Margaret Malloch
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Margaret Malloch has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gill McIvor
University of Stirling, UK
4 shared publications Cheryl Burgess
University of Stirling
3 shared publicationsPaul Rigby
Margaret Malloch is Professor of Criminology and Paul Rigby is Lecturer in Social Work Faculty of Social Sciences University of Stirling
2 shared publications- Cecep Mustafa
Stirling University
1 shared publication - Elizabeth Stanley
Victoria University of Wellington
1 shared publication - Fiona Mitchell
School of Applied Social Science University of Stirling Stirling UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal
- Vol. 22 (4) , 784-806
Making lives grievable: Crime, culture and remembering the accused witches of Scotland
Recent campaigns to remember those accused during the witch-hunts of the 16th and 17th century in Scotland have exposed the vindictiveness of law and kirk (church). The practice of ‘witchcraft’, or consulting with a ‘witch’, though ill-defined, was a capital offence under the Witchcraft Act of 1563 resulting in the execution of over 2500 people, mainly women. For the convicted, execution was frequently followed by the eradication of their lives from local history. Grieving is a powerful individual and cultural response to loss and an expression of mourning. In the case of controversial deaths, the right to grieve is often removed and drawing on the work of Judith Butler, some lives are considered ‘un-grievable’. By exploring this concept through primary research into contemporary campaigns to memorialise the historic Scottish witch-hunts, this paper highlights the ways in which campaigners have resisted the distortion and eradication of some lives. Importantly, the paper argues that the cultural power of memorialisation is a form of resistance and witnessing, making ungrievable lives grievable through collective acts of remembrance.
- 5 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal
- Vol. 22 (4) , 784-806
Open AccessMaking lives grievable: Crime, culture and remembering the accused witches of Scotland
Recent campaigns to remember those accused during the witch-hunts of the 16th and 17th century in Scotland have exposed the vindictiveness of law and kirk (church). The practice of ‘witchcraft’, or consulting with a ‘witch’, though ill-defined, was a capital offence under the Witchcraft Act of 1563 resulting in the execution of over 2500 people, mainly women. For the convicted, execution was frequently followed by the eradication of their lives from local history. Grieving is a powerful individual and cultural response to loss and an expression of mourning. In the case of controversial deaths, the right to grieve is often removed and drawing on the work of Judith Butler, some lives are considered ‘un-grievable’. By exploring this concept through primary research into contemporary campaigns to memorialise the historic Scottish witch-hunts, this paper highlights the ways in which campaigners have resisted the distortion and eradication of some lives. Importantly, the paper argues that the cultural power of memorialisation is a form of resistance and witnessing, making ungrievable lives grievable through collective acts of remembrance.
- 26 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 387-409
Therapeutic or Therapunitive? Conceptualising Community Custody in Scotland
- 26 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 387-409
Therapeutic or Therapunitive? Conceptualising Community Custody in Scotland
- 15 June 2020
- Published by Wiley in The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice
- Vol. 59 (2) , 158-173
The Complexities of ‘Home’: Young People ‘on the Move’ and State Responses
‘Home’ invokes ambiguous meanings for policy, practice and academia. This article explores the complexities of ‘home’ in relation to the experiences of two groups of young people in transitory circumstances (UK children who go missing from the family home or alternative care; and young people who have been separated from their home and families as refugees). We consider how the meaning given to ‘home’, despite its inherent ambiguity, functions as a central concept around which the vulnerability and credibility of children and young people are constructed. By problematising the universalised concept of home and the notion of ‘family’ that it implies, this article contributes to criminology and refugee studies by exploring State responses to ‘youth journeys’ (within and to the UK) through an idealised lens of ‘home’. This normative view, we suggest, forms the basis for determining State responses, with significant consequences for these young people.
- 15 June 2020
- Published by Wiley in The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice
- Vol. 59 (2) , 158-173
The Complexities of ‘Home’: Young People ‘on the Move’ and State Responses
‘Home’ invokes ambiguous meanings for policy, practice and academia. This article explores the complexities of ‘home’ in relation to the experiences of two groups of young people in transitory circumstances (UK children who go missing from the family home or alternative care; and young people who have been separated from their home and families as refugees). We consider how the meaning given to ‘home’, despite its inherent ambiguity, functions as a central concept around which the vulnerability and credibility of children and young people are constructed. By problematising the universalised concept of home and the notion of ‘family’ that it implies, this article contributes to criminology and refugee studies by exploring State responses to ‘youth journeys’ (within and to the UK) through an idealised lens of ‘home’. This normative view, we suggest, forms the basis for determining State responses, with significant consequences for these young people.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy
- Vol. 28 (2) , 118-126
‘Discursive struggles’ between criminal justice sanctions and health interventions for people who use drugs: a qualitative exploration of diversion policy and practice in Scotland
Amidst growing recognition that people who use drugs are often vulnerable and in need of health-focused support, international conventions and national priorities on personal drug use are changing with emphasis shifting from criminal justice to health narratives. In Scotland, there has been a move toward health-led drug policymaking, and yet little is known about how diversion operates in this context. An exploratory qualitative study was conducted utilizing semi-structured interviews with professionals holding lead, strategic-level roles in Scottish diversion policy and practice (n = 15). Interview transcripts were thematically analyzed using a structured framework technique. Findings show that the term ‘diversion’ is used to refer to criminal justice-initiated drug treatment routes, both pre- and post-conviction. Unlike many international examples, Scottish diversions tend to embed health-focused support within criminal sanctions, rather than acting as alternatives. Participants expressed the view that the term diversion implied a shift from criminal justice sanctions to health-led support that did not occur in reality. We, therefore, argue that the term diversion may function to mute a ‘discursive struggle’ between criminal justice sanctions and health interventions for people who use drugs, obscuring a growing gap between aspirational governance principles and institutional and lived realities.
- 12 June 2020
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy
- Vol. 28 (2) , 118-126
Open Access‘Discursive struggles’ between criminal justice sanctions and health interventions for people who use drugs: a qualitative exploration of diversion policy and practice in Scotland
Amidst growing recognition that people who use drugs are often vulnerable and in need of health-focused support, international conventions and national priorities on personal drug use are changing with emphasis shifting from criminal justice to health narratives. In Scotland, there has been a move toward health-led drug policymaking, and yet little is known about how diversion operates in this context. An exploratory qualitative study was conducted utilizing semi-structured interviews with professionals holding lead, strategic-level roles in Scottish diversion policy and practice (n = 15). Interview transcripts were thematically analyzed using a structured framework technique. Findings show that the term ‘diversion’ is used to refer to criminal justice-initiated drug treatment routes, both pre- and post-conviction. Unlike many international examples, Scottish diversions tend to embed health-focused support within criminal sanctions, rather than acting as alternatives. Participants expressed the view that the term diversion implied a shift from criminal justice sanctions to health-led support that did not occur in reality. We, therefore, argue that the term diversion may function to mute a ‘discursive struggle’ between criminal justice sanctions and health interventions for people who use drugs, obscuring a growing gap between aspirational governance principles and institutional and lived realities.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Crime, Law and Social Change
- Vol. 74 (3) , 297-313
Judicial perspectives on the sentencing of minor drug offenders in Indonesia: discretionary practice and compassionate approaches
This paper explores the perceptions of Indonesian Judges in sentencing minor drug offenders. The Judge holds a central role in the administration of justice and, because of the significance of judicial discretion, it is essential to understand how judges come to their sentencing decisions. To develop an understanding of what judges are trying to achieve when sentencing minor drug offenders, a total of 31 judges were interviewed: 28 participants came from District Courts in Urban and Rural jurisdictions in Indonesia (17 from Urban Courts and 11 from Rural Courts) and three were Supreme Court judges. The findings highlight that the process of justice involves not merely the application of the rule of the law or relevant legal codes; rather, how the judiciary balance and interpret the law is a central part of court sentencing practice.
- 12 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Crime, Law and Social Change
- Vol. 74 (3) , 297-313
Open AccessJudicial perspectives on the sentencing of minor drug offenders in Indonesia: discretionary practice and compassionate approaches
This paper explores the perceptions of Indonesian Judges in sentencing minor drug offenders. The Judge holds a central role in the administration of justice and, because of the significance of judicial discretion, it is essential to understand how judges come to their sentencing decisions. To develop an understanding of what judges are trying to achieve when sentencing minor drug offenders, a total of 31 judges were interviewed: 28 participants came from District Courts in Urban and Rural jurisdictions in Indonesia (17 from Urban Courts and 11 from Rural Courts) and three were Supreme Court judges. The findings highlight that the process of justice involves not merely the application of the rule of the law or relevant legal codes; rather, how the judiciary balance and interpret the law is a central part of court sentencing practice.
- 10 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 233-255
Reconceptualising Custody: Rights, Responsibilities and ‘Imagined Communities’
- 10 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 233-255
Reconceptualising Custody: Rights, Responsibilities and ‘Imagined Communities’
- 5 May 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 619-632
Social Networks: Impact on Teaching and Learning in Schools and Classrooms
- 5 May 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 619-632
Social Networks: Impact on Teaching and Learning in Schools and Classrooms
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Edinburgh University Press
- p. 1-16
Contexts and Complexities
Chapter 1 introduces the book with a brief description of the complex phenomena of human trafficking, highlighting the contested definitions that characterise it. Using the Mediterranean ‘migrant crisis’ of 2014/15 as a backdrop the chapter explores the way that terminology is used interchangeably to confuse the whole area of exploitation and focus on individualised perpetrators while largely ignoring the socio-economic conditions that permit the ‘trade’ in people to flourish. By examining the complex nature of human trafficking and the challenges of conceptualising it in terms of exploitation discourses, chapter one introduces the book’s focus on an examination of the appropriateness of current responses to victims/survivors and attempts to provide ‘holistic’ and ‘effective’ intervention. Within this analysis, the challenges that the wider socio-political sphere imposes on survivor care are examined.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Edinburgh University Press
- p. 1-16
Contexts and Complexities
Chapter 1 introduces the book with a brief description of the complex phenomena of human trafficking, highlighting the contested definitions that characterise it. Using the Mediterranean ‘migrant crisis’ of 2014/15 as a backdrop the chapter explores the way that terminology is used interchangeably to confuse the whole area of exploitation and focus on individualised perpetrators while largely ignoring the socio-economic conditions that permit the ‘trade’ in people to flourish. By examining the complex nature of human trafficking and the challenges of conceptualising it in terms of exploitation discourses, chapter one introduces the book’s focus on an examination of the appropriateness of current responses to victims/survivors and attempts to provide ‘holistic’ and ‘effective’ intervention. Within this analysis, the challenges that the wider socio-political sphere imposes on survivor care are examined.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Edinburgh University Press
- p. 175-193
Criminalising Victims of Human Trafficking: State Responses and Punitive Practices
International responses to trafficking in humans include a presumption against the prosecution of victims who commit crimes as a direct result of their victimisation. However, there is increasing international evidence that victims of trafficking continue to be detained or imprisoned in state institutions following ‘liberation’ from traffickers. This chapter examines the social, political and economic depiction of ‘deserving’ and ‘undeserving’ victims and the political basis for the criminalisation of certain victims of human trafficking. The broader questions that this raises in terms of appropriate responses to victims of human trafficking, and the limitations of effective survivor care, are considered.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by Edinburgh University Press
- p. 175-193
Criminalising Victims of Human Trafficking: State Responses and Punitive Practices
International responses to trafficking in humans include a presumption against the prosecution of victims who commit crimes as a direct result of their victimisation. However, there is increasing international evidence that victims of trafficking continue to be detained or imprisoned in state institutions following ‘liberation’ from traffickers. This chapter examines the social, political and economic depiction of ‘deserving’ and ‘undeserving’ victims and the political basis for the criminalisation of certain victims of human trafficking. The broader questions that this raises in terms of appropriate responses to victims of human trafficking, and the limitations of effective survivor care, are considered.
- 14 October 2015
- Published by Bristol University Press
- p. 59-78
A comparison: criminalised women in Scotland
Whilst the Corston report was focused upon the imprisonment of vulnerable women in England and Wales, the experiences of imprisoned women in Scotland have similarly been a cause for concern for policy makers, practitioners and academics over a period of more than 15 years, prompted initially by a series of suicides in the mid-1990s in Scotland’s only dedicated female prison. Despite the publication of a number of successive reports highlighting the need to limit the use of female imprisonment and make increased use of alternative, gender-appropriate community based services, the rate of female imprisonment has continued to rise, with more women being sent to prison for increasing periods of time. This chapter will provide an historical analysis of developments in policy, practice and research in relation to criminalized women in Scotland, starting with the publication of ‘A Safer way’ in 1998 and concluding with a reflection on the likely impact of the Commission on Women Offenders that was established by the Scottish Government and reported in 2012.
- 14 October 2015
- Published by Bristol University Press
- p. 59-78
A comparison: criminalised women in Scotland
Whilst the Corston report was focused upon the imprisonment of vulnerable women in England and Wales, the experiences of imprisoned women in Scotland have similarly been a cause for concern for policy makers, practitioners and academics over a period of more than 15 years, prompted initially by a series of suicides in the mid-1990s in Scotland’s only dedicated female prison. Despite the publication of a number of successive reports highlighting the need to limit the use of female imprisonment and make increased use of alternative, gender-appropriate community based services, the rate of female imprisonment has continued to rise, with more women being sent to prison for increasing periods of time. This chapter will provide an historical analysis of developments in policy, practice and research in relation to criminalized women in Scotland, starting with the publication of ‘A Safer way’ in 1998 and concluding with a reflection on the likely impact of the Commission on Women Offenders that was established by the Scottish Government and reported in 2012.