TMThomas Münch

Thomas Münch

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Thomas Münch has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The colors of proxy noise

    by Mara Y. McPartland, Thomas Münch, Andrew M. Dolman, Raphaël Hébert, Thomas Laepple

    The complex biological and physical processes that preserve paleoclimate information over centuries or longer introduce variations in proxy time series that are unrelated to the true climate. These non-climatic variations act on different timescales and are often referred to as “noise” of a specific color, based on similarities between a time series' power spectrum and the electromagnetic spectrum of light. For example, “white noise” equally affects all timescales, where “red noise” dominates only on long timescales, similar to longwave red light. Noise spectra in proxy records have far-reaching implications in paleoclimate research, but noise characteristics are often assumed based on first principles rather than estimated directly, risking either inflating or underestimating error at particular frequencies. Here, we provide concrete definitions of the various types of timescale-dependent errors that are present in proxy data, and review the literature on methods for quantifying noise terms. We then synthesize the results of several published studies that use a common empirical approach for estimating the noise spectrum in ice-core, coral, and tree-ring data. We posit that the colors of proxy noise are archive-specific, with white noise dominating in depositional archives such as ice cores and marine sediment cores, while red noise is more common in biological archives such as tree rings and corals. Our synthesis supports assigning specific colored noise terms in proxy system models, data assimilations and other experiments.

  • Open Access

    The impact of measurement precision on the resolvable resolution of ice core water isotope reconstructions

    by Fyntan Shaw, Thomas Münch, Vasileios Gkinis, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes in ice cores serve as a valuable proxy for the climate of the past hundreds of thousands of years. Over time, water isotope diffusion causes significant attenuation of the isotopic signal, exacerbated in deep ice due to extreme layer thinning and increased temperatures from geothermal heat flux. This damping affects higher frequencies to a greater extent, erasing information on the shortest timescales. It is possible to restore some of the attenuated variability through deconvolution, a method which reverses the effect of diffusion. However, since the measured isotopic signal always contains noise from the measurement process, deconvolution inevitably amplifies this measurement noise along with the isotopic signal. Thus the effectiveness of deconvolution depends on the precision of the measurements, with noisier data limiting the ability to restore otherwise resolvable frequencies. Here, we quantify the upper frequency limit introduced by the magnitude of the measurement noise analytically for different climate states, and offer a numerical example using the Beyond EPICA Oldest Ice Core (BE-OIC). We also demonstrate the qualitative significance of measurement noise on simulated Antarctic isotopic profiles. The general resolution improvement for firn or upper ice records is on the order of 1.5 times for a 10-fold reduction in measurement noise. Similarly, throughout the BE-OIC, we find the deconvolution of δ18O records with measurement error of 0.1 ‰ contributes a 1.5 times increase in the maximum resolvable frequency, which rises to a factor of 2 improvement after reducing the measurement noise to 0.01 ‰. While progress is continuously being made towards improving precision of stable isotope measurements, further improvements using longer integration times should be considered when analysing limited and precious deep ice in order to obtain the most faithful climate reconstructions possible.

  • Open Access

    Greenland Ice Core Isotope Variability Strongly Influenced by Systematic Changes in Depositional Noise

    by Nora Hirsch, Andrew M. Dolman, Thomas Münch, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes from ice cores are a unique proxy for reconstructing polar climate variability. Their interpretation is, however, challenging due to the impact of depositional noise. Here, we analyze the centennial‐ to millennial‐scale isotope variability of the Greenland ice cores NGRIP, GRIP, and GISP2 to investigate how their coherent signal and local noise have evolved over the last 100,000 years. We show that the noise systematically depends on the climate state, with higher levels under colder temperatures and lower accumulation rates. Most of the noise originates from local stratigraphic disturbances, while additional noise variability only emerges in the Greenland stadials. The remaining climate signal variability is higher in the last glacial period compared to the Holocene, but does not systematically differ between stadials and interstadials. We show that, by considering systematic changes of noise, it is possible to achieve more accurate estimates of past climate variability.


  • Open Access

    Reply on RC1

    by Fyntan Shaw, Thomas Münch, Vasileios Gkinis, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes in ice cores serve as a valuable proxy for the climate of the past hundreds of thousands of years. Over time, water isotope diffusion causes significant attenuation of the isotopic signal, exacerbated in deep ice due to extreme layer thinning and increased temperatures from geothermal heat flux. This damping affects higher frequencies to a greater extent, erasing information on the shortest timescales. It is possible to restore some of the attenuated variability through deconvolution, a method which reverses the effect of diffusion. However, since the measured isotopic signal always contains noise from the measurement process, deconvolution inevitably amplifies this measurement noise along with the isotopic signal. Thus the effectiveness of deconvolution depends on the precision of the measurements, with noisier data limiting the ability to restore otherwise resolvable frequencies. Here, we quantify the upper frequency limit introduced by the magnitude of the measurement noise analytically for different climate states, and offer a numerical example using the Beyond EPICA Oldest Ice Core (BE-OIC). We also demonstrate the qualitative significance of measurement noise on simulated Antarctic isotopic profiles. The general resolution improvement for firn or upper ice records is on the order of 1.5 times for a 10-fold reduction in measurement noise. Similarly, throughout the BE-OIC, we find the deconvolution of δ18O records with measurement error of 0.1 ‰ contributes a 1.5 times increase in the maximum resolvable frequency, which rises to a factor of 2 improvement after reducing the measurement noise to 0.01 ‰. While progress is continuously being made towards improving precision of stable isotope measurements, further improvements using longer integration times should be considered when analysing limited and precious deep ice in order to obtain the most faithful climate reconstructions possible.

  • Open Access

    Reply on RC2

    by Fyntan Shaw, Thomas Münch, Vasileios Gkinis, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes in ice cores serve as a valuable proxy for the climate of the past hundreds of thousands of years. Over time, water isotope diffusion causes significant attenuation of the isotopic signal, exacerbated in deep ice due to extreme layer thinning and increased temperatures from geothermal heat flux. This damping affects higher frequencies to a greater extent, erasing information on the shortest timescales. It is possible to restore some of the attenuated variability through deconvolution, a method which reverses the effect of diffusion. However, since the measured isotopic signal always contains noise from the measurement process, deconvolution inevitably amplifies this measurement noise along with the isotopic signal. Thus the effectiveness of deconvolution depends on the precision of the measurements, with noisier data limiting the ability to restore otherwise resolvable frequencies. Here, we quantify the upper frequency limit introduced by the magnitude of the measurement noise analytically for different climate states, and offer a numerical example using the Beyond EPICA Oldest Ice Core (BE-OIC). We also demonstrate the qualitative significance of measurement noise on simulated Antarctic isotopic profiles. The general resolution improvement for firn or upper ice records is on the order of 1.5 times for a 10-fold reduction in measurement noise. Similarly, throughout the BE-OIC, we find the deconvolution of δ18O records with measurement error of 0.1 ‰ contributes a 1.5 times increase in the maximum resolvable frequency, which rises to a factor of 2 improvement after reducing the measurement noise to 0.01 ‰. While progress is continuously being made towards improving precision of stable isotope measurements, further improvements using longer integration times should be considered when analysing limited and precious deep ice in order to obtain the most faithful climate reconstructions possible.

  • Open Access

    Greenland ice core isotope variability strongly influenced by systematic changes in depositional noise

    by Nora Hirsch, Andrew Mark Dolman, Thomas Münch, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes from ice cores are a unique proxy for reconstructing polar climate variability. Their interpretation is, however, challenging due to the impact of depositional noise. Here, we analyse the centennial- to millennial-scale isotope variability of the Greenland ice cores NGRIP, GRIP, and GISP2 to investigate how their coherent signal and local noise have evolved over the last 100,000 years. We show that the noise systematically depends on the climate state, with higher levels under colder temperatures and lower accumulation rates. Most of the noise originates from local stratigraphic disturbances, while additional noise variability only emerges in the Greenland stadials. The remaining climate signal variability is higher in the last glacial period compared to the Holocene, but does not systematically differ between stadials and interstadials. We show that, by considering systematic changes of noise, it is possible to achieve more accurate estimates of past climate variability.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2024-3650

    by Fyntan Shaw, Thomas Münch, Vasileios Gkinis, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes in ice cores serve as a valuable proxy for the climate of the past hundreds of thousands of years. Over time, water isotope diffusion causes significant attenuation of the isotopic signal, exacerbated in deep ice due to extreme layer thinning and increased temperatures from geothermal heat flux. This damping affects higher frequencies to a greater extent, erasing information on the shortest timescales. It is possible to restore some of the attenuated variability through deconvolution, a method which reverses the effect of diffusion. However, since the measured isotopic signal always contains noise from the measurement process, deconvolution inevitably amplifies this measurement noise along with the isotopic signal. Thus the effectiveness of deconvolution depends on the precision of the measurements, with noisier data limiting the ability to restore otherwise resolvable frequencies. Here, we quantify the upper frequency limit introduced by the magnitude of the measurement noise analytically for different climate states, and offer a numerical example using the Beyond EPICA Oldest Ice Core (BE-OIC). We also demonstrate the qualitative significance of measurement noise on simulated Antarctic isotopic profiles. The general resolution improvement for firn or upper ice records is on the order of 1.5 times for a 10-fold reduction in measurement noise. Similarly, throughout the BE-OIC, we find the deconvolution of δ18O records with measurement error of 0.1 ‰ contributes a 1.5 times increase in the maximum resolvable frequency, which rises to a factor of 2 improvement after reducing the measurement noise to 0.01 ‰. While progress is continuously being made towards improving precision of stable isotope measurements, further improvements using longer integration times should be considered when analysing limited and precious deep ice in order to obtain the most faithful climate reconstructions possible.

  • Open Access

    Comment on egusphere-2024-3650

    by Fyntan Shaw, Thomas Münch, Vasileios Gkinis, Thomas Laepple

    Stable water isotopes in ice cores serve as a valuable proxy for the climate of the past hundreds of thousands of years. Over time, water isotope diffusion causes significant attenuation of the isotopic signal, exacerbated in deep ice due to extreme layer thinning and increased temperatures from geothermal heat flux. This damping affects higher frequencies to a greater extent, erasing information on the shortest timescales. It is possible to restore some of the attenuated variability through deconvolution, a method which reverses the effect of diffusion. However, since the measured isotopic signal always contains noise from the measurement process, deconvolution inevitably amplifies this measurement noise along with the isotopic signal. Thus the effectiveness of deconvolution depends on the precision of the measurements, with noisier data limiting the ability to restore otherwise resolvable frequencies. Here, we quantify the upper frequency limit introduced by the magnitude of the measurement noise analytically for different climate states, and offer a numerical example using the Beyond EPICA Oldest Ice Core (BE-OIC). We also demonstrate the qualitative significance of measurement noise on simulated Antarctic isotopic profiles. The general resolution improvement for firn or upper ice records is on the order of 1.5 times for a 10-fold reduction in measurement noise. Similarly, throughout the BE-OIC, we find the deconvolution of δ18O records with measurement error of 0.1 ‰ contributes a 1.5 times increase in the maximum resolvable frequency, which rises to a factor of 2 improvement after reducing the measurement noise to 0.01 ‰. While progress is continuously being made towards improving precision of stable isotope measurements, further improvements using longer integration times should be considered when analysing limited and precious deep ice in order to obtain the most faithful climate reconstructions possible.

  • Open Access

    Greenland ice core isotope variability is controlled by systematic changes of depositional noise

    by Nora Hirsch, Andrew Dolman, Thomas Münch, Thomas Laepple

    Ice core stable water isotopes are among the few proxies capable of capturing past climate variability at timescales up to decades throughout and beyond the last Glacial period. They are therefore used to assess climate variability across different global mean temperatures and climate states. However, a significant portion of the isotope variability in ice cores can be attributed to noise, originating, for example, from stratigraphic disturbances at the snow surface and irregular, patchy precipitation events (i.e., precipitation intermittency). This additive noise is influenced by climate system components like accumulation, precipitation, or wind, which can systematically shift over time and across different climate states. Still, most recent studies on isotope variability have largely overlooked the impact of changing noise levels. In this study, we therefore use data from the Greenland ice cores GRIP, GISP2, and NGRIP to show how the common (signal) variability and the independent (noise) variability have evolved over the past 100,000 years and how these variations correlate with the prevailing climate state and accumulation rates. Our findings highlight that systematic fluctuations in noise levels must be accounted for as an additional source of uncertainty when comparing isotope variability across both high and low frequencies between different time periods.

  • Limitations of ice cores in reconstructing temperature seasonality

    by T. Laepple, T. Münch, N. Hirsch, F. Shaw, M. Hörhold