expressed in the United States, we argue that analyses of space and social difference are central to understanding household water insecurity and must be prioritized in the development of cross-comparable metrics and global measurement tools. Key Words: census microdata, hot spot analysis, household water insecurity, infrastructural geographies, IPUMS. 家户水资源不安全,是对人类健康与发展的全球危害,但既有的度量,却缺乏对地理不均和空间变异的系统性考量。我们于本文中引入“配管贫穷”一词,作为概念与方法论上的启发,以检视基础建设、空间与社会不均之间的相互交织本质。配管贫穷以双重观念进行理解:首先作为由根本上具有空间变异的社会关系所生产的物质与基础建设条件,再者,作为操作社会不均的空间探索之方法。运用数以百万计的人口普查纪录,我们将家户水资源安全拆解成单一的重要测量——完整家户配管的存在——以评估其空间和社会人口趋势。我们指认配管贫穷的显着热点(较平均值为高的地理群聚), 追溯其社会和空间变异,并揭露其根本上的种族化本质。我们的研究发现,在美国,配管贫穷在空间或社会上并非具任意性。反之,配管不全在空间上集中于美国的若干区域,并明显是种族化的:居住于美国印地安人或阿拉斯加原住民族、黑人或西裔的家户中,增加了配管不足的机会,且这些预测指标随着空间经纬而异。在考量什麽人经历基础建设功能障碍的慢性暴力中——一种在美国同时受到忽略并不均展现的地理——我们主张,空间与社会差异的分析,是理解家户水资源不安全的核心,并且必需在建立横跨可比较的度量和全球测量工具时给予优先顺序。关键词:人口普查微观数据,热点分析,家户水资源不安全,基础建设地理学,微观共享整合数据库(IPUMS)。 La inseguridad en la disponibilidad de agua potable para uso doméstico es una amenaza global para la salud y el desarrollo humano, aunque las métricas existentes adolecen de la falta de consideración sistemática de la desigualdad geográfica y la variación espacial. En este artículo presentamos la noción de pobreza de plomería como heurística conceptual y metodológica para examinar la naturaleza interseccional de la infraestructura, el espacio y la desigualdad social. La pobreza de plomería se entiende en un sentido dual: primero, como una condición material e infraestructural producida por las relaciones sociales que fundamentalmente varían a través del espacio, y, segundo, como una metodología que operacionaliza la exploración espacial de la desigualdad social. Basándonos en millones de registros censales, desnudamos la seguridad del agua para uso doméstico, hasta convertirla en una sencilla medida vital—la presencia de una cabal plomería en el hoga—para evaluar sus tendencias espaciales y sociodemográficas. Identificamos puntos calientes perceptibles (agrupamientos geográficos con valores más altos que el promedio) de pobreza de plomería, rastreamos su varianza social y espacial, y exponemos su naturaleza fundamentalmente racializada. Nuestro estudio establece que la pobreza de plomería en los Estados Unidos no es ni espacial ni socialmente aleatoria. En vez de eso, la plomería deficiente se presenta agrupada espacialmente en ciertas regiones del país y es claramente racializada: Vivir en un hogar de indígenas americanos o nativos de Alaska, negro o hispánico, incrementa las posibilidades de ser pobre en plomería, y tales predictores campean a través del espacio. Al considerar quién experimenta la lenta violencia de la disfunción estructural, una geografía que es simultáneamente ignorada y expresada de manera desigual en los Estados Unidos, consideramos que los análisis de espacio y de diferencia social son centrales para entender la inseguridad del agua para uso doméstico y debe tener prioridad en el desarrollo de métricas comparables y herramientas de medición de uso global. Palabras clave: análisis de puntos calientes, geografías infraestructurales, inseguridad de agua potable, microdatos censales, IPUMS.