Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Rebecca J. Sharman has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Edge-enhanced disruptive camouflage is contrast dependent in VR environments

    by Ioan E. Smart, Rebecca J. Sharman, Kenneth C. Scott-Brown, P. George Lovell

    In camouflage research, field studies provide ecological validity but lack experimental control, and computer-based experimental studies have the opposite issue. Virtual reality (VR) systems could potentially allow researchers to have both experimental control and ecological validity. Here we develop a VR environment using Unreal Engine and present it via a head-mounted display (HMD). The HMD affords binocular depth and therefore a more ecologically valid, three-dimensional environment, whilst still maintaining experimental control. Disruptive camouflage interferes with depth-based cues, making it a good candidate for testing within a VR environment. Disruptively camouflaged moth-like targets were presented to human surrogate predators, and their survivability was measured. We show that VR can be used to measure camouflage effectiveness by replicating existing findings showing that edge-enhanced disruptive camouflage (EE-DC) is more effective than disruptive camouflage (DC) alone. Furthermore, we extend these findings to show that the effectiveness of EE-DC is modulated by the relative contrast of the disruptive patches. Specifically, it is more effective when the contrast difference between the patches is low. Additionally, we considered edge-enhancement in isolation and found that it still provided a camouflage benefit even without a DC component. Search paradigms within an immersive VR experimental framework offer a unique opportunity to evaluate camouflage theory in a rigorous, yet ecologically grounded manner. Significance Statement: When trying to measure camouflage effectiveness, researchers currently have two main methods: field studies, and computer-controlled experiments. However, both have limitations; field studies are very realistic, but difficult to control, whereas laboratory studies are highly controlled, but not very realistic. We propose that using a virtual reality (VR) paradigm would give researchers the best of both worlds. Using VR, we replicated existing findings and collected new data showing the importance of contrast in specific types of camouflage effectiveness. This establishes a methodological advance: researchers can now act as “digital architects” and control the visual information present in the environment. This flexibility makes it possible to investigate both longstanding and emerging questions about visual perception within ecologically realistic, experimentally controlled environments.


  • Open Access

    Neurodivergent Friendships

    by Rebecca J Sharman, Teresa Seedorf

    There is anecdotal evidence of neurodivergent (ND) people preferentially befriending each other. Here we present large-scale mixed-methods evidence investigating whether neurotype affects friendship making and exploring ND and neurotypical (NT) experiences of being friends with ND people. Our results show that ND people have significantly more ND friends than NT people. Furthermore, people have proportionally more friends with the same neurotype as their own, for example, autistic people have more autistic friends. We used reflexive thematic analysis to address the questions of what participants like and dislike about their friendships with ND people, and whether there is something different about those friendships. Five themes were found that highlight issues of miscommunication between different neurotypes, the joy of communicating in your preferred style, the sense of connectedness and belonging between ND friends, the issues associated with having friends with conflicting needs to your own, and the complexities of giving and receiving support. We discuss these findings in terms of ND culture and acceptance of inherent differences in friendship styles. Lay Many people believe that neurodivergent (ND) people prefer being friends with other ND people, however, it is not clear whether this is actually the case. In this article, we look at whether a person's brain type affects the proportion of friends they have from different groups and ask people about their experiences of being friends with ND people. Our results show that ND people have mostly ND friends, and neurotypical (NT) people have mostly NT friends. We also found that people have more friends with the same type of brain as their own, for example, autistic people have more autistic friends. When we asked people about their friendships with ND people, we found five main topics of discussion (1) difficulties in communication with people with a different type of brain, (2) joy at being friends with people who like to communicate in the same way as you, (3) a sense of connectedness and belonging between ND friends (4) issues when friends needs conflict with each other, for example, if one person needs quiet and the other needs to make a noise, (5) how complicated it can be to give and receive support, particularly when you may have challenges of your own. We talk about the idea of ND people having their own culture, with friendships that work a bit differently to their NT counterparts.


  • Open Access

    Dazzle camouflage: benefits and problems revealed

    by P. George Lovell, Rebecca J. Sharman, Tim S. Meese

    During WWI, ships were painted in high-contrast ‘dazzle’ patterns believed to distort, among other things, submariners' perceptions of direction when aiming their torpedoes, but was this strategy effective? Here, we investigated the effects of different camouflage patterns, including versions used in the war, on the perceived direction of travel for a three-dimensional computer model of the RMS Mauretania. The results of this study showed that texture gradients ‘twisted’ the perceived direction of the ship, the effect being ~10° for a regular pattern of circles. We also found a second, larger effect, ‘hysteresis’, that biased perceived target directions to parallel the horizon for directions of travel within approximately ±30° of 90° (left–right). Hysteresis persisted outside this central plateau, causing perceived directions to be offset from veridical. The twist and hysteresis effects combined linearly and were constructive (enhancing protection) or destructive (diminishing protection) depending on the directions of (i) travel and (ii) the ‘twisting’ texture gradients. However, the strength of hysteresis reduced as a function of experience. Our simulated torpedo attacks suggest that systematic perceptual distortion of direction by dazzle might have been effective only where submariners had low hysteresis and ships were fast enough to benefit from the perceptual error imposed by twist.


  • Open Access

    Abstracts of Scottish Vision Group 2023 Meeting

    by Paul George Lovell, Rebecca J. Sharman

    Scottish Vision Group has become a yearly event for vision scientists based in Scotland since its inception in 2001. Each year, the conference is hosted at a different location and organised by a different team. The 2023 SVG meeting was hosted in the city of Dundee by Abertay University. Delegates travelled from the United Kingdom, Europe and beyond. The meeting started with a roundtable panel discussion sponsored by Meta Reality Labs. The roundtable, titled The Past, Present and Future of Visual Search, was organised and presented by Árni Kristjánsson (Iceland), Ioan Smart (Abertay) and Ian Thornton (Malta). The MDPI Keynote lecture was introduced by Professor Andrew Parker (Oxford University and Otto-von-Guericke University in Magdeburg, Germany) and presented by Prof. Timothy Ledgeway (Nottingham) on sensory eye dominance and plasticity in adult binocular vision. The remaining two days of the conference hosted a wide range of talks on topics ranging from insect navigation to visual illusions, facial recognition and binocular coding. The Saturday evening saw a special event where delegates explored the sensory properties of a range of single-malt whiskies. Here, we present a selection of abstracts for the various talks and posters.

  • Open Access

    Edge-Enhanced Disruptive Camouflage Impairs Shape Discrimination

    by Rebecca J. Sharman, P. George Lovell

    Disruptive colouration (DC) is a form of camouflage comprised of areas of pigmentation across a target’s surface that form false edges, which are said to impede detection by disguising the outline of the target. In nature, many species with DC also exhibit edge enhancement (EE); light areas have lighter edges and dark areas have darker edges. EE DC has been shown to undermine not only localisation but also identification of targets, even when they are not hidden ( Sharman, Moncrieff, & Lovell, 2018 ). We use a novel task, where participants judge which “snake” is more “wiggly,” to measure shape discrimination performance for three colourations (uniform, DC, and EE DC) and two backgrounds (leafy and uniform). We show that EE DC impairs shape discrimination even when targets are not hidden in a textured background. We suggest that this mechanism may contribute to misidentification of EE DC targets.


  • Open Access

    Orientation of pattern elements does not influence mirror-symmetry perception

    by Rebecca J Sharman, Elena Gheorghiu

    Stimuli used to study symmetry perception often lack orientation information. However, orientation noise decreases the salience of symmetrical shapes suggesting that the two signals may interact (Machilsen et al., 2009, JoV). Here we investigate whether (i) orientation and position-symmetry signals interact in the perception of symmetry (Experiment 1), and (ii) symmetry detection mechanisms are sensitive to the orientation of pattern elements (Experiment 2). Stimuli were patterns made of oriented Gabors arranged either symmetrically about the vertical axis or randomly. We varied the amount of position-symmetry by changing the proportion of symmetrical Gabors and measured symmetry detection thresholds using a 2IFC procedure. Experiment 1 had two conditions: (a) ‘segregated’- position-symmetric Gabors had one orientation and the noise Gabors had a different orientation, and (b) ‘non-segregated’- position-symmetric Gabors were of two orientations in equal proportions, as were the random-positioned Gabors. We varied the separation between the two orientations (0°, 30°, 60°, 90°) in different trials. In Experiment 2, the orientation and position symmetry were manipulated independently. We used (a) position-symmetric patterns in which all Gabors had either the same (asymmetric), mirror-symmetric or random orientations. (b) position-symmetric Gabors had symmetric orientations and noise Gabors had random orientations and positions, (c) patterns with no position-symmetry, and varying amounts of orientation-symmetry. We found that symmetry detection thresholds were not significantly different for the segregated and non-segregated conditions, for all stimulus orientation differences (Experiment 1). The thresholds were also comparable across all conditions containing position-symmetry, but were significantly higher for the orientation-symmetry only (no position-symmetry) condition (Experiment 2). We conclude that symmetry detection mechanisms are not sensitive to orientation information. Although orientation is a dominant visual feature in many visual tasks, it does not affect symmetry detection even when the orientation signals are asymmetric, suggesting that symmetry detection mechanisms are solely reliant on position information.


  • Open Access

    Speed tuning properties of mirror symmetry detection mechanisms

    by Rebecca J. Sharman, Elena Gheorghiu

    The human visual system is often tasked with extracting image properties such as symmetry from rapidly moving objects and scenes. The extent to which motion speed and symmetry processing mechanisms interact is not known. Here we examine speed-tuning properties of symmetry detection mechanisms using dynamic dot-patterns containing varying amounts of position and local motion-direction symmetry. We measured symmetry detection thresholds for stimuli in which symmetric and noise elements either drifted with different relative speeds, were relocated at different relative temporal frequencies or were static. We also measured percentage correct responses under two stimulus conditions: a segregated condition in which symmetric and noise elements drifted at different speeds, and a non-segregated condition in which the symmetric elements drifted at two different speeds in equal proportions, as did the noise elements. We found that performance (i) improved gradually with increasing the difference in relative speed between symmetric and noise elements, but was invariant across relative temporal frequencies/lifetime duration differences between symmetric and noise elements, (ii) was higher in the segregated compared to non-segregated conditions, and in the moving compared to the static conditions. We conclude that symmetry detection mechanisms are broadly tuned to speed, with speed-selective symmetry channels combining their outputs by probability summation.


  • Open Access

    Spatiotemporal and Luminance Contrast Properties of Symmetry Perception

    by Rebecca J. Sharman, Elena Gheorghiu

    Recent studies have shown that limiting the lifetime of pattern elements improves symmetry detection, potentially by increasing the number of element locations. Here, we investigate how spatial relocation, luminance contrast modulation and lifetime duration of elements affect symmetry perception in dynamic stimuli. Stimuli were dynamic dot-patterns containing varying amounts of symmetry about a vertical axis. Symmetrical matched-pairs were: (i) relocated to multiple successive, but random locations (i.e., multiple locations condition); (ii) relocated between the same two locations (i.e., two locations condition); (iii) not, relocated, but their luminance contrast was modulated at different temporal frequencies (i.e., one location condition), and (iv) not relocated, but a single pattern was presented at full contrast (i.e., static condition). In the dynamic conditions, we varied the elements’ lifetime duration and temporal frequency of contrast modulation. We measured symmetry detection thresholds using a two-interval forced choice procedure. Our results show improved performance for the multiple locations condition compared to two-location and static conditions, suggesting a cumulative process whereby weak symmetry information is integrated by spatiotemporal filters to increase overall symmetry signal strength. Performance also improved for the static, contrast modulated patterns, but this was explained by a reduction in perceived density. This suggests that different mechanisms mediate symmetry detection in dynamic stimuli and static contrast modulated patterns.


  • Open Access

    Temporal dynamics of mirror-symmetry perception

    by Rebecca J. Sharman, Sebastian Gregersen, Elena Gheorghiu

    Recent studies have suggested that temporal dynamics rather than symmetrical motion-direction contribute to mirror-symmetry perception. Here we investigate temporal aspects of symmetry perception and implicitly, its temporal flexibility and limitations, by examining how symmetrical pattern elements are combined over time. Stimuli were dynamic dot-patterns consisting of either an on-going alternation of two images (sustained stimulus presentation) or just two images each presented once (transient stimulus presentation) containing different amounts of symmetry about the vertical axis. We varied the duration of the two images under five temporal-arrangement conditions: (a) whole patterns in which a symmetric pattern alternated with a noise pattern; (b) delayed halves—the halves of the symmetric and noise patterns were presented with temporal delay; (c) matched-pairs—two alternating images each containing equal amounts of symmetrical matched-pairs; (d) delayed matched-pairs—the same as arrangement (c), but with matched-pairs presented with delay; and (e) static—both images presented simultaneously as one. We found increased sensitivity in sustained compared to transient stimulus presentations and with synchronous compared to delayed matched-pairs stimuli. For the delayed conditions, sensitivity decreased gradually with longer image durations (>60 ms), prominently for the transient stimulus presentations. We conclude that spatial correlations across-the-symmetry-midline can be integrated over time (∼120 ms), and symmetry mechanisms can tolerate temporal delays between symmetric dot-pairs of up to ∼60 ms.


  • Open Access

    Dissociating the effect of disruptive colouration on localisation and identification of camouflaged targets

    by Rebecca J. Sharman, Stephen J. Moncrieff, P. George Lovell

    Disruptive camouflage features contrasting areas of pigmentation across the animals’ surface that form false edges which disguise the shape of the body and impede detection. In many taxa these false edges feature local contrast enhancement or edge enhancement, light areas have lighter edges and dark areas have darker edges. This additional quality is often overlooked in existing research. Here we ask whether disruptive camouflage can have benefits above and beyond concealing location. Using a novel paradigm, we dissociate the time courses of localisation and identification of a target in a single experiment. We measured the display times required for a stimulus to be located or identified (the critical duration). Targets featured either uniform, disruptive or edge enhanced disruptive colouration. Critical durations were longer for identifying targets with edge enhanced disruptive colouration camouflage even when presented against a contrasting background, such that all target types were located equally quickly. For the first time, we establish empirically that disruptive camouflage not only conceals location, but also disguises identity. This shows that this form of camouflage can be useful even when animals are not hidden. Our findings offer insights into how edge enhanced disruptive colouration undermines visual perception by disrupting object recognition.