Navjit Sagoo
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Navjit Sagoo has a total of 92 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Thorsten Mauritsen
15 shared publications- Martin Renoult
Department of Geological Sciences, Stockholm University, Stockholm, 11417, Sweden
14 shared publications - Daniel J. Lunt
School of Geographical Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
7 shared publications - Johannes Hörner
Department of Meteorology and Geophysics, University of Vienna
6 shared publications - Matthew Huber
Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences Purdue University West Lafayette IN USA
6 shared publications A. Winguth
University of Texas at Arlington
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (2) , 303-318
Snowball Earth transitions from Last Glacial Maximum conditions provide an independent upper limit on Earth's climate sensitivity
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (>635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the snowball instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly, the snowball Earth transition appears to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity by using the relationship of simulated LGM temperatures and the models' equilibrium climate sensitivity. The constraint depends only on the simple fact that Earth did not enter a snowball instability during the recent ice ages. Using the here estimated transition temperature, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 6.2 °C (3.9–8.4 °C, 5 %–95 % confidence). This upper bound estimate of climate sensitivity is only weakly sensitive to uncertainty in the transition temperature, approximately 0.3° per degree.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (2) , 303-318
Open AccessSnowball Earth transitions from Last Glacial Maximum conditions provide an independent upper limit on Earth's climate sensitivity
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (>635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the snowball instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly, the snowball Earth transition appears to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity by using the relationship of simulated LGM temperatures and the models' equilibrium climate sensitivity. The constraint depends only on the simple fact that Earth did not enter a snowball instability during the recent ice ages. Using the here estimated transition temperature, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 6.2 °C (3.9–8.4 °C, 5 %–95 % confidence). This upper bound estimate of climate sensitivity is only weakly sensitive to uncertainty in the transition temperature, approximately 0.3° per degree.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Exploring how physical climate storylines and narratives impact private stakeholder behaviour
The private sector and industry are increasingly accessing physical climate data to a) identify and disclose climate risk as required by regulations and b) seek to estimate and limit both present and future economic impacts of physical risk on their business.Projections of physical climate risk and associated changes in estimates in losses are typically provided to private sector stakeholders in isolation from the wider social and systemic picture. Whilst individual private sector stakeholders can take some measures to minimise impacts from climate hazards, a collective approach in conjunction with local communities and the public sector may be more effective, in terms of both risk reduction, and upfront cost.We provide physical climate storylines and narratives as a complement to the typical physical risk data provided to private stakeholders. We work with many private stakeholders and are seeking interdisciplinary discussion and collaboration with a view to exploring and quantifying the cost- benefit of individual stakeholder action versus collective action.
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessExploring how physical climate storylines and narratives impact private stakeholder behaviour
The private sector and industry are increasingly accessing physical climate data to a) identify and disclose climate risk as required by regulations and b) seek to estimate and limit both present and future economic impacts of physical risk on their business.Projections of physical climate risk and associated changes in estimates in losses are typically provided to private sector stakeholders in isolation from the wider social and systemic picture. Whilst individual private sector stakeholders can take some measures to minimise impacts from climate hazards, a collective approach in conjunction with local communities and the public sector may be more effective, in terms of both risk reduction, and upfront cost.We provide physical climate storylines and narratives as a complement to the typical physical risk data provided to private stakeholders. We work with many private stakeholders and are seeking interdisciplinary discussion and collaboration with a view to exploring and quantifying the cost- benefit of individual stakeholder action versus collective action.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC3
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC3
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- Open Access
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC1
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC1
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- Open Access
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Comment on egusphere-2024-2981
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2981
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- Open Access
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Comment on egusphere-2024-2981
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2981
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Snowball Earth transitions from Last Glacial Maximum conditions provide an independent upper limit on Earth’s climate sensitivity
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- 2 October 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessSnowball Earth transitions from Last Glacial Maximum conditions provide an independent upper limit on Earth’s climate sensitivity
Geological evidence of a snowball Earth state indicate persistent tropical sea ice cover during the Neoproterozoic (> 635 million years ago). Current theory is that a strengthening of the positive surface albedo feedback with cooling temperatures, eventually exceeding the sum of all other feedbacks, leads to a global climate instability. Several recent high sensitivity climate models with strongly positive cloud feedbacks have not been able to simulate the much warmer Last Glacial Maximum state, suggestive that they cool excessively in response to a modest decrease in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore enter the snowball instability by this mechanism. Using a coupled Earth system model, MPI-ESM1.2, we show that clouds accelerate the transition to a snowball Earth state and reduce the radiative forcing required to trigger the climate instability. Positive cloud feedbacks over tropical oceans and ahead of the sea-ice edge act to cool down the oceans and promote sea ice formation. Regardless, when approached slowly the snowball Earth transitions appear to occur around a global mean temperature of zero degree Celsius, simultaneously with the sea ice edge advancing into the sub-tropics thereby strengthening the surface albedo feedback. This temperature threshold, if supported by several climate models, could be used as a novel and independent constraint on the upper bound of climate sensitivity. Currently, using the results from MPI-ESM1.2, we find it is implausible that Earth's climate sensitivity exceeds 5.5 K (4.4–6.6, 90 percent confidence).
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Observationally Constrained Cloud Phase Unmasks Orbitally Driven Climate Feedbacks
The mechanisms that amplify orbitally-driven changes in insolation and drive the glacial cycles of the past 2.6 million years, the Pleistocene, are poorly understood. Previous studies indicate that cloud-phase feedbacks oppose ice sheet initiation when orbital configuration supports ice sheet growth. Cloud phase was observationally constrained in a recent study and provides evidence for a weaker negative cloud feedback in response to carbon dioxide doubling. We observationally constrain cloud phase in the Community Earth System Model and explore how changes in orbital configuration impact the climate response. Constraining cloud phase weakens the negative high latitude cloud phase feedback and unmasks positive water vapor and cloud feedbacks (amount and optical depth) that extend cooling to lower latitudes. Snowfall accumulation and ablation metrics also support ice sheet expansion as seen in proxy records. This indicates that well-known cloud and water vapor feedbacks are the mechanisms amplifying orbital climate forcing.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessObservationally Constrained Cloud Phase Unmasks Orbitally Driven Climate Feedbacks
The mechanisms that amplify orbitally-driven changes in insolation and drive the glacial cycles of the past 2.6 million years, the Pleistocene, are poorly understood. Previous studies indicate that cloud-phase feedbacks oppose ice sheet initiation when orbital configuration supports ice sheet growth. Cloud phase was observationally constrained in a recent study and provides evidence for a weaker negative cloud feedback in response to carbon dioxide doubling. We observationally constrain cloud phase in the Community Earth System Model and explore how changes in orbital configuration impact the climate response. Constraining cloud phase weakens the negative high latitude cloud phase feedback and unmasks positive water vapor and cloud feedbacks (amount and optical depth) that extend cooling to lower latitudes. Snowfall accumulation and ablation metrics also support ice sheet expansion as seen in proxy records. This indicates that well-known cloud and water vapor feedbacks are the mechanisms amplifying orbital climate forcing.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Are high sensitivity models compatible with the Last Glacial Maximum?
The wide range of Effective Climate Sensitivity (ECS) values in climate models are driven by inter-model spread in cloud feedbacks. The most recent generation of models (CMIP6) show an increase in both average ECS values as well as the appearance of very high ECS values (> 4.5 K) compared to the previous generation which has been attributed to an increase in the strength of total cloud feedbacks in CMIP6. Constraining ECS and in particular the high range of ECS values is paramount for reliable predictions of future climate change. The Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) is an out-of-sample climate for modern models and thus provides a valuable evaluation test for these models. This work explores whether models with high ECS values are compatible with the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) climate and whether we can use the LGM to constrain a plausible upper boundary of ECS. We create a single model ensemble with a wide range of ECS values by modifying cloud feedbacks in the MPI-ESM1.2 model. We simulate the LGM with this ensemble and compare it with four different paleo-reconstructions. Our results indicate models with an ECS > 4 K are incompatible with the existing LGM climate reconstructions: global surface air temperature (SAT) anomalies are too cold compared to reconstructions and ultimately become unstable due to sea ice dynamics in the model. Our study indicates that models with large total cloud feedbacks and high ECS values are not plausible during the LGM. This study highlights the value of using paleoclimates to benchmark models particularly in areas where existing validation techniques are not yet sufficient i.e. constraining cloud feedbacks.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAre high sensitivity models compatible with the Last Glacial Maximum?
The wide range of Effective Climate Sensitivity (ECS) values in climate models are driven by inter-model spread in cloud feedbacks. The most recent generation of models (CMIP6) show an increase in both average ECS values as well as the appearance of very high ECS values (> 4.5 K) compared to the previous generation which has been attributed to an increase in the strength of total cloud feedbacks in CMIP6. Constraining ECS and in particular the high range of ECS values is paramount for reliable predictions of future climate change. The Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) is an out-of-sample climate for modern models and thus provides a valuable evaluation test for these models. This work explores whether models with high ECS values are compatible with the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) climate and whether we can use the LGM to constrain a plausible upper boundary of ECS. We create a single model ensemble with a wide range of ECS values by modifying cloud feedbacks in the MPI-ESM1.2 model. We simulate the LGM with this ensemble and compare it with four different paleo-reconstructions. Our results indicate models with an ECS > 4 K are incompatible with the existing LGM climate reconstructions: global surface air temperature (SAT) anomalies are too cold compared to reconstructions and ultimately become unstable due to sea ice dynamics in the model. Our study indicates that models with large total cloud feedbacks and high ECS values are not plausible during the LGM. This study highlights the value of using paleoclimates to benchmark models particularly in areas where existing validation techniques are not yet sufficient i.e. constraining cloud feedbacks.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
High-biased climate sensitivity estimates from mid-Pliocene Warm Period temperatures
The warm Pliocene epoch is used to estimate Earth's equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS), which is the long-term temperature change after a sustained doubling of atmospheric CO2 over pre-industrial levels. Using an emergent constraint on the relationship between mid-Pliocene Warm Period simulated temperatures and ECS, we estimate ECS to be 4.8 K, which is higher than previous studies on the Pliocene. This is partly due to using warmer SST reconstruction than before; a consequence of focusing modelling efforts on the mid-Pliocene warm period. Using the temperatures of a broader period within the Pliocene, we quantify ECS to be 3.1 K. Further uncertainties on proxy data and data-model disagreements are expected to affect ECS estimates. We find that CO2 uncertainties are the main driver of variations in ECS estimates, followed by biases from seasonal temperatures. The bias from polar amplification is apparently small, but could be an overlooked source of error. We conclude that the Pliocene-based emergent constraint is nonetheless robust and is likely to improve further as geological reconstructions improve.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessHigh-biased climate sensitivity estimates from mid-Pliocene Warm Period temperatures
The warm Pliocene epoch is used to estimate Earth's equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS), which is the long-term temperature change after a sustained doubling of atmospheric CO2 over pre-industrial levels. Using an emergent constraint on the relationship between mid-Pliocene Warm Period simulated temperatures and ECS, we estimate ECS to be 4.8 K, which is higher than previous studies on the Pliocene. This is partly due to using warmer SST reconstruction than before; a consequence of focusing modelling efforts on the mid-Pliocene warm period. Using the temperatures of a broader period within the Pliocene, we quantify ECS to be 3.1 K. Further uncertainties on proxy data and data-model disagreements are expected to affect ECS estimates. We find that CO2 uncertainties are the main driver of variations in ECS estimates, followed by biases from seasonal temperatures. The bias from polar amplification is apparently small, but could be an overlooked source of error. We conclude that the Pliocene-based emergent constraint is nonetheless robust and is likely to improve further as geological reconstructions improve.