Luis Abdala‐Roberts
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Luis Abdala‐Roberts has a total of 195 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Xoaquín Moreira
Misión Biológica de Galicia (MBG-CSIC), Pontevedra, Spain
26 shared publications - Ted Christiaan Joannes Turlings
State Key Laboratory of Crop Stress Adaptation and Improvement, State Key Laboratory of Cotton Bio-breeding and Integrated Utilization, School of Life Sciences, College of Agriculture, Henan University, Kaifeng, China
11 shared publications Xoaquín Moreira
10 shared publications- Sergio Rasmann
University of Neuchâtel
8 shared publications - Carla Vázquez‐González
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of California‐Irvine Irvine California USA
7 shared publications Ted C. J. Turlings
State Key Laboratory of Cotton Bio-breeding and Integrated Utilization, School of Life Sciences, Henan University, Kaifeng, 475004, China
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Chemical Ecology
- Vol. 52 (6) , 97
Ontogenetic Variation in Plant-to-Plant Signaling Effects on Direct and Indirect Defenses in Wild Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum)
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Chemical Ecology
- Vol. 52 (6) , 97
Ontogenetic Variation in Plant-to-Plant Signaling Effects on Direct and Indirect Defenses in Wild Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum)
- Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 113 (10) , e70280
The intensity and spatial dispersion of within‐plant herbivory drive trait‐specific resistance and tolerance in wild cotton
Premise: Herbivory induces complex plant defensive responses that may vary depending on the amount and spatial dispersion of damage on the plant; however, of the two variables, damage dispersion has received much less attention. To address this gap, we studied wild cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum ) defensive responses to different herbivory amounts and degrees of dispersion among leaves using the specialist caterpillar Alabama argillacea (Erebidae). Methods: Four herbivory treatments differing in the amount and spatial distribution were applied to 4‐month‐old plants: no herbivory (controls), low (two caterpillars: one on each of two leaves), high‐concentrated (four caterpillars: one pair on each of two leaves), and high‐dispersed (four caterpillars: one on each of four leaves). We measured extrafloral nectar (EFN) and phenolics, both resistance‐related traits, and as a proxy for tolerance, regrowth capacity (new leaf biomass post‐herbivory). To differentiate local from systemic induction, we measured EFN and phenolics separately for damaged and undamaged leaves. Results: EFN was significantly and more consistently induced in damaged leaves (i.e., stronger local induction) and in response to high‐dispersed damage, but phenolics were unaffected by the treatment. Biomass of new leaves produced post herbivory was similar to that of controls for most treatment groups, except for high‐concentrated damage (lower than controls), suggesting this damage treatment incurred higher costs. Conclusions: These results highlight the importance of studying induced plant defenses under various herbivory patterns and suggest that the spatial distribution of within‐plant damage has contrasting effects on resistance‐ (namely EFN) versus tolerance‐related induced responses of importance for wild cotton growth and ant‐plant interactions.
- 16 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 113 (10) , e70280
Open AccessThe intensity and spatial dispersion of within‐plant herbivory drive trait‐specific resistance and tolerance in wild cotton
Premise: Herbivory induces complex plant defensive responses that may vary depending on the amount and spatial dispersion of damage on the plant; however, of the two variables, damage dispersion has received much less attention. To address this gap, we studied wild cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum ) defensive responses to different herbivory amounts and degrees of dispersion among leaves using the specialist caterpillar Alabama argillacea (Erebidae). Methods: Four herbivory treatments differing in the amount and spatial distribution were applied to 4‐month‐old plants: no herbivory (controls), low (two caterpillars: one on each of two leaves), high‐concentrated (four caterpillars: one pair on each of two leaves), and high‐dispersed (four caterpillars: one on each of four leaves). We measured extrafloral nectar (EFN) and phenolics, both resistance‐related traits, and as a proxy for tolerance, regrowth capacity (new leaf biomass post‐herbivory). To differentiate local from systemic induction, we measured EFN and phenolics separately for damaged and undamaged leaves. Results: EFN was significantly and more consistently induced in damaged leaves (i.e., stronger local induction) and in response to high‐dispersed damage, but phenolics were unaffected by the treatment. Biomass of new leaves produced post herbivory was similar to that of controls for most treatment groups, except for high‐concentrated damage (lower than controls), suggesting this damage treatment incurred higher costs. Conclusions: These results highlight the importance of studying induced plant defenses under various herbivory patterns and suggest that the spatial distribution of within‐plant damage has contrasting effects on resistance‐ (namely EFN) versus tolerance‐related induced responses of importance for wild cotton growth and ant‐plant interactions.
- Open Access
From mainland to islands: the evolution of resistance and tolerance to herbivory in long‐lived oaks
Island biogeography theory predicts that island plants should exhibit reduced defences compared with their mainland relatives due to relaxed herbivory pressure. However, growing empirical evidence challenges this prediction, revealing substantial variation among systems, plant lineages and defence types. These inconsistencies suggest that simple expectations of reduced defence on islands overlook the diversity of selective agents and strategies plants use to cope with herbivores. A more integrative perspective proposes that island – mainland comparisons should simultaneously consider multiple defensive mechanisms, including resistance – both constitutive and inducible – and tolerance‐related traits. In this study, we conducted two complementary greenhouse experiments to examine resistance and tolerance responses in seven island–mainland species pairs of oaks Quercus across three biogeographical regions: Bornholm Island versus mainland Sweden, the Balearic Islands versus mainland Spain, and Lesbos Island versus mainland Greece. Seedlings were exposed to controlled foliar herbivory by the generalist Lymantria dispar , with undamaged plants serving as controls. Resistance was quantified by measuring key chemical defences – namely total phenolic content and volatile organic compounds – assessed both at constitutive levels and in terms of inducibility following herbivore damage. Tolerance, in contrast, was evaluated as the plant's capacity for growth compensation, quantified through height regrowth after herbivory. Our results show that, contrary to traditional expectations, island and mainland oak seedlings did not differ significantly in either chemical resistance or growth‐based tolerance to herbivory. These results suggest that the evolution of plant defences on islands may not be universally reduced and that both island and mainland oaks maintain comparable strategies to cope with herbivory, highlighting the importance of considering multiple defence mechanisms and local ecological contexts when assessing insularity effects.
Open AccessFrom mainland to islands: the evolution of resistance and tolerance to herbivory in long‐lived oaks
Island biogeography theory predicts that island plants should exhibit reduced defences compared with their mainland relatives due to relaxed herbivory pressure. However, growing empirical evidence challenges this prediction, revealing substantial variation among systems, plant lineages and defence types. These inconsistencies suggest that simple expectations of reduced defence on islands overlook the diversity of selective agents and strategies plants use to cope with herbivores. A more integrative perspective proposes that island – mainland comparisons should simultaneously consider multiple defensive mechanisms, including resistance – both constitutive and inducible – and tolerance‐related traits. In this study, we conducted two complementary greenhouse experiments to examine resistance and tolerance responses in seven island–mainland species pairs of oaks Quercus across three biogeographical regions: Bornholm Island versus mainland Sweden, the Balearic Islands versus mainland Spain, and Lesbos Island versus mainland Greece. Seedlings were exposed to controlled foliar herbivory by the generalist Lymantria dispar , with undamaged plants serving as controls. Resistance was quantified by measuring key chemical defences – namely total phenolic content and volatile organic compounds – assessed both at constitutive levels and in terms of inducibility following herbivore damage. Tolerance, in contrast, was evaluated as the plant's capacity for growth compensation, quantified through height regrowth after herbivory. Our results show that, contrary to traditional expectations, island and mainland oak seedlings did not differ significantly in either chemical resistance or growth‐based tolerance to herbivory. These results suggest that the evolution of plant defences on islands may not be universally reduced and that both island and mainland oaks maintain comparable strategies to cope with herbivory, highlighting the importance of considering multiple defence mechanisms and local ecological contexts when assessing insularity effects.
- Open Access
- 6 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (8)
Artificial exposure to herbivore‐induced volatile organic compounds reduces herbivory and modulates gene expression in potato plants
Climate change accelerates pest development, posing a serious threat to agricultural yields worldwide. While the application of chemical pesticides can control pests, their overuse poses risks to human health and the environment and contributes to the emergence of pesticide‐resistant populations. Within this context, the use of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) emerges as a promising tool for sustainable crop pest management. Informed by and building on prior work identifying key candidate herbivore‐induced volatiles, we investigated whether exposure to artificial VOC blends mimicking those induced by natural herbivore damage enhances potato ( Solanum tuberosum ) resistance to herbivory. Plants were paired in cages and each cage was exposed to either VOC blends similar to those produced by undamaged (control) plants or VOC blends emulating those from plants damaged by Spodoptera exigua (induced). After 3 days of exposure, one plant per cage was removed and leaf tissue collected for gene expression analyses, while the remaining plants were subjected to an herbivory bioassay to assess resistance to S. exigua feeding. After assessing resistance, we again collected leaves for gene expression analyses in induced receivers. Plants exposed to induced VOC blends exhibited a significant reduction in herbivory compared to those exposed to control blends. Molecular analyses indicated that 4CL defensive gene expression increased to a greater extent in response to damage for plants previously exposed to the induced VOCs blend versus those exposed to control VOC blends, consistent with volatile‐mediated priming of induced defences. Synthesis and applications . These findings provide strong mechanistic evidence for VOCs mediating pest resistance and suggest that exposure to herbivore‐induced, plant‐derived VOCs can enhance pest resistance in potato crops. These results might offer novel information for developing ecologically sustainable plant volatile‐based strategies for boosting protection against pests in potato plantations.
- 6 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (8)
Open AccessArtificial exposure to herbivore‐induced volatile organic compounds reduces herbivory and modulates gene expression in potato plants
Climate change accelerates pest development, posing a serious threat to agricultural yields worldwide. While the application of chemical pesticides can control pests, their overuse poses risks to human health and the environment and contributes to the emergence of pesticide‐resistant populations. Within this context, the use of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) emerges as a promising tool for sustainable crop pest management. Informed by and building on prior work identifying key candidate herbivore‐induced volatiles, we investigated whether exposure to artificial VOC blends mimicking those induced by natural herbivore damage enhances potato ( Solanum tuberosum ) resistance to herbivory. Plants were paired in cages and each cage was exposed to either VOC blends similar to those produced by undamaged (control) plants or VOC blends emulating those from plants damaged by Spodoptera exigua (induced). After 3 days of exposure, one plant per cage was removed and leaf tissue collected for gene expression analyses, while the remaining plants were subjected to an herbivory bioassay to assess resistance to S. exigua feeding. After assessing resistance, we again collected leaves for gene expression analyses in induced receivers. Plants exposed to induced VOC blends exhibited a significant reduction in herbivory compared to those exposed to control blends. Molecular analyses indicated that 4CL defensive gene expression increased to a greater extent in response to damage for plants previously exposed to the induced VOCs blend versus those exposed to control VOC blends, consistent with volatile‐mediated priming of induced defences. Synthesis and applications . These findings provide strong mechanistic evidence for VOCs mediating pest resistance and suggest that exposure to herbivore‐induced, plant‐derived VOCs can enhance pest resistance in potato crops. These results might offer novel information for developing ecologically sustainable plant volatile‐based strategies for boosting protection against pests in potato plantations.
- Open Access
Exposure to herbivore-induced plant volatiles directly induces jasmonic acid and primes chemical defences in cotton plants
Plants can deploy alternative defensive strategies in response to airborne signals from damaged neighbours to prepare for incoming attack: a straightaway response up-regulating their defences (induction), or a primed state, leading to a faster/stronger defence response after herbivory. However, it is unclear which mechanisms are involved in each response. We used a monophagous and a polyphagous leafworm species to specifically dissect induction and priming effects of exposure to herbivore-induced plant volatiles (HIPVs). Exposure to HIPVs directly elevated jasmonate levels in undamaged receivers but did not induce defensive terpenoids or volatiles. However, HIPV-primed plants accumulated high levels of toxic terpenoids (e.g. gossypol) and emitted high quantities of volatile sesquiterpenes, when damaged by either species of caterpillars. This comprehensive study demonstrates that both defence induction and priming can be detected in cotton but occur as different, linked responses which are robust to herbivore identity, providing insights into a generalised plant communication strategy.
Open AccessExposure to herbivore-induced plant volatiles directly induces jasmonic acid and primes chemical defences in cotton plants
Plants can deploy alternative defensive strategies in response to airborne signals from damaged neighbours to prepare for incoming attack: a straightaway response up-regulating their defences (induction), or a primed state, leading to a faster/stronger defence response after herbivory. However, it is unclear which mechanisms are involved in each response. We used a monophagous and a polyphagous leafworm species to specifically dissect induction and priming effects of exposure to herbivore-induced plant volatiles (HIPVs). Exposure to HIPVs directly elevated jasmonate levels in undamaged receivers but did not induce defensive terpenoids or volatiles. However, HIPV-primed plants accumulated high levels of toxic terpenoids (e.g. gossypol) and emitted high quantities of volatile sesquiterpenes, when damaged by either species of caterpillars. This comprehensive study demonstrates that both defence induction and priming can be detected in cotton but occur as different, linked responses which are robust to herbivore identity, providing insights into a generalised plant communication strategy.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 985-1000
Tri-trophic consequences of plant-to-plant volatile signalling and its contingency on plant relatedness in wild cotton
Background and Aims: Plant volatile organic compounds (VOCs) induced by herbivory boost defences in neighbouring plants. These effects have been shown primarily for direct plant defences and are often stronger when emitter and receiver plants are genetically related. However, we know much less about how plant indirect defence is affected by VOC signalling. To address this, we conducted field experiments controlling for plant relatedness, testing the effects of VOC signalling on extrafloral nectar (EFN) production, a key indirect defence, and its impact on ant recruitment and attacks on herbivores of wild cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) plants. Methods: Experiments consisted of plant triplets, in which one individual acted as an emitter of VOCs and two as receivers. One receiver shared the same mother plant as the emitter, and the other was descended from a different mother. Half of the emitter plants were induced using the specialist caterpillar Alabama argillacea, and VOCs were collected. We then induced receivers and measured their EFN production, in addition to ant abundance and attack on sentinel caterpillars. We also subsequently excluded ants from half of the receivers to test for ant-mediated effects on natural herbivory occurring over the following weeks. Key Results: Receivers exposed to VOCs of damaged emitters produced a greater volume and concentration of EFN in response to herbivory relative to those exposed to undamaged emitters and, accordingly, showed higher rates of ant attack on sentinel caterpillars (albeit no differences in ant abundance). These effects were not contingent on emitter–receiver relatedness. In addition, we found no effect of ant exclusion on natural herbivory levels on receiver plants, although damage was low overall. Conclusions: These findings provide insight into inter-plant VOC signalling effects on multitrophic interactions by revealing indirect defence induction that leads to herbivore reduction by ants but that such effect occurs independently of the degree of emitter–receiver relatedness.
- 8 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 985-1000
Open AccessTri-trophic consequences of plant-to-plant volatile signalling and its contingency on plant relatedness in wild cotton
Background and Aims: Plant volatile organic compounds (VOCs) induced by herbivory boost defences in neighbouring plants. These effects have been shown primarily for direct plant defences and are often stronger when emitter and receiver plants are genetically related. However, we know much less about how plant indirect defence is affected by VOC signalling. To address this, we conducted field experiments controlling for plant relatedness, testing the effects of VOC signalling on extrafloral nectar (EFN) production, a key indirect defence, and its impact on ant recruitment and attacks on herbivores of wild cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) plants. Methods: Experiments consisted of plant triplets, in which one individual acted as an emitter of VOCs and two as receivers. One receiver shared the same mother plant as the emitter, and the other was descended from a different mother. Half of the emitter plants were induced using the specialist caterpillar Alabama argillacea, and VOCs were collected. We then induced receivers and measured their EFN production, in addition to ant abundance and attack on sentinel caterpillars. We also subsequently excluded ants from half of the receivers to test for ant-mediated effects on natural herbivory occurring over the following weeks. Key Results: Receivers exposed to VOCs of damaged emitters produced a greater volume and concentration of EFN in response to herbivory relative to those exposed to undamaged emitters and, accordingly, showed higher rates of ant attack on sentinel caterpillars (albeit no differences in ant abundance). These effects were not contingent on emitter–receiver relatedness. In addition, we found no effect of ant exclusion on natural herbivory levels on receiver plants, although damage was low overall. Conclusions: These findings provide insight into inter-plant VOC signalling effects on multitrophic interactions by revealing indirect defence induction that leads to herbivore reduction by ants but that such effect occurs independently of the degree of emitter–receiver relatedness.
- Open Access
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Entomology
- Vol. 51 (2) , 395-404
From leaves to defenders: How the amount and dispersion of leaf damage affect extrafloral nectar production and ant‐mediated protection in wild cotton
Extrafloral nectar (EFN) drives mutualistic interactions between plants and ants. However, EFN production is costly, and its induction is predicted to vary with herbivore‐related factors. We examine how the amount and within‐plant damage spatial uniformity (i.e., dispersed and concentrated damage) affect EFN production and ant‐mediated defence in wild cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum ). Previous work suggests that severe and concentrated damage is costliest to plants, leading us to hypothesise that such damage types would induce greater EFN production and, consequently, stronger ant attraction and protection. We conducted a greenhouse experiment in which plants were subjected to one of the following mechanical damage treatments: control (no damage), low damage (two damaged leaves, 30% of area removed each), high concentrated damage (two damaged leaves, 60% each) and high dispersed damage (four damaged leaves, 30% each; that is, same total area than concentrated damage). The day after establishing damage treatments, we measured the EFN volume and sugar content from one nectary per plant (a per‐nectary EFN response) and the number of secreting nectaries per plant (a proxy for whole‐plant level EFN response). Subsequently, we performed a field experiment applying the same treatments to another set of plants to evaluate EFN‐mediated ant recruitment and ant‐provided protection by placing caterpillars on plants. Both high‐damage treatments increased EFN volume per nectary, whereas low damage did not. However, dispersed damage was the only treatment that increased the number of secreting nectaries. Consistently, once placed in the field, plants with dispersed damage recruited more ants and caterpillars on them were more likely to be attacked by ants. Contrary to expectations, plants subjected to dispersed damage exhibited a greater total investment in EFN, presumably via local induction of more nectaries per plant, and thereby enhanced ant‐mediated defence. This study highlights the importance of herbivory intensity and within‐plant spatial uniformity in shaping ant–plant interactions.
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Entomology
- Vol. 51 (2) , 395-404
Open AccessFrom leaves to defenders: How the amount and dispersion of leaf damage affect extrafloral nectar production and ant‐mediated protection in wild cotton
Extrafloral nectar (EFN) drives mutualistic interactions between plants and ants. However, EFN production is costly, and its induction is predicted to vary with herbivore‐related factors. We examine how the amount and within‐plant damage spatial uniformity (i.e., dispersed and concentrated damage) affect EFN production and ant‐mediated defence in wild cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum ). Previous work suggests that severe and concentrated damage is costliest to plants, leading us to hypothesise that such damage types would induce greater EFN production and, consequently, stronger ant attraction and protection. We conducted a greenhouse experiment in which plants were subjected to one of the following mechanical damage treatments: control (no damage), low damage (two damaged leaves, 30% of area removed each), high concentrated damage (two damaged leaves, 60% each) and high dispersed damage (four damaged leaves, 30% each; that is, same total area than concentrated damage). The day after establishing damage treatments, we measured the EFN volume and sugar content from one nectary per plant (a per‐nectary EFN response) and the number of secreting nectaries per plant (a proxy for whole‐plant level EFN response). Subsequently, we performed a field experiment applying the same treatments to another set of plants to evaluate EFN‐mediated ant recruitment and ant‐provided protection by placing caterpillars on plants. Both high‐damage treatments increased EFN volume per nectary, whereas low damage did not. However, dispersed damage was the only treatment that increased the number of secreting nectaries. Consistently, once placed in the field, plants with dispersed damage recruited more ants and caterpillars on them were more likely to be attacked by ants. Contrary to expectations, plants subjected to dispersed damage exhibited a greater total investment in EFN, presumably via local induction of more nectaries per plant, and thereby enhanced ant‐mediated defence. This study highlights the importance of herbivory intensity and within‐plant spatial uniformity in shaping ant–plant interactions.
- Open Access
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 879-885
The effect of herbivory on pollinators: a revisited meta-analysis
Background and Aims: Plant–herbivore and plant–pollinator interactions are closely interconnected through their combined influence on plant reproduction, involving both direct and indirect (plant-mediated) effects between these consumer groups. Although these dynamics have been investigated for nearly three decades and were previously synthesized in a meta-analysis, rapid growth in the field in recent years warrants an updated quantitative assessment. Methods: We extend the most recent synthesis by incorporating primary studies published between 2018 and 2023, nearly doubling the dataset from 88 to 171 studies and increasing the number of independent observations from 568 to 1348. We reanalysed the effects of both natural and simulated herbivory on floral traits, pollinator visitation and plant reproductive output, expanding previous damage categories to include stem damage and mixed-tissue damage – defined here as damage affecting multiple plant tissues simultaneously (e.g. grazing that impacts both leaves and flowers). Key Results: Plant damage significantly reduced floral traits, pollinator attraction and reproductive success. These effects varied with both the type of damage and the tissue affected, with their interaction strongly moderating plant responses. Natural damage to leaves and flowers in most cases reduced floral traits, pollinator visitation and reproduction (except floral traits in the case of flower damage). By contrast, root and mixed damage had no significant effects. Simulated damage, on the other hand, also influenced responses: damage to flowers and stems only reduced floral traits, while damage to leaves reduced pollinator attraction. Importantly, our updated analysis corroborates some trends but also overturns earlier findings: whereas previous work suggested no impact of simulated herbivory, we now detect significant negative effects, and natural floral damage, once considered neutral or in some cases positive for reproduction, is revealed to be detrimental. Conclusions: These findings demonstrate that herbivory alters plant–pollinator interactions in trait- and tissue-specific ways, providing new insights into the ecological and evolutionary consequences of plant–herbivore–pollinator linkages.
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 879-885
Open AccessThe effect of herbivory on pollinators: a revisited meta-analysis
Background and Aims: Plant–herbivore and plant–pollinator interactions are closely interconnected through their combined influence on plant reproduction, involving both direct and indirect (plant-mediated) effects between these consumer groups. Although these dynamics have been investigated for nearly three decades and were previously synthesized in a meta-analysis, rapid growth in the field in recent years warrants an updated quantitative assessment. Methods: We extend the most recent synthesis by incorporating primary studies published between 2018 and 2023, nearly doubling the dataset from 88 to 171 studies and increasing the number of independent observations from 568 to 1348. We reanalysed the effects of both natural and simulated herbivory on floral traits, pollinator visitation and plant reproductive output, expanding previous damage categories to include stem damage and mixed-tissue damage – defined here as damage affecting multiple plant tissues simultaneously (e.g. grazing that impacts both leaves and flowers). Key Results: Plant damage significantly reduced floral traits, pollinator attraction and reproductive success. These effects varied with both the type of damage and the tissue affected, with their interaction strongly moderating plant responses. Natural damage to leaves and flowers in most cases reduced floral traits, pollinator visitation and reproduction (except floral traits in the case of flower damage). By contrast, root and mixed damage had no significant effects. Simulated damage, on the other hand, also influenced responses: damage to flowers and stems only reduced floral traits, while damage to leaves reduced pollinator attraction. Importantly, our updated analysis corroborates some trends but also overturns earlier findings: whereas previous work suggested no impact of simulated herbivory, we now detect significant negative effects, and natural floral damage, once considered neutral or in some cases positive for reproduction, is revealed to be detrimental. Conclusions: These findings demonstrate that herbivory alters plant–pollinator interactions in trait- and tissue-specific ways, providing new insights into the ecological and evolutionary consequences of plant–herbivore–pollinator linkages.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (11)
Regional Variation in Insularity Effects on Acorn Herbivory in European Oaks Challenges Predictions of Lower Herbivory on Islands
Aim: Ecological theory predicts lower herbivory on islands. However, most island‐mainland comparisons have focused on vegetative tissues, while reproductive structures remain understudied despite their direct influence on plant fitness and recruitment. This study investigates how insularity affects insect herbivory in oak ( Quercus ) acorns across multiple island‐mainland regions and explores the role of acorn traits (chemical defences and nutrients) and climate as potential drivers. Location: Three island‐mainland regions in Europe: Lesbos Island—mainland Greece, the Balearic Islands—mainland Spain, and Bornholm Island—mainland Sweden. Time Period: Acorns were collected in autumn 2023. Climatic data are long‐term averages for each population. Major Taxa Studied: Seven oak ( Quercus ) species across regions. Methods: We aimed to sample up to three island and three mainland populations per species, with four trees per population, but logistical constraints reduced these numbers, resulting in a total of 150 sampled trees. We assessed acorn damage by insect herbivores and analysed chemical defences (phenolics) and nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) to test their influence on island–mainland differences in herbivory. Climatic data from the WorldClim database were used to assess climate‐mediated insularity effects on acorn traits and herbivory. Results: Acorn damage did not differ overall between mainland and island populations. However, in the Balearic Islands, damage was higher than in mainland Spain, while no significant differences were found in the other regions. There were no general insularity effects on acorn traits, but a region‐by‐insularity interaction influenced phosphorus levels, with higher values in mainland Sweden than Bornholm Island, while the reverse was observed in Greece. Climate influenced acorn traits, but trait differences did not explain herbivory patterns. Main Conclusions: Our findings challenge the expectation that insularity reduces herbivory, highlighting region‐specific processes. While climate influenced acorn traits, these traits did not mediate insularity effects on herbivory, suggesting local ecological factors drive variation across regions.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (11)
Open AccessRegional Variation in Insularity Effects on Acorn Herbivory in European Oaks Challenges Predictions of Lower Herbivory on Islands
Aim: Ecological theory predicts lower herbivory on islands. However, most island‐mainland comparisons have focused on vegetative tissues, while reproductive structures remain understudied despite their direct influence on plant fitness and recruitment. This study investigates how insularity affects insect herbivory in oak ( Quercus ) acorns across multiple island‐mainland regions and explores the role of acorn traits (chemical defences and nutrients) and climate as potential drivers. Location: Three island‐mainland regions in Europe: Lesbos Island—mainland Greece, the Balearic Islands—mainland Spain, and Bornholm Island—mainland Sweden. Time Period: Acorns were collected in autumn 2023. Climatic data are long‐term averages for each population. Major Taxa Studied: Seven oak ( Quercus ) species across regions. Methods: We aimed to sample up to three island and three mainland populations per species, with four trees per population, but logistical constraints reduced these numbers, resulting in a total of 150 sampled trees. We assessed acorn damage by insect herbivores and analysed chemical defences (phenolics) and nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) to test their influence on island–mainland differences in herbivory. Climatic data from the WorldClim database were used to assess climate‐mediated insularity effects on acorn traits and herbivory. Results: Acorn damage did not differ overall between mainland and island populations. However, in the Balearic Islands, damage was higher than in mainland Spain, while no significant differences were found in the other regions. There were no general insularity effects on acorn traits, but a region‐by‐insularity interaction influenced phosphorus levels, with higher values in mainland Sweden than Bornholm Island, while the reverse was observed in Greece. Climate influenced acorn traits, but trait differences did not explain herbivory patterns. Main Conclusions: Our findings challenge the expectation that insularity reduces herbivory, highlighting region‐specific processes. While climate influenced acorn traits, these traits did not mediate insularity effects on herbivory, suggesting local ecological factors drive variation across regions.
- Open Access
From leaves to defenders: how the amount and dispersion of leaf damage affect extrafloral nectar production and ant-mediated protection in wild cotton
Extrafloral nectar (EFN) drives mutualistic interactions between plants and ants. However, EFN production is costly, and its induction is predicted to vary with herbivore-related factors. We examine how the amount and within-plant damage spatial uniformity (i.e., dispersed and concentrated damage) affect EFN production and ant-mediated defence in wild cotton (Gossypium hirsutum). Previous work suggests that severe and concentrated damage is costliest to plants, leading us to hypothesise that such damage would induce greater EFN production and, consequently, stronger ant attraction and protection. We conducted a greenhouse experiment in which plants were subjected to one of the following mechanical damage treatments: control (no damage), low damage (two damaged leaves, 30% of area removed each), high concentrated damage (two damaged leaves, 60% each), and high dispersed damage (four damaged leaves, 30% each; i.e., same total area than concentrated damage). The day after treatments, we measured EFN volume and sugar content from one nectary per plant (a per-nectary EFN response), and the number of secreting nectaries per plant (a proxy for whole-plant level EFN response). Subsequently, we performed a field experiment using the same treatments to evaluate EFN-mediated ant recruitment and ant-provided protection by placing caterpillars on plants. Both high-damage treatments increased EFN volume per nectary, whereas low damage did not. However, against our prediction, dispersed damage was the only treatment that increased the number of secreting nectaries. Consistently, once placed in the field, plants with dispersed damage recruited more ants and caterpillars on them were more likely to be attacked by ants. Contrary to expectations, plants subjected to dispersed damage exhibited a greater total investment in EFN, presumably via local induction of more nectaries per plant, and thereby enhancing ant-mediated defence. This study highlights the importance of herbivory intensity and within-plant spatial uniformity in shaping ant-plant interactions.
Open AccessFrom leaves to defenders: how the amount and dispersion of leaf damage affect extrafloral nectar production and ant-mediated protection in wild cotton
Extrafloral nectar (EFN) drives mutualistic interactions between plants and ants. However, EFN production is costly, and its induction is predicted to vary with herbivore-related factors. We examine how the amount and within-plant damage spatial uniformity (i.e., dispersed and concentrated damage) affect EFN production and ant-mediated defence in wild cotton (Gossypium hirsutum). Previous work suggests that severe and concentrated damage is costliest to plants, leading us to hypothesise that such damage would induce greater EFN production and, consequently, stronger ant attraction and protection. We conducted a greenhouse experiment in which plants were subjected to one of the following mechanical damage treatments: control (no damage), low damage (two damaged leaves, 30% of area removed each), high concentrated damage (two damaged leaves, 60% each), and high dispersed damage (four damaged leaves, 30% each; i.e., same total area than concentrated damage). The day after treatments, we measured EFN volume and sugar content from one nectary per plant (a per-nectary EFN response), and the number of secreting nectaries per plant (a proxy for whole-plant level EFN response). Subsequently, we performed a field experiment using the same treatments to evaluate EFN-mediated ant recruitment and ant-provided protection by placing caterpillars on plants. Both high-damage treatments increased EFN volume per nectary, whereas low damage did not. However, against our prediction, dispersed damage was the only treatment that increased the number of secreting nectaries. Consistently, once placed in the field, plants with dispersed damage recruited more ants and caterpillars on them were more likely to be attacked by ants. Contrary to expectations, plants subjected to dispersed damage exhibited a greater total investment in EFN, presumably via local induction of more nectaries per plant, and thereby enhancing ant-mediated defence. This study highlights the importance of herbivory intensity and within-plant spatial uniformity in shaping ant-plant interactions.