SJSimon Judge

Simon Judge

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Simon Judge has a total of 131 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Perceptual and Motor Constraints on Sequential Input in Gaze and Mouse Typing

    by Tom Griffiths, Simon Judge, Kevin Paterson, David Souto

    Eye-gaze control provides a powerful alternative input modality for both mainstream and assistive technologies. However, empiricalevidence comparing gaze control directly to manual input, such as using a computer mouse, remains limited. This comparison iscritical, as manual control constraints heavily influence interface design. In this study, we trained participants to type on a virtualkeyboard by using mouse control or eye-gaze control. Users selected letters by "dwelling" – a standard way of avoiding the "MidasTouch" problem. We analysed error-rates depending on the position within the letter sequence, the direction of the movement, andeccentricity. Although confusion matrices and analysis of error types indicated largely shared sources of error, we also found systematicdifferences. Yet, gaze control errors scaled less with eccentricity but increased during downwards selections compared to mousecontrol. Trajectory analysis revealed further distinctions between modalities: mouse trajectories were more flexible, allowing forlonger inter-key intervals but shorter dwell times. We suggest that eye-gaze control differs from mouse control mostly by enforcingsequential movement planning and visual processing of the movement targets.

  • Open Access

    Advancing EEG-based assessment of consciousness and cognition in prolonged disorders of consciousness

    by Naomi du Bois, Attila Korik, Stephanie Hodge, Leah Hudson, Ainjila S. Elahi, Alain Bigirimana, Natalie Dayan, Jose M. Sanchez-Bornot, Alison McCann, Kudret Yelden, et al.

    Background: Accurate assessment of residual awareness in patients with Prolonged Disorders of Consciousness (PDoC) remains a major clinical challenge, as conventional behavioural tools can underestimate covert cognition. This study evaluates whether a structured, multi-phase motor imagery Brain–Computer Interface (MI-BCI) protocol provides objective electroencephalography (EEG)-based indicators of awareness that complement behavioural assessments. Methods: Forty-four participants ( N = 44) completed repeated imagined-movement tasks using wearable EEG (PDoC: Unresponsive Wakefulness Syndrome (UWS, n = 14), Minimally Conscious State (MCS, n = 17), Locked-In Syndrome (LIS, n = 11); two able-bodied participants as benchmarks; ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT03827187; 30-01-2019). The protocol assessed sensorimotor rhythm modulation, training with and without neurofeedback, and binary question answering across phases. Standard behavioural assessments (CRS-R and WHIM) were administered at each session. Results: Significant MI-BCI decoding accuracy (DA) is achieved by 73.8% of patients, of whom 90% progress to Q&A testing and frequently exceed the 70% usability threshold, revealing marked inter-individual heterogeneity. For significant MI-BCI runs, LIS outperform MCS ( p = 0.007) and UWS ( p = 0.048), while UWS exceed MCS during Q&A ( p = 0.049), driven by familiar-voice stimuli. Using leave-one-subject-out cross-validation, combining predictions from DA and behavioural assessments improves balanced diagnostic accuracy to 62% (from 55%), increasing sensitivity to MCS (39% to 69%), with a modest reduction in LIS sensitivity (78% to 67%). Task-related activity over sensorimotor and parietal cortices differentiate diagnostic groups. Conclusions: The structured MI-BCI protocol demonstrates potential as a movement-independent, EEG-based tool for distinguishing UWS, MCS and LIS. Integrating DA and spatial patterns yields diagnostic information that may augment behavioural assessment and advance objective tools for evaluating awareness in PDoC.


  • Open Access

    Before the Technological Fix: Scoping AI and AAC for Social Futures

    by Seray B Ibrahim, Tom Griffiths, Michael Clarke, Simon Judge, Petr Slovak, Graham Pullin, Jeff Higginbotham


  • Open Access

    Timing of communication and technology control support in ALS – a systematic review

    by Simon Judge, Kirsty Ballesteros, Christopher J. McDermott, Steven Bloch

    Objective: To review evidence on the optimal timing of interventions that support communication and technology control for people living with Amyotrophic Lateral sclerosis (ALS). Methods: A systematic review was conducted following a pre-registered protocol. Databases were searched for studies involving people living with ALS that addressed timing of assistive technology interventions for communication or technology control. Screening and data extraction were completed in duplicate, findings were synthesized using a thematic analysis, and relevant findings presented as a descriptive summary. Results: Twenty-eight studies met the inclusion criteria. Evidence focused overwhelmingly on communication support rather than wider assistive technology interventions. Need for a communication aid typically occurs between one and five years from diagnosis and the timing of this varies significantly according to the site of onset of ALS. There are significant variations in the timing of changes for individuals within these groupings and there are likely a larger number of groupings that would be clinically useful. A significant correlation between changes in speaking rate and intelligibility has been shown. Once changes to speech do start to occur then the time to the loss of functional speech appears relatively consistent across the types of ALS. Conclusion: Current best practice guidelines are not reflective of the findings of this review and do not support professionals in identifying how to provide timely support. Monitoring speech changes systematically may support timely intervention. There is potential for individual level predictive modeling to help support people living with ALS to be proactive and prepared for changes.


  • Open Access

    Defining outcomes: exploring the perspectives of people who use aided augmentative and alternative communication to develop the content for a patient-reported outcome measure

    by Katherine Broomfield, Deborah James, Georgina L. Jones, Simon Judge

    Evaluating clinical interventions is an important component of quality assurance and informs decision making about the funding and commissioning of health and care services. Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) are tools that evaluate health interventions from the perspective of people receiving care. There is no validated PROM tool that evaluates the impact of augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) interventions. The current study was designed to understand what outcomes are important to people who use aided AAC. The study aimed to generate measurement items and to confirm the conceptual framework for a PROM for AAC. Seventeen participants aged 14 to 72 who use AAC were recruited. Each participant contributed to a one-to-one interview, informed by a topic guide developed in collaboration with a group of people with experience of using AAC. The research team used framework analysis to map data into an analytic framework informed by previous research. Analysis resulted in the development 33 items within seven domains that constitute the content for a PROM for AAC. The domains were mapped onto two conceptual models: Participation, including the Family of Participation-Related Constructs (fPRC), and the Communication Capability Approach. This research contributes rigorously developed PROM content grounded in the voices of people who use AAC and offers two conceptual frameworks to guide future tool development. It also raises critical questions about the theoretical underpinnings of AAC interventions and the need for outcome measures that reflect the evolving aspirations of users. The findings have implications for clinical practice, service delivery, and the ethical development of person-centred outcome measures in AAC.


  • AI, communication aids and the challenge of authentic authorship – Whose line is it anyway‽

    by Tom Griffiths, Katherine Broomfield, Laura Hrastelj, Simon Judge, Jonathan Toogood

    Purpose: AI and, more specifically, large language models (LLMs) have great scope for use in voice output communication aids (VOCAs), and this is being realised as the technology finds a greater foothold in mainstream systems. Design/methodology/approach: In this paper we examine what we know is important in VOCA design and use the approach of casuistry to examine the potential ethical implications of the use of LLMs in VOCAs. Findings: We suggest that there is relevant similarity between some potential applications of LLMs and the discredited technique of facilitated communication (FC). We highlight risks related to authorship and authenticity of the message produced by LLM-enabled VOCAs and discuss the importance of a holistic view of communication, which is multi-modal and co-constructed by all participants, generating agreed meaning with a shared understanding of where that meaning originates. We also draw attention to the potential impact of LLMs on language and communication development, where they may remove important opportunities for co-construction, correction and non-VOCA interactions that are so vital to development. Originality/value: Ultimately, we recognise the potential benefits of LLMs in VOCAs but counsel against a technoableist, technology-led implementation of LLMs without due consideration of the communication needs of VOCA users. We counsel against the uncritical inclusion of LLMs within new and existing VOCAs, and encourage a deeper engagement with the ethical risks of doing so, as well as with important concepts such as authorship, humanness and user-centred design.


  • Open Access

    Exploring electromyography for assistive technology: feasibility, usability and performance of a dry sensor EMG switch

    by Simon Judge

    Switch access is a tool used by many individuals with physical disabilities. Switches used in assistive technology are typically electro-mechanical. Electromyography (EMG) has previously been suggested for assistive technology switch access but has been little explored. Materials and Methods: An exploratory study aiming to investigate the feasibility, usability and performance of a dry sensor EMG switch when used by individuals with physical disabilities to control assistive technology was conducted. Results: Twelve participants with a range of underlying conditions trialled a novel dry sensor EMG switch. Switch reaction performance data for both EMG and conventional switches and qualitative feedback from semi-structured interviews were collected and tabulated. Results showed that the EMG switch was feasible to use in a range of placements and with a range of individuals, that it was feasible in some situations where a conventional switch was not, and that it may be more appropriate for those with hypokinetic movement disorders. Some participants described use of the EMG switch as less effortful and fatiguing. Some participants had faster reaction times using the EMG switch compared to conventional switches, the fastest average reaction time reported in the study (483 ms) was using the EMG switch. More false positive activations occurred when using the EMG switch and participants described this as impacting on usability. Setup complexity was also noted as a key usability barrier. Conclusions: This study highlights potential benefits of EMG switches but suggests further development is needed to improve ease of use and minimise false activations if EMG switches are to achieve broader adoption.

  • Open Access

    An evaluation of combined objective neurophysiologic markers to aid assessment of prolonged disorders of consciousness (PDoC)

    by Naomi du Bois, Jeremy Hill, Attila Korik, Damon Hoad, Lloyd Bradley, Simon Judge, Theresa M Vaughan, Jonathan R Wolpaw, Damien Coyle

    Objective: Clinical assessments of individuals with Cognitive-Motor Dissociation (CMD) following brain injury are challenging and prone to errors. This prompts investigation of objective, movement-independent neurophysiological markers using electroencephalography (EEG)-based Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) technology. The current pilot study involving adults with prolonged disorders of consciousness (PDoC) investigated the combination of Motor-Imagery BCI (MI-BCI) training and auditory evoked Event Related Potentials (ERPs) using an oddball paradigm to produce complementary biomarkers to improve evaluation of awareness in PDoC. Approach: EEG data (16 channels) were collected from participants with Unresponsive Wakefulness Syndrome (UWS, n = 2), Minimally Conscious State (MCS, n = 3), and Locked-In Syndrome (LIS, n = 4). The MI-BCI involved assessing sensorimotor rhythm modulation, motor-imagery training with and without auditory feedback, and motor-imagery responses to closed questions over 12 sessions each lasting ∼1hour. The oddball protocol was also deployed in 2-3 of those sessions, with ∼10 days between first and last, featuring auditory stimuli, comprising two 5-minute sets of standard, deviant beeps plus novel sounds, in a structured ratio. We expected those with the lowest levels of awareness would have reduced ERP components, with highest latencies to peak, as well as lowest accuracy in the motor imagery BCI protocol – and that trends across these metrics would be observed across the three patient groups based on their clinical diagnoses. Main results: Significant differences in mean N1 component latencies and mean MI Decoding Accuracies (DA, for significant runs) occurred between groups – with shorter N1 latencies for the LIS and MCS groups than for the UWS group (LIS vs. UWS and MCS vs. UWS, p < 0.001), and higher DA for the LIS group compared to MCS and UWS ( p < 0.001). Mean DA were found to have a significant negative correlation with mean N1 latencies (two-tailed, p = 0.017). Significance: The results indicate that neurophysiological markers from the concomitant application of an MI-BCI and auditory-oddball paradigm can augment standard clinical assessments by providing objective measures that produce robust evidence of awareness in people with PDoC.


  • Open Access

    Use of eye-gaze technology feedback by assistive technology professionals: findings from a thematic analysis

    by Tom Griffiths, Simon Judge, David Souto

    Purpose: Eye-gaze technology offers professionals a range of feedback tools, but it is not well understood how these are used to support decision-making or how professionals understand their purpose and function. This paper explores how professionals use a variety of feedback tools and provides commentary on their current use and ideas for future tool development.Methods and Materials: The study adopted a focus group methodology with two groups of professional participants: those involved in the assessment and provision of eye-gaze technology (n = 6) and those who interact with individuals using eye-gaze technology on an ongoing basis (n = 5). Template analysis was used to provide qualitative insight into the research questions.Results: Professionals highlighted several issues with existing tools and gave suggestions on how these could be made better. It is generally felt that existing tools highlight the existence of problems but offer little in the way of solutions or suggestions. Some differences of opinion related to professional perspective were highlighted. Questions about automating certain processes were raised by both groups.Conclusions: Discussion highlighted the need for different levels of feedback for users and professionals. Professionals agreed that current tools are useful to identify problems but do not offer insight into potential solutions. Some tools are being used to draw inferences about vision and cognition which are not supported by existing literature. New tools may be needed to better meet the needs of professionals and an increased understanding of how existing tools function may support such development. Professionals sometimes make use of feedback tools to infer the cognitive and/or visual abilities of users, although the tools are not designed or validated for these purposes, and the existing literature does not support this.Some eye-gaze feedback tools are perceived as a "black box", leaving professionals uncertain as to how to usefully interpret and apply the outputs.There is an opportunity to improve tools that provide feedback on how well an eye-gaze system is working or how effectively a user can interact with this technology.Professionals identified that tools could be better at offering potential solutions, rather than simply identifying the existence of problems.


  • Open Access

    Using longitudinal qualitative research to explore the experience of receiving and using augmentative and alternative communication

    by Katherine Broomfield, Simon Judge, Karen Sage, Georgina L. Jones, Deborah James

    Background: People who have communication difficulties may benefit from using augmentative and alternative communication (AAC). Understanding and measuring outcomes from the use of AAC is an important part of evaluating the impact of devices and services. Outcome measurement needs to reflect the changing nature of the impact of using AAC on an individual's ability to participate in activities of daily life. There is a limited understanding of the concepts that should inform the evaluation of outcomes from AAC device provision, nor how people's expectations from AAC may change over time.Aims: To inform the development of a patient‐reported outcome measure for AAC by understanding more about people's expectations from AAC and how these change over time.Methods & Procedures: A longitudinal qualitative research study was designed and carried out with seven participants over a period of 2 years. Participants were recruited from a regional specialist assessment service for AAC in the south‐west of the UK. Four semi‐structured interviews were carried out: (1) before assessment for AAC, (2) after assessment, (3) directly after provision of an AAC device and (4) between 6 and 12 months after provision. An original analytic method was used in this study that built on the principles of longitudinal interpretative phenomenology analysis, applied with a dialogic theoretical lens. This approach enabled the inclusion of a range of multimodal and embodied data collected to this study and allowed the research team to draw out salient themes across the cohort group while attending to the influence of time and context on experience.Outcomes & Results: The results confirm and extend the three core concepts that were used to guide analysis: changes; contexts; future possibilities. The contextual and temporal influences on outcomes attainable from AAC for this cohort were also identified and illustrated through cross‐case comparison. Deeper, analytic, and conceptual engagement with theory, which was then applied to analysis of the data, provided methodological rigour in the study. The results enhance our understanding of people's hopes and expectations from AAC and how these change over time.Conclusions & Implications: This qualitative longitudinal research study provides new insights into the journeys of people who experience communication disability, and the shifting nature of their sense of identity as they engage with, and learn from using, AAC. The study is significant as it attends to the dynamic nature of experience and how contextual and experiential factors influence people's hopes and expectations from AAC. The paper presents an original application of longitudinal qualitative research methodology with people who use AAC which can be further applied and tested in the field of communication disability research.WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: What is already known on this subject: We did not know the impact that time has on the concepts that have been identified to represent important outcomes from AAC. The existing concepts used to define outcomes from AAC were not adequately conceptualized to develop a patient‐reported outcome measure. This study sought to extend our knowledge about outcomes from AAC. What this paper adds to the existing knowledge: This study adds to the methodological toolkit available for qualitative inquiry in the field of communication disability research by presenting a longitudinal qualitative research methodology. It adds depth to our understanding of the concepts that underpin outcomes from AAC and highlights the dynamic nature of contexts and how this influences desired outcomes. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work?: This longitudinal qualitative research study provides a broader perspective on the experience of getting AAC. It will enable clinicians to better navigate the contextual and transitionary factors that influence people's experience of acquiring AAC devices. The enhanced concepts described will also support clinical conversations that consider the wider facets of communication and what AAC can add to existing communicative tool kits beyond getting a message across.