Tuomas Leisti
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Tuomas Leisti has a total of 54 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jenni Radun
Smart and Creative Cities Innovation Hub, Metropolia University of Applied Sciences, 00920 Helsinki, Finland
12 shared publications - Jukka Häkkinen
Department of Psychology and Logopedics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
12 shared publications Göte Nyman
Univ. of Helsinki (Finland)
10 shared publications- Toni Virtanen
Institute of Behavioural Sciences, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
9 shared publications Raisa Halonen
Helsinki Univ. of Technology (Finland)
6 shared publicationsPirkko Oittinen
Helsinki Univ. of Technology (Finland)
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Photographies
- Vol. 18 (2) , 297-317
Constructing knowledge within the photographic apparatus
- 4 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Photographies
- Vol. 18 (2) , 297-317
Open AccessConstructing knowledge within the photographic apparatus
- Open Access
- 21 June 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 867874
The Fewer Reasons, the More You Like It! How Decision-Making Heuristics of Image Quality Estimation Exploit the Content of Subjective Experience
Imaging science has approached subjective image quality (IQ) as a perceptual phenomenon, with an emphasis on thresholds of defects. The paradigmatic design of subjective IQ estimation, the two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) method, however, requires viewers to make decisions. We investigated decision strategies in three experiments both by asking the research participants to give reasons for their decisions and by examining the decision times. We found that typical for larger quality differences is a smaller set of subjective attributes, resulting from convergent attention toward the most salient attribute, leading to faster decisions and better accuracy. Smaller differences are characterized by divergent attention toward different attributes and an emphasis on preferential attributes instead of defects. In larger differences, attributes have sigmoidal relationships between their visibility and their occurrence in explanations. For other attributes, this relationship is more random. We also examined decision times in different attribute configurations to clarify the heuristics of IQ estimation, and we distinguished a top-down-oriented Take-the-Best heuristic and a bottom-up visual salience-based heuristic. In all experiments, heuristic one-reason decision-making endured as a prevailing strategy independent of quality difference or task.
- 21 June 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 13, 867874
Open AccessThe Fewer Reasons, the More You Like It! How Decision-Making Heuristics of Image Quality Estimation Exploit the Content of Subjective Experience
Imaging science has approached subjective image quality (IQ) as a perceptual phenomenon, with an emphasis on thresholds of defects. The paradigmatic design of subjective IQ estimation, the two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) method, however, requires viewers to make decisions. We investigated decision strategies in three experiments both by asking the research participants to give reasons for their decisions and by examining the decision times. We found that typical for larger quality differences is a smaller set of subjective attributes, resulting from convergent attention toward the most salient attribute, leading to faster decisions and better accuracy. Smaller differences are characterized by divergent attention toward different attributes and an emphasis on preferential attributes instead of defects. In larger differences, attributes have sigmoidal relationships between their visibility and their occurrence in explanations. For other attributes, this relationship is more random. We also examined decision times in different attribute configurations to clarify the heuristics of IQ estimation, and we distinguished a top-down-oriented Take-the-Best heuristic and a bottom-up visual salience-based heuristic. In all experiments, heuristic one-reason decision-making endured as a prevailing strategy independent of quality difference or task.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 31 (3) , 367-379
Learning to Decide with and without Reasoning: How Task Experience Affects Attribute Weighting and Preference Stability
Certain experiments have shown that reasoning may weaken the stability of people's preferences, especially with regard to well‐learned perceptual judgment and decision‐making tasks, while learning has an opposite, consistency‐enhancing effect on preferences. We examined the effects of these factors in a visual multi‐attribute decision‐making task where reasoning, in contrast, has been found to benefit judgments by making them more stable. The initial assumption in this study was that this benefit would be typical for novel tasks, like the one employed here, and that it would decrease when the task is thoroughly learned. This assumption was examined in three experiments by contrasting it with an alternative assumption that this previously obtained beneficial effect is caused solely by learning, not by reasoning. It was found that learning indeed makes preferences more stable by consolidating the weights of the attributes. Reasoning, however, does not benefit this task when it is completely novel but facilitates learning and stability of the preferences long run, therefore increasing the consistency of the participants in the macrolevel. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 4 December 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 31 (3) , 367-379
Open AccessLearning to Decide with and without Reasoning: How Task Experience Affects Attribute Weighting and Preference Stability
Certain experiments have shown that reasoning may weaken the stability of people's preferences, especially with regard to well‐learned perceptual judgment and decision‐making tasks, while learning has an opposite, consistency‐enhancing effect on preferences. We examined the effects of these factors in a visual multi‐attribute decision‐making task where reasoning, in contrast, has been found to benefit judgments by making them more stable. The initial assumption in this study was that this benefit would be typical for novel tasks, like the one employed here, and that it would decrease when the task is thoroughly learned. This assumption was examined in three experiments by contrasting it with an alternative assumption that this previously obtained beneficial effect is caused solely by learning, not by reasoning. It was found that learning indeed makes preferences more stable by consolidating the weights of the attributes. Reasoning, however, does not benefit this task when it is completely novel but facilitates learning and stability of the preferences long run, therefore increasing the consistency of the participants in the macrolevel. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2016
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Applied Perception
- Vol. 13 (3) , 1-22
Individual Differences in Image-Quality Estimations
Subjective image-quality estimation with high-quality images is often a preference-estimation task. Preferences are subjective, and individual differences exist. Individual differences are also seen in the eye movements of people. A task's subjectivity can result from people using different rules as a basis for their estimation. Using two studies, we investigated whether different preference-estimation rules are related to individual differences in viewing behaviour by examining the process of preference estimation of high-quality images. The estimation rules were measured from free subjective reports on important quality-related attributes (Study 1) and from estimations of the attributes’ importance in preference estimation (Study 2). The free reports showed that the observers used both feature-based image-quality attributes (e.g., sharpness, illumination) and abstract attributes, which include an interpretation of the image features (e.g., atmosphere and naturalness). In addition, the observers were classified into three viewing-strategy groups differing in fixation durations in both studies. These groups also used different estimation rules. In both studies, the group with medium-length fixations differed in their estimation rules from the other groups. In Study 1, the observers in this group used more abstract attributes than those in the other groups; in Study 2, they considered atmosphere to be a more important image feature. The study shows that individual differences in a quality-estimation task are related to both estimation rules and viewing strategies, and that the difference is related to the level of abstraction of the estimations.
- 28 May 2016
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Applied Perception
- Vol. 13 (3) , 1-22
Open AccessIndividual Differences in Image-Quality Estimations
Subjective image-quality estimation with high-quality images is often a preference-estimation task. Preferences are subjective, and individual differences exist. Individual differences are also seen in the eye movements of people. A task's subjectivity can result from people using different rules as a basis for their estimation. Using two studies, we investigated whether different preference-estimation rules are related to individual differences in viewing behaviour by examining the process of preference estimation of high-quality images. The estimation rules were measured from free subjective reports on important quality-related attributes (Study 1) and from estimations of the attributes’ importance in preference estimation (Study 2). The free reports showed that the observers used both feature-based image-quality attributes (e.g., sharpness, illumination) and abstract attributes, which include an interpretation of the image features (e.g., atmosphere and naturalness). In addition, the observers were classified into three viewing-strategy groups differing in fixation durations in both studies. These groups also used different estimation rules. In both studies, the group with medium-length fixations differed in their estimation rules from the other groups. In Study 1, the observers in this group used more abstract attributes than those in the other groups; in Study 2, they considered atmosphere to be a more important image feature. The study shows that individual differences in a quality-estimation task are related to both estimation rules and viewing strategies, and that the difference is related to the level of abstraction of the estimations.
- 1 May 2016
- Published by Elsevier in Consciousness and Cognition
- Vol. 42, 340-351
The effect of introspection on judgment and decision making is dependent on the quality of conscious thinking
- 1 May 2016
- Published by Elsevier in Consciousness and Cognition
- Vol. 42, 340-351
The effect of introspection on judgment and decision making is dependent on the quality of conscious thinking
- 8 February 2015
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 9396, 93960Q-93960Q-11
Alternative performance metrics and target values for the CID2013 database
- 8 February 2015
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 9396, 93960Q-93960Q-11
Alternative performance metrics and target values for the CID2013 database
- 23 December 2014
- Published by Springer Nature in Multimedia Tools and Applications
- Vol. 75 (4) , 2367-2391
A new method for evaluating the subjective image quality of photographs: dynamic reference
- 23 December 2014
- Published by Springer Nature in Multimedia Tools and Applications
- Vol. 75 (4) , 2367-2391
A new method for evaluating the subjective image quality of photographs: dynamic reference
- Open Access
- 7 August 2014
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Electronic Imaging
- Vol. 23 (06) , 1-14
Why is quality estimation judgment fast? Comparison of gaze control strategies in quality and difference estimation tasks
To understand the viewing strategies employed in a quality estimation task, we compared two visual tasks—quality estimation and difference estimation. The estimation was done for a pair of natural images having small global changes in quality. Two groups of observers estimated the same set of images, but with different instructions. One group estimated the difference in quality and the other the difference between image pairs. The results demonstrated the use of different visual strategies in the tasks. The quality estimation was found to include more visual planning during the first fixation than the difference estimation, but afterward needed only a few long fixations on the semantically important areas of the image. The difference estimation used many short fixations. Salient image areas were mainly attended to when these areas were also semantically important. The results support the hypothesis that these tasks’ general characteristics (evaluation time, number of fixations, area fixated on) show differences in processing, but also suggest that examining only single fixations when comparing tasks is too narrow a view. When planning a subjective experiment, one must remember that a small change in the instructions might lead to a noticeable change in viewing strategy.
- 7 August 2014
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Electronic Imaging
- Vol. 23 (06) , 1-14
Open AccessWhy is quality estimation judgment fast? Comparison of gaze control strategies in quality and difference estimation tasks
To understand the viewing strategies employed in a quality estimation task, we compared two visual tasks—quality estimation and difference estimation. The estimation was done for a pair of natural images having small global changes in quality. Two groups of observers estimated the same set of images, but with different instructions. One group estimated the difference in quality and the other the difference between image pairs. The results demonstrated the use of different visual strategies in the tasks. The quality estimation was found to include more visual planning during the first fixation than the difference estimation, but afterward needed only a few long fixations on the semantically important areas of the image. The difference estimation used many short fixations. Salient image areas were mainly attended to when these areas were also semantically important. The results support the hypothesis that these tasks’ general characteristics (evaluation time, number of fixations, area fixated on) show differences in processing, but also suggest that examining only single fixations when comparing tasks is too narrow a view. When planning a subjective experiment, one must remember that a small change in the instructions might lead to a noticeable change in viewing strategy.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Acta Psychologica
- Vol. 145, 65-74
Concurrent explanations can enhance visual decision making
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Acta Psychologica
- Vol. 145, 65-74
Concurrent explanations can enhance visual decision making
- 22 January 2012
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 8293, 82930M
How do we watch images? A case of change detection and quality estimation
The most common tasks in subjective image estimation are change detection (a detection task) and image quality estimation (a preference task). We examined how the task influences the gaze behavior when comparing detection and preference tasks. The eye movements of 16 naïve observers were recorded with 8 observers in both tasks. The setting was a flicker paradigm, where the observers see a non-manipulated image, a manipulated version of the image and again the non-manipulated image and estimate the difference they perceived in them. The material was photographic material with different image distortions and contents. To examine the spatial distribution of fixations, we defined the regions of interest using a memory task and calculated information entropy to estimate how concentrated the fixations were on the image plane. The quality task was faster and needed fewer fixations and the first eight fixations were more concentrated on certain image areas than the change detection task. The bottom-up influences of the image also caused more variation to the gaze behavior in the quality estimation task than in the change detection task The results show that the quality estimation is faster and the regions of interest are emphasized more on certain images compared with the change detection task that is a scan task where the whole image is always thoroughly examined. In conclusion, in subjective image estimation studies it is important to think about the task.
- 22 January 2012
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 8293, 82930M
How do we watch images? A case of change detection and quality estimation
The most common tasks in subjective image estimation are change detection (a detection task) and image quality estimation (a preference task). We examined how the task influences the gaze behavior when comparing detection and preference tasks. The eye movements of 16 naïve observers were recorded with 8 observers in both tasks. The setting was a flicker paradigm, where the observers see a non-manipulated image, a manipulated version of the image and again the non-manipulated image and estimate the difference they perceived in them. The material was photographic material with different image distortions and contents. To examine the spatial distribution of fixations, we defined the regions of interest using a memory task and calculated information entropy to estimate how concentrated the fixations were on the image plane. The quality task was faster and needed fewer fixations and the first eight fixations were more concentrated on certain image areas than the change detection task. The bottom-up influences of the image also caused more variation to the gaze behavior in the quality estimation task than in the change detection task The results show that the quality estimation is faster and the regions of interest are emphasized more on certain images compared with the change detection task that is a scan task where the whole image is always thoroughly examined. In conclusion, in subjective image estimation studies it is important to think about the task.