EHEdward H. Hagen

Edward H. Hagen

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Edward H. Hagen has a total of 152 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Peers link conflict-resolution reputation to social and cognitive capacities rather than the capacity to impose costs among Ethiopian forager-horticulturalists

    by Zachary H Garfield, Erik Ringen, Edward H Hagen

    Leadership emergence in socially egalitarian contexts depends on the qualities of individuals and on how others perceive their capacity to use them. Multi-Capital Leadership theory proposes that leaders deploy material, social, somatic, and neural capital to solve problems of group living by providing benefits to group members or imposing costs. Conflict resolution is one important leadership domain. We reanalyse peer rankings of 60 adults in a relatively egalitarian community of Chabu forager-horticulturalists in southwest Ethiopia. Seven peer-raters ranked participants on twelve traits identified as relevant to leadership in contemporary evolutionary theories. A previous analysis averaged rankings before modelling, obscuring differences among raters and treating positions within an ordering as continuous measurements. Here, we fitted a multivariate Plackett–Luce model directly to the individual rankings. This accounts for dependence within rankings and incorporates uncertainty into estimates. It also allows us to estimate consensus orderings and systematic variation associated with rater sex. Male and female peer-raters produced broadly similar orderings, including for conflict resolution. This could reflect actual covariation in participants’ qualities, a shared evaluative schema, or both. Peer-ranked proxies for material, social, and neural capital covaried closely and did not form clearly separable perceptual domains. The clearest descriptive contrast was between benefit-related attributes, including conflict resolution, sound decision-making, and prosociality, and cost-related attributes, including being feared and fighting. Conflict-resolution reputation was most closely associated with decision-making, kin support, respect, and intelligence, and showed no clear positive association with fighting. In these rankings, a reputation for conflict resolution was more clearly distinguished from aggression and coercion than were measures capturing the three capital domains represented in the instrument.

  • Open Access

    Menopause Averted a Midlife Energetic Crisis With Help From Older Dependent Children and Parents: A Simulation Study

    by Edward H. Hagen

    Objectives: The grandmother hypothesis proposes that ancestral women ceased reproduction midlife to instead provision their grandchildren. An alternative “two‐sex” account proposes that the high energetic burden of caring for slow‐developing offspring was met with biparental investment. Menopause evolved because the physiological costs of reproduction increased with age, yet productivity also increased with age, and the benefits of resource transfers by parents and grandparents of both sexes to adult children and their offspring eventually outweighed the diminishing benefits of continued reproduction. The “father absent” hypothesis proposes that the higher mortality rate of husbands would often have left wives without the resources to raise young children, selecting for early reproductive cessation. Juvenile production plays little role in the three hypotheses, yet subsequent studies have found it to be surprisingly high. Materials and Methods: Simulations were conducted of hunter‐gatherer energy consumption and production across the lifespan, taking account of age‐ and sex‐specific survivorship, interbirth intervals, and varying rates of foraging skill acquisition typical of contemporary foragers. Results: There is a pronounced midlife energy deficit that could be averted with the increasing production of maturing juveniles; midlife cessation of reproduction, which limited the number of mouths to feed; and energy transfers from older parents, and sometimes younger couples (e.g., brideservice). Discussion: Menopause emerges as an integral and necessary component of the unique human pattern of relatively short interbirth intervals, a long period of juvenile dependency, and extensive food sharing, supporting and extending the “two sex” and grandmother hypotheses.

  • Open Access

    Menopause averted a midlife energetic crisis with help from older children and parents: A simulation study

    by Edward H. Hagen

    The grandmother hypothesis is the most influential account of the evolution of menopause in humans, but other theories warrant investigation. Here I use simulations to investigate two theories that ground the evolution of menopause in biparental care. Kaplan et al. (2010) proposed a "two-sex" learning and skill-based account, termed the Embodied Capital Model (ECM), in which the high energetic burden of caring for multiple, slow-developing offspring was met with biparental investment. Menopause evolved because the physiological costs of pregnancy and childbirth increased with age yet productivity also increased with age, and the benefits of transferring resources to adult children and their offspring eventually outweigh the benefits of continued reproduction. Kuhle (2007) proposed the "father absent" hypothesis in which the higher mortality rate of husbands would often have left wives without the resources to raise young children, selecting for early reproductive cessation in monogamous couples. Simulations of hunter-gatherer energy consumption and production across the lifespan, taking account of age- and sex-specific survivorship, interbirth intervals, and varying rates of strength and foraging skill acquisition typical of contemporary foragers, reveal a pronounced midlife energy deficit that could be averted by ceasing reproduction midlife and receiving energy transfers from both younger couples (e.g., brideservice) and from older parents (the grandmother hypothesis). Menopause emerges as an integral and strictly necessary component of the unique human pattern of relatively short interbirth intervals and a long period of juvenile dependency, supporting and extending the ECM.

  • Open Access

    The Multi-Capital Leadership Theory: An Integrative Framework for Human Leadership Diversity

    by Zachary H Garfield, Chris von Rueden, Edward H Hagen

    Human leadership and followership take many forms, shaped by the social, economic, political, and cultural contexts of our groups and societies. Underlying this complexity, we argue, are key elements of human social psychology regarding social comparison and the resolution of coordination and collective action problems. The Multi-Capital Leadership (MCL) theory posits that leader emergence and effectiveness depend on perceptions of individuals’ abilities to provide benefits or impose costs in solving challenges of group living, through the deployment of different forms of capital: material, social, somatic (e.g., physical formidability, height, immune functionality), and neural (e.g., knowledge, intelligence, personality, supernatural abilities). We integrate this framework with a review of leadership across human societies, including in non-state and non-industrial contexts, and with novel comparative analyses of ethnographic data. This synthesis highlights how context-specific demands for coordination and collective action, and the accuracy of social comparison, shape the structure and dynamics of leadership and followership across cultures.

  • The Natural History of Child Signals of Need in Utila, Honduras

    by Michael R. Gaffney, Jessica K. Hlay, Izabel Rodríguez James, Kristen L. Syme, Steven A. Arnocky, Aaron D. Blackwell, Carolyn R. Hodges-Simeon, Edward H. Hagen

    To gain support, children use signals to communicate their needs and wants to parents. Infant signals of need, particularly infant cries, have been extensively studied in diverse populations. However, the full range of potential child signals of need, which extend beyond cries, has rarely been investigated in a single study of children of all ages. To help fill this gap, we collected mother and other primary caregiver reports of three common types of child signaling from 131 families with 263 children on Utila, a small island off the coast of Honduras. In exploratory analyses, we found that child signaling was common in both sexes and across all ages, although it decreased with age and neighborhood quality and increased with the frequency of conflict between children and caretakers. Consistent with signaling theory, children who were sad more frequently were perceived as needier within the household and were more likely to receive investment. Caregivers were less likely to respond positively in situations of family conflict or child transgressions, and more likely for injuries and illness. Our results suggest that evolutionary theories of signaling can help explain patterns of child sadness, crying, and temper tantrums.


  • Open Access

    The Meanings and Dividends of Man the Hunter

    by Vivek Vasi Venkataraman, Edward H Hagen, Duncan Stibbard Hawkes, Raymond Hames, Sheina Lew-Levy, Haneul Jang, Luke Glowacki, Jordie Hoffman, Karen Kramer, Helen Elizabeth Davis, et al.

    The phrase Man the Hunter is associated with sexist theories of human evolution, but wildly disparate use of the phrase has led to unnecessary scientific disagreement and popular misunderstanding. In this paper, we ask: what does Man the Hunter mean? We distinguish three historical meanings of Man the Hunter. First, in the early-to-mid 20th century, popular writers propagated ideas of human evolution that focused on hunting, men, aggression, rigid sexual divisions of labor, and immutable sex differences. These ideas gained widespread acceptance in popular circles and continue to be influential, but were rejected by anthropologists as early as the 1950s. Second, the Man the Hunter conference (1966) and resulting volume (1968) brought together hunter-gatherer scholars to synthesize how contemporary hunter-gatherers inform human prehistory. Third, Man the Hunter has referred to the field of hunter-gatherer behavioral ecology, which studies how human behavior is adapted to local environmental context, and has offered a critical foundation for present-day knowledge about hunting and gathering lifeways, and human origins, which we summarize. In the final section of the paper, we trace the historical development of these three meanings of Man the Hunter, situating their origins in evolutionary biology, ethnology, feminist studies, ethology, genetics, and other disciplines. While the latter two meanings were strongly intertwined, there was little intellectual exchange, and mostly antagonism, between these two and the earlier popularized meaning. Based on these disparate histories, conflating the three meanings of Man the Hunter should be avoided. Finally, we offer suggestions for improving scientific and popular discourse regarding Man the Hunter.

  • Vocalizations are ideal identity signals

    by Juliet C. Barry, Edward H. Hagen, Samuel A. Mehr

    If human societies are understood as identity groups, then our psychology should include design for the production and detection of credible identity signals. We argue that vocalizations are ideal identity signals because the human auditory system is sensitive to subtle acoustic features; vocal signals are efficient; and speech and song are highly complex, enabling the embedding therein of identity signals.

  • Open Access

    Vocalizations are ideal identity signals

    by Juliet Barry, Edward H Hagen, Samuel A Mehr

    If human societies are understood as identity groups, then human psychology should include design for the production and detection of credible identity signals. We argue that vocalizations are ideal identity signals because our auditory system is sensitive to subtle acoustic features; vocal signals are efficient; and speech and song are highly complex, enabling the embedding therein of identity signals.

  • Open Access

    Woman the Hunter? Female foragers sometimes hunt, yet gendered divisions of labor are real

    by Vivek Venkataraman, Jordie Hoffman, Raymond B. Hames, Duncan N.E. Stibbard-Hawkes, Karen Kramer, Robert Kelly, Kyle Farquharson, Edward H. Hagen, Barry S. Hewlett, Helen Elizabeth Davis, et al.

    Gendered divisions of labor are a feature of every known contemporary hunter-gatherer (forager) society. While gender roles are certainly flexible, and prominent and well-studied cases of female hunting do exist, it is more often men who hunt. A new study (Anderson et al., 2023) surveyed ethnographically known foragers and found that women hunt in 79% of foraging societies, with big-game hunting occurring in 33%. Based on this single type of labor, which is one among dozens performed in foraging societies, the authors question the existence of gendered division of labor altogether. As a diverse group of hunter-gatherer experts, we find that claims that foraging societies lack or have weak gendered divisions of labor are contradicted by empirical evidence. We conducted an in-depth examination of Anderson et al. (2023) data and methods, finding evidence of sample selection bias and numerous coding errors undermining the paper’s conclusions. Anderson et al. (2023) have started a useful dialogue to ameliorate the popular misconception that women never hunt. However, their analysis does not contradict the wide body of empirical evidence for gendered divisions of labor in foraging societies. Furthermore, a myopic focus on hunting diminishes the value of contributions that take different forms and downplays the trade-offs foragers of both sexes routinely face. We caution against ethnographic revisionism that projects Westernized conceptions of labor and its value onto foraging societies.

  • Open Access

    Homo medicus: The transition to meat eating increased pathogen pressure and the use of pharmacological plants in Homo

    by Edward H. Hagen, Aaron D. Blackwell, Aaron D. Lightner, Roger J. Sullivan

    The human lineage transitioned to a more carnivorous niche 2.6 mya and evolved a large body size and slower life history, which likely increased zoonotic pathogen pressure. Evidence for this increase includes increased zoonotic infections in modern hunter‐gatherers and bushmeat hunters, exceptionally low stomach pH compared to other primates, and divergence in immune‐related genes. These all point to change, and probably intensification, in the infectious disease environment of Homo compared to earlier hominins and other apes. At the same time, the brain, an organ in which immune responses are constrained, began to triple in size. We propose that the combination of increased zoonotic pathogen pressure and the challenges of defending a large brain and body from pathogens in a long‐lived mammal, selected for intensification of the plant‐based self‐medication strategies already in place in apes and other primates. In support, there is evidence of medicinal plant use by hominins in the middle Paleolithic, and all cultures today have sophisticated, plant‐based medical systems, add spices to food, and regularly consume psychoactive plant substances that are harmful to helminths and other pathogens. We propose that the computational challenges of discovering effective plant‐based treatments, the consequent ability to consume more energy‐rich animal foods, and the reduced reliance on energetically‐costly immune responses helped select for increased cognitive abilities and unique exchange relationships in Homo. In the story of human evolution, which has long emphasized hunting skills, medical skills had an equal role to play.