Claudio Carvajal
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Claudio Carvajal has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Laurent Peyras
INRAE, RECOVER, Aix Marseille University, 13182 Aix-en-Provence, France
25 shared publications - Daniel Dias
SR Laboratory, University Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, Grenoble INP, F-38000 Grenoble, France
5 shared publications - Florence Mainguenaud
INRAE, RECOVER Aix Marseille Université Aix‐en‐Provence France
5 shared publications Laurent Peyras
5 shared publications- Marc Vuillet
Lab’Urba, Université Gustave Eiffel, Ecole des Ingénieurs de la Ville de Paris, Université Paris-Est Creteil, 75019 Paris, France
5 shared publications - Pierre Breul
Institut Pascal, SIGMA Clermont, Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS, Clermont-Ferrand, France
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Estimating flood exceedance probabilities for several levee breach scenarios for an urban riverine environment in Toronto, Canada
Assessing flood risk requires the combination of flood hazard, exposure, and vulnerability. Hence, flood hazard is a key component of flood risk assessments. As flood propagation is impacted by hydraulic structures built along the river, flood defense such as levees have gained attention as they are rarely included in large scaled flood risk assessments. However, flood events such as hurricane Katrina showcased the impact that levee failure has on flow depth, velocity, and flood extent. Therefore, its consideration should be regularly implemented in flood risk assessments. However, with current flood risk assessment methods, considering different levee failure scenarios results in numerous flood scenarios, simulations, and hazard maps. The multiplication of simulations and maps increases the complexity of flood risk management. We propose to improve flood hazard assessments by considering a single probabilistic flood map accounting for several flood events and levee breaching scenarios. For flood events enabling the performance assessment of the levee (i.e. levee breaching), we assessed levee failure probabilities, associating each levee segment to a fragility curve. Then, we defined breaching and non-breaching scenarios and ran flood simulations using HEC-RAS and its integrated parametric levee breaching model. We propose a new method to compute flood scenario probabilities and flood exceedance probabilities. The cumulative flood exceedance probability provides a curve for every location of the flooded area. Using GIS, we applied this method to the entire flooded area, resulting in an interactive flood hazard map. An application to the Etobicoke Creek located in the Greater Toronto Area showed that this new approach provides an operational levee breaching flood hazard method that can be used in integrated flood risk assessments.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEstimating flood exceedance probabilities for several levee breach scenarios for an urban riverine environment in Toronto, Canada
Assessing flood risk requires the combination of flood hazard, exposure, and vulnerability. Hence, flood hazard is a key component of flood risk assessments. As flood propagation is impacted by hydraulic structures built along the river, flood defense such as levees have gained attention as they are rarely included in large scaled flood risk assessments. However, flood events such as hurricane Katrina showcased the impact that levee failure has on flow depth, velocity, and flood extent. Therefore, its consideration should be regularly implemented in flood risk assessments. However, with current flood risk assessment methods, considering different levee failure scenarios results in numerous flood scenarios, simulations, and hazard maps. The multiplication of simulations and maps increases the complexity of flood risk management. We propose to improve flood hazard assessments by considering a single probabilistic flood map accounting for several flood events and levee breaching scenarios. For flood events enabling the performance assessment of the levee (i.e. levee breaching), we assessed levee failure probabilities, associating each levee segment to a fragility curve. Then, we defined breaching and non-breaching scenarios and ran flood simulations using HEC-RAS and its integrated parametric levee breaching model. We propose a new method to compute flood scenario probabilities and flood exceedance probabilities. The cumulative flood exceedance probability provides a curve for every location of the flooded area. Using GIS, we applied this method to the entire flooded area, resulting in an interactive flood hazard map. An application to the Etobicoke Creek located in the Greater Toronto Area showed that this new approach provides an operational levee breaching flood hazard method that can be used in integrated flood risk assessments.
- Open Access
- 16 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (1)
Probabilistic Flood Hazard Assessment for Multiple Flood and Levee Breaching Scenarios: A Case Study of Etobicoke Creek, Canada
Flood hazard assessment is crucial to mitigate the risks associated with flooding. Integrating levee failure scenarios into these assessments should improve the evaluation of flood risks and enhance the resilience of communities and infrastructure. This research presents a probabilistic flood hazard approach to assess levee failure and its impact on flood hazard. Our method includes a comprehensive assessment of backward erosion and overflowing failure mechanisms, integrated within a 1D/2D hydraulic model that simulates flood propagation and levee breaching. We calculate the cumulative probability of flood depth and velocity considering various scenarios, taking into account levee failure breaching for various failure mechanisms and several flood intensities. We apply the method to a residential area along Etobicoke Creek in Ontario, Canada. The results highlight which levee segment has the most impact on flood hazard, emphasizing the importance of incorporating levee failure scenarios in flood hazard assessments. The cumulative probability curve provides a more holistic result in locating the most hazardous areas rather than considering one return period or one failure mechanism. It can be expended to every location of the protected area, allowing for the creation of a probabilistic map for a desired probability.
- 16 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (1)
Open AccessProbabilistic Flood Hazard Assessment for Multiple Flood and Levee Breaching Scenarios: A Case Study of Etobicoke Creek, Canada
Flood hazard assessment is crucial to mitigate the risks associated with flooding. Integrating levee failure scenarios into these assessments should improve the evaluation of flood risks and enhance the resilience of communities and infrastructure. This research presents a probabilistic flood hazard approach to assess levee failure and its impact on flood hazard. Our method includes a comprehensive assessment of backward erosion and overflowing failure mechanisms, integrated within a 1D/2D hydraulic model that simulates flood propagation and levee breaching. We calculate the cumulative probability of flood depth and velocity considering various scenarios, taking into account levee failure breaching for various failure mechanisms and several flood intensities. We apply the method to a residential area along Etobicoke Creek in Ontario, Canada. The results highlight which levee segment has the most impact on flood hazard, emphasizing the importance of incorporating levee failure scenarios in flood hazard assessments. The cumulative probability curve provides a more holistic result in locating the most hazardous areas rather than considering one return period or one failure mechanism. It can be expended to every location of the protected area, allowing for the creation of a probabilistic map for a desired probability.
- Open Access
Integrating Multiple Levee-Breaching Scenarios and Flood Events to Develop a Probabilistic Spatial Flood-Hazard Map of Etobicoke Creek in Toronto, Canada
Forecasting flood characteristics (e.g., water levels and velocity) is a growing concern due to climate change. It is therefore necessary to consider the stability conditions of earthen levees used to mitigate floods during a flood risk assessment. This technical note presents a method to assess probabilistic flood hazard that takes into account levee failures, for a levee located along Etobicoke Creek in Toronto, Canada. We compute flood scenario probabilities resulting from multiple flood scenarios that accounts for both the levee failures across the length of the levee, and different levee-failure mechanisms (e.g., backward erosion and overtopping). Then, for each location of the flooded area, we compute a cumulative flood exceedance probability curve for flood depth and velocity. This method provides a flood-hazard map (depth and velocity) for a given probability and probabilistic maps for given values of depth or velocity.
Open AccessIntegrating Multiple Levee-Breaching Scenarios and Flood Events to Develop a Probabilistic Spatial Flood-Hazard Map of Etobicoke Creek in Toronto, Canada
Forecasting flood characteristics (e.g., water levels and velocity) is a growing concern due to climate change. It is therefore necessary to consider the stability conditions of earthen levees used to mitigate floods during a flood risk assessment. This technical note presents a method to assess probabilistic flood hazard that takes into account levee failures, for a levee located along Etobicoke Creek in Toronto, Canada. We compute flood scenario probabilities resulting from multiple flood scenarios that accounts for both the levee failures across the length of the levee, and different levee-failure mechanisms (e.g., backward erosion and overtopping). Then, for each location of the flooded area, we compute a cumulative flood exceedance probability curve for flood depth and velocity. This method provides a flood-hazard map (depth and velocity) for a given probability and probabilistic maps for given values of depth or velocity.
- Open Access
- 31 May 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 14 (11) , 4749
Pore Water Pressure Prediction Based on Machine Learning Methods—Application to an Earth Dam Case
Pore water pressure (PWP) response is significant for evaluating the earth dams’ stability, and PWPs are, therefore, generally monitored. However, due to the soil heterogeneity and its non-linear behavior within earths, the PWP is usually difficult to estimate and predict accurately in order to detect a pathology or anomaly in the behavior of an embankment dam. This study endeavors to tackle this challenge through the application of diverse machine learning (ML) techniques in estimating the PWP within an existing earth dam. The methods employed include random forest (RF) combined with simulated annealing (SA), multilayer perceptron (MLP), standard recurrent neural networks (RNNs), and gated recurrent unit (GRU). The prediction capability of these techniques was gauged using metrics such as the coefficient of determination (R2), mean square error (MSE), and CPU training time. It was found that all the considered ML methods could give satisfactory results for the PWP estimation. Upon comparing these methods within the case study, the findings suggest that, in this study, multilayer perceptron (MLP) gives the most accurate PWP prediction, achieving the highest coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.99) and the lowest mean square error (MSE = 0.0087) metrics. A sensitivity analysis is then presented to evaluate the models’ robustness and the hyperparameter’s influence on the performance of the prediction model.
- 31 May 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 14 (11) , 4749
Open AccessPore Water Pressure Prediction Based on Machine Learning Methods—Application to an Earth Dam Case
Pore water pressure (PWP) response is significant for evaluating the earth dams’ stability, and PWPs are, therefore, generally monitored. However, due to the soil heterogeneity and its non-linear behavior within earths, the PWP is usually difficult to estimate and predict accurately in order to detect a pathology or anomaly in the behavior of an embankment dam. This study endeavors to tackle this challenge through the application of diverse machine learning (ML) techniques in estimating the PWP within an existing earth dam. The methods employed include random forest (RF) combined with simulated annealing (SA), multilayer perceptron (MLP), standard recurrent neural networks (RNNs), and gated recurrent unit (GRU). The prediction capability of these techniques was gauged using metrics such as the coefficient of determination (R2), mean square error (MSE), and CPU training time. It was found that all the considered ML methods could give satisfactory results for the PWP estimation. Upon comparing these methods within the case study, the findings suggest that, in this study, multilayer perceptron (MLP) gives the most accurate PWP prediction, achieving the highest coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.99) and the lowest mean square error (MSE = 0.0087) metrics. A sensitivity analysis is then presented to evaluate the models’ robustness and the hyperparameter’s influence on the performance of the prediction model.
- Open Access
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Probabilistic analysis of backward erosion piping in an embankment dam considering the spatial variability of soil properties
The spatial variability of soil seepage parameters is an essential component of the uncertainty of earth dams. This paper presents a method for probabilistic backward erosion analysis that considers the spatial variability of seepage parameters in earth dams to assess the distribution of the Factor of Safety (FoS) and the failure probability (Pf). In this study, the Karhunen-Loeve method is used to generate Random Fields (RFs) of soil hydraulic properties, and Monte Carlo simulations (MCs) are used to generate realisations of these RFs, which are then introduced into the numerical model to assess the spatial variability of the seepage analysis results. The hydraulic gradient distribution is compared with the critical hydraulic gradient to assess the FoS and the Pf due to backward erosion at each point of the dam. This study also presents the effect of water level H, permeability anisotropy coefficient ξ, and RFs parameters (permeability covariance COVKs, correlation length Lh & Lv) on the FoS and Pf of Backward Erosion Piping (BEP). The results illustrate that the failure probability Pf increases with H, COVKs and ξ. The failure probability Pf is not sensitive to the vertical correlation length, but may decrease with the horizontal correlation length. Additionally, the study discusses on the potential location of the initiation of internal erosion as well as the results obtained with criteria based on the local and global hydraulic gradient.
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessProbabilistic analysis of backward erosion piping in an embankment dam considering the spatial variability of soil properties
The spatial variability of soil seepage parameters is an essential component of the uncertainty of earth dams. This paper presents a method for probabilistic backward erosion analysis that considers the spatial variability of seepage parameters in earth dams to assess the distribution of the Factor of Safety (FoS) and the failure probability (Pf). In this study, the Karhunen-Loeve method is used to generate Random Fields (RFs) of soil hydraulic properties, and Monte Carlo simulations (MCs) are used to generate realisations of these RFs, which are then introduced into the numerical model to assess the spatial variability of the seepage analysis results. The hydraulic gradient distribution is compared with the critical hydraulic gradient to assess the FoS and the Pf due to backward erosion at each point of the dam. This study also presents the effect of water level H, permeability anisotropy coefficient ξ, and RFs parameters (permeability covariance COVKs, correlation length Lh & Lv) on the FoS and Pf of Backward Erosion Piping (BEP). The results illustrate that the failure probability Pf increases with H, COVKs and ξ. The failure probability Pf is not sensitive to the vertical correlation length, but may decrease with the horizontal correlation length. Additionally, the study discusses on the potential location of the initiation of internal erosion as well as the results obtained with criteria based on the local and global hydraulic gradient.
- Open Access
- 20 October 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Geotechnics
- Vol. 3 (4) , 1117-1134
Stability Analysis of Earth Dam Slopes Based on the Second-Order Work Criterion in Finite Element Modeling
Slope instability issues could cause severe damage and endanger the population, especially when dams are concerned. Over the past years, more and more refined numerical approaches have been proposed to evaluate the slope stability. However, a criterion based on the lack of numerical convergence is generally considered to compute the safety factor with this kind of approaches, which may result in a dramatic increase in the overall computation time for the probabilistic assessment of the safety factor (e.g., using Monte Carlo simulations that require the automation of a large number of simulations). This paper proposes an original approach coupling the shear strength reduction technique with the second-order work criterion. This approach is implemented in the open finite element software Cast3M, version 22.0. The relevance and efficiency of the developed approach is illustrated with two case studies: a heuristic slope and an existing earth dam. Safety factors similar to those calculated by classical approaches are obtained, but without pushing the calculation to the point of non-convergence. Among other advantages described in the paper, the proposed approach makes it possible to compute safety factors using a rational and physically based criterion, while facilitating probabilistic calculations.
- 20 October 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Geotechnics
- Vol. 3 (4) , 1117-1134
Open AccessStability Analysis of Earth Dam Slopes Based on the Second-Order Work Criterion in Finite Element Modeling
Slope instability issues could cause severe damage and endanger the population, especially when dams are concerned. Over the past years, more and more refined numerical approaches have been proposed to evaluate the slope stability. However, a criterion based on the lack of numerical convergence is generally considered to compute the safety factor with this kind of approaches, which may result in a dramatic increase in the overall computation time for the probabilistic assessment of the safety factor (e.g., using Monte Carlo simulations that require the automation of a large number of simulations). This paper proposes an original approach coupling the shear strength reduction technique with the second-order work criterion. This approach is implemented in the open finite element software Cast3M, version 22.0. The relevance and efficiency of the developed approach is illustrated with two case studies: a heuristic slope and an existing earth dam. Safety factors similar to those calculated by classical approaches are obtained, but without pushing the calculation to the point of non-convergence. Among other advantages described in the paper, the proposed approach makes it possible to compute safety factors using a rational and physically based criterion, while facilitating probabilistic calculations.
- 28 July 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Computers and Geotechnics
- Vol. 162
Stochastic seepage analysis in embankment dams using different types of random fields
- 28 July 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Computers and Geotechnics
- Vol. 162
Stochastic seepage analysis in embankment dams using different types of random fields
- Open Access
- 17 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 16 (4)
A probabilistic approach to levee reliability based on sliding, backward erosion and overflowing mechanisms: Application to an inspired Canadian case study
Improving protection against fluvial floods requires a better estimation of levee failure. We developed an assessment method of levee failure probabilities for sliding, backward erosion, and overflowing each represented by fragility curves. We tested two approaches to aggregate those fragility curves into a global fragility curve respectively using: an enveloping curve and Monte‐Carlo simulations. We implemented this approach to earthen levee reliability for several flood return periods to the Bow River in Calgary, Canada. We used limit equilibrium method to estimate the safety factor of the levee segment and Monte‐Carlo simulations to estimate sliding probabilities. We used Terzaghi's critical hydraulic gradient to estimate backward erosion failure probabilities. The estimation of overflowing probabilities required expert judgment. We discussed how the choice of the hydraulic gradient area and the consideration of a steady state or transient model impact backward erosion failure probabilities. The results showed for our study case that, even though the transient model is a closer representation of reality, the levee saturation parameter has little impact on hydraulic gradient values, by extension, on sliding and backward erosion failure probabilities. The Monte‐Carlo aggregated fragility curve is more realistic than the envelop curve of the failure mechanisms for an equivalent computation time.
- 17 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 16 (4)
Open AccessA probabilistic approach to levee reliability based on sliding, backward erosion and overflowing mechanisms: Application to an inspired Canadian case study
Improving protection against fluvial floods requires a better estimation of levee failure. We developed an assessment method of levee failure probabilities for sliding, backward erosion, and overflowing each represented by fragility curves. We tested two approaches to aggregate those fragility curves into a global fragility curve respectively using: an enveloping curve and Monte‐Carlo simulations. We implemented this approach to earthen levee reliability for several flood return periods to the Bow River in Calgary, Canada. We used limit equilibrium method to estimate the safety factor of the levee segment and Monte‐Carlo simulations to estimate sliding probabilities. We used Terzaghi's critical hydraulic gradient to estimate backward erosion failure probabilities. The estimation of overflowing probabilities required expert judgment. We discussed how the choice of the hydraulic gradient area and the consideration of a steady state or transient model impact backward erosion failure probabilities. The results showed for our study case that, even though the transient model is a closer representation of reality, the levee saturation parameter has little impact on hydraulic gradient values, by extension, on sliding and backward erosion failure probabilities. The Monte‐Carlo aggregated fragility curve is more realistic than the envelop curve of the failure mechanisms for an equivalent computation time.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Mapping the impact of levee failure on flood risks: A Toronto case study
Urban areas are frequently built along rivers and earthen levees are commonly used to protect areas from fluvial floods. Levees are designed to protect assets from flooding, however, they deteriorate over time. Maintenance checks are required to maintain their efficacy but even in good condition, a levee structure may fail during a flood, hence flood risk assessments in fluvial areas require an investigation of levee failures, e.g. by overtopping, erosion, or sliding. In this research, we investigate the failure probability due to backward erosion of an adapted levee in the Etobicoke Creek watershed, in Toronto, Canada. The study proposes an adapted levee as the residential area is often flooded. Backward erosion is the most probable and challenging failure mechanism for our case study based on the levee shape and soil type. For this probabilistic study, the levee was modelled using GeoStudio, which produces seepage analysis from geotechnical and hydrological parameters. The seepage analysis provides hydraulic gradients from which we determine the failure probability of backward erosion based on a critical hydraulic gradient value. To obtain the flood hazard, we use a steady flow hydraulic model (HEC-RAS) to simulate the 350-years return period flow through the River. We compare two backward failure scenarios: one with a levee breach and one without, to better understand how failure of the levee will impact flood risks, and therefore, highlighting the importance of on-going levee maintenance. To obtain flood risk maps, the flood hazard (i.e., flood extent) is combined with flood exposure. The flood exposure includes land-use type (residential, commercial, etc.) and demographic information. Flood hazard and exposure data are combined using ArcGIS. The flood hazard and exposure rasters are reclassified in a new scale to determine flood risk. We then overlay the rasters to determine the spatial distribution of flood risk for both scenarios. We compare the resulting flood risk maps and calculate the change in flood risks for the area protected by the levee. Accounting for potential failure of infrastructure in flood risk mapping results in more accurate risk estimations. We also demonstrate the positive impact of the levee.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMapping the impact of levee failure on flood risks: A Toronto case study
Urban areas are frequently built along rivers and earthen levees are commonly used to protect areas from fluvial floods. Levees are designed to protect assets from flooding, however, they deteriorate over time. Maintenance checks are required to maintain their efficacy but even in good condition, a levee structure may fail during a flood, hence flood risk assessments in fluvial areas require an investigation of levee failures, e.g. by overtopping, erosion, or sliding. In this research, we investigate the failure probability due to backward erosion of an adapted levee in the Etobicoke Creek watershed, in Toronto, Canada. The study proposes an adapted levee as the residential area is often flooded. Backward erosion is the most probable and challenging failure mechanism for our case study based on the levee shape and soil type. For this probabilistic study, the levee was modelled using GeoStudio, which produces seepage analysis from geotechnical and hydrological parameters. The seepage analysis provides hydraulic gradients from which we determine the failure probability of backward erosion based on a critical hydraulic gradient value. To obtain the flood hazard, we use a steady flow hydraulic model (HEC-RAS) to simulate the 350-years return period flow through the River. We compare two backward failure scenarios: one with a levee breach and one without, to better understand how failure of the levee will impact flood risks, and therefore, highlighting the importance of on-going levee maintenance. To obtain flood risk maps, the flood hazard (i.e., flood extent) is combined with flood exposure. The flood exposure includes land-use type (residential, commercial, etc.) and demographic information. Flood hazard and exposure data are combined using ArcGIS. The flood hazard and exposure rasters are reclassified in a new scale to determine flood risk. We then overlay the rasters to determine the spatial distribution of flood risk for both scenarios. We compare the resulting flood risk maps and calculate the change in flood risks for the area protected by the levee. Accounting for potential failure of infrastructure in flood risk mapping results in more accurate risk estimations. We also demonstrate the positive impact of the levee.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Geotechnics
- Vol. 3 (2) , 254-277
Dynamic Properties of a Compacted Residual Soil from the West Indies
This paper presents a laboratory investigation of the strain-dependent cyclic properties of a compacted tropical residual soil as measured in a resonant column and cyclic triaxial testing program. The mechanical properties were evaluated with respect to cyclic shear strain amplitude, initial void ratio, and confining pressure. It was shown that the existing models for the prediction of shear modulus reduction and damping ratio curves were not pertinent in the case of the compacted residual soil studied. Empirical equations were developed for the small-strain shear modulus and the normalized shear modulus, damping ratio, and pore water pressure ratio curves for void ratios between e = 1.00 and e = 1.50 and mean effective pressures of = 50−300 kPa. The comparison of the models to the measured values suggest that the uncertainties associated with each of these models are lower than 20% of the predicted values. The results were established as part of a project for the construction of an embankment dam in the West Indies. However, the methodology as well as the model formulation framework presented in the article can be generalized to other residual soils and applied in all fields of geotechnical engineering.- 28 April 2023
- Published by MDPI AG in Geotechnics
- Vol. 3 (2) , 254-277
Open AccessDynamic Properties of a Compacted Residual Soil from the West Indies
This paper presents a laboratory investigation of the strain-dependent cyclic properties of a compacted tropical residual soil as measured in a resonant column and cyclic triaxial testing program. The mechanical properties were evaluated with respect to cyclic shear strain amplitude, initial void ratio, and confining pressure. It was shown that the existing models for the prediction of shear modulus reduction and damping ratio curves were not pertinent in the case of the compacted residual soil studied. Empirical equations were developed for the small-strain shear modulus and the normalized shear modulus, damping ratio, and pore water pressure ratio curves for void ratios between e = 1.00 and e = 1.50 and mean effective pressures of = 50−300 kPa. The comparison of the models to the measured values suggest that the uncertainties associated with each of these models are lower than 20% of the predicted values. The results were established as part of a project for the construction of an embankment dam in the West Indies. However, the methodology as well as the model formulation framework presented in the article can be generalized to other residual soils and applied in all fields of geotechnical engineering.