Kristin B. Hulvey
Research Subjects
Kristin B. Hulvey has a total of 105 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Erika S. Zavaleta
University of California Department of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology Santa Cruz
4 shared publications - Michael Philip Perring
UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology Deiniol Road Bangor LL57 2UW U.K.
4 shared publications Rachel J. Standish
3 shared publications- Richard J. Hobbs
School of Biological Sciences University of Western Australia Crawley WA 6009 Australia
3 shared publications Elise S. Gornish
School of Natural Resources and Environment University of Arizona Tucson AZ 85721 U.S.A.
2 shared publications- Lori Lach
Centre for Tropical Biosecurity, College of Science & Engineering James Cook University Smithfield Queensland Australia
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 8 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 112 (5) , 1164-1180
Tree diversity reduces variability in sapling survival under drought
Enhancing tree diversity may be important to fostering resilience to drought‐related climate extremes. So far, little attention has been given to whether tree diversity can increase the survival of trees and reduce its variability in young forest plantations. We conducted an analysis of seedling and sapling survival from 34 globally distributed tree diversity experiments (363,167 trees, 168 species, 3744 plots, 7 biomes) to answer two questions: (1) Do drought and tree diversity alter the mean and variability in plot‐level tree survival, with higher and less variable survival as diversity increases? and (2) Do species that survive poorly in monocultures survive better in mixtures and do specific functional traits explain monoculture survival? Tree species richness reduced variability in plot‐level survival, while functional diversity (Rao's Q entropy) increased survival and also reduced its variability. Importantly, the reduction in survival variability became stronger as drought severity increased. We found that species with low survival in monocultures survived comparatively better in mixtures when under drought. Species survival in monoculture was positively associated with drought resistance (indicated by hydraulic traits such as turgor loss point), plant height and conservative resource‐acquisition traits (e.g. low leaf nitrogen concentration and small leaf size). Synthesis. The findings highlight: (1) The effectiveness of tree diversity for decreasing the variability in seedling and sapling survival under drought; and (2) the importance of drought resistance and associated traits to explain altered tree species survival in response to tree diversity and drought. From an ecological perspective, we recommend mixing be considered to stabilize tree survival, particularly when functionally diverse forests with drought‐resistant species also promote high survival of drought‐sensitive species.
- 8 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 112 (5) , 1164-1180
Tree diversity reduces variability in sapling survival under drought
Enhancing tree diversity may be important to fostering resilience to drought‐related climate extremes. So far, little attention has been given to whether tree diversity can increase the survival of trees and reduce its variability in young forest plantations. We conducted an analysis of seedling and sapling survival from 34 globally distributed tree diversity experiments (363,167 trees, 168 species, 3744 plots, 7 biomes) to answer two questions: (1) Do drought and tree diversity alter the mean and variability in plot‐level tree survival, with higher and less variable survival as diversity increases? and (2) Do species that survive poorly in monocultures survive better in mixtures and do specific functional traits explain monoculture survival? Tree species richness reduced variability in plot‐level survival, while functional diversity (Rao's Q entropy) increased survival and also reduced its variability. Importantly, the reduction in survival variability became stronger as drought severity increased. We found that species with low survival in monocultures survived comparatively better in mixtures when under drought. Species survival in monoculture was positively associated with drought resistance (indicated by hydraulic traits such as turgor loss point), plant height and conservative resource‐acquisition traits (e.g. low leaf nitrogen concentration and small leaf size). Synthesis. The findings highlight: (1) The effectiveness of tree diversity for decreasing the variability in seedling and sapling survival under drought; and (2) the importance of drought resistance and associated traits to explain altered tree species survival in response to tree diversity and drought. From an ecological perspective, we recommend mixing be considered to stabilize tree survival, particularly when functionally diverse forests with drought‐resistant species also promote high survival of drought‐sensitive species.
- Open Access
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 58 (10) , 2113-2123
Rotational grazing can mitigate ecosystem service trade‐offs between livestock production and water quality in semi‐arid rangelands
Mitigating ecosystem service (ES) trade‐offs is a key management goal in locations where stakeholders value different and potentially conflicting ecosystem services (ESs). However, studies are not often designed to examine how local management actions address ES trade‐offs, and therefore do not provide options that can alleviate conflict. In semi‐arid rangelands, we examined the potential for managers to mitigate trade‐offs between livestock production and water quality. To move away from solutions that offer cattle removal as a singular management strategy, we examined how cattle presence, plus two elements of rotational grazing—the length of time cattle spend on rangeland (i.e. duration), and the season grazed (i.e. timing), affected stream Escherichia coli (E. coli concentrations). We also modelled how grazing duration and timing affected the ability to meet regulatory benchmarks for water quality throughout a grazing season. Grazing duration controlled the length of time E. coli concentrations were high in streams. In short‐ and medium‐duration systems, E. coli concentrations were high for shorter periods of time than in long‐duration systems, resulting in fewer violations of national and state water quality standards. Stream E. coli concentrations showed a consistent seasonal pattern, starting low in spring, peaking in summer and declining towards fall. Thus, grazing during spring or fall, rather than in summer, reduced the number of days that E. coli levels exceeded water quality standards. Our results suggest that reducing the grazing duration and shifting its timing are complementary strategies that can mitigate the trade‐offs between livestock grazing and water quality without fencing‐off riparian areas or removing cattle from pastures with streams. Synthesis and applications. In this study, we found grazing duration and timing can be used as tools to mitigate ecosystem service (ES) trade‐offs between cattle production and water quality in rangeland streams. Shorter grazing durations reduced the number of days E. coli levels were above regulatory limits, as did grazing that occurred either early or late in the season. These results support the idea that rotational grazing can be an effective strategy to manage water quality in semi‐arid rangelands. They also highlight the need for more grazing studies that incorporate gradients of duration and timing into study designs.
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 58 (10) , 2113-2123
Open AccessRotational grazing can mitigate ecosystem service trade‐offs between livestock production and water quality in semi‐arid rangelands
Mitigating ecosystem service (ES) trade‐offs is a key management goal in locations where stakeholders value different and potentially conflicting ecosystem services (ESs). However, studies are not often designed to examine how local management actions address ES trade‐offs, and therefore do not provide options that can alleviate conflict. In semi‐arid rangelands, we examined the potential for managers to mitigate trade‐offs between livestock production and water quality. To move away from solutions that offer cattle removal as a singular management strategy, we examined how cattle presence, plus two elements of rotational grazing—the length of time cattle spend on rangeland (i.e. duration), and the season grazed (i.e. timing), affected stream Escherichia coli (E. coli concentrations). We also modelled how grazing duration and timing affected the ability to meet regulatory benchmarks for water quality throughout a grazing season. Grazing duration controlled the length of time E. coli concentrations were high in streams. In short‐ and medium‐duration systems, E. coli concentrations were high for shorter periods of time than in long‐duration systems, resulting in fewer violations of national and state water quality standards. Stream E. coli concentrations showed a consistent seasonal pattern, starting low in spring, peaking in summer and declining towards fall. Thus, grazing during spring or fall, rather than in summer, reduced the number of days that E. coli levels exceeded water quality standards. Our results suggest that reducing the grazing duration and shifting its timing are complementary strategies that can mitigate the trade‐offs between livestock grazing and water quality without fencing‐off riparian areas or removing cattle from pastures with streams. Synthesis and applications. In this study, we found grazing duration and timing can be used as tools to mitigate ecosystem service (ES) trade‐offs between cattle production and water quality in rangeland streams. Shorter grazing durations reduced the number of days E. coli levels were above regulatory limits, as did grazing that occurred either early or late in the season. These results support the idea that rotational grazing can be an effective strategy to manage water quality in semi‐arid rangelands. They also highlight the need for more grazing studies that incorporate gradients of duration and timing into study designs.
- Open Access
- 3 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 58 (8) , 1705-1717
Global change shifts trade‐offs among ecosystem functions in woodlands restored for multifunctionality
Ecological restoration increasingly aims at improving ecosystem multifunctionality and making landscapes resilient to future threats, especially in biodiversity hotspots such as Mediterranean‐type ecosystems. Plants and their traits play a major role in the functioning of an ecosystem. Therefore, successful restoration towards long‐term multifunctionality requires a fundamental mechanistic understanding of this link under changing climate. An integrated approach of empirical research and simulation modelling with a focus on plant traits can allow this understanding. Based on empirical data from a large‐scale restoration project in a Mediterranean‐type ecosystem in Western Australia, we developed and validated the spatially explicit simulation model Modelling Ecosystem Functions and Services based on Traits (ModEST), which calculates coupled dynamics of nutrients, water and individual plants characterised by functional traits. We then simulated all possible combinations of eight plant species with different levels of diversity to assess the role of plant diversity and traits on multifunctionality, the provision of six ecosystem functions that can be linked to ecosystem services, as well as trade‐offs and synergies among the functions under current and future climatic conditions. Our results show that multifunctionality cannot fully be achieved because of trade‐offs among functions that are attributable to sets of traits that affect functions differently. Our measure of multifunctionality was increased by higher levels of planted species richness under current, but not future climatic conditions. In contrast, single functions were differently impacted by increased plant diversity and thus the choice and weighting of these functions affected multifunctionality. In addition, we found that trade‐offs and synergies among functions shifted with climate change due to different direct and indirect (mediated via community trait changes) effects of climate change on functions. Synthesis and application. With our simulation model Modelling Ecosystem Functions and Services based on Traits (ModEST), we show that restoration towards multifunctionality might be challenging not only under current conditions but also in the long‐term. However, once ModEST is parameterised and validated for a specific restoration site, managers can assess which target goals can be achieved given the set of available plant species and site‐specific conditions. It can also highlight which species combinations can best achieve long‐term improved multifunctionality due to their trait diversity.
- 3 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 58 (8) , 1705-1717
Open AccessGlobal change shifts trade‐offs among ecosystem functions in woodlands restored for multifunctionality
Ecological restoration increasingly aims at improving ecosystem multifunctionality and making landscapes resilient to future threats, especially in biodiversity hotspots such as Mediterranean‐type ecosystems. Plants and their traits play a major role in the functioning of an ecosystem. Therefore, successful restoration towards long‐term multifunctionality requires a fundamental mechanistic understanding of this link under changing climate. An integrated approach of empirical research and simulation modelling with a focus on plant traits can allow this understanding. Based on empirical data from a large‐scale restoration project in a Mediterranean‐type ecosystem in Western Australia, we developed and validated the spatially explicit simulation model Modelling Ecosystem Functions and Services based on Traits (ModEST), which calculates coupled dynamics of nutrients, water and individual plants characterised by functional traits. We then simulated all possible combinations of eight plant species with different levels of diversity to assess the role of plant diversity and traits on multifunctionality, the provision of six ecosystem functions that can be linked to ecosystem services, as well as trade‐offs and synergies among the functions under current and future climatic conditions. Our results show that multifunctionality cannot fully be achieved because of trade‐offs among functions that are attributable to sets of traits that affect functions differently. Our measure of multifunctionality was increased by higher levels of planted species richness under current, but not future climatic conditions. In contrast, single functions were differently impacted by increased plant diversity and thus the choice and weighting of these functions affected multifunctionality. In addition, we found that trade‐offs and synergies among functions shifted with climate change due to different direct and indirect (mediated via community trait changes) effects of climate change on functions. Synthesis and application. With our simulation model Modelling Ecosystem Functions and Services based on Traits (ModEST), we show that restoration towards multifunctionality might be challenging not only under current conditions but also in the long‐term. However, once ModEST is parameterised and validated for a specific restoration site, managers can assess which target goals can be achieved given the set of available plant species and site‐specific conditions. It can also highlight which species combinations can best achieve long‐term improved multifunctionality due to their trait diversity.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Rangelands
- Vol. 40 (5) , 152-159
A Comparison of Two Herbaceous Cover Sampling Methods to Assess Ecosystem Services in High-Shrub Rangelands: Photography-Based Grid Point Intercept (GPI) Versus Quadrat Sampling
- 1 October 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Rangelands
- Vol. 40 (5) , 152-159
Open AccessA Comparison of Two Herbaceous Cover Sampling Methods to Assess Ecosystem Services in High-Shrub Rangelands: Photography-Based Grid Point Intercept (GPI) Versus Quadrat Sampling
- Open Access
Site conditions determine a key native plant's contribution to invasion resistance in grasslands
Many plant invasion studies in grasslands suggest that resident plants that share functional traits with invaders can reduce invasion by competing for limiting resources. However, since invasion studies often occur in highly controlled plots or microcosms, it is unclear how heterogeneous site conditions alter competitive interactions under realistic scenarios. To explore how landscape heterogeneity affects biotic resistance provided by competitive resident plants, we conducted a field‐based experiment across four sites in California grasslands. Plots contained naturally occurring populations of nativeHemizonia congesta,but differed in other characteristics, including litter cover, annual grass cover, soil moisture, and species richness. We invaded plots with the functionally similar nonnativeCentaurea solstitalis(yellow starthistle) and, at one site, supplemented one‐half of the established plots with water to test the effects of increasing a limiting resource. As in simplified plots and microcosms, increasingH. congestaabundance reduced starthistle biomass by competing for limited soil moisture, but only in plots with high starthistle germination. We conclude that higher abundances of nativeH. congestacan reduce starthistle invasion in heterogeneous grasslands, but competition is also affected by both abiotic (soil moisture) and biotic (starthistle germination number) conditions that vary across sites.
Open AccessSite conditions determine a key native plant's contribution to invasion resistance in grasslands
Many plant invasion studies in grasslands suggest that resident plants that share functional traits with invaders can reduce invasion by competing for limiting resources. However, since invasion studies often occur in highly controlled plots or microcosms, it is unclear how heterogeneous site conditions alter competitive interactions under realistic scenarios. To explore how landscape heterogeneity affects biotic resistance provided by competitive resident plants, we conducted a field‐based experiment across four sites in California grasslands. Plots contained naturally occurring populations of nativeHemizonia congesta,but differed in other characteristics, including litter cover, annual grass cover, soil moisture, and species richness. We invaded plots with the functionally similar nonnativeCentaurea solstitalis(yellow starthistle) and, at one site, supplemented one‐half of the established plots with water to test the effects of increasing a limiting resource. As in simplified plots and microcosms, increasingH. congestaabundance reduced starthistle biomass by competing for limited soil moisture, but only in plots with high starthistle germination. We conclude that higher abundances of nativeH. congestacan reduce starthistle invasion in heterogeneous grasslands, but competition is also affected by both abiotic (soil moisture) and biotic (starthistle germination number) conditions that vary across sites.
- 13 March 2018
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Society Bulletin
- Vol. 42 (1) , 131-135
Susceptibility of spring‐flowering garden plants to herbivory by mule deer
Many people look forward to spring flowers, only to discover that mule deer ( Odocoileus hemionus ) have eaten the sprouting plants and flower buds. One potential method to prevent this problem is to grow unpalatable flowering plants in gardens where deer herbivory is expected, but this requires knowledge about the relative palatability of plant species. We examined spring‐flowering plants in gardens located in Cache County, Utah, USA (2010 through 2017), and recorded the proportion of leaves and flower buds browsed by mule deer. Mule deer browsing was greatest on tulips ( Tulipa spp.), grape hyacinths ( Muscari spp.), and crocuses ( Crocus spp.) and lowest on iris ( Iris spp.) and daffodils ( Narcissus spp.) We hypothesized that the first plants to sprout in the spring experienced greater levels of deer herbivory because of the lack of alternate plants that deer can browse during that time of year. To test this hypothesis, we started plants in greenhouses so that they sprouted at the same time. We then placed these plants in locations throughout Cache Valley where there were deer trails and deer feces. Among these plants, tulip, liatris ( Liatris spp.), and grape hyacinth were browsed heavily, suggesting that deer found these plants palatable. In contrast, crocus were rarely eaten, suggesting that deer damage on this plant results more from its early sprouting rather than its palatability. Planting unpalatable plants may be a viable approach to reducing homeowners’ angst from finding that their spring‐flowering plants have been browsed. Wildlife biologists and Cooperative Extension agents should find our results useful when guiding homeowners in selecting which spring‐flowering plants to grow in areas where deer herbivory can be expected. © 2018 The Wildlife Society.
- 13 March 2018
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Society Bulletin
- Vol. 42 (1) , 131-135
Susceptibility of spring‐flowering garden plants to herbivory by mule deer
Many people look forward to spring flowers, only to discover that mule deer ( Odocoileus hemionus ) have eaten the sprouting plants and flower buds. One potential method to prevent this problem is to grow unpalatable flowering plants in gardens where deer herbivory is expected, but this requires knowledge about the relative palatability of plant species. We examined spring‐flowering plants in gardens located in Cache County, Utah, USA (2010 through 2017), and recorded the proportion of leaves and flower buds browsed by mule deer. Mule deer browsing was greatest on tulips ( Tulipa spp.), grape hyacinths ( Muscari spp.), and crocuses ( Crocus spp.) and lowest on iris ( Iris spp.) and daffodils ( Narcissus spp.) We hypothesized that the first plants to sprout in the spring experienced greater levels of deer herbivory because of the lack of alternate plants that deer can browse during that time of year. To test this hypothesis, we started plants in greenhouses so that they sprouted at the same time. We then placed these plants in locations throughout Cache Valley where there were deer trails and deer feces. Among these plants, tulip, liatris ( Liatris spp.), and grape hyacinth were browsed heavily, suggesting that deer found these plants palatable. In contrast, crocus were rarely eaten, suggesting that deer damage on this plant results more from its early sprouting rather than its palatability. Planting unpalatable plants may be a viable approach to reducing homeowners’ angst from finding that their spring‐flowering plants have been browsed. Wildlife biologists and Cooperative Extension agents should find our results useful when guiding homeowners in selecting which spring‐flowering plants to grow in areas where deer herbivory can be expected. © 2018 The Wildlife Society.
- 3 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 32 (4) , 926-937
Assessment of the Conservation Measures Partnership's effort to improve conservation outcomes through adaptive management
Conservation practice has demonstrated an increasing desire for accountability of actions, particularly with respect to effectiveness, efficiency, and impact to clearly identified objectives. This has been accompanied by increased attention to achieving adaptive management. In 2002, practitioners representing several prominent conservation nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) launched a community of practice called the Conservation Measures Partnership (CMP). The partnership CMP has worked to establish standards of conservation practice to improve accountability of conservation actions through adaptive management. The focal organizing framework for CMP has been the Open Standards for the Practice of Conservation (OS). We evaluated, through an online survey and personal interviews, the first decade of CMP and the OS. The CMP has garnered a positive reputation among agencies, NGOs, and funders and has succeeded in developing a large user base of the OS. However, CMP has not fully achieved its goal of making the OS standard operating procedure for the largest NGOs (e.g., The Nature Conservancy, World Wildlife Fund), despite it being widely used within these organizations. This lack of institutionalization is attributable to multiple causes, including an increase in the number of partially overlapping decision‐support frameworks and challenges achieving full‐cycle adaptive management. Users strongly believed the OS fosters better conservation practice and highly valued the OS for improving their practice. A primary objective of the OS is to assist practitioners to achieve full‐cycle adaptive management to better integrate learning into improving the effectiveness and efficiency of actions. However, most practitioners had not yet achieved cycle completion for their projects. To improve the effectiveness of CMP, OS, and conservation practice in general, we recommend collaborative efforts among the proponents of multiple decision‐support frameworks to foster strong institutional adoption of a common set of adaptive‐management standards for conservation accountability.
- 3 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 32 (4) , 926-937
Assessment of the Conservation Measures Partnership's effort to improve conservation outcomes through adaptive management
Conservation practice has demonstrated an increasing desire for accountability of actions, particularly with respect to effectiveness, efficiency, and impact to clearly identified objectives. This has been accompanied by increased attention to achieving adaptive management. In 2002, practitioners representing several prominent conservation nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) launched a community of practice called the Conservation Measures Partnership (CMP). The partnership CMP has worked to establish standards of conservation practice to improve accountability of conservation actions through adaptive management. The focal organizing framework for CMP has been the Open Standards for the Practice of Conservation (OS). We evaluated, through an online survey and personal interviews, the first decade of CMP and the OS. The CMP has garnered a positive reputation among agencies, NGOs, and funders and has succeeded in developing a large user base of the OS. However, CMP has not fully achieved its goal of making the OS standard operating procedure for the largest NGOs (e.g., The Nature Conservancy, World Wildlife Fund), despite it being widely used within these organizations. This lack of institutionalization is attributable to multiple causes, including an increase in the number of partially overlapping decision‐support frameworks and challenges achieving full‐cycle adaptive management. Users strongly believed the OS fosters better conservation practice and highly valued the OS for improving their practice. A primary objective of the OS is to assist practitioners to achieve full‐cycle adaptive management to better integrate learning into improving the effectiveness and efficiency of actions. However, most practitioners had not yet achieved cycle completion for their projects. To improve the effectiveness of CMP, OS, and conservation practice in general, we recommend collaborative efforts among the proponents of multiple decision‐support frameworks to foster strong institutional adoption of a common set of adaptive‐management standards for conservation accountability.
- 17 December 2017
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 25 (S2) , S110-S113
Emerging approaches to successful ecological restoration: five imperatives to guide innovation
As the science of restoration ecology and the practice of habitat restoration adapt to new sets of goals in a changing climate, we turn our attention to novel techniques and emerging approaches in the field. This special issue brings together eight papers that answer the question, “Given that we have defined our goals, can we find better ways to reach them?” From them, we derive five directives for ecologists and practitioners seeking to innovate with new methods, analyses, or applications: (1) ground the approach in ecological theory; (2) take advantage of the latest technology and models; (3) reject dogma; (4) subject the analysis to critique; and (5) be aware of time, budget, and expertise constraints faced by stakeholders and practitioners. Our five imperatives are illustrated by examples of papers from the special issue.
- 17 December 2017
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 25 (S2) , S110-S113
Emerging approaches to successful ecological restoration: five imperatives to guide innovation
As the science of restoration ecology and the practice of habitat restoration adapt to new sets of goals in a changing climate, we turn our attention to novel techniques and emerging approaches in the field. This special issue brings together eight papers that answer the question, “Given that we have defined our goals, can we find better ways to reach them?” From them, we derive five directives for ecologists and practitioners seeking to innovate with new methods, analyses, or applications: (1) ground the approach in ecological theory; (2) take advantage of the latest technology and models; (3) reject dogma; (4) subject the analysis to critique; and (5) be aware of time, budget, and expertise constraints faced by stakeholders and practitioners. Our five imperatives are illustrated by examples of papers from the special issue.
- 29 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 25 (S2) , S124-S134
Restoration islands: a tool for efficiently restoring dryland ecosystems?
Restoration islands are concentrated plantings in strategic locations, created to efficiently use resources to achieve restoration goals. These methods have been used effectively in mesic ecosystems, particularly tropical forests, where the goal of island plantings is often to “nucleate” across a degraded area, providing a seed source for spread outside the planted area. Here, we consider how an island strategy might be used to achieve restoration goals in dryland ecosystems, where limited resources and large areas of degraded land make restoration extremely challenging. In contrast to more productive areas, spread or “nucleation” from restoration islands in drylands may not occur or occur more slowly than required by most management time frames. Despite this, small‐scale, more intensive island plantings may still be useful for achieving short‐term goals, such as weed control, fire management, erosion control, and creation of wildlife habitat. Over the long term, island plantings could serve the same nucleation function as in other ecosystems and serve as repositories for genetic diversity within highly fragmented native systems. Here, we highlight the opportunities for using these high‐intensity, targeted planting methods in dryland ecosystems, provide the guidelines for establishing islands to achieve short‐ and long‐term restoration goals, and identify the areas where additional research is needed to understand the value of restoration islands in dryland ecosystems.
- 29 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 25 (S2) , S124-S134
Restoration islands: a tool for efficiently restoring dryland ecosystems?
Restoration islands are concentrated plantings in strategic locations, created to efficiently use resources to achieve restoration goals. These methods have been used effectively in mesic ecosystems, particularly tropical forests, where the goal of island plantings is often to “nucleate” across a degraded area, providing a seed source for spread outside the planted area. Here, we consider how an island strategy might be used to achieve restoration goals in dryland ecosystems, where limited resources and large areas of degraded land make restoration extremely challenging. In contrast to more productive areas, spread or “nucleation” from restoration islands in drylands may not occur or occur more slowly than required by most management time frames. Despite this, small‐scale, more intensive island plantings may still be useful for achieving short‐term goals, such as weed control, fire management, erosion control, and creation of wildlife habitat. Over the long term, island plantings could serve the same nucleation function as in other ecosystems and serve as repositories for genetic diversity within highly fragmented native systems. Here, we highlight the opportunities for using these high‐intensity, targeted planting methods in dryland ecosystems, provide the guidelines for establishing islands to achieve short‐ and long‐term restoration goals, and identify the areas where additional research is needed to understand the value of restoration islands in dryland ecosystems.
- 3 June 2014
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 51 (4) , 997-1005
Using filter‐based community assembly models to improve restoration outcomes
Summary: Ecological filter models derived from community assembly theory can inform restoration planning by highlighting management actions most likely to affect community composition. Despite growing interest in these models, many restoration studies solely manipulate a single assembly filter – the biotic filter by altering interspecific competition – while ignoring abiotic and dispersal filters that may also influence restoration success. To examine how manipulating all three assembly filters (biotic, abiotic, dispersal) affected restoration in an annual‐type grassland, we seeded native forbs from the same functional group as a target invader to increase biotic resistance to invasion (biotic filter), cut standing biomass and either removed it or returned it to plots as litter to alter light conditions (abiotic filter), and added native forbs at different seeding rates to alter density of establishing native populations (dispersal filter). We measured grassland restoration success by recording native species and invader cover in plots. The addition of native species with phenological and morphological traits similar to the target invader reduced invasion and increased native populations, but only in litter‐free plots when high densities of native seed were added. Seeding two species with functional traits similar to the invader was more effective for achieving restoration goals than seeding just one functionally similar species. As such, trait differences among restoration species, even species belonging to the same functional group, may increase biotic resistance to invasion in restored communities. Litter removal altered native–invader interactions. When litter was left on the plots, added natives did not reduce invader cover. However, when litter was removed, added natives led to declines in invader cover. Increasing native seeding rates led to larger native populations and increased invasion resistance. Synthesis and applications. In this study, simultaneously manipulating biotic, abiotic and dispersal filters was necessary to optimize grassland restoration outcomes. In particular, the biotic filter only contributed to successful restoration outcomes under abiotic and dispersal conditions that were created through management actions specifically targeting these two additional filters. Restoration planning based on filter models should incorporate actions that target all three assembly filters, rather than solely focusing on the biotic filter.
- 3 June 2014
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 51 (4) , 997-1005
Using filter‐based community assembly models to improve restoration outcomes
Summary: Ecological filter models derived from community assembly theory can inform restoration planning by highlighting management actions most likely to affect community composition. Despite growing interest in these models, many restoration studies solely manipulate a single assembly filter – the biotic filter by altering interspecific competition – while ignoring abiotic and dispersal filters that may also influence restoration success. To examine how manipulating all three assembly filters (biotic, abiotic, dispersal) affected restoration in an annual‐type grassland, we seeded native forbs from the same functional group as a target invader to increase biotic resistance to invasion (biotic filter), cut standing biomass and either removed it or returned it to plots as litter to alter light conditions (abiotic filter), and added native forbs at different seeding rates to alter density of establishing native populations (dispersal filter). We measured grassland restoration success by recording native species and invader cover in plots. The addition of native species with phenological and morphological traits similar to the target invader reduced invasion and increased native populations, but only in litter‐free plots when high densities of native seed were added. Seeding two species with functional traits similar to the invader was more effective for achieving restoration goals than seeding just one functionally similar species. As such, trait differences among restoration species, even species belonging to the same functional group, may increase biotic resistance to invasion in restored communities. Litter removal altered native–invader interactions. When litter was left on the plots, added natives did not reduce invader cover. However, when litter was removed, added natives led to declines in invader cover. Increasing native seeding rates led to larger native populations and increased invasion resistance. Synthesis and applications. In this study, simultaneously manipulating biotic, abiotic and dispersal filters was necessary to optimize grassland restoration outcomes. In particular, the biotic filter only contributed to successful restoration outcomes under abiotic and dispersal conditions that were created through management actions specifically targeting these two additional filters. Restoration planning based on filter models should incorporate actions that target all three assembly filters, rather than solely focusing on the biotic filter.