Benny Goodman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Benny Goodman has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Peter Morrall
Leeds Institute of Health and Social Work, Leeds, LS2 9JT, United Kingdom
2 shared publications- Alec Grant
University of Brighton
1 shared publication Benny Goodman Faculty of health
1 shared publication- Chris Nash
Safeguarding Children, Cornwall & Isles of Scilly Primary Care Trust, UK
1 shared publication Christine Purcell
1 shared publicationDawn Jackson
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 June 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Sociology, Knowledge and Engagement: A Case for a Muckraking Sociology of Health and Healthcare in the Time of COVID
We adopt the definition of muckraking advanced by Marx in his Muckraking Sociology. At its core is a commitment to social criticism via the exposure and challenging of those rhetorics that provide cover for dominant interests. Our focus is on the field of health and health care, with particular reference to the largely hidden agendas of successive Health Ministers post-2010. We present two substantial case studies. The first concerns the sustained attack on the National Health Service (NHS) with a view to replacing it with a more market-oriented system. This begins with the run-up to the Health and Social Care Act of 2012 and goes on to feature governmental action taken as a consequence of this Act, often under the public radar. The second hones in on the government’s response to the coronavirus pandemic. We argue that this reflects an ideological commitment to undermine and marketise the NHS and its public health arm. Following on from these case studies, we venture a re-appraisal of the sociological project in light of the growing need for evidence-based social criticism to examine, expose and if necessary counter a political tendency to fabricate policy-based evidence in line with the prevailing ideology.
- 26 June 2021
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessSociology, Knowledge and Engagement: A Case for a Muckraking Sociology of Health and Healthcare in the Time of COVID
We adopt the definition of muckraking advanced by Marx in his Muckraking Sociology. At its core is a commitment to social criticism via the exposure and challenging of those rhetorics that provide cover for dominant interests. Our focus is on the field of health and health care, with particular reference to the largely hidden agendas of successive Health Ministers post-2010. We present two substantial case studies. The first concerns the sustained attack on the National Health Service (NHS) with a view to replacing it with a more market-oriented system. This begins with the run-up to the Health and Social Care Act of 2012 and goes on to feature governmental action taken as a consequence of this Act, often under the public radar. The second hones in on the government’s response to the coronavirus pandemic. We argue that this reflects an ideological commitment to undermine and marketise the NHS and its public health arm. Following on from these case studies, we venture a re-appraisal of the sociological project in light of the growing need for evidence-based social criticism to examine, expose and if necessary counter a political tendency to fabricate policy-based evidence in line with the prevailing ideology.
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 52, 53-56
The case of the Trump regime: The need for resistance in international nurse education
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 52, 53-56
The case of the Trump regime: The need for resistance in international nurse education
- 29 March 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 55, 140-141
Antonio Gramsci on intellectual thought – Challenging nursing
- 29 March 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 55, 140-141
Antonio Gramsci on intellectual thought – Challenging nursing
- Open Access
- 1 March 2017
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Erving Goffman and the 'Total Institution'
The four essays in Erving Goffman's work Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates were published in 1961, and anyone who has both read the book and seen the film One flew over the cuckoo's nest will not fail to make the connections between the two. The vivid depiction of institutional life in the film may be considered a relic of history, and Goffman's account of life in a 'mental hospital' a bygone era. Asylums may have been demolished and the care of vulnerable adults transferred to community settings. However, we may wish to reflect upon the degree to which the social processes of total institutions also lie in ruins, to be replaced by respect, dignity, autonomy and beneficence. Of course, the answer has to be that total institutions in health care are no more: we consider that we have banished paternalism and 'institutionalising' practices to the dustbin of history. However, given the reports of poor quality care in too many care organisations (and not just in the UK), we might want to revisit Goffman and ask ourselves: ‘To what degree have modern healthcare organisations moved on in the mode of delivery and bureaucratic control of patients and clients in their care, or is there something inherently totalising in the very fabric of their being?’
- 1 March 2017
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessErving Goffman and the 'Total Institution'
The four essays in Erving Goffman's work Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates were published in 1961, and anyone who has both read the book and seen the film One flew over the cuckoo's nest will not fail to make the connections between the two. The vivid depiction of institutional life in the film may be considered a relic of history, and Goffman's account of life in a 'mental hospital' a bygone era. Asylums may have been demolished and the care of vulnerable adults transferred to community settings. However, we may wish to reflect upon the degree to which the social processes of total institutions also lie in ruins, to be replaced by respect, dignity, autonomy and beneficence. Of course, the answer has to be that total institutions in health care are no more: we consider that we have banished paternalism and 'institutionalising' practices to the dustbin of history. However, given the reports of poor quality care in too many care organisations (and not just in the UK), we might want to revisit Goffman and ask ourselves: ‘To what degree have modern healthcare organisations moved on in the mode of delivery and bureaucratic control of patients and clients in their care, or is there something inherently totalising in the very fabric of their being?’
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 48, 120-122
Margaret Archer, modes of reflexivity: The structured agency of nursing action
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 48, 120-122
Margaret Archer, modes of reflexivity: The structured agency of nursing action
- 25 July 2016
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Philosophy
- Vol. 17 (4) , 298-306
Developing the concept of sustainability in nursing
Sustainability, and the related concept of climate change, is an emerging domain within nursing and nurse education. Climate change has been posited as a serious global health threat requiring action by health professionals and action at international level. Anåker & Elf undertook a concept analysis of sustainability in nursing based on Walker and Avant's framework. Their main conclusions seem to be that while defining attributes and cases can be established, there is not enough research into sustainability in the nursing literature. This paper seeks to develop their argument to argue that sustainability in nursing can be better understood by accessing non‐nursing and grey literature and, for example, the literature in the developing web‐based ‘paraversity’. Without this understanding, and application in nursing scholarship, nurses will have a rather narrow understanding of sustainability and its suggested links with social and health inequalities and the dynamics underpinning unsustainable neoliberalist political economy. This understanding is based on the social and political determinants of health approach and the emerging domain of planetary health. However, this is a major challenge as it requires a critical reflection on what counts as nursing knowledge, a reflection which might reject sustainability and political economy as irrelevant to much of nursing practice.
- 25 July 2016
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Philosophy
- Vol. 17 (4) , 298-306
Developing the concept of sustainability in nursing
Sustainability, and the related concept of climate change, is an emerging domain within nursing and nurse education. Climate change has been posited as a serious global health threat requiring action by health professionals and action at international level. Anåker & Elf undertook a concept analysis of sustainability in nursing based on Walker and Avant's framework. Their main conclusions seem to be that while defining attributes and cases can be established, there is not enough research into sustainability in the nursing literature. This paper seeks to develop their argument to argue that sustainability in nursing can be better understood by accessing non‐nursing and grey literature and, for example, the literature in the developing web‐based ‘paraversity’. Without this understanding, and application in nursing scholarship, nurses will have a rather narrow understanding of sustainability and its suggested links with social and health inequalities and the dynamics underpinning unsustainable neoliberalist political economy. This understanding is based on the social and political determinants of health approach and the emerging domain of planetary health. However, this is a major challenge as it requires a critical reflection on what counts as nursing knowledge, a reflection which might reject sustainability and political economy as irrelevant to much of nursing practice.
- 20 May 2016
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Philosophy
- Vol. 17 (3) , 211-221
Lying to ourselves: rationality, critical reflexivity, and the moral order as ‘structured agency’
A report suggests that United States’ army officers may engage in dishonest reporting regarding their compliance procedures. Similarly, nurses with espoused high ethical standards sometimes fail to live up to them and may do so while deceiving themselves about such practices. Reasons for lapses are complex. However, multitudinous managerial demands arising within ‘technical and instrumental rationality’ may impact on honest decision‐making. This paper suggests that compliance processes, which operates within the social structural context of the technical and instrumental rationality manifest as ‘managerialism’, contributes to professional ‘dishonesty’ about lapses in care, sometimes through ‘thoughtlessness’. The need to manage risk, measure, account, and control in order to deliver efficiency, effectiveness, and economy (technical rationality) thus has both unintended and dysfunctional consequences. Meeting compliance requirements may be mediated by factors such as the ‘affect heuristic’ and ‘reflexive deliberations’ as part of the ‘structured agency’ of nurses. It is the complexity of ‘structured agency’ which may explain why some nurses fail to respond to such things as sentinel events, a failure to recognize ‘personal troubles’ as ‘public issues’, a failure which to outsiders who expect rational and professional responses may seem inconceivable. There is a need to understand these processes so that nurses can critique the context in which they work and to move beyond either/or explanations of structureoragency for care failures, and professional dishonesty.
- 20 May 2016
- Published by Wiley in Nursing Philosophy
- Vol. 17 (3) , 211-221
Lying to ourselves: rationality, critical reflexivity, and the moral order as ‘structured agency’
A report suggests that United States’ army officers may engage in dishonest reporting regarding their compliance procedures. Similarly, nurses with espoused high ethical standards sometimes fail to live up to them and may do so while deceiving themselves about such practices. Reasons for lapses are complex. However, multitudinous managerial demands arising within ‘technical and instrumental rationality’ may impact on honest decision‐making. This paper suggests that compliance processes, which operates within the social structural context of the technical and instrumental rationality manifest as ‘managerialism’, contributes to professional ‘dishonesty’ about lapses in care, sometimes through ‘thoughtlessness’. The need to manage risk, measure, account, and control in order to deliver efficiency, effectiveness, and economy (technical rationality) thus has both unintended and dysfunctional consequences. Meeting compliance requirements may be mediated by factors such as the ‘affect heuristic’ and ‘reflexive deliberations’ as part of the ‘structured agency’ of nurses. It is the complexity of ‘structured agency’ which may explain why some nurses fail to respond to such things as sentinel events, a failure to recognize ‘personal troubles’ as ‘public issues’, a failure which to outsiders who expect rational and professional responses may seem inconceivable. There is a need to understand these processes so that nurses can critique the context in which they work and to move beyond either/or explanations of structureoragency for care failures, and professional dishonesty.
- 15 February 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Research in Nursing
- Vol. 21 (4) , 325-335
The missing two Cs – commodity and critique: Obscuring the political economy of the ‘gift’ of nursing
This discussion paper argues for understanding nursing care as a commodity within capitalist relations of production, ultimately as a product of labour, whose use value far exceeds its exchange value and price. This under-recognised commodification of care work obscures the social relationships involved in the contribution to the social reproduction of labour and to capital accumulation by nursing care work. This matters, because many care workers give of themselves and their unpaid overtime to provide care as if in a ‘gift economy’, but in doing so find themselves in subordinate subject positions as a part of the social reproduction of labour in a ‘commodity economy’. Thus they are caught in the contradiction between the ‘appearance’ and reality. A focus on the individual moral character of nurses (e.g. the UK’s 6Cs), may operate as a screen deflecting understanding of the reality of the lived experiences of thousands of care workers and supports the discourse of ‘care as a gift’. The commodification of care work also undermines social reproduction itself. Many nurses will not have tools of analysis to critique their subject positioning by power elites and have thus been largely ineffectual in creating change to the neoliberalist and managerialist contexts that characterise many healthcare and other public sector organisations. The implications of this analysis for healthcare policy and nursing practice is the need for a critical praxis (an ‘action nursing’) by nurses and nursing bodies, along with their allies, which may include patient groups, to put care in all its guises and consequences central to the political agenda.
- 15 February 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Research in Nursing
- Vol. 21 (4) , 325-335
The missing two Cs – commodity and critique: Obscuring the political economy of the ‘gift’ of nursing
This discussion paper argues for understanding nursing care as a commodity within capitalist relations of production, ultimately as a product of labour, whose use value far exceeds its exchange value and price. This under-recognised commodification of care work obscures the social relationships involved in the contribution to the social reproduction of labour and to capital accumulation by nursing care work. This matters, because many care workers give of themselves and their unpaid overtime to provide care as if in a ‘gift economy’, but in doing so find themselves in subordinate subject positions as a part of the social reproduction of labour in a ‘commodity economy’. Thus they are caught in the contradiction between the ‘appearance’ and reality. A focus on the individual moral character of nurses (e.g. the UK’s 6Cs), may operate as a screen deflecting understanding of the reality of the lived experiences of thousands of care workers and supports the discourse of ‘care as a gift’. The commodification of care work also undermines social reproduction itself. Many nurses will not have tools of analysis to critique their subject positioning by power elites and have thus been largely ineffectual in creating change to the neoliberalist and managerialist contexts that characterise many healthcare and other public sector organisations. The implications of this analysis for healthcare policy and nursing practice is the need for a critical praxis (an ‘action nursing’) by nurses and nursing bodies, along with their allies, which may include patient groups, to put care in all its guises and consequences central to the political agenda.
- 1 October 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 35 (10) , 1011-1012
Wendell Berry—health is membership
- 1 October 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 35 (10) , 1011-1012
Wendell Berry—health is membership
- 1 June 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 35 (6) , 729-730
Simone de Beauvoir: A woman's place in nursing?
- 1 June 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Nurse Education Today
- Vol. 35 (6) , 729-730
Simone de Beauvoir: A woman's place in nursing?