Sophy Barber
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Sophy Barber has a total of 76 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jonathan Shelswell
Department of Orthodontics, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK
3 shared publications Andrew Shelton
Consultant Orthodontist, Orthodontic Department, Montagu Hospital Adwick Road, Mexborough, UK
2 shared publicationsB. Khambay
School of Dentistry, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
2 shared publicationsBalvinder Khambay
School of Dentistry, Level 6, Worsley Building, Clarendon, Way, Leeds LS2 9LU, UK
2 shared publicationsCatherine Brierley
Charles Clifford Dental Hospital, Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Sheffield, UK
2 shared publicationsD. Meads
Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, Leeds, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 9 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
Single-use plastics in orthodontic practice in the UK: A service evaulation
Aim: This service evaluation aimed to estimate the number and mass of SUPs used by orthodontic providers in primary and secondary care settings (1) per year and (2) per course of treatment (COT) to identify potential strategies for SUP reduction. Methods: A multicentre, prospective service evaluation was undertaken across six primary and three secondary care orthodontic providers in the north of England (UK). Two dental undergraduate students observed orthodontic appointments and recorded the number and mass of SUPs used during review and treatment appointments using a piloted data collection sheet. Mean SUP use was calculated for each appointment type and extrapolated to annual and COT estimates. Results: Across all sites, 133 orthodontic appointments were observed. An average of 9.5 SUPs per review and 13.9 SUPs per treatment appointment were used in primary care, weighing 37 g and 44.6 g, respectively. In secondary care, an average of 9.3 SUPs per review and 14.9 SUPs per treatment appointment were used, weighing 41 g and 73.4 g, respectively. It was estimated that a primary care orthodontic provider would use 187,200 SUPs annually weighing 652.8 kg, and 237 SUPs per COT weighing 0.78 kg. In secondary care, it was estimated that an orthodontic provider would use 193,000 SUPs annually weighing 915.2 kg, and 296.1 SUPs per COT weighing 1.44 kg. Conclusions: This service evaluation provided a baseline estimate of SUP use in orthodontic care settings. It offers insight into the potential waste generated by an orthodontic provider per year and per COT, which indicates where SUP use could potentially be reduced.
- 9 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
Single-use plastics in orthodontic practice in the UK: A service evaulation
Aim: This service evaluation aimed to estimate the number and mass of SUPs used by orthodontic providers in primary and secondary care settings (1) per year and (2) per course of treatment (COT) to identify potential strategies for SUP reduction. Methods: A multicentre, prospective service evaluation was undertaken across six primary and three secondary care orthodontic providers in the north of England (UK). Two dental undergraduate students observed orthodontic appointments and recorded the number and mass of SUPs used during review and treatment appointments using a piloted data collection sheet. Mean SUP use was calculated for each appointment type and extrapolated to annual and COT estimates. Results: Across all sites, 133 orthodontic appointments were observed. An average of 9.5 SUPs per review and 13.9 SUPs per treatment appointment were used in primary care, weighing 37 g and 44.6 g, respectively. In secondary care, an average of 9.3 SUPs per review and 14.9 SUPs per treatment appointment were used, weighing 41 g and 73.4 g, respectively. It was estimated that a primary care orthodontic provider would use 187,200 SUPs annually weighing 652.8 kg, and 237 SUPs per COT weighing 0.78 kg. In secondary care, it was estimated that an orthodontic provider would use 193,000 SUPs annually weighing 915.2 kg, and 296.1 SUPs per COT weighing 1.44 kg. Conclusions: This service evaluation provided a baseline estimate of SUP use in orthodontic care settings. It offers insight into the potential waste generated by an orthodontic provider per year and per COT, which indicates where SUP use could potentially be reduced.
- Open Access
- 19 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 25
Exploring the Wider Effects of Participating in a Clinical Trial for Clinical and Research Staff: A Protocol for a Qualitative Study
Background: Participating in research is widely accepted to have benefits for participants, but there is less evidence about the impact on researchers, clinical staff and organisations involved in the research delivery. Aim: To explore how participation in a randomised controlled clinical trial impacts on researcher development, professional development of clinical staff, organisational capacity and delivery of clinical services. Design: Longitudinal qualitative study using interviews undertaken at three timepoints across the period of a clinical trial. Participants and Setting: Three groups of participants involved in a clinical trial being undertaken at nine centres across India will be invited to participate. This includes: 1) Research staff involved in the design and delivery of the clinical trial; 2) Clinical staff involved in delivering the clinical aspects of the trial; 3) Organisational representatives from the hospital senior management teams at each site. Materials and Methods: Ethical approval has been granted by University of Leeds Dental Research Ethics Committee and Bharath Institute of Higher Education and Research. Interviews will be undertaken virtually using communication platforms that are commonly used across India (Microsoft Teams and Zoom). Training and technical support will be offered to anyone who is not familiar with the platforms. Participants will be asked for consent for the interviews to be audio-recorded and auto-transcribed. Experienced qualitative researchers will facilitate interviews using a topic guide. Data will be collected at three time points: at the start of the clinical trial, 18 months and 3 years after recruitment commences. Analysis will follow an inductive reflexive thematic approach.
- 19 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
- Vol. 25
Open AccessExploring the Wider Effects of Participating in a Clinical Trial for Clinical and Research Staff: A Protocol for a Qualitative Study
Background: Participating in research is widely accepted to have benefits for participants, but there is less evidence about the impact on researchers, clinical staff and organisations involved in the research delivery. Aim: To explore how participation in a randomised controlled clinical trial impacts on researcher development, professional development of clinical staff, organisational capacity and delivery of clinical services. Design: Longitudinal qualitative study using interviews undertaken at three timepoints across the period of a clinical trial. Participants and Setting: Three groups of participants involved in a clinical trial being undertaken at nine centres across India will be invited to participate. This includes: 1) Research staff involved in the design and delivery of the clinical trial; 2) Clinical staff involved in delivering the clinical aspects of the trial; 3) Organisational representatives from the hospital senior management teams at each site. Materials and Methods: Ethical approval has been granted by University of Leeds Dental Research Ethics Committee and Bharath Institute of Higher Education and Research. Interviews will be undertaken virtually using communication platforms that are commonly used across India (Microsoft Teams and Zoom). Training and technical support will be offered to anyone who is not familiar with the platforms. Participants will be asked for consent for the interviews to be audio-recorded and auto-transcribed. Experienced qualitative researchers will facilitate interviews using a topic guide. Data will be collected at three time points: at the start of the clinical trial, 18 months and 3 years after recruitment commences. Analysis will follow an inductive reflexive thematic approach.
- Open Access
- 26 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 53 (1) , 9-19
Information provision for orthognathic treatment by consultant orthodontists in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland: A questionnaire-based study
Objectives: The aim of this research was to carry out a study of consultant orthodontists in the United Kingdom (UK) and Republic of Ireland (RoI), exploring the information provision for patients both considering and undergoing orthognathic treatment to help inform the development of decision support tools. Design: A questionnaire-based study of consultant orthodontists in the UK and RoI through the British Orthodontic Society (BOS) Consultant Orthodontist Group. Setting: Data collected using an online survey platform (Qualtrics ® XM). Results: A final sample of 56 respondents was achieved with an estimated response rate of 28%. All respondents (100%) said their patients routinely attended an orthognathic multidisciplinary team (MDT) clinic before commencing any active treatment. The majority (98.21%) of respondents said they utilised nationally available resources produced by the BOS, with the most commonly used resource being the BOS ‘ Your Jaw Surgery ’ online resource. When considering the benefits of treatment that were routinely discussed, the three most commonly selected responses were improvement in occlusion (92.86%), improvement in facial aesthetics (91.07%) and improvement in dental aesthetics (83.93%). There were nine orthodontic risks that were routinely discussed by more than 90% of respondents, including pain and discomfort, duration of treatment and long-term commitment to retainer wear, alongside 11 surgical risks, including permanent and temporary paraesthesia or dysaesthesia of the lips/chin/tongue, and postoperative pain. Conclusion: From the responses received, patients considering orthognathic treatment routinely attend an orthognathic MDT clinic before commencing active treatment. Information is provided with nationally available resources and consultant orthodontists routinely discuss risks and benefits of the orthodontic and surgical treatment with prospective patients to help them make informed decisions regarding their care.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 53 (1) , 9-19
Open AccessInformation provision for orthognathic treatment by consultant orthodontists in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland: A questionnaire-based study
Objectives: The aim of this research was to carry out a study of consultant orthodontists in the United Kingdom (UK) and Republic of Ireland (RoI), exploring the information provision for patients both considering and undergoing orthognathic treatment to help inform the development of decision support tools. Design: A questionnaire-based study of consultant orthodontists in the UK and RoI through the British Orthodontic Society (BOS) Consultant Orthodontist Group. Setting: Data collected using an online survey platform (Qualtrics ® XM). Results: A final sample of 56 respondents was achieved with an estimated response rate of 28%. All respondents (100%) said their patients routinely attended an orthognathic multidisciplinary team (MDT) clinic before commencing any active treatment. The majority (98.21%) of respondents said they utilised nationally available resources produced by the BOS, with the most commonly used resource being the BOS ‘ Your Jaw Surgery ’ online resource. When considering the benefits of treatment that were routinely discussed, the three most commonly selected responses were improvement in occlusion (92.86%), improvement in facial aesthetics (91.07%) and improvement in dental aesthetics (83.93%). There were nine orthodontic risks that were routinely discussed by more than 90% of respondents, including pain and discomfort, duration of treatment and long-term commitment to retainer wear, alongside 11 surgical risks, including permanent and temporary paraesthesia or dysaesthesia of the lips/chin/tongue, and postoperative pain. Conclusion: From the responses received, patients considering orthognathic treatment routinely attend an orthognathic MDT clinic before commencing active treatment. Information is provided with nationally available resources and consultant orthodontists routinely discuss risks and benefits of the orthodontic and surgical treatment with prospective patients to help them make informed decisions regarding their care.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (4) , 326-336
Co-delivery of orthodontic treatment: Perceptions of supervising clinicians and orthodontic therapists
Objectives: To establish how orthodontics is currently co-delivered by orthodontic therapists (OTs) and supervising clinicians (SCs), and to explore both sets of clinicians’ perceptions of these working arrangements. Design and setting: Cross-sectional survey using an online questionnaire. Participants: General Dental Council (GDC)-registered OTs and specialist or non-specialist dentists who supervise OTs and work in the UK. Methods: A link to the online questionnaire was emailed to all members of the British Orthodontic Society and Orthodontic National Group and was posted in two Facebook groups. Reminder emails and Facebook posts were sent. Results: A total of 161 responses were received from 89 SCs and 72 OTs. Most worked in primary care as their main clinical role. Most OTs in primary care provided a mix of NHS and private care. Appointments with OTs were most likely to be supervised every other visit, with more frequent supervision reported by SCs, and by clinicians in secondary care. Remote supervision of some kind was reported by 63% of OTs. Different barriers and enablers to effective working practices were suggested by OTs and SCs. OTs reported improved patient satisfaction as the main consequence of their utilisation in the orthodontic workforce while SCs described improved clinical efficiency. Conclusions: OTs reported improved patient satisfaction as the main consequence of their utilisation, whereas SCs described improved clinical efficiency. Some OTs felt that SCs should be more readily available and that OTs should have more autonomy. SCs would prefer more time to supervise and provide prescriptions.
- 15 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (4) , 326-336
Open AccessCo-delivery of orthodontic treatment: Perceptions of supervising clinicians and orthodontic therapists
Objectives: To establish how orthodontics is currently co-delivered by orthodontic therapists (OTs) and supervising clinicians (SCs), and to explore both sets of clinicians’ perceptions of these working arrangements. Design and setting: Cross-sectional survey using an online questionnaire. Participants: General Dental Council (GDC)-registered OTs and specialist or non-specialist dentists who supervise OTs and work in the UK. Methods: A link to the online questionnaire was emailed to all members of the British Orthodontic Society and Orthodontic National Group and was posted in two Facebook groups. Reminder emails and Facebook posts were sent. Results: A total of 161 responses were received from 89 SCs and 72 OTs. Most worked in primary care as their main clinical role. Most OTs in primary care provided a mix of NHS and private care. Appointments with OTs were most likely to be supervised every other visit, with more frequent supervision reported by SCs, and by clinicians in secondary care. Remote supervision of some kind was reported by 63% of OTs. Different barriers and enablers to effective working practices were suggested by OTs and SCs. OTs reported improved patient satisfaction as the main consequence of their utilisation in the orthodontic workforce while SCs described improved clinical efficiency. Conclusions: OTs reported improved patient satisfaction as the main consequence of their utilisation, whereas SCs described improved clinical efficiency. Some OTs felt that SCs should be more readily available and that OTs should have more autonomy. SCs would prefer more time to supervise and provide prescriptions.
- Open Access
- 15 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 194-204
Using photo-elicitation to explore young people’s short-term experience of and adherence to orthodontic retainers
Objective: To investigate young people’s experience of retainer wear in the immediate term and at 6 months after appliance removal, and to explore the factors affecting retainer wear adherence. Design: Qualitative study. Setting: Orthodontic departments at two teaching hospitals in Yorkshire, UK. Participants: A total of 12 participants aged 13–18 years were recruited using a purposive sampling approach. Methods: Data collection occurred through one-to-one, virtual, photo-elicitation interviews at two time points (immediate and 6 months) with data analysed using interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA). Results: Three overarching themes were developed to describe young people’s experience of orthodontic retention: immediate experience and expectation of retainers; the process of adaptation; and motivating factors. Barriers to adherence were mostly ascribed to daytime wear, despite normalisation of retainers in young people’s lives. Interventions to help individuals overcome the initial adaptation phase and self-manage their foreseen problems of forgetfulness include routines and reminders, which seem to be less important at 6 months. At both time points, internal and external motivation significantly contribute to retainer adherence, with compensatory changes in behaviour being more important at 6 months. Conclusions: Understanding early experiences of retainer wear can help clinicians to provide timely and well-targeted interventions and information. Co-constructing unique adherence strategies may help to overcome the initial adaptation phase, with particular emphasis on understanding the individual.
- 15 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (2) , 194-204
Open AccessUsing photo-elicitation to explore young people’s short-term experience of and adherence to orthodontic retainers
Objective: To investigate young people’s experience of retainer wear in the immediate term and at 6 months after appliance removal, and to explore the factors affecting retainer wear adherence. Design: Qualitative study. Setting: Orthodontic departments at two teaching hospitals in Yorkshire, UK. Participants: A total of 12 participants aged 13–18 years were recruited using a purposive sampling approach. Methods: Data collection occurred through one-to-one, virtual, photo-elicitation interviews at two time points (immediate and 6 months) with data analysed using interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA). Results: Three overarching themes were developed to describe young people’s experience of orthodontic retention: immediate experience and expectation of retainers; the process of adaptation; and motivating factors. Barriers to adherence were mostly ascribed to daytime wear, despite normalisation of retainers in young people’s lives. Interventions to help individuals overcome the initial adaptation phase and self-manage their foreseen problems of forgetfulness include routines and reminders, which seem to be less important at 6 months. At both time points, internal and external motivation significantly contribute to retainer adherence, with compensatory changes in behaviour being more important at 6 months. Conclusions: Understanding early experiences of retainer wear can help clinicians to provide timely and well-targeted interventions and information. Co-constructing unique adherence strategies may help to overcome the initial adaptation phase, with particular emphasis on understanding the individual.
- Open Access
- 16 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (1) , 45-55
Orthodontic treatment protocol versus Peer Assessment Rating: Assessing the quality of orthodontic treatment
Objective: To apply the Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) to cases that have been assessed by the NHS Business Service Authority (NHSBSA) using the orthodontic treatment protocol (OTO), then compare the NHSBSA outcome assessment with weighted (W) and unweighted (U) PAR scores. Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: UK. Cases: Anonymised orthodontic cases submitted to the NHSBSA. Methods: A sample of 30 reports from 2021/2022 were randomly selected to include different standard of treatment grades. The records were de-identified and the pre- and post-treatment study models were PAR scored by a calibrated assessor. Results: The mean percentage change in PAR was higher in cases from green reports (W: 78%; U: 79%) than amber (W: 68%; U: 67%) and red reports (W: 65%; U: 65%). Alignment and poor buccal segment interdigitation were the most reported concerns for cases included in the red and amber graded reports. A residual increased overjet was the most common occlusal feature leading to PAR scores not being more than 70% improved. Only slight agreement was shown between OTP and PAR using the kappa statistic, and the chi-square statistical test found that outcome measures are statistically significantly different. Conclusion: There are fundamental differences between OTP and PAR, and general agreement between them has not been demonstrated. The NHSBSA Report provides a more critical outcome assessment than PAR, identifying elements that are not assessed or measured by the PAR index.
- 16 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 52 (1) , 45-55
Open AccessOrthodontic treatment protocol versus Peer Assessment Rating: Assessing the quality of orthodontic treatment
Objective: To apply the Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) to cases that have been assessed by the NHS Business Service Authority (NHSBSA) using the orthodontic treatment protocol (OTO), then compare the NHSBSA outcome assessment with weighted (W) and unweighted (U) PAR scores. Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: UK. Cases: Anonymised orthodontic cases submitted to the NHSBSA. Methods: A sample of 30 reports from 2021/2022 were randomly selected to include different standard of treatment grades. The records were de-identified and the pre- and post-treatment study models were PAR scored by a calibrated assessor. Results: The mean percentage change in PAR was higher in cases from green reports (W: 78%; U: 79%) than amber (W: 68%; U: 67%) and red reports (W: 65%; U: 65%). Alignment and poor buccal segment interdigitation were the most reported concerns for cases included in the red and amber graded reports. A residual increased overjet was the most common occlusal feature leading to PAR scores not being more than 70% improved. Only slight agreement was shown between OTP and PAR using the kappa statistic, and the chi-square statistical test found that outcome measures are statistically significantly different. Conclusion: There are fundamental differences between OTP and PAR, and general agreement between them has not been demonstrated. The NHSBSA Report provides a more critical outcome assessment than PAR, identifying elements that are not assessed or measured by the PAR index.
- 17 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 50 (3) , 310-317
Sustainability in orthodontics: Challenges and opportunities for improving our environmental impact
Objective: To highlight the potential environmental impact of different aspects of orthodontic care in the United Kingdom, outline the major barriers and challenges to reducing this impact, and summarise the possible action that could help the orthodontic community to tackle the climate change crisis. Impact: Travel, procurement and supply, material use, waste management, energy use and water consumption within dentistry have a considerable effect on the environment. There are, however, marked knowledge gaps pertaining to the impact of orthodontic treatment. Challenges: The lack of awareness of the NHS contribution to the carbon footprint and net-zero goals among healthcare workers, the NHS backlogs and budget cuts, and cross-infection control requirements particularly following the COVID-19 pandemic are some of the many challenges to making healthcare delivery more sustainable. Opportunities: By considering the triple bottom line (social, environmental and economic), incorporating the four Rs (Reduce, Reuse, Recycle, Rethink), taking practical action, including steps to educate ourselves and the wider team, and to promote research on environmental sustainability, we can get one step closer to reaching the NHS net-zero goals. Conclusion: Climate change is a global health threat with multiple contributors associated with orthodontic treatment delivery, which can be tackled on an individual, organisational and system level.
- 17 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 50 (3) , 310-317
Sustainability in orthodontics: Challenges and opportunities for improving our environmental impact
Objective: To highlight the potential environmental impact of different aspects of orthodontic care in the United Kingdom, outline the major barriers and challenges to reducing this impact, and summarise the possible action that could help the orthodontic community to tackle the climate change crisis. Impact: Travel, procurement and supply, material use, waste management, energy use and water consumption within dentistry have a considerable effect on the environment. There are, however, marked knowledge gaps pertaining to the impact of orthodontic treatment. Challenges: The lack of awareness of the NHS contribution to the carbon footprint and net-zero goals among healthcare workers, the NHS backlogs and budget cuts, and cross-infection control requirements particularly following the COVID-19 pandemic are some of the many challenges to making healthcare delivery more sustainable. Opportunities: By considering the triple bottom line (social, environmental and economic), incorporating the four Rs (Reduce, Reuse, Recycle, Rethink), taking practical action, including steps to educate ourselves and the wider team, and to promote research on environmental sustainability, we can get one step closer to reaching the NHS net-zero goals. Conclusion: Climate change is a global health threat with multiple contributors associated with orthodontic treatment delivery, which can be tackled on an individual, organisational and system level.
- Open Access
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Dental Traumatology
- Vol. 39 (S1) , 30-39
Identifying important prognostic factors and outcomes for autotransplantation of developing teeth: Clinicians' perspectives
Background/Aim: Variability in the outcome measures used to assess the success of tooth autotransplantation presents challenges for combining data to examine the success of the technique. Reaching agreement on the most important outcomes will enable routine procedural and follow‐up data to be collected in a standardised way. In turn this will promote greater data synthesis to evaluate outcomes and examine which procedural techniques influence outcome. The aim of this study was to identify which prognostic factors and outcomes are most important to clinicians with experience in autotransplantation of developing teeth.Methods: The Delphi method was used to build consensus on the most important prognostic factors and outcomes. Item identification involved a systematic literature review and review of current clinical datasets in use. A two‐round Delphi questionnaire was undertaken with clinicians providing tooth autotransplantation, followed by a consensus meeting to finalise the most important items.Results: Outcomes and prognostic factors were identified from the systematic review (82 studies and eight reviews), one guideline and three existing clinical datasets. Patient interviews and a clinician survey added a number of items that would not have been identified from the literature only. A total of 56 outcomes and 93 prognostic factors were included for rating in the Delphi questionnaire. The Delphi questionnaire was completed by 15 respondents in round one and 13 respondents in round two. The consensus meeting was attended by nine participants. The final items that were judged to be most important included 29 outcomes (25 clinical, three patient‐reported and one service delivery) and 49 prognostic factors (18 patient characteristics, four presurgical, 17 surgical and 10 postsurgical). Clinical outcomes were consistently rated higher than patient‐reported outcomes.Conclusions: The clinical outcomes rated as the most important were transplant survival and reason for failure, outcomes relating to pulp health, different types of resorption and evidence of infection (suppuration). Important patient‐reported outcomes were satisfaction with overall treatment experience, and outcome and quality of life related to function of the transplanted tooth. Procedural information rated as being the most important related to the donor tooth: stage of root development, method for surgical removal and storage and condition of the donor tooth root surface following removal.
- 7 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Dental Traumatology
- Vol. 39 (S1) , 30-39
Open AccessIdentifying important prognostic factors and outcomes for autotransplantation of developing teeth: Clinicians' perspectives
Background/Aim: Variability in the outcome measures used to assess the success of tooth autotransplantation presents challenges for combining data to examine the success of the technique. Reaching agreement on the most important outcomes will enable routine procedural and follow‐up data to be collected in a standardised way. In turn this will promote greater data synthesis to evaluate outcomes and examine which procedural techniques influence outcome. The aim of this study was to identify which prognostic factors and outcomes are most important to clinicians with experience in autotransplantation of developing teeth.Methods: The Delphi method was used to build consensus on the most important prognostic factors and outcomes. Item identification involved a systematic literature review and review of current clinical datasets in use. A two‐round Delphi questionnaire was undertaken with clinicians providing tooth autotransplantation, followed by a consensus meeting to finalise the most important items.Results: Outcomes and prognostic factors were identified from the systematic review (82 studies and eight reviews), one guideline and three existing clinical datasets. Patient interviews and a clinician survey added a number of items that would not have been identified from the literature only. A total of 56 outcomes and 93 prognostic factors were included for rating in the Delphi questionnaire. The Delphi questionnaire was completed by 15 respondents in round one and 13 respondents in round two. The consensus meeting was attended by nine participants. The final items that were judged to be most important included 29 outcomes (25 clinical, three patient‐reported and one service delivery) and 49 prognostic factors (18 patient characteristics, four presurgical, 17 surgical and 10 postsurgical). Clinical outcomes were consistently rated higher than patient‐reported outcomes.Conclusions: The clinical outcomes rated as the most important were transplant survival and reason for failure, outcomes relating to pulp health, different types of resorption and evidence of infection (suppuration). Important patient‐reported outcomes were satisfaction with overall treatment experience, and outcome and quality of life related to function of the transplanted tooth. Procedural information rated as being the most important related to the donor tooth: stage of root development, method for surgical removal and storage and condition of the donor tooth root surface following removal.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 50 (2) , 177-187
Orthodontic retention experience of university students: A qualitative study
Objective: To explore university students’ experience of retention and identify potential barriers and facilitators to long-term adherence. Design: Cross-sectional qualitative study using virtual focus groups. Setting: University of Leeds. Participants: Dental and non-dental students from the University of Leeds, who had previously undergone orthodontic treatment and had received removable retainers. Methods: Students were invited to participate via email. Virtual focus groups were undertaken using Microsoft Teams. A topic guide was used to explore the experience of orthodontic retention including factors that influence long-term retainer wear. Focus groups were recorded and analysed using an inductive thematic approach. Results: In total, 23 students participated in four focus groups, including 13 dental students. The period since the end of orthodontic treatment varied from 9 months to 10 years. Of the 23 participants, 8 (35%) were no longer wearing their retainers. Four themes were identified: (1) experience of orthodontic treatment including knowledge of relapse; (2) experience of retainer wear, including motivators and barriers; (3) role of others; and (4) increasing adherence. Key factors influencing use of retainers were the importance placed on maintaining treatment outcomes, awareness of unwanted tooth movement and understanding of the role of the retainer, access to replacement retainers, and ongoing support to encourage retainer wear. Greater knowledge and dental awareness reported by dental students did not necessarily increase adherence. Conclusion: Adherence to removable retainer wear is an important aspect of orthodontic treatment but it is recognised that long-term retainer wear is highly variable. The understanding of relapse and retention is variable. Challenges in gaining access to replacement retainers are a common cause of cessation of retainer wear. Dental professionals are perceived to be important in encouraging and supporting retainer wear and individuals reported they would like more follow-up.
- 15 November 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 50 (2) , 177-187
Open AccessOrthodontic retention experience of university students: A qualitative study
Objective: To explore university students’ experience of retention and identify potential barriers and facilitators to long-term adherence. Design: Cross-sectional qualitative study using virtual focus groups. Setting: University of Leeds. Participants: Dental and non-dental students from the University of Leeds, who had previously undergone orthodontic treatment and had received removable retainers. Methods: Students were invited to participate via email. Virtual focus groups were undertaken using Microsoft Teams. A topic guide was used to explore the experience of orthodontic retention including factors that influence long-term retainer wear. Focus groups were recorded and analysed using an inductive thematic approach. Results: In total, 23 students participated in four focus groups, including 13 dental students. The period since the end of orthodontic treatment varied from 9 months to 10 years. Of the 23 participants, 8 (35%) were no longer wearing their retainers. Four themes were identified: (1) experience of orthodontic treatment including knowledge of relapse; (2) experience of retainer wear, including motivators and barriers; (3) role of others; and (4) increasing adherence. Key factors influencing use of retainers were the importance placed on maintaining treatment outcomes, awareness of unwanted tooth movement and understanding of the role of the retainer, access to replacement retainers, and ongoing support to encourage retainer wear. Greater knowledge and dental awareness reported by dental students did not necessarily increase adherence. Conclusion: Adherence to removable retainer wear is an important aspect of orthodontic treatment but it is recognised that long-term retainer wear is highly variable. The understanding of relapse and retention is variable. Challenges in gaining access to replacement retainers are a common cause of cessation of retainer wear. Dental professionals are perceived to be important in encouraging and supporting retainer wear and individuals reported they would like more follow-up.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Dental Research
- Vol. 101 (13) , 1590-1596
Adolescent and Parent Preferences for Hypodontia: Discrete Choice Experiment
Choosing hypodontia treatment requires young people and parents to consider a large amount of information, identify what is important to them, and make trade-offs between options. This study aimed to examine young people and parents’ preferences for hypodontia treatment using discrete choice experiment (DCE). This was a cross-sectional survey of young people (12–16 y) with hypodontia of any severity, at any stage of treatment, and their parents. Participants were recruited from NHS Hospitals in England and Wales. A bespoke DCE questionnaire was developed to measure preferences for 6 attributes of hypodontia treatment (waiting time, treatment time, problems during treatment, discomfort during treatment, bite, appearance). The questionnaire was completed 1) online by young people and parents, individually or together, and 2) by child–parent dyads under observation. Preferences were analyzed using regression models. In total, 204 participants (122 young people, 56 parents, 26 dyads) completed the online questionnaire and 15 child–parent dyads completed the questionnaire under observation. The most important attribute in hypodontia treatment was improvement in appearance, but significant heterogeneity was found in preferences. Four distinct groups of participants were found: group 1 (39%): severe discomfort and problems were most important; group 2 (31%): most concerned about improvement in appearance of teeth and improvement in bite; group 3 (22%): appearance 3 times more important than any other attribute; and group 4 (9%): preferences difficult to interpret. There was variation in how child–parent dyads approached decision-making, with some negotiating joint preferences, while for others, one individual dominated. Making trade-offs in DCE tasks helped some people think about treatment and identify their preferences. Appearance is an important outcome from hypodontia treatment, but preferences vary and potential risks and functional outcome are also important to some people. There is a notable level of uncertainty in decision-making, which suggests further shared decision support would be valuable.
- 21 October 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Dental Research
- Vol. 101 (13) , 1590-1596
Open AccessAdolescent and Parent Preferences for Hypodontia: Discrete Choice Experiment
Choosing hypodontia treatment requires young people and parents to consider a large amount of information, identify what is important to them, and make trade-offs between options. This study aimed to examine young people and parents’ preferences for hypodontia treatment using discrete choice experiment (DCE). This was a cross-sectional survey of young people (12–16 y) with hypodontia of any severity, at any stage of treatment, and their parents. Participants were recruited from NHS Hospitals in England and Wales. A bespoke DCE questionnaire was developed to measure preferences for 6 attributes of hypodontia treatment (waiting time, treatment time, problems during treatment, discomfort during treatment, bite, appearance). The questionnaire was completed 1) online by young people and parents, individually or together, and 2) by child–parent dyads under observation. Preferences were analyzed using regression models. In total, 204 participants (122 young people, 56 parents, 26 dyads) completed the online questionnaire and 15 child–parent dyads completed the questionnaire under observation. The most important attribute in hypodontia treatment was improvement in appearance, but significant heterogeneity was found in preferences. Four distinct groups of participants were found: group 1 (39%): severe discomfort and problems were most important; group 2 (31%): most concerned about improvement in appearance of teeth and improvement in bite; group 3 (22%): appearance 3 times more important than any other attribute; and group 4 (9%): preferences difficult to interpret. There was variation in how child–parent dyads approached decision-making, with some negotiating joint preferences, while for others, one individual dominated. Making trade-offs in DCE tasks helped some people think about treatment and identify their preferences. Appearance is an important outcome from hypodontia treatment, but preferences vary and potential risks and functional outcome are also important to some people. There is a notable level of uncertainty in decision-making, which suggests further shared decision support would be valuable.