Candice N. Hirsch
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Candice N. Hirsch has a total of 464 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nathan Michael Springer
University of Minnesota
35 shared publications - Shawn M. Kaeppler
Wisconsin Crop Innovation Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Middleton, Wisconsin 53562, USA
17 shared publications - Natalia de Leon
Department of Plant and Agroecosystem Sciences University of Wisconsin‐Madison Madison Wisconsin USA
15 shared publications - Cory D. Hirsch
Department of Plant Pathology, University of Minnesota, United States
12 shared publications - Peng Zhou
Department of Plant and Microbial Biology, University of Minnesota
12 shared publications - Sherry Flint-Garcia
USDA-ARS, University of Missouri
12 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
An open field phenomics resource for multimodal maize yield prediction across divergent environments
Temporal drone phenotyping captures crop development, but irregular flight schedules complicate comparisons across environments. We release curated imagery from 356 flights across 19 Genomes to Fields environments containing 1,180 maize ( Zea mays L.) hybrids. To evaluate its utility, we integrated functional principal components of vegetation index and weather trajectories with genomic information. Combinined genomic and phenomic kernels improved yield prediction, reaching correlations up to r = 0.501 for held-out hybrids in environments represented in training and 0.408 when environments were also withheld. Accumulated growing degree days offered no consistent predictive advantage over days after planting, and weather contributed modest, task-dependent gains. A transformer neural process learned directly from irregular observations, serving as a novel application of neural process models in agriculture. Mapping vegetation index functional principal components identified recurrent quantitative trait loci on chromosomes 3 and 7. This resource and its reproducible analyses guide the use of temporal spectral data for crop prediction and genetic discovery.
Open AccessAn open field phenomics resource for multimodal maize yield prediction across divergent environments
Temporal drone phenotyping captures crop development, but irregular flight schedules complicate comparisons across environments. We release curated imagery from 356 flights across 19 Genomes to Fields environments containing 1,180 maize ( Zea mays L.) hybrids. To evaluate its utility, we integrated functional principal components of vegetation index and weather trajectories with genomic information. Combinined genomic and phenomic kernels improved yield prediction, reaching correlations up to r = 0.501 for held-out hybrids in environments represented in training and 0.408 when environments were also withheld. Accumulated growing degree days offered no consistent predictive advantage over days after planting, and weather contributed modest, task-dependent gains. A transformer neural process learned directly from irregular observations, serving as a novel application of neural process models in agriculture. Mapping vegetation index functional principal components identified recurrent quantitative trait loci on chromosomes 3 and 7. This resource and its reproducible analyses guide the use of temporal spectral data for crop prediction and genetic discovery.
- Open Access
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in G3: Genes, Genomes, Genetics
- Vol. 16 (9)
Dissecting genetic variance structure and evaluating genomic prediction models for single-cross hybrids derived from Stiff Stalk and Non-Stiff Stalk maize heterotic groups
The early 20th-century discovery of heterosis and the establishment of heterotic groups transformed maize (Zea mays L.) into a keystone of global agriculture. However, maize breeding faces two significant challenges: the gradual decline of general combining ability (GCA) variance within heterotic groups and the impracticality of testing all possible single crosses in the early stages of a breeding program. Here, we developed genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP)-based multikernel models, using additive and two alternative nonadditive genomic relationship matrices, to estimate the variance components associated with the general combining ability of Stiff Stalk (SS) and Non-Stiff Stalk (NSS) heterotic groups and the specific combining ability arising from their crosses. We further applied these models to predict the performance of untested single-cross combinations under varying levels of parental information. We showed that the SS and NSS groups retained significant GCA variance across traits in both early- and late-maturity groups. The SS group, in contrast, exhibited no detectable GCA variance in grain yield for the intermediate-flowering subset of hybrids, highlighting a limitation for future genetic improvement. Furthermore, our results showed that GBLUP-based multikernel models effectively identified superior hybrids when parental information was available. In the absence of this information, however, these models underperformed compared to covariance-based approaches. Both nonadditive matrices yielded similar results, indicating that they capture comparable genetic relationship patterns despite their distinct formulations. Overall, this study sheds light on the future use of US maize commercial germplasm and demonstrates how GBLUP-based multikernel models can improve the efficiency of hybrid breeding programs.
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in G3: Genes, Genomes, Genetics
- Vol. 16 (9)
Open AccessDissecting genetic variance structure and evaluating genomic prediction models for single-cross hybrids derived from Stiff Stalk and Non-Stiff Stalk maize heterotic groups
The early 20th-century discovery of heterosis and the establishment of heterotic groups transformed maize (Zea mays L.) into a keystone of global agriculture. However, maize breeding faces two significant challenges: the gradual decline of general combining ability (GCA) variance within heterotic groups and the impracticality of testing all possible single crosses in the early stages of a breeding program. Here, we developed genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP)-based multikernel models, using additive and two alternative nonadditive genomic relationship matrices, to estimate the variance components associated with the general combining ability of Stiff Stalk (SS) and Non-Stiff Stalk (NSS) heterotic groups and the specific combining ability arising from their crosses. We further applied these models to predict the performance of untested single-cross combinations under varying levels of parental information. We showed that the SS and NSS groups retained significant GCA variance across traits in both early- and late-maturity groups. The SS group, in contrast, exhibited no detectable GCA variance in grain yield for the intermediate-flowering subset of hybrids, highlighting a limitation for future genetic improvement. Furthermore, our results showed that GBLUP-based multikernel models effectively identified superior hybrids when parental information was available. In the absence of this information, however, these models underperformed compared to covariance-based approaches. Both nonadditive matrices yielded similar results, indicating that they capture comparable genetic relationship patterns despite their distinct formulations. Overall, this study sheds light on the future use of US maize commercial germplasm and demonstrates how GBLUP-based multikernel models can improve the efficiency of hybrid breeding programs.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Plant Physiology
- Vol. 201 (3)
Phenomics-derived temporal maize health and environmental index enhance physiology-informed genomic prediction of yield across environments
Integrating multi-omics data, including phenomic, genomic, and environmental inputs, offers a powerful approach for enhancing maize performance and predicting grain yield. In this study, crop health was quantified using temporal NGRDI (Normalized Green Red Difference Index) trajectories collected from 16 unoccupied (unmanned) aerial vehicle or system (UAV or UAS, drones and sensors) flights (from 19 to 117 d after planting) in maize trials conducted in Texas. Crop health indices (CHIs) were calculated through area under the curve (CHIAUC) and functional principal component analysis (CHIFPCA), capturing dynamic plant health responses throughout the growing season. Heritability estimates of NGRDI fluctuated between 0.3 and 0.7, averaging 0.51 ± 0.02, reflecting consistent genetic contributions to growth dynamics. CHIs derived from a favorable (irrigated) trial in Texas effectively separated high- and low-yielding hybrids across 41 environment-tester combinations, achieving significant differentiation in 27 (CHIAUC) and 28 (CHIFPCA1) environments. In comparison, only 21 environments were differentiated when using grain yield alone. Genomic mapping of temporal NGRDI revealed key quantitative trait loci (QTLs) linked to maize growth, containing candidate genes including br2, phyC1, wus1, mads69, cct1, rap2, miR172, and gl15, associated with canopy development, flowering regulation, and drought adaptation. Integrating multi-omics data into phenomic- and environment-informed genomic prediction models improved yield prediction accuracy by approximately 18.5%, particularly for untested genotypes in both tested and untested environments. These findings demonstrate that multi-omics integration provides a scalable framework for enhancing maize performance and advancing grain yield prediction across diverse agricultural systems.
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Plant Physiology
- Vol. 201 (3)
Open AccessPhenomics-derived temporal maize health and environmental index enhance physiology-informed genomic prediction of yield across environments
Integrating multi-omics data, including phenomic, genomic, and environmental inputs, offers a powerful approach for enhancing maize performance and predicting grain yield. In this study, crop health was quantified using temporal NGRDI (Normalized Green Red Difference Index) trajectories collected from 16 unoccupied (unmanned) aerial vehicle or system (UAV or UAS, drones and sensors) flights (from 19 to 117 d after planting) in maize trials conducted in Texas. Crop health indices (CHIs) were calculated through area under the curve (CHIAUC) and functional principal component analysis (CHIFPCA), capturing dynamic plant health responses throughout the growing season. Heritability estimates of NGRDI fluctuated between 0.3 and 0.7, averaging 0.51 ± 0.02, reflecting consistent genetic contributions to growth dynamics. CHIs derived from a favorable (irrigated) trial in Texas effectively separated high- and low-yielding hybrids across 41 environment-tester combinations, achieving significant differentiation in 27 (CHIAUC) and 28 (CHIFPCA1) environments. In comparison, only 21 environments were differentiated when using grain yield alone. Genomic mapping of temporal NGRDI revealed key quantitative trait loci (QTLs) linked to maize growth, containing candidate genes including br2, phyC1, wus1, mads69, cct1, rap2, miR172, and gl15, associated with canopy development, flowering regulation, and drought adaptation. Integrating multi-omics data into phenomic- and environment-informed genomic prediction models improved yield prediction accuracy by approximately 18.5%, particularly for untested genotypes in both tested and untested environments. These findings demonstrate that multi-omics integration provides a scalable framework for enhancing maize performance and advancing grain yield prediction across diverse agricultural systems.
- Open Access
Promoter Structural Variants are Drivers of Genome-Wide Differential Expression in Maize
Background: Structural variants (SVs) are large insertions or deletions of DNA sequences. While less numerous than single nucleotide polymorphisms, SVs often account for a greater proportion of nucleotide differences between genomes. Their size and frequent association with repetitive sequences has historically hindered their detection, which has limited the ability to associate this variation with molecular and phenotypic trait variation. While some SVs have been linked to observable traits, it remains unclear whether such effects are rare or broadly distributed across the genome. Results: To test for genome-wide relationships between SVs and gene expression, we analyzed genome assemblies and transcriptomic data from 10 tissues across 26 diverse maize inbred lines. We identified SVs amongst these lines and examined variants located within the 1kb promoter region upstream of genes. Thousands of genes showed expression differences associated with promoter SVs, often in a tissue-specific manner. One common feature of these SVs was the presence of transposable element sequences. LTR retrotransposons were enriched amongst promoter SVs associated with differential expression and often reduced expression of the nearby gene. Despite widespread expression changes, we found no enrichment for specific biological functions or pathways among affected genes. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that extant TE-mediated promoter SVs play a significant role in shaping gene expression patterns across the maize genome. However, their phenotypic effects appear limited or context-dependent, suggesting that many variants may have minimal impact outside specific developmental stages or environmental conditions.
Open AccessPromoter Structural Variants are Drivers of Genome-Wide Differential Expression in Maize
Background: Structural variants (SVs) are large insertions or deletions of DNA sequences. While less numerous than single nucleotide polymorphisms, SVs often account for a greater proportion of nucleotide differences between genomes. Their size and frequent association with repetitive sequences has historically hindered their detection, which has limited the ability to associate this variation with molecular and phenotypic trait variation. While some SVs have been linked to observable traits, it remains unclear whether such effects are rare or broadly distributed across the genome. Results: To test for genome-wide relationships between SVs and gene expression, we analyzed genome assemblies and transcriptomic data from 10 tissues across 26 diverse maize inbred lines. We identified SVs amongst these lines and examined variants located within the 1kb promoter region upstream of genes. Thousands of genes showed expression differences associated with promoter SVs, often in a tissue-specific manner. One common feature of these SVs was the presence of transposable element sequences. LTR retrotransposons were enriched amongst promoter SVs associated with differential expression and often reduced expression of the nearby gene. Despite widespread expression changes, we found no enrichment for specific biological functions or pathways among affected genes. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that extant TE-mediated promoter SVs play a significant role in shaping gene expression patterns across the maize genome. However, their phenotypic effects appear limited or context-dependent, suggesting that many variants may have minimal impact outside specific developmental stages or environmental conditions.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Cereal Chemistry
Maize Kernel Composition and Morphology Influences Pericarp Retention During Nixtamalization
Background and Objectives: Pericarp retention during nixtamalization directly influences masa quality, affecting texture, machinability, and nutritional content of staple foods such as tortillas and chips. Despite its industrial relevance, the underlying kernel traits that govern pericarp retention remain poorly characterized. This study aimed to assess an existing staining method to quantify pericarp retention based on visual evaluation, and identify the compositional and morphological characteristics of maize kernels that most strongly predict pericarp retention during nixtamalization. Findings: Stain‐based scoring of pericarp retention showed moderate correlation with directly measured pericarp mass, achieving a Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.77 in the rapid cook test and 0.56 in the benchtop cook test. Pearson correlation coefficients of 18 compositional and morphological traits range from −0.294 to 0.538. Ground kernel ash content and initial pericarp quantity were the most correlated and predictive variables associated with pericarp retention. Conclusions: Stain‐based methods lack the resolution necessary for quantitative pericarp assessment. Initial pericarp quantity and ground kernel ash content are statistically correlated with nixtamalization pericarp retention. Future studies are needed to understand the mechanistic basis of these statistical relationships. Significance and Novelty: This study provides a first assessment on the impacts of morphological and compositional variation for pericarp retention, which can be built upon to develop improved varieties and cooking methods for product optimization.
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Cereal Chemistry
Open AccessMaize Kernel Composition and Morphology Influences Pericarp Retention During Nixtamalization
Background and Objectives: Pericarp retention during nixtamalization directly influences masa quality, affecting texture, machinability, and nutritional content of staple foods such as tortillas and chips. Despite its industrial relevance, the underlying kernel traits that govern pericarp retention remain poorly characterized. This study aimed to assess an existing staining method to quantify pericarp retention based on visual evaluation, and identify the compositional and morphological characteristics of maize kernels that most strongly predict pericarp retention during nixtamalization. Findings: Stain‐based scoring of pericarp retention showed moderate correlation with directly measured pericarp mass, achieving a Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.77 in the rapid cook test and 0.56 in the benchtop cook test. Pearson correlation coefficients of 18 compositional and morphological traits range from −0.294 to 0.538. Ground kernel ash content and initial pericarp quantity were the most correlated and predictive variables associated with pericarp retention. Conclusions: Stain‐based methods lack the resolution necessary for quantitative pericarp assessment. Initial pericarp quantity and ground kernel ash content are statistically correlated with nixtamalization pericarp retention. Future studies are needed to understand the mechanistic basis of these statistical relationships. Significance and Novelty: This study provides a first assessment on the impacts of morphological and compositional variation for pericarp retention, which can be built upon to develop improved varieties and cooking methods for product optimization.
- Open Access
Dissecting genetic variance structure and evaluating genomic prediction models for single-cross hybrids derived from Stiff Stalk and Non-Stiff Stalk maize heterotic groups
The early 20th-century discovery of heterosis and the establishment of heterotic groups transformed maize ( Zea mays L.) into a keystone of global agriculture. However, maize breeding faces two significant challenges: the gradual decline of general combining ability (GCA) variance within heterotic groups and the impracticality of testing all possible single crosses in the early stages of a breeding program. Here, we developed genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP)-based multi-kernel models, using additive and two alternative non-additive genomic relationship matrices, to estimate the variance components associated with the GCA of Stiff Stalk (SS) and Non-Stiff Stalk (NSS) heterotic groups and the specific combining ability (SCA) arising from their crosses. We further applied these models to predict the performance of untested single-cross combinations under varying levels of parental information. We showed that the SS and NSS groups retained significant GCA variance across traits in both early- and late-maturity groups. The SS group, in contrast, exhibited no detectable GCA variance in grain yield for the intermediate-flowering subset of hybrids, highlighting a limitation for future genetic improvement. Furthermore, our results showed that GBLUP-based multi-kernel models effectively identified superior hybrids when parental information was available. In the absence of this information, however, these models underperformed compared to covariance-based approaches. Both types of non-additive matrices produced similar results, affirming the robustness of the inferred genetic architecture. Overall, this study sheds light on the future use of US maize commercial germplasm and demonstrates how GBLUP-based multi-kernel models can improve the efficiency of hybrid breeding programs.
Open AccessDissecting genetic variance structure and evaluating genomic prediction models for single-cross hybrids derived from Stiff Stalk and Non-Stiff Stalk maize heterotic groups
The early 20th-century discovery of heterosis and the establishment of heterotic groups transformed maize ( Zea mays L.) into a keystone of global agriculture. However, maize breeding faces two significant challenges: the gradual decline of general combining ability (GCA) variance within heterotic groups and the impracticality of testing all possible single crosses in the early stages of a breeding program. Here, we developed genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP)-based multi-kernel models, using additive and two alternative non-additive genomic relationship matrices, to estimate the variance components associated with the GCA of Stiff Stalk (SS) and Non-Stiff Stalk (NSS) heterotic groups and the specific combining ability (SCA) arising from their crosses. We further applied these models to predict the performance of untested single-cross combinations under varying levels of parental information. We showed that the SS and NSS groups retained significant GCA variance across traits in both early- and late-maturity groups. The SS group, in contrast, exhibited no detectable GCA variance in grain yield for the intermediate-flowering subset of hybrids, highlighting a limitation for future genetic improvement. Furthermore, our results showed that GBLUP-based multi-kernel models effectively identified superior hybrids when parental information was available. In the absence of this information, however, these models underperformed compared to covariance-based approaches. Both types of non-additive matrices produced similar results, affirming the robustness of the inferred genetic architecture. Overall, this study sheds light on the future use of US maize commercial germplasm and demonstrates how GBLUP-based multi-kernel models can improve the efficiency of hybrid breeding programs.
- Open Access
Inter-variety competition dynamics in US inbred and hybrid maize
Variety mixtures provide a potential avenue in US cropping systems to improve yield stability and disease resistance. However, implementation of variety mixtures requires an understanding of the competitive dynamics of the crop. In this study, we examine the effects of plant competition both between and within plots through five unique experiments: 1) 5,000 diverse inbred lines in single-row plots, 2) hybrids in two-row plots developed from the above inbred lines, 3) over 4,000 hybrids measured in 141 locations in two-row plots as part of Genomes to Fields, 4) mixtures of two hybrids within a two-row plot planted across two years and five locations, and 5) mixtures of up to twenty hybrids in four-row plots in three locations. Across all experiments, we find that competitive interactions are extremely limited. Within inbred lines, height of the neighboring plot accounts for 1.2% of the variance in focal plot height. Similarly, neighbor height explains 1.7% of the variance in focal plot yield in hybrids developed from the inbred lines. The genetics of neighboring plots explains 1.55% of the variation in yield across 141 location-year environments, reinforcing the generally modest impacts of neighbor competition. In evaluating mixtures of hybrids in both two and four-row plots, we observe no yield penalty compared to conventional single hybrid plots, even with large height differentials of the hybrids included in the mixture or in mixtures of up to 20 hybrids within a plot. Finally, we observe that mixtures have more yield stability compared to conventional plots, highlighting a new avenue for increased stability in higher risk environments. The lack of yield penalty and stability benefits are promising for future investigations of mixtures that may complement each other in disease resistance or abiotic stress tolerance and increase overall yield stability in the field.
Open AccessInter-variety competition dynamics in US inbred and hybrid maize
Variety mixtures provide a potential avenue in US cropping systems to improve yield stability and disease resistance. However, implementation of variety mixtures requires an understanding of the competitive dynamics of the crop. In this study, we examine the effects of plant competition both between and within plots through five unique experiments: 1) 5,000 diverse inbred lines in single-row plots, 2) hybrids in two-row plots developed from the above inbred lines, 3) over 4,000 hybrids measured in 141 locations in two-row plots as part of Genomes to Fields, 4) mixtures of two hybrids within a two-row plot planted across two years and five locations, and 5) mixtures of up to twenty hybrids in four-row plots in three locations. Across all experiments, we find that competitive interactions are extremely limited. Within inbred lines, height of the neighboring plot accounts for 1.2% of the variance in focal plot height. Similarly, neighbor height explains 1.7% of the variance in focal plot yield in hybrids developed from the inbred lines. The genetics of neighboring plots explains 1.55% of the variation in yield across 141 location-year environments, reinforcing the generally modest impacts of neighbor competition. In evaluating mixtures of hybrids in both two and four-row plots, we observe no yield penalty compared to conventional single hybrid plots, even with large height differentials of the hybrids included in the mixture or in mixtures of up to 20 hybrids within a plot. Finally, we observe that mixtures have more yield stability compared to conventional plots, highlighting a new avenue for increased stability in higher risk environments. The lack of yield penalty and stability benefits are promising for future investigations of mixtures that may complement each other in disease resistance or abiotic stress tolerance and increase overall yield stability in the field.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 66 (1)
Optimizing population simulations to accurately parallel empirical data for digital breeding
The use of computational and data‐driven approaches to accelerate and optimize breeding programs is becoming common practice among plant breeders. Simulations allow breeders to evaluate potential changes in breeding schemes in a time‐ and cost‐efficient manner. However, accurately simulating traits that match empirical trait data remain a challenge. Here we tested if incorporating information about the genetic architecture from genome‐wide association studies (GWASs) of maize ( Zea mays L.) agronomic traits with varying heritabilities into simulations can improve the concordance between simulated and empirical data in a population of hybrids developed from crosses of 333 maize recombinant inbred lines grown in 4–11 environments. Using at least 200 nonredundant top GWAS hits as causative variants, regardless of statistical significance, resulted in mean correlations between simulated and empirical trait data of 0.397–0.616 within environments and 0.610–0.915 across environments. Reducing the GWAS‐estimated marker effect sizes in the simulations further improved concordance with empirical data. This study provides valuable insights into methods for simulating more realistic phenotypes for digital breeding to parallel empirical trait distributions and shows that these simulated traits are highly concordant with observed variance partitioning (i.e., genotype, environment, etc.) and genomic prediction performance.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Crop Science
- Vol. 66 (1)
Open AccessOptimizing population simulations to accurately parallel empirical data for digital breeding
The use of computational and data‐driven approaches to accelerate and optimize breeding programs is becoming common practice among plant breeders. Simulations allow breeders to evaluate potential changes in breeding schemes in a time‐ and cost‐efficient manner. However, accurately simulating traits that match empirical trait data remain a challenge. Here we tested if incorporating information about the genetic architecture from genome‐wide association studies (GWASs) of maize ( Zea mays L.) agronomic traits with varying heritabilities into simulations can improve the concordance between simulated and empirical data in a population of hybrids developed from crosses of 333 maize recombinant inbred lines grown in 4–11 environments. Using at least 200 nonredundant top GWAS hits as causative variants, regardless of statistical significance, resulted in mean correlations between simulated and empirical trait data of 0.397–0.616 within environments and 0.610–0.915 across environments. Reducing the GWAS‐estimated marker effect sizes in the simulations further improved concordance with empirical data. This study provides valuable insights into methods for simulating more realistic phenotypes for digital breeding to parallel empirical trait distributions and shows that these simulated traits are highly concordant with observed variance partitioning (i.e., genotype, environment, etc.) and genomic prediction performance.
- Open Access
Gene-by-Environment Interaction Significantly Drives Bacterial Endophyte Communities in Maize Stalks
Background: Many microbes are known to boost the performance of crop plants, and their use as crop treatments ("biologicals") is an active area of research and commercialization. Although many identified microbes can boost plant production under laboratory settings, most fail to translate to field settings, and even the ones that are commercialized are often unreliable. While many factors likely underlie these issues, one that has been underexplored is the idea that interactions between plants and microbes can vary across both different host genetics and different environments, and that specific combinations of host and environment can result in very different microbial outcomes. Results: To quantify how a plant microbiome can change across host genotype and environment and to determine the relative importance of these factors, we sampled maize stalks from 20 specific hybrid varieties grown at 15 locations in the United States. Using 16S rRNA gene sequencing, we find that the stalk microbiome is highly variable, with a handful of bacterial taxa conserved at broader taxonomic levels (Phylum, Class) and almost none at finer levels (Genus, Species). Local environment and gene-by-environment interactions both had consistently large and significant effects on the microbial community (measured by alpha- and beta-diversity summary statistics, individual taxa, and inferred functional capacity), whereas host genotype had little to no consistent effect across environments. We also identified specific soil factors (pH and potassium) as the most significant environmental drivers of the community, even though these communities were living inside the stalks. Conclusions: Taken together, our results indicate that while host genetics can significantly affect the stalk microbial community, these effects are almost entirely predicated on interactions with the environment. These results imply that reliable deployment of microbes for crop production will require significant investment in trials across many locations and genetic backgrounds, either to estimate the GxE effects directly or to screen for microbes whose effects are less dependent on these two factors.
Open AccessGene-by-Environment Interaction Significantly Drives Bacterial Endophyte Communities in Maize Stalks
Background: Many microbes are known to boost the performance of crop plants, and their use as crop treatments ("biologicals") is an active area of research and commercialization. Although many identified microbes can boost plant production under laboratory settings, most fail to translate to field settings, and even the ones that are commercialized are often unreliable. While many factors likely underlie these issues, one that has been underexplored is the idea that interactions between plants and microbes can vary across both different host genetics and different environments, and that specific combinations of host and environment can result in very different microbial outcomes. Results: To quantify how a plant microbiome can change across host genotype and environment and to determine the relative importance of these factors, we sampled maize stalks from 20 specific hybrid varieties grown at 15 locations in the United States. Using 16S rRNA gene sequencing, we find that the stalk microbiome is highly variable, with a handful of bacterial taxa conserved at broader taxonomic levels (Phylum, Class) and almost none at finer levels (Genus, Species). Local environment and gene-by-environment interactions both had consistently large and significant effects on the microbial community (measured by alpha- and beta-diversity summary statistics, individual taxa, and inferred functional capacity), whereas host genotype had little to no consistent effect across environments. We also identified specific soil factors (pH and potassium) as the most significant environmental drivers of the community, even though these communities were living inside the stalks. Conclusions: Taken together, our results indicate that while host genetics can significantly affect the stalk microbial community, these effects are almost entirely predicated on interactions with the environment. These results imply that reliable deployment of microbes for crop production will require significant investment in trials across many locations and genetic backgrounds, either to estimate the GxE effects directly or to screen for microbes whose effects are less dependent on these two factors.
- Open Access
Distributional Data Analysis Uncovers Hundreds of Novel and Heritable Phenomic Features from Temporal Cotton and Maize Drone Imagery
Genomic and phenomic analyses suggest additional heritable phenomic features can improve modeling of important end traits like senescence or yield. Field phenotyping generally uses trait values averaged across individual experimental units (plants or numerous plants within plots), ignoring the full distributional pattern of collected measures. Images of plants or plots, as captured by drones (unoccupied aerial vehicles / UAVs / drones), can be viewed as individual distribution functions that capture biological information. This study introduces and validates distributional data analysis in two crops and experiment types – cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.) single plant vegetation index (VI) analysis and maize ( Zea mays L.) plot-level yield predictions. In both crops, the concept of within-day variance decomposition was demonstrated. In cotton, genotypes exerted significant influences on temporal quantile functions of VIs. Maize yield prediction using distributional data with elastic-net regression indicated improvements in yield prediction between 12.7%-21.6% with quantiles outside the conventionally used median responsible for added predictive power. A novel data visualization method for per-pixel heritability allowed distributional features to be explainable and interpretable. These results have implications for future plant phenomic studies, indicating that distributional data analysis applied across temporal imagery captures novel, heritable, and interpretable biological signal that is lost when working with conventional measures of central tendency such as mean or median summary values of experimental units. Significance: Repeated aerial imaging of agricultural experiments produces image data sets that capture plant development in high spatial and temporal resolutions. Frequently, images are summarized by measures of central tendency, such as mean or median values. Here, functional data distributional methods were applied to cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.) and maize ( Zea mays L.) image data, capturing more information than standard approaches. Cotton genotypes significantly impacted distributional spectral data while in maize, distributional data enabled more accurate predictions of grain yield versus models trained with median data alone. Distributional data were more explainable by genetics, with novel data visualization techniques able to shine light on specific parts of plant imagery with high and low genetic variance.
Open AccessDistributional Data Analysis Uncovers Hundreds of Novel and Heritable Phenomic Features from Temporal Cotton and Maize Drone Imagery
Genomic and phenomic analyses suggest additional heritable phenomic features can improve modeling of important end traits like senescence or yield. Field phenotyping generally uses trait values averaged across individual experimental units (plants or numerous plants within plots), ignoring the full distributional pattern of collected measures. Images of plants or plots, as captured by drones (unoccupied aerial vehicles / UAVs / drones), can be viewed as individual distribution functions that capture biological information. This study introduces and validates distributional data analysis in two crops and experiment types – cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.) single plant vegetation index (VI) analysis and maize ( Zea mays L.) plot-level yield predictions. In both crops, the concept of within-day variance decomposition was demonstrated. In cotton, genotypes exerted significant influences on temporal quantile functions of VIs. Maize yield prediction using distributional data with elastic-net regression indicated improvements in yield prediction between 12.7%-21.6% with quantiles outside the conventionally used median responsible for added predictive power. A novel data visualization method for per-pixel heritability allowed distributional features to be explainable and interpretable. These results have implications for future plant phenomic studies, indicating that distributional data analysis applied across temporal imagery captures novel, heritable, and interpretable biological signal that is lost when working with conventional measures of central tendency such as mean or median summary values of experimental units. Significance: Repeated aerial imaging of agricultural experiments produces image data sets that capture plant development in high spatial and temporal resolutions. Frequently, images are summarized by measures of central tendency, such as mean or median values. Here, functional data distributional methods were applied to cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.) and maize ( Zea mays L.) image data, capturing more information than standard approaches. Cotton genotypes significantly impacted distributional spectral data while in maize, distributional data enabled more accurate predictions of grain yield versus models trained with median data alone. Distributional data were more explainable by genetics, with novel data visualization techniques able to shine light on specific parts of plant imagery with high and low genetic variance.