Emma Bartle
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Emma Bartle has a total of 52 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jill Thistlethwaite
Faculty of Health, Western Sydney University
4 shared publications - Sandra. E. Carr
Health Professions Education, School of Allied Health, The University of Western Australia, Perth, Australia
3 shared publications - Wendy Hu
Western Sydney University
3 shared publications - Jennifer Cleland
Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang Technological University
2 shared publications - Lorna Davin
Curtin Medical School Curtin University Bentley Western Australia Australia
2 shared publications - Mark Pegrum
University of Western Australia, Perth, Australia
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (12) , 1403-1404
Channelling Socrates to re‐imagine asynchronous online learning
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (12) , 1403-1404
Channelling Socrates to re‐imagine asynchronous online learning
- Open Access
- 28 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
Understanding Stress in Undergraduate Dental Education Through Student Perspectives: A Mixed‐Methods Study
Background: Dental students experience high levels of stress, which may negatively affect wellbeing, learning and clinical performance. Although stress in dental education is well documented, fewer studies have explored students' perspectives alongside their views on educational practices using mixed‐methods approaches. Methods: A mixed‐methods cross‐sectional study was conducted among third‐, fourth‐ and fifth‐year undergraduate dental students at an Australian dental school. A validated questionnaire assessed sociodemographic characteristics, perceived sources of stress, and satisfaction with educational practices. Quantitative data were analysed using non‐parametric statistical tests and correlational analysis. Free‐text responses were analysed using in vivo coding and integrated with quantitative findings. Results: Eighty students participated (response rate 62%). Examinations, managing complex treatment plans and fear of making mistakes on patients were the highest‐rated stressors. Fourth‐year students reported the highest overall stress, particularly related to clinical supervisory feedback. Stress was negatively correlated with satisfaction with educational practices ( ρ = −0.26, p = 0.02). Qualitative findings reinforced the importance of assessments, clinical responsibility and supervisory support as key stress‐related themes. Conclusions: Undergraduate dental students experience substantial stress, particularly during the transition to clinical training. Institutional factors, especially clinical supervision and feedback, appear to influence students' stress and educational experiences. Addressing these areas may support student wellbeing and optimise the clinical learning environment.
- 28 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
Open AccessUnderstanding Stress in Undergraduate Dental Education Through Student Perspectives: A Mixed‐Methods Study
Background: Dental students experience high levels of stress, which may negatively affect wellbeing, learning and clinical performance. Although stress in dental education is well documented, fewer studies have explored students' perspectives alongside their views on educational practices using mixed‐methods approaches. Methods: A mixed‐methods cross‐sectional study was conducted among third‐, fourth‐ and fifth‐year undergraduate dental students at an Australian dental school. A validated questionnaire assessed sociodemographic characteristics, perceived sources of stress, and satisfaction with educational practices. Quantitative data were analysed using non‐parametric statistical tests and correlational analysis. Free‐text responses were analysed using in vivo coding and integrated with quantitative findings. Results: Eighty students participated (response rate 62%). Examinations, managing complex treatment plans and fear of making mistakes on patients were the highest‐rated stressors. Fourth‐year students reported the highest overall stress, particularly related to clinical supervisory feedback. Stress was negatively correlated with satisfaction with educational practices ( ρ = −0.26, p = 0.02). Qualitative findings reinforced the importance of assessments, clinical responsibility and supervisory support as key stress‐related themes. Conclusions: Undergraduate dental students experience substantial stress, particularly during the transition to clinical training. Institutional factors, especially clinical supervision and feedback, appear to influence students' stress and educational experiences. Addressing these areas may support student wellbeing and optimise the clinical learning environment.
- 29 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (8) , 873-884
Widening access to medical school in Australia: A realist evaluation
Introduction: While medical school selection research has largely focused on the validity of tools and processes, less attention has been paid to the quality and impact of widening access (WA) pathways. Existing studies are often limited in scope, focusing on single institutions or interventions. This study aimed to develop transferable insights into WA selection practices through a realist evaluation across four Australian medical schools. Methods: Building on a prior realist review, we employed the RAMESES II protocol to explore how contextual factors and mechanisms interact to influence WA outcomes through four case studies. Data collection included institutional document and website reviews, semistructured interviews and focus groups (41 staff and 17 students). The evaluation framework examined context (diversity within sociocultural settings), interventions (targeted pathways and adjusted selection scores), mechanisms (institutional, dispositional and situational) and outcomes (applicant diversity, selection success). Retroductive context–intervention‐mechanism–outcome (CIMO) analysis clarified WA programme theory. Results: Two key interventions were successful across all sites: (1) targeted pathways with selection score adjustments for under‐represented groups (e.g., Indigenous, rural and low socio‐economic backgrounds) and (2) sustained partnerships with these communities to raise awareness of medicine as a viable career. These partnerships aimed to enhance applicants' dispositions and readiness for selection. However, structural changes within institutions posed significant risks to the sustainability of WA. The resulting programme theory identified five mechanisms underpinning effective WA: visionary leadership, Indigenous cultural safety, longitudinal relational engagement, tailored applicant support and preparation for selection processes. Discussion: This realist evaluation highlights how institutional commitment, shaped by federal policy and accreditation standards, has driven demographic shifts, particularly in rural and Indigenous representation, over a 10‐ to12‐year period; however, the scope of WA remains narrow. We argue for a national, coordinated approach to WA in medical education, underpinned by long‐term investment, robust evaluation and a broader conceptualisation of equity in access. WA must be embedded as a core institutional commitment rather than a peripheral initiative.
- 29 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (8) , 873-884
Widening access to medical school in Australia: A realist evaluation
Introduction: While medical school selection research has largely focused on the validity of tools and processes, less attention has been paid to the quality and impact of widening access (WA) pathways. Existing studies are often limited in scope, focusing on single institutions or interventions. This study aimed to develop transferable insights into WA selection practices through a realist evaluation across four Australian medical schools. Methods: Building on a prior realist review, we employed the RAMESES II protocol to explore how contextual factors and mechanisms interact to influence WA outcomes through four case studies. Data collection included institutional document and website reviews, semistructured interviews and focus groups (41 staff and 17 students). The evaluation framework examined context (diversity within sociocultural settings), interventions (targeted pathways and adjusted selection scores), mechanisms (institutional, dispositional and situational) and outcomes (applicant diversity, selection success). Retroductive context–intervention‐mechanism–outcome (CIMO) analysis clarified WA programme theory. Results: Two key interventions were successful across all sites: (1) targeted pathways with selection score adjustments for under‐represented groups (e.g., Indigenous, rural and low socio‐economic backgrounds) and (2) sustained partnerships with these communities to raise awareness of medicine as a viable career. These partnerships aimed to enhance applicants' dispositions and readiness for selection. However, structural changes within institutions posed significant risks to the sustainability of WA. The resulting programme theory identified five mechanisms underpinning effective WA: visionary leadership, Indigenous cultural safety, longitudinal relational engagement, tailored applicant support and preparation for selection processes. Discussion: This realist evaluation highlights how institutional commitment, shaped by federal policy and accreditation standards, has driven demographic shifts, particularly in rural and Indigenous representation, over a 10‐ to12‐year period; however, the scope of WA remains narrow. We argue for a national, coordinated approach to WA in medical education, underpinned by long‐term investment, robust evaluation and a broader conceptualisation of equity in access. WA must be embedded as a core institutional commitment rather than a peripheral initiative.
- Open Access
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (2) , 106-118
Widening access to medicine: A realist review
Introduction: Despite policy drivers and “on‐the‐ground” activity to encourage applicants from under‐represented minority groups (URMs) into medicine, their representation remains limited because of the challenge of overcoming complex societal and systemic barriers. This realist review sought to review the existing literature to identify underlying CIMOs with respect to widening access (WA) to medical school. Method: We conducted a realist literature review informed by Pawson's five iterative strategies and consistent with RAMESES standards. We searched eight electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL Plus, PsycInfo, JBI EBP, ERIC, Scopus, Proquest Public Health) to identify studies published from 1990 to April 2023 on WA pathways into medical school. We used a realist logic of analysis to examine how the mechanisms of action (M) identified for each WA intervention (I) triggered outcomes (O) related to widening access, and thus increasing cohort diversity, in different contexts (C). Results: Thirty‐two of 6300 studies identified and screened met the inclusion criteria. Most papers were from Global North countries (31/32). They reported five types of WA interventions: Minimising Bias; Modifying selection criteria; Community Collaboration; Preparing applicants for selection and studying medicine; Combining College with Medical School. Mechanisms were categorised as addressing institutional, situational, or dispositional barriers to studying medicine. Interventions were classified as addressing WA at a system‐level or individual‐level. There were four outcomes of interest: established widened selection pathways; an increased number of pathway applications for medical school; a change in offers for medical school, and increased cohort diversity. Conclusions: This review highlights that issues with access to medical education are still being seen as individual not systemic, with most reported WA interventions focussing predominantly on addressing situational and dispositional ‘barriers’ to medical education. The dominant implicit positioning of the applicant as the only aspect in the WA process in need of change reinforces the status quo.
- 8 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (2) , 106-118
Open AccessWidening access to medicine: A realist review
Introduction: Despite policy drivers and “on‐the‐ground” activity to encourage applicants from under‐represented minority groups (URMs) into medicine, their representation remains limited because of the challenge of overcoming complex societal and systemic barriers. This realist review sought to review the existing literature to identify underlying CIMOs with respect to widening access (WA) to medical school. Method: We conducted a realist literature review informed by Pawson's five iterative strategies and consistent with RAMESES standards. We searched eight electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL Plus, PsycInfo, JBI EBP, ERIC, Scopus, Proquest Public Health) to identify studies published from 1990 to April 2023 on WA pathways into medical school. We used a realist logic of analysis to examine how the mechanisms of action (M) identified for each WA intervention (I) triggered outcomes (O) related to widening access, and thus increasing cohort diversity, in different contexts (C). Results: Thirty‐two of 6300 studies identified and screened met the inclusion criteria. Most papers were from Global North countries (31/32). They reported five types of WA interventions: Minimising Bias; Modifying selection criteria; Community Collaboration; Preparing applicants for selection and studying medicine; Combining College with Medical School. Mechanisms were categorised as addressing institutional, situational, or dispositional barriers to studying medicine. Interventions were classified as addressing WA at a system‐level or individual‐level. There were four outcomes of interest: established widened selection pathways; an increased number of pathway applications for medical school; a change in offers for medical school, and increased cohort diversity. Conclusions: This review highlights that issues with access to medical education are still being seen as individual not systemic, with most reported WA interventions focussing predominantly on addressing situational and dispositional ‘barriers’ to medical education. The dominant implicit positioning of the applicant as the only aspect in the WA process in need of change reinforces the status quo.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 47 (11) , 1836-1845
Translating faculty development into practice and professional identity: The lived experience of clinical educators
There is limited evidence about whether and how faculty development programs influence clinical educators' practice and professional identity formation, and the factors which make faculty development outcomes sustained and impactful. This multi-institution interpretive phenomenological study reports on the findings from in-depth interviews of 21 clinical educators who had participated in university-based longitudinal faculty development programs. Participants perceived completing these programs had influenced their growth as clinical educators. There was evidence that participants experienced growth differently based on the program duration: all participants described growth in teaching practices but those who had completed a program of one year or longer in duration also articulated their experiences around growing in their educator identity and perspective. According to participants, the program elements that most influenced growth were embedded reflective learning activities, opportunities to learn and apply at the same time, and connections they made with other clinical educators in the program. Our findings contribute to an ongoing discussion around how clinical educators' translate learning outcomes from university-based faculty development programs into their clinical and education workplaces. Importantly, they provide insights into how longer longitudinal faculty development programs can support professional identity development and provide a viable and visible career path as a future clinician educator.
- 14 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 47 (11) , 1836-1845
Open AccessTranslating faculty development into practice and professional identity: The lived experience of clinical educators
There is limited evidence about whether and how faculty development programs influence clinical educators' practice and professional identity formation, and the factors which make faculty development outcomes sustained and impactful. This multi-institution interpretive phenomenological study reports on the findings from in-depth interviews of 21 clinical educators who had participated in university-based longitudinal faculty development programs. Participants perceived completing these programs had influenced their growth as clinical educators. There was evidence that participants experienced growth differently based on the program duration: all participants described growth in teaching practices but those who had completed a program of one year or longer in duration also articulated their experiences around growing in their educator identity and perspective. According to participants, the program elements that most influenced growth were embedded reflective learning activities, opportunities to learn and apply at the same time, and connections they made with other clinical educators in the program. Our findings contribute to an ongoing discussion around how clinical educators' translate learning outcomes from university-based faculty development programs into their clinical and education workplaces. Importantly, they provide insights into how longer longitudinal faculty development programs can support professional identity development and provide a viable and visible career path as a future clinician educator.
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 405-412
Creative Podcasting to Develop Content Knowledge and Communication Skills
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 405-412
Creative Podcasting to Develop Content Knowledge and Communication Skills
- 25 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 25 (2) , 282-290
Clinical supervisors’ reflections on their role, training needs and overall experience as dental educators
Objectives: The aims of this study were to understand the views of clinical supervisors overseeing final year dental students and investigate their perceived role, level of support and training available, and ways to improve the supervisory experience.Methods: Clinical supervisors who oversaw fifth‐year dental students in 2019 were invited to participate in an online survey. Respondents who indicated their willingness to participate were contacted for a semi‐structured interview which were analysed using Constant Comparative Methodology.Results: Sixteen supervisors completed the survey, with a response rate of 73%. Respondents reported low levels of formal training in clinical supervision (38%) and most (75%) felt further training would be beneficial for their role. While nearly all (94%) reported they had developed as a dental professional through supervision, most (63%) were not positively encouraged to develop a career as a supervisor, with tensions between health service delivery and academia identified as a key challenge. The driving motivator to supervise was a desire to teach (62.5%). Seven (44%) participants completed the semi‐structured interview. Participants’ perception of their role varied depending on career stage and clinic location. Lack of recognition and defined career pathways were the biggest challenges reported by participants.Conclusion: Retention and morale of supervisors may increase with better‐defined career pathways and meaningful professional development opportunities. There is a need to develop tailored training programs for supervisors that enable them to teach critical thinking and clinical judgement while ensuring patient safety.
- 25 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 25 (2) , 282-290
Clinical supervisors’ reflections on their role, training needs and overall experience as dental educators
Objectives: The aims of this study were to understand the views of clinical supervisors overseeing final year dental students and investigate their perceived role, level of support and training available, and ways to improve the supervisory experience.Methods: Clinical supervisors who oversaw fifth‐year dental students in 2019 were invited to participate in an online survey. Respondents who indicated their willingness to participate were contacted for a semi‐structured interview which were analysed using Constant Comparative Methodology.Results: Sixteen supervisors completed the survey, with a response rate of 73%. Respondents reported low levels of formal training in clinical supervision (38%) and most (75%) felt further training would be beneficial for their role. While nearly all (94%) reported they had developed as a dental professional through supervision, most (63%) were not positively encouraged to develop a career as a supervisor, with tensions between health service delivery and academia identified as a key challenge. The driving motivator to supervise was a desire to teach (62.5%). Seven (44%) participants completed the semi‐structured interview. Participants’ perception of their role varied depending on career stage and clinic location. Lack of recognition and defined career pathways were the biggest challenges reported by participants.Conclusion: Retention and morale of supervisors may increase with better‐defined career pathways and meaningful professional development opportunities. There is a need to develop tailored training programs for supervisors that enable them to teach critical thinking and clinical judgement while ensuring patient safety.
- 10 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 24 (4) , 790-798
Mentorship availability and needs for junior faculty members at the United States and Australian dental schools
Objectives The aims of this study were to understand the experiences junior faculty have during their professional socialisation as educators and how they perceive the need and value of mentorship. Methods A cross‐sectional qualitative study design was used. Data were collected in 2019 through a pre‐survey and focus groups with junior faculty (defined as 0‐5 years) across four institutions in Australia and the United States of America. Framework analysis was used to identify themes in the data, based on our defined research questions, and socio‐cognitive career theory was applied to guide our analysis. Results A total of 22 junior faculty participated in the study. Only one of the four institutions had a formal mentoring program for junior dental faculty. At this institution, 83% of participants indicated they were likely/extremely likely to remain in dental education. Across the three institutions where formal mentoring for junior dental faculty was not available, only 40% of participants indicated they were likely/extremely likely to remain in dental education. We identified five themes in the qualitative data: motivation for career choice, the importance of relationships, personal goals and the need for self‐direction, expectations of the role, and institutional effects. Conclusion Our findings suggest that mentoring is a critical factor in a junior faculty member’s experience entering and socializing into a career in dental education. The perceived value of mentoring emerged across all themes, both from the perspective of participants who had received formal mentoring and those who had not.
- 10 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 24 (4) , 790-798
Mentorship availability and needs for junior faculty members at the United States and Australian dental schools
Objectives The aims of this study were to understand the experiences junior faculty have during their professional socialisation as educators and how they perceive the need and value of mentorship. Methods A cross‐sectional qualitative study design was used. Data were collected in 2019 through a pre‐survey and focus groups with junior faculty (defined as 0‐5 years) across four institutions in Australia and the United States of America. Framework analysis was used to identify themes in the data, based on our defined research questions, and socio‐cognitive career theory was applied to guide our analysis. Results A total of 22 junior faculty participated in the study. Only one of the four institutions had a formal mentoring program for junior dental faculty. At this institution, 83% of participants indicated they were likely/extremely likely to remain in dental education. Across the three institutions where formal mentoring for junior dental faculty was not available, only 40% of participants indicated they were likely/extremely likely to remain in dental education. We identified five themes in the qualitative data: motivation for career choice, the importance of relationships, personal goals and the need for self‐direction, expectations of the role, and institutional effects. Conclusion Our findings suggest that mentoring is a critical factor in a junior faculty member’s experience entering and socializing into a career in dental education. The perceived value of mentoring emerged across all themes, both from the perspective of participants who had received formal mentoring and those who had not.
- 8 September 2019
- Published by Wiley in The Clinical Teacher
- Vol. 16 (6) , 559-564
Touch in health professional practice: a review
Summary: Background: The appropriate use of touch is central to effective and compassionate care in the clinical environment; however, in a time of the #MeToo movement, and with heightened awareness of child and elder abuse, the notion of physical contact is frequently viewed negatively, and may be associated with gender and power divides. The use of touch in the clinical context has increasing layers of complexity and is highly context specific. … in a time of the #MeToo movement … the notion of physical contact is frequently viewed negatively … Methods: We reviewed relevant literature, including textbooks, and have drawn on our own experiences to explore the concept and use of touch across medicine, nursing and dentistry. Results: In the context of learning and teaching in health we recognised two types of physical touch: expressive and procedural. Discussion: Our review legitimises the importance of learners and educators being equipped to consider the role and nuances of touch when engaging in professional behaviour. We provide suggestions for how this complex concept may be embedded into entry‐to‐practice curricula and approached in faculty development.
- 8 September 2019
- Published by Wiley in The Clinical Teacher
- Vol. 16 (6) , 559-564
Touch in health professional practice: a review
Summary: Background: The appropriate use of touch is central to effective and compassionate care in the clinical environment; however, in a time of the #MeToo movement, and with heightened awareness of child and elder abuse, the notion of physical contact is frequently viewed negatively, and may be associated with gender and power divides. The use of touch in the clinical context has increasing layers of complexity and is highly context specific. … in a time of the #MeToo movement … the notion of physical contact is frequently viewed negatively … Methods: We reviewed relevant literature, including textbooks, and have drawn on our own experiences to explore the concept and use of touch across medicine, nursing and dentistry. Results: In the context of learning and teaching in health we recognised two types of physical touch: expressive and procedural. Discussion: Our review legitimises the importance of learners and educators being equipped to consider the role and nuances of touch when engaging in professional behaviour. We provide suggestions for how this complex concept may be embedded into entry‐to‐practice curricula and approached in faculty development.
- 2 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 23 (4) , 507-514
Depression, anxiety and stress in a cohort of Australian dentistry students
Introduction: Dentistry students face a challenging academic and clinical curriculum that can result in depression and anxiety. While studies usually report sources of stress for dentistry students, there is less information on levels of stress. This study used the Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS‐21), to report perceived levels of depression, anxiety and stress in a cohort of Australian undergraduate dentistry students.Methods: Students enrolled in years 1‐4 of the Bachelor of Dental Science (Honours) program at The University of Queensland were invited to complete the DASS‐21 using an online questionnaire. Students completed the same questionnaire 1 year later.Results: At baseline, the mean DASS‐21 scores for this cohort (n = 179; females = 56%) were in the normal range for depression (4.69, SD 3.87) and stress (5.50, SD 3.65), and mild range for anxiety (4.25, SD 3.21). Overall, 24% (n = 42), 44% (n = 78) and 11% (n = 20) of students had moderate or above levels of depression, anxiety and stress, respectively. At 1‐year follow‐up, DASS‐21 scores were not significantly different.Conclusions: Dental students have higher levels of depression, anxiety or stress than the general population, indicating they may be at risk for greater psychological distress. The information from this study should guide curriculum and learning environment design, as well as interventions to support students through this challenging degree.
- 2 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Dental Education
- Vol. 23 (4) , 507-514
Depression, anxiety and stress in a cohort of Australian dentistry students
Introduction: Dentistry students face a challenging academic and clinical curriculum that can result in depression and anxiety. While studies usually report sources of stress for dentistry students, there is less information on levels of stress. This study used the Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS‐21), to report perceived levels of depression, anxiety and stress in a cohort of Australian undergraduate dentistry students.Methods: Students enrolled in years 1‐4 of the Bachelor of Dental Science (Honours) program at The University of Queensland were invited to complete the DASS‐21 using an online questionnaire. Students completed the same questionnaire 1 year later.Results: At baseline, the mean DASS‐21 scores for this cohort (n = 179; females = 56%) were in the normal range for depression (4.69, SD 3.87) and stress (5.50, SD 3.65), and mild range for anxiety (4.25, SD 3.21). Overall, 24% (n = 42), 44% (n = 78) and 11% (n = 20) of students had moderate or above levels of depression, anxiety and stress, respectively. At 1‐year follow‐up, DASS‐21 scores were not significantly different.Conclusions: Dental students have higher levels of depression, anxiety or stress than the general population, indicating they may be at risk for greater psychological distress. The information from this study should guide curriculum and learning environment design, as well as interventions to support students through this challenging degree.