William M. Baum
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
William M. Baum has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michael Davison
The University of Auckland Aotearoa/New Zealand
5 shared publications Michael Davison
University of Auckland
3 shared publicationsCarlos F. Aparicio
Salem State University
2 shared publications- Carlos F. Aparicio
University of Guadalajara
2 shared publications - Matthew C. Bell
Santa Clara University
2 shared publications Peter J. Richerson
University of California
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 28 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 181-202
Time Allocation, Induction, and Matching Theory
- Open Access
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 49 (2) , 297-311
Behavior, Process, and Evolution in the Multiscale Molar Paradigm
The Multiscale Molar View of behavior fits with evolutionary theory and with General Process Theory. These two theories combine to afford a monistic ontological basis for understanding behavior as consisting of extended activities controlled by extended behavior–environment relations. General Process Theory casts the world as process and all existences as processes—no objects, no events, and no substance. Although the theory applies to both animate and inanimate things, behavior analysts focus on animate processes. Evolutionary theory conceives of a species as a process, the function of which is to evolve, and the individual members—the parts—as processes, the function of which is to reproduce. All behavior consists of activities, which are processes that ultimately promote surviving and reproducing. Evolutionary theory, process ontology, and the concept of induction provide a powerful conceptual framework for understanding not only behavioral phenomena in the laboratory and everyday life but also for more flexible approaches to clinical applications.
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 49 (2) , 297-311
Open AccessBehavior, Process, and Evolution in the Multiscale Molar Paradigm
The Multiscale Molar View of behavior fits with evolutionary theory and with General Process Theory. These two theories combine to afford a monistic ontological basis for understanding behavior as consisting of extended activities controlled by extended behavior–environment relations. General Process Theory casts the world as process and all existences as processes—no objects, no events, and no substance. Although the theory applies to both animate and inanimate things, behavior analysts focus on animate processes. Evolutionary theory conceives of a species as a process, the function of which is to evolve, and the individual members—the parts—as processes, the function of which is to reproduce. All behavior consists of activities, which are processes that ultimately promote surviving and reproducing. Evolutionary theory, process ontology, and the concept of induction provide a powerful conceptual framework for understanding not only behavioral phenomena in the laboratory and everyday life but also for more flexible approaches to clinical applications.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 7, 1-40
Cultural evolution in the laboratory: evolution of cooperative altruistic punishing
Culture consists of practices – behaviour patterns – shared by members of a group. Some attempts to demonstrate evolution of cultural practices in the laboratory have shown evolution of material products, such as paper aeroplanes. Some attempts have shown evolution of actual group behaviour. The present experiments demonstrated evolution of group coordination across generations in punishing defection in a public-goods game. Cost of punishing defection varied across replicates that consisted of series of groups (generations) of 10 undergraduates each. Each generation played the game anonymously for 10 rounds and could write messages to the other participants and punish defection every round. The effectiveness of punishment depended on the number of participants choosing to punish. In Experiment 1, cultural transmission from generation to generation consisted of written advice from one generation read aloud to the next generation. In Experiment 2, transmission from generation to generation consisted of having some participants return from the previous group. The cost of punishing varied across replicates: zero, one, two or five cents. In both experiments, the evolution of altruistic punishing was strongly dependent on the cost of punishing. The results add to plausibility of studying evolution of complex behaviour patterns like cooperation in the laboratory.
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 7, 1-40
Open AccessCultural evolution in the laboratory: evolution of cooperative altruistic punishing
Culture consists of practices – behaviour patterns – shared by members of a group. Some attempts to demonstrate evolution of cultural practices in the laboratory have shown evolution of material products, such as paper aeroplanes. Some attempts have shown evolution of actual group behaviour. The present experiments demonstrated evolution of group coordination across generations in punishing defection in a public-goods game. Cost of punishing defection varied across replicates that consisted of series of groups (generations) of 10 undergraduates each. Each generation played the game anonymously for 10 rounds and could write messages to the other participants and punish defection every round. The effectiveness of punishment depended on the number of participants choosing to punish. In Experiment 1, cultural transmission from generation to generation consisted of written advice from one generation read aloud to the next generation. In Experiment 2, transmission from generation to generation consisted of having some participants return from the previous group. The cost of punishing varied across replicates: zero, one, two or five cents. In both experiments, the evolution of altruistic punishing was strongly dependent on the cost of punishing. The results add to plausibility of studying evolution of complex behaviour patterns like cooperation in the laboratory.
- Open Access
- 21 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 48 (2) , 173-202
Explaining Performance on Interval and Ratio Schedules with a Molar View of Behavior
Some of the most basic phenomena in behavior analysis are the differences between performance on interval and ratio schedules. They have long been known and long puzzled over. Previous attempts to explain the performances have foundered either because they lacked a mechanism or because they adopted a molecular view of behavior based on discrete responses and contiguity. The molar view of behavior offers the sought-for explanation of differences in activity rate and the inability of ratio schedules to maintain activity at low food rates. The present account relies on induction by phylogenetically important events (PIE) according to power functions, molar feedback functions, and the framework of matching theory. A model described by a feedback system with all parameters the same predicts the relations between activity rate and PIE rate. The difference in overall activity rate arises from a difference in units of activities selected by ratio and interval schedules. The results demonstrate the greater explanatory power of the molar view of behavior.
- 21 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 48 (2) , 173-202
Open AccessExplaining Performance on Interval and Ratio Schedules with a Molar View of Behavior
Some of the most basic phenomena in behavior analysis are the differences between performance on interval and ratio schedules. They have long been known and long puzzled over. Previous attempts to explain the performances have foundered either because they lacked a mechanism or because they adopted a molecular view of behavior based on discrete responses and contiguity. The molar view of behavior offers the sought-for explanation of differences in activity rate and the inability of ratio schedules to maintain activity at low food rates. The present account relies on induction by phylogenetically important events (PIE) according to power functions, molar feedback functions, and the framework of matching theory. A model described by a feedback system with all parameters the same predicts the relations between activity rate and PIE rate. The difference in overall activity rate arises from a difference in units of activities selected by ratio and interval schedules. The results demonstrate the greater explanatory power of the molar view of behavior.
- 26 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 122 (3) , 375-391
Understanding resurgence and other emergent activity with the laws of allocation, induction, and covariance
Resurgence is defined as an increase in a previously extinguished target response (B1) resulting from the worsening of conditions for a more recently reinforced alternative response (B2). Worsening includes extinction or reductions in rate, amount, and immediacy of delivery of food or some other phylogenetically important event (PIE). In the first part of the article, we apply the laws of allocation, induction, and covariance to understand not only resurgence of operant activity previously covarying with the PIE (B1) but also a constellation of ontogenetic and phylogenetic activities both related to the PIE (B0) and unrelated to the PIE (BN). In the second part, we discuss how induction might be incorporated into and provide alternative processes within an existing matching‐based framework, resurgence as choice (RaC). We begin to identify how this range of activities could depend on changes in the relative competitive weight (V) of all available activities (B1, B2, B0, BN) in addition to only those receiving explicit training (B1, B2). Future empirical and theoretical research is needed within this framework to provide a more complete understanding of resurgence and behavior more generally.
- 26 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 122 (3) , 375-391
Understanding resurgence and other emergent activity with the laws of allocation, induction, and covariance
Resurgence is defined as an increase in a previously extinguished target response (B1) resulting from the worsening of conditions for a more recently reinforced alternative response (B2). Worsening includes extinction or reductions in rate, amount, and immediacy of delivery of food or some other phylogenetically important event (PIE). In the first part of the article, we apply the laws of allocation, induction, and covariance to understand not only resurgence of operant activity previously covarying with the PIE (B1) but also a constellation of ontogenetic and phylogenetic activities both related to the PIE (B0) and unrelated to the PIE (BN). In the second part, we discuss how induction might be incorporated into and provide alternative processes within an existing matching‐based framework, resurgence as choice (RaC). We begin to identify how this range of activities could depend on changes in the relative competitive weight (V) of all available activities (B1, B2, B0, BN) in addition to only those receiving explicit training (B1, B2). Future empirical and theoretical research is needed within this framework to provide a more complete understanding of resurgence and behavior more generally.
- 3 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 121 (1) , 134-143
A molar view of goal direction and habit
When we treat behavior within an evolutionary framework and as temporally extended flow, two fundamental questions arise: (a) What is an organism? and (b) What is behavior? An organism is a process that stays intact by constantly exchanging energy with the environment. It takes in resources and puts out waste. The behavior of an organism consists of those process parts of the organism process that make up the exchange. These activities serve the function of reproducing, which generally depends on surviving. Surviving and reproducing depend on responding to phylogenetically important events (PIEs). A PIE induces activities that enhance or mitigate the PIE. Organisms respond not only to a PIE but also to events that covary with the PIE. Both activities and environmental features may covary with a PIE. When either type of covariance is introduced to an organism, behavior adapts over time. The early stages of adaptation constitute what researchers call “goal direction,” and the later stages constitute what researchers call “habit.” Behavior and environment constitute a dynamic system, and manipulations of the covariances and environmental features of the system allow many experimental interventions. This molar approach allows experiments on goal direction and habit to be understood without appeal to everyday mentalistic terms.
- 3 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 121 (1) , 134-143
A molar view of goal direction and habit
When we treat behavior within an evolutionary framework and as temporally extended flow, two fundamental questions arise: (a) What is an organism? and (b) What is behavior? An organism is a process that stays intact by constantly exchanging energy with the environment. It takes in resources and puts out waste. The behavior of an organism consists of those process parts of the organism process that make up the exchange. These activities serve the function of reproducing, which generally depends on surviving. Surviving and reproducing depend on responding to phylogenetically important events (PIEs). A PIE induces activities that enhance or mitigate the PIE. Organisms respond not only to a PIE but also to events that covary with the PIE. Both activities and environmental features may covary with a PIE. When either type of covariance is introduced to an organism, behavior adapts over time. The early stages of adaptation constitute what researchers call “goal direction,” and the later stages constitute what researchers call “habit.” Behavior and environment constitute a dynamic system, and manipulations of the covariances and environmental features of the system allow many experimental interventions. This molar approach allows experiments on goal direction and habit to be understood without appeal to everyday mentalistic terms.
- 24 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Behavioural Processes
- Vol. 206, 104834
Choice and rate-amount independence in a titration procedure
- 24 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Behavioural Processes
- Vol. 206, 104834
Choice and rate-amount independence in a titration procedure
- 24 May 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 118 (1) , 96-131
Rate matching, probability matching, and optimization in concurrent ratio schedules
Much research has documented rate matching in concurrent variable‐interval schedules, but comparatively little research has examined performance in concurrent variable‐ratio schedules, except in discrete‐trials procedures that sometimes produce probability matching. One should expect that the two types of schedule would result in different performances, because ratio schedules cannot improve with time the way interval schedules do; ratio schedules lack the temporal dynamics of interval schedules. The present experiment exposed rats to concurrent variable‐ratio schedules. Seven unsignaled components were presented in random order within each daily session, with probability ratios ranging from 1:8 to 8:1. Three conditions were studied that varied the overall probability of food while leaving probability ratios the same. Choice appeared to conform to probability matching, because sensitivities in the rate–matching relation were close to 0.5, whereas sensitivities to probability ratio were close to 1.0. The sensitivities alone, however, could not confirm probability matching, because undermatching to rate occurs often. Analyses at smaller time scales supported the interpretation of probability matching. In particular, control by food deliveries was highly local in concurrent variable‐ratio schedules, in contrast with concurrent variable‐interval schedules, in which control is extended. Activity continued to switch between alternatives throughout components, contradicting optimal sampling theory.
- 24 May 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 118 (1) , 96-131
Rate matching, probability matching, and optimization in concurrent ratio schedules
Much research has documented rate matching in concurrent variable‐interval schedules, but comparatively little research has examined performance in concurrent variable‐ratio schedules, except in discrete‐trials procedures that sometimes produce probability matching. One should expect that the two types of schedule would result in different performances, because ratio schedules cannot improve with time the way interval schedules do; ratio schedules lack the temporal dynamics of interval schedules. The present experiment exposed rats to concurrent variable‐ratio schedules. Seven unsignaled components were presented in random order within each daily session, with probability ratios ranging from 1:8 to 8:1. Three conditions were studied that varied the overall probability of food while leaving probability ratios the same. Choice appeared to conform to probability matching, because sensitivities in the rate–matching relation were close to 0.5, whereas sensitivities to probability ratio were close to 1.0. The sensitivities alone, however, could not confirm probability matching, because undermatching to rate occurs often. Analyses at smaller time scales supported the interpretation of probability matching. In particular, control by food deliveries was highly local in concurrent variable‐ratio schedules, in contrast with concurrent variable‐interval schedules, in which control is extended. Activity continued to switch between alternatives throughout components, contradicting optimal sampling theory.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 117 (2) , 123-150
Covariance, feedback, and discounting in ratio schedules
Action–outcome relations in the everyday world are often looser than the relations programmed in the laboratory. Reinforcement theory addressed this looseness by theorizing about “delay of reinforcement.” Response–reinforcer interval affects response rate and choice, but need not be thought of as delay. Experiments on temporal discounting are often said to reveal effects of delay also, but the intervals chosen differ from delays, because an outcome after a week, month, or year occurs after life has continued and many events have intervened. They are better called lag intervals. The present experiment studied the effects of varying lag interval on pigeons' responding on ratio‐like schedules of food. In a continuous procedure, a lag interval separated pecking that earned food from delivery of the food earned. In one series of conditions, the relation was fixed equivalent to variable‐ratio (VR) 40 while the lag interval varied. In a second series, the equivalent VR varied while the lag interval was fixed. The results accorded with matching theory, but with a factor for temporal discounting or loose feedback. The results suggest that both temporal discounting and probability discounting may be characterized within matching theory, but that temporal discounting requires a separate treatment from probability discounting.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 117 (2) , 123-150
Covariance, feedback, and discounting in ratio schedules
Action–outcome relations in the everyday world are often looser than the relations programmed in the laboratory. Reinforcement theory addressed this looseness by theorizing about “delay of reinforcement.” Response–reinforcer interval affects response rate and choice, but need not be thought of as delay. Experiments on temporal discounting are often said to reveal effects of delay also, but the intervals chosen differ from delays, because an outcome after a week, month, or year occurs after life has continued and many events have intervened. They are better called lag intervals. The present experiment studied the effects of varying lag interval on pigeons' responding on ratio‐like schedules of food. In a continuous procedure, a lag interval separated pecking that earned food from delivery of the food earned. In one series of conditions, the relation was fixed equivalent to variable‐ratio (VR) 40 while the lag interval varied. In a second series, the equivalent VR varied while the lag interval was fixed. The results accorded with matching theory, but with a factor for temporal discounting or loose feedback. The results suggest that both temporal discounting and probability discounting may be characterized within matching theory, but that temporal discounting requires a separate treatment from probability discounting.
- 23 September 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 116 (3) , 379-396
Behavioral ephemera, difficult discriminations, and behavioral stability
Every species possesses abilities for successfully interacting with its environment. These result from phylogeny. In the laboratory, one may arrange artificial conditions that thwart an organism's abilities. The result may be a “phenomenon.” With sufficient training, however, the phenomenon may prove to be ephemeral, as the organism's basic abilities reassert themselves. Pigeons respond extremely well to differences and nondifferences in rate of obtaining food. This ability may be thwarted in a variety of ways, but the results tend to be ephemeral. An example is an experiment that pitted pigeons' preference for unimpeded responding against their ability to respond to food rate. In a concurrent‐chains procedure, the terminal links were identical variable‐interval schedules, but in one terminal link, every response produced a timeout. The duration of the timeout varied, and preference varied with it, but the relation vanished with training, in keeping with the equality of food rate across the 2 terminal links. Some other examples of “phenomena” that tend to disappear with sufficient training and sufficient variation in experimental parameters are behavioral contrast, conditioned reinforcement, resistance to extinction, and suboptimal choice. These “phenomena” depend on pigeons' failing to make difficult discriminations. They appear to be behavioral ephemera.
- 23 September 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 116 (3) , 379-396
Behavioral ephemera, difficult discriminations, and behavioral stability
Every species possesses abilities for successfully interacting with its environment. These result from phylogeny. In the laboratory, one may arrange artificial conditions that thwart an organism's abilities. The result may be a “phenomenon.” With sufficient training, however, the phenomenon may prove to be ephemeral, as the organism's basic abilities reassert themselves. Pigeons respond extremely well to differences and nondifferences in rate of obtaining food. This ability may be thwarted in a variety of ways, but the results tend to be ephemeral. An example is an experiment that pitted pigeons' preference for unimpeded responding against their ability to respond to food rate. In a concurrent‐chains procedure, the terminal links were identical variable‐interval schedules, but in one terminal link, every response produced a timeout. The duration of the timeout varied, and preference varied with it, but the relation vanished with training, in keeping with the equality of food rate across the 2 terminal links. Some other examples of “phenomena” that tend to disappear with sufficient training and sufficient variation in experimental parameters are behavioral contrast, conditioned reinforcement, resistance to extinction, and suboptimal choice. These “phenomena” depend on pigeons' failing to make difficult discriminations. They appear to be behavioral ephemera.