Duncan Andrew Thomas
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Duncan Andrew Thomas has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Maria Nedeva
Manchester Institute of Innovation Research, Alliance Manchester Business School, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
5 shared publications - Irene Ramos-Vielba
Danish Centre for Studies in Research and Research Policy, Department of Political Science, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark
4 shared publications - Andreas Kjær Stage
Danish Centre for Studies in Research and Research Policy, Department of Political Science, Aarhus University, Bartholins Allé 8, 8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
3 shared publications - Carter Bloch
Dansk Center for Forskningsanalyse, Aarhus Universitet
3 shared publications Dale Whittington
Environmental Sciences & Engineering, and City & Regional Planning, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA
2 shared publications- Liv Langfeldt
Nordic Institute for Studies in Innovation, Research and Education (NIFU)
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 November 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- p. 1-24
Exploring Cross-Grant Interactions in Research Funding: "Amplifying What Is Possible"
Researchers often work across multiple concurrent grants, yet studies of research funding, its features, goals, and impacts, typically examine single grants in isolation. This overlooks the broader context of funding configurations within which researchers organize their work. This exploratory paper explores cross-grant interactions (or co-use), through interviews and mapping of the grant configurations of 12 principal investigators in Denmark, the Netherlands, and Norway. The analysis shows that cross-grant interactions were reported in both parallel and sequential forms, enabled mainly by overlaps of people, infrastructure, and knowledge. Interviewees described such interactions as producing beneficial synergies, including expanded capacity and knowledge transfer, while also identifying grey zones related to attribution, administration, funder rules, and personnel or resource allocation. The funding configurations were more heterogeneous than expected in size, grant number, funder origin, researcher role, and funder requirements. This heterogeneity limited the identification of stable configuration archetypes in the present sample. It nevertheless demonstrates that single-grant approaches can miss much of the funding context relevant to research practice and evaluation. The paper calls for greater attention to cross-grant interactions, not by treating all overlap as either misuse or synergy, but to develop practices that make legitimate co-use visible, assessable, and, where appropriate, supportable.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- p. 1-24
Open AccessExploring Cross-Grant Interactions in Research Funding: "Amplifying What Is Possible"
Researchers often work across multiple concurrent grants, yet studies of research funding, its features, goals, and impacts, typically examine single grants in isolation. This overlooks the broader context of funding configurations within which researchers organize their work. This exploratory paper explores cross-grant interactions (or co-use), through interviews and mapping of the grant configurations of 12 principal investigators in Denmark, the Netherlands, and Norway. The analysis shows that cross-grant interactions were reported in both parallel and sequential forms, enabled mainly by overlaps of people, infrastructure, and knowledge. Interviewees described such interactions as producing beneficial synergies, including expanded capacity and knowledge transfer, while also identifying grey zones related to attribution, administration, funder rules, and personnel or resource allocation. The funding configurations were more heterogeneous than expected in size, grant number, funder origin, researcher role, and funder requirements. This heterogeneity limited the identification of stable configuration archetypes in the present sample. It nevertheless demonstrates that single-grant approaches can miss much of the funding context relevant to research practice and evaluation. The paper calls for greater attention to cross-grant interactions, not by treating all overlap as either misuse or synergy, but to develop practices that make legitimate co-use visible, assessable, and, where appropriate, supportable.
- Open Access
- 21 September 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 6, 901-921
The funding configuration method: Tracing and visualizing all research grants of individual researchers
Many scientific researchers are involved in multiple grants at once. This paper offers a novel method to trace, visualize, and understand such researcher funding configurations. Existing methods, which draw upon funding acknowledgments and funder databases, are insufficient to capture how much and what kinds of grants individual researchers have. They have led actors to underestimate funding concentration and overestimate the impact of single grants. The funding configuration method remedies these shortcomings and illuminates potential cross-grant influences (e.g., via complementary grant conditions). Cross-grant flows of money, people, infrastructure, and knowledge are part of how competitive funding shapes knowledge production. Hence, this new method is vital to understand contexts in which researchers tap into multiple funding streams and projects at the same time. The method can inform both detailed analysis of smaller samples, large-scale studies of funding configurations, and future AI automation.
- 21 September 2025
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 6, 901-921
Open AccessThe funding configuration method: Tracing and visualizing all research grants of individual researchers
Many scientific researchers are involved in multiple grants at once. This paper offers a novel method to trace, visualize, and understand such researcher funding configurations. Existing methods, which draw upon funding acknowledgments and funder databases, are insufficient to capture how much and what kinds of grants individual researchers have. They have led actors to underestimate funding concentration and overestimate the impact of single grants. The funding configuration method remedies these shortcomings and illuminates potential cross-grant influences (e.g., via complementary grant conditions). Cross-grant flows of money, people, infrastructure, and knowledge are part of how competitive funding shapes knowledge production. Hence, this new method is vital to understand contexts in which researchers tap into multiple funding streams and projects at the same time. The method can inform both detailed analysis of smaller samples, large-scale studies of funding configurations, and future AI automation.
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
How can societally-targeted research funding shape researcher networks and practices?
Funding is considered to have a central role in defining the scope, content and direction of public research. However, we lack sufficient understanding of how funding can shape research networks and practices to enhance societal goals. In this paper, we apply a recent approach that explores the societal targeting of funding across four key dimensions: interdisciplinarity, transdisciplinarity, prioritized research problems, and user-oriented outputs. Through in-depth case studies of 12 funded research projects, we explore shaping in these dimensions by contrasting pre- and post-acquisition of a societally targeted project grant based on the accounts of principal investigators (PI). We examine cases across two research areas—renewable energy and food science—in three European countries—Denmark, Netherlands and Norway. Our analysis suggests that societally targeted funding can act as an enabler of inter- and transdisciplinary collaborations and the accumulation of experience to manage them. This funding also encourages research practices that prioritize societal research problems and foster users’ utilization of research outputs while still preserving researcher scientific autonomy. Shaping dynamics are then examined in connection with funding requirements across the four dimensions.
- 31 May 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
How can societally-targeted research funding shape researcher networks and practices?
Funding is considered to have a central role in defining the scope, content and direction of public research. However, we lack sufficient understanding of how funding can shape research networks and practices to enhance societal goals. In this paper, we apply a recent approach that explores the societal targeting of funding across four key dimensions: interdisciplinarity, transdisciplinarity, prioritized research problems, and user-oriented outputs. Through in-depth case studies of 12 funded research projects, we explore shaping in these dimensions by contrasting pre- and post-acquisition of a societally targeted project grant based on the accounts of principal investigators (PI). We examine cases across two research areas—renewable energy and food science—in three European countries—Denmark, Netherlands and Norway. Our analysis suggests that societally targeted funding can act as an enabler of inter- and transdisciplinary collaborations and the accumulation of experience to manage them. This funding also encourages research practices that prioritize societal research problems and foster users’ utilization of research outputs while still preserving researcher scientific autonomy. Shaping dynamics are then examined in connection with funding requirements across the four dimensions.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 33
The quality landscape of economics: The top five and beyond
Whereas a growing number of studies evidence that research quality notions and evaluative practices are field- and context-specific, many focus on single evaluative practices or moments. This paper introduces the concept of quality landscape to capture dynamics of interrelated quality notions, evaluative moments and practices in a research field. This concept shifts focus to (1) the field-specific universe of practices, devices and notions of research quality; (2) ways that interrelated valuations provide structure and boundeness to a landscape; (3) ways that perspectives on a shared landscape may change with position within the landscape; and (4) ways in which a quality landscape is intertwined with the field’s socio-epistemic conditions. With extensive interview data from top ranked departments in three Scandinavian countries, we use economics as a case for exploring the value of a quality landscape lens. We find that the field’s journal hierarchy and its ‘Top 5’ journals dominate the landscape, while other important evaluative practices beyond the top five are interlinked with the journal hierarchy. However, quantitative evaluative metrics common in other fields are virtually absent. We further find that national and local policy reinforce the journal hierarchy emphasis, and that career stages affect quality perspectives. We argue that the quality landscape is structured as a quality hierarchy with a focus on the core ‘general interest’, and suggest the notion of ordinalization (the process of rank ordering) as an organizing principle linking the quality landscape to the field’s socio-epistemic conditions. Finally, we offer suggestions for further research.
- 24 April 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 33
Open AccessThe quality landscape of economics: The top five and beyond
Whereas a growing number of studies evidence that research quality notions and evaluative practices are field- and context-specific, many focus on single evaluative practices or moments. This paper introduces the concept of quality landscape to capture dynamics of interrelated quality notions, evaluative moments and practices in a research field. This concept shifts focus to (1) the field-specific universe of practices, devices and notions of research quality; (2) ways that interrelated valuations provide structure and boundeness to a landscape; (3) ways that perspectives on a shared landscape may change with position within the landscape; and (4) ways in which a quality landscape is intertwined with the field’s socio-epistemic conditions. With extensive interview data from top ranked departments in three Scandinavian countries, we use economics as a case for exploring the value of a quality landscape lens. We find that the field’s journal hierarchy and its ‘Top 5’ journals dominate the landscape, while other important evaluative practices beyond the top five are interlinked with the journal hierarchy. However, quantitative evaluative metrics common in other fields are virtually absent. We further find that national and local policy reinforce the journal hierarchy emphasis, and that career stages affect quality perspectives. We argue that the quality landscape is structured as a quality hierarchy with a focus on the core ‘general interest’, and suggest the notion of ordinalization (the process of rank ordering) as an organizing principle linking the quality landscape to the field’s socio-epistemic conditions. Finally, we offer suggestions for further research.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 27-51
The Rise of EdTech Platforms in Higher Education: Mapping Themes from Emerging Critical Literature
- 14 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 27-51
Open AccessThe Rise of EdTech Platforms in Higher Education: Mapping Themes from Emerging Critical Literature
- Open Access
- 12 May 2021
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 16 (5) , e0251488
Getting to the bottom of research funding: Acknowledging the complexity of funding dynamics
Research funding is an important factor for public science. Funding may affect which research topics get addressed, and what research outputs are produced. However, funding has often been studied simplistically, using top-down or system-led perspectives. Such approaches often restrict analysis to confined national funding landscapes or single funding organizations and instruments in isolation. This overlooks interlinkages, broader funding researchers might access, and trends of growing funding complexity. This paper instead frames a ‘bottom-up’ approach that analytically distinguishes between increasing levels of aggregation of funding instrument co-use. Funding of research outputs is selected as one way to test this approach, with levels traced via funding acknowledgements (FAs) in papers published 2009–18 by researchers affiliated to Denmark, the Netherlands or Norway, in two test research fields (Food Science, Renewable Energy Research). Three funding aggregation levels are delineated: at the bottom, ‘funding configurations’ of funding instruments co-used by individual researchers (from single-authored papers with two or more FAs); a middle, ‘funding amalgamations’ level, of instruments co-used by collaborating researchers (from multi-authored papers with two or more FAs); and a ‘co-funding network’ of instruments co-used across all researchers active in a research field (all papers with two or more FAs). All three levels are found to include heterogenous funding co-use from inside and outside the test countries. There is also co-funding variety in terms of instrument ‘type’ (public, private, university or non-profit) and ‘origin’ (domestic, foreign or supranational). Limitations of the approach are noted, as well as its applicability for future analyses not using paper FAs to address finer details of research funding dynamics.
- 12 May 2021
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 16 (5) , e0251488
Open AccessGetting to the bottom of research funding: Acknowledging the complexity of funding dynamics
Research funding is an important factor for public science. Funding may affect which research topics get addressed, and what research outputs are produced. However, funding has often been studied simplistically, using top-down or system-led perspectives. Such approaches often restrict analysis to confined national funding landscapes or single funding organizations and instruments in isolation. This overlooks interlinkages, broader funding researchers might access, and trends of growing funding complexity. This paper instead frames a ‘bottom-up’ approach that analytically distinguishes between increasing levels of aggregation of funding instrument co-use. Funding of research outputs is selected as one way to test this approach, with levels traced via funding acknowledgements (FAs) in papers published 2009–18 by researchers affiliated to Denmark, the Netherlands or Norway, in two test research fields (Food Science, Renewable Energy Research). Three funding aggregation levels are delineated: at the bottom, ‘funding configurations’ of funding instruments co-used by individual researchers (from single-authored papers with two or more FAs); a middle, ‘funding amalgamations’ level, of instruments co-used by collaborating researchers (from multi-authored papers with two or more FAs); and a ‘co-funding network’ of instruments co-used across all researchers active in a research field (all papers with two or more FAs). All three levels are found to include heterogenous funding co-use from inside and outside the test countries. There is also co-funding variety in terms of instrument ‘type’ (public, private, university or non-profit) and ‘origin’ (domestic, foreign or supranational). Limitations of the approach are noted, as well as its applicability for future analyses not using paper FAs to address finer details of research funding dynamics.
- Open Access
- 29 June 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 29 (3) , 275-288
Changing research on research evaluation: A critical literature review to revisit the agenda
The current range and volume of research evaluation-related literature is extensive and incorporates scholarly and policy/practice-related perspectives. This reflects academic and practical interest over many decades and trails the changing funding and reputational modalities for universities, namely increased selectivity applied to institutional research funding streams and the perceived importance of university rankings and other reputational devices. To make sense of this highly diverse body of literature, we undertake a critical review of over 350 works constituting, in our view, the ‘state-of-the-art’ on institutional performance-based research evaluation arrangements (PREAs). We focus on PREAs because they are becoming the predominant means world-wide to allocate research funds and accrue reputation for universities. We highlight the themes addressed in the literature and offer critical commentary on the balance of scholarly and policy/practice-related orientations. We then reflect on five limitations to the state-of-the-art and propose a new agenda, and a change of perspective, to progress this area of research in future studies.
- 29 June 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 29 (3) , 275-288
Open AccessChanging research on research evaluation: A critical literature review to revisit the agenda
The current range and volume of research evaluation-related literature is extensive and incorporates scholarly and policy/practice-related perspectives. This reflects academic and practical interest over many decades and trails the changing funding and reputational modalities for universities, namely increased selectivity applied to institutional research funding streams and the perceived importance of university rankings and other reputational devices. To make sense of this highly diverse body of literature, we undertake a critical review of over 350 works constituting, in our view, the ‘state-of-the-art’ on institutional performance-based research evaluation arrangements (PREAs). We focus on PREAs because they are becoming the predominant means world-wide to allocate research funds and accrue reputation for universities. We highlight the themes addressed in the literature and offer critical commentary on the balance of scholarly and policy/practice-related orientations. We then reflect on five limitations to the state-of-the-art and propose a new agenda, and a change of perspective, to progress this area of research in future studies.
- 18 June 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 124 (3) , 2229-2249
Mapping research fields using co-nomination: the case of hyper-authorship heavy flavour physics
- 18 June 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientometrics
- Vol. 124 (3) , 2229-2249
Mapping research fields using co-nomination: the case of hyper-authorship heavy flavour physics