IAIldar R. Abitov

Ildar R. Abitov

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Ildar R. Abitov has a total of 44 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Objective and subjective evaluation of psychotherapy outcomes: a new perspective on the concept of effectiveness

    by Vladimir D. Mendelevich, Ildar R. Abitov, Elena A. Gorobets

    This article presents the results of a narrative scientific data review addressing the problem of evaluating psychotherapy effectiveness. The traditional evidence-based approach commonly used in medicine is analyzed, and the methodological challenges of applying it to the study of psychotherapy outcomes and other psychological interventions are described. At present, the need for strictly implementing evidence-based principles in psychotherapy is being cautiously reconsidered. Researchers are shifting the focus from attempts to objectify psychotherapy effectiveness toward examining client satisfaction with the quality of psychological care. Researchers have shown increasing interest in subjective measures of psychotherapy effectiveness, focusing on such evaluation aspects as satisfaction with the therapeutic process, enhanced self-understanding, increased autonomy, and greater social engagement. The significance of client and therapist expectations regarding psychotherapy outcomes, as well as the impact of anticipatory (predictive) abilities, is highlighted. It is concluded that a new perspective on the concept of psychotherapy effectiveness should include not only objective assessments of changes in a client’s psychological state but also the client’s subjective perception of these changes. In this regard, the development and adaptation of feedback scales (the Outcome Rating Scale and the Session Rating Scale) are considered important for monitoring the effectiveness of psychotherapeutic work with clients.

  • Open Access

    Monitoring client feedback in the context of common factors theory in psychotherapy

    by Ildar R. Abitov, Inna M. Gorodetskaya, Elena A. Gorobets, Rezeda R. Abdulina, Vladimir D. Mendelevich

    BACKGROUND: The issue of common factors in psychotherapy remains debatable, while their study is important for improving the effectiveness of psychological care. Feedback scales serve as one of the tools for researching changes in a client’s condition during psychological assistance and assessing the client’s perception of communication with a specialist. AIM: To identify the effectiveness of feedback scales (the Outcome Rating Scale and Session Rating Scale) for monitoring client work effectiveness. METHODS: Modified versions of the Outcome Rating Scale and Session Rating Scale were used, adapted based on personality relations theory, as translated by Bogomolov, Dmitrievsky, and Pavlovsky. The Outcome Rating Scale was additionally modified by the authors of this article. The Outcome Rating Scale was administered at the beginning of each session, while the Session Rating Scale was used during the final 5–10 minutes of each session. Solution-focused brief therapy served as the primary therapeutic method, with Myasishchev’s personality relations theory forming the conceptual basis for shaping certain therapeutic hypotheses. RESULTS: The analysis units included data from 151 sessions conducted with 34 clients (28 women and 6 men) aged 18 to 55. The sessions were conducted by a specialist with higher psychological education (one of the article’s co-authors). Normative values were obtained for the first and subsequent sessions using the modified Outcome Rating Scale; however, establishing normative values for the Session Rating Scale proved impossible due to extreme unevenness of score distribution. Both scales demonstrated good internal consistency. Data revealed significant changes from the first to last session in clients’ self-assessment of personal well-being, family/intimate relationship quality, general well-being, therapist-client relationship perception, and overall session evaluation. CONCLUSION: The Outcome Rating Scale and Session Rating Scale are reliable tools for monitoring changes in client status and therapeutic relationship quality, and can be used to assess the effectiveness of psychological care.


  • Personal resources of innovation-oriented young researchers in the scientific environment

    by Kazan (Volga Region) Federal University, Inna V. Krotova, Ildar R. Abitov, Ekaterina S. Palekha, Anna V. Lavrentyeva

    Introduction. The needs of modern society are associated with the demand for an increase in the number of effective scientific personnel, the growth of talented authors of new technologies, inventions, breakthrough ideas – scientific-creative, active and persistent personalities, who are in a constant process of development and self development. The purpose of this study is to build a psychological model of young researchers' personal resources. Materials and methods. Our study involved 130 master's students of Kazan (Volga Region) Federal University of the socio-humanitarian direction of full-time study; their test results were analyzed after they completed their master's studies. The first group – those who completed their studies within the established timeframe, passed all exams with "excellent" grade, had published more than five articles, became winners of scientific competitions and grants, and successfully defended their dissertations (30 people). The second group – students with lower academic indicators (100 people). In the first stage, data were collected through testing (N = 130), in the second stage (N = 30, N=100) data were processed using SPSS analysis. Correlation and divergent analysis were also used (Pearson's coefficient, Student's coefficient); the levels of statistical significance were p ≤ 0.05; 0.01; 0.001; 81 indicators of purposeful change of self, object and circumstaces). KEYWORDS Results. Model of personal resources of young researchers is defined: there are methodicality, self-value, creativity, correctness, as characteristic of this group and not characteristic of the group of less successful master’s graduates, with a significance level of differences of p<0.001 in the severity and relationships of psychological indicators. Conclusion. The results of the study of personal resources of young scientists’ will be useful for recommendations for psychological support of young researchers (undergraduate, specialist, master's, and postgraduate students).

  • Influence of Parental Attitude and Parents' Superstitiousness on Teenagers' Superstitiousness

    by Rezeda Abdulina, Ildar Abitov, Inna Gorodetskaya, Gulsina Khaibullina, Kseniya Razumova, Anastasiya Novikova, Anastasiya Popkova

  • Interrelation of Predictors of Irrational Behavior, Individual-Typological and Personal Characteristics

    by Kazan Federal University, Ildar Abitov, Inna Gorodetskaya, Alexey Dvoinin, HSE University

    A number of studies in cognitive psychology indicate that human behavior is largely governed by irrational factors (heuristics, cognitive biases, attitudes). These factors influence vital decisions, which can subsequently affect a person’s life and behavior in a broad temporal perspective. There is a lack of research on identifying the individual-typological and personal characteristics that make the irrational behavior more likely to occur. Our research is aimed at revealing the interrelation of predictors of irrational behavior (superstitiousness, “prelogical” defense, unconstructive, categorical, personally superstitious and esoteric thinking, naive optimism), individual-typological and personality characteristics of respondents. We used I. R. Abitov’s questionnaire, J. Tobacyk’s Paranormal Belief Scale adapted by D. S. Grigoriev, I. Y. Stoyanova’s Beliefs and Superstitions Questionnaire, and S. Epstein’s Constructive Thinking Inventory (adapted by S. N. Enikolopov and S. V. Lebedev) to reveal the expression of irrational behavior predictors. The individual-typological characteristics were identified using the Temperament Accentuation Test and the Individual-Typological Questionnaire, while the personal characteristics were identified using the G. V. Zalewski Psychological Rigidity Questionnaire and the C. Scheyer and M. Carver Test for Optimism. It was found that a decrease in the constructive thinking is associated with the expression of such characteristics as shyness, aggression, neuroticism (anxiety), sensitivity to external influences, various manifestations of rigidity, emotional instability and pessimism. It was also found that the expression of these characteristics, as well as pessimism and aversion to changes in self-esteem and personal position, is associated with a tendency to show categorical (“black and white”) thinking. Naive optimism is more often shown by respondents with such characteristics as hyperthymia and increased social activity. The relationship of personality-superstitious thinking with pessimism, fear of new situations, shyness, neuroticism (anxiety), and a tendency to exaggerate one’s difficulties were found. The novelty of our study lies in the discovery of complexes of characteristics that can increase the likelihood of irrational behavior. Reviewing the literature on the topic of the research, we did not find any works made in the mainstream of such an approach. The complexes of individual-typological and personal characteristics revealed in the given research can be considered as “targets” of psychological correction and prevention to decrease the risk of socially dangerous behavior.


  • Open Access

    GENDER ASPECTS OF SUPERSTITIOUS BELIEFS AND THEIR CORRELATIONS WITH THE LIFE MEANING ORIENTATIONS OF PERSONALITY

    by Инна Михайловна Городецкая, Ильдар Равильевич Абитов, Анастасия Николаевна Дорогова

    Несмотря на усиливающийся интерес исследователей к проблеме суеверности, на данный момент остается много противоречий и вопросов относительно ее природы и сущности, роли в жизнедеятельности и места в структуре личности. Феномен суеверности, не теряющий своей актуальности в современном обществе, рассматривается в гендерном аспекте и во взаимосвязи со смысложизненными ориентациями личности. Эмпирическое исследование феномена суеверности, а также его связи со смысложизненными ориентациями личности в гендерном контексте, проведенное на выборке из 40 человек (20 мужчин и 20 женщин) в возрасте от 18 до 45 лет, не выявило значимых половых различий в выраженности компонентов суеверности и смысложизненных ориентаций, хотя все показатели суеверности у женщин были несколько выше, чем у мужчин. Были, однако, обнаружены различия в структуре взаимосвязей показателей суеверности и смысложизненных ориентаций личности между мужской и женской выборками. In spite of growing research interest in the scientific problem of superstitiousness nowadays there are still a wide range of contradictions and challenges in this sphere of research: the nature and essence of the concept of superstitiousness, its role in everyday living and its position in the structure of personality. Being a very archaic phenomenon superstitiousness is still relevant in the modern society. This article addresses gender context of superstitiousness and its intercorrelation with individual value orientations that give the meaning of live. The study was carried out in May – July 2021 in Kazan (Russia). The study was conducted on a sample of 40 people (20 men and 20 women) aged 18 to 45 years and showed no significant gender differences in the manifestation of superstitiousness and life-meaning values, although female sample displayed higher superstitiousness indexes. Some interesting differences were found in the structure of correlations between superstition beliefs and lifemeaning orientations. The male sample had negative correlation links between pra-logical perception and locus of control. Also, magical forecast, pra-logical defense and integral superstitiousness index was negatively correlated with general awareness. In the female sample group magical anxiety, magical forecast, unconventional heeling, pra-logical defense and integral superstitiousness index had negative correlations with the locus of control.


  • Особенности проявления суеверности женщинами в норме и при патологии беременности

    by I.R. Abitov, I.M. Gorodetskaya, N.I. Kadyrova, M.V. Ilchenko

    One of the urgent problems of modern obstetrics and gynecology remains the problem of pregnancy pathology. Women with various types of pregnancy pathology are under the influence of high-intensity stress, as they experience physiological changes, often face the need for hospitalization for a long or indefinite period, are in a situation of uncertainty and lack of control due to the inability to influence the course of pregnancy and its successful outcome. A number of authors note that in such a situation of uncertainty and lack of control, people often resort to the use of various rituals, adhere to various superstitious beliefs. The purpose of our study is to identify the features of the manifestations of superstition and its interrelationships with the type of attitude to pregnancy and anxiety in women with pregnancy pathology. To solve the research tasks, the questionnaire of I. R. Abitov's superstition, the scale of belief in the paranormal by J. R. Abitov were used. Tobasika in the adaptation of D. S. Grigoriev, a questionnaire of beliefs and superstitions I. Ya. Stoyanova and I. V. Dobryakova's pregnant relationship test, Spielberger–Hanin's method of self-assessment of anxiety. The study involved 37 women with a normal pregnancy (aged 21 to 48 years) and 29 women with pregnancy pathology (aged 19 to 41 years). Differences were revealed in such indicators as personal anxiety (p≤0.01, U=734.5), superstition (p≤0.001, U=805.5), traditional religious faith (p≤0.001, U=880.0), belief in psi abilities (p≤0.04, U=755.5), witchcraft (p≤0.001, U=863.0), superstitions (p≤0.001, U=851.0), spiritualism (p≤0.001, U=895.5), predictions (p≤0.001, U=890.0) and extraordinary life forms (p≤0.016, U=722.5), pralogical perception (p≤0.001, U=871.0), magical anxiety (p≤0.001, U=875.5), magical prognosis (p≤0.001, U=867.0), the use of non-traditional methods of treatment (p≤0.001, U=853.0) and active use of pralogical protection (p≤0.001, U=825.0). In the group of women with a normal pregnancy, a large number of direct correlations of indicators of personal anxiety and an anxious type of attitude to pregnancy with various indicators of superstition and belief in the paranormal were revealed, while in the group of women with pregnancy pathology, only one direct relationship of the indicator of personal anxiety with the indicator of belief in psi abilities (p≤0.019, r=0.433) and two inverse correlations of the indicator of an anxious type of attitude to pregnancy with the indicator of traditional religious faith (p≤0.015, r=-0.446) and an indicator of a euphoric type of attitude to pregnancy with an indicator of faith in superstitions (p≤0.049, r=-0.369). The obtained results can be applied in correctional work aimed at reducing stress levels and preparing women with pregnancy pathology for childbirth. Одной из актуальных проблем современного акушерства и гинекологии остается проблема патологии беременности. Женщины, имеющие различные виды патологии беременности, находятся под воздействием стресса высокой интенсивности, так как переживают физиологические изменения, часто оказываются перед необходимостью госпитализации на длительный или неопределенный срок, находятся в ситуации неопределенности и отсутствия контроля из-за невозможности повлиять на протекание беременности и ее благополучный исход. Ряд авторов отмечают, что в такой ситуации неопределенности и недостаточности контроля люди зачастую прибегают к использованию различных ритуалов, придерживаются различных суеверных представлений. Целью нашего исследования является выявление особенностей проявлений суеверности и ее взаимосвязей с типом отношения к беременности и тревожностью у женщин с патологией беременности. Для решения задач исследования были использованы опросник суеверности И. Р. Абитова, шкала веры в паранормальное Дж. Тобасика в адаптации Д. С. Григорьева, опросник верований и суеверий И. Я. Стояновой и тест отношений беременной И. В. Добрякова, методика самооценки тревожности Спилбергера – Ханина. В исследовании приняли участие 37 женщин с нормально протекающей беременностью (в возрасте от 21 до 48 лет) и 29 женщин с патологией беременности (в возрасте от 19 до 41 года). Были выявлены различия в таких показателях, как личностная тревожность (р≤0,01, U=734,5), суеверность (р≤0,001, U=805,5), традиционная религиозная вера (р≤0,001, U=880,0), вера в пси-способности (р≤0,04, U=755,5), колдовство (р≤0,001, U=863,0), суеверия (р≤0,001, U=851,0), спиритизм (р≤0,001, U=895,5), предсказания (р≤0,001, U=890,0) и экстраординарные формы жизни (р≤0,016, U=722,5),...

  • Engagement in learning activities as a cognitive mental state: research experience

    by И.р. Абитов, П.н. Устин, Л.в. Артищева

    Актуальность исследования обусловлена расширением масштабов применения цифровых средств в образовании. Особенно остро проблема вовлеченности студентов в учебную деятельность в цифровой среде встала в период пандемии коронавирусной инфекции, когда все российские вузы перешли на дистанционный формат обучения. Цель работы заключается в исследовании субъективной (переживание) и объективной (проявления в поведении) сторон вовлеченности студентов при обучении в цифровой образовательной среде. Вовлеченность понимается авторами как познавательное психическое состояние, которое включает в себя когнитивную, эмоциональную, а также поведенческую готовность проявлять усилия, интенсивно работать и вкладываться в различные виды активности, включаться в образовательный процесс. Вовлечённость отражает стремление, желание студента работать и реализовываться в учебном процессе максимально эффективно, прилагать усилия, заинтересованность в самом процессе и в результате своей деятельности.В результате исследования установлены корреляции между показателями субъективного и объективного аспектов вовлеченности, а также индивидуальные особенности динамики состояния вовлеченности студентов в учебную деятельность в условиях цифровой образовательной среды. The relevance of the study is due to the expansion of the use of digital tools in education. The problem of students' engagement in educational activities in the digital environment was particularly actual and up-to-date during the coronavirus pandemic, when all Russian universities switched to a distance learning format. The purpose of the work is to study the subjective (experience) and objective (manifestations in behavior) aspects of students’ engagement in learning in a digital educational environment. Engagement in this research is understood as a cognitive mental state, which includes cognitive, emotional and behavioral readiness to make efforts, work intensively and to be involved in the educational process. Engagement reflects student’s desire to work and be realized in the educational process as efficiently as possible, to make efforts, interest in the process itself, and as a result of their activities.


  • Possibilities Of Dynamic Assessment Of Student Engagement In Online Learning

    by Kamil Nasibullov, Ildar R. Abitov, Lira V. Artishcheva, Pavel N. Ustin, Timirhan B. Alishev, Leonid M. Popov