PHPatricia M. Herman

Patricia M. Herman

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Patricia M. Herman has a total of 163 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Creating Research Capacity in Complementary and Integrative Institutions: Design of the RAND Research Across Complementary and Integrative Health Institutions (REACH) Center

    by Michele J. Maiers, Patricia M. Herman, Heather Zwickey, Tiffany Keyes, Margaret Whitley, Nipher Malika, Ryan Bradley, Margaret A. Chesney, Ian D. Coulter

    Purpose: Complementary and integrative health (CIH) professions educate a distinctive and growing segment of the U.S. health care workforce, including acupuncturists, doctors of chiropractic, and naturopathic physicians. Historically their small, largely private, non-profit educational institutions have faced structural barriers to building sustainable, competitive research programs. Limited access to research infrastructure such as biostatistical and informatics support, grants administration, and experienced mentorship has constrained the ability of CIH academic institutions to successfully compete for research grants and federal funding. This inhibits the ability of those trained in CIH professions to contribute robust evidence relevant to their professional practice and to such current research endeavors as whole person health and health policy. Furthermore, CIH academic institutions are largely tuition dependent. Without grants, research and scholarship are often funded indirectly by student fees. These challenges may also be faced by other family medicine professions trained in small academic centers. Interventions: One response to these challenges was the founding of the RAND Center for Collaborative Research in CIH (the RAND Center), which was launched in 2020. This center later received support to become the NIH-funded RAND Research Across Complementary and Integrative Health Institutions (REACH) Center. This article describes the historical context motivating the creation of a multi-institutional, virtual research center; the collaborative process through which it was developed; its organizational structure and guiding principles; and the ways in which it adapts and extends established clinical and translational research infrastructure models to meet the needs of CIH institutions. Conclusion: The RAND REACH Center represents a novel, scalable approach to strengthening research capacity, fostering cross-institutional collaboration, and developing the next generation of CIH clinician-scientists.

  • Response to Letter to the Editor

    by Patricia M. Herman, Sam Mann, Lynn L. DeBar

    Was not provided for this article.

  • Cost-Effectiveness of Acupuncture Needling for Older Adults With Chronic Low Back Pain

    by Patricia M. Herman, Sam Mann, Lynn L DeBar, Andrew L Avins, Morgan Justice, Arya Nielsen, Alice Pressman, Katie L. Stone, Robert Wellman, Andrea J. Cook

    Study Design.: Preplanned economic evaluation alongside a clinical trial. Objective.: Determine the 1-year cost-effectiveness from health care sector and Medicare perspectives of adding either standard acupuncture (SA; ≤15 treatment sessions over 12 wk) or enhanced acupuncture (EA; SA plus ≤ 6 additional sessions) to usual medical care (UMC) versus UMC alone. Summary of Background Data.: Chronic low back pain (CLBP) is common and expensive to treat largely due to the use of non-guideline-concordant pharmaceuticals and procedures. CLBP is also more common in older populations. Acupuncture has been shown to be effective and cost-effective for CLBP, but no studies have focused specifically on older adults. Methods.: Cost-utility and cost-effectiveness analyses comparing SA and EA to UMC using data from a randomized trial across three US health care systems. Bias-corrected and accelerated bootstrap techniques were used to generate 95% CIs. Results.: EA (n=225) reduced annual back pain-related health care sector costs by $491 (CI: −$2861, $1144) per participant versus UMC (n=225), and reduced Medicare-reimbursed costs by $421 (CI: −$2707, $1249) per participant. These cost savings came with a statistically and clinically significant gain in quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs; 0.037; CI: 0.013, 0.062), and a significant increase in the percentage of participants achieving a clinically meaningful improvement (CMI) in their Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire scores (18.5% points; CI: 9.0%, 27.9%). SA (n=222) was more expensive than UMC; the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio from the health care sector perspective was $52,897/QALY. The QALY gains (0.014; CI: −0.014, 0.043) and increase in percentage of participants with a CMI (6.9%; CI: −2.7%, 16.4%) in SA versus UMC were not statistically significant. Conclusion.: EA was cost-saving and SA may be cost-effective from the health care sector and Medicare perspectives compared with UMC for older adults with CLBP in three large health care systems in California and Washington State. Level of Evidence.: Level II.


  • Open Access

    Comparing three measures of sleep disturbance in persons with chronic low back and neck pain

    by Nabeel Qureshi, Daniel Siconolfi, Anthony Rodriguez, Ron D. Hays, Ian D. Coulter, Patricia M. Herman


  • Open Access

    Addressing the “Black Hole” of Low Back Pain Care With Clinical Decision Support: User-Centered Design and Initial Usability Study

    by Robert S Rudin, Patricia M Herman, Robert Vining

    Background: Low back pain (LBP) is a highly prevalent problem causing substantial personal and societal burden. Although there are specific types of LBP, each with evidence-based treatment recommendations, most patients receive a nonspecific diagnosis that does not facilitate evidence-based and individualized care. Objectives: We designed, developed, and initially tested the usability of a LBP diagnosis and treatment decision support tool based on the available evidence for use by clinicians who treat LBP, with an initial focus on chiropractic care. Methods: Our 3-step user-centered design approach consisted of identifying clinical requirements through the analysis of evidence reviews, iteratively identifying task-based user requirements and developing a working web-based prototype, and evaluating usability through scenario-based interviews and the System Usability Scale. Results: The 5 participating users had an average of 18.5 years of practicing chiropractic medicine. Clinical requirements included 44 patient interview and examination items. Of these, 13 interview items were enabled for all patients and 13 were enabled conditional on other input items. One examination item was enabled for all patients and 16 were enabled conditional on other items. One item was a synthesis of interview and examination items. These items provided evidence of 12 possible working diagnoses of which 3 were macrodiagnoses and 9 were microdiagnoses. Each diagnosis had relevant treatment recommendations and corresponding patient educational materials. User requirements focused on tasks related to inputting data, and reviewing and selecting working diagnoses, treatments, and patient education. User input led to key refinements in the design, such as organizing the input questions by microdiagnosis, adding a patient summary screen that persists during data input and when reviewing output, adding more information buttons and graphics to input questions, and providing traceability by highlighting the input items used by the clinical logic to suggest a working diagnosis. Users believed that it would be important to have the tool accessible from within an electronic health record for adoption within their workflows. The System Usability Scale score for the prototype was 84.75 (range: 67.5‐95), considered as the top 10th percentile. Users believed that the tool was easy to use although it would require training and practice on the clinical content to use it effectively. With such training and practice, users believed that it would improve care and shed light on the “black hole” of LBP diagnosis and treatment. Conclusions: Our systematic process of defining clinical requirements and eliciting user requirements to inform a clinician-facing decision support tool produced a prototype application that was viewed positively and with enthusiasm by clinical users. With further planned development, this tool has the potential to guide clinical evaluation, inform more specific diagnosis, and encourage patient education and individualized treatment planning for patients with LBP through the application of evidence at the point of care.

  • Open Access

    Comparing Health Survey Data Cost and Quality Between Amazon’s Mechanical Turk and Ipsos’ KnowledgePanel: Observational Study

    by Patricia M Herman, Mary E Slaughter, Nabeel Qureshi, Tarek Azzam, David Cella, Ian D Coulter, Graham DiGuiseppi, Maria Orlando Edelen, Arie Kapteyn, Anthony Rodriguez, et al.

    Background: Researchers have many options for web-based survey data collection, ranging from access to curated probability-based panels, where individuals are selectively invited to join based on their membership in a representative population, to convenience panels, which are open for anyone to join. The mix of respondents available also varies greatly regarding representation of a population of interest and in motivation to provide thoughtful and accurate responses. Despite the additional dataset-building labor required of the researcher, convenience panels are much less expensive than probability-based panels. However, it is important to understand what may be given up regarding data quality for those cost savings. Objective: This study examined the relative costs and data quality of fielding equivalent surveys on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (MTurk), a convenience panel, and KnowledgePanel, a nationally representative probability-based panel. Methods: We administered the same survey measures to MTurk (in 2021) and KnowledgePanel (in 2022) members. We applied several recommended quality assurance steps to enhance the data quality achieved using MTurk. Ipsos, the owner of KnowledgePanel, followed their usual (industry standard) protocols. The survey was designed to support psychometric analyses and included >60 items from the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS), demographics, and a list of health conditions. We used 2 fake conditions (“syndomitis” and “chekalism”) to identify those more likely to be honest respondents. We examined the quality of each platform’s data using several recommended metrics (eg, consistency, reliability, representativeness, missing data, and correlations) including and excluding those respondents who had endorsed a fake condition and examined the impact of weighting on representativeness. Results: We found that prescreening in the MTurk sample (removing those who endorsed a fake health condition) improved data quality but KnowledgePanel data quality generally remained superior. While MTurk’s unweighted point estimates for demographics exhibited the usual mismatch with national averages (younger, better educated, and lower income), weighted MTurk data matched national estimates. KnowledgePanel’s point estimates better matched national benchmarks even before poststratification weighting. Correlations between PROMIS measures and age and income were similar in MTurk and KnowledgePanel; the mean absolute value of the difference between each platform’s 137 correlations was 0.06, and 92% were <0.15. However, correlations between PROMIS measures and educational level were dramatically different; the mean absolute value of the difference across these 17 correlation pairs was 0.15, the largest difference was 0.29, and the direction of more than half of these relationships in the MTurk sample was the opposite from that expected from theory. Therefore, caution is needed if using MTurk for studies where educational level is a key variable. Conclusions: The data quality of our MTurk sample was often inferior to that of the KnowledgePanel sample but possibly not so much as to negate the benefits of its cost savings for some uses. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): RR2-10.1186/s12891-020-03696-2


  • Open Access

    The current state of the quality of homeopathic clinical research

    by Patricia M. Herman, Cindy C. Crawford, Margaret A. Maglione, Sydne J. Newberry, Paul S. Amieux, Kimberlee Blyden-Taylor, Raheleh Khorsan, Marcia Prenguber, Elizabeth Rice, Andy Shollar, et al.


  • Open Access

    A Perspective on the Measurement of Whole Person Health

    by Patricia M. Herman, Anthony Rodriguez, Maria Orlando Edelen, Graham DiGuiseppi, Chengbo Zeng, Ian D. Coulter, Ron D. Hays

    There is growing interest in moving away from a reductionistic view of the person and the health services they need to focus on improving the health of the whole person. However, there needs to be agreement about what this focus entails and how to measure its achievement. From this perspective, we offer suggestions for moving the measurement discussion forward. Our key suggestion is to separate the measurement of whole person health (WPH)—that is, the end goal or ultimate outcome we want to improve and/or maintain—from the measurement of WPH determinants—that is, the things that can be intervened upon to maximize WPH. We also offer some next steps toward developing a measure of WPH.


  • Open Access

    Dropout in a Longitudinal Survey of Amazon Mechanical Turk Workers With Low Back Pain: Observational Study

    by Nabeel Qureshi, Ron D Hays, Patricia M Herman

    Background: Surveys of internet panels such as Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (MTurk) are common in health research. Nonresponse in longitudinal studies can limit inferences about change over time. Objective: This study aimed to (1) describe the patterns of survey responses and nonresponse among MTurk members with back pain, (2) identify factors associated with survey response over time, (3) assess the impact of nonresponse on sample characteristics, and (4) assess how well inverse probability weighting can account for differences in sample composition. Methods: We surveyed adult MTurk workers who identified as having back pain. We report participation trends over 3 survey waves and use stepwise logistic regression to identify factors related to survey participation in successive waves. Results: A total of 1678 adults participated in wave 1. Of those, 983 (59%) participated in wave 2 and 703 (42%) in wave 3. Participants who did not drop out took less time to complete previous surveys (30 min vs 35 min in wave 1, P<.001; 24 min vs 26 min in wave 2, P=.02) and reported having fewer health conditions (5.88 vs 6.6, P<.001). In multivariate models predicting responding at wave 2, lower odds of participation were associated with more time to complete the baseline survey (odds ratio [OR] 0.98, 95% CI 0.97-0.99), being Hispanic (compared with non-Hispanic, OR 0.69, 95% CI 0.49-0.96), having a bachelor’s degree as their terminal degree (compared with all other levels of education, OR 0.58, 95% CI 0.46-0.73), having more pain interference and intensity (OR 0.75, 95% CI 0.64-0.89), and having more health conditions. In contrast, older respondents (older than 45 years age compared with 18-24 years age) were more likely to respond to the wave 2 survey (OR 2.63 and 3.79, respectively) and those whose marital status was divorced (OR 1.81) and separated (OR 1.77) were also more likely to respond to the wave 2 survey. Weighted analysis showed slight differences in sample demographics and conditions and larger differences in pain assessments, particularly for those who responded to wave 2. Conclusions: Longitudinal studies on MTurk have large, differential dropouts between waves. This study provided information about the individuals more likely to drop out over time, which can help researchers prepare for future surveys.