AKAsaf Karagila

Asaf Karagila

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Asaf Karagila has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Critical embeddings

    by Asaf Karagila, Jiachen Yuan

    Hayut and the first author isolated the notion of a critical cardinal in [1]. In this work, we answer several questions raised in the original paper. We show that it is consistent for a critical cardinal not to have any ultrapower elementary embeddings, as well as that it is consistent that no target model is closed. We also prove that if $$\kappa $$ κ is a critical point by any ultrapower embedding, then it is the critical point of an ultrapower embedding by a normal measure. The paper concludes by presenting several open questions of interest in the study of critical cardinals.

  • Open Access

    Small measurable cardinals

    by Yair Hayut, Asaf Karagila

    We continue the work from [8] and make a small—but significant—improvement to the definition of j -decomposable system. This provides us with a better lifting of elementary embeddings to symmetric extensions. In particular, this allows us to more easily lift weakly compact embeddings and thus preserve the notion of weakly critical cardinals. We use this improved lifting criterion to show that the first measurable cardinal can be the first weakly critical cardinal or the first Mahlo cardinal, both relative to the existence of a single measurable cardinal. However, if the first inaccessible cardinal is the first measurable cardinal, then in a suitable inner model it has Mitchell order of at least 2.


  • Intermediate models and Kinna–Wagner Principles

    by Asaf Karagila, Jonathan Schilhan

    Kinna–Wagner Principles state that every set can be mapped into some fixed iterated power set of an ordinal, and we write K W P \mathsf {KWP} to denote that there is some α \alpha for which this holds. The Kinna–Wagner Conjecture, formulated by the first author [Bull. Symb. Log., arXiv:2006.04514], states that if V V is a model of Z F + K W P \mathsf {ZF}+\mathsf {KWP} and G G is a V V -generic filter, then whenever W W is an intermediate model of Z F \mathsf {ZF} , that is V ⊆ W ⊆ V [ G ] V\subseteq W\subseteq V[G] , then W = V ( x ) W=V(x) for some x x if and only if W W satisfies K W P \mathsf {KWP} . In this work we prove the conjecture and generalise it even further. We include a brief historical overview of Kinna–Wagner Principles and new results about Kinna–Wagner Principles in the multiverse of sets.


  • Open Access

    APPROACHING A BRISTOL MODEL

    by Asaf Karagila

    The Bristol model is an inner model of $L[c]$ , where c is a Cohen real, which is not constructible from a set. The idea was developed in 2011 in a workshop taking place in Bristol, but was only written in detail by the author in [8]. This article is a guide for those who want to get a broader view of the construction. We try to provide more intuition that might serve as a jumping board for those interested in this construction and in odd models of $\mathsf {ZF}$ . We also correct a few minor issues in the original paper, as well as prove new results. For example, the Boolean Prime Ideal theorem fails in the Bristol model, as some sets cannot be linearly ordered, and the ground model is always definable in its Bristol extensions. In addition to this we include a discussion on Kinna–Wagner Principles, which we think may play an important role in understanding the generic multiverse in $\mathsf {ZF}$ .


  • Open Access

    The $κ$-Strongly Proper Forcing Axiom

    by David Asperó, Sean Cox, Asaf Karagila, Christoph Weiss

    We study methods to obtain the consistency of forcing axioms, and particularly higher forcing axioms. We first force over a model with a supercompact cardinal $\theta>\kappa$ to get the consistency of the forcing axiom for $\kappa$-strongly proper forcing notions which are also $\kappa$-lattice, and then eliminate the need for large cardinals. The proof goes through a natural reflection property for $\kappa$-strongly proper forcings. We also produce a model of this forcing axiom with $2^\kappa$ arbitrarily large, and prove the inconsistency of certain natural strengthenings of the axiom.

  • Open Access

    Geometric Condition For Dependent Choice

    by A. Karagila, J. Schilhan


  • Open Access

    Critical embeddings

    by Asaf Karagila, Jiachen Yuan

    Hayut and first author isolated the notion of a critical cardinal in [1]. In this work we answer several questions raised in the original paper. We show that it is consistent for a critical cardinals to not have any ultrapower elementary embeddings, as well as that it is consistent that no target model is closed. We also prove that if $κ$ is a critical point by any ultrapower embedding, then it is the critical point by a normal ultrapower embedding. The paper contains several open questions of interest in the study of critical cardinals.

  • Which pairs of cardinals can be Hartogs and Lindenbaum numbers of a set?

    by Asaf Karagila, Calliope Ryan-Smith

    Given any $\lambda \leq \kappa $, we construct a symmetric extension in which there is a set $X$ such that $\aleph (X)=\lambda $ and $\aleph ^*(X)=\kappa $. Consequently, we show that $\mathsf{ZF} {}+{}$“for all pairs of infinite cardinals $\lambda \leq \


  • Open Access

    Hilbert Spaces Without Countable AC

    by Bruce Blackadar, Ilijas Farah, Asaf Karagila

    This article examines Hilbert spaces constructed from sets whose existence is incompatible with the Countable Axiom of Choice (CC). Our point of view is twofold: (1) We examine what can and cannot be said about Hilbert spaces and operators on them in ZF set theory without any assumptions of Choice axioms, even the CC. (2) We view Hilbert spaces as ``quantized'' sets and obtain some set-theoretic results from associated Hilbert spaces.

  • Open Access

    Geometric condition for Dependent Choice

    by Asaf Karagila, Jonathan Schilhan

    We provide a geometric condition which characterises when the Principle of Dependent Choice holds in a Fraenkel--Mostowski--Specker permutation model. This condition is a slight weakening of requiring the filter of groups to be closed under countable intersections. We show that this condition holds nontrivially in a new permutation model we call "the nowhere dense model" and we study its extensions to uncountable cardinals as well.