Adam C. Smith
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Adam C. Smith has a total of 241 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Lenore Fahrig
Carleton University
13 shared publications Charles M. Francis
National Wildlife Research Centre
7 shared publications- Brandon P. M. Edwards
University of Guelph
6 shared publications Marie-Anne R. Hudson
Canadian Wildlife Service Environment and Climate Change Canada
4 shared publicationsLindsay Daly
Canadian Wildlife Service Environment and Climate Change Canada
3 shared publications- Marie-Anne R. Hudson
Canadian Wildlife Service Environment and Climate Change Canada Ottawa ON Canada
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Hyper-dominant species drive unexpected functional shifts in North American birds
Climate change has led to consistent intraspecific shifts in functional traits, yet the extent to which within-species trends predict community-level changes is unknown. We assessed how local community-weighted means of seven key traits have changed over the past 50 years across North American bird communities. Communities shifted toward larger body mass and smaller appendages over time, the opposite of widely documented within-species changes. These unexpected patterns arise from a small proportion (5%) of hyper-dominant species. Idiosyncratic changes in their abundances led to weak associations between functional shifts and climate but strong associations with human-induced land use changes. Our results reveal contrasting within-species responses to climate change and community-level responses to broader environmental dynamics, highlighting the importance of hyper-dominant species in shaping biodiversity under global change.
Open AccessHyper-dominant species drive unexpected functional shifts in North American birds
Climate change has led to consistent intraspecific shifts in functional traits, yet the extent to which within-species trends predict community-level changes is unknown. We assessed how local community-weighted means of seven key traits have changed over the past 50 years across North American bird communities. Communities shifted toward larger body mass and smaller appendages over time, the opposite of widely documented within-species changes. These unexpected patterns arise from a small proportion (5%) of hyper-dominant species. Idiosyncratic changes in their abundances led to weak associations between functional shifts and climate but strong associations with human-induced land use changes. Our results reveal contrasting within-species responses to climate change and community-level responses to broader environmental dynamics, highlighting the importance of hyper-dominant species in shaping biodiversity under global change.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in FACETS
- Vol. 10, 1-15
Under pressure: the relationship between vertebrate populations and high-intensity cumulative threats in habitats across Canada
Biodiversity and human pressures are unevenly distributed, and understanding local patterns is key to appropriately directing conservation action. Here, we investigate the relationship between spatially explicit high-intensity cumulative threats (HICTs) and indices of monitored population abundance of Canadian vertebrates, disaggregating patterns among habitats. We found average population declines across habitats and reaffirm the concentration of HICT in southern Canada—particularly in the Mixedwood Plains ecozone. We found that terrestrial vertebrate populations often coincided spatially with proximity to humans, infrastructure, and land cover change, while marine population data commonly overlapped with shipping, exploitation, and pollution pressures. We reveal significant negative associations between monitored population trends and both (i) HICT and the (ii) number of habitats occupied by the species in question—both of which were identified as important predictors. However, marginal R 2 values for our models were small, and thus the proportion of variance that the predictor variables (e.g., threats and habitats) can confidently explain is limited. Our analysis provides novel spatial products and analyses—integrating both marine and terrestrial/freshwater realms, contributing to a growing evidence base for supporting prioritization of conservation action at a national scale. Nevertheless, we provide recommendations on methodological improvements to improve the utility of predictive models.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in FACETS
- Vol. 10, 1-15
Open AccessUnder pressure: the relationship between vertebrate populations and high-intensity cumulative threats in habitats across Canada
Biodiversity and human pressures are unevenly distributed, and understanding local patterns is key to appropriately directing conservation action. Here, we investigate the relationship between spatially explicit high-intensity cumulative threats (HICTs) and indices of monitored population abundance of Canadian vertebrates, disaggregating patterns among habitats. We found average population declines across habitats and reaffirm the concentration of HICT in southern Canada—particularly in the Mixedwood Plains ecozone. We found that terrestrial vertebrate populations often coincided spatially with proximity to humans, infrastructure, and land cover change, while marine population data commonly overlapped with shipping, exploitation, and pollution pressures. We reveal significant negative associations between monitored population trends and both (i) HICT and the (ii) number of habitats occupied by the species in question—both of which were identified as important predictors. However, marginal R 2 values for our models were small, and thus the proportion of variance that the predictor variables (e.g., threats and habitats) can confidently explain is limited. Our analysis provides novel spatial products and analyses—integrating both marine and terrestrial/freshwater realms, contributing to a growing evidence base for supporting prioritization of conservation action at a national scale. Nevertheless, we provide recommendations on methodological improvements to improve the utility of predictive models.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 16 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 33 (19) , e17532
Genetic rescue often leads to higher fitness as a result of increased heterozygosity across animal taxa
Biodiversity loss has reached critical levels partly due to anthropogenic habitat loss and degradation. These landscape changes are damaging as they can fragment species distributions into small, isolated populations, resulting in limited gene flow, population declines and reduced adaptive potential. Genetic rescue, the translocation of individuals to increase genetic diversity and ultimately fitness, has produced promising results for fragmented populations but remains underutilized due to a lack of long‐term data and monitoring. To promote a better understanding of genetic rescue and its potential risks and benefits over the short‐term, we reviewed and analysed published genetic rescue attempts to identify whether genetic diversity increases following translocation, and if this change is associated with increased fitness. Our review identified 19 studies that provided genetic and fitness data from before and after the translocation; the majority of these were on mammals, and included experimental, natural and conservation‐motivated translocations. Using a Bayesian meta‐analytical approach, we found that on average, genetic diversity and fitness increased in populations post translocations, although there were some exceptions to this trend. Overall, genetic diversity was a positive predictor of population fitness, and in some cases this relationship extended three generations post‐rescue. These data suggest a single translocation can have lasting fitness benefits, and support translocation as another tool to facilitate conservation success. Given the limited number of studies with long‐term data, we echo the need for genetic monitoring of populations post‐translocation to understand whether genetic rescue can also limit the loss of adaptive potential in the long‐term.
- 16 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 33 (19) , e17532
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessGenetic rescue often leads to higher fitness as a result of increased heterozygosity across animal taxa
Biodiversity loss has reached critical levels partly due to anthropogenic habitat loss and degradation. These landscape changes are damaging as they can fragment species distributions into small, isolated populations, resulting in limited gene flow, population declines and reduced adaptive potential. Genetic rescue, the translocation of individuals to increase genetic diversity and ultimately fitness, has produced promising results for fragmented populations but remains underutilized due to a lack of long‐term data and monitoring. To promote a better understanding of genetic rescue and its potential risks and benefits over the short‐term, we reviewed and analysed published genetic rescue attempts to identify whether genetic diversity increases following translocation, and if this change is associated with increased fitness. Our review identified 19 studies that provided genetic and fitness data from before and after the translocation; the majority of these were on mammals, and included experimental, natural and conservation‐motivated translocations. Using a Bayesian meta‐analytical approach, we found that on average, genetic diversity and fitness increased in populations post translocations, although there were some exceptions to this trend. Overall, genetic diversity was a positive predictor of population fitness, and in some cases this relationship extended three generations post‐rescue. These data suggest a single translocation can have lasting fitness benefits, and support translocation as another tool to facilitate conservation success. Given the limited number of studies with long‐term data, we echo the need for genetic monitoring of populations post‐translocation to understand whether genetic rescue can also limit the loss of adaptive potential in the long‐term.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithological Applications
- Vol. 126 (4)
Two listeners detect slightly more birds than a single listener when interpreting acoustic recordings
Acoustic recorders are increasingly important for monitoring bird populations and have potential to augment existing monitoring programs such as the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS). An advantage of acoustic recordings is that they can be reviewed multiple times by multiple experts, potentially yielding improved estimates of species abundance and community richness. Yet, few studies have examined how frequently successive listeners disagree on acoustic interpretations and how strongly estimates of species richness and abundance are altered when multiple experts review each recording. We assigned multiple expert listeners to interpret recordings at 690 Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) stops, and subsequently assigned second listeners to conduct a review of first listeners’ interpretations. We examined the extent to which listeners agreed with each other and quantified the effect of disagreements on resultant estimates of species occurrence, abundance, and stop-level richness. We also compared estimates from acoustic recordings to those obtained during simultaneous field surveys. Estimates were highly correlated for number of species per stop (r = 0.92) and detection probabilities of species (r = 0.97) based on first and second-listener data. Second listeners disagreed with ~9% of first listeners’ interpretations and added an average of ~15% additional species and 16% additional birds not reported by first listeners. Estimates based on acoustic recordings were also highly correlated with those obtained from field surveys, though listeners were unable to count flocks. A single expert reviewer can provide a reasonable approximation of the relative abundance and species composition of birds available for acoustic detection during Breeding Bird Surveys. However, acoustic review by multiple listeners may still be important for species that are rare, difficult to identify, or of high conservation concern.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithological Applications
- Vol. 126 (4)
Two listeners detect slightly more birds than a single listener when interpreting acoustic recordings
Acoustic recorders are increasingly important for monitoring bird populations and have potential to augment existing monitoring programs such as the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS). An advantage of acoustic recordings is that they can be reviewed multiple times by multiple experts, potentially yielding improved estimates of species abundance and community richness. Yet, few studies have examined how frequently successive listeners disagree on acoustic interpretations and how strongly estimates of species richness and abundance are altered when multiple experts review each recording. We assigned multiple expert listeners to interpret recordings at 690 Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) stops, and subsequently assigned second listeners to conduct a review of first listeners’ interpretations. We examined the extent to which listeners agreed with each other and quantified the effect of disagreements on resultant estimates of species occurrence, abundance, and stop-level richness. We also compared estimates from acoustic recordings to those obtained during simultaneous field surveys. Estimates were highly correlated for number of species per stop (r = 0.92) and detection probabilities of species (r = 0.97) based on first and second-listener data. Second listeners disagreed with ~9% of first listeners’ interpretations and added an average of ~15% additional species and 16% additional birds not reported by first listeners. Estimates based on acoustic recordings were also highly correlated with those obtained from field surveys, though listeners were unable to count flocks. A single expert reviewer can provide a reasonable approximation of the relative abundance and species composition of birds available for acoustic detection during Breeding Bird Surveys. However, acoustic review by multiple listeners may still be important for species that are rare, difficult to identify, or of high conservation concern.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Avian Conservation and Ecology
- Vol. 19 (2)
Patterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates
Spatial patterns in population trends, particularly those at fine geographic scales, can help better understand the factors driving population change in North American birds. The standard trend models for the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) were designed to estimate changes in relative abundance through time (trend) within broad geographic strata, such as countries, Bird Conservation Regions, U.S. states, and Canadian territories or provinces. Calculating trend estimates at the level of the BBS’s individual survey transects (“routes”) allows exploration of finer spatial patterns and estimation of the effects of covariates, such as habitat loss or annual weather, on both relative abundance and trend. Here, we describe four related hierarchical Bayesian models that estimate trends for individual BBS routes. All four models estimate route-level trends and relative abundances using a hierarchical structure that shares information among routes, and three of the models share information in a spatially explicit way. The spatial models use either an intrinsic Conditional Autoregressive (iCAR) structure or a distance-based Gaussian Process (GP) to estimate the spatial components. We fit all four models to data for 71 species and then, because of the intensive computations required, fit two of the models (one spatial and one non-spatial) for an additional 216 species. In a leave-future-out cross-validation, the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial models for 284 out of 287 species. The best approach to modeling the spatial components depends on the species being modeled; the Gaussian Process had the highest predictive accuracy for 69% of the species tested here and the iCAR was better for the remaining 31%. We also present two examples of route-level covariate analyses focused on spatial and temporal variation in habitat for Rufous Hummingbird (Selasphorus rufus) and Horned Grebe (Podiceps auritus). In both examples, the inclusion of covariates improved our understanding of the patterns in the rate of population change for both species. Route-level models for BBS data are useful for visualizing spatial patterns of population change, generating hypotheses on the causes of change, comparing patterns of change among regions and species, and testing hypotheses on causes of change with relevant covariates.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Avian Conservation and Ecology
- Vol. 19 (2)
Open AccessPatterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates
Spatial patterns in population trends, particularly those at fine geographic scales, can help better understand the factors driving population change in North American birds. The standard trend models for the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) were designed to estimate changes in relative abundance through time (trend) within broad geographic strata, such as countries, Bird Conservation Regions, U.S. states, and Canadian territories or provinces. Calculating trend estimates at the level of the BBS’s individual survey transects (“routes”) allows exploration of finer spatial patterns and estimation of the effects of covariates, such as habitat loss or annual weather, on both relative abundance and trend. Here, we describe four related hierarchical Bayesian models that estimate trends for individual BBS routes. All four models estimate route-level trends and relative abundances using a hierarchical structure that shares information among routes, and three of the models share information in a spatially explicit way. The spatial models use either an intrinsic Conditional Autoregressive (iCAR) structure or a distance-based Gaussian Process (GP) to estimate the spatial components. We fit all four models to data for 71 species and then, because of the intensive computations required, fit two of the models (one spatial and one non-spatial) for an additional 216 species. In a leave-future-out cross-validation, the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial models for 284 out of 287 species. The best approach to modeling the spatial components depends on the species being modeled; the Gaussian Process had the highest predictive accuracy for 69% of the species tested here and the iCAR was better for the remaining 31%. We also present two examples of route-level covariate analyses focused on spatial and temporal variation in habitat for Rufous Hummingbird (Selasphorus rufus) and Horned Grebe (Podiceps auritus). In both examples, the inclusion of covariates improved our understanding of the patterns in the rate of population change for both species. Route-level models for BBS data are useful for visualizing spatial patterns of population change, generating hypotheses on the causes of change, comparing patterns of change among regions and species, and testing hypotheses on causes of change with relevant covariates.
- Open Access
- 29 November 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithological Applications
- Vol. 126 (1)
Spatially explicit Bayesian hierarchical models improve estimates of avian population status and trends
Population trend estimates form the core of avian conservation assessments in North America and indicate important changes in the state of the natural world. The models used to estimate these trends would be more efficient and informative for conservation if they explicitly considered the spatial locations of the monitoring data. We created spatially explicit versions of some standard status and trend models applied to long-term monitoring data for birds across North America. We compared the spatial models to simpler non-spatial versions of the same models, fitting them to simulated data and real data from 3 broad-scale monitoring programs: the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS), the Christmas Bird Count, and a collection of programs we refer to as Migrating Shorebird Surveys. All the models generally reproduced the simulated trends and population trajectories when there were many data, and the spatial models performed better when there were fewer data and in locations where the local trends differed from the range-wide means. When fit to real data, the spatial models revealed interesting spatial patterns in trend, such as recent population increases along the Appalachian Mountains for the Eastern Whip-poor-will (Antrostomus vociferus), that were much less apparent in results from the non-spatial versions. The spatial models also had higher out-of-sample predictive accuracy than the non-spatial models for a selection of species using BBS data. The spatially explicit sharing of information allows fitting the models with much smaller strata, allowing for finer-grained patterns in trends. Spatially informed trends will facilitate more locally relevant conservation, highlight areas of conservation successes and challenges, and help generate and test hypotheses about the spatially dependent drivers of population change. • We created population trend models that share information on species abundance and trend among neighboring regions and compared those to models without spatial information. • Trends and population trajectories from the spatial models were more accurate, precise, and better predicted future observations than the non-spatial models. • Spatial information allows for finer-scale stratifications, producing more detailed spatial patterns and highlighting areas for local conservation. • The predictions from these models (trends, trajectories, maps of patterns in trends, etc.) will improve our understanding of the status of bird populations in time and space, and guide future research into the drivers of ongoing avian population declines.
- 29 November 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithological Applications
- Vol. 126 (1)
Open AccessSpatially explicit Bayesian hierarchical models improve estimates of avian population status and trends
Population trend estimates form the core of avian conservation assessments in North America and indicate important changes in the state of the natural world. The models used to estimate these trends would be more efficient and informative for conservation if they explicitly considered the spatial locations of the monitoring data. We created spatially explicit versions of some standard status and trend models applied to long-term monitoring data for birds across North America. We compared the spatial models to simpler non-spatial versions of the same models, fitting them to simulated data and real data from 3 broad-scale monitoring programs: the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS), the Christmas Bird Count, and a collection of programs we refer to as Migrating Shorebird Surveys. All the models generally reproduced the simulated trends and population trajectories when there were many data, and the spatial models performed better when there were fewer data and in locations where the local trends differed from the range-wide means. When fit to real data, the spatial models revealed interesting spatial patterns in trend, such as recent population increases along the Appalachian Mountains for the Eastern Whip-poor-will (Antrostomus vociferus), that were much less apparent in results from the non-spatial versions. The spatial models also had higher out-of-sample predictive accuracy than the non-spatial models for a selection of species using BBS data. The spatially explicit sharing of information allows fitting the models with much smaller strata, allowing for finer-grained patterns in trends. Spatially informed trends will facilitate more locally relevant conservation, highlight areas of conservation successes and challenges, and help generate and test hypotheses about the spatially dependent drivers of population change. • We created population trend models that share information on species abundance and trend among neighboring regions and compared those to models without spatial information. • Trends and population trajectories from the spatial models were more accurate, precise, and better predicted future observations than the non-spatial models. • Spatial information allows for finer-scale stratifications, producing more detailed spatial patterns and highlighting areas for local conservation. • The predictions from these models (trends, trajectories, maps of patterns in trends, etc.) will improve our understanding of the status of bird populations in time and space, and guide future research into the drivers of ongoing avian population declines.
- Open Access
- 27 October 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Patterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates
Spatial patterns in population trends, particularly those at finer geographic scales, can help us better understand the factors driving population change in North American birds. The standard status and trend models for the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) were designed to estimate trends within broad geographic strata, such as Bird Conservation Regions, U.S. states, and Canadian territories or provinces. Calculating trend estimates at the level of individual survey transects (“routes”) from the BBS allows us to explore finer spatial patterns and simultaneously estimate the effects of covariates, such as habitat-loss or annual weather, on both relative abundance and trend (changes in relative abundance through time). Here, we describe four related hierarchical Bayesian models that estimate trends for individual BBS routes, implemented in the probabilistic programing language Stan. All four models estimate route-level trends and relative abundances using a hierarchical structure that shares information among routes, and three of the models share information in a spatially explicit way. The spatial models use either an intrinsic Conditional Autoregressive structure or a distance-based Gaussian process to estimate the spatial components. We fit all four models to data for 71 species and then fit only two of the models (one spatial and one non-spatial) for an additional 216 species due to computational limitations. Leave-future-out cross-validation showed the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial model for 284 out of 287 species. For the species tested here, the best approach to modeling the spatial components depended on the species; the Gaussian Process had the highest predictive accuracy for 2/3 of the species tested here and the iCAR was better for the remaining 1/3. We also present two examples of route-level covariate analyses focused on spatial and temporal variation in habitat for Rufous Hummingbird (Selasphorus rufus) and Horned Grebe (Podiceps auritus). Covariates explain or affect patterns in the rate of population change for both species. Route-level models for BBS data are useful for visualizing spatial patterns of population change, generating hypotheses on the causes of change, comparing patterns of change among regions and species, and testing hypotheses on causes of change with relevant covariates.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessPatterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates
Spatial patterns in population trends, particularly those at finer geographic scales, can help us better understand the factors driving population change in North American birds. The standard status and trend models for the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) were designed to estimate trends within broad geographic strata, such as Bird Conservation Regions, U.S. states, and Canadian territories or provinces. Calculating trend estimates at the level of individual survey transects (“routes”) from the BBS allows us to explore finer spatial patterns and simultaneously estimate the effects of covariates, such as habitat-loss or annual weather, on both relative abundance and trend (changes in relative abundance through time). Here, we describe four related hierarchical Bayesian models that estimate trends for individual BBS routes, implemented in the probabilistic programing language Stan. All four models estimate route-level trends and relative abundances using a hierarchical structure that shares information among routes, and three of the models share information in a spatially explicit way. The spatial models use either an intrinsic Conditional Autoregressive structure or a distance-based Gaussian process to estimate the spatial components. We fit all four models to data for 71 species and then fit only two of the models (one spatial and one non-spatial) for an additional 216 species due to computational limitations. Leave-future-out cross-validation showed the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial model for 284 out of 287 species. For the species tested here, the best approach to modeling the spatial components depended on the species; the Gaussian Process had the highest predictive accuracy for 2/3 of the species tested here and the iCAR was better for the remaining 1/3. We also present two examples of route-level covariate analyses focused on spatial and temporal variation in habitat for Rufous Hummingbird (Selasphorus rufus) and Horned Grebe (Podiceps auritus). Covariates explain or affect patterns in the rate of population change for both species. Route-level models for BBS data are useful for visualizing spatial patterns of population change, generating hypotheses on the causes of change, comparing patterns of change among regions and species, and testing hypotheses on causes of change with relevant covariates.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 34 (2) , e2919
Substituting space for time: Bird responses to forest loss in space provide a general picture of responses over time
The practice of space‐for‐time substitution assumes that the responses of species or communities to land‐use change over space represents how they will respond to that same change over time. Space‐for‐time substitution is commonly used in both ecology and conservation, but whether the assumption produces reliable insights remains inconclusive. Here, we tested space‐for‐time substitution using data from the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) and Global Forest Change (GFC) to compare the effects of landscape‐scale forest cover on bird richness and abundance over time and space, for 25 space–time comparisons. Each comparison consisted of a landscape that experienced at least 20% forest loss over 19 years (temporal site) and a set of 15–19 landscapes (spatial sites) that represented the same forest cover gradient over space in 2019 as experienced over time in their corresponding temporal site. Across the 25 comparisons, the observed responses of forest and open‐habitat birds to forest cover over time generally aligned with their responses to forest cover over space, but with comparatively higher variability in the magnitude and direction of effect across the 25 temporal slopes than across the 25 spatial slopes. On average, the mean differences between the spatial and temporal slopes across the 25 space–time comparisons frequently overlapped with zero, suggesting that the spatial slopes are generally informative of the temporal slopes. However, we observed high variability around these mean differences, indicating that a single spatial slope is not strongly predictive of its corresponding temporal slope. We suggest that our results may be explained by annual variability in other relevant environmental factors that combine to produce complex effects on population abundances over time that are not easily captured by snapshots in space. While not being a 1:1 proxy, measuring bird responses to changes in habitat amount in space provides an idea on how birds might be expected to eventually equilibrate to similar changes in habitat amount over time. Further, analyses such as this could be potentially used to screen for cases of regional space–time mismatches where population‐limiting factors other than habitat could be playing a more important role in the population trends observed there.
- 6 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 34 (2) , e2919
Open AccessSubstituting space for time: Bird responses to forest loss in space provide a general picture of responses over time
The practice of space‐for‐time substitution assumes that the responses of species or communities to land‐use change over space represents how they will respond to that same change over time. Space‐for‐time substitution is commonly used in both ecology and conservation, but whether the assumption produces reliable insights remains inconclusive. Here, we tested space‐for‐time substitution using data from the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) and Global Forest Change (GFC) to compare the effects of landscape‐scale forest cover on bird richness and abundance over time and space, for 25 space–time comparisons. Each comparison consisted of a landscape that experienced at least 20% forest loss over 19 years (temporal site) and a set of 15–19 landscapes (spatial sites) that represented the same forest cover gradient over space in 2019 as experienced over time in their corresponding temporal site. Across the 25 comparisons, the observed responses of forest and open‐habitat birds to forest cover over time generally aligned with their responses to forest cover over space, but with comparatively higher variability in the magnitude and direction of effect across the 25 temporal slopes than across the 25 spatial slopes. On average, the mean differences between the spatial and temporal slopes across the 25 space–time comparisons frequently overlapped with zero, suggesting that the spatial slopes are generally informative of the temporal slopes. However, we observed high variability around these mean differences, indicating that a single spatial slope is not strongly predictive of its corresponding temporal slope. We suggest that our results may be explained by annual variability in other relevant environmental factors that combine to produce complex effects on population abundances over time that are not easily captured by snapshots in space. While not being a 1:1 proxy, measuring bird responses to changes in habitat amount in space provides an idea on how birds might be expected to eventually equilibrate to similar changes in habitat amount over time. Further, analyses such as this could be potentially used to screen for cases of regional space–time mismatches where population‐limiting factors other than habitat could be playing a more important role in the population trends observed there.
- Open Access
- 18 May 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Spatially explicit Bayesian hierarchical models for avian population status and trends
Population trend estimates form the core of avian conservation assessments in North America and indicate important changes in the state of the natural world. The models used to estimate these trends would be more efficient and informative for conservation if they explicitly considered the spatial locations of the monitoring data. We created spatially explicit versions of some standard status and trend models applied to long-term monitoring data for birds across North America. We compared the spatial models to simpler non-spatial versions of the same models, fitting them to simulated data and real data from three broad-scale monitoring programs: the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS), the Christmas Bird Count (CBC), and a collection of programs we refer to as Migrating Shorebird Surveys (MSS). All the models generally reproduced the true simulated trends and population trajectories when there were many data, but the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial models when there were fewer data and in locations where the local trends differed from the range-wide means. When fit to real data, the spatial models revealed interesting spatial patterns in trends that were much less apparent in results from the non-spatial versions. The spatially explicit sharing of information also means we can fit the models with much smaller strata, allowing for finer-grained patterns in trends. Spatially informed trends will facilitate more locally relevant conservation, highlight areas of conservation successes and challenges, and help generate and test hypotheses about the spatially dependent drivers of population change.
- 18 May 2023
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessSpatially explicit Bayesian hierarchical models for avian population status and trends
Population trend estimates form the core of avian conservation assessments in North America and indicate important changes in the state of the natural world. The models used to estimate these trends would be more efficient and informative for conservation if they explicitly considered the spatial locations of the monitoring data. We created spatially explicit versions of some standard status and trend models applied to long-term monitoring data for birds across North America. We compared the spatial models to simpler non-spatial versions of the same models, fitting them to simulated data and real data from three broad-scale monitoring programs: the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS), the Christmas Bird Count (CBC), and a collection of programs we refer to as Migrating Shorebird Surveys (MSS). All the models generally reproduced the true simulated trends and population trajectories when there were many data, but the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial models when there were fewer data and in locations where the local trends differed from the range-wide means. When fit to real data, the spatial models revealed interesting spatial patterns in trends that were much less apparent in results from the non-spatial versions. The spatially explicit sharing of information also means we can fit the models with much smaller strata, allowing for finer-grained patterns in trends. Spatially informed trends will facilitate more locally relevant conservation, highlight areas of conservation successes and challenges, and help generate and test hypotheses about the spatially dependent drivers of population change.
- Open Access
Point count offsets for estimating population sizes of north American landbirds
Bird monitoring in North America over several decades has generated many open databases, housing millions of structured and semi‐structured bird observations. These provide the opportunity to estimate bird densities and population sizes, once variation in factors such as underlying field methods, timing, land cover, proximity to roads, and uneven spatial coverage are accounted for. To facilitate integration across databases, we introduce NA‐POPS: Point Count Offsets for Population Sizes of North American Landbirds. NA‐POPS is a large‐scale, multi‐agency project providing an open‐source database of detectability functions for all North American landbirds. These detectability functions allow the integration of data from across disparate survey methods using the QPAD approach, which considers the probability of detection (q) and availability (p) of birds in relation to area (a) and density (d). To date, NA‐POPS has compiled over 7.1 million data points spanning 292 projects from across North America, and produced detectability functions for 338 landbird species. Here, we describe the methods used to curate these data and generate these detectability functions, as well as the open‐access nature of the resulting database.
Open AccessPoint count offsets for estimating population sizes of north American landbirds
Bird monitoring in North America over several decades has generated many open databases, housing millions of structured and semi‐structured bird observations. These provide the opportunity to estimate bird densities and population sizes, once variation in factors such as underlying field methods, timing, land cover, proximity to roads, and uneven spatial coverage are accounted for. To facilitate integration across databases, we introduce NA‐POPS: Point Count Offsets for Population Sizes of North American Landbirds. NA‐POPS is a large‐scale, multi‐agency project providing an open‐source database of detectability functions for all North American landbirds. These detectability functions allow the integration of data from across disparate survey methods using the QPAD approach, which considers the probability of detection (q) and availability (p) of birds in relation to area (a) and density (d). To date, NA‐POPS has compiled over 7.1 million data points spanning 292 projects from across North America, and produced detectability functions for 338 landbird species. Here, we describe the methods used to curate these data and generate these detectability functions, as well as the open‐access nature of the resulting database.