JFJoel Frohlich

Joel Frohlich

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Joel Frohlich has a total of 139 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Joerg F. Hipp

    Roche Pharma Research and Early Development, Neuroscience and Rare Diseases, Roche Innovation Center Basel, Basel, Switzerland

    8 shared publications
  • Pedro A. M. Mediano

    Imperial College London

    7 shared publications
  • Shafali S. Jeste

    Center for Autism Research and Treatment, University of California Los Angeles, Semel Institute for Neuroscience, Los Angeles, CA, USA

    7 shared publications
  • Alireza Gharabaghi

    Institute for Neuromodulation and Neurotechnology, University Hospital and University of Tuebingen, Tuebingen, Germany

    5 shared publications
  • Hubert Preissl

    IDM/fMEG Center of the Helmholtz Center Munich at the University of Tübingen, Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen, German Center for Diabetes Research (DZD), Tübingen, Germany

    5 shared publications
  • John Dell’iTalia

    Institute for Advanced Consciousness Studies, Santa Monica, CA, USA

    5 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Aquahenosis: A non-pharmacological altered state of consciousness induced by Floatation-REST in individuals with anxiety and depression

    by Theo Tobel, Aidan Cone, Emily Choquette, McKenna Garland, Micah Johnson, Keller Mink, Caitlin Lynch, Joel Frohlich, Justin Feinstein, Nicco Reggente, et al.

    Floatation-REST (Reduced Environmental Stimulation Therapy) systematically alters sensory and bodily input by combining neutral buoyancy, thermal and proprioceptive neutrality, attenuation of exteroceptive stimulation, and enhancement of cardiorespiratory signaling to the brain. Here we examined whether this non-pharmacological sensory perturbation induces altered states of consciousness and whether specific experiential dimensions are statistically related to changes in affect. In a secondary analysis of a randomized controlled feasibility trial, 75 treatment-seeking adults with anxiety and depression were assigned to six sessions of Floatation-REST with prescribed scheduling, Floatation-REST with preferred scheduling and duration, or a zero-gravity chair comparison condition. Altered states of consciousness were assessed using the 5-Dimensional Altered States of Consciousness Rating Scale, alongside measures of interoceptive awareness and affect. Compared to the chair condition, Floatation-REST was associated with increased interoceptive awareness of cardiorespiratory sensations and an altered state of consciousness characterized by Oceanic Boundlessness, Disembodiment, and Experience of Unity—a pattern we refer to as "aquahenosis." Effects were strongest among participants who selected longer and more flexible float sessions. Experiential profiles selectively overlapped with those reported for psilocybin and ketamine along boundary-dissolution dimensions. These findings identify Floatation-REST as a tractable, non-pharmacological method for inducing specific altered states of consciousness and highlight oceanic boundlessness as an important mediator of the float-induced changes in positive affect.

  • Open Access

    Neural complexity in preterm infants is predicted by developmental variables

    by Lorenzo Semeia, Amer Zaylaa, Dimitrios Metaxas, Mina Nourhashemi, Mahdi Mahmoudzadeh, Andreas L. Birkenfeld, Katrin Sippel, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Hubert Preissl, Fabrice Wallois, et al.

    Neural complexity, measured as the entropy of noninvasively recorded electrophysiological signals, evolves with age in early infancy, differentiates between typical and atypical development, and likely serves as a surrogate marker of brain maturation. However, the reason for this evolution of neural entropy in early infant development remains unclear. To understand this evolution, we measured the proportion of time that the infant brain spent in a bursting pattern of activity and related this activity pattern to the neural complexity (i.e., entropy or entropy rate). Additionally, we sought to predict neural complexity using each infant’s gestational age and to replicate sex-related complexity differences previously reported in age-equivalent fetuses. Four distinct complexity estimator algorithms – Lempel-Ziv (LZ) complexity, multiscale entropy (MSE), complexity via state-space entropy rate (CSER), and context tree weighting (CTW) – were applied to 8-channel infant electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings in 28 preterm infants (27–34 weeks gestational age). To explore factors influencing signal complexity, we modeled relationships between complexity estimates, on the one hand, and spontaneous activity transients, gestational age, and sex, on the other hand. We calculated channel-averages for each complexity estimate separately, as derived either from entire EEG recordings or separately from burst and interburst periods. Our results suggest that increased EEG signal continuity with maturation may drive increases in neural complexity as quiescent periods subside. Additionally, our results largely recapitulate previous findings linking neural complexity to biological sex in third-trimester fetuses. We also observed unexpected differences between entropy rate results obtained using CSER (a newer algorithm) and older algorithms. These findings support further research into neural complexity as a potential predictor of clinical outcomes in infants at high risk for neurodevelopmental disorders.


  • Open Access

    Frequency tagging evidence supports perceptual separation of rapid stimuli in human fetuses

    by Joel Frohlich, Julia Moser, Dimitrios Metaxas, Katrin Sippel, Laura Batterink, Hubert Preissl

    In early human development, perceptual processes grow faster with maturation, as inferred using the duration of the attentional blink and multisensory integration window. The consequences of this developmental trend for sensory-cognition in fetuses are unclear: does the fetus perceive rapid stimuli as discrete events or, rather, one fused stimulus? We addressed this question using frequency tagging in two experiments with rapid auditory stimuli while neural responses were recorded in the third trimester with fetal magnetoencephalography (MEG). Our results are the first successful demonstration of frequency tagging in the fetal MEG amplitude spectrum and show that the fetal cortex generates separate neural responses to discrete auditory stimuli in both experiments, and similar results were also obtained when one experiment was repeated in newborns. While we cannot rule out perceptual fusion of rapid stimuli in higher-order association cortices, our results weaken the hypothesis that fetuses fuse rapid auditory stimuli into a single prolonged percept. Finally, our work points to frequency tagging analysis as a solution which avoids the uncertainties surrounding immature neural response latencies in time-domain analysis of fetal MEG.

  • Open Access

    EEG entropy reflects both intrinsic and stimulation-induced corticospinal excitability

    by Simon Ruch, Joel Frohlich, Marius Keute, Ge Tang, Nelli Keksel, Alireza Gharabaghi

    Background Cortical excitability fluctuates throughout the day on multiple timescales, ranging from milliseconds to hours. This is reflected in the large variability of the brain’s response to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). However, robust and interpretable biomarkers of the brain’s current excitability state are lacking. Objective We investigated whether entropy derived from singular value decomposition of short electroencephalography (EEG) segments could serve as a biomarker of cortical excitability as probed by TMS. Methods Entropy was computed from 1-second EEG segments preceding single-pulse TMS applied over the motor cortex. We assessed whether spontaneous fluctuations in pre-pulse entropy predicted trial-by-trial variability in TMS-induced motor-evoked potentials (MEPs). Additionally, we evaluated whether entropy tracked stimulation-induced changes in cortical excitability. Results Higher pre-pulse entropy, particularly over frontal regions, was associated with larger MEP amplitudes. TMS locally increased entropy over the motor cortex, while entropy decreased in other regions during the intervention. Participants who showed greater local increases in entropy from pre-to post-intervention also demonstrated larger increases in corticospinal excitability. Conclusion Entropy derived from short EEG segments reflects both intrinsic and stimulation-induced changes in cortical excitability. This marker may help optimize TMS interventions by informing brain state-dependent stimulation strategies and providing an index of intervention efficacy.

  • Open Access

    Recent pseudoscience accusation echoes historic pushback against general relativity

    by Joel Frohlich, Adam Safron, Nicco Reggente

    Last year, a controversial letter criticized a highly cited theory of consciousness, integratedinformation theory or IIT, as “pseudoscience”. The letter was penned by 10 prominentpsychologists, cognitive scientists, and neuroscientists, and signed by over 100 additional researchers,creating a group called “IIT-Concerned.” The pseudoscience accusation, while controversial, hassince been repeated by one of IIT-Concerned most vocal members. Herein, we will challenge IIT-Concerned’s criticism by providing a historical parallel. And yet, our goal is not to promote IIT over other theories of consciousness. As discussed below, we believe that IIT has both strengths and weaknesses as a theory of consciousness; we are not arguing against reasonable criticisms of the theory. Rather, our goal is to critique the reasoning of IIT-Concerned. In what follows, we provide a brief background on IIT for context before diving into the controversy surrounding the theory and, finally, drawing a historical analogy that we believe to be illuminating.


  • Open Access

    Neural complexity in preterm infants is predicted by developmental variables

    by Lorenzo Semeia, Amer Zaylaa, Mina Nourhashemi, Mahmoudzadeh, Andreas L. Birkenfeld, Katrin Sippel, Hubert Preissl, Fabrice Wallois, Joel Frohlich

    Measures of neural complexity have been shown to evolve with age during the earliest weeks of infancy and to differentiate between typical and atypical development, suggesting that they may be promising surrogate markers of brain maturation. In our current work, we explored developmental trends in neural complexity with the goals of better understanding what drives age-related changes and replicating previously reported sex-related complexity differences in age-equivalent fetuses. Toward this end, we employed three different neural complexity measures derived from 8-channel EEG recordings in 29 preterm infants between 27 and 34 weeks of gestational age (GA). To investigate potential factors impacting signal complexity, we modeled the relation between complexity measures and spontaneous activity transients (SATs, i.e., intermittent bursts of neural activity which play a critical role in brain development and maturation), as well as other developmental variables including GA and sex. We then applied principal component analysis (PCA) to complexity measures across all channels, derived from either the entire EEG recording or separately from burst and interburst periods. Our results suggest that the increasing continuity of the EEG signal with maturation may drive GA-related increases in neural complexity as quiescent periods subside. Additionally, our results largely recapitulate earlier findings linking neural complexity to biological sex in third-trimester fetuses. Notably, we also discovered important differences between a newer complexity algorithm and two older approaches. Our findings pave the way toward further investigations which may explore neural complexity as a predictor of clinical outcome in infants at high risk of neurodevelopmental disorders.

  • Open Access

    Markers of consciousness in infants: Towards a ‘cluster‐based’ approach

    by Joel Frohlich, Tim Bayne

    As recently as the 1980s, it was not uncommon for paediatric surgeons to operate on infants without anaesthesia. Today, the same omission would be considered criminal malpractice, and there is an increased concern with the possibility of consciousness in the earliest stage of human infancy. This concern reflects a more general trend that has characterised science since the early 1990s of taking consciousness seriously. While this attitude shift has opened minds towards the possibility that our earliest experiences predate our first memories, convincing demonstrations of infant consciousness remain challenging given that infants cannot report on their experiences. Furthermore, while many behavioural and neural markers of consciousness that do not rely on language have been validated in adults, no one specific marker can be confidently translated to infancy. For this reason, we have proposed the ‘cluster‐based’ approach, in which a consensus of evidence across many markers, all pointing towards the same developmental period, could be used to argue convincingly for the presence of consciousness.Conclusion: We review the most promising markers for early consciousness, arguing that consciousness is likely to be in place by 5 months of age if not earlier.


  • Sex differences in prenatal development of neural complexity in the human brain

    by Joel Frohlich, Julia Moser, Katrin Sippel, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Hubert Preissl, Alireza Gharabaghi


  • Open Access

    Brain signal complexity and aperiodicity predict human corticospinal excitability

    by Joel Frohlich, Simon Ruch, Bettina H. Trunk, Marius Keute, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Alireza Gharabaghi

    Background: Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) holds promise for brain modulation with relevant scientific and therapeutic applications, but it is limited by response variability. Targeting state-dependent EEG features such as phase and power shows potential, but uncertainty remains about the suitable brain states. Objective: This study evaluated broadband EEG measures (BEMs), including the aperiodic exponent (AE) and entropy measures (CTW, LZ), as alternatives to band-limited features, such as power and phase, for predicting corticospinal excitability (CSE). Methods: TMS was delivered with randomly applied single pulses targeting the left primary motor cortex in 34 healthy participants while simultaneously recording EEG and EMG signals. Broadband and band-limited EEG features were evaluated for their ability to predict CSE using motor evoked potentials (MEPs) from the right extensor digitorum communis muscle as the outcome measure. Results: BEMs (AE, CTW) significantly predicted CSE, comparable to beta-band power and phase, the most predictive and spatially specific band-limited markers of motor cortex CSE. Unlike these localized CSE markers at the site of stimulation, BEMs captured more global brain states and greater within-subject variability, indicating sensitivity to dynamic state changes. Notably, CTW was associated with high CSE, while AE was linked to low CSE. Conclusion: This study reveals BEMs as robust predictors of CSE that circumvent challenges of band-limited EEG features, such as narrowband filtering and phase estimation. They may reflect more general markers of brain excitability. With their slower timescale and broader sensitivity, BEMs are promising biomarkers for state-dependent TMS applications, particularly in therapeutic contexts.


  • Open Access

    Neural entrainment induced by periodic audiovisual stimulation: A large-sample EEG study

    by Joel Frohlich, Ninette Simonian, Grant Hanada, Christian Kothe, Nicco Reggente

    Stroboscopic or “flicker” stimulation is a form of periodic visual stimulation that induces geometric hallucinations through closed eyelids. While the visual effects of this form of sensory stimulation have received considerable attention, few studies have investigated the neural entrainment effects of periodic visual stimulation. Here, we introduce two variants of the classic flicker paradigm while recording EEG to study neural entrainment effects in a large sample (over 80 participants per condition). In the first condition, we used multimodal stimulation composed of two simultaneous visual strobe frequencies paired with binaural beats which provided auditory stimulation at roughly the same frequency as the slower strobe. We compared this condition to sham stimulation, in which both strobes were set to very low frequencies and in which the binaural beats were absent. Additionally, we compared both conditions to a control group in which participants focused on their breathing during eyes-closed meditation (no stimulation). Our results demonstrate powerful evidence of neural entrainment at the frequency of the slower strobe in the experimental condition. Moreover, our findings resemble effects reported in prior literature using conventional non-invasive techniques for electromagnetic brain stimulation. We argue that stroboscopic stimulation should be further developed along these lines, e.g., as a potential therapeutic technique in psychiatric disorders.