Beatrice L. Gordon
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Beatrice L. Gordon has a total of 52 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Rosemary. W. H. Carroll
Desert Research Institute
5 shared publications - Adrian Adam Harpold
Department of Natural Resources & Environmental Science University of Nevada Reno NV USA
4 shared publications Christine Albano
3 shared publications- Christine M. Albano
Desert Research Institute
3 shared publications - Gabrielle F. S. Boisrame
Desert Research Institute
3 shared publications - Austen A. Lorenz
Aythya Analytics
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Comparing Rural Residents’ Perceptions of Drought, Heat, and Wildfire with Instrumented Indicators: Evidence from Nevada’s Humboldt River Basin
Rural communities face increasing exposure to drought, extreme heat, and wildfire, but adaptation decisions depend not only on environmental change itself but also on how residents perceive that change. This study examines perception–instrumented divergence (PΔI), defined as the difference between perceived hazard change and matched instrumented hazard indicators, and evaluates whether PΔI is associated with adaptation intensity among rural residents in Nevada’s Humboldt River Basin. Survey measures of perceived hazard change and adaptation actions were combined with hazard-specific instrumented indicators for drought, heat, and wildfire. Instrumented trends were converted to a common seven-category scale using residence-matched Sen’s slopes and an autoregressive sieve-bootstrap classification procedure, allowing direct comparison with seven-point perception measures. Results showed that PΔI varied substantially by hazard and dimension. Heat was generally characterized by negative divergence, especially for magnitude and frequency, while drought showed positive divergence for magnitude and frequency. Wildfire showed mixed patterns across dimensions. In partial proportional-odds models, perceived hazard change had the clearest and most consistent association with adaptation intensity. Absolute PΔI showed weaker evidence of association, while directional PΔI indicated that greater under-perception was associated with lower adaptation intensity. Over-perception was less stable across model specifications. These findings suggest that climate risk management should consider not only whether residents perceive hazard change, but also whether specific hazard dimensions are under-perceived relative to local instrumented indicators. PΔI offers a practical diagnostic tool for identifying where risk communication and adaptation support may need to be more targeted.
- 14 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessComparing Rural Residents’ Perceptions of Drought, Heat, and Wildfire with Instrumented Indicators: Evidence from Nevada’s Humboldt River Basin
Rural communities face increasing exposure to drought, extreme heat, and wildfire, but adaptation decisions depend not only on environmental change itself but also on how residents perceive that change. This study examines perception–instrumented divergence (PΔI), defined as the difference between perceived hazard change and matched instrumented hazard indicators, and evaluates whether PΔI is associated with adaptation intensity among rural residents in Nevada’s Humboldt River Basin. Survey measures of perceived hazard change and adaptation actions were combined with hazard-specific instrumented indicators for drought, heat, and wildfire. Instrumented trends were converted to a common seven-category scale using residence-matched Sen’s slopes and an autoregressive sieve-bootstrap classification procedure, allowing direct comparison with seven-point perception measures. Results showed that PΔI varied substantially by hazard and dimension. Heat was generally characterized by negative divergence, especially for magnitude and frequency, while drought showed positive divergence for magnitude and frequency. Wildfire showed mixed patterns across dimensions. In partial proportional-odds models, perceived hazard change had the clearest and most consistent association with adaptation intensity. Absolute PΔI showed weaker evidence of association, while directional PΔI indicated that greater under-perception was associated with lower adaptation intensity. Over-perception was less stable across model specifications. These findings suggest that climate risk management should consider not only whether residents perceive hazard change, but also whether specific hazard dimensions are under-perceived relative to local instrumented indicators. PΔI offers a practical diagnostic tool for identifying where risk communication and adaptation support may need to be more targeted.
- Open Access
- 12 October 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (19) , 194029
Out of the frying pan, into the fire? Tradeoffs between drought adaptation and wildfire risk under cropland loss and urbanization in the western United States
The western United States faces two escalating, co-occurring hazards in the form of persistent water scarcity (drought) and increasingly frequent wildfires in places humans live and recreate. Drought adaptation has emphasized water savings from cropland retirement, while wildfire adaptation has emphasized the fire risks of urbanization. By overlooking what retired cropland becomes and what development replaces, neither has fully examined cropland’s role as a landscape-scale buffer to wildfire in the western US. We demonstrate this buffering capacity across 11 states and 39 years of data, showing that cropland is less likely to burn than other vegetation classes. Within 477 watersheds where cropland has interacted with wildfire in the western US, approximately 4.29 million hectares of cropland was lost between 1985 and 2024. Cropland loss in most watersheds (77%) was consistent with fallowing transitions to more burnable herbaceous and scrubland vegetation across the Pacific Northwest, Inland Northwest, Intermountain West, and Great Basin. In a smaller portion of watersheds (19%), losses occurred through cropland-to-developed transitions clustered around major metropolitan areas in California, Idaho, Oregon, Washington, Utah, and Colorado, where development simultaneously removes buffering capacity and adds ignition sources. The remaining watersheds saw cropland transitions to wetlands and forests. Results highlight emerging tradeoffs between drought adaptation and wildfire risk in the western US, with retirement-driven fallowing and development-driven conversion reshaping where wildfires stop at landscape-scales. Integrated planning tools that evaluate water use savings and wildfire risks jointly, and expanded agricultural conservation programs that incorporate fire-buffering value, can help manage tradeoffs.
- 12 October 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (19) , 194029
Open AccessOut of the frying pan, into the fire? Tradeoffs between drought adaptation and wildfire risk under cropland loss and urbanization in the western United States
The western United States faces two escalating, co-occurring hazards in the form of persistent water scarcity (drought) and increasingly frequent wildfires in places humans live and recreate. Drought adaptation has emphasized water savings from cropland retirement, while wildfire adaptation has emphasized the fire risks of urbanization. By overlooking what retired cropland becomes and what development replaces, neither has fully examined cropland’s role as a landscape-scale buffer to wildfire in the western US. We demonstrate this buffering capacity across 11 states and 39 years of data, showing that cropland is less likely to burn than other vegetation classes. Within 477 watersheds where cropland has interacted with wildfire in the western US, approximately 4.29 million hectares of cropland was lost between 1985 and 2024. Cropland loss in most watersheds (77%) was consistent with fallowing transitions to more burnable herbaceous and scrubland vegetation across the Pacific Northwest, Inland Northwest, Intermountain West, and Great Basin. In a smaller portion of watersheds (19%), losses occurred through cropland-to-developed transitions clustered around major metropolitan areas in California, Idaho, Oregon, Washington, Utah, and Colorado, where development simultaneously removes buffering capacity and adds ignition sources. The remaining watersheds saw cropland transitions to wetlands and forests. Results highlight emerging tradeoffs between drought adaptation and wildfire risk in the western US, with retirement-driven fallowing and development-driven conversion reshaping where wildfires stop at landscape-scales. Integrated planning tools that evaluate water use savings and wildfire risks jointly, and expanded agricultural conservation programs that incorporate fire-buffering value, can help manage tradeoffs.
- Open Access
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
A probabilistic framework for matching climate perceptions to instrumental trends across space and time
While the instrumental record provides our best means of estimating climate variability, adaptation decisions at regional and/or local scales are often shaped by perceived rather than measured trends. This gap between measured and perceived change may, in some instances, hinder adaptation efforts. Often this ”delta” is evaluated qualitatively, within a homogeneous region, or using a small range of climate variables. Here, we provide a statistical approach that allows for comparison across three different USA ecological regions, using a suite of climate variables related to heat, drought, and wildfire. We employ an autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) time series model to understand the temporal structure of each climatic variable and apply Monte Carlo simulation to construct a trend estimator null distribution. We evaluate observed trends against the distribution generated by these ARIMA simulations to categorize them into seven groups, comparable to perceived trends expressed in a Likert-scale survey. We use common error and bias measures of comparison to quantify the difference between perceived and instrumental change in each region. The ARIMA approach offers a flexible and broadly applicable framework to quantify differences between perceived versus measured trends across a wide range of climatological variables. It is particularly useful in circumstances when detailed social surveys are used to measure perceived change. The method can be extended to alternative trend estimators, such as ordinary least squares (OLS) regression slopes, and adapted for time series with diverse and often skewed distributions.
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessA probabilistic framework for matching climate perceptions to instrumental trends across space and time
While the instrumental record provides our best means of estimating climate variability, adaptation decisions at regional and/or local scales are often shaped by perceived rather than measured trends. This gap between measured and perceived change may, in some instances, hinder adaptation efforts. Often this ”delta” is evaluated qualitatively, within a homogeneous region, or using a small range of climate variables. Here, we provide a statistical approach that allows for comparison across three different USA ecological regions, using a suite of climate variables related to heat, drought, and wildfire. We employ an autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) time series model to understand the temporal structure of each climatic variable and apply Monte Carlo simulation to construct a trend estimator null distribution. We evaluate observed trends against the distribution generated by these ARIMA simulations to categorize them into seven groups, comparable to perceived trends expressed in a Likert-scale survey. We use common error and bias measures of comparison to quantify the difference between perceived and instrumental change in each region. The ARIMA approach offers a flexible and broadly applicable framework to quantify differences between perceived versus measured trends across a wide range of climatological variables. It is particularly useful in circumstances when detailed social surveys are used to measure perceived change. The method can be extended to alternative trend estimators, such as ordinary least squares (OLS) regression slopes, and adapted for time series with diverse and often skewed distributions.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Snow Loss, Economic Cost, and Potential (Mal)Adaptation in Irrigated Agriculture: Case Studies from the Western US
Climate change is altering snow accumulation and ablation dynamics in snow-dependent regions worldwide, reshaping runoff timing and water availability for people, ecosystems, and agriculture. As the world’s largest consumer of freshwater, irrigated agriculture is particularly exposed, and these hydrologic changes impose substantial economic costs. Here, we demonstrate how hydrology and economics can be combined to assign costs to snow-driven hydrologic change, using irrigated agriculture in the western United States as a large, snow-dependent test case. By integrating reduced-form economic models with climate model projections spanning approximately 2–5 °C of warming, we estimate that irrigated cropland could decline by 27–46% by the end of the century, while agricultural profitability—proxied using land rental rates—declines by 11–26%, corresponding to annual losses of approximately $8.2–$14.7 billion. Against this economic backdrop, scientists have an opportunity to leverage expanding data and modeling capabilities to provide actionable information about adaptation strategies that can reduce damages.However, there remains a persistent gap between the scales at which snow loss research is conducted and the scales at which land and water management decisions are made. To address this challenge, we propose that archetypes—drawn from social-ecological systems research—could help accelerate matching adaptation strategies to specific decision-making contexts by explicitly accounting for governance capacity and behavioral dynamics. This approach has not been widely explored in agricultural adaptation to snow hydrology but could enable rapid, locally-relevant guidance.Yet rapid adaptation without integration across hazards risks unintended consequences. Through analysis of four decades of fire perimeter data (1984-present) and aerial imagery, we show that cropland is 2x less likely to be on the inside of a fire perimeter than any other land-cover type, suggesting an important landscape-scale buffering effect. Using drought and wildfire as an example, this finding demonstrates how cropland abandonment—a strategy that may enhance drought resilience—could amplify fire risk if poorly coordinated, illustrating how rational responses to one hazard can inadvertently increase exposure to others. Results underscore the complexity of adaptation under compounding climate risks and the importance of working in partnership with decision-makers to leverage ever expanding data and modeling capabilities for locally-relevant solutions.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSnow Loss, Economic Cost, and Potential (Mal)Adaptation in Irrigated Agriculture: Case Studies from the Western US
Climate change is altering snow accumulation and ablation dynamics in snow-dependent regions worldwide, reshaping runoff timing and water availability for people, ecosystems, and agriculture. As the world’s largest consumer of freshwater, irrigated agriculture is particularly exposed, and these hydrologic changes impose substantial economic costs. Here, we demonstrate how hydrology and economics can be combined to assign costs to snow-driven hydrologic change, using irrigated agriculture in the western United States as a large, snow-dependent test case. By integrating reduced-form economic models with climate model projections spanning approximately 2–5 °C of warming, we estimate that irrigated cropland could decline by 27–46% by the end of the century, while agricultural profitability—proxied using land rental rates—declines by 11–26%, corresponding to annual losses of approximately $8.2–$14.7 billion. Against this economic backdrop, scientists have an opportunity to leverage expanding data and modeling capabilities to provide actionable information about adaptation strategies that can reduce damages.However, there remains a persistent gap between the scales at which snow loss research is conducted and the scales at which land and water management decisions are made. To address this challenge, we propose that archetypes—drawn from social-ecological systems research—could help accelerate matching adaptation strategies to specific decision-making contexts by explicitly accounting for governance capacity and behavioral dynamics. This approach has not been widely explored in agricultural adaptation to snow hydrology but could enable rapid, locally-relevant guidance.Yet rapid adaptation without integration across hazards risks unintended consequences. Through analysis of four decades of fire perimeter data (1984-present) and aerial imagery, we show that cropland is 2x less likely to be on the inside of a fire perimeter than any other land-cover type, suggesting an important landscape-scale buffering effect. Using drought and wildfire as an example, this finding demonstrates how cropland abandonment—a strategy that may enhance drought resilience—could amplify fire risk if poorly coordinated, illustrating how rational responses to one hazard can inadvertently increase exposure to others. Results underscore the complexity of adaptation under compounding climate risks and the importance of working in partnership with decision-makers to leverage ever expanding data and modeling capabilities for locally-relevant solutions.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Shifting Storage Regimes and Declining Streamflow Resilience in Mountain Systems
Mountain snow is a globally important source of water for downstream users and ecosystem sustainability, but it is uncertain when and where traditional snow metrics alone provide reliable indicators of water supply. Here, we synthesize large-sample regional analysis with a high-resolution integrated hydrologic model of a headwater basin of the Colorado River (East River, Colorado, 750 km2) to demonstrate the tight coupling between land surface and subsurface process on mountain streamflow generation. Our analysis of nearly 4,700 western US mountain watersheds indicates that streamflow predictability depends not only on snow accumulation magnitude, but on whether snow represents the dominant water reservoir. Snow storage-dominated mountain basins exhibit a tight coupling between peak snow water equivalent and runoff, while mixed storage systems, such as the East River, depend on interactions among snow, rainfall, and groundwater. Recent declines in runoff efficiency and the degradation of low-flow metrics in the East River coincide with persistent subsurface storage deficits due to overlapping climate extremes, signaling a shift toward subsurface storage-limited behavior. Modeled scenarios of persistent and prolonged warming indicate enhanced vegetation water use reduces recharge, drives substantial groundwater storage loss that disproportionately affects dry years and limits recovery even during wet periods, ultimately reducing annual flows and increasing stream intermittency. Sensitivity experiments further show that the depth and porosity of active bedrock circulation strongly modulate drought response. Deeper, higher-porosity groundwater systems are able to buffer low flows during multi-year drought conditions but experience prolonged post-drought recovery. Collectively, these findings highlight the tight coupling among climate, vegetation, snow, and groundwater, and demonstrate that explicit representation of subsurface storage dynamics is essential for forecasting mountain water supply, ecosystem vulnerability, and drought response under future climate conditions.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessShifting Storage Regimes and Declining Streamflow Resilience in Mountain Systems
Mountain snow is a globally important source of water for downstream users and ecosystem sustainability, but it is uncertain when and where traditional snow metrics alone provide reliable indicators of water supply. Here, we synthesize large-sample regional analysis with a high-resolution integrated hydrologic model of a headwater basin of the Colorado River (East River, Colorado, 750 km2) to demonstrate the tight coupling between land surface and subsurface process on mountain streamflow generation. Our analysis of nearly 4,700 western US mountain watersheds indicates that streamflow predictability depends not only on snow accumulation magnitude, but on whether snow represents the dominant water reservoir. Snow storage-dominated mountain basins exhibit a tight coupling between peak snow water equivalent and runoff, while mixed storage systems, such as the East River, depend on interactions among snow, rainfall, and groundwater. Recent declines in runoff efficiency and the degradation of low-flow metrics in the East River coincide with persistent subsurface storage deficits due to overlapping climate extremes, signaling a shift toward subsurface storage-limited behavior. Modeled scenarios of persistent and prolonged warming indicate enhanced vegetation water use reduces recharge, drives substantial groundwater storage loss that disproportionately affects dry years and limits recovery even during wet periods, ultimately reducing annual flows and increasing stream intermittency. Sensitivity experiments further show that the depth and porosity of active bedrock circulation strongly modulate drought response. Deeper, higher-porosity groundwater systems are able to buffer low flows during multi-year drought conditions but experience prolonged post-drought recovery. Collectively, these findings highlight the tight coupling among climate, vegetation, snow, and groundwater, and demonstrate that explicit representation of subsurface storage dynamics is essential for forecasting mountain water supply, ecosystem vulnerability, and drought response under future climate conditions.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth's Future
- Vol. 12 (6)
The Essential Role of Local Context in Shaping Risk and Risk Reduction Strategies for Snowmelt‐Dependent Irrigated Agriculture
Climate change‐induced shifts in snow storage and snowmelt patterns pose risks for adverse impacts to people, the environment, and irrigated agriculture. Existing research primarily focuses on evaluating these risks to irrigated agriculture at large scales, overlooking the role of local context in shaping risk dynamics. Consequently, many “at‐risk” areas lack insight into how adaptation strategies for managing risk through water supply augmentation or water conservation vary across contexts and over time. To address this gap, we develop a comprehensive index for evaluating irrigated agriculture's risk and adaptation potential to changes in snow at local scales and apply it throughout the western US. Results confirm trends toward escalating risk for changes in snow storage and snowmelt patterns over the century. However, substantial heterogeneity in the extent and drivers of risk exists due to variability in localized interactions between declines in water supply (approximately −9% ± 13% by 2100) and increased agricultural demand (approximately 7% ± 5% by 2100). Despite an existing focus on supply augmentation as a critical adaptation strategy to reduce risk, we show its effectiveness diminishes for many areas over time, declining to an average of −54% of historical augmentation potential by 2100. Conserving water through historical changes in crop acreage and type emerges as a more stable adaptation measure, reducing demand by 7%–8% regardless of time. While particularly relevant for higher elevation, less intensive agricultural settings in snowmelt‐dependent regions, findings underscore the need for strategies that support local‐scale, context‐appropriate adaptation to effectively manage escalating risk as snow changes.
- 11 June 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth's Future
- Vol. 12 (6)
Open AccessThe Essential Role of Local Context in Shaping Risk and Risk Reduction Strategies for Snowmelt‐Dependent Irrigated Agriculture
Climate change‐induced shifts in snow storage and snowmelt patterns pose risks for adverse impacts to people, the environment, and irrigated agriculture. Existing research primarily focuses on evaluating these risks to irrigated agriculture at large scales, overlooking the role of local context in shaping risk dynamics. Consequently, many “at‐risk” areas lack insight into how adaptation strategies for managing risk through water supply augmentation or water conservation vary across contexts and over time. To address this gap, we develop a comprehensive index for evaluating irrigated agriculture's risk and adaptation potential to changes in snow at local scales and apply it throughout the western US. Results confirm trends toward escalating risk for changes in snow storage and snowmelt patterns over the century. However, substantial heterogeneity in the extent and drivers of risk exists due to variability in localized interactions between declines in water supply (approximately −9% ± 13% by 2100) and increased agricultural demand (approximately 7% ± 5% by 2100). Despite an existing focus on supply augmentation as a critical adaptation strategy to reduce risk, we show its effectiveness diminishes for many areas over time, declining to an average of −54% of historical augmentation potential by 2100. Conserving water through historical changes in crop acreage and type emerges as a more stable adaptation measure, reducing demand by 7%–8% regardless of time. While particularly relevant for higher elevation, less intensive agricultural settings in snowmelt‐dependent regions, findings underscore the need for strategies that support local‐scale, context‐appropriate adaptation to effectively manage escalating risk as snow changes.
- 23 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Environmental Management
- Vol. 352, 119958
Adaptable and comprehensive vulnerability assessments for water resources systems in a rapidly changing world
- 23 January 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Environmental Management
- Vol. 352, 119958
Adaptable and comprehensive vulnerability assessments for water resources systems in a rapidly changing world
- Open Access
- 19 September 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 58 (9)
Can We Use the Water Budget to Infer Upland Catchment Behavior? The Role of Data Set Error Estimation and Interbasin Groundwater Flow
Water budgets are essential for characterizing water supplies from snow‐dominated upland catchments where data are sparse, groundwater systems are complex, and measurements are prone to error (ε). One solution is imposing water budget closure (CWB) by ignoring difficult‐to‐measure variables, including inter‐basin groundwater fluxes (G) and ε. However, conventional CWB‐based analyses, which derive evapotranspiration (ET) from precipitation (P) and streamflow (Q) (e.g., the Budyko hypothesis), are limited in their ability to take advantage of recent advances in ET products, physically‐based frameworks for improving inferences about G, or tools to statistically characterize ε (Triple Collocation [TC]); all of which offer promise for improved water supply predictions via open water budgets (OWB). We clarify the value of these advances in upland settings by comparing standard land surface model, Ensemble Mean, and TC‐Merged P and ET products in 114 upland catchments. When compared against a long‐term OWB, we find that the CWB assumptions are unsupported in 75%–100% of our 114 catchments, depending on the product. We then show how applying these CWB assumptions in snowy, steep catchments where ε is large can inflate inferences about streamflow response to climate change by up 9 times more than independent (OWB) estimates of ET using TC. Finally, we demonstrate how advances in OWB analysis reveal that high, arid settings with deep permeable substrate are groundwater exporters while most other basins are groundwater importers. Our results highlight the advantages of OWB analyses that harness new products, tools, and frameworks for characterizing inter‐basin groundwater fluxes in critical upland settings.
- 19 September 2022
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 58 (9)
Open AccessCan We Use the Water Budget to Infer Upland Catchment Behavior? The Role of Data Set Error Estimation and Interbasin Groundwater Flow
Water budgets are essential for characterizing water supplies from snow‐dominated upland catchments where data are sparse, groundwater systems are complex, and measurements are prone to error (ε). One solution is imposing water budget closure (CWB) by ignoring difficult‐to‐measure variables, including inter‐basin groundwater fluxes (G) and ε. However, conventional CWB‐based analyses, which derive evapotranspiration (ET) from precipitation (P) and streamflow (Q) (e.g., the Budyko hypothesis), are limited in their ability to take advantage of recent advances in ET products, physically‐based frameworks for improving inferences about G, or tools to statistically characterize ε (Triple Collocation [TC]); all of which offer promise for improved water supply predictions via open water budgets (OWB). We clarify the value of these advances in upland settings by comparing standard land surface model, Ensemble Mean, and TC‐Merged P and ET products in 114 upland catchments. When compared against a long‐term OWB, we find that the CWB assumptions are unsupported in 75%–100% of our 114 catchments, depending on the product. We then show how applying these CWB assumptions in snowy, steep catchments where ε is large can inflate inferences about streamflow response to climate change by up 9 times more than independent (OWB) estimates of ET using TC. Finally, we demonstrate how advances in OWB analysis reveal that high, arid settings with deep permeable substrate are groundwater exporters while most other basins are groundwater importers. Our results highlight the advantages of OWB analyses that harness new products, tools, and frameworks for characterizing inter‐basin groundwater fluxes in critical upland settings.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 17 (5) , 053004
Why does snowmelt-driven streamflow response to warming vary? A data-driven review and predictive framework
Climate change is altering the seasonal accumulation and ablation of snow across mid-latitude mountainous regions in the Northern Hemisphere with profound implications for the water resources available to downstream communities and environments. Despite decades of empirical and model-based research on snowmelt-driven streamflow, our ability to predict whether streamflow will increase or decrease in a changing climate remains limited by two factors. First, predictions are fundamentally hampered by high spatial and temporal variability in the processes that control net snow accumulation and ablation across mountainous environments. Second, we lack a consistent and testable framework to coordinate research to determine which dominant mechanisms influencing seasonal snow dynamics are most and least important for streamflow generation in different basins. Our data-driven review marks a step towards the development of such a framework. We first conduct a systematic literature review that synthesizes knowledge about seasonal snowmelt-driven streamflow and how it is altered by climate change, highlighting unsettled questions about how annual streamflow volume is shaped by changing snow dynamics. Drawing from literature, we then propose a framework comprised of three testable, inter-related mechanisms—snow season mass and energy exchanges, the intensity of snow season liquid water inputs, and the synchrony of energy and water availability. Using data for 537 catchments in the United States, we demonstrate the utility of each mechanism and suggest that streamflow prediction will be more challenging in regions with multiple interacting mechanisms. This framework is intended to inform the research community and improve management predictions as it is tested and refined.
- 25 April 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 17 (5) , 053004
Open AccessWhy does snowmelt-driven streamflow response to warming vary? A data-driven review and predictive framework
Climate change is altering the seasonal accumulation and ablation of snow across mid-latitude mountainous regions in the Northern Hemisphere with profound implications for the water resources available to downstream communities and environments. Despite decades of empirical and model-based research on snowmelt-driven streamflow, our ability to predict whether streamflow will increase or decrease in a changing climate remains limited by two factors. First, predictions are fundamentally hampered by high spatial and temporal variability in the processes that control net snow accumulation and ablation across mountainous environments. Second, we lack a consistent and testable framework to coordinate research to determine which dominant mechanisms influencing seasonal snow dynamics are most and least important for streamflow generation in different basins. Our data-driven review marks a step towards the development of such a framework. We first conduct a systematic literature review that synthesizes knowledge about seasonal snowmelt-driven streamflow and how it is altered by climate change, highlighting unsettled questions about how annual streamflow volume is shaped by changing snow dynamics. Drawing from literature, we then propose a framework comprised of three testable, inter-related mechanisms—snow season mass and energy exchanges, the intensity of snow season liquid water inputs, and the synchrony of energy and water availability. Using data for 537 catchments in the United States, we demonstrate the utility of each mechanism and suggest that streamflow prediction will be more challenging in regions with multiple interacting mechanisms. This framework is intended to inform the research community and improve management predictions as it is tested and refined.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2019
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
- Vol. 3
Existing Accessible Modeling Tools Offer Limited Support to Evaluation of Impact Investment in Rangeland Ecosystem Services
Privately owned rangelands in the western US support many ecosystem services and are threatened by financial incentives favoring conversion to housing development and more intensive forms of agriculture. Recognizing this threat, the impact investment community has identified rangeland management as a potential investing strategy to produce financial returns while preserving or enhancing the ecosystem services provided by intact rangelands. This strategy is based primarily on the notion that a capital-intensive conversion from continuous to rotational grazing can financially sustain rangelands through a combination of increased productivity and potentially monetized ecosystem service flows. The potential for these gains is supported by compelling anecdotal evidence, yet a robust body of scientific literature based on rigorous field experiments has not supported those claims, nor produced transferrable estimates of the benefits provided by rotational grazing of livestock (particularly cattle in the western US). Therefore, to demonstrate investment viability and measure investment success, impact investors will likely need to address these well-documented disconnects through some combination of monitoring and process-based modeling. This study examines the extent to which existing modeling tools are up to this task, by assessing the ability of two process-based models to represent four specific rotational grazing benefits put forth by impact investors, using a ranch in northeastern Wyoming as a case study. Using the Soil Water Assessment Tool, we simulated high magnitude changes in the water balance from surface runoff to evapotranspiration, which may be a benefit or negative impact depending on context (Benefit 1). We simulated a decrease in soil water storage under rotational grazing, which directly contradicts the outcome assumed in investment literature (Benefit 2). Using the InVEST beta Rangeland Production Model (based on the Century ecosystem model), we simulated increased biomass productivity (Benefit 3) under rotational grazing, which enhanced animal performance under some management parameters but negatively impacted it in others (Benefit 4). We conclude that the impact investing community will likely find greater success through a shift to objective-oriented ranch management, rather than a specific focus on rotation, and will also need additional investment in science and monitoring to demonstrate benefits.
- 24 September 2019
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
- Vol. 3
Open AccessExisting Accessible Modeling Tools Offer Limited Support to Evaluation of Impact Investment in Rangeland Ecosystem Services
Privately owned rangelands in the western US support many ecosystem services and are threatened by financial incentives favoring conversion to housing development and more intensive forms of agriculture. Recognizing this threat, the impact investment community has identified rangeland management as a potential investing strategy to produce financial returns while preserving or enhancing the ecosystem services provided by intact rangelands. This strategy is based primarily on the notion that a capital-intensive conversion from continuous to rotational grazing can financially sustain rangelands through a combination of increased productivity and potentially monetized ecosystem service flows. The potential for these gains is supported by compelling anecdotal evidence, yet a robust body of scientific literature based on rigorous field experiments has not supported those claims, nor produced transferrable estimates of the benefits provided by rotational grazing of livestock (particularly cattle in the western US). Therefore, to demonstrate investment viability and measure investment success, impact investors will likely need to address these well-documented disconnects through some combination of monitoring and process-based modeling. This study examines the extent to which existing modeling tools are up to this task, by assessing the ability of two process-based models to represent four specific rotational grazing benefits put forth by impact investors, using a ranch in northeastern Wyoming as a case study. Using the Soil Water Assessment Tool, we simulated high magnitude changes in the water balance from surface runoff to evapotranspiration, which may be a benefit or negative impact depending on context (Benefit 1). We simulated a decrease in soil water storage under rotational grazing, which directly contradicts the outcome assumed in investment literature (Benefit 2). Using the InVEST beta Rangeland Production Model (based on the Century ecosystem model), we simulated increased biomass productivity (Benefit 3) under rotational grazing, which enhanced animal performance under some management parameters but negatively impacted it in others (Benefit 4). We conclude that the impact investing community will likely find greater success through a shift to objective-oriented ranch management, rather than a specific focus on rotation, and will also need additional investment in science and monitoring to demonstrate benefits.