Valerie R. Renegar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Valerie R. Renegar has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kirsti Cole
English Department, Minnesota State University, Mankato
4 shared publications Stacey K. Sowards
4 shared publicationsGeorge N. Dionisopoulos
School of Communication, San Diego State University
2 shared publicationsCharles E. Goehring
Communication , San Diego State University
1 shared publicationJennifer A. Malkowski
1 shared publicationKarl R. Smerecnik
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 31 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 145-152
Third-Wave Feminist Rhetoric in the 21st Century
With almost 25 years of growth, third-wave feminist rhetoric has created opportunities that we could not have predicted and revealed its shortcomings more clearly than we had imagined. One of the most exciting legacies of the third wave from a rhetorical perspective is the extent to which individuals grew more comfortable maintaining multiple, sometimes contradictory, identity categories simultaneously. Our initial inklings about some of the shortcomings of the third wave have also come to fruition. Notably, one of its hallmarks was a focus on individual agency, rather than collective action, as rhetorical practice. However, we argue that the lack of a coherent, shared agenda and an understanding of, and familiarity with, the principles of organizing have been detrimental to protecting rights and implementing social changes. We use the example of the Women’s March in 2017 to explore the widespread desire for change, and its failure to result in meaningful change as indicative of a feminist rhetoric more interested in popular culture and individual consciousness-raising than collective action or political activism.
- 31 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 145-152
Third-Wave Feminist Rhetoric in the 21st Century
With almost 25 years of growth, third-wave feminist rhetoric has created opportunities that we could not have predicted and revealed its shortcomings more clearly than we had imagined. One of the most exciting legacies of the third wave from a rhetorical perspective is the extent to which individuals grew more comfortable maintaining multiple, sometimes contradictory, identity categories simultaneously. Our initial inklings about some of the shortcomings of the third wave have also come to fruition. Notably, one of its hallmarks was a focus on individual agency, rather than collective action, as rhetorical practice. However, we argue that the lack of a coherent, shared agenda and an understanding of, and familiarity with, the principles of organizing have been detrimental to protecting rights and implementing social changes. We use the example of the Women’s March in 2017 to explore the widespread desire for change, and its failure to result in meaningful change as indicative of a feminist rhetoric more interested in popular culture and individual consciousness-raising than collective action or political activism.
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Refiguring Motherhood Beyond Biology
This book unpacks and interrogates dominant constructions of mothering, making use of interdisciplinary, ideological and theoretical perspectives to investigate how new rhetorics of mothering can expand the realm of maternal care-givers beyond the biological definitions of motherhood. This diverse collection is at the cutting-edge of rhetoric, feminism, and motherhood studies, and the chapters challenge the confines of biological parenting as heteronormative within the neo-liberal nuclear family. The contributors examine, how despite the diversity of parental relationships, many are excluded by the understanding of mothers biologically tied to their children. The volume seeks to expose the underpinnings of biological primacy and argues that 21st-century families and familial circumstances are ill-served by biological ideology. Topics include Re-Imagining Queer Black Motherhood, Chicana Feminist approaches to reproductive justice, the commercialization and medicalization of infertility, and ableism and motherhood. This is a unique and fascinating book suitable for students and scholars in gender studies, sexuality studies, communication studies, sociology, and cultural studies.
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Refiguring Motherhood Beyond Biology
This book unpacks and interrogates dominant constructions of mothering, making use of interdisciplinary, ideological and theoretical perspectives to investigate how new rhetorics of mothering can expand the realm of maternal care-givers beyond the biological definitions of motherhood. This diverse collection is at the cutting-edge of rhetoric, feminism, and motherhood studies, and the chapters challenge the confines of biological parenting as heteronormative within the neo-liberal nuclear family. The contributors examine, how despite the diversity of parental relationships, many are excluded by the understanding of mothers biologically tied to their children. The volume seeks to expose the underpinnings of biological primacy and argues that 21st-century families and familial circumstances are ill-served by biological ideology. Topics include Re-Imagining Queer Black Motherhood, Chicana Feminist approaches to reproductive justice, the commercialization and medicalization of infertility, and ableism and motherhood. This is a unique and fascinating book suitable for students and scholars in gender studies, sexuality studies, communication studies, sociology, and cultural studies.
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 214-229
Challenges to Neoliberal Parenting and The Rise of the Ideal Stepmother
While the wicked stepmother stereotype continues to persist, the current political moment also presents us with a new image of the stepmother in the figure of First Lady Jill Biden. Biden serves as an exemplar of the “ideal stepmother” because she fills the role of a deceased mother, practices intensive mothering, and deliberately obscures her status as a stepmother. Renegar and Cole argue that rather than stepmothers embodying the destruction of the nuclear family, they show us another way to parent. However, even the language used to normalize stepmothering is caught up in and fraught with the same social and ideological contradictions that are so present in the wicked stepmother archetype. This chapter explores an emerging version of stepmothering that attempts to, and perhaps successfully does move past the age-old trope of wickedness. They call this the Ideal Stepmother and see it embodied in the way that First Lady Dr. Jill Biden was introduced to the public at the Democratic National Convention in 2019.
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 214-229
Challenges to Neoliberal Parenting and The Rise of the Ideal Stepmother
While the wicked stepmother stereotype continues to persist, the current political moment also presents us with a new image of the stepmother in the figure of First Lady Jill Biden. Biden serves as an exemplar of the “ideal stepmother” because she fills the role of a deceased mother, practices intensive mothering, and deliberately obscures her status as a stepmother. Renegar and Cole argue that rather than stepmothers embodying the destruction of the nuclear family, they show us another way to parent. However, even the language used to normalize stepmothering is caught up in and fraught with the same social and ideological contradictions that are so present in the wicked stepmother archetype. This chapter explores an emerging version of stepmothering that attempts to, and perhaps successfully does move past the age-old trope of wickedness. They call this the Ideal Stepmother and see it embodied in the way that First Lady Dr. Jill Biden was introduced to the public at the Democratic National Convention in 2019.
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-16
Introduction: Resisting Rhetorics of Mothering, Intensive Mothering, and Biological Determinism
In May 2019, the Rhetoric Society of America held its annual summer institute at the University of Maryland, College Park. One of the workshops, led by Professors Sara Hayden and Jennifer Borda, was Motherhood Rhetorics. The intensive workshop included scholars from Communication, Composition, and Rhetoric who were interested in exploring, challenging, and understanding motherhood rhetoric. We met in a small basement room each day to theorize the directions that motherhood studies might advance in our fields of academic inquiry and struggled with the ways motherhood rhetoric tends to be treated as a niche in the field even though it is increasingly relevant in our current culture. Communication scholars and rhetoricians have worked in the past several decades to understand, explain, and expand how motherhood is rhetorically constructed. A rich space for feminist rhetorical inquiry, motherhood rhetorics construct, resist, judge, challenge, and perpetuate various caregiving relationships. However, rhetorics of motherhood rarely move into spaces of mainstream rhetorical scholarship. Like so many other “women's issues,” research concerning motherhood rhetoric tends to be published, discussed, and publicized in places reserved largely for women and feminist discourse, and in some cases, not taken seriously as scholarship at all. The global pandemic has helped illuminate the diversity of child-rearing schemas in the United States and highlighted the disproportionate work that many women must shoulder (Lukpat 2022; Moyer 2022). As a result, the need for a wider understanding of the implications of rhetoric concerning motherhood is more present now than ever before (Lenz 2020).
- 12 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-16
Introduction: Resisting Rhetorics of Mothering, Intensive Mothering, and Biological Determinism
In May 2019, the Rhetoric Society of America held its annual summer institute at the University of Maryland, College Park. One of the workshops, led by Professors Sara Hayden and Jennifer Borda, was Motherhood Rhetorics. The intensive workshop included scholars from Communication, Composition, and Rhetoric who were interested in exploring, challenging, and understanding motherhood rhetoric. We met in a small basement room each day to theorize the directions that motherhood studies might advance in our fields of academic inquiry and struggled with the ways motherhood rhetoric tends to be treated as a niche in the field even though it is increasingly relevant in our current culture. Communication scholars and rhetoricians have worked in the past several decades to understand, explain, and expand how motherhood is rhetorically constructed. A rich space for feminist rhetorical inquiry, motherhood rhetorics construct, resist, judge, challenge, and perpetuate various caregiving relationships. However, rhetorics of motherhood rarely move into spaces of mainstream rhetorical scholarship. Like so many other “women's issues,” research concerning motherhood rhetoric tends to be published, discussed, and publicized in places reserved largely for women and feminist discourse, and in some cases, not taken seriously as scholarship at all. The global pandemic has helped illuminate the diversity of child-rearing schemas in the United States and highlighted the disproportionate work that many women must shoulder (Lukpat 2022; Moyer 2022). As a result, the need for a wider understanding of the implications of rhetoric concerning motherhood is more present now than ever before (Lenz 2020).
- 2 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Women's Studies in Communication
- Vol. 42 (4) , 511-533
“Evil Is Part of the Territory”: Inventing the Stepmother in Self-Help Books
The “wicked stepmother” is a popular cultural commonplace, but when women become stepmothers, many find themselves trapped by the cliche with few resources to navigate or resist it. In this article, we examine the rhetoric of self-help books, one of the few print genres aimed at stepmothers. We argue that these texts reify a particular identity by perpetuating cultural stereotypes, reinforcing negative connotations about stepmothers, and providing inadequate solutions to common issues that arise as a result. The books reinscribe the primacy of biological mothering and relegate stepmothers to a secondary status at the same time as they subject stepmothers to the contradictory expectations of intensive mothering. The privilege of motherhood is granted, deflected, and denied across these advice books. We seek to move beyond the negative expectations of this common parenting role and point to the inadequacies of the solutions offered in self-help books to expand and diversify the visibility of and possibilities for alternative familial configurations.
- 2 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Women's Studies in Communication
- Vol. 42 (4) , 511-533
“Evil Is Part of the Territory”: Inventing the Stepmother in Self-Help Books
The “wicked stepmother” is a popular cultural commonplace, but when women become stepmothers, many find themselves trapped by the cliche with few resources to navigate or resist it. In this article, we examine the rhetoric of self-help books, one of the few print genres aimed at stepmothers. We argue that these texts reify a particular identity by perpetuating cultural stereotypes, reinforcing negative connotations about stepmothers, and providing inadequate solutions to common issues that arise as a result. The books reinscribe the primacy of biological mothering and relegate stepmothers to a secondary status at the same time as they subject stepmothers to the contradictory expectations of intensive mothering. The privilege of motherhood is granted, deflected, and denied across these advice books. We seek to move beyond the negative expectations of this common parenting role and point to the inadequacies of the solutions offered in self-help books to expand and diversify the visibility of and possibilities for alternative familial configurations.
- 5 February 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 80 (2) , 185-203
Up in the Airwith a Burkean Clown: The Comic Frame of Acceptance in Uncertain Economic Times
This analysis of Up in the Air illustrates that contracting the focus of Burke’s comic frame from the social to the individual has the potential to limit social change. We argue that focusing on the failings of individuals rather than the problems of the larger culture facilitates the acceptance of the prevailing social order. To explore our contention, we examine Burke’s concept of a comic frame and the role of the clown. We analyze how the film’s main character enacts the role of a “clown” across the three acts of the film, then conclude with observations concerning the film’s message about economic uncertainty and the implications of our analysis for the rhetorical and critical use of the comic frame and the figure of the clown.
- 5 February 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 80 (2) , 185-203
Up in the Airwith a Burkean Clown: The Comic Frame of Acceptance in Uncertain Economic Times
This analysis of Up in the Air illustrates that contracting the focus of Burke’s comic frame from the social to the individual has the potential to limit social change. We argue that focusing on the failings of individuals rather than the problems of the larger culture facilitates the acceptance of the prevailing social order. To explore our contention, we examine Burke’s concept of a comic frame and the role of the clown. We analyze how the film’s main character enacts the role of a “clown” across the three acts of the film, then conclude with observations concerning the film’s message about economic uncertainty and the implications of our analysis for the rhetorical and critical use of the comic frame and the figure of the clown.
- 25 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 77 (5) , 509-513
Critical/Cultural Scholarship and the Responsibility for Building Theory: Enduring Criticism Revisited
Communication journals appeal to an audience with an interest in communication and communication theory. Consequently, critical/cultural scholars should contribute to the body of theory in our field. This engagement with theory enables our discipline to produce “enduring criticism” that offers insight long after the fascination with particular artifacts has passed.
- 25 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 77 (5) , 509-513
Critical/Cultural Scholarship and the Responsibility for Building Theory: Enduring Criticism Revisited
Communication journals appeal to an audience with an interest in communication and communication theory. Consequently, critical/cultural scholars should contribute to the body of theory in our field. This engagement with theory enables our discipline to produce “enduring criticism” that offers insight long after the fascination with particular artifacts has passed.
- 2 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 78 (1) , 58-77
“When God Gives You AIDS … Make Lemon-AIDS”: Ironic Persona and Perspective by Incongruity in Sarah Silverman'sJesus is Magic
Sarah Silverman, one of the most polarizing and popular comedians performing today, gained notoriety with the release of the 2005 standup comedy movie Jesus is Magic. Through her discussion of sensitive social issues such as 9/11, the Holocaust, and AIDS, Silverman has developed a distinct onstage ironic persona of ignorance and innocence that juxtaposes with her controversial, humorous content. This stark contrast of delivery and content highlights a unique iteration of Kenneth Burke's concept of perspective by incongruity, originally conceptualized as only “verbal atom cracking.” Silverman's use of performance to “crack” ideas extends Burke's original notion in a new way. Throughout her ironic performance, Silverman comically and subversively discusses white privilege, post-feminism, and the trivialization of serious events as a means of highlighting questionable behaviors and attitudes. We argue that Silverman creates social and rhetorical significance through the implementation of perspective by incongruity via an ironic persona that enables her audience to adopt a comic perspective on important cultural issues.
- 2 August 2013
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Western Journal of Communication
- Vol. 78 (1) , 58-77
“When God Gives You AIDS … Make Lemon-AIDS”: Ironic Persona and Perspective by Incongruity in Sarah Silverman'sJesus is Magic
Sarah Silverman, one of the most polarizing and popular comedians performing today, gained notoriety with the release of the 2005 standup comedy movie Jesus is Magic. Through her discussion of sensitive social issues such as 9/11, the Holocaust, and AIDS, Silverman has developed a distinct onstage ironic persona of ignorance and innocence that juxtaposes with her controversial, humorous content. This stark contrast of delivery and content highlights a unique iteration of Kenneth Burke's concept of perspective by incongruity, originally conceptualized as only “verbal atom cracking.” Silverman's use of performance to “crack” ideas extends Burke's original notion in a new way. Throughout her ironic performance, Silverman comically and subversively discusses white privilege, post-feminism, and the trivialization of serious events as a means of highlighting questionable behaviors and attitudes. We argue that Silverman creates social and rhetorical significance through the implementation of perspective by incongruity via an ironic persona that enables her audience to adopt a comic perspective on important cultural issues.
- 20 September 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Southern Communication Journal
- Vol. 76 (4) , 323-341
The Dream of a Cyberpunk Future? Entelechy, Dialectical Tension, and the Comic Corrective in William Gibson'sNeuromancer
We argue the comic frame, as described by Kenneth Burke, can serve as a vehicle for critical self-reflection and social critique. William Gibson's Neuromancer is a work of cyberpunk science fiction that details a future that closely resembles the present. The book exemplifies this process of encouraging self-reflection because it calls the trends of the present into question by imagining what kind of future they will construct. Gibson's future is simultaneously exciting and devastating. The dialectical tension between these oppositional ideas opens up a discursive space for audiences to begin the process of critical self-reflection about the technological trends of contemporary society. Gibson rhetorically constructs this tension through incongruity, irony, and casuistic stretching, thus fostering a corrective perspective.
- 20 September 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Southern Communication Journal
- Vol. 76 (4) , 323-341
The Dream of a Cyberpunk Future? Entelechy, Dialectical Tension, and the Comic Corrective in William Gibson'sNeuromancer
We argue the comic frame, as described by Kenneth Burke, can serve as a vehicle for critical self-reflection and social critique. William Gibson's Neuromancer is a work of cyberpunk science fiction that details a future that closely resembles the present. The book exemplifies this process of encouraging self-reflection because it calls the trends of the present into question by imagining what kind of future they will construct. Gibson's future is simultaneously exciting and devastating. The dialectical tension between these oppositional ideas opens up a discursive space for audiences to begin the process of critical self-reflection about the technological trends of contemporary society. Gibson rhetorically constructs this tension through incongruity, irony, and casuistic stretching, thus fostering a corrective perspective.
- 2 June 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 4 (2) , 152-171
Capitalistic Agency: The Rhetoric of BP's Helios Power Campaign
- 2 June 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 4 (2) , 152-171
Capitalistic Agency: The Rhetoric of BP's Helios Power Campaign