PGPaolo Gasperini

Paolo Gasperini

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Paolo Gasperini has a total of 185 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Probabilistic earthquake forecasting in Italy: bridging the gap between alarm-based and probability-based models

    by E Biondini, P Gasperini, B Lolli

    SUMMARY: We present a probabilistic framework for evaluating earthquake forecasting models that use an alarm-based approach. In this approach, alarms are triggered by specific precursor signals. In a previous paper we compared such models and two ensemble models combining them in additive and multiplicative mode, with the ETAS (Epidemic Type Aftershock Sequence) forecasting model, which is defined in a probability-based approach, by making the latter to issue an alarm when the expected rate exceeds a pre-defined threshold. In this work we compare the alarm-based models with the ETAS and with another probability-based model, EEPAS (Every Earthquake a Precursor According to Scale) previously applied to Italy, using the testing procedures developed for probability-based models within the Collaboratory Study for Earthquake Predictability (CSEP) initiative. To do that, for the four alarm-based models, we compute empirical probabilities (frequencies) of Mw ≥ 5.0 earthquakes in Italy, inside and outside alarm time intervals issued by such models from 1990 to 2011. We then compare pseudo-prospectively the forecasting ability of all six models, by applying the CSEP tests on the time interval from 2012 to 2023. We found that the evaluation method used has a strong impact on the ranking of model performance. Probabilistic models like ETAS and EEPAS tend to score better under the CSEP testing framework whereas alarm-based models generally outperform probability-based ones when assessed using alarm-based metrics.

  • Open Access

    The Role of “Equation Error” in Empirical Regressions for Seismic Magnitude Conversions

    by Paolo Gasperini, Emanuele Biondini, Barbara Lolli

    In the last two decades, empirical regressions for the conversions of traditional magnitudes (e.g., ML, Ms, and mb) to moment magnitude Mw were mostly computed using error-in-variable (EIV) method, also known as general orthogonal regression, and not the ordinary least-squares (OLS) method because the uncertainties of traditional magnitudes are not negligible when compared to that of Mw. However, a few recent articles criticized such approaches based on the hypothesis that an error in the equation, that is, the epistemic uncertainty associated with the form of the regression equation, is present, and this is better accounted for by the OLS rather than by the EIV. In this work, we first discuss the problem theoretically and then make some analysis on real datasets. We find that the regression coefficients are strongly influenced by the assumption made about the sizes of the errors of traditional magnitudes. In particular, the role of equation error may be significant if the assumed errors of the traditional magnitudes are small (≤0.1 magnitude units) or may even be almost negligible if the errors are only slightly larger (>0.12–0.15). In general, the EIV method has always to be preferred with respect to OLS, but it might require a small correction for equation error. These findings have significant implications for statistical forecasting and seismic hazard assessment.


  • Open Access

    Can we quickly calculate reliable earthquake parameters from citizen testimonies?

    by Gianfranco Vannucci, Remy Bossu, Matthieu Landès, Paolo Gasperini

    In a recent work, we tested the ability to compute earthquake parameters (location and magnitude) using citizen testimonies collected by the European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre (EMSC). Each intensity estimated by individual non-professional users of the LastQuake smartphone application is indicated as an individual data point (IDP). Each IDP is archived by EMSC with a time stamp, allowing the calculation of the time delay from the earthquake origin time. To use IDPs as classic intensities, i.e. macroseismic data points (MDPs), identifying damage at the scale of towns or cities, they must be grouped into spatial clusters, which are then processed by the BOXER code to locate and size global earthquakes. A retrospective analysis on a dataset of more than 15,000 events collected over the past 10 years shows that the procedure can provide reliable parameters and that the results depend on the geographical area and improve over time and as the number of available IDPs/MDPs increases. The key question is whether early IDPs/MDPs can quickly provide reliable parameters (location and magnitude) for users and stakeholders (e.g. the civil protection agencies). Using clustering methods that statistically provide, on average, the best agreement with instrumental data, we tested some predefined time intervals within which to group the available IDPs into MDPs. We then applied the BOXER code to these MDPs, evaluating the agreement with the final instrumental parameters. Results confirm that reliability increases with the number and distribution of MDPs, strictly dependent on the number and distribution of available IDPs. This retrospective analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach and its potential to quickly provide parameters for future real-time applications. The method may offer a reliable and rapid tool to support emergency response, improving as more IDPs/MDPs are collected.

  • Open Access

    Can we quickly calculate reliable earthquake parameters from citizen testimonies?

    by Gianfranco Vannucci, Remy Bossu, Matthieu Landès, Paolo Gasperini

    In a recent work, we tested the ability to compute macroseismic parameters (location and magnitude) using citizen testimonies collected by the European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre (EMSC). Each intensity estimated by individual non-professional users of the LastQuake smartphone application is indicated as an individual data point (IDP). Each IDP is archived by EMSC with a time stamp, allowing the calculation of the time delay from the earthquake origin time. To use IDPs as classic intensities, i.e. macroseismic data points (MDPs), identifying damage at the scale of towns or cities, they must be grouped into spatial clusters, which are then processed by the BOXER code to locate and size earthquakes. A retrospective analysis on a dataset of more than 15000 events collected over the past 10 years shows that the procedure can provide reliable parameters and that the results depend on the geographical area and improve over time and as the number of available IDPs/MDPs increases.The key question is whether early IDPs/MDPs can quickly provide reliable parameters (location and magnitude) for users and stakeholders (e.g. the civil protection agencies). Using clustering methods that statistically provide, on average, the best agreement with instrumental data, we tested some predefined time intervals within which to group the available IDPs into MDPs. We then applied the BOXER code to these MDPs, evaluating the agreement with the final instrumental parameters. Results confirm that reliability increases with the number and distribution of MDPs, strictly dependent on the number and distribution of available IDPs. This retrospective analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach and its potential to quickly provide parameters for future real-time applications. The method may offer a reliable and rapid tool to support emergency response, improving as more IDPs/MDPs are collected.

  • Open Access

    An experiment on earthquake size distribution estimations reveals unexpected large epistemic uncertainty across methods

    by Anna Maria Lombardi, Licia Faenza, Francesco Pio Lucente, Matteo Taroni, Laura Gulia, Anna Tramelli, Emanuele Biondini, Rodolfo Console, Vincenzo Convertito, Cataldo Godano, et al.

    SUMMARY: The earthquake size distribution is well described by the Gutenberg Richter Law, controlled by the b-value parameter. In recent decades, a great variety of methods for estimating the b-value have been proposed by the scientific community, despite the simplicity of this relationship. All these methods underlie the different views of individual modellers and, therefore, often generate inconsistent results. In this study, we perform a seismological experiment in which we compare different, commonly adopted, methodologies, to estimate the completeness magnitude and the b-value, for seismicity in Central Italy. The intermethod differences are on average equal to 0.4 and 0.3, for Mc and b, respectively, but reach much larger values, especially during more intense seismic activity. This shows that epistemic uncertainty in the b-value plays a more crucial role than intramethod uncertainties, opening new perspectives in the interpretation of discrepant, single studies.


  • Open Access

    Pseudo-prospective earthquakes forecasting experiment in Italy based on temporal variation of the b-value of the Gutenberg-Richter law.

    by Emanuele Biondini, Flavia D'ORazio, Barbara Lolli, Paolo Gasperini

    The analysis of space-time variations of the b-value of the frequency-magnitude distribution of earthquakes can be considered an important indicator in understanding the processes that precede strong earthquake events. Variations in b-value can provide valuable information on the stress state and probability of earthquake occurrence in a specific geographical region. By analyzing spatial variations in b-value, changes in local tectonic conditions can be identified, highlighting areas where seismic risk may increase. Similarly, the analysis of temporal variations in b-value can reveal patterns preceding seismic events, providing a possible precursor signal. Such variations could be the result of complex geological processes, such as the progressive accumulation of stress along active faults or the presence of underground fluids that influence fault dynamics. In fact, as it has been observed in many cases, the b-value tends to descend in the preparatory phases of a strong earthquake, and it increases suddenly after the mainshock occurrence.To evaluate such a hypothesis, in this work, an alarm-based forecasting method that uses b-value space-time variations as a precursor signal is implemented. The forecasting method has been retrospectively calibrated and optimized for the period 1990-2011 to forecast Italian shallow earthquake (Z

  • Open Access

    Recalibration of the intensity prediction equation in Italy using the Macroseismic Dataset DBMI15 V2.

    by Barbara Lolli, Paolo Gasperini, Gianfranco Vannucci

    We re-compute the coefficients of the intensity prediction equation (IPE) in Italy using the data of the DBMI15 V2.0 intensity database and the instrumental and combined (instrumental plus macroseismic) magnitudes reported by the CPTI15 V2.0 catalog. We follow the same procedure described in a previous article, consisting of a first step in which the attenuation of intensity I with respect to the distance D from macroseismic hypocenter is referred to the expected intensity at the epicenter IEand a second step in which IEis related to the instrumental magnitude Mi, the combined magnitude Mc, the epicentral intensity I0 and the maximum intensity Imax, using error-in-variable (EIV) regression methods. The main methodological difference with respect to the original article concerns the estimation of the uncertainty of IEto be used for EIV regressions, which is empirically derived from the standard deviation of regression between IE and Miand also used for the regressions of IEwith Mc, I0 and Imax. In summary, the new IPE determined from DBMI15 V2.0 is 𝐼=𝐼𝐸−0.0081(𝐷−ℎ)−1.072[ln(𝐷)−ln(ℎ)] where 𝐷=√(𝑅2+ℎ2), h=4.49 km and IEcan be calculated from the intensity data distribution of the earthquake. If the intensity data distribution is not available, IEcan be calculated from the following relationships 𝐼𝐸=−2.578+1.867𝑀𝑤 IE=I0

  • Open Access

    Pseudo-prospective earthquake forecasting experiment in Italy based on temporal variation of the b-value of the Gutenberg–Richter law

    by E Biondini, F D'ORazio, B Lolli, P Gasperini

    SUMMARY: We present the BVAL method, designed to forecast potentially damaging earthquakes (Mw ≥ 5.0) in Italy based on temporal variations of the b-value of the Gutenberg–Richter frequency–magnitude distribution. The b-value is used as an indicator of stress within the Earth's crust, with lower b-values associated with higher stress levels and an increased likelihood of significant seismic events. This method issues alarms when the b-value falls below a critical threshold. It is optimized using the HOmogenized instRUmental Seismic catalogue data from 1990 to 2004 and validated pseudo-prospectively using data from 2005 to 2022. Our analysis uses the recently developed b-positive (b+) method to compute the b-value from magnitude differences, providing resilience against data incompleteness. We compare the performance of the BVAL method with two established models: the Epidemic Type Aftershock Sequence (ETAS) model, which forecasts earthquake rates based on the epidemic principle that each shock triggers subsequent shocks, and the FORE model, which relies on the occurrence of strong foreshocks. Additionally, we evaluate two ensemble models that combine BVAL and FORE through additive (EADD) and multiplicative (EMUL) strategies to balance false alarms and missed events. The EADD model declares an alarm when either BVAL or FORE signals it, while the EMUL model triggers alarms only when both methods agree. We assess the predictive efficiency of these models using the area skill score, derived from Molchan diagrams, which plot the miss rate against the fraction of space-time occupied by alarms. Our results demonstrate that BVAL is less effective than FORE and ETAS at high space-time fractions, but it outperforms ETAS at low fractions ($\tau \ $ < 2–4 per cent), indicating its potential utility in scenarios where minimizing false alarms is critical. This comprehensive comparison highlights the strengths and limitations of each method, suggesting that integrating multiple forecasting strategies can enhance the reliability of earthquake preparedness and response efforts in Italy.


  • Open Access

    Completeness and calibration of the Italian Seismological Instrumental and Parametric Database (ISIDe) before 16 April 2005

    by Barbara Lolli, Gianfranco Vannucci, Paolo Gasperini

    The Italian Seismological Instrumental and Parametric Database (ISIDe) is the recipient of earthquake data collected in real-time by the Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV), and used by the studies of earthquake forecasting and seismic hazard assessment in Italy in the last decade. When it went online, following a significant improvement of the seismic acquisition system of INGV, it was including only data since the second fortnight of April 2005. About ten years later, the data since the beginning of 1985 suddenly appeared without any prior notice than the updating of the starting date of the dataset. However, the characteristics of the added data appeared clearly different from the following period both in terms of the numbers of located earthquakes and of types of magnitudes provided. After having analyzed the numerical consistency and the calibration of magnitudes of ISIDe as a function of time from 1985 to 15 April 2005, we can say that such a dataset is incomplete and poorly calibrated compared to other catalogs of Italian seismicity (CSTI, CSI, and HORUS) available for the same period. Hence, we suggest not using it as is for statistical analyses of Italian seismicity. However, it provides some magnitudes that are missed by other catalogs and thus might be used for improving such catalogs.

  • Open Access

    A theoretical comparison among macroseismic scales used in Italy

    by Gianfranco Vannucci, Barbara Lolli, Paolo Gasperini

    In a recent work, we evidenced some empirical discrepancies between the macroseismic intensity estimates in Italy in the last decade with respect to those made previously. A possible reason might be the progressive adoption by Italian researchers of the European Macroseismic Scale (EMS) in place of the Mercalli Cancani Sieberg (MCS) scale mostly used up to 2009. In theory, in modern settlements where reinforced concrete (RC) buildings are increasingly replacing those in masonry, EMS should overestimate MCS because the former accounts for the lower vulnerability of RC whereas the latter does not because RC buildings were not considered at all by the MCS scale since they were almost absent at the time (1912–1932) when it was compiled by Sieberg. However, such theoretical inference is contradicted by the empirical evidence that, on average, MCS intensities really estimated in Italy over the past decade slightly overestimate EMS and not vice versa as it should be. A possible explanation is that the EMS scale had not been well calibrated to reproduce the MCS, as its authors intended to do. Another possible reason for the discrepancies between the last decade and the previous ones might be that the MCS scale applied today is not the same as that defined by Sieberg at the beginning of the twentieth century. In order to better understand the possible causes of such discrepancies, we present here a formal comparison between the definitions of the different degrees of such macroseismic scales. After such analysis, we might argue that another possible reason for the observed discrepancy may come from the inaccurate assessment of building vulnerability when assessing the EMS intensity.