SKShannon M. Kachel

Shannon M. Kachel

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Shannon M. Kachel has a total of 79 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Estimating absolute DNA abundance from replicated metabarcoding

    by Andrew Olaf Shelton, Shannon M. Kachel, Megan R. Shaffer, Pedro F. P. Brandão‐Dias, Eiren K. Jacobson, Len Thomas, Ryan P. Kelly

    Datasets derived from mixed‐template DNA amplification and sequencing (‘metabarcoding’) are common in environmental DNA (eDNA), microbiome or microbial ecology analyses. Such metabarcoding data have been broadly used to inform estimates of biodiversity, distribution and abundance across a wide range of species and habitats. Generally, data from metabarcoding consist of a table of read‐counts assigned to each of a set of taxa or sequence variants. As such, they appear to contain quantitative information about the environment under study, immediately eligible for traditional community ecology analyses. In fact, metabarcoding data are compositional, can be biased by variation in PCR amplification rates among taxa, and have other statistical attributes that are distinct from many other common ecological observations. The difficulty in understanding and accounting for the complexity of metabarcoding observations has hindered their ecological interpretation and limited their integration with other ecological data types. Here, we use both simulations and empirical observations to show that the variability among replicate metabarcoding observations is closely tied to the absolute quantities of DNA present in a sample. We then develop a general statistical model for estimating DNA abundance from metabarcoding observations using the relationship between mean and variance of metabarcoding reads. We demonstrate that the model can effectively estimate DNA abundances using simulations and from experimentally created DNA samples. The model can be applied to a single marker or to multiple markers simultaneously, allowing the direct integration of information from multiple genetic markers derived from a common biological sample. Estimates of absolute DNA abundance are the logical unit to connect DNA observations to organismal abundance or biomass. Our methods can be used to link together multiple types of DNA observations or to connect DNA observations with non‐genetic ecological methods for surveying ecosystems. However, important aspects of the ‘ecology of DNA’ remain unresolved and may limit our ability to link observed concentrations to organismal abundances in a general way.

  • Field‐based evaluation of conservation surrogates at local scales: Moving beyond a single umbrella species on the Tibetan Plateau

    by Peiyun Li, Shannon Kachel, Robert M. Dorazio, Johannes M. H. Knops, Yi Zou, Jakob Bro‐Jørgensen, Ding Jia, Xiang Zhao, Zhi Lu, Lingyun Xiao

    Prioritising conservation efforts towards single surrogate species (such as umbrella species) to conserve other sympatric species is a common practice, as it offers a pragmatic approach when distribution data are sparse and funding is constrained. However, the effectiveness of a single umbrella species is context‐dependent, and the utility of umbrella species selected for regional conservation purposes must be evaluated with systematic field data to refine choices at local scales and guide adaptive management. We evaluated the effectiveness of snow leopards Panthera uncia , a commonly used umbrella species in Central Asia's mountain ecosystems, in representing co‐occurring species' conservation needs. Using a multi‐site camera trap dataset spanning over 7000 km 2 , we adopted a multi‐species occupancy modelling (MSOM) framework to quantify similarity among species' habitat preferences at fine spatial scales, while accounting for imperfect detection. We categorised the mammalian community into distinct habitat‐based groups and compared snow leopards with other sympatric species as potential umbrella species based on their representativeness of other species' habitat needs and broader biodiversity patterns. Our results indicate that snow leopards effectively serve as an umbrella for mountain‐endemic species but poorly represent the broader mammal community in total species richness and threatened species richness. Cluster analysis of MSOM results revealed three major habitat groups: (1) alpine meadow specialists, (2) generalists and (3) alpine shrub‐meadow/open woodland specialists. Top umbrella candidates predominantly arise from the generalist and alpine shrub‐meadow/open woodland specialist groups, whereas snow leopards ranked highly for endemic species richness within their own alpine meadow specialist group. Synthesis and applications . These findings underscore the scale‐dependent performance of conservation surrogates showing that broad geographical range overlaps (e.g. based on global distribution maps) can diverge from fine‐scale habitat requirements evaluated with field data. This suggests that conservation actions based on a single charismatic species may miss threats and habitat needs at local scales. We advocate identifying multiple umbrella species to better represent the habitat requirements of a broader species assemblage. Given the growing use of camera trap surveys, our framework provides a path from single‐species to community‐level conservation, thereby guiding targeted monitoring where resources are limited.


  • Open Access

    A case for multi-method assessments: detection probabilities of nearshore fish with eDNA and seine nets vary by functional traits

    by Lia K. Domke, Kimberly J. Ledger, Jessica M. Whitney, Shannon M. Kachel, Wesley A. Larson, Ginny L. Eckert, Diana S. Baetscher

    Ecological studies aim to understand species distributions, yet the sampling methods affect which species are detected and may be influenced by species traits. Detection of marine fishes based on species traits has been studied using traditional sampling methods, but such studies have generally not extended to environmental DNA (eDNA). Here, we investigated which functional species traits (scale type, schooling behavior, and position-in-water-column) are detected by eDNA metabarcoding and beach seines in nearshore eelgrass, mixed eelgrass, and understory kelp habitats. Using data from 35 sites across southeast Alaska, we applied occupancy modeling to estimate detection of species traits by each method. Detection probability with eDNA was 27 times greater for the species with deciduous scales ( Clupea pallasii) compared to species with non-deciduous scales, and lower for species with plates (rather than scales). Conversely, species with plates showed greater odds of detection with beach seines. Given the novelty of eDNA sampling, quantifying interactions between detection and functional traits will be important to accurately characterize species distributions across marine habitats.


  • Open Access

    A case for multi-gear assessments: Detection probabilities of nearshore fish with eDNA and seine nets vary by functional traits

    by Lia K. Domke, Kimberly J. Ledger, Jessica M. Whitney, Shannon M. Kachel, Wes Larson, Ginny L. Eckert, Diana S. Baetscher

    Ecological studies aim to understand species distributions, yet the methods used to sample affect which species are detected (i.e., gear selectivity) and may be influenced by species traits. Interactions between traditional gear selectivity for marine fishes and their species traits have been studied, but such studies have generally not extended to selectivity of environmental DNA (eDNA). Here, we investigated which functional species traits (scale type, schooling behaviour, and position-in-water-column) are selected for by eDNA metabarcoding and beach seines in nearshore eelgrass, mixed eelgrass, and understory kelp habitats. Using data from 35 sites across southeast Alaska, we applied occupancy modeling to estimate detection of species traits by each gear type. Detection probability with eDNA was 27 times greater for species with deciduous scales compared to species with non-deciduous scales, and lower for species with plates (rather than scales). Conversely, species with plates showed greater odds of detection with beach seines. Given the novelty of eDNA sampling, quantifying interactions between functional traits and gear selectivity will be important to accurately characterize species distributions across marine habitats.

  • Open Access

    An evaluation of multi‐species occupancy models with correlated species occurrences

    by Robert M. Dorazio, Peiyun Li, Lingyun Xiao, Shannon M. Kachel

    Multi‐species occupancy models for estimating the effects of environmental covariates on species occurrences while accounting for the effects of false‐negative errors in detection were developed more than 20 years ago. Only recently have these models been extended to include correlations in occurrence between species. Tobler et al. (2019) proposed two of these models wherein species occurrences are specified using a probit‐regression model of correlated multivariate binary outcomes. In one model, correlations in occurrence between species are formal parameters. In the other model, a factor‐analytic approximation of these correlations is used. After conducting extensive simulation studies to compare the performance of these models, Tobler et al. (2019) recommended the latter model in favour of the former owing to difficulties in fitting the former to simulated or real data. The same software (JAGS) was used to fit both models. Since the former model specifies the actual process used to generate species occurrences, we hypothesized that shortcomings in the software were responsible for the difficulties reported by Tobler et al. (2019). We therefore devised an efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm for fitting the data‐generating, multi‐species occupancy model using parameter‐expanded data augmentation. Using this algorithm, we conducted analyses of simulated data sets to re‐evaluate and compare the performance of the two multi‐species occupancy models. We also compared the results of fitting these models to a real dataset collected in camera‐trap surveys of mammalian species on the Tibetan Plateau. Our analyses of simulated data revealed that estimators of species occurrence, correlation and detection parameters had similar performance in terms of average bias, average root‐mean‐squared error and average coverage of 95% credible intervals regardless of whether the data‐generating model or its factor‐analytic approximation was used to analyse the data. However, our analyses also revealed the presence of systematic bias in the correlation estimates of both models, wherein strongly negative correlations were overestimated and strongly positive correlations were underestimated. Systematic bias was not evident in correlations estimated by fitting a multivariate probit regression model to latent species occurrences; therefore, the systematic bias in correlation estimates of the two occupancy models must have been produced by the failure of these models to estimate latent species occurrences accurately.


  • Open Access

    Extreme in Every Way: Exceedingly Low Genetic Diversity in Snow Leopards Due to Persistently Small Population Size

    by Katherine A. Solari, Simon Morgan, Andrey D. Poyarkov, Byron Weckworth, Gustaf Samelius, Koustubh Sharma, Stephane Ostrowski, Uma Ramakrishnan, Zairbek Kubanychbekov, Shannon Kachel, et al.

    Snow leopards ( Panthera uncia ) serve as an umbrella species whose conservation benefits their high-elevation Asian habitat. Their numbers are believed to be in decline due to numerous Anthropogenic threats; however, their conservation is hindered by numerous knowledge gaps. They are the least studied genetically of all big cat species with more to learn regarding their population structure, historical population size, and current levels of genetic diversity. Here, we use whole-genome sequencing data for 41 snow leopards (37 newly sequenced) to offer new insights into these unresolved questions. Among our samples, we find evidence of a primary genetic divide between the northern and southern part of the range around the Dzungarian Basin, as previously identified, and a secondary divide south of Kyrgyzstan around the Taklamakan Desert. Most noteworthy, we find that snow leopards have the lowest genetic diversity of any big cat species, due to a persistently small population size (relative to other big cat species) throughout their evolutionary history rather than recent inbreeding. Without a large population size or ample standing genetic variation to help buffer them from any forthcoming Anthropogenic challenges, snow leopard persistence may be more tenuous than currently appreciated.


  • Genomic analysis of wolves from Pakistan clarifies boundaries among three divergent wolf lineages

    by Lauren M Hennelly, Ghulam Sarwar, Hira Fatima, Geraldine Werhahn, Fakhar I Abbas, Abdul M Khan, Tariq Mahmood, Shannon Kachel, Zairbek Kubanychbekov, Muhammad T Waseem, et al.

    Among the three main divergent lineages of gray wolf (Canis lupus), the Holarctic lineage is the most widespread and best-studied, particularly in North America and Europe. Less is known about Tibetan (also called Himalayan) and Indian wolf lineages in southern Asia, especially in areas surrounding Pakistan where all three lineages are thought to meet. Given the endangered status of the Indian wolf in neighboring India and unclear southwestern boundary of the Tibetan wolf range, we conducted mitochondrial and genome-wide sequencing of wolves from Pakistan and Kyrgyzstan. Sequences of the mitochondrial D-loop region of 81 wolves from Pakistan indicated contact zones between Holarctic and Indian lineages across the northern and western mountains of Pakistan. Reduced-representation genome sequencing of 8 wolves indicated an east-to-west cline of Indian to Holarctic ancestry, consistent with a contact zone between these two lineages in Pakistan. The western boundary of the Tibetan lineage corresponded to the Ladakh region of India’s Himalayas with a narrow zone of admixture spanning this boundary from the Karakoram Mountains of northern Pakistan into Ladakh, India. Our results highlight the conservation significance of Pakistan’s wolf populations, especially the remaining populations in Sindh and Southern Punjab that represent the highly endangered Indian lineage.


  • Ungulate spatiotemporal responses to contrasting predation risk from wolves and snow leopards

    by Shannon Kachel, Rana Bayrakcısmith, Zairbek Kubanychbekov, Rahim Kulenbekov, Thomas McCarthy, Byron Weckworth, Aaron Wirsing

    Spatial responses to risk from multiple predators can precipitate emergent consequences for prey (i.e. multiple‐predator effects, MPEs) and mediate indirect interactions between predators. How prey navigate risk from multiple predators may therefore have important ramifications for understanding the propagation of predation‐risk effects (PREs) through ecosystems. The interaction of predator and prey traits has emerged as a potentially key driver of antipredator behaviour but remains underexplored in large vertebrate systems, particularly where sympatric prey share multiple predators. We sought to better generalize our understanding of how predators influence their ecosystems by considering how multiple sources of contingency drive prey distribution in a multi‐predator–multi‐prey system. Specifically, we explored how two sympatric ungulates with different escape tactics—vertically agile, scrambling ibex Capra sibirica and sprinting argali Ovis ammon—responded to predation risk from shared predators with contrasting hunting modes—cursorial wolves Canis lupus and vertical‐ambushing, stalking snow leopards Panthera uncia. Contrasting risk posed by the two predators presented prey with clear trade‐offs. Ibex selected for greater exposure to chronic long‐term risk from snow leopards, and argali for wolves, in a nearly symmetrical manner that was predictable based on the compatibility of their respective traits. Yet, acute short‐term risk from the same predator upended these long‐term strategies, increasing each ungulates' exposure to risk from the alternate predator in a manner consistent with a scenario in which conflicting antipredator behaviours precipitate risk‐enhancing MPEs and mediate predator facilitation. By contrast, reactive responses to wolves led ibex to reduce their exposure to risk from both predators—a risk‐reducing MPE. Evidence of a similar reactive risk‐reducing effect for argali vis‐à‐vis snow leopards was lacking. Our results suggest that prey spatial responses and any resulting MPEs and prey‐mediated interactions between predators are contingent on the interplay of hunting mode and escape tactics. Further investigation of interactions among various drivers of contingency in PREs will contribute to a more comprehensive understanding and improved forecasting of the ecological effects of predators.


  • Open Access

    Guidelines for Telemetry Studies on Snow Leopards

    by Örjan Johansson, Shannon Kachel, Byron Weckworth

    Animal-borne tracking devices have generated a wealth of new knowledge, allowing us to better understand, manage and conserve species. Fitting such tracking devices requires that animals are captured and often chemically immobilized. Such procedures cause stress and involve the risk of injuries and loss of life even in healthy individuals. For telemetry studies to be justifiable, it is vital that capture operations are planned and executed in an efficient and ethical way. Project objectives must be clearly articulated to address well-defined knowledge gaps, and studies designed to maximize the probability of achieving those goals. We provide guidelines for how to plan, design, and implement telemetry studies with a special emphasis on snow leopards that are typically captured using foot snares. We also describe the necessary steps to ensure that captures are conducted safely, and with minimal stress to animals.


  • Predator niche overlap and partitioning and potential interactions in the mountains of Central Asia

    by Shannon Kachel, Khalil Karimov, Aaron J. Wirsing

    Direct and indirect interactions among predators affect predator fitness, distribution, and overall community structure. Yet, outside of experimental settings, such interactions are difficult to observe and thus poorly understood. Patterns of niche overlap among predators reflect and shape community interactions and may therefore help elucidate the nature and intensity of intraguild interactions. To better understand the coexistence of two apex predators, snow leopards (Panthera uncia) and wolves (Canis lupus), we investigated their spatial, temporal, and dietary niche overlap in summer in the Pamir Mountains of Tajikistan. We estimated population-level space use via spatial capture–recapture models based on noninvasive genetics and camera traps, diel activity patterns based on camera trap detections, and diet composition from prey remains in carnivore scats, from which we estimated coefficients between 0 and 1 for overlap in space, time, and diet, respectively. Snow leopards and wolves displayed moderate spatial partitioning (0.26, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.17–37), but overlapping temporal (0.77, 95% CI: 0.64–0.90) and dietary (0.97, 95% CI: 0.80–0.99) niches. Both predators relied on seasonally abundant marmots (Marmota caudata) rather than wild ungulates, their typical primary prey, suggesting that despite patterns of overlap that were superficially conducive to exploitation competition and predator facilitation, prey were likely not a limiting factor. Therefore, prey-mediated interactions, if present, were unlikely to be a major structuring force in the ecosystem. By implication, carnivore conservation planning and monitoring in the mountains of Central Asia should more fully account for the seasonal importance of marmots in the ecosystem.