CBCrystal L. Brogan

Crystal L. Brogan

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Crystal L. Brogan has a total of 658 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The ALMA EGO-10 survey of massive protoclusters: correlation of 1.3 mm continuum source clustering with evolutionary state

    by Michael C Logue, Claudia J Cyganowski, Crystal L Brogan, Todd R Hunter, Alessio Traficante, Allison P M Towner, Stella S R Offner

    Massive stars characteristically form in clustered environments. Characterizing young massive ‘protoclusters’ is therefore crucial to constraining the mechanism(s) of massive star formation, and of the assembly of stellar clusters. We present 1.3 mm continuum results from the ALMA (Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array) EGO-10 imaging survey, targeting 10 Spitzer GLIMPSE (Galactic Legacy Infrared Mid-Plane Survey Extraordinaire) Extended Green Objects (EGOs) – massive protostars with active outflows traced by extended 4.5 μm emission. Our sensitive 1.6 arcmin $\times$1.6 arcmin mosaics reveal rich protoclusters associated with all targets. With a mean spatial resolution 2200$\times$1600 au, we identify 570 cores – between 13 and 135 per field. We quantify protocluster structure with the $\mathcal {Q}$-parameter, finding structural diversity with 0.5 $\lesssim \mathcal {Q}\lesssim$ 0.9. The sample is notable for the wealth of complementary high-resolution multiwavelength data available. Correlating our cores with these observations, we find only 2 per cent, 5 per cent, and 4 per cent of cores host 6.7 GHz CH$_3$OH masers, 22 GHz H$_2$O masers, and cm–$\lambda$ continuum sources, respectively. The massive protostars traced by 6.7 GHz masers typically reside near protocluster centres (median offset 0.045 pc), and all at $d\lt$ 3 kpc are found in clustered locales, with >10 cores within 10 000 au. Using VLA (Very Large Array) cm–$\lambda$ continuum observations, we construct a new evolutionary indicator: the ratio of protocluster cm–$\lambda$ continuum luminosity to the mass of the associated ATLASGAL (APEX Telescope Large Area Survey of the Galaxy) clump ($L_\text{cm}/M_\text{AGAL}$). This ratio correlates positively with $\mathcal {Q}$, with the correlation driven primarily by the cm–$\lambda$ continuum emission from massive young stellar objects (MYSOs). This suggests dynamic protocluster structure, evolving from subclustered to centrally condensed, consistent with the global collapse in hierarchical, clump-fed models of massive star formation.

  • Open Access

    ALMAGAL

    by J. Allande, M. T. Beltrán, V. M. Rivilla, Á. López-Gallifa, C. Y. Law, Á. Sánchez-Monge, C. Battersby, M. Benedettini, H. Beuther, C. L. Brogan, et al.

    Context . High-mass star-forming regions are rich in complex organic molecules (COMs), which are carbon-bearing species with at least six atoms. Their formation pathways remain debated. The ALMA evolutionary study of high-mass protocluster formation in the GALaxy (ALMAGAL) survey provides a unique opportunity to probe this chemical complexity in a large statistical significant sample of high-mass star-forming regions. Aims . We present a detailed molecular line analysis of one of the most chemically rich cores in the ALMAGAL sample, the high-mass core 9 in the AG318.9477−00.1960 clump (AG318−c9), located at a heliocentric distance of ∼10.4 kpc. This source was selected because it combines an exceptionally high line density with a relatively simple kinematic structure, making it an optimal template for chemical analysis in the survey. We further assessed whether the emission of selected COMs, that is, ethylene glycol ((CH 2 OH) 2 ; EG), glycolaldehyde (CH 2 (OH)CHO; GA), and methyl formate (CH 3 OCHO; MF), can be used to trace the innermost regions of hot molecular cores (HMCs). Methods . We analysed ALMA Band 6 observations (∼217–221 GHz). Spectral line identification and local thermodynamic equilibrium modelling were performed using the software called MAdrid Data CUBe Analysis (MADCUBA). We derived the physical parameters, including the column density ( N ), excitation temperature ( T ex ), velocity, line width, and molecular abundances relative to H 2 , for all detected species. The chemical inventory of AG318−c9 was compared with that of the HMC G31.41 + 0.31 (G31). In addition, we performed a pixel-by-pixel analysis of EG, GA, and MF to generate spatially resolved N and T ex maps and corresponding radial profiles. Results . We report the detection of 65 molecular species, including 31 main species and 34 isotopologues and vibrationally excited species. Of these, 44 are O-bearing species, 28 are N-bearing, 8 are S-bearing, and 2 are Si-bearing. While AG318−c9 exhibits lower abundances than G31 overall, it shows detections of species that have not yet been reported in G31, such as ethyl formate (C 2 H 5 OCHO). Moreover, 12 species depart from the general trend, displaying relative overabundances in AG318−c9. The comparison also reveals a chemical differentiation between O- and N- bearing COMs, with O-bearing species systematically more abundant in G31. Regarding EG, GA, and MF, the latter is the most abundant ( X ∼ 3 × 10 −8 ), followed by EG ( X ∼ 7 × 10 −9 ) and GA ( X ∼ 2 × 10 −9 ). The N and T ex maps suggest that MF is the most spatially extended species, whereas EG and GA are more compact and confined to the innermost hot region. Conclusions . AG318−c9 reveals a rich chemical inventory characteristic of an HMC. The chemical comparison with G31 suggests that AG318−c9 is a less evolved hot core dominated by the recent sublimation of ice mantles, in contrast to the higher abundances observed in the possible more evolved G31. MF emerges as an excellent tracer of the gas temperature in HMCs owing to its wide spatial extent and wide dynamic range of the excitation temperature. In contrast, EG and GA are more compact and preferentially trace the innermost high-density regions of the core, suggesting a high sublimation temperature threshold and supporting a shared grain-surface formation pathway. While EG and MF seem to be partly limited by sensitivity, GA reflects an intrinsically central distribution.

  • Open Access

    A nine-member protostellar system forming via filament fragmentation in the high mass protocluster NGC 6334-43

    by D J Taylor, C J Cyganowski, C L Brogan, T R Hunter, B A McGuire, G M Williams

    We present the serendipitous discovery of a nine-member system comprised of protostellar and candidate prestellar sources in $\sim$350 au-resolution images from Complex Chemistry in hot Cores with ALMA (CoCCoA). The system is bound in a stability analysis, has a mean separation between pairs of 7930 au, and appears to have formed via the fragmentation of a single large-scale filamentary structure traced by 1.20 mm continuum and H$^{13}$CO$^+$ J = 3–2 emission. Two multiples within the nine-member system, a triple and a binary, have properties consistent with formation by core fragmentation on $\sim$1500–1700 au scales. The hot core NGC 6334-43 is resolved into two components (ALMA2a/ALMA2b) separated by 618 au and driving a bipolar outflow traced by $^{12}$CO J = 2–1 and SiO J = 5–4 in $\sim$1250 au-resolution archival Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) data. Only one other source in the nine-member system is clearly protostellar: ALMA6a, which drives an outflow traced by $^{12}$CO. The outflow properties of ALMA2a/ALMA2b and ALMA6a are consistent with high-mass and low-mass Class 0 sources, respectively. By fitting the CH$_{3}$CN J = 13–12 emission towards ALMA2a, ALMA2b, and ALMA6a, we derive M$_{\rm vir}$ = 4.5, 5.4, and 2.6 M$_{\odot }$, respectively. The other six sources in the nine-member multiple have M$_{\rm gas}$ = 0.50–1.87 M$_{\odot }$ and appear young, as indicated by their sparse mm-wavelength line emission and non-detection in published cm continuum observations. Our results highlight the potential of serendipitous discoveries in ALMA surveys to add to the small observational sample of young high-mass protomultiple systems.

  • Open Access

    ALMAGAL. VII. Cataloging Hierarchical Continuum Structure from Cores to Clumps across the Galactic Disk

    by Jennifer Wallace, Taevis Kolz, Cara Battersby, Aleksandra Kuznetsova, Álvaro Sánchez-Monge, Eugenio Schisano, Alessandro Coletta, Qizhou Zhang, Sergio Molinari, Peter Schilke, et al.

    Investigating the multiscale fragmentation of dense clumps into compact cores is essential for understanding the processes that govern the initial distribution of mass in stellar clusters and how high-mass stars (>8 M ⊙ ) form. We present a catalog of the hierarchical continuum structure from 904 clumps observed in the ALMAGAL program, a high-resolution (0 . ″ 15–0 . ″ 8) 1.38 mm Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array large program targeting dense clumps capable of high-mass star formation throughout the Galactic disk. We use astrodendro , a dendrogram-based algorithm, on a uniform linear resolution (2000 au) version of the data to extract 5160 continuum structures with effective radii spanning 800–42000 au and estimated masses between 0.05–670 M ⊙ . With our large sample, we statistically examine differences in clump properties for regions with varying levels of hierarchical complexity. We find that clumps exhibiting the richest hierarchical morphology have distributions with higher dust temperatures, surface densities, luminosity-to-mass ( L / M ) ratios, and most massive core masses, indicating that these regions tend to be at later evolutionary stages. We find a positive correlation between the mass of cores from the ALMAGAL core catalog and the surface density of their surrounding structures identified in this work. However, this correlation is weaker for cores in more evolved clumps, where lower-mass cores can be found at higher local surface densities. This could indicate that some cores accrete mass less efficiently from the intraclump reservoir than others, despite the total available mass increasing over time, a scenario that is congruent with a clump-fed core accretion model.


  • Open Access

    A Millimeter Methanol Maser Ring Tracing the Deceleration of the Heat Wave Powered by the Massive Protostellar Accretion Outburst in G358.93–0.03 MM1

    by T. R. Hunter, C. L. Brogan, G. C. MacLeod, C. J. Cyganowski, R. A. Burns, B. A. McGuire

    We present multiepoch, multiband Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array imaging of the new Class II millimeter methanol masers excited during the accretion outburst of the massive protostar G358.93−0.03 MM1. The highest angular resolution image (24 mas ≈160 au) reveals a nearly complete, circular ring of strong maser spots in the 217.2992 GHz ( v t = 1) maser line that closely circumscribes the dust continuum emission from MM1. Weaker maser emission lies inside the eastern and southern halves of the maser ring, generally coincident with the centimeter masers excited during the outburst but avoiding the densest parts of the hot core gas traced by high excitation lines of CH 3 CN. Using a variety of fitting techniques on the image cubes of the two strongest maser lines, each observed over three to four epochs, we find the diameter of the ring increased by ≳60% (from ≈1100 to ≈1800 au in the 217 GHz line) over 200 days, consistent with an average radial propagation rate of ≈0.01 c , while the maser intensity declined exponentially. Fitting the angular extent of the millimeter masers versus time yields a power law of index 0.39 ± 0.06, which also reproduces the observed extent of the 6.7 GHz masers in the first very long baseline interferometry epoch of R. A. Burns et al. 2020 This exponent is consistent with the prediction of radius versus time in the Taylor–von Neumann–Sedov self-similar solution for an intense spherical explosion from a point source ( R ∝ t 2/5 ). These results demonstrate the explosive nature of accretion outbursts in massive protostars and their ability to generate subluminal heat waves traceable by centimeter and millimeter masers for several months as the energy traverses the surrounding molecular material.


  • Open Access

    ALMAGAL

    by Á. Sánchez-Monge, C. L. Brogan, T. R. Hunter, A. Ahmadi, A. Avison, M. T. Beltrán, H. Beuther, A. Coletta, G. A. Fuller, K. G. Johnston, et al.

    Context. Stars form preferentially in clusters embedded inside massive molecular clouds, many of which contain high-mass stars. Thus, a comprehensive understanding of star formation requires a robust and statistically well-constrained characterization of the formation and early evolution of these high-mass star clusters. To achieve this, we designed the ALMAGAL Large Program that observed 1017 high-mass star-forming regions distributed throughout the Galaxy, sampling different evolutionary stages and environmental conditions. Aims. In this work, we present the acquisition and processing of the ALMAGAL data. The main goal is to set up a robust pipeline that generates science-ready products, that is, continuum and spectral cubes for each ALMAGAL field, with a good and uniform quality across the whole sample. Methods. ALMAGAL observations were performed with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA). Each field was observed in three different telescope arrays, being sensitive to spatial scales ranging from ≈1000 au up to ≈0.1 pc. The spectral setup allows sensitive (≈0.1 mJy beam−1) imaging of the continuum emission at 219 GHz (or 1.38 mm), and it covers multiple molecular spectral lines observed in four different spectral windows that span about ≈4 GHz in frequency coverage. We have designed a Python-based processing workflow to calibrate and image these observational data. This ALMAGAL pipeline includes an improved continuum determination, suited for line-rich sources; an automatic self-calibration process that reduces phase-noise fluctuations and improves the dynamical range by up to a factor ≈5 in about 15% of the fields; and the combination of data from different telescope arrays to produce science-ready, fully combined images. Results. The final products are a set of uniformly generated continuum images and spectral cubes for each ALMAGAL field, including individual-array and combined-array products. The fully combined products have spatial resolutions in the range 800–2000 au, and mass sensitivities in the range 0.02–0.07 M⊙. We also present a first analysis of the spectral line information included in the ALMAGAL setup, and its potential for future scientific studies. As an example, specific spectral lines (e.g., SiO and CH3CN) at ≈1000 au scales resolve the presence of multiple outflows in clusters and will help us to search for disk candidates around massive protostars. Moreover, the broad frequency bands provide information on the chemical richness of the different cluster members, which can be used to study the chemical evolution during the formation process of star clusters.


  • Open Access

    ALMAGAL

    by S. Molinari, P. Schilke, C. Battersby, P. T. P. Ho, Á. Sánchez-Monge, A. Traficante, B. Jones, M. T. Beltrán, H. Beuther, G. A. Fuller, et al.

    Context. A large fraction of stars form in clusters containing high-mass stars, which subsequently influences the local and galaxy-wide environment. Aims. Fundamental questions about the physics responsible for fragmenting molecular parsec-scale clumps into cores of a few thousand astronomical units (au) are still open, that only a statistically significant investigation with ALMA is able to address; for instance: the identification of the dominant agents that determine the core demographics, mass, and spatial distribution as a function of the physical properties of the hosting clumps, their evolutionary stage and the different Galactic environments in which they reside. The extent to which fragmentation is driven by clumps dynamics or mass transport in filaments also remains elusive. Methods. With the ALMAGAL project, we observed the 1.38 mm continuum and lines toward more than 1000 dense clumps in our Galaxy, with M ≥ 500 M⊙, Σ ≥ 0.1 g cm−2 and d ≤ 7.5 kiloparsec (kpc). Two different combinations of ALMA Compact Array (ACA) and 12-m array setups were used to deliver a minimum resolution of ∼1000 au over the entire sample distance range. The sample covers all evolutionary stages from infrared dark clouds (IRDCs) to H II regions from the tip of the Galactic bar to the outskirts of the Galaxy. With a continuum sensitivity of 0.1 mJy, ALMAGAL enables a complete study of the clump-to-core fragmentation process down to M ∼ 0.3 M⊙ across the Galaxy. The spectral setup includes several molecular lines to trace the multiscale physics and dynamics of gas, notably CH3CN, H2CO, SiO, CH3OH, DCN, HC3N, and SO, among others. Results. We present an initial overview of the observations and the early science product and results produced in the ALMAGAL Consortium, with a first characterization of the morphological properties of the continuum emission detected above 5σ in our fields. We used “perimeter-versus-area” and convex hull-versus-area metrics to classify the different morphologies. We find that more extended and morphologically complex (significantly departing from circular or generally convex) shapes are found toward clumps that are relatively more evolved and have higher surface densities. Conclusions. ALMAGAL is poised to serve as a game-changer for a number of specific issues in star formation: clump-to-core fragmentation processes, demographics of cores, core and clump gas chemistry and dynamics, infall and outflow dynamics, and disk detections. Many of these issues will be covered in the first generation of papers that closely follow on the present publication.


  • Open Access

    ALMAGAL

    by A. Coletta, S. Molinari, E. Schisano, A. Traficante, D. Elia, M. Benedettini, C. Mininni, J. D. Soler, Á. Sánchez-Monge, P. Schilke, et al.

    The physical mechanisms behind the fragmentation of high-mass dense clumps into compact star-forming cores and the properties of these cores are fundamental topics that are heavily investigated in current astrophysical research. The ALMAGAL survey provides the opportunity to study this process at an unprecedented level of detail and statistical significance, featuring high-angular resolution 1.38 mm ALMA observations of 1013 massive dense clumps at various Galactic locations. These clumps cover a wide range of distances (~2–8 kpc), masses (~102–104 M⊙), surface densities (0.1–10 g cm−2), and evolutionary stages (luminosity over mass ratio indicator of ~0.05 < L/M < 450L⊙/M⊙). Here, we present the catalog of compact sources obtained with the CuTEx algorithm from continuum images of the full ALMAGAL clump sample combining ACA-7 m and 12 m ALMA arrays, reaching a uniform high median spatial resolution of ~1400 au (down to ~800 au). We characterize and discuss the revealed fragmentation properties and the photometric and estimated physical parameters of the core population. The ALMAGAL compact source catalog includes 6348 cores detected in 844 clumps (83% of the total), with a number of cores per clump between 1 and 49 (median of 5). The estimated core diameters are mostly within ~800–3000 au (median of 1700 au). We assigned core temperatures based on the L/M of the hosting clump, and obtained core masses from 0.002 to 345 M⊙ (complete above 0.23 M⊙), exhibiting a good correlation with the core radii (M ∝ R2.6). We evaluated the variation in the core mass function (CMF) with evolution as traced by the clump L/M, finding a clear, robust shift and change in slope among CMFs within subsamples at different stages. This finding suggests that the CMF shape is not constant throughout the star formation process, but rather it builds (and flattens) with evolution, with higher core masses reached at later stages. We found that all cores within a clump grow in mass on average with evolution, while a population of possibly newly formed lower-mass cores is present throughout. The number of cores increases with the core masses, at least until the most massive core reaches ~10M⊙. More generally, our results favor a clump-fed scenario for high-mass star formation, in which cores form as low-mass seeds, and then gain mass while further fragmentation occurs in the clump.


  • Open Access

    Interstellar Glycolaldehyde, Methyl Formate, and Acetic Acid. II. Chemical Modeling of the Bimodal Abundance Pattern in NGC 6334I

    by Brielle M. Shope, Samer J. El-Abd, Crystal L. Brogan, Todd R. Hunter, Eric R. Willis, Brett A. McGuire, Robin T. Garrod

    Gas-phase abundance ratios between C2H4O2 isomers methyl formate (MF), glycolaldehyde (GA), and acetic acid (AA) are typically on the order of 100:10:1 in star-forming regions. However, an unexplained divergence from this neat relationship was recently observed toward a collection of sources in the massive protocluster NGC 6334I; some sources exhibited extreme MF:GA ratios, producing a bimodal behavior between different sources, while the MF:AA ratio remained stable. Here, we use a three-phase gas-grain hot-core chemical model to study the effects of a large parameter space on the simulated C2H4O2 abundances. A combination of high gas densities and long timescales during ice-mantle desorption (∼125–160 K) appears to be the physical cause of the high MF:GA ratios. The main chemical mechanism for GA destruction occurring under these conditions is the rapid adsorption and reaction of atomic H with GA on the ice surfaces before it has time to desorb. The different binding energies of MF and GA on water ice are crucial to the selectivity of the surface destruction mechanism; individual MF molecules rapidly escape the surface when exposed by water loss, while GA lingers and is destroyed by H. Moderately elevated cosmic-ray ionization rates can increase absolute levels of “complex organic molecule” (COM) production in the ices and increase the MF:GA ratio, but extreme values are destructive for gas-phase COMs. We speculate that the high densities required for extreme MF:GA ratios could be evidence of COM emission dominated by COMs desorbing within a circumstellar disk.


  • Open Access

    Filamentary mass accretion towards the high-mass protobinary system G11.92–0.61 MM2

    by S Zhang, C J Cyganowski, J D Henshaw, C L Brogan, T R Hunter, R K Friesen, I A Bonnell, S Viti

    We present deep, sub-arcsecond ($\sim$2000 au) resolution ALMA 0.82-mm observations of the former high-mass prestellar core candidate G11.92–0.61 MM2, recently shown to be an $\sim$500 au-separation protobinary. Our observations show that G11.92–0.61 MM2, located in the G11.92–0.61 protocluster, lies on a filamentary structure traced by 0.82-mm continuum and N$_2$H$^+$(4-3) emission. The N$_2$H$^+$(4-3) spectra are multipeaked, indicative of multiple velocity components along the line of sight. To analyse the gas kinematics, we performed pixel-by-pixel Gaussian decomposition of the N$_2$H$^+$ spectra using scousepy and hierarchical clustering of the extracted velocity components using acorns. Seventy velocity- and position-coherent clusters (called ‘trees’) are identified in the N$_2$H$^+$-emitting gas, with the eight largest trees accounting for $\gt $60 per cent of the fitted velocity components. The primary tree, with $\sim$20 per cent of the fitted velocity components, displays a roughly north–south velocity gradient along the filamentary structure traced by the 0.82-mm continuum. Analysing an $\sim$0.17 pc-long substructure, we interpret its velocity gradient of $\sim$10.5 km s$^{-1}$ pc$^{-1}$ as tracing filamentary accretion towards MM2 and estimate a mass inflow rate of $\sim 1.8\times 10^{-4}$ to 1.2$\times 10^{-3}$ M$_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$. Based on the recent detection of a bipolar molecular outflow associated with MM2, accretion on to the protobinary is ongoing, likely fed by the larger scale filamentary accretion flows. If 50 per cent of the filamentary inflow reaches the protostars, each member of the protobinary would attain a mass of 8 M$_\odot$ within $\sim 1.6\times 10^5$ yr, comparable to the combined time-scale of the 70-μm- and mid-infrared-weak phases derived for ATLASGAL-TOP100 massive clumps using chemical clocks.