Elena Makarova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Elena Makarova has a total of 352 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anna K. Döring
Psychology, School of Social Sciences, University of Westminster, London, UK
10 shared publications Walter Herzog
Institute for Educational Sciences, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
10 shared publicationsAnna K. Döring
School of Social Sciences, University of Westminster, London, United Kingdom
6 shared publications- Anat Bardi
Department of Psychology Royal Holloway, University of London Egham UK
5 shared publications - Jana Lindner
Institute for Educational Sciences, University of Basel
5 shared publications - Dina Birman
Department of Educational and Psychological Studies, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL, USA
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Contemporary Educational Psychology
- Vol. 86
Mapping longitudinal trajectories of personal values in elementary school: unveiling roles of the classroom
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Contemporary Educational Psychology
- Vol. 86
Open AccessMapping longitudinal trajectories of personal values in elementary school: unveiling roles of the classroom
- Open Access
- 4 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 16 (3) , 386
Tridimensional Acculturation and Academic Self-Concept of Minoritized Primary Students in Swiss Multicultural Classrooms: A Latent Profile Analysis
Schools are increasingly shaped by societal change and growing cultural diversity, calling for refined approaches to understanding the acculturation of minoritized students. This study examined acculturation profiles among minoritized primary students (n = 736) in Switzerland, applying a tridimensional framework that incorporates a multicultural orientation, beyond heritage and majority orientation. Using a three-stage latent profile analysis, four distinct acculturation profiles emerged: Multiculturalists (33.3%), Heritage-oriented Multiculturalists (29.9%), Majority-oriented Multiculturalists (29.2%), and a smaller group of Assimilationists (7.6%). The number of parents born abroad, religious practice, Swiss citizenship, and socioeconomic status predicted students’ profile membership. Comparisons of academic self-concept showed that only Majority-oriented Multiculturalists differed from the other profiles. Our findings suggest that a high multicultural orientation may support students’ academic self-concept mainly when paired exclusively with a strong majority orientation. In contrast, our results demonstrate that a strong heritage orientation may be less favorably related to academic self-concept, even when paired with a high multicultural orientation. However, given the cross-sectional design, the results call for further longitudinal research. Nonetheless, the results of this study indicate a necessity for more differentiated acculturation frameworks that consider the multidimensionality of acculturation in contemporary culturally diverse classrooms.
- 4 March 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 16 (3) , 386
Open AccessTridimensional Acculturation and Academic Self-Concept of Minoritized Primary Students in Swiss Multicultural Classrooms: A Latent Profile Analysis
Schools are increasingly shaped by societal change and growing cultural diversity, calling for refined approaches to understanding the acculturation of minoritized students. This study examined acculturation profiles among minoritized primary students (n = 736) in Switzerland, applying a tridimensional framework that incorporates a multicultural orientation, beyond heritage and majority orientation. Using a three-stage latent profile analysis, four distinct acculturation profiles emerged: Multiculturalists (33.3%), Heritage-oriented Multiculturalists (29.9%), Majority-oriented Multiculturalists (29.2%), and a smaller group of Assimilationists (7.6%). The number of parents born abroad, religious practice, Swiss citizenship, and socioeconomic status predicted students’ profile membership. Comparisons of academic self-concept showed that only Majority-oriented Multiculturalists differed from the other profiles. Our findings suggest that a high multicultural orientation may support students’ academic self-concept mainly when paired exclusively with a strong majority orientation. In contrast, our results demonstrate that a strong heritage orientation may be less favorably related to academic self-concept, even when paired with a high multicultural orientation. However, given the cross-sectional design, the results call for further longitudinal research. Nonetheless, the results of this study indicate a necessity for more differentiated acculturation frameworks that consider the multidimensionality of acculturation in contemporary culturally diverse classrooms.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (4) , 1-19
Editorial: Research on value development in the school context: new directions and approaches from an international perspective
This special issue advances the study of value formation in educational settings by introducing and applying the Value Transmission in the School Context model, which has been developed on the basis of a conceptual synthesis of Schwartz’s Theory of Basic Human Values, Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory, and Fend’s New Theory of School. While human values are central to global educational agendas, empirical research on how values develop in school contexts remains limited. The ten original studies in this issue draw on diverse methodologies and data from six countries to examine value development in children and adolescents across micro-, meso-, and macro-levels of schooling. Together, the contributions highlight the dynamic interplay between vertical value transmission (from educational systems to classroom practices and vice versa) and horizontal transmission (between teachers and students, as well as among peers). The findings emphasize that schools are not only institutional settings for value education but also social spaces where values are continuously shaped through interaction and negotiation. This editorial situates the studies within the proposed framework offering a cohesive perspective on the multilevel processes that shape value development in schools. It concludes by identifying key directions for future research that account for systemic structures, developmental dynamics, and contextual factors.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (4) , 1-19
Open AccessEditorial: Research on value development in the school context: new directions and approaches from an international perspective
This special issue advances the study of value formation in educational settings by introducing and applying the Value Transmission in the School Context model, which has been developed on the basis of a conceptual synthesis of Schwartz’s Theory of Basic Human Values, Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory, and Fend’s New Theory of School. While human values are central to global educational agendas, empirical research on how values develop in school contexts remains limited. The ten original studies in this issue draw on diverse methodologies and data from six countries to examine value development in children and adolescents across micro-, meso-, and macro-levels of schooling. Together, the contributions highlight the dynamic interplay between vertical value transmission (from educational systems to classroom practices and vice versa) and horizontal transmission (between teachers and students, as well as among peers). The findings emphasize that schools are not only institutional settings for value education but also social spaces where values are continuously shaped through interaction and negotiation. This editorial situates the studies within the proposed framework offering a cohesive perspective on the multilevel processes that shape value development in schools. It concludes by identifying key directions for future research that account for systemic structures, developmental dynamics, and contextual factors.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 245-257
Gender-sensitive Career Guidance Using Digital Media as an Educational Resource
Context: Gender stereotypes continue to often unconsciously shape young people’s career aspirations resulting in a narrowed range of perceived career options and gender-typical career choices. Despite increased awareness of gender inequality, horizontal segregation in education and the labour market persists, particularly in STEM fields. Schools represent a key environment for addressing these patterns, yet many teachers report lacking time, training, and materials needed to implement gender-sensitive career guidance in practice. Digital tools, when embedded in didactic concepts, offer promising opportunities to support teachers and engage students in meaningful reflection on gender and career. Approach: To explore the potential of digital media in promoting gender-sensitive career guidance, two practice-oriented studies were conducted in Switzerland. Both studies focused on the digital toolbox “Berufswahl klischeefrei!” [ “Career choice without stereotypes!” ] and its key components: the serious game like2be and new gender-sensitive teaching units for the educational resource Profolio. Study 1 examined teachers’ perspectives through qualitative interviews (n = 6), focusing on their needs, challenges, and feedback on the didactic design. Study 2 captured student perspectives (n = 74) through an online survey following the use of selected Profolio learning units in regular classroom instruction. Findings: Teachers and students emphasised the importance of accessible, clearly structured, and engaging materials. Key features identified as particularly helpful included relatable role models, opportunities for peer discussion, and reflective tasks in gender-sensitive contexts. Based on these results, the digital toolbox was revised and expanded. Both like2be and Profolio were positively evaluated as helpful resources for implementing gender-sensitive career guidance in schools. Conclusions: The findings demonstrate how digital tools can promote gender-sensitive career guidance when they are practice-oriented, embedded in teaching concepts, and aligned with curricular needs. The toolbox illustrates how digital media can support inclusive education and contribute to more equitable participation the world of work in the future.
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 245-257
Open AccessGender-sensitive Career Guidance Using Digital Media as an Educational Resource
Context: Gender stereotypes continue to often unconsciously shape young people’s career aspirations resulting in a narrowed range of perceived career options and gender-typical career choices. Despite increased awareness of gender inequality, horizontal segregation in education and the labour market persists, particularly in STEM fields. Schools represent a key environment for addressing these patterns, yet many teachers report lacking time, training, and materials needed to implement gender-sensitive career guidance in practice. Digital tools, when embedded in didactic concepts, offer promising opportunities to support teachers and engage students in meaningful reflection on gender and career. Approach: To explore the potential of digital media in promoting gender-sensitive career guidance, two practice-oriented studies were conducted in Switzerland. Both studies focused on the digital toolbox “Berufswahl klischeefrei!” [ “Career choice without stereotypes!” ] and its key components: the serious game like2be and new gender-sensitive teaching units for the educational resource Profolio. Study 1 examined teachers’ perspectives through qualitative interviews (n = 6), focusing on their needs, challenges, and feedback on the didactic design. Study 2 captured student perspectives (n = 74) through an online survey following the use of selected Profolio learning units in regular classroom instruction. Findings: Teachers and students emphasised the importance of accessible, clearly structured, and engaging materials. Key features identified as particularly helpful included relatable role models, opportunities for peer discussion, and reflective tasks in gender-sensitive contexts. Based on these results, the digital toolbox was revised and expanded. Both like2be and Profolio were positively evaluated as helpful resources for implementing gender-sensitive career guidance in schools. Conclusions: The findings demonstrate how digital tools can promote gender-sensitive career guidance when they are practice-oriented, embedded in teaching concepts, and aligned with curricular needs. The toolbox illustrates how digital media can support inclusive education and contribute to more equitable participation the world of work in the future.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 239-244
Supporting Young People in Choosing their Vocational or Academic Pathways
Context: This paper provides an overview and commentary on the four papers in the symposium focused on the potential of digital tools in career guidance. The first paper, "Killers and Socialisers – Game Types and Gender-Sensitive Career Planning" by Christine Hoffelner, Elena Makarova, and Christof Nägele, based on the www.digibe.ch project, highlights the potential of skills gained through computer gaming for career planning. The second paper, "Gender-Sensitive Career Guidance" by Jana Lindner and Elena Makarova, draws on insights from the www.like2be.ch project and shows that online gender-sensitive career guidance can be effective when integrated into a solid pedagogical framework. The third paper, "Innovation of the Game Portal ThiGro" by Sonja Susnic, demonstrates how online tools can promote reflection, problem-solving, communication, and inclusion skills. The fourth paper, " Problems and solutions in the guidance process for re-entering education and creating personal pathways" by María-José Pérez Albo, explores how digital media can serve as a vital resource by identifying key barriers to reintegration and trace different digital resources that contribute to tailored guidance pathways. Approach: Taken together, these projects use different methodological and conceptual approaches, providing a multi-perspective view on the integration of digital tools in career guidance. Conclusions: The four contributions demonstrate the potential and added value of online and digital tools in improving career guidance practices.
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 239-244
Open AccessSupporting Young People in Choosing their Vocational or Academic Pathways
Context: This paper provides an overview and commentary on the four papers in the symposium focused on the potential of digital tools in career guidance. The first paper, "Killers and Socialisers – Game Types and Gender-Sensitive Career Planning" by Christine Hoffelner, Elena Makarova, and Christof Nägele, based on the www.digibe.ch project, highlights the potential of skills gained through computer gaming for career planning. The second paper, "Gender-Sensitive Career Guidance" by Jana Lindner and Elena Makarova, draws on insights from the www.like2be.ch project and shows that online gender-sensitive career guidance can be effective when integrated into a solid pedagogical framework. The third paper, "Innovation of the Game Portal ThiGro" by Sonja Susnic, demonstrates how online tools can promote reflection, problem-solving, communication, and inclusion skills. The fourth paper, " Problems and solutions in the guidance process for re-entering education and creating personal pathways" by María-José Pérez Albo, explores how digital media can serve as a vital resource by identifying key barriers to reintegration and trace different digital resources that contribute to tailored guidance pathways. Approach: Taken together, these projects use different methodological and conceptual approaches, providing a multi-perspective view on the integration of digital tools in career guidance. Conclusions: The four contributions demonstrate the potential and added value of online and digital tools in improving career guidance practices.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 258-264
Killers and Socialisers Revisited
Context: The transition from compulsory education to vocational training or secondary school marks a critical phase in adolescents' educational pathways. In Switzerland, career guidance is systematically integrated into lower secondary education to facilitate a smooth transition. This involves encouraging self-reflection and, in most programmes, raising awareness of gender norms that can influence career choices. Despite these efforts, adolescents still tend to select gender-typical careers, and there is limited understanding of the gendered differences in skills needed to approach career planning as a coping mechanism. The gaming world offers unique opportunities to fill this research gap. Approach: This study is grounded in the life design framework and its concept of career adaptability, connected to McGonigal’s challenge mindset approach and Bartle’s taxonomy of game types. It is part of the longitudinal www.digibe.ch project, which explores how engaging in online reflection tasks can support career planning. A specific task examines the relationship between gaming experiences and career planning. The research adopts a quantitative approach, applying chi-square tests to identify significant differences in gaming behaviours between male and female adolescents. Based on these findings, subgroups were formed, and Mann-Whitney U tests were used to assess the effects of gaming behaviours on coping skills relevant to career planning. Findings: Results show that male adolescents, especially those aligning with Bartle’s Killer game type, prefer competitive gaming but demonstrate limited collaboration skills in career planning. Female adolescents, more often associated with the Socialiser game type, prefer cooperative strategies in gaming and career planning. While male adolescents may benefit from enhancing their teamwork and collaboration skills, female adolescents might need support in areas such as assertiveness and self-advocacy. These findings suggest that integrating game-based interventions into vocational orientation programmes could help develop a balanced set of critical skills, including teamwork, collaboration, network-building, and self-assertion. Conclusions: Given the widespread popularity of video games among adolescents, this approach holds significant potential for improving gender-sensitive career guidance. By addressing skill gaps and encouraging adaptability, this research offers innovative insights into leveraging gaming to prepare young people for the challenges of career planning in an evolving labour market.
- 11 September 2025
- Published by OAPublishing Collective in VETNET Conference Series
- Vol. 8, 258-264
Open AccessKillers and Socialisers Revisited
Context: The transition from compulsory education to vocational training or secondary school marks a critical phase in adolescents' educational pathways. In Switzerland, career guidance is systematically integrated into lower secondary education to facilitate a smooth transition. This involves encouraging self-reflection and, in most programmes, raising awareness of gender norms that can influence career choices. Despite these efforts, adolescents still tend to select gender-typical careers, and there is limited understanding of the gendered differences in skills needed to approach career planning as a coping mechanism. The gaming world offers unique opportunities to fill this research gap. Approach: This study is grounded in the life design framework and its concept of career adaptability, connected to McGonigal’s challenge mindset approach and Bartle’s taxonomy of game types. It is part of the longitudinal www.digibe.ch project, which explores how engaging in online reflection tasks can support career planning. A specific task examines the relationship between gaming experiences and career planning. The research adopts a quantitative approach, applying chi-square tests to identify significant differences in gaming behaviours between male and female adolescents. Based on these findings, subgroups were formed, and Mann-Whitney U tests were used to assess the effects of gaming behaviours on coping skills relevant to career planning. Findings: Results show that male adolescents, especially those aligning with Bartle’s Killer game type, prefer competitive gaming but demonstrate limited collaboration skills in career planning. Female adolescents, more often associated with the Socialiser game type, prefer cooperative strategies in gaming and career planning. While male adolescents may benefit from enhancing their teamwork and collaboration skills, female adolescents might need support in areas such as assertiveness and self-advocacy. These findings suggest that integrating game-based interventions into vocational orientation programmes could help develop a balanced set of critical skills, including teamwork, collaboration, network-building, and self-assertion. Conclusions: Given the widespread popularity of video games among adolescents, this approach holds significant potential for improving gender-sensitive career guidance. By addressing skill gaps and encouraging adaptability, this research offers innovative insights into leveraging gaming to prepare young people for the challenges of career planning in an evolving labour market.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (3) , 1-2
Correction to: Children’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom in the early elementary school years: mapping longitudinal trajectories
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (3) , 1-2
Open AccessCorrection to: Children’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom in the early elementary school years: mapping longitudinal trajectories
- Open Access
- 23 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (3) , 1-34
Children’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom in the early elementary school years: mapping longitudinal trajectories
This study pioneers the examination of developmental trajectories of children’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom at the start of elementary school, exploring these dynamics of change in younger children. Additionally, we consider the classroom context, being an important but often overlooked setting for children’s value development. In a sample of 1,184 Swiss children (Mean age at T1: 6.82 years) who self-reported their values and whose classroom teachers rated their behavior at four time points, set three to four months apart, we analyzed trajectories of personal values and classroom behaviors at both individual and classroom levels. Multilevel growth curve analyses revealed similar trajectories of value change at both individual and classroom levels, showing a substantial linear increase in values of self-transcendence (benevolence and universalism) and a substantial linear decrease in values of self-enhancement (achievement and power). The trajectories of children’s value-expressive behaviors (supportive, achievement-oriented, disciplined, learning-oriented), however, did not align with these value trends and were relatively flat over time, with no significant change at the classroom level. Adding a time-lagged prediction to the multilevel growth curve models, we found that children’s values positively predicted their expressive behavior one time point later, except for conservation values which did not predict future disciplined behavior. Furthermore, the higher children’s supportive, achievement-, learning-oriented, and disciplined behavior was, the higher were their future values of self-transcendence, self-enhancement, openness to change and conservation respectively. Our findings emphasize the bidirectional nature of these relationships, offering important implications for enhancing educational practices in elementary schools.
- 23 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Psychology of Education
- Vol. 40 (3) , 1-34
Open AccessChildren’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom in the early elementary school years: mapping longitudinal trajectories
This study pioneers the examination of developmental trajectories of children’s personal values and their behavior in the classroom at the start of elementary school, exploring these dynamics of change in younger children. Additionally, we consider the classroom context, being an important but often overlooked setting for children’s value development. In a sample of 1,184 Swiss children (Mean age at T1: 6.82 years) who self-reported their values and whose classroom teachers rated their behavior at four time points, set three to four months apart, we analyzed trajectories of personal values and classroom behaviors at both individual and classroom levels. Multilevel growth curve analyses revealed similar trajectories of value change at both individual and classroom levels, showing a substantial linear increase in values of self-transcendence (benevolence and universalism) and a substantial linear decrease in values of self-enhancement (achievement and power). The trajectories of children’s value-expressive behaviors (supportive, achievement-oriented, disciplined, learning-oriented), however, did not align with these value trends and were relatively flat over time, with no significant change at the classroom level. Adding a time-lagged prediction to the multilevel growth curve models, we found that children’s values positively predicted their expressive behavior one time point later, except for conservation values which did not predict future disciplined behavior. Furthermore, the higher children’s supportive, achievement-, learning-oriented, and disciplined behavior was, the higher were their future values of self-transcendence, self-enhancement, openness to change and conservation respectively. Our findings emphasize the bidirectional nature of these relationships, offering important implications for enhancing educational practices in elementary schools.
- Open Access
- 21 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 15, 1458393
Value-related educational goals of primary school teachers: a comparative study in two European countries
Schools serve as social institutions that convey values in the context of socialization and enculturation. Teachers are pivotal in this transmission process via their value-related educational goals (VrEGs), which outline how they would like to see their pupils in terms of values. What factors influence these VrEGs? We suggest that those vary on an individual level, but also correspond to the prevailing value orientations of the society. In our study we followed two main goals to test this thesis. Firstly, we examine the differences in VrEGs between teachers of two European countries: Switzerland (CH) and United Kingdom (UK). Secondly, we investigated the similarity of the teachers’ VrEGs with prevailing national value orientations from the specific countries. One hundred and fifty primary school teachers (108 CH, 42 UK) were asked about their VrEGs using an adapted version of Schwartz’s Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ-21). Data from the Human Value Scale (HVS) of the European Social Survey (ESS) was used for country-specific value orientations. Analyses of the value structures and the differences in value priorities showed that for the individuals from the two countries as well as for the teachers’ VrEGs from the two countries, significant differences exist in several value types. Teachers’ VrEGs in each country showed a high correlation with the corresponding national value profile. We discuss our results in light of cross-national differences in value education in schools.
- 21 November 2024
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 15, 1458393
Open AccessValue-related educational goals of primary school teachers: a comparative study in two European countries
Schools serve as social institutions that convey values in the context of socialization and enculturation. Teachers are pivotal in this transmission process via their value-related educational goals (VrEGs), which outline how they would like to see their pupils in terms of values. What factors influence these VrEGs? We suggest that those vary on an individual level, but also correspond to the prevailing value orientations of the society. In our study we followed two main goals to test this thesis. Firstly, we examine the differences in VrEGs between teachers of two European countries: Switzerland (CH) and United Kingdom (UK). Secondly, we investigated the similarity of the teachers’ VrEGs with prevailing national value orientations from the specific countries. One hundred and fifty primary school teachers (108 CH, 42 UK) were asked about their VrEGs using an adapted version of Schwartz’s Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ-21). Data from the Human Value Scale (HVS) of the European Social Survey (ESS) was used for country-specific value orientations. Analyses of the value structures and the differences in value priorities showed that for the individuals from the two countries as well as for the teachers’ VrEGs from the two countries, significant differences exist in several value types. Teachers’ VrEGs in each country showed a high correlation with the corresponding national value profile. We discuss our results in light of cross-national differences in value education in schools.
- Open Access
- 19 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 39 (5) , 677-696
Value incoherence precedes value change: Evidence from value development in childhood and adolescence across cultures
We test the theory that personality incoherence may instigate personality change in the context of personal values. Values’ near-universal organization makes value incoherence assessment straightforward. The study included 13 longitudinal samples from seven cultures (Australia, Israel Palestinian citizens, Israel Jewish majority, Italy, Poland, Portugal, and Switzerland), total N = 7,126, and T1 M age ranging between 6 and 18. Each participant reported values between two- and six-times. Using unfolding analysis, we calculated the fit of the internal value structure of each participant at the first time point to the value structure in their sample (normative structure) and to the theoretical structure of values. We estimated value change using Growth Curve Modeling (when at least three measurement times were available) and the difference between T1 and T2 in each sample. We correlated value incoherence with value change and estimated the effect across samples using a meta-analysis. Incoherence with the structure of values predicted greater value change. The associations were stronger when participant’s value structures were compared to the normative value structure at T1 than when they were compared to the theoretical structure. A meta-regression analysis indicated that effects were not moderated by age. We discuss possible underlying processes and implications for personality development.
- 19 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Personality
- Vol. 39 (5) , 677-696
Open AccessValue incoherence precedes value change: Evidence from value development in childhood and adolescence across cultures
We test the theory that personality incoherence may instigate personality change in the context of personal values. Values’ near-universal organization makes value incoherence assessment straightforward. The study included 13 longitudinal samples from seven cultures (Australia, Israel Palestinian citizens, Israel Jewish majority, Italy, Poland, Portugal, and Switzerland), total N = 7,126, and T1 M age ranging between 6 and 18. Each participant reported values between two- and six-times. Using unfolding analysis, we calculated the fit of the internal value structure of each participant at the first time point to the value structure in their sample (normative structure) and to the theoretical structure of values. We estimated value change using Growth Curve Modeling (when at least three measurement times were available) and the difference between T1 and T2 in each sample. We correlated value incoherence with value change and estimated the effect across samples using a meta-analysis. Incoherence with the structure of values predicted greater value change. The associations were stronger when participant’s value structures were compared to the normative value structure at T1 than when they were compared to the theoretical structure. A meta-regression analysis indicated that effects were not moderated by age. We discuss possible underlying processes and implications for personality development.