Tibor Papp
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tibor Papp has a total of 53 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
J. L. Campbell
Guelph-Waterloo Program for Graduate Work in Physics, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada N1G 2W1
10 shared publicationsJ. A. Maxwell
Cambridge Scientific, 175 Elizabeth Street, Guelph, ON, N1E 2X5, Canada
6 shared publicationsJ.L. Campbell
4 shared publicationsJ. Pálinkás
3 shared publicationsJ.A. Maxwell
Cambridge Scientific 3A‐47 Surrey Street East Guelph ON N1H 3P6 Canada
3 shared publicationsS. Raman
Physics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37831
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 4 April 2017
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 46 (5) , 367-373
Is a sufficient measure of the standard uncertainty in X‐ray spectroscopy?
There is a magnitude larger scatter in the experimental data of fundamental parameters than the claimed error estimate. We give examples from recent compilations of excitation and decay parameter values for the untenable large scatters, indicating methodological problems. One is the improper use of uncertainty estimation. The measured spectrum is not expected to follow Poisson distribution. We report proper statistical uncertainty calculations. It implies a two to five times larger uncertainty but still does not account for the large scatter. The other possible explanation could be rooted in the ill‐posed problem of exponential analysis, as radiation measurement belongs to this category. We give evidence from particle‐induced X‐ray emission and X‐ray fluorescence for additional exponential terms, thus leading to multi‐exponential analysis. This could explain the large scatter, as the usual square root of counts rule cannot be used for the standard uncertainty. We present a novel approach where discriminators are used to reduce the number of exponentials and the discriminated events are also processed and collected into a separate spectrum. Analyzing both spectra and the live time and dead time clocks allows the determination of the true input counts. It is a non‐extended dead time approach. With this approach, we have a much reduced statistical uncertainty, and both the total spectrum and the fractional spectrum have the same uncertainty. As an independent quality assurance tool, the time interval histogram analysis is also presented. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 4 April 2017
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 46 (5) , 367-373
Is a sufficient measure of the standard uncertainty in X‐ray spectroscopy?
There is a magnitude larger scatter in the experimental data of fundamental parameters than the claimed error estimate. We give examples from recent compilations of excitation and decay parameter values for the untenable large scatters, indicating methodological problems. One is the improper use of uncertainty estimation. The measured spectrum is not expected to follow Poisson distribution. We report proper statistical uncertainty calculations. It implies a two to five times larger uncertainty but still does not account for the large scatter. The other possible explanation could be rooted in the ill‐posed problem of exponential analysis, as radiation measurement belongs to this category. We give evidence from particle‐induced X‐ray emission and X‐ray fluorescence for additional exponential terms, thus leading to multi‐exponential analysis. This could explain the large scatter, as the usual square root of counts rule cannot be used for the standard uncertainty. We present a novel approach where discriminators are used to reduce the number of exponentials and the discriminated events are also processed and collected into a separate spectrum. Analyzing both spectra and the live time and dead time clocks allows the determination of the true input counts. It is a non‐extended dead time approach. With this approach, we have a much reduced statistical uncertainty, and both the total spectrum and the fractional spectrum have the same uncertainty. As an independent quality assurance tool, the time interval histogram analysis is also presented. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Scitechnol Biosoft Pvt. Ltd. in Journal of Scientific and Industrial Metrology
- Vol. 01 (02)
Radiation Measurements without Posing the Inversion Problem
Purpose: Radiation measurement is an exponential analysis, which is an “illposed” problem, where the solution is not unique. Therefore, the accuracy of data points is critical. If the radiation detector is sensitive during the dead time, usually an extended dead time signal processing method is necessary and the calculation of the dead time and pile up rate invoke the inversion problem, which is difficult to solve, and only approximated. We have used two new approaches, where the inversion problem is not posed, and there is no need to assume the Poisson distribution or constant source strength. It goes beyond all previous techniques by handling the presence of discriminators. The preamplifier-signal processing chain has dead times and applies discriminators, as a consequence disturbs the randomness, and other distributions may also contribute. Although an undisturbed nuclear decay should be Poisson in nature, the measured spectrum usually does not have a Poisson distribution. The robustness of the two methods was investigated, focusing on the traceable derivation of statistical uncertainty. The two new methods were applied in gamma spectra measurements of 152Eu calibration sources, and nuclear half-life of 68Ga PET isotope, and compared with measurements using previous techniques. Methods: CSX (Cambridge Scientific) digital signal processors were used with five HPGe detectors in two operation modes in two measurement series. In quality assurance mode, the CSX processes all events, both the accepted and rejected ones, placing each event into one or more spectra based on the applied discriminators. Based on the accepted spectrum, the rejected spectra were analyzed to determine the single, double and triple events, the rate of unrelated, and noise events all to obtain the true input counts. The second and independent approach was a time interval histogram analysis for the measurement of the gamma ray intensities. In time interval histogram mode, the CSX creates an energy spectrum as well as an interval histogram of arrival times between successive events. This operation mode does not apply discriminators and has no dead time. The CSX signal processor was selected, as it offers a dead time free and less than 1% pile up rate up to about a million counts per second input rate, as well as quality assurance at the signal processing level. Results: The CSX processors employ a non-extended dead time approach and in quality assurance mode the true input rate is readily determined. As a consequence, the inversion problem was avoided. The uncertainties and uncertainty propagation are clearly justified. For the half-life measurement of 68Ga, the time interval histogram analysis gave six times smaller standard uncertainty than the square root of the counts. The inter-arrival time histogram was sensitive to non-deterministic behaviour of the detectors, and electronic disturbances, discrediting several measurement series. This additional ability is significant for quality measurements. Conclusion: Spectroscopy with HPGe detectors has lacked a method to credibly determine the uncertainties when discrimination is applied. In addition, a calibration procedure was required to establish the output rate versus input rate relations for each input rate preferably with a similar spectral distribution as the spectrum of interest. The preamplifier signal shape varied as a function of the input rate for each of the HPGe detectors studied. In such cases both the accepted and rejected event spectra are necessary for a proper evaluation. Accounting for all the events allows the determination of the uncertainties. The time interval histogram analysis is simple and straightforward, and offers an elegant way to determine the true input rate and uncertainty. The measurement can be applied over large input counting ranges, and does not require calibration.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Scitechnol Biosoft Pvt. Ltd. in Journal of Scientific and Industrial Metrology
- Vol. 01 (02)
Open AccessRadiation Measurements without Posing the Inversion Problem
Purpose: Radiation measurement is an exponential analysis, which is an “illposed” problem, where the solution is not unique. Therefore, the accuracy of data points is critical. If the radiation detector is sensitive during the dead time, usually an extended dead time signal processing method is necessary and the calculation of the dead time and pile up rate invoke the inversion problem, which is difficult to solve, and only approximated. We have used two new approaches, where the inversion problem is not posed, and there is no need to assume the Poisson distribution or constant source strength. It goes beyond all previous techniques by handling the presence of discriminators. The preamplifier-signal processing chain has dead times and applies discriminators, as a consequence disturbs the randomness, and other distributions may also contribute. Although an undisturbed nuclear decay should be Poisson in nature, the measured spectrum usually does not have a Poisson distribution. The robustness of the two methods was investigated, focusing on the traceable derivation of statistical uncertainty. The two new methods were applied in gamma spectra measurements of 152Eu calibration sources, and nuclear half-life of 68Ga PET isotope, and compared with measurements using previous techniques. Methods: CSX (Cambridge Scientific) digital signal processors were used with five HPGe detectors in two operation modes in two measurement series. In quality assurance mode, the CSX processes all events, both the accepted and rejected ones, placing each event into one or more spectra based on the applied discriminators. Based on the accepted spectrum, the rejected spectra were analyzed to determine the single, double and triple events, the rate of unrelated, and noise events all to obtain the true input counts. The second and independent approach was a time interval histogram analysis for the measurement of the gamma ray intensities. In time interval histogram mode, the CSX creates an energy spectrum as well as an interval histogram of arrival times between successive events. This operation mode does not apply discriminators and has no dead time. The CSX signal processor was selected, as it offers a dead time free and less than 1% pile up rate up to about a million counts per second input rate, as well as quality assurance at the signal processing level. Results: The CSX processors employ a non-extended dead time approach and in quality assurance mode the true input rate is readily determined. As a consequence, the inversion problem was avoided. The uncertainties and uncertainty propagation are clearly justified. For the half-life measurement of 68Ga, the time interval histogram analysis gave six times smaller standard uncertainty than the square root of the counts. The inter-arrival time histogram was sensitive to non-deterministic behaviour of the detectors, and electronic disturbances, discrediting several measurement series. This additional ability is significant for quality measurements. Conclusion: Spectroscopy with HPGe detectors has lacked a method to credibly determine the uncertainties when discrimination is applied. In addition, a calibration procedure was required to establish the output rate versus input rate relations for each input rate preferably with a similar spectral distribution as the spectrum of interest. The preamplifier signal shape varied as a function of the input rate for each of the HPGe detectors studied. In such cases both the accepted and rejected event spectra are necessary for a proper evaluation. Accounting for all the events allows the determination of the uncertainties. The time interval histogram analysis is simple and straightforward, and offers an elegant way to determine the true input rate and uncertainty. The measurement can be applied over large input counting ranges, and does not require calibration.
- 23 January 2012
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 41 (3) , 128-132
A critical analysis of the experimental L‐shell Coster–Kronig and fluorescence yields data
A critical analysis of the methods used to determine the L‐shell Coster–Kronig and fluorescence yield data are given. The collected data sets have a large scatter, indicating methodological issues. The K α ‐L coincidence technique and the synchrotron ionization methods are analyzed in detail, and it is demonstrated that both methods have unrecognized systematic errors. It is emphasized that the synchrotron measurements clearly show deviations from the exclusively used exponential form of the energy dependence of the photoionization cross‐section. Thus, the far‐range extrapolation introduces an error, which magnitude is difficult to assess. Comment on the use of polarization‐sensitive devices to detect polarized X‐ray is offered. New strategies are recommended for the measurement of these parameters. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 23 January 2012
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 41 (3) , 128-132
A critical analysis of the experimental L‐shell Coster–Kronig and fluorescence yields data
A critical analysis of the methods used to determine the L‐shell Coster–Kronig and fluorescence yield data are given. The collected data sets have a large scatter, indicating methodological issues. The K α ‐L coincidence technique and the synchrotron ionization methods are analyzed in detail, and it is demonstrated that both methods have unrecognized systematic errors. It is emphasized that the synchrotron measurements clearly show deviations from the exclusively used exponential form of the energy dependence of the photoionization cross‐section. Thus, the far‐range extrapolation introduces an error, which magnitude is difficult to assess. Comment on the use of polarization‐sensitive devices to detect polarized X‐ray is offered. New strategies are recommended for the measurement of these parameters. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 28 October 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Radiation and Isotopes
- Vol. 68 (4) , 561-565
The necessity of recognizing all events in X-ray detection
- 28 October 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Radiation and Isotopes
- Vol. 68 (4) , 561-565
The necessity of recognizing all events in X-ray detection
- 1 August 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy
- Vol. 64 (8) , 761-770
A maximum information utilization approach in X-ray fluorescence analysis
- 1 August 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy
- Vol. 64 (8) , 761-770
A maximum information utilization approach in X-ray fluorescence analysis
- 16 March 2009
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 38 (3) , 210-215
The necessity of maximum information utilization in x‐ray analysis
There are significant discrepancies in the experimental data needed in the analysis of x‐ray spectra. Examination of the data in detail shows that they often contradict simple logic, elemental arithmetic, even parity and angular momentum conservation laws. We have identified that the main source of the problems, other than the human factor, is rooted in the signal processing electronics. We have developed a line of fully digital signal processors that not only have excellent resolution and line shape but also allow proper accounting. We achieve this by processing all events and separating them into two or more spectra where the first spectrum is the accepted or good spectrum and the second spectrum is the rejected spectrum. It is not enough to know that an event was rejected, and increment the input counter—it is necessary to know what happened and why, whether it was pure noise, a noisy or disturbed event, a true event, or any pile up combination of the above in order to account properly for true event input rate and processor dead time. The data processing methodology cannot be reliably established on the partial and fractional information offered by other approaches. The availability of all the events allows one to see the other part of the spectrum. To our surprise the total information explains many of the shortcomings and contradictions of the x‐ray database. We call this a maximum information utilization approach in signal processing. Also a fundamental parameter x‐ray fluorescence analysis program (CSX‐XRF) has been developed to utilize all the information offered by the signal processor. The fundamental parameter method is only as good as the database it uses and the description of the x‐ray fluorescence analysis system. This latter poses significant difficulties, and to ease the demand we have developed an inverse fundamental parameter program package for x‐ray tube based equipment characterization. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 16 March 2009
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 38 (3) , 210-215
The necessity of maximum information utilization in x‐ray analysis
There are significant discrepancies in the experimental data needed in the analysis of x‐ray spectra. Examination of the data in detail shows that they often contradict simple logic, elemental arithmetic, even parity and angular momentum conservation laws. We have identified that the main source of the problems, other than the human factor, is rooted in the signal processing electronics. We have developed a line of fully digital signal processors that not only have excellent resolution and line shape but also allow proper accounting. We achieve this by processing all events and separating them into two or more spectra where the first spectrum is the accepted or good spectrum and the second spectrum is the rejected spectrum. It is not enough to know that an event was rejected, and increment the input counter—it is necessary to know what happened and why, whether it was pure noise, a noisy or disturbed event, a true event, or any pile up combination of the above in order to account properly for true event input rate and processor dead time. The data processing methodology cannot be reliably established on the partial and fractional information offered by other approaches. The availability of all the events allows one to see the other part of the spectrum. To our surprise the total information explains many of the shortcomings and contradictions of the x‐ray database. We call this a maximum information utilization approach in signal processing. Also a fundamental parameter x‐ray fluorescence analysis program (CSX‐XRF) has been developed to utilize all the information offered by the signal processor. The fundamental parameter method is only as good as the database it uses and the description of the x‐ray fluorescence analysis system. This latter poses significant difficulties, and to ease the demand we have developed an inverse fundamental parameter program package for x‐ray tube based equipment characterization. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- Open Access
- 12 July 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Analytical Sciences
- Vol. 21 (7) , 737-745
Quality Assurance Challenges in X-ray Emission Based Analyses, the Advantage of Digital Signal Processing
There is a large scatter in the results of X-ray analysis with solid-state detectors suggesting methodological origin. In order to improve the methodology, detector response functions have been investigated by many researchers and analysts. This was necessary as the departure of the response function of some detector-signal processing electronics from the normally assumed Gaussian line shape can exceed 100% in area. Several detector models have been proposed to improve understanding and establish a firm basis for quantitative work. After reviewing some contradictory results, we describe a signal processor that offers quality assurance, by producing two spectra for each measurement. One is the normal spectrum of accepted events, while the second spectrum contains all of the rejected events. For each measurement, therefore, all X-ray events are recorded, enabling quality control. In addition to this improvement, the digital signal processor of Cambridge Scientific, Canada, delivers a high throughput rate, excellent resolution, decreased low energy tailing and a line shape justified by the physics of the detector. Comparative measurements are presented to demonstrate the improved rejection of background from gamma rays as well as a significant improvement in pile-up recognition. The rejected events spectrum gives insight into the origin of the response function, which suggests that the flat plateau of the frequently used Hypermet function, normally attributed to detector dead layers, originates from pile-up with the low energy noise events. A detailed analysis demonstrates how the relative intensities of the X-ray lines can change in a varying noise environment, thus potentially explaining the unacceptable large scatter in the experimental data currently found in the literature. The comparison of the accepted and rejected events adds the possibility of monitoring the electronic efficiency of signal recognition that has generally been ignored in this field.
- 12 July 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Analytical Sciences
- Vol. 21 (7) , 737-745
Open AccessQuality Assurance Challenges in X-ray Emission Based Analyses, the Advantage of Digital Signal Processing
There is a large scatter in the results of X-ray analysis with solid-state detectors suggesting methodological origin. In order to improve the methodology, detector response functions have been investigated by many researchers and analysts. This was necessary as the departure of the response function of some detector-signal processing electronics from the normally assumed Gaussian line shape can exceed 100% in area. Several detector models have been proposed to improve understanding and establish a firm basis for quantitative work. After reviewing some contradictory results, we describe a signal processor that offers quality assurance, by producing two spectra for each measurement. One is the normal spectrum of accepted events, while the second spectrum contains all of the rejected events. For each measurement, therefore, all X-ray events are recorded, enabling quality control. In addition to this improvement, the digital signal processor of Cambridge Scientific, Canada, delivers a high throughput rate, excellent resolution, decreased low energy tailing and a line shape justified by the physics of the detector. Comparative measurements are presented to demonstrate the improved rejection of background from gamma rays as well as a significant improvement in pile-up recognition. The rejected events spectrum gives insight into the origin of the response function, which suggests that the flat plateau of the frequently used Hypermet function, normally attributed to detector dead layers, originates from pile-up with the low energy noise events. A detailed analysis demonstrates how the relative intensities of the X-ray lines can change in a varying noise environment, thus potentially explaining the unacceptable large scatter in the experimental data currently found in the literature. The comparison of the accepted and rejected events adds the possibility of monitoring the electronic efficiency of signal recognition that has generally been ignored in this field.
- 13 September 2004
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 34 (2) , 106-111
A new approach to the determination of the Fano factor for semiconductor detectors
Values of the Fano factor are widely scattered in the literature, indicating the difficulties in its determination. We chose to analyze both the escape peaks and parent peaks of Ge detector spectra where the parent peak penetration depth and the escape peak escape depth are much larger than the size of the incomplete charge collection region. Hence, the escape peaks are expected to be free of low‐energy tailing as, although the actually deposited energy is low, it is deposited beyond the incomplete charge collection region. It was found that the product of electron–hole pair creation energy (ε) and the Fano factor ( F ) has an energy dependence at low energies, as is expected from electron transport theories. Although ε is expected to have its own energy dependence, if a reference value of 2.96 eV is assumed for ε, then the Fano factor values varied between 0.059 and 0.083. The escape peak is less advantageous for Si, hence a different method was used for Si(Li) detectors. Assuming the reference value of 3.8 eV for ε, the Fano factor was found to be 0.063 at 5.9 keV x‐ray energy. We consider the Fano factors reported here as upper limits, rather than the mean values. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 13 September 2004
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 34 (2) , 106-111
A new approach to the determination of the Fano factor for semiconductor detectors
Values of the Fano factor are widely scattered in the literature, indicating the difficulties in its determination. We chose to analyze both the escape peaks and parent peaks of Ge detector spectra where the parent peak penetration depth and the escape peak escape depth are much larger than the size of the incomplete charge collection region. Hence, the escape peaks are expected to be free of low‐energy tailing as, although the actually deposited energy is low, it is deposited beyond the incomplete charge collection region. It was found that the product of electron–hole pair creation energy (ε) and the Fano factor ( F ) has an energy dependence at low energies, as is expected from electron transport theories. Although ε is expected to have its own energy dependence, if a reference value of 2.96 eV is assumed for ε, then the Fano factor values varied between 0.059 and 0.083. The escape peak is less advantageous for Si, hence a different method was used for Si(Li) detectors. Assuming the reference value of 3.8 eV for ε, the Fano factor was found to be 0.063 at 5.9 keV x‐ray energy. We consider the Fano factors reported here as upper limits, rather than the mean values. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 1 June 2004
- Published by Elsevier in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms
- Vol. 219-220, 503-507
On the role of the signal processing electronics in X-ray analytical measurements
- 1 June 2004
- Published by Elsevier in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms
- Vol. 219-220, 503-507
On the role of the signal processing electronics in X-ray analytical measurements
- 7 October 2003
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 32 (6) , 458-469
On the response function of solid‐state detectors, based on energetic electron transport processes
In studies of the response function of state‐of‐the‐art Si(Li) and HPGe detectors to low‐energy (2–20 keV) mono‐energetic x‐rays, various characteristic features have been observed. To trace their origin we have studied the effect of the signal processing electronics on the evolution of the electronic signal, and measured the spectral shape of energetic electrons originating from the surfaces of Si and Ge crystals and front contact materials, using a high‐energy range electrostatic electron spectrometer. From the measured electron spectra leaving the surfaces of the detector and front contact materials, and from the details of electron transport processes, the origin of the distinct features is identified and an approximate analytical form for the representation of the detector response function has been derived. It gives an excellent description of the response function and may replace the frequently applied Hypermet function. On the basis of this study, an explanation is given of the origin of the exponential tail and other various discrete structures on the low‐energy side of the primary peak. The difference in low‐energy side tailing between Si and HPGe detectors is explored. A detailed analysis of the so‐called dead layer concept is given. Characteristic structures, ‘kinks’, are predicted in the spectra measured by solid‐state detectors. Copyright © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 7 October 2003
- Published by Wiley in X-Ray Spectrometry
- Vol. 32 (6) , 458-469
On the response function of solid‐state detectors, based on energetic electron transport processes
In studies of the response function of state‐of‐the‐art Si(Li) and HPGe detectors to low‐energy (2–20 keV) mono‐energetic x‐rays, various characteristic features have been observed. To trace their origin we have studied the effect of the signal processing electronics on the evolution of the electronic signal, and measured the spectral shape of energetic electrons originating from the surfaces of Si and Ge crystals and front contact materials, using a high‐energy range electrostatic electron spectrometer. From the measured electron spectra leaving the surfaces of the detector and front contact materials, and from the details of electron transport processes, the origin of the distinct features is identified and an approximate analytical form for the representation of the detector response function has been derived. It gives an excellent description of the response function and may replace the frequently applied Hypermet function. On the basis of this study, an explanation is given of the origin of the exponential tail and other various discrete structures on the low‐energy side of the primary peak. The difference in low‐energy side tailing between Si and HPGe detectors is explored. A detailed analysis of the so‐called dead layer concept is given. Characteristic structures, ‘kinks’, are predicted in the spectra measured by solid‐state detectors. Copyright © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.