EKElmira Robertovna Khairullina

Elmira Robertovna Khairullina

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Elmira Robertovna Khairullina has a total of 162 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Exploring gender in ICT integrated STEM education: A bibliometric study

    by Denis A. Dobrokhotov, Anastasia E. Sayapina, Elmira R. Khairullina, Aygul A. Khafizova, Alexey I. Prokopyev, Natalya S. Erokhova

    Gender inequalities are one of the principal issues that academic gurus and policy makers have noted in information and communication technology (ICT) integrated STEM education. Therefore, this bibliometric analysis has the research objectives to investigate the quantity of research carried out and published over the years on gender in STEM education. Data source was Scopus database with time frame from 2010-2024. According to our investigation of the literature, scholarly work that focuses on gender in ICT integrated STEM education has been on the rise in the last ten years proving that gender issues are worth considering in this context. This study examines the evolution of research output and trends in the incorporation of gender studies into ICT integrated STEM education. The findings indicate a notable increase in research activity over the years, with a peak in article production and citations in 2022 and 2023. Noteworthy patterns of collaboration among prolific authors underscore the interdisciplinary nature of the field. Keyword analysis highlights a strong focus on gender-related issues, such as gender differences and disparities, reflecting a concerted effort to address gender inequalities in ICT integrated STEM education. The global distribution of research contributions emphasizes the universal relevance of gender issues in ICT integrated STEM, with the USA leading in article production. Key journals and institutions are identified as pivotal in advancing gender equity in ICT integrated STEM, with funding agencies playing a crucial role in driving research agendas. The interdisciplinary nature of research on gender in ICT integrated STEM is evident, with various disciplines contributing to a comprehensive understanding of gender dynamics in educational and professional contexts.


  • Open Access

    An analysis of science teachers’ use of artificial intelligence in education from a Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge perspective

    by Gasangusein I. Ibragimov, Elena N. Kolomoets, Alla A. Filippova, Elmira R. Khairullina, Natalya Y. Garnova, Julia V. Torkunova

    The aim of the study is to evaluate science teachers’ use of artificial intelligence (AI) within the context of Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK). The study examines teachers’ AI Competence Self-Efficacy and their TPACK according to demographic variables, investigates the relationship between these two variables, and determines the predictive effect of AI competence self-efficacy on TPACK. Quantitative research method was used at research and relational survey model used. The sample of the study consists of 296 science teachers in 13 different middle schools during the February–March 2025 period. Data were collected by Teacher AI Competency Self-Efficacy Scale (TAICS) and the AI Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (AI-TPACK) Scale. For data analysis, Independent Samples t-test, ANOVA, Pearson Correlation Analysis, and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) were used. According to the results, the overall mean scores of both AI-TPACK and TAICS were found to be medium level. According to gender analysis, female teachers scored higher than male teachers in the sub-dimensions of both AI-TPACK and TAICS. Teachers with fewer years of experience had higher scores in the technology-related components of AI-TPACK, whereas those with more teaching experience had higher averages in dimensions such as Pedagogical Knowledge (PK), Content Knowledge (CK), and Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK). In terms of TAICS, teachers with lower experience also had higher average scores. Overall, there were positive and significant correlations between the dimensions of TAICS and AI-TPACK. Finally, the TAICS construct significantly predicted AI-TPACK. Based on these findings, recommendations were given for future research to focus on the active use of AI within the TPACK framework and to include qualitative research designs aimed at exploring the challenges encountered in the process of AI integration.


  • The Role of Rural Tourism in Diversification of the Rural Settlements

    by R.V. Kadyrov, E.R. Khairullina, V.I. Bogdanova

    The promotion of socio-economic development in Russian regions and the diversification of the rural economy through rural tourism are possible within the framework of federal and regional legislative acts and programmes, as well as the territory's tourist and recreational resources and infrastructure potential. The purpose of this study is to assess the factors contributing to the development of tourism and the diversification of the economy in rural areas. The analysis of the regulatory framework showed that these acts and programmes focus on the sustainable development of rural areas. These documents defined the tasks of stimulating an increase in jobs in non-agricultural areas of rural settlements. The study showed that rural tourism includes several types and subtypes. Therefore, to determine the tourist and recreational resources and assess the infrastructure potential for rural tourism, the signs of its hierarchy were compiled. Considering the prospects for the development of rural tourism, the authors of the study identified the main criteria for assessing factors. These criteria include the natural environment, the level of infrastructure development, and the logistics of rural tourist routes. Furthermore, for the effective development of rural tourism and the diversification of the economy in rural areas, it is necessary to form self-organisation and cooperation among agricultural producers and organisers of rural tourism.


  • Open Access

    An examination of mobile learning adoption in higher education: Research trends in twenty years

    by Julia A. Krokhina, Irina I. Kruse, Elmira R. Khairullina, Gasangusein Ibragimov, Lyubov V. Kochneva, Olga V. Pashanova

    Mobile learning presents many benefits to lecturers, students, and universities. It provides the opportunity for all to access information anytime and anywhere and also promotes learning autonomy and mobility. This paper aims to systematically analyze publications on mobile learning in higher education conducted over twenty years by providing knowledge to help researchers in this area. The data were obtained from the Scopus database. A total of 587 peer-reviewed publications were analyzed. The results show that the number of articles increased significantly after 2016, and there was an upward trend after 2018. Our results regarding prolific journals show that many articles in this field were published in several prominent journals. Our results revealed that 91 countries contributed to research worldwide, and the most productive institutions are from different continents. In addition, results indicated that recently published countries on the topic are India, Saudi Arabia, Thailand, Indonesia, and Germany. Regarding research trends, our results yielded three research clusters. The first cluster focused on building a learning environment for students, while the second cluster included research on mobile learning in medical education. In addition, the third cluster investigated young adults’ use and perceptions of mobile phones in learning through surveys and questionnaires. Moreover, the results we obtained demonstrated that recent studies also focused on academic performance and augmented reality was a trending topic before academic performance.


  • Open Access

    Innovations in science education: A bibliometric exploration of trends and future directions

    by Sergey V. Kondrashev, Natalia L. Sokolova, Zulfiya F. Zaripova, Elmira R. Khairullina, Leyla B. Omarova, Elena I. Zamaraeva, Denis A. Dobrokhotov

    This article carries out a bibliometric research review to present the evolving landscape of innovations in science education. The study acknowledges the dynamism of the contemporary educational practices and uses the bibliometric analyses for identification of trends, assessment of impacts of scholarly outputs, and mapping the future directions in the field of science education innovation. Starting with a review of the standard bibliometric indicators, e.g., citation analysis and co-authorship, the review lays down the theoretical basis for the understanding of the scientific impact of the innovations in science education. The analysis, moreover, consists of identifying thematic foci and emerging topics through keyword mapping, which together present a holistic picture of the intellectual map of the field. The review points to seminal works and trends, demonstrating the nature of interdisciplinarity in research in science education innovation. By the analysis of collaborative networks and research hotspots the research not only demonstrates the present status of the field, but also predicts its future directions, which could help researchers and educators at the same time. Also, as a retrospective tool, the article explores the general relevance of bibliometric insights for educators, administrators, and other researchers. It highlights the application of bibliometrics in evidence-based decision-making, curricula design and international collaboration, because it is common knowledge that it can trigger the great revolution in innovative science education. This bibliometric review generates useful outcomes, which are beneficial to academic discussions and provide guidelines for future research efforts as a key reference for researchers who would like to have a deep, general overview of the innovations in science education.


  • Open Access

    A comprehensive bibliometric analysis of information and communication technologies in science education

    by Elmira R. Khairullina, Nikolay N. Kosarenko, Alexey A. Chistyakov, Gorezi Erkiada, Larisa B. Vaskova, Valeria P. Kotina

    Using information and communication technologies (ICTs) in science education is presented in this article along with a comprehensive bibliometric analysis. Relevant articles are extracted using specific keywords related to ICT and science education from data in the Scopus Database. Data is then analyzed using various bibliometric markers such as publication citation and collaboration patterns. In this study you will find things like publication types, author keywords, author geography and journals. The bibliometric analysis aims to uncover the publishing pattern and trends at the intersection of science education and ICT. The results of this study show the growth of ICT-related research and innovation in science education during the previous ten years. The bibliometric examination uncovers a huge expansion in the quantity of distributions, showing a developing interest around here. In general, this article enhances our comprehension of the current state of ICT innovation and use in science education. The results can make it simpler for educators, researchers, and policymakers to grasp current trends and priority areas, making it simpler to develop effective ICT integration strategies for science education. Future research areas and their consequences for practice are also highlighted.


  • Open Access

    A bibliometric overview of science communication research in STEM education

    by Alfia M. Ishmuradova, Marina N. Svintsova, Nataliia A. Kondakchian, Natalia A. Zaitseva, Natalia L. Sokolova, Elmira R. Khairullina

    Science communication has recently gained importance in many countries worldwide. This study conducted a bibliometric analysis to evaluate the scientific output of science communication in STEM education in the SCOPUS database for 2000-2022. For this purpose, the published studies on science communication were analyzed bibliometrically, and the trend of the last 22 years was shown. The database SCOPUS was used for data collection. The studies were analyzed under the following subheadings: Number of publications per year, type of publications, the language of publications, citation analysis, country collaborations, common citation networks, and conceptual trends. The results showed that the number of articles increased between 2019 and 2022. The United States and the United Kingdom had the most publications. The results also showed that the countries with the most collaboration in co-authored studies were Germany, the United States, Finland, Australia, and the Netherlands. Most published authors were mainly from the United States and Australia. The results of peer-reviewed journals demonstrated that the highest bibliographic link strengths included the International Journal of Science Education-Part B, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, Science Communication, Public Understanding of Science, and Journal of Science Communication. In addition, the most frequently used keywords were science communication, science education, education, human, communication, public understanding of science, and stem. Educational implications are drawn in the conclusion.


  • Open Access

    Validation of The Scale on Pre-Service Teachers’ Digital Competence to Assist Students with Functional Diversity

    by Alfiya R. Masalimova, Klavdiya G. Erdyneeva, Anatoly S. Kislyakov, Zhanna M. Sizova, Elena Kalashnikova, Elmira R. Khairullina

    One of the objectives of education is to provide diverse pupils with proper educational opportunities. It is anticipated that the night instructors will have this equipment. In this study, validity, and reliability evaluations of the scale to be used to identify digital competence in prospective instructors to support children with functional diversity were conducted. To conduct the research, education faculty students were selected as the target audience. The data gathered were subjected to exploratory factor analysis. A confirmatory factor analysis was used to validate the obtained results. According to the findings of the investigation, thirty components and five contributing variables were found. It has been proposed that future academics do studies on the validity and reliability of the instruments with a number of different populations.


  • Open Access

    Exploring Preservice STEM Teachers’ Smartphone Addiction

    by Alfiya R. Masalimova, Elmira R. Khairullina, Natalya I. Lapidus, Natalia A. Orekhovskaya, Marina R. Zheltukhina, Ekaterina A. Baranova

    Smartphones are mobile technology cutting-edge. Daily, the amount of time spent on a phone increases. Excessive smartphone use and addiction have developed into big social issues. Addiction to smartphones is a negative and pathological concept that is assessed by a set of subjective and behavioral symptoms including fixation, loss of control, and withdrawal symptoms. Teachers in STEM fields have a higher degree of involvement with their students in the use of digital tools. STEM teacher candidates must demonstrate an understanding of how to incorporate technology successfully into classroom activities. Determine the incidence of smartphone addiction among prospective STEM educators to justify future awareness training. The association between pre-service STEM instructors’ smartphone addiction was studied. The research included 242 persons, 180 of whom were females and 62 males. The SAI is self-administered and scored independently for each dimension. Data is analyzed using machine learning techniques. Cluster analysis is used to analyze the inventory’s dimensions. The k-means technique is used for cluster analysis. The library’s SHAP (SHapley additive explanations) approach was used to evaluate the classification result and assess the impact of attributes on the classification result. According to the findings, the highest level was judged to be 30 participants. Approximately 3%4 participants are deemed moderate (high and very high). Also, 48 people are at a low level. In terms of the overall group, it is modest. Being in the lowest cluster is linked to 100+ uses, whereas being in the highest cluster is linked to 6-10 uses. The exact degree of smartphone use linked to smartphone addiction is unknown. Females inversely correlate with the highest and lowest clusters.


  • Open Access

    Investigation of the Effects of University Field Courses on Distance Education

    by Shemsedin Vehabi, Chulpan S. Zakirova, Alfiya R. Masalimova, Elmira R. Khairullina, Elena V. Slepneva, Sergey A. Reznichenko

    This research focuses on examining the effects of university field courses on distance education and the integration of distance education into courses. A group of 357 university students studying biomedical engineering at universities in the Kosovo region and the Russian Federation volunteered to participate in the research. A quantitative research method was used in the study. In the research, the "Distance Education" measurement tool developed by the researchers was used as a data collection tool. The questionnaire was developed and edited by experts in the field. Data were collected using an online survey. The collected data were ana-lysed using the SPSS program. Frequency, percentage, mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum values, one-way ANOVA and T-test were applied to analyse the data obtained from the Distance Education measurement tool. This re-search concluded that the majority of university students consider them-selves competent enough to use distance education technologies in the learning environment in the field courses, and they do not have difficulty using the systems in the field courses and their universities do not have sufficient equipment for the use of distance education technologies.