Elizabeth H. Shadwick
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Elizabeth H. Shadwick has a total of 962 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Matthew A. Chamberlain
CSIRO Environment, Castray Esplanade, Hobart, Tasmania 7004, Australia
13 shared publications - Pearse James Buchanan
Biosphere Sciences and Engineering, Carnegie Institution for Science
13 shared publications - Bronte Tilbrook
CSIRO Environment, Castray Esplanade, Hobart, Tasmania 7004, Australia
11 shared publications - Tyler Rohr
Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, University of Tasmania Hobart Tas Australia
11 shared publications H. Thomas
Department of Oceanography, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
10 shared publications- Xiang Yang
University of Tasmania, Institute of Marine and Antarctic Studies
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 November 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in AGU Advances
- Vol. 7 (8)
Challenges in Relating Surface Productivity to Deep Organic Carbon Flux in the Subantarctic Zone: Implications for Climate Mitigation Strategies
The efficiency and stability of the biological carbon pump (BCP) set the ocean's capacity to sequester carbon on climate‐relevant timescales. Despite its importance, the BCP is difficult to observe directly making quantification of its efficiency challenging. Here, we present multi‐year sediment trap records from two sites in the iron‐limited Subantarctic Zone (SAZ): the Southern Ocean Time Series (SOTS; south of Australia) and the Subantarctic Mooring (SAM; east of Aotearoa New Zealand). Particle fluxes are combined with satellite‐based net primary production (NPP) and BGC‐Argo float‐based estimates of particulate organic carbon (POC) concentration to investigate the links between variability at the surface and the delivery of material to depth. Despite higher NPP at SAM, annual POC flux was not significantly different at the two sites. Correlation of monthly NPP anomalies with POC flux anomalies from sediment traps indicates a complex temporal mismatch between surface variability and arrival of material at depth, whereas BGC‐Argo float‐based estimates of POC concentration indicate coherence within the water column. These results show that verifying a link between variations in surface productivity and carbon sequestration is challenging with current methodologies, highlighting the difficulty in evaluating and verifying proposed climate mitigation strategies that aim to enhance deep ocean carbon sequestration by using ocean fertilization.
- 14 November 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in AGU Advances
- Vol. 7 (8)
Open AccessChallenges in Relating Surface Productivity to Deep Organic Carbon Flux in the Subantarctic Zone: Implications for Climate Mitigation Strategies
The efficiency and stability of the biological carbon pump (BCP) set the ocean's capacity to sequester carbon on climate‐relevant timescales. Despite its importance, the BCP is difficult to observe directly making quantification of its efficiency challenging. Here, we present multi‐year sediment trap records from two sites in the iron‐limited Subantarctic Zone (SAZ): the Southern Ocean Time Series (SOTS; south of Australia) and the Subantarctic Mooring (SAM; east of Aotearoa New Zealand). Particle fluxes are combined with satellite‐based net primary production (NPP) and BGC‐Argo float‐based estimates of particulate organic carbon (POC) concentration to investigate the links between variability at the surface and the delivery of material to depth. Despite higher NPP at SAM, annual POC flux was not significantly different at the two sites. Correlation of monthly NPP anomalies with POC flux anomalies from sediment traps indicates a complex temporal mismatch between surface variability and arrival of material at depth, whereas BGC‐Argo float‐based estimates of POC concentration indicate coherence within the water column. These results show that verifying a link between variations in surface productivity and carbon sequestration is challenging with current methodologies, highlighting the difficulty in evaluating and verifying proposed climate mitigation strategies that aim to enhance deep ocean carbon sequestration by using ocean fertilization.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "Global Carbon Budget 2026"
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "Global Carbon Budget 2026"
- Open Access
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-146
Global Carbon Budget 2026
Accurate assessment of anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions and their partitioning among the atmosphere, ocean, and terrestrial biosphere in a changing climate is critical to better understand the global carbon cycle, supporting the development of climate policies, and project future climate change. Here we describe and synthesise datasets and methodologies to quantify the five major components of the global carbon budget and their uncertainties. Fossil CO2 emissions (EFOS) are based on energy and cement production data. Emissions from land-use change (ELUC) are estimated by bookkeeping models based on land-use data. The global atmospheric CO2 growth rate (GATM) is computed from changes in concentration measured at surface stations. The global net uptake of CO2 by the ocean (SOCEAN) is estimated with global ocean biogeochemistry models and observation-based fCO2-products. The global net uptake of CO2 by the land (SLAND) is estimated with dynamic global vegetation models. Additional lines of evidence are provided by atmospheric inversions, atmospheric oxygen measurements, ocean interior observation-based estimates, and Earth System Models. The sum of all sources and sinks results in the carbon budget imbalance (BIM), a measure of imperfect data and incomplete understanding of the contemporary carbon cycle. All uncertainties are reported as ±1σ. For the year 2025, EFOS increased by 1.2% relative to 2024, with fossil emissions at 10.5 ± 0.5 GtC yr-1 (including the cement carbonation sink, 0.2 GtC yr-1), ELUC was 1.2 ± 0.7 GtC yr-1, for total anthropogenic CO2 emissions of 11.7 ± 0.9 GtC yr-1 (42.8 ± 3.2 GtCO2 yr-1). Also, for 2025, GATM was 4.4 ± 0.2 GtC yr-1 (2.06 ± 0.1 ppm yr-1), 3.6 GtC lower than the record high 2024 growth rate. SOCEAN was 3.2 ± 0.7 GtC yr-1 and SLAND was 3.6 ± 0.9 GtC yr-1, with a small BIM (0.5 GtC yr-1). The global atmospheric CO2 concentration averaged over 2025 reached 425.6 ± 0.1 ppm. Preliminary data for 2026 suggest a decrease in EFOS relative to 2025 of 0.40% (–1.5% to +0.6%) globally, and atmospheric CO2 concentration increasing by 2.2 ppm reaching 427.7 ppm, 54% above the pre-industrial level (around 278 ppm in 1750). Overall, the mean and trend in the components of the global carbon budget are consistently estimated over the period 1959–2025, with a small positive overall budget imbalance, (0.6 GtC yr-1 averaged over the period 1959–2025), although discrepancies of up to around 1 GtC yr-1 persist for the representation of annual to decadal variability in CO2 fluxes. Comparison of estimates from multiple approaches and observations shows: (1) a persistent large uncertainty in the estimate of land-use change emissions, (2) a low agreement between the different estimates on the magnitude of the land CO2 flux, particularly in the northern extra-tropics, and (3) a discrepancy between the different estimates on the mean ocean sink and its trend. This living data update documents changes in methods and datasets applied to this most-recent global carbon budget as well as evolving community understanding of the global carbon cycle. The data presented in this work are available at https://doi.org/10.18160/GCP-2026 (Friedlingstein et al., 2026b).
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-146
Open AccessGlobal Carbon Budget 2026
Accurate assessment of anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions and their partitioning among the atmosphere, ocean, and terrestrial biosphere in a changing climate is critical to better understand the global carbon cycle, supporting the development of climate policies, and project future climate change. Here we describe and synthesise datasets and methodologies to quantify the five major components of the global carbon budget and their uncertainties. Fossil CO2 emissions (EFOS) are based on energy and cement production data. Emissions from land-use change (ELUC) are estimated by bookkeeping models based on land-use data. The global atmospheric CO2 growth rate (GATM) is computed from changes in concentration measured at surface stations. The global net uptake of CO2 by the ocean (SOCEAN) is estimated with global ocean biogeochemistry models and observation-based fCO2-products. The global net uptake of CO2 by the land (SLAND) is estimated with dynamic global vegetation models. Additional lines of evidence are provided by atmospheric inversions, atmospheric oxygen measurements, ocean interior observation-based estimates, and Earth System Models. The sum of all sources and sinks results in the carbon budget imbalance (BIM), a measure of imperfect data and incomplete understanding of the contemporary carbon cycle. All uncertainties are reported as ±1σ. For the year 2025, EFOS increased by 1.2% relative to 2024, with fossil emissions at 10.5 ± 0.5 GtC yr-1 (including the cement carbonation sink, 0.2 GtC yr-1), ELUC was 1.2 ± 0.7 GtC yr-1, for total anthropogenic CO2 emissions of 11.7 ± 0.9 GtC yr-1 (42.8 ± 3.2 GtCO2 yr-1). Also, for 2025, GATM was 4.4 ± 0.2 GtC yr-1 (2.06 ± 0.1 ppm yr-1), 3.6 GtC lower than the record high 2024 growth rate. SOCEAN was 3.2 ± 0.7 GtC yr-1 and SLAND was 3.6 ± 0.9 GtC yr-1, with a small BIM (0.5 GtC yr-1). The global atmospheric CO2 concentration averaged over 2025 reached 425.6 ± 0.1 ppm. Preliminary data for 2026 suggest a decrease in EFOS relative to 2025 of 0.40% (–1.5% to +0.6%) globally, and atmospheric CO2 concentration increasing by 2.2 ppm reaching 427.7 ppm, 54% above the pre-industrial level (around 278 ppm in 1750). Overall, the mean and trend in the components of the global carbon budget are consistently estimated over the period 1959–2025, with a small positive overall budget imbalance, (0.6 GtC yr-1 averaged over the period 1959–2025), although discrepancies of up to around 1 GtC yr-1 persist for the representation of annual to decadal variability in CO2 fluxes. Comparison of estimates from multiple approaches and observations shows: (1) a persistent large uncertainty in the estimate of land-use change emissions, (2) a low agreement between the different estimates on the magnitude of the land CO2 flux, particularly in the northern extra-tropics, and (3) a discrepancy between the different estimates on the mean ocean sink and its trend. This living data update documents changes in methods and datasets applied to this most-recent global carbon budget as well as evolving community understanding of the global carbon cycle. The data presented in this work are available at https://doi.org/10.18160/GCP-2026 (Friedlingstein et al., 2026b).
- Open Access
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 23 (19) , 6947-6977
Towards constraining the drivers of variability and trends in subantarctic productivity
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO 2 , contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive differences in NPP between years (NPP interannual variability) remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analysed the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (PISCES-QUOTA-FE; 1958–2022) in the subantarctic zone south of Tasmania, Australia. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to a subset of CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted. Additionally, further observational data, including zooplankton grazing and phytoplankton biomass distributions over depth are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers and develop models through mechanistic inclusion.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 23 (19) , 6947-6977
Open AccessTowards constraining the drivers of variability and trends in subantarctic productivity
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO 2 , contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive differences in NPP between years (NPP interannual variability) remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analysed the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (PISCES-QUOTA-FE; 1958–2022) in the subantarctic zone south of Tasmania, Australia. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to a subset of CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted. Additionally, further observational data, including zooplankton grazing and phytoplankton biomass distributions over depth are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers and develop models through mechanistic inclusion.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-37
Reply to RC1
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- 18 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-37
Open AccessReply to RC1
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Reply to RC2
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- 18 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Open AccessReply to RC2
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- Open Access
- 29 April 2026
- Published by University of California Press in Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene
- Vol. 14 (1)
Monitoring, reporting, and verification of marine carbon dioxide removal: Exploring scientific consensus and divergences across continents
Marine Carbon Dioxide Removal (mCDR) approaches are increasingly considered for climate change mitigation as a supplement to rapid emissions reduction. However, it is still unclear if mCDR approaches could be effective, safe, and accountable. A critical requirement for mCDR to work, potentially, is robust monitoring, reporting, and verification (MRV) of greenhouse gas(es) removed through mCDR activities. MRV frameworks and protocols are currently developed in a scattered manner by individual stakeholders, so that the principles they are built upon may or may not appeal to the broader international community that is interested in the ocean commons. International agreement and consolidation on MRV for mCDR seem crucial to legitimize and validate mCDR, considering that the ocean is a globally interconnected fluid and that activities by some may affect many others. Here, we undertake a step toward consolidation of MRV by consulting the international scientific community. We established a global network of scientists organized into 6 “continental” nodes, each of which addressed the same set of MRV-related questions and whose thoughts were equally weighted in the synthesis. Our consultation shows that while there are many converging views on MRV (e.g., the importance of modeling for MRV), there are also differences in the regional MRV priorities (e.g., the importance of regional vs global models). The areas of consensus and divergence identified herein may be instrumental in the design of more widely accepted MRV frameworks, informed equally by scientists from 6 continents.
- 29 April 2026
- Published by University of California Press in Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene
- Vol. 14 (1)
Open AccessMonitoring, reporting, and verification of marine carbon dioxide removal: Exploring scientific consensus and divergences across continents
Marine Carbon Dioxide Removal (mCDR) approaches are increasingly considered for climate change mitigation as a supplement to rapid emissions reduction. However, it is still unclear if mCDR approaches could be effective, safe, and accountable. A critical requirement for mCDR to work, potentially, is robust monitoring, reporting, and verification (MRV) of greenhouse gas(es) removed through mCDR activities. MRV frameworks and protocols are currently developed in a scattered manner by individual stakeholders, so that the principles they are built upon may or may not appeal to the broader international community that is interested in the ocean commons. International agreement and consolidation on MRV for mCDR seem crucial to legitimize and validate mCDR, considering that the ocean is a globally interconnected fluid and that activities by some may affect many others. Here, we undertake a step toward consolidation of MRV by consulting the international scientific community. We established a global network of scientists organized into 6 “continental” nodes, each of which addressed the same set of MRV-related questions and whose thoughts were equally weighted in the synthesis. Our consultation shows that while there are many converging views on MRV (e.g., the importance of modeling for MRV), there are also differences in the regional MRV priorities (e.g., the importance of regional vs global models). The areas of consensus and divergence identified herein may be instrumental in the design of more widely accepted MRV frameworks, informed equally by scientists from 6 continents.
- Open Access
- 18 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Comment on egusphere-2026-44
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- 18 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-44
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- Open Access
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Towards Constraining the Drivers of Variability and Trends in Subantarctic Productivity
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- 23 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-37
Open AccessTowards Constraining the Drivers of Variability and Trends in Subantarctic Productivity
The subantarctic Southern Ocean is a climatically important region, where primary production largely drives the seasonal uptake of atmospheric CO2, contributing to the sequestration of anthropogenic carbon emissions. Seasonal iron and light limitation control annual net primary production (NPP) in this region, but the explicit mechanisms that drive interannual variability in NPP remain elusive due to sparse observations. This uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent interannual variability and trend estimates of remotely-sensed NPP algorithms. Without clear mechanistic underpinning, confidence in remotely-sensed NPP trends remains low and hinders predictive capability. To overcome observational limitations and better understand the drivers of interannual NPP variability, we analyse the explicit bottom-up and top-down controls of depth integrated NPP in a biogeochemical ocean model historical run (1958–2022) from the Indian sector of the subantarctic zone. The highest NPP years were primarily driven by increased relief of iron limitation, with iron supplied from both deeper mixing in winter/spring and enhanced remineralisation in summer. In spring, higher phytoplankton growth rates were decoupled from surface biomass, such that years with higher NPP were due to faster growth in the mixed layer. Faster growth rates emerged following deeper winter mixed layers, driving phytoplankton distributions deeper in winter and reducing mixed layer grazing loss rates in spring. This generated a predator-prey dynamic favouring surface biomass accumulation moving into summer. Thus, inconsistent remote-sensing NPP estimates may derive from how algorithms link biomass (rather than growth rates) to NPP. We applied our analysis to CMIP6 models, and while all historical simulations converged with respect to positive trends in NPP, bias from sea surface temperature trends influenced the mechanisms driving interannual NPP variability. These findings show that interacting top-down and bottom-up processes can decouple changes in NPP with respect to phytoplankton biomass, which has important implications for remote sensing NPP estimates based on biomass. Therefore, the need for cautionary approaches to NPP trend interpretation is highlighted, and that further observational data are needed to ground truth mechanistic understanding of NPP drivers.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Wiley
Organic carbon sequestration is insensitive to variability in surface productivity in the Subantarctic Zone: implications for enhancing the biological carbon pump for climate mitigation
The efficiency and stability of the biological carbon pump (BCP) set the ocean’s capacity to sequester carbon on climate-relevant timescales. Despite its importance, the BCP is difficult to observe directly making quantification of its efficiency challenging. Here, we present multi-year sediment trap records from two sites in the iron-limited Subantarctic Zone (SAZ): the Southern Ocean Time Series (SOTS; south of Australia) and the Subantarctic Mooring (SAM; east of Aotearoa New Zealand). Particle fluxes are combined with satellite-based net primary production (NPP) to investigate the links between variability at the surface and the delivery of material to depth. Despite higher NPP at SAM, annual particulate organic carbon (POC) flux was not significantly different at the two sites. Interannual anomalies in NPP are much smaller than POC flux anomalies and are weakly correlated with POC flux. At the SOTS site, the correlation between BSi and POC flux suggests that silicifying phytoplankton are important for the delivery of material to depth. By contrast, ballasting material has very little predictive value for annual POC flux at the SAM site. These results show that carbon sequestration is not necessarily related to short-term surface variability, implying limited leverage of productivity-enhancement strategies (e.g., iron fertilization) for enhancing the BCP in the SAZ. This underscores the need to distinguish carbon export near the surface from carbon retained at depth in order to quantify baseline variability in the BCP prior to evaluating the feasibility of proposed climate mitigation strategies that aim to enhance deep ocean carbon sequestration.
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessOrganic carbon sequestration is insensitive to variability in surface productivity in the Subantarctic Zone: implications for enhancing the biological carbon pump for climate mitigation
The efficiency and stability of the biological carbon pump (BCP) set the ocean’s capacity to sequester carbon on climate-relevant timescales. Despite its importance, the BCP is difficult to observe directly making quantification of its efficiency challenging. Here, we present multi-year sediment trap records from two sites in the iron-limited Subantarctic Zone (SAZ): the Southern Ocean Time Series (SOTS; south of Australia) and the Subantarctic Mooring (SAM; east of Aotearoa New Zealand). Particle fluxes are combined with satellite-based net primary production (NPP) to investigate the links between variability at the surface and the delivery of material to depth. Despite higher NPP at SAM, annual particulate organic carbon (POC) flux was not significantly different at the two sites. Interannual anomalies in NPP are much smaller than POC flux anomalies and are weakly correlated with POC flux. At the SOTS site, the correlation between BSi and POC flux suggests that silicifying phytoplankton are important for the delivery of material to depth. By contrast, ballasting material has very little predictive value for annual POC flux at the SAM site. These results show that carbon sequestration is not necessarily related to short-term surface variability, implying limited leverage of productivity-enhancement strategies (e.g., iron fertilization) for enhancing the BCP in the SAZ. This underscores the need to distinguish carbon export near the surface from carbon retained at depth in order to quantify baseline variability in the BCP prior to evaluating the feasibility of proposed climate mitigation strategies that aim to enhance deep ocean carbon sequestration.