Nicholas S. Holtzman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Nicholas S. Holtzman has a total of 68 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Brent Donnellan
6 shared publicationsMatthias R. Mehl
University of Arizona
5 shared publicationsJames W. Pennebaker
University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA
3 shared publicationsM. Brent Donnellan
Department of Psychology Michigan State University East Lansing Michigan USA
3 shared publicationsRyne A. Sherman
Hogan Assessment Systems, Tulsa, OK, USA
3 shared publicationsAllison Mary Tackman
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality Science
- Vol. 7
Personality for Self, Personality for Others: The Case of Machiavellianism and Conscientiousness
Personality can impact oneself, and it can impact other people. Here, we focus upon Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for oneself (e.g., planning and organizing for personal goals), versus conscientiousness for other people (e.g., planning interpersonal events and organizing for others’ needs). Across two preregistered studies with undergraduate participants, we developed a measure with which we reliably assessed conscientiousness for self and conscientiousness for others. Results for two self-report studies (valid n = 405 and 138 for Study 1 and Study 2) revealed a large positive correlation between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for self, virtually no correlation between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for others, and the two correlations significantly differed. Understanding the link between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness appears to depend on whether that conscientiousness is for oneself or for others. Ultimately, we hope the broader distinction between personality for self and personality for others helps to more accurately describe personality and predict behavior.
- 15 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Personality Science
- Vol. 7
Open AccessPersonality for Self, Personality for Others: The Case of Machiavellianism and Conscientiousness
Personality can impact oneself, and it can impact other people. Here, we focus upon Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for oneself (e.g., planning and organizing for personal goals), versus conscientiousness for other people (e.g., planning interpersonal events and organizing for others’ needs). Across two preregistered studies with undergraduate participants, we developed a measure with which we reliably assessed conscientiousness for self and conscientiousness for others. Results for two self-report studies (valid n = 405 and 138 for Study 1 and Study 2) revealed a large positive correlation between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for self, virtually no correlation between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness for others, and the two correlations significantly differed. Understanding the link between Machiavellianism and conscientiousness appears to depend on whether that conscientiousness is for oneself or for others. Ultimately, we hope the broader distinction between personality for self and personality for others helps to more accurately describe personality and predict behavior.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Life Narratives and the Ten Aspects of the Big Five Across Open-ended and Targeted Prompts
Personality psychology seeks to understand not only individuals’ dispositional traits, but also components of personality like self-defining life narratives. Past studies correlating traits to narrative themes have largely focused on the Big Five. In the current study, two U.S. undergraduate samples (Study 1, N = 219; Study 2, N = 107) completed the Big Five Aspect Scales, which measure the Big Five domains and ten lower-order aspects (two per domain; e.g., Conscientiousness: Industriousness and Orderliness). Participants’ 2-page life stories (Study 1) and life high point, low point, and turning point narratives (Study 2) were coded for motivational, affective, structural, and autobiographical-reasoning themes. A mini meta-analysis across the two studies revealed several aspect-specific associations with motivational themes. For example, when controlling for shared variance between the aspects, Industriousness was positively associated with agency whereas Orderliness was negatively associated with agency. Trait associations with other narrative themes varied based on narrative methodology. In particular, the open-ended prompts and expanded coding schemes implemented in Study 1 may have allowed participants to better express their dispositional traits through narrative.
- 16 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessLife Narratives and the Ten Aspects of the Big Five Across Open-ended and Targeted Prompts
Personality psychology seeks to understand not only individuals’ dispositional traits, but also components of personality like self-defining life narratives. Past studies correlating traits to narrative themes have largely focused on the Big Five. In the current study, two U.S. undergraduate samples (Study 1, N = 219; Study 2, N = 107) completed the Big Five Aspect Scales, which measure the Big Five domains and ten lower-order aspects (two per domain; e.g., Conscientiousness: Industriousness and Orderliness). Participants’ 2-page life stories (Study 1) and life high point, low point, and turning point narratives (Study 2) were coded for motivational, affective, structural, and autobiographical-reasoning themes. A mini meta-analysis across the two studies revealed several aspect-specific associations with motivational themes. For example, when controlling for shared variance between the aspects, Industriousness was positively associated with agency whereas Orderliness was negatively associated with agency. Trait associations with other narrative themes varied based on narrative methodology. In particular, the open-ended prompts and expanded coding schemes implemented in Study 1 may have allowed participants to better express their dispositional traits through narrative.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Journal of Individual Differences
- Vol. 47 (1) , 21-31
Do Personal Values Predict Music Preferences, Above and Beyond Personality Traits?
Music preferences are associated with personality traits, like the Big Five traits. We tested the idea that, above and beyond personality traits, personal values explain music preferences. Evidence from an undergraduate convenience sample in the southern US (valid n = 389) provided some evidence in favor of this prediction for some genres. For example, the Unpretentious dimension of the MUSIC model, which encompasses country music, was particularly reflected in personal values (e.g., traditional values), with personal values more than doubling the predictive capacity of the traits-only model. This study extends work showing that human values may find expression in music preferences, above and beyond the association between personality traits and music preferences.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Hogrefe Publishing Group in Journal of Individual Differences
- Vol. 47 (1) , 21-31
Do Personal Values Predict Music Preferences, Above and Beyond Personality Traits?
Music preferences are associated with personality traits, like the Big Five traits. We tested the idea that, above and beyond personality traits, personal values explain music preferences. Evidence from an undergraduate convenience sample in the southern US (valid n = 389) provided some evidence in favor of this prediction for some genres. For example, the Unpretentious dimension of the MUSIC model, which encompasses country music, was particularly reflected in personal values (e.g., traditional values), with personal values more than doubling the predictive capacity of the traits-only model. This study extends work showing that human values may find expression in music preferences, above and beyond the association between personality traits and music preferences.
- 23 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Personality
- Vol. 93 (2) , 394-411
Notes from the Underground: Seeking the top personality correlates of self‐referencing
Objective: Self‐focused language use has been frequently assumed to reflect narcissism; however, research indicates that the association between first‐person singular pronouns (i.e., “I‐talk”) and grandiose narcissism is negligible.Method: To extend this literature, we progressively identify vulnerable narcissism and rumination as positive correlates of I‐talk in five studies (valid Ns = 211, 475, 1253, 289, 1113).Results: The first study revealed positive correlates of I‐talk suggestive of vulnerable narcissism. The second study showed more directly that vulnerable narcissism was a positive correlate but that this association was attributable to shared variance with neuroticism. The third study, a preregistered effort, replicated and extended the results of the second study. The fourth and fifth studies focused on rumination in a preregistered manner.Conclusions: All the studies point to a clear distinction: While grandiose narcissism is negligibly related to I‐talk, vulnerable narcissism is positively related to I‐talk; moreover, rumination is a robust predictor of I‐talk. A research synthesis revealed the following constructs significantly capture I‐talk: depression (r = 0.10), neuroticism (r = 0.15), rumination (r = 0.14), and vulnerable narcissism (r = 0.12). The association between I‐talk and neuroticism was partially mediated by rumination, providing a testable candidate mechanism for neuroticism interventions.
- 23 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Personality
- Vol. 93 (2) , 394-411
Notes from the Underground: Seeking the top personality correlates of self‐referencing
Objective: Self‐focused language use has been frequently assumed to reflect narcissism; however, research indicates that the association between first‐person singular pronouns (i.e., “I‐talk”) and grandiose narcissism is negligible.Method: To extend this literature, we progressively identify vulnerable narcissism and rumination as positive correlates of I‐talk in five studies (valid Ns = 211, 475, 1253, 289, 1113).Results: The first study revealed positive correlates of I‐talk suggestive of vulnerable narcissism. The second study showed more directly that vulnerable narcissism was a positive correlate but that this association was attributable to shared variance with neuroticism. The third study, a preregistered effort, replicated and extended the results of the second study. The fourth and fifth studies focused on rumination in a preregistered manner.Conclusions: All the studies point to a clear distinction: While grandiose narcissism is negligibly related to I‐talk, vulnerable narcissism is positively related to I‐talk; moreover, rumination is a robust predictor of I‐talk. A research synthesis revealed the following constructs significantly capture I‐talk: depression (r = 0.10), neuroticism (r = 0.15), rumination (r = 0.14), and vulnerable narcissism (r = 0.12). The association between I‐talk and neuroticism was partially mediated by rumination, providing a testable candidate mechanism for neuroticism interventions.
- Open Access
- 8 September 2023
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 9 (1)
Individual Difference Correlates of Being Sexually Unrestricted Yet Declining an HIV Test
Which individual differences accurately predict one’s decision to get tested for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and do individuals who have regular short-term sex get tested at higher rates? Two studies—one lab study (total valid N = 69, with n = 20 who were tested) and one involving a student health center (valid N = 250, n = 4 who were tested)—involved participants (total valid N = 319, with n = 24 who got tested) taking a number of personality and individual difference measures, including the dark triad (Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy). Then, in both studies, participants had the opportunity to actually get tested for HIV. After analyzing data from Study 1, for Study 2 we preregistered the prediction that narcissistic participants would tend to (a) show disinclination to get tested for HIV, and (b) show proclivity for unrestricted short-term sexual behavior, manifesting in (c) a significant difference between these two correlations. As predicted, such a difference in correlations was evident for narcissism as well as psychopathy (the latter, however, was not predicted), suggesting that such individuals are not likely to seek HIV diagnostic information, but are taking more sexual risks. A research synthesis was consistent with these ideas (although controlling for demographic factors diminished the effects). Narcissistic and psychopathic individuals may be undetected hubs in the network of sexually active individuals with HIV. These results are silent on whether the typical HIV patient is narcissistic or psychopathic; the results merely implicate narcissistic and psychopathic traits in the spread of the virus.
- 8 September 2023
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 9 (1)
Open AccessIndividual Difference Correlates of Being Sexually Unrestricted Yet Declining an HIV Test
Which individual differences accurately predict one’s decision to get tested for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and do individuals who have regular short-term sex get tested at higher rates? Two studies—one lab study (total valid N = 69, with n = 20 who were tested) and one involving a student health center (valid N = 250, n = 4 who were tested)—involved participants (total valid N = 319, with n = 24 who got tested) taking a number of personality and individual difference measures, including the dark triad (Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy). Then, in both studies, participants had the opportunity to actually get tested for HIV. After analyzing data from Study 1, for Study 2 we preregistered the prediction that narcissistic participants would tend to (a) show disinclination to get tested for HIV, and (b) show proclivity for unrestricted short-term sexual behavior, manifesting in (c) a significant difference between these two correlations. As predicted, such a difference in correlations was evident for narcissism as well as psychopathy (the latter, however, was not predicted), suggesting that such individuals are not likely to seek HIV diagnostic information, but are taking more sexual risks. A research synthesis was consistent with these ideas (although controlling for demographic factors diminished the effects). Narcissistic and psychopathic individuals may be undetected hubs in the network of sexually active individuals with HIV. These results are silent on whether the typical HIV patient is narcissistic or psychopathic; the results merely implicate narcissistic and psychopathic traits in the spread of the virus.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
A Simulator of the Degree to Which Random Responding Leads to Biases in the Correlations Between Two Individual Differences
Random responding can inflate Type I and Type II error rates (Huang, Liu, & Bowling, 2015, Journal of Applied Psychology, 100). Type II error inflation often involves certain variables having Invalid Centered Responses And Valid Uncentered Responses (ICRAVUR; pronunciation: /aikreɪvər/). Although Huang et al. (2015) offer a set of formulas for calculating the expected bias in a correlation when such variables are present, they do not offer a way to simulate the effects. We offer two sets of Monte Carlo simulations of ICRAVUR variables. Study 1 examines the correlation between narcissism and psychopathy—thought to be a large effect. The effect was inflated (by r = .16), comparable to what the Huang formulas forecast. Study 2 examines the correlation between secure attachment and self-esteem—thought to be a large effect. The effect was inflated (by r = .26), but this time the simulation result was larger than the forecast from the Huang formulas. Thus, our simulator offers a way to test tailored hypotheses about specific variables—sometimes yielding effects more extreme than the Huang formulas. We guide the readers through software, available at the first author’s website, allowing for estimating the impact of ICRAVUR variables on any Pearson correlation.
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessA Simulator of the Degree to Which Random Responding Leads to Biases in the Correlations Between Two Individual Differences
Random responding can inflate Type I and Type II error rates (Huang, Liu, & Bowling, 2015, Journal of Applied Psychology, 100). Type II error inflation often involves certain variables having Invalid Centered Responses And Valid Uncentered Responses (ICRAVUR; pronunciation: /aikreɪvər/). Although Huang et al. (2015) offer a set of formulas for calculating the expected bias in a correlation when such variables are present, they do not offer a way to simulate the effects. We offer two sets of Monte Carlo simulations of ICRAVUR variables. Study 1 examines the correlation between narcissism and psychopathy—thought to be a large effect. The effect was inflated (by r = .16), comparable to what the Huang formulas forecast. Study 2 examines the correlation between secure attachment and self-esteem—thought to be a large effect. The effect was inflated (by r = .26), but this time the simulation result was larger than the forecast from the Huang formulas. Thus, our simulator offers a way to test tailored hypotheses about specific variables—sometimes yielding effects more extreme than the Huang formulas. We guide the readers through software, available at the first author’s website, allowing for estimating the impact of ICRAVUR variables on any Pearson correlation.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Did Narcissism Evolve?
This chapter, like each chapter in the edited book, focuses on narcissism (arrogance, exploitativeness, self-admiration, etc.). My goal is to entertain and evaluate the possibility that narcissism evolved. It is important to point out that, by way of background, just because something is morally suspect does not mean that it didn’t evolve; indeed, bad things can evolve. But despite narcissism being heritable, there is no direct evidence that narcissism is caused by specific genes, indicating that the evolutionary mechanisms are unknown. Through which pathways—such as mating pathways—does narcissism get passed onto the next generation? Narcissism appears to be positively correlated with short-term mating (e.g., promiscuity), suggesting that narcissism gets pushed into subsequent generations via promiscuous activity. The idea that narcissism evolved via short-term mating, however, is currently questionable, mainly because narcissists are not physically attractive at the unadorned level; in theory, narcissists should be attractive at the unadorned level because short-term mating situations select for raw attractiveness. All told, the prospect of narcissism having evolved is in a precarious position as of this writing. Several gaps in the literature lead to a call for more molecular genetic research and collaborative, large-scale behavioral research.
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessDid Narcissism Evolve?
This chapter, like each chapter in the edited book, focuses on narcissism (arrogance, exploitativeness, self-admiration, etc.). My goal is to entertain and evaluate the possibility that narcissism evolved. It is important to point out that, by way of background, just because something is morally suspect does not mean that it didn’t evolve; indeed, bad things can evolve. But despite narcissism being heritable, there is no direct evidence that narcissism is caused by specific genes, indicating that the evolutionary mechanisms are unknown. Through which pathways—such as mating pathways—does narcissism get passed onto the next generation? Narcissism appears to be positively correlated with short-term mating (e.g., promiscuity), suggesting that narcissism gets pushed into subsequent generations via promiscuous activity. The idea that narcissism evolved via short-term mating, however, is currently questionable, mainly because narcissists are not physically attractive at the unadorned level; in theory, narcissists should be attractive at the unadorned level because short-term mating situations select for raw attractiveness. All told, the prospect of narcissism having evolved is in a precarious position as of this writing. Several gaps in the literature lead to a call for more molecular genetic research and collaborative, large-scale behavioral research.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Roots of Narcissus: Old and New Models of the Evolution of Narcissism
The construct of narcissism encompasses attributes such as arrogance, assertiveness, a sense of authority, entitlement, exhibitionism, exploitativeness, forcefulness, self-absorption, social potency, and vanity. The purpose of this chapter is to provide an overview of the evolutionary origins of this multifaceted trait. We posit: (1) Narcissism is rooted in physical characteristics that, in turn, shape one’s psychological development; (2) narcissism is shaped by complex gene × environment interactions; and (3) narcissism is related to numerous genes with very small effects that have been subjected to selection pressures over the course of human evolutionary history. Building on this third explanation, we propose a model for the evolutionary origins of narcissism. Namely, narcissism manifests as a result of selection for attributes that promote short-term mating and dominance—facilitating reproduction and survival.
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Roots of Narcissus: Old and New Models of the Evolution of Narcissism
The construct of narcissism encompasses attributes such as arrogance, assertiveness, a sense of authority, entitlement, exhibitionism, exploitativeness, forcefulness, self-absorption, social potency, and vanity. The purpose of this chapter is to provide an overview of the evolutionary origins of this multifaceted trait. We posit: (1) Narcissism is rooted in physical characteristics that, in turn, shape one’s psychological development; (2) narcissism is shaped by complex gene × environment interactions; and (3) narcissism is related to numerous genes with very small effects that have been subjected to selection pressures over the course of human evolutionary history. Building on this third explanation, we propose a model for the evolutionary origins of narcissism. Namely, narcissism manifests as a result of selection for attributes that promote short-term mating and dominance—facilitating reproduction and survival.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
A Meta-Analysis of Correlations between Depression and First Person Singular Pronoun Use
Depression is a burden. We discuss how theories, identification, assessment, and treatment of depression are at least partially tied to the correlation between first person singular pronoun use and individual differences in depression. We conducted a meta-analysis (k = 21, N = 3,758) of these correlations, including numerous unpublished correlations from the file drawer. Our fixed effects analysis revealed a small correlation (r = .13, 95% CI = [.10 to .16]) by modern standards. The correlation was not moderated by gender, nor by whether the effect had been published. These results more firmly establish first person singular pronoun use as a linguistic marker of depression—a marker that appears to be useful across demographic lines.
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessA Meta-Analysis of Correlations between Depression and First Person Singular Pronoun Use
Depression is a burden. We discuss how theories, identification, assessment, and treatment of depression are at least partially tied to the correlation between first person singular pronoun use and individual differences in depression. We conducted a meta-analysis (k = 21, N = 3,758) of these correlations, including numerous unpublished correlations from the file drawer. Our fixed effects analysis revealed a small correlation (r = .13, 95% CI = [.10 to .16]) by modern standards. The correlation was not moderated by gender, nor by whether the effect had been published. These results more firmly establish first person singular pronoun use as a linguistic marker of depression—a marker that appears to be useful across demographic lines.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Schemas Mediate the Link between Procrastination and Depression: Results from the United States and Pakistan
The current study extended the Procrastination-Health model by examining a multiple mediation model, with two cognitive schemas (defectiveness; insufficient self-control) serving as mediators. The models were as follows: procrastination defectiveness depression; procrastination insufficient self-control depression. Participants included 412 (271 women, 141 men) United States (U.S.) and 240 (107 women, 133 men) Pakistani college students, who responded via self-report questionnaires. In the U.S. sample, results revealed a non-significant direct effect between procrastination and depression after consideration for the two cognitive schemas, suggesting the schemas completely mediated the model. Both defectiveness and insufficient self-control schemas were significant individual mediators. In the Pakistani model, results revealed a significant direct effect and indirect effect through the two cognitive schemas, indicating partial mediation. Only the indirect path through defectiveness schemas was significant in the Pakistani model. Given slight differences in the two models, a moderated-mediation model was analyzed to determine if the strength of the direct and indirect effects varied by nationality. The strength of the direct and indirect effects was not moderated by nationality. Overall, this is the first study to identify cognitive mediators in the procrastination-depression relationship. Such findings represent a significant extension of the Procrastination-Health model and offer some unique cognitive insights into culturally sensitive conceptualizations and treatments for depression.
- 6 May 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSchemas Mediate the Link between Procrastination and Depression: Results from the United States and Pakistan
The current study extended the Procrastination-Health model by examining a multiple mediation model, with two cognitive schemas (defectiveness; insufficient self-control) serving as mediators. The models were as follows: procrastination defectiveness depression; procrastination insufficient self-control depression. Participants included 412 (271 women, 141 men) United States (U.S.) and 240 (107 women, 133 men) Pakistani college students, who responded via self-report questionnaires. In the U.S. sample, results revealed a non-significant direct effect between procrastination and depression after consideration for the two cognitive schemas, suggesting the schemas completely mediated the model. Both defectiveness and insufficient self-control schemas were significant individual mediators. In the Pakistani model, results revealed a significant direct effect and indirect effect through the two cognitive schemas, indicating partial mediation. Only the indirect path through defectiveness schemas was significant in the Pakistani model. Given slight differences in the two models, a moderated-mediation model was analyzed to determine if the strength of the direct and indirect effects varied by nationality. The strength of the direct and indirect effects was not moderated by nationality. Overall, this is the first study to identify cognitive mediators in the procrastination-depression relationship. Such findings represent a significant extension of the Procrastination-Health model and offer some unique cognitive insights into culturally sensitive conceptualizations and treatments for depression.