TYTolga Yıldız

Tolga Yıldız

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Tolga Yıldız has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • From Form to Ratification: Reassessing AI “Communication” After the Facebook Chatbot Episode

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This article revisits the 2017 Facebook negotiation-bot episode, widely reported as a case of artificial intelligence “inventing a language,” to ask a narrower and more sociologically precise question: under what conditions should machine output count as language rather than as task-conditioned symbol coordination? Methodologically, the article is a narrative review and conceptual synthesis organized in line with the Scale for the Assessment of Narrative Review Articles (SANRA). It draws on purposively selected work in developmental psychology, philosophy of mind, sociology, and recent research literature on large language models (LLMs). The analysis proceeds in three steps. First, it shows that the Facebook case involved a reinforcement-learning negotiation agent and cannot be generalized to contemporary LLMs without serious qualification. Second, it argues that current debates about AI “understanding” are best read not as a choice between hype and dismissal but as disputes about different kinds of competence. Third, it develops a sociological distinction between form, coordination, and ratification. Contemporary AI systems can generate linguistically legible forms and sometimes support limited coordination, but language in the stronger sense depends on public uptake, normative correction, and institutional durability. The article’s contribution lies in shifting the debate from inner-state attribution to the social conditions under which signs become language.

  • Advanced Theory of Mind in Syrian Arabic–Turkish Sequential Bilinguals and Turkish Monolinguals: Assessment Language, School-Language Attainment, and the Ecology of Bilingualism

    by Merve Nur Asan, Tolga Yıldız

    Claims about bilingual advantages in children’s social cognition remain unsettled, particularly when language proficiency and context are taken seriously. This study examined advanced theory of mind in Syrian Arabic–Turkish sequential bilinguals in Türkiye. One hundred bilingual children (11–12 years) and 50 Turkish monolingual peers completed the Reading the Mind in the Eyes Test–Child (RMET) and the Faux Pas Recognition Test–Child; bilinguals were randomly assigned to Arabic or Turkish assessment. Monolinguals outperformed bilinguals on RMET, Faux Pas, control, and total Faux Pas scores. Within the bilingual sample, Turkish assessment improved RMET performance but not Faux Pas performance. These patterns remained after adjustment for age, nonverbal reasoning, Turkish attainment, preschool duration, and household size. The findings suggest that advanced social-cognitive performance in immigrant bilinguals is shaped less by language status alone than by school-language experience and the broader ecology in which bilingualism is lived.

  • Fragmented desire? Platform intimacy and the politics of care

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This article argues that fragmentation is not the inevitable outcome of dating and hook-up apps, nor a simple synonym for the decline of intimacy. It is better understood as a recurrent tendency of platformized intimacy: the reformatting of intimate exchange into searchable, ranked, and monetizable units. Drawing on scholarship on digital intimacies, platform governance, and relational labor, the article shows how swipe-based abundance, algorithmic sorting, and continuous self-presentation can intensify provisionality, decision fatigue, and emotional exhaustion. At the same time, it rejects technological determinism by foregrounding user ambivalence, tactical agency, and the indispensable role that apps can play for LGBTQ+ users seeking safety, friendship, sexual publics, and recognition. The problem, then, is not digital intimacy as such, but the way intimate life is increasingly organized by extractive infrastructures whose benefits and harms are unevenly distributed. The article concludes by reworking an ethics of care as a political rather than nostalgic project: one that links platform accountability, differentiated safety protections, relational literacy, and labor protections for those whose intimate visibility is monetized.

  • Concepts in Motion: Toward a Relational Ontology of Meaning, Practice, and Mind

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This article advances a relational ontology of concepts (ROC) by synthesizing philosophy of language, cultural-historical psychology, developmental science, linguistics, and conceptual history into a single account of concepts as dynamic, multi-realized coordination patterns that are socially regulated and historically situated. Against views that treat concepts as fixed inner structures or mere labels, I first establish a single, coherent definition: concepts are purpose-oriented, public coordination patterns realized across distributed resources. I then develop a four-layer framework in which conceptual life emerges through coordination among embodied-affordance dynamics, grammatical-discursive scaffolds, social-normative participation, and institutional-historical infrastructures. Stability is explained by interlocking stabilization loops-practice canalization, grammatical regularities, norm enforcement, and codification-while flexibility is explained by recontextualization dynamics involving goal shifts, framing, dialogical realignment, and artifact or infrastructure innovation. I reinterpret Frege's sense/reference as publicly shared inferential profiles, integrate Wittgenstein's rule-following as the enactment and policing of public criteria, and develop a cultural-historical account in which internalization/externalization, the tension between conventional meaning (znachenie) and personal sense (smysl), and the interplay of everyday and scientific concepts reorganize conceptual practice across development. The framework yields methodological guidance for multi-stream evidence, cross-linguistic and cross-cultural predictions consonant with moderate linguistic relativity and thinking-for-speaking, and educational design principles that build coalitions across bodies, grammars, discourse, and inscriptions. I conclude by outlining limitations and a research program aimed at formalizing coalition reweighing and tracing how concepts become coordinates for coordinated action, understanding, and life in common. The result is a coherent, testable synthesis linking meaning, practice, and mind.


  • The Cognitive Foundations of Ritual Monumentality: Multicausal Pathways to the Neolithic in Southwest Asia

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This article reconceptualizes the Neolithic transformation in Southwest Asia as a cumulative and recursive process shaped by the interplay of symbolic cognition, ecological thresholds, ritual innovation, and demographic intensification. Departing from linear or monocausal models, it proposes that the emergence of agriculture, sedentism, and monumentality resulted not from discrete breakthroughs but from feedback loops between communication, cooperation, and cosmology. Drawing on recent archeological evidence from sites such as Göbekli Tepe, Körtik Tepe, WF16, and Jericho, as well as theoretical insights from cognitive evolution and ritual theory, the paper argues that symbolic institutions—ritual, architecture, and myth—were not consequences of surplus, but preconditions for its development. It distinguishes between ancient symbolic potential and the formalization of shared meaning into durable, transmittable cultural systems. Rather than treating Göbekli Tepe as an anomaly, the study situates it within a broader regional network of symbolic convergence and architectural innovation, tracing how ritual ecologies stabilized early social complexity. The article concludes by offering a multicausal, testable framework for understanding the Neolithic as a transformation in relations—between humans, environments, and shared representations.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    FROM CONSTRUCTIVISM TO CULTURAL COGNITION: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF PIAGET, VYGOTSKY, AND TOMASELLO'S THEORIES OF COGNITIVE DEVELOPMENT

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This study explores the developmental theories of Jean Piaget, Lev Vygotsky, and Michael Tomasello, three seminal figures in the field of cognitive psychology. Piaget's theory of genetic epistemology emphasizes the biological stages of cognitive development, highlighting how children construct knowledge through active interaction with their environment. Vygotsky introduces a sociocultural perspective, asserting that cognitive development is fundamentally shaped by social interactions and cultural tools, particularly language. Tomasello builds upon these foundations by integrating comparative primate studies, proposing that shared intentionality and cultural learning are unique to human cognition. Through a comprehensive examination of their theories, this study compares and critiques their contributions, illuminating the evolution of developmental psychology from individualistic to more socially and culturally integrated models. The analysis underscores the significance of integrating biological, social, and cultural factors in understanding cognitive development. The conclusion reflects on the enduring impact of these theorists on contemporary psychology and suggests directions for future research that bridges their perspectives.


  • Top Cited Papers

    The Minds We Make: A Philosophical Inquiry into Theory of Mind and Artificial Intelligence

    by Tolga Yıldız

    This theoretical paper offers an in-depth examination of the intersection between Theory of Mind (ToM) and artificial intelligence (AI), drawing on developmental psychology and philosophical analysis. By investigating the key developmental stages at which children begin to understand that others have distinct mental states, the paper provides a framework for assessing the cognitive boundaries of AI systems. It critically interrogates the pervasive human inclination to anthropomorphize machines, particularly through the attribution of complex mental states like “knowing,” “thinking,” or “believing” to AI entities that lack subjective experience. The paper argues that AI, while capable of simulating cognitive processes, operates without the conscious awareness that defines human cognition, raising profound epistemological and ethical questions. It explores the broader implications of this projection for society, considering how our conceptualization of AI affects both technological development and social structures. Ultimately, this interdisciplinary inquiry calls for a more nuanced understanding of the distinctions between human and machine cognition, advocating for responsible approaches to AI as its capabilities evolve.