Kaja Wierucka
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Kaja Wierucka has a total of 102 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Judith Maria Burkart
Department of Evolutionary Anthropology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
9 shared publications - Benjamin J. Pitcher
Taronga Institute of Science and Learning, Taronga Conservation Society Australia, Mosman, NSW 2088, Australia
5 shared publications - Robert Harcourt
IMOS Animal Tagging, Sydney Institute of Marine Science, 19 Chowder Bay Road, Mosman, Australia
5 shared publications - Stephan T. Leu
School of Animal and Veterinary Sciences The University of Adelaide Roseworthy South Australia Australia
5 shared publications - Nikhil Phaniraj
Department of Evolutionary Anthropology, University of Zurich; Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zürich, Switzerland
4 shared publications - Isabelle Charrier
Institut des Neurosciences Paris-Saclay (NeuroPSI), CNRS UMR 9197, Université Paris-Saclay 1 , 91400 Saclay, France
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
WhaleSonic: Recordings of cetacean vocal behaviour with hydrophone arrays in Northern Norway
Killer whales, humpback whales, fin whales, and sperm whales converged in a fjord system in Northern Norway during the 2023–2024 winter, where whale watching and fishing vessels add to the acoustic scene. Cetaceans are intensely studied for their acoustic behaviour and communication, and the co-occurrence of four species in confined waters offers a unique opportunity to record them with hydrophone arrays. We present WhaleSonic, a raw acoustic dataset recorded with two synchronised array systems. Four drifting buoys, each carrying a tetrahedral hydrophone array, captured 78 hours of calibrated recordings; seven bottom-mounted hydrophones yielded 52 days of continuous data. Both systems are synchronised to UTC ( < 1 μs and 3–7 ms) and positioned to 2 m accuracy. Transmission experiments and sound velocity measurements provide in-situ ground truth. All data are in physical units and a unified coordinate system, self-documented in HDF5 files, and published with open-source tools. WhaleSonic supports the development of multichannel algorithms for source separation, localisation, sound field analysis, and group communication in free-ranging cetaceans.
Open AccessWhaleSonic: Recordings of cetacean vocal behaviour with hydrophone arrays in Northern Norway
Killer whales, humpback whales, fin whales, and sperm whales converged in a fjord system in Northern Norway during the 2023–2024 winter, where whale watching and fishing vessels add to the acoustic scene. Cetaceans are intensely studied for their acoustic behaviour and communication, and the co-occurrence of four species in confined waters offers a unique opportunity to record them with hydrophone arrays. We present WhaleSonic, a raw acoustic dataset recorded with two synchronised array systems. Four drifting buoys, each carrying a tetrahedral hydrophone array, captured 78 hours of calibrated recordings; seven bottom-mounted hydrophones yielded 52 days of continuous data. Both systems are synchronised to UTC ( < 1 μs and 3–7 ms) and positioned to 2 m accuracy. Transmission experiments and sound velocity measurements provide in-situ ground truth. All data are in physical units and a unified coordinate system, self-documented in HDF5 files, and published with open-source tools. WhaleSonic supports the development of multichannel algorithms for source separation, localisation, sound field analysis, and group communication in free-ranging cetaceans.
- Open Access
Effects of caller dominance rank on response to contact calls in ring-tailed lemurs ( Lemur catta )
In group-living species, dominance hierarchies play a central role in shaping social dynamics, influencing both agonistic and affiliative interactions. Being able to recognise an individual’s dominance rank at a distance, can reduce direct conflicts, facilitating group coordination, and mediating social cohesion. While the role of dominance in relation to aggressive or reproductive vocalizations has been well documented, its influence on affiliative contact calls, particularly in mediating group movement and social integration, remains underexplored. We conducted playback experiments with free-ranging adult ringtailed lemurs (Lemur catta) at the Affenwald Wildlife Park to investigate how dominance rank of the caller and rank differences between caller and listener affect behavioral responses. Using Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs), we analysed three response variables: vocal response, number of visual scans, and occurrence of movement. Our results revealed sex-specific effects: females exhibited increased movement following contact calls from high-ranking individuals, and tended to refrain from moving when their own rank exceeded that of the caller. In contrast, no significant effects of dominance rank were observed in males. These findings suggest that high-ranking females may play an important role in initiating group movement. This study provides insights into the role of dominance rank in mediating social coordination through contact calls and provides a foundation for further research into the role of vocal communication in maintaining group cohesion in primates.
Open AccessEffects of caller dominance rank on response to contact calls in ring-tailed lemurs ( Lemur catta )
In group-living species, dominance hierarchies play a central role in shaping social dynamics, influencing both agonistic and affiliative interactions. Being able to recognise an individual’s dominance rank at a distance, can reduce direct conflicts, facilitating group coordination, and mediating social cohesion. While the role of dominance in relation to aggressive or reproductive vocalizations has been well documented, its influence on affiliative contact calls, particularly in mediating group movement and social integration, remains underexplored. We conducted playback experiments with free-ranging adult ringtailed lemurs (Lemur catta) at the Affenwald Wildlife Park to investigate how dominance rank of the caller and rank differences between caller and listener affect behavioral responses. Using Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs), we analysed three response variables: vocal response, number of visual scans, and occurrence of movement. Our results revealed sex-specific effects: females exhibited increased movement following contact calls from high-ranking individuals, and tended to refrain from moving when their own rank exceeded that of the caller. In contrast, no significant effects of dominance rank were observed in males. These findings suggest that high-ranking females may play an important role in initiating group movement. This study provides insights into the role of dominance rank in mediating social coordination through contact calls and provides a foundation for further research into the role of vocal communication in maintaining group cohesion in primates.
- Open Access
Evidence for a cohesion-related function of alpaca hums: Linking automated call detection with GPS data
Understanding how animals communicate while moving helps explain social dynamics, but simultaneously tracking vocal and spatial behaviour in freely moving groups remains challenging. Animal-borne audio and GPS recordings can place naturally occurring vocalisations in their spatial context, but continuous recordings generate large datasets that require automated call detection. We used this approach to investigate whether alpaca hums, a poorly characterised vocalisation, contribute to group cohesion. We combined automated detection of hums from continuous collar-borne audio with synchronised GPS data from a partially collared herd to test whether humming is associated with changes in spacing and movement consistent with a contact-call function. We combined deep-learning-assisted detection with manual validation to build a large curated hum corpus from 2,011.1 h of continuous recordings from a partially collared herd. We then tested how humming was associated with spacing and movement at both individual and group levels. Following hum production, distance between focal alpaca and the group shifted toward closer contact relative to matched non-hum periods. Hums were also more likely to occur when the collared alpaca moved faster. These findings support a cohesion-related role of hums and suggest that this call type may help alpaca maintain social contact while moving. More broadly, our study shows how automated call detection combined with movement data can place poorly characterised vocalisations in a behavioural context, narrow their plausible functions, and generate targeted hypotheses even when caller identity remains uncertain and only part of a group can be collared. This approach extends functional research on vocal communication to species whose calls remain poorly understood.
Open AccessEvidence for a cohesion-related function of alpaca hums: Linking automated call detection with GPS data
Understanding how animals communicate while moving helps explain social dynamics, but simultaneously tracking vocal and spatial behaviour in freely moving groups remains challenging. Animal-borne audio and GPS recordings can place naturally occurring vocalisations in their spatial context, but continuous recordings generate large datasets that require automated call detection. We used this approach to investigate whether alpaca hums, a poorly characterised vocalisation, contribute to group cohesion. We combined automated detection of hums from continuous collar-borne audio with synchronised GPS data from a partially collared herd to test whether humming is associated with changes in spacing and movement consistent with a contact-call function. We combined deep-learning-assisted detection with manual validation to build a large curated hum corpus from 2,011.1 h of continuous recordings from a partially collared herd. We then tested how humming was associated with spacing and movement at both individual and group levels. Following hum production, distance between focal alpaca and the group shifted toward closer contact relative to matched non-hum periods. Hums were also more likely to occur when the collared alpaca moved faster. These findings support a cohesion-related role of hums and suggest that this call type may help alpaca maintain social contact while moving. More broadly, our study shows how automated call detection combined with movement data can place poorly characterised vocalisations in a behavioural context, narrow their plausible functions, and generate targeted hypotheses even when caller identity remains uncertain and only part of a group can be collared. This approach extends functional research on vocal communication to species whose calls remain poorly understood.
- Open Access
VesperFlow: An automated pipeline for decoding multisensor data from biologging tags
Integrating multi-sensor data from biologging tags is key to understanding animal behavior, particularly in group-living species, where communication, movement, and spatial dynamics are closely linked. However, analyzing such data at scale is often hindered by proprietary binary formats or manual decoding workflows in existing software. We present VesperFlow, an open-source Python pipeline that automates the decoding of inertial measurement unit (IMU), audio, and GPS data from Vesper Wildlife tags. VesperFlow batch-processes large datasets from multiple individuals, synchronizes timestamps across sensors with sub-second precision, and removes hardware-induced artifacts such as spurious gyroscope spikes and audio pops. Out-puts are exported as CSV and WAV files for direct use in common downstream analysis workflows. We validate the pipeline on field data from 10 ring-tailed lemurs ( Lemur catta ), showing that our pipeline reliably processes movement, vocal, and spatial data. By lowering technical barriers and automating processes, VesperFlow supports more scalable, multi-modal research on animal behavior. VesperFlow is freely available at https://github.com/dasilva98/vesperflow .
Open AccessVesperFlow: An automated pipeline for decoding multisensor data from biologging tags
Integrating multi-sensor data from biologging tags is key to understanding animal behavior, particularly in group-living species, where communication, movement, and spatial dynamics are closely linked. However, analyzing such data at scale is often hindered by proprietary binary formats or manual decoding workflows in existing software. We present VesperFlow, an open-source Python pipeline that automates the decoding of inertial measurement unit (IMU), audio, and GPS data from Vesper Wildlife tags. VesperFlow batch-processes large datasets from multiple individuals, synchronizes timestamps across sensors with sub-second precision, and removes hardware-induced artifacts such as spurious gyroscope spikes and audio pops. Out-puts are exported as CSV and WAV files for direct use in common downstream analysis workflows. We validate the pipeline on field data from 10 ring-tailed lemurs ( Lemur catta ), showing that our pipeline reliably processes movement, vocal, and spatial data. By lowering technical barriers and automating processes, VesperFlow supports more scalable, multi-modal research on animal behavior. VesperFlow is freely available at https://github.com/dasilva98/vesperflow .
- Open Access
“Mine” or “yours”? Acoustic structure of food calls predicts sharing decisions in marmosets
Foraging and feeding are often associated with vocalisations across animal species. Food calls may function to claim ownership of resources or recruit others to feeding sites, yet their potential role in facilitating food sharing remains poorly understood. This study investigates the relationship between food calls and food-sharing behaviour in common marmosets ( Callithrix jacchus ), focusing on adult–infant interactions, where food transfers are most frequent. We analysed over 1000 food interactions across six groups, categorising events as non-sharing (without begging or despite begging) or sharing (proactive, resisted, or facilitated). We examined the spectro-temporal structure of food calls produced immediately before each interaction. Food transfers were more likely to occur when preceded by a food call, suggesting a functional link between food calls and sharing. Random forest models reliably classified food calls according to interaction type, while generalized linear mixed models identified acoustic variation associated with sharing outcomes. Our results suggest that food calls encode information to either encourage or deter conspecific (infant) approach, influencing food transfer outcomes. These findings highlight the role of food calls in modulating social interactions around food in marmosets, advancing our understanding of vocal communication and its integration with cooperative behaviours in primates.
Open Access“Mine” or “yours”? Acoustic structure of food calls predicts sharing decisions in marmosets
Foraging and feeding are often associated with vocalisations across animal species. Food calls may function to claim ownership of resources or recruit others to feeding sites, yet their potential role in facilitating food sharing remains poorly understood. This study investigates the relationship between food calls and food-sharing behaviour in common marmosets ( Callithrix jacchus ), focusing on adult–infant interactions, where food transfers are most frequent. We analysed over 1000 food interactions across six groups, categorising events as non-sharing (without begging or despite begging) or sharing (proactive, resisted, or facilitated). We examined the spectro-temporal structure of food calls produced immediately before each interaction. Food transfers were more likely to occur when preceded by a food call, suggesting a functional link between food calls and sharing. Random forest models reliably classified food calls according to interaction type, while generalized linear mixed models identified acoustic variation associated with sharing outcomes. Our results suggest that food calls encode information to either encourage or deter conspecific (infant) approach, influencing food transfer outcomes. These findings highlight the role of food calls in modulating social interactions around food in marmosets, advancing our understanding of vocal communication and its integration with cooperative behaviours in primates.
- Open Access
What’s encoded in a marmoset phee call? Food context beyond arousal and valence
Animal vocalisations can convey information about external events, but whether this goes beyond reflecting the emotional state elicited by these events is debated. To explore this, we studied the acoustic structure of common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) phee (long-distance contact) and ek (alert/mobbing) calls produced in five treatments varying in the emotional valence and arousal they elicit (internal state), as well as food and social context (external events). We measured changes in arousal via nasal temperature and analysed both basic acoustic parameters and Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCCs) of the calls. Support Vector Machines combined with Linear Mixed effect models revealed that phee calls encode both external events and internal states, while eks reflected predominantly arousal. Notably, an acoustic signature related to food context was present in phees both when provided (positive valence) and teased with highly preferred food items (negative valence), and even when food was not physically present (food call playback treatment). This suggests marmoset long-distant phee calls encode external information beyond emotional arousal and valence, and independently of the presence of an immediately triggering stimulus.
Open AccessWhat’s encoded in a marmoset phee call? Food context beyond arousal and valence
Animal vocalisations can convey information about external events, but whether this goes beyond reflecting the emotional state elicited by these events is debated. To explore this, we studied the acoustic structure of common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) phee (long-distance contact) and ek (alert/mobbing) calls produced in five treatments varying in the emotional valence and arousal they elicit (internal state), as well as food and social context (external events). We measured changes in arousal via nasal temperature and analysed both basic acoustic parameters and Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCCs) of the calls. Support Vector Machines combined with Linear Mixed effect models revealed that phee calls encode both external events and internal states, while eks reflected predominantly arousal. Notably, an acoustic signature related to food context was present in phees both when provided (positive valence) and teased with highly preferred food items (negative valence), and even when food was not physically present (food call playback treatment). This suggests marmoset long-distant phee calls encode external information beyond emotional arousal and valence, and independently of the presence of an immediately triggering stimulus.
- Open Access
- 3 June 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 293 (2072)
Dynamic vocal learning in adult marmoset monkeys
Socially mediated vocal plasticity, such as vocal accommodation, is an important mechanism for maintaining social cohesion and coordination in group-living animals. Yet, the cognitive mechanisms underlying vocal accommodation remain poorly understood. Here we scrutinize the temporal dynamics of vocal accommodation in common marmosets by tracking the vocalizations of pairs during the first two months after pair formation. We show that vocal accommodation in marmoset pairs displayed the following properties: (i) bidirectional learning (i.e. both males and females underwent equal amount of vocal change); (ii) an exponential decrease in vocal distance with time; (iii) sensitivity to initial vocal distance, that is, pairs converged to a higher extent when their vocalizations were initially more dissimilar; and (iv) synchronous dyadic movement through acoustic space. We find that mathematical models capturing these characteristics and accurately simulating the phenomena rely on dynamic template matching. This suggests that marmosets match their vocalizations to an auditory template continuously updated to track changes in partners’ vocalizations, a dynamic form of vocal learning. The model thus suggests that vocal convergence is a highly interactive process that may have provided a foundation for more advanced vocal learning in primates, resonating with recent claims about its role in language evolution.
- 3 June 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 293 (2072)
Open AccessDynamic vocal learning in adult marmoset monkeys
Socially mediated vocal plasticity, such as vocal accommodation, is an important mechanism for maintaining social cohesion and coordination in group-living animals. Yet, the cognitive mechanisms underlying vocal accommodation remain poorly understood. Here we scrutinize the temporal dynamics of vocal accommodation in common marmosets by tracking the vocalizations of pairs during the first two months after pair formation. We show that vocal accommodation in marmoset pairs displayed the following properties: (i) bidirectional learning (i.e. both males and females underwent equal amount of vocal change); (ii) an exponential decrease in vocal distance with time; (iii) sensitivity to initial vocal distance, that is, pairs converged to a higher extent when their vocalizations were initially more dissimilar; and (iv) synchronous dyadic movement through acoustic space. We find that mathematical models capturing these characteristics and accurately simulating the phenomena rely on dynamic template matching. This suggests that marmosets match their vocalizations to an auditory template continuously updated to track changes in partners’ vocalizations, a dynamic form of vocal learning. The model thus suggests that vocal convergence is a highly interactive process that may have provided a foundation for more advanced vocal learning in primates, resonating with recent claims about its role in language evolution.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Multimodal mother-offspring recognition in the Australian sea lion, Neophoca cinerea
La reconnaissance multi-modale mère-juene chez le lion de mer Australien, Neophoca cinerea: La reconnaissance joue un rôle important dans les systèmes de communication animale et plusieurs modalités sensorielles sont impliquées à cette fin. Bien que la reconnaissance mère-jeune ait été largement étudiée, il y a un manque d'information sur la reconnaissance multimodale et l'importance relative des différentes modalités dans ce processus. Dans cette thèse, j'ai exploré la communication multimodale chez un mammifère colonial - le lion de mer Australien (Neophoca cinerea). La reconnaissance mère-jeune est connue pour être multimodale chez cette espèce, mais les processus sous-jacents de la reconnaissance olfactive et visuelle, ainsi que les interactions entre les indices acoustiques, visuels et olfactifs, et leurs contributions relatives restent inconnues. Des analyses chimiques ont permis de déterminer si les profils chimiques diffèrent selon le sexe et l'âge, les colonies et les régions corporelles des animaux. La présence de similarités chimiques entre la mère et son petit suggèrent que l'appariement des phénotypes pourrait être utilisé pour la reconnaissance olfactive. J'ai examiné le rôle des indices visuels lors de la reconnaissance mère-jeune et j'ai constaté que les indices visuels spécifiques à l'âge sont utilisés par les femelles pour affiner la recherche de leur petit dans la colonie. Les jeunes ont également la capacité de distinguer divers indices visuels, qui peuvent être utilisés pour identifier les différentes classes de congénères. Enfin, j’ai pu aussi déterminer comment les indices acoustiques, olfactifs et visuels sont utilisés de manière synergique dans le processus d’identification individuel, et les résultats sont interprété dans une perspective coûts-avantages pour démêler les pressions évolutives sur chaque composante de ce système de communication. Si les différents indices sensoriels ont la capacité de transmettre des informations en isolation, leur rôle peut être différent lorsque d'autres indices sensoriels sont présents. Les résultats de cette recherche fournissent des résultats sans précédent, contribuant à une meilleure compréhension de la reconnaissance mère-jeune chez les mammifères, ainsi que des règles générales de communication chez les vertébrés.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Agence Bibliographique de l'Enseignement Supérieur
Multimodal mother-offspring recognition in the Australian sea lion, Neophoca cinerea
La reconnaissance multi-modale mère-juene chez le lion de mer Australien, Neophoca cinerea: La reconnaissance joue un rôle important dans les systèmes de communication animale et plusieurs modalités sensorielles sont impliquées à cette fin. Bien que la reconnaissance mère-jeune ait été largement étudiée, il y a un manque d'information sur la reconnaissance multimodale et l'importance relative des différentes modalités dans ce processus. Dans cette thèse, j'ai exploré la communication multimodale chez un mammifère colonial - le lion de mer Australien (Neophoca cinerea). La reconnaissance mère-jeune est connue pour être multimodale chez cette espèce, mais les processus sous-jacents de la reconnaissance olfactive et visuelle, ainsi que les interactions entre les indices acoustiques, visuels et olfactifs, et leurs contributions relatives restent inconnues. Des analyses chimiques ont permis de déterminer si les profils chimiques diffèrent selon le sexe et l'âge, les colonies et les régions corporelles des animaux. La présence de similarités chimiques entre la mère et son petit suggèrent que l'appariement des phénotypes pourrait être utilisé pour la reconnaissance olfactive. J'ai examiné le rôle des indices visuels lors de la reconnaissance mère-jeune et j'ai constaté que les indices visuels spécifiques à l'âge sont utilisés par les femelles pour affiner la recherche de leur petit dans la colonie. Les jeunes ont également la capacité de distinguer divers indices visuels, qui peuvent être utilisés pour identifier les différentes classes de congénères. Enfin, j’ai pu aussi déterminer comment les indices acoustiques, olfactifs et visuels sont utilisés de manière synergique dans le processus d’identification individuel, et les résultats sont interprété dans une perspective coûts-avantages pour démêler les pressions évolutives sur chaque composante de ce système de communication. Si les différents indices sensoriels ont la capacité de transmettre des informations en isolation, leur rôle peut être différent lorsque d'autres indices sensoriels sont présents. Les résultats de cette recherche fournissent des résultats sans précédent, contribuant à une meilleure compréhension de la reconnaissance mère-jeune chez les mammifères, ainsi que des règles générales de communication chez les vertébrés.
- Open Access
Sequence-level vocal convergence in common marmosets
Vocal accommodation is the process by which individuals adjust their vocalizations to resemble those of social partners. This phenomenon is widespread in social animals and can reinforce affiliation, signal group identity, and facilitate coordination. Most studies of vocal accommodation have focused on convergence in the acoustic structure of individual calls. Whether social partners also converge in how calls are arranged into sequences remains largely unknown. We examined vocal convergence during pair formation in common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) by recording phee sequences from nine dyads composed of three males and three females before pairing and again four months after, in two audience contexts: when individuals interacted vocally with their partner or with an opposite sex stranger. We quantified similarity between individuals in call sequence-structure using transition probabilities, bigram frequencies, repeat-length distributions, and local alignment, and quantified similarity in acoustic structure using spectral parameters, MFCCs, and dynamic time warping. We found vocal convergence on a sequence level. After pair formation, partners became more similar in sequence structure when calling to strangers, whereas no change was detected in partner directed sequences. In contrast, call acoustic structure did not change in either context. Because vocal repertoires are constrained by anatomy and physiology, reorganizing existing call types into different combinations may provide a flexible route for modifying signals without altering the acoustic structure of individual calls. Our results provide evidence that social bonds can drive sequence level vocal convergence in a non-human primate, suggesting that vocal flexibility may arise not only through changes in acoustic structures but also through changes in how calls are organized over time.
Open AccessSequence-level vocal convergence in common marmosets
Vocal accommodation is the process by which individuals adjust their vocalizations to resemble those of social partners. This phenomenon is widespread in social animals and can reinforce affiliation, signal group identity, and facilitate coordination. Most studies of vocal accommodation have focused on convergence in the acoustic structure of individual calls. Whether social partners also converge in how calls are arranged into sequences remains largely unknown. We examined vocal convergence during pair formation in common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) by recording phee sequences from nine dyads composed of three males and three females before pairing and again four months after, in two audience contexts: when individuals interacted vocally with their partner or with an opposite sex stranger. We quantified similarity between individuals in call sequence-structure using transition probabilities, bigram frequencies, repeat-length distributions, and local alignment, and quantified similarity in acoustic structure using spectral parameters, MFCCs, and dynamic time warping. We found vocal convergence on a sequence level. After pair formation, partners became more similar in sequence structure when calling to strangers, whereas no change was detected in partner directed sequences. In contrast, call acoustic structure did not change in either context. Because vocal repertoires are constrained by anatomy and physiology, reorganizing existing call types into different combinations may provide a flexible route for modifying signals without altering the acoustic structure of individual calls. Our results provide evidence that social bonds can drive sequence level vocal convergence in a non-human primate, suggesting that vocal flexibility may arise not only through changes in acoustic structures but also through changes in how calls are organized over time.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (8) , 1574-1586
Same data, different results? Machine learning approaches in bioacoustics
Automated acoustic analysis is increasingly used in behavioural ecology, and determining caller identity is a key element for many investigations. However, variability in feature extraction and classification methods limits the comparability of results across species and studies, constraining conclusions we can draw about the ecology and evolution of the groups under study. We investigated the impact of using different feature extraction (spectro‐temporal measurements, linear and Mel‐frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCC), as well as highly comparative time‐series analysis) and classification methods (discriminant function analysis, neural networks, random forests (RF), and support vector machines) on the consistency of caller identity classification accuracy across 16 mammalian datasets. We found that MFCCs and RFs yield consistently reliable results across datasets, facilitating a standardised approach across species that generates directly comparable data. These findings remained consistent across vocalisation sample sizes and number of individuals considered. We offer guidelines for processing and analysing mammalian vocalisations, fostering greater comparability and advancing our understanding of the evolutionary significance of acoustic communication in diverse mammalian species.
- 9 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (8) , 1574-1586
Open AccessSame data, different results? Machine learning approaches in bioacoustics
Automated acoustic analysis is increasingly used in behavioural ecology, and determining caller identity is a key element for many investigations. However, variability in feature extraction and classification methods limits the comparability of results across species and studies, constraining conclusions we can draw about the ecology and evolution of the groups under study. We investigated the impact of using different feature extraction (spectro‐temporal measurements, linear and Mel‐frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCC), as well as highly comparative time‐series analysis) and classification methods (discriminant function analysis, neural networks, random forests (RF), and support vector machines) on the consistency of caller identity classification accuracy across 16 mammalian datasets. We found that MFCCs and RFs yield consistently reliable results across datasets, facilitating a standardised approach across species that generates directly comparable data. These findings remained consistent across vocalisation sample sizes and number of individuals considered. We offer guidelines for processing and analysing mammalian vocalisations, fostering greater comparability and advancing our understanding of the evolutionary significance of acoustic communication in diverse mammalian species.