Nicole G. Lunning
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Nicole G. Lunning has a total of 134 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Robert J. Bodnar
Department of Geosciences Virginia Tech Blacksburg Virginia 24061 USA
6 shared publicationsHarry Y. McSween
5 shared publications- Dante S. Lauretta
Lunar and Planetary Laboratory University of Arizona Tucson Arizona USA
4 shared publications Catherine M. Corrigan
3 shared publications- Francis M. McCubbin
NASA Johnson Space Center Houston Texas USA
3 shared publications - Harold. C. Connolly
Lunar and Planetary Laboratory University of Arizona Tucson Arizona USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
Diverse lithologies in Bennu stones revealed using X‐ray computed tomography under pristine conditions
The OSIRIS‐REx mission collected a 121.6 g regolith sample from the surface of asteroid Bennu. Preliminary examination (PE) was conducted jointly by JSC Curation and the OSIRIS‐REx Sample Analysis Team. To enable advanced, non‐destructive characterization during PE, 59 centimeter‐scale stones were individually scanned using X‐ray computed tomography (XCT) inside custom‐built containers to preserve their pristine condition. The XCT data provide three‐dimensional petrographic context that supports PE, sample processing and allocation, and subsequent scientific investigations. We analyzed 14.46% ± 0.03% (17.585 ± 0.038 g) of the total returned sample mass and document extensive lithologic diversity within the collection. The samples are divided into two primary groups, monolithic and clastic, which are further subdivided into nine lithological categories. Using XCT‐derived volumes combined with measured masses, we find that the monolithic group is denser than the clastic group, and some monolithic lithologies exhibit statistically higher average densities, likely reflecting differences in composition and/or internal structure. Shape, quantified using orthogonal caliper measurements and Sneed & Folk and Zingg classifications, does not systematically correspond to lithology. The monolithic‐dark‐veined lithology is an exception, exhibiting consistently flat, bladed shapes. Correspondence between stone morphology, defined as hummocky, angular, or mottled, and lithology varies. Using X‐ray attenuation contrast in conjunction with prior petrographic and compositional studies, we identify veins, large carbonates, candidate chondrules, coarse‐grained pyrrhotite assemblages, ~25 μm long highly‐X‐ray‐attenuating phases that possibly contain platinum group elements and surface micro‐impact craters. These results provide a three‐dimensional petrographic framework for continued characterization of the returned sample and for deciphering Bennu's origin and geological history.
- 8 November 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
Open AccessDiverse lithologies in Bennu stones revealed using X‐ray computed tomography under pristine conditions
The OSIRIS‐REx mission collected a 121.6 g regolith sample from the surface of asteroid Bennu. Preliminary examination (PE) was conducted jointly by JSC Curation and the OSIRIS‐REx Sample Analysis Team. To enable advanced, non‐destructive characterization during PE, 59 centimeter‐scale stones were individually scanned using X‐ray computed tomography (XCT) inside custom‐built containers to preserve their pristine condition. The XCT data provide three‐dimensional petrographic context that supports PE, sample processing and allocation, and subsequent scientific investigations. We analyzed 14.46% ± 0.03% (17.585 ± 0.038 g) of the total returned sample mass and document extensive lithologic diversity within the collection. The samples are divided into two primary groups, monolithic and clastic, which are further subdivided into nine lithological categories. Using XCT‐derived volumes combined with measured masses, we find that the monolithic group is denser than the clastic group, and some monolithic lithologies exhibit statistically higher average densities, likely reflecting differences in composition and/or internal structure. Shape, quantified using orthogonal caliper measurements and Sneed & Folk and Zingg classifications, does not systematically correspond to lithology. The monolithic‐dark‐veined lithology is an exception, exhibiting consistently flat, bladed shapes. Correspondence between stone morphology, defined as hummocky, angular, or mottled, and lithology varies. Using X‐ray attenuation contrast in conjunction with prior petrographic and compositional studies, we identify veins, large carbonates, candidate chondrules, coarse‐grained pyrrhotite assemblages, ~25 μm long highly‐X‐ray‐attenuating phases that possibly contain platinum group elements and surface micro‐impact craters. These results provide a three‐dimensional petrographic framework for continued characterization of the returned sample and for deciphering Bennu's origin and geological history.
- Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
Post‐flight assessment of the OSIRIS ‐ REx Sample Return Capsule ( SRC ) for organic and other potential contaminants
Regolith samples from the carbonaceous asteroid Bennu were stowed and delivered to Earth in the OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft's Sample Return Capsule (SRC). We applied multiple analytical techniques to study the components of the post‐flight SRC, with a focus on assessing the conditions and any contaminants to which the Bennu samples were exposed. Examination of the passive temperature sensors placed inside the SRC, in combination with thermal modeling results, indicate that the samples were not heated above the 75°C limit imposed by OSIRIS‐REx mission requirements. The sample canister air filter was found to contain Bennu particulates that had escaped from the sample collector, as well as a range of contaminants likely associated with the original filter component materials. No indications of terrestrial soils were found in the filter. Isotopic analyses of organic compounds and noble gases trapped in the filter show values consistent with terrestrial origins, and there are no indications of trapped asteroidal volatiles. Organic compounds found in the flight filter that were not present in a non‐flight control filter include aromatic hydrocarbons, alkylated aromatic hydrocarbons, phenolic‐related compounds, aliphatic hydrocarbons, and alcohols. The abundances of these organic compounds typically decrease from outer layers of the filter toward the canister interior, suggesting that they are external contaminants. We conclude that the majority of these organic compounds are chemical byproducts associated with outgassing of the SRC heatshield and backshell following the ablation portion of SRC atmospheric entry. Overall, our findings show that the OSIRIS‐REx SRC performed excellently in containerizing the asteroidal samples obtained at Bennu, delivering them safely to the ground at the UTTR, and preventing most, though perhaps not all, external contaminants from reaching them. We discuss lessons learned from the flight and recovery of the OSIRIS‐REx SRC that can benefit future sample return missions.
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
Open AccessPost‐flight assessment of the OSIRIS ‐ REx Sample Return Capsule ( SRC ) for organic and other potential contaminants
Regolith samples from the carbonaceous asteroid Bennu were stowed and delivered to Earth in the OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft's Sample Return Capsule (SRC). We applied multiple analytical techniques to study the components of the post‐flight SRC, with a focus on assessing the conditions and any contaminants to which the Bennu samples were exposed. Examination of the passive temperature sensors placed inside the SRC, in combination with thermal modeling results, indicate that the samples were not heated above the 75°C limit imposed by OSIRIS‐REx mission requirements. The sample canister air filter was found to contain Bennu particulates that had escaped from the sample collector, as well as a range of contaminants likely associated with the original filter component materials. No indications of terrestrial soils were found in the filter. Isotopic analyses of organic compounds and noble gases trapped in the filter show values consistent with terrestrial origins, and there are no indications of trapped asteroidal volatiles. Organic compounds found in the flight filter that were not present in a non‐flight control filter include aromatic hydrocarbons, alkylated aromatic hydrocarbons, phenolic‐related compounds, aliphatic hydrocarbons, and alcohols. The abundances of these organic compounds typically decrease from outer layers of the filter toward the canister interior, suggesting that they are external contaminants. We conclude that the majority of these organic compounds are chemical byproducts associated with outgassing of the SRC heatshield and backshell following the ablation portion of SRC atmospheric entry. Overall, our findings show that the OSIRIS‐REx SRC performed excellently in containerizing the asteroidal samples obtained at Bennu, delivering them safely to the ground at the UTTR, and preventing most, though perhaps not all, external contaminants from reaching them. We discuss lessons learned from the flight and recovery of the OSIRIS‐REx SRC that can benefit future sample return missions.
- Open Access
- 5 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (8) , 1788-1805
Visible, near‐, and thermal infrared spectra of asteroid Bennu samples: Relationship to and implications for remote sensing of carbonaceous asteroids
Remote spectroscopy is used to characterize the mineralogy and infer the history of planetary bodies. Carbonaceous asteroids, such as B‐type (101955) Bennu, represent the earliest stages of planet formation. B types have a blue (negative) spectral slope and comprise <5% of asteroids. Samples from Bennu returned by the OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft complement remote observations of this rare population. We show here, using laboratory spectra that are directly comparable to spacecraft data, that OSIRIS‐REx accurately determined Bennu's dust content and most of its surface composition. However, spectra of the asteroid exhibit stronger water absorptions than those of bulk samples, possibly due to hydrous, Mg‐rich phosphate or solar wind implantation at Bennu's uppermost surface. Bennu samples spectrally resemble the most aqueously altered carbonaceous meteorites and samples of (162173) Ryugu, indicating similarly pervasive aqueous alteration. However, one carbon‐enriched Bennu stone does not appear to have a spectral analog among Ryugu samples or meteorites. Our findings demonstrate the leverage obtained using a wide range of wavelengths and that sample analysis anchors the interpretations of remote sensing, leading to more robust characterization of planetary surface composition and evolution.
- 5 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (8) , 1788-1805
Open AccessVisible, near‐, and thermal infrared spectra of asteroid Bennu samples: Relationship to and implications for remote sensing of carbonaceous asteroids
Remote spectroscopy is used to characterize the mineralogy and infer the history of planetary bodies. Carbonaceous asteroids, such as B‐type (101955) Bennu, represent the earliest stages of planet formation. B types have a blue (negative) spectral slope and comprise <5% of asteroids. Samples from Bennu returned by the OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft complement remote observations of this rare population. We show here, using laboratory spectra that are directly comparable to spacecraft data, that OSIRIS‐REx accurately determined Bennu's dust content and most of its surface composition. However, spectra of the asteroid exhibit stronger water absorptions than those of bulk samples, possibly due to hydrous, Mg‐rich phosphate or solar wind implantation at Bennu's uppermost surface. Bennu samples spectrally resemble the most aqueously altered carbonaceous meteorites and samples of (162173) Ryugu, indicating similarly pervasive aqueous alteration. However, one carbon‐enriched Bennu stone does not appear to have a spectral analog among Ryugu samples or meteorites. Our findings demonstrate the leverage obtained using a wide range of wavelengths and that sample analysis anchors the interpretations of remote sensing, leading to more robust characterization of planetary surface composition and evolution.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 5 (2) , 53
Large Carbonaceous Chondrite Parent Bodies Favored by Abundance–Volatility Modeling: A Possible Chemical Signature of Pebble Accretion
Primitive meteorite groups such as the Vigarano, Mighei, and Karoonda carbonaceous chondrites have enigmatic patterns of elemental abundances, with moderately volatile elements—those that transition from vapor to condensate between ∼400 and ∼900 K—defining plateaus of subequal abundances despite a wide range in volatility. In detail, each group defines a plateau with distinctive nonmonotonic “chemical fingerprints” that have been attributed to combinations of mixing, vaporization/condensation, and fluid-mediated metasomatism—but the extent to which these processes can reproduce the observed variability has not been quantified. Starting with primitive Ivuna chondrite, a two-stage, two-component equilibrium condensation–vaporization model—with gravity implemented as Jeans escape—can explain large-scale plateaus in these chondrite groups, as well as more complex, nonmonotonic small-scale variations. For all three chondritic meteorite groups, models favor earlier high-temperature fractionation under low-gravity conditions followed by a low-temperature fractionation event that took place on a protoplanet at least as large as Ceres. The second fractionation event may represent the fractionation of incoming materials to the planetesimal during protracted pebble accretion. Models with only thermally driven volatile loss, gravity, and mixing can explain more than 80% of the observed compositional variability in these meteorite groups. In our five-parameter model, using only five randomly selected elements yields uselessly large ranges of planet sizes and temperatures, ranges that converge with increasing numbers of elements. These results suggest that even simple models are prone to generating inaccurate conclusions when constrained by too few observations, a fault likely held by more complex models as well.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Planetary Science Journal
- Vol. 5 (2) , 53
Open AccessLarge Carbonaceous Chondrite Parent Bodies Favored by Abundance–Volatility Modeling: A Possible Chemical Signature of Pebble Accretion
Primitive meteorite groups such as the Vigarano, Mighei, and Karoonda carbonaceous chondrites have enigmatic patterns of elemental abundances, with moderately volatile elements—those that transition from vapor to condensate between ∼400 and ∼900 K—defining plateaus of subequal abundances despite a wide range in volatility. In detail, each group defines a plateau with distinctive nonmonotonic “chemical fingerprints” that have been attributed to combinations of mixing, vaporization/condensation, and fluid-mediated metasomatism—but the extent to which these processes can reproduce the observed variability has not been quantified. Starting with primitive Ivuna chondrite, a two-stage, two-component equilibrium condensation–vaporization model—with gravity implemented as Jeans escape—can explain large-scale plateaus in these chondrite groups, as well as more complex, nonmonotonic small-scale variations. For all three chondritic meteorite groups, models favor earlier high-temperature fractionation under low-gravity conditions followed by a low-temperature fractionation event that took place on a protoplanet at least as large as Ceres. The second fractionation event may represent the fractionation of incoming materials to the planetesimal during protracted pebble accretion. Models with only thermally driven volatile loss, gravity, and mixing can explain more than 80% of the observed compositional variability in these meteorite groups. In our five-parameter model, using only five randomly selected elements yields uselessly large ranges of planet sizes and temperatures, ranges that converge with increasing numbers of elements. These results suggest that even simple models are prone to generating inaccurate conclusions when constrained by too few observations, a fault likely held by more complex models as well.
- Open Access
- 8 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 58 (4) , 572-590
Curation planning and facilities for asteroid Bennu samples returned by the OSIRIS‐REx mission
NASA's OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft collected samples from carbonaceous near‐Earth asteroid (101955) Bennu on October 20, 2020, and will deliver them to the Earth on September 24, 2023. The samples will be processed at the NASA Johnson Space Center (JSC), where most of the sample collection will be subsequently curated in a new cleanroom suite. The spacecraft collected loose regolith two ways: in a bulk sample chamber capable of holding up to 2 kg, and on industrial Velcro “contact pads” intended to collect small particles at the surface. Included in the JSC collection will be the bulk sample, the contact pads, contamination‐monitoring witness plates, and supporting hardware. Planning for the curation of the samples and hardware started at the earliest phase of proposal development and continued in parallel with project development and execution. Because a major mission goal is characterization of organic compounds in the Bennu samples, extra effort was spent in the design stage to ensure a clean curation environment. Here, we describe the preparations to receive the sample, including the design, construction, outfitting, and monitoring of the cleanrooms at JSC; the planned recovery of the sample‐containing capsule when it lands on Earth; and the approach to characterizing and cataloging the samples. These curation efforts will result in the distribution of pristine Bennu samples from JSC to the OSIRIS‐REx science team, international partners, and the global scientific community for years to come.
- 8 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 58 (4) , 572-590
Open AccessCuration planning and facilities for asteroid Bennu samples returned by the OSIRIS‐REx mission
NASA's OSIRIS‐REx spacecraft collected samples from carbonaceous near‐Earth asteroid (101955) Bennu on October 20, 2020, and will deliver them to the Earth on September 24, 2023. The samples will be processed at the NASA Johnson Space Center (JSC), where most of the sample collection will be subsequently curated in a new cleanroom suite. The spacecraft collected loose regolith two ways: in a bulk sample chamber capable of holding up to 2 kg, and on industrial Velcro “contact pads” intended to collect small particles at the surface. Included in the JSC collection will be the bulk sample, the contact pads, contamination‐monitoring witness plates, and supporting hardware. Planning for the curation of the samples and hardware started at the earliest phase of proposal development and continued in parallel with project development and execution. Because a major mission goal is characterization of organic compounds in the Bennu samples, extra effort was spent in the design stage to ensure a clean curation environment. Here, we describe the preparations to receive the sample, including the design, construction, outfitting, and monitoring of the cleanrooms at JSC; the planned recovery of the sample‐containing capsule when it lands on Earth; and the approach to characterizing and cataloging the samples. These curation efforts will result in the distribution of pristine Bennu samples from JSC to the OSIRIS‐REx science team, international partners, and the global scientific community for years to come.
- 24 July 2021
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 56 (8) , 1556-1573
Identification and pairing reassessment of unequilibrated ordinary chondrites from four Antarctic dense collection areas
New analyses of Cr2O3 contents of olivines from type II chondrules in unequilibrated chondrites (UOC) from four dense collections are reported here. This survey of petrologic type 3 UOCs was undertaken to identify primitive chondrites that may have been overlooked, and to address possible pairing errors. We have identified 23 primitive UOCs (≤3.10) (only five identified previously, for a total of 28 overall), and also recommend other revisions to prior classifications and pairings.
- 24 July 2021
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 56 (8) , 1556-1573
Identification and pairing reassessment of unequilibrated ordinary chondrites from four Antarctic dense collection areas
New analyses of Cr2O3 contents of olivines from type II chondrules in unequilibrated chondrites (UOC) from four dense collections are reported here. This survey of petrologic type 3 UOCs was undertaken to identify primitive chondrites that may have been overlooked, and to address possible pairing errors. We have identified 23 primitive UOCs (≤3.10) (only five identified previously, for a total of 28 overall), and also recommend other revisions to prior classifications and pairings.
- 19 December 2019
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 55 (1) , 130-148
Insights into the formation of silica‐rich achondrites from impact melts in Rumuruti‐type chondrites
Ancient, SiO2‐rich achondrites have previously been proposed to have formed by disequilibrium partial melting of chondrites. Here, we test the alternative hypothesis that these achondrites formed by fractional crystallization of impact melts of Rumuruti (R) chondrites. We identified two new melt clasts in R chondrites, one in Pecora Escarpment (PCA) 91241 and one in LaPaz Icefield (LAP) 031275. We analyzed major, minor, and trace element concentrations, as well as oxygen isotopes, of these two clasts and a third one that had been previously recognized (Bischoff et al. 2011) as an impact melt in Dar al Gani (DaG) 013. The melt clast in PCA 91241 is an R chondrite impact melt closely resembling the one previously recognized in DaG 013. The melt clast in LAP 031275 has an L chondrite provenance. We show that SiO2‐rich melts could form from the mesostases of R chondrite impact melts. However, their CI‐normalized rare earth element patterns are flat, whereas those of ancient SiO2‐rich achondrites (Day et al. 2012; Srinivasan et al. 2018) and those of disequilibrium partial melts of chondrites (Feldstein et al. 2001) have positive Eu anomalies from preferential melting of plagioclase. Thus, we conclude that ancient SiO2‐rich achondrites were probably formed by disequilibrium partial melting (due to an internal heat source on their parent bodies), rather than from impact melts.
- 19 December 2019
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 55 (1) , 130-148
Insights into the formation of silica‐rich achondrites from impact melts in Rumuruti‐type chondrites
Ancient, SiO2‐rich achondrites have previously been proposed to have formed by disequilibrium partial melting of chondrites. Here, we test the alternative hypothesis that these achondrites formed by fractional crystallization of impact melts of Rumuruti (R) chondrites. We identified two new melt clasts in R chondrites, one in Pecora Escarpment (PCA) 91241 and one in LaPaz Icefield (LAP) 031275. We analyzed major, minor, and trace element concentrations, as well as oxygen isotopes, of these two clasts and a third one that had been previously recognized (Bischoff et al. 2011) as an impact melt in Dar al Gani (DaG) 013. The melt clast in PCA 91241 is an R chondrite impact melt closely resembling the one previously recognized in DaG 013. The melt clast in LAP 031275 has an L chondrite provenance. We show that SiO2‐rich melts could form from the mesostases of R chondrite impact melts. However, their CI‐normalized rare earth element patterns are flat, whereas those of ancient SiO2‐rich achondrites (Day et al. 2012; Srinivasan et al. 2018) and those of disequilibrium partial melts of chondrites (Feldstein et al. 2001) have positive Eu anomalies from preferential melting of plagioclase. Thus, we conclude that ancient SiO2‐rich achondrites were probably formed by disequilibrium partial melting (due to an internal heat source on their parent bodies), rather than from impact melts.
- 1 August 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
- Vol. 259, 253-269
Lewis Cliff 86211 and 86498: Metal-sulfide liquid segregates from a carbonaceous chondrite impact melt
- 1 August 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
- Vol. 259, 253-269
Lewis Cliff 86211 and 86498: Metal-sulfide liquid segregates from a carbonaceous chondrite impact melt
- 22 May 2018
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 53 (10) , 2122-2137
Experimental insights into Stannern‐trend eucrite petrogenesis
The incompatible trace element‐enriched Stannern‐trend eucrites have long been recognized as requiring a distinct petrogenesis from the Main Group‐Nuevo Laredo (MGNL) eucrites. Barrat et al. () proposed that Stannern‐trend eucrites formed via assimilation of crustal partial melts by a MGNL‐trend magma. Previous experimental studies of low‐degree partial melting of eucrites did not produce sufficiently large melt pools for both major and trace element analyses. Low‐degree partial melts produced near the solidus are potentially the best analog to the assimilated crustal melts. We partially melted the unbrecciated, unequilibrated MGNL‐trend eucrite NWA 8562 in a 1 atm gas‐mixing furnace, at IW‐0.5, and at temperatures between 1050 and 1200 °C. We found that low‐degree partial melts formed at 1050 °C are incompatible trace element enriched, although the experimental melts did not reach equilibrium at all temperatures. Using our experimental melt compositions and binary mixing modeling, the FeO/MgO trend of the resultant magmas coincides with the range of known Stannern‐trend eucrites when a primary magma is contaminated by crustal partial melts. When experimental major element compositions for eucritic crustal partial melts are combined with trace element concentrations determined by previous modeling (Barrat et al. ), the Stannern‐trend can be replicated with respect to both major, minor, and trace element concentrations.
- 22 May 2018
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 53 (10) , 2122-2137
Experimental insights into Stannern‐trend eucrite petrogenesis
The incompatible trace element‐enriched Stannern‐trend eucrites have long been recognized as requiring a distinct petrogenesis from the Main Group‐Nuevo Laredo (MGNL) eucrites. Barrat et al. () proposed that Stannern‐trend eucrites formed via assimilation of crustal partial melts by a MGNL‐trend magma. Previous experimental studies of low‐degree partial melting of eucrites did not produce sufficiently large melt pools for both major and trace element analyses. Low‐degree partial melts produced near the solidus are potentially the best analog to the assimilated crustal melts. We partially melted the unbrecciated, unequilibrated MGNL‐trend eucrite NWA 8562 in a 1 atm gas‐mixing furnace, at IW‐0.5, and at temperatures between 1050 and 1200 °C. We found that low‐degree partial melts formed at 1050 °C are incompatible trace element enriched, although the experimental melts did not reach equilibrium at all temperatures. Using our experimental melt compositions and binary mixing modeling, the FeO/MgO trend of the resultant magmas coincides with the range of known Stannern‐trend eucrites when a primary magma is contaminated by crustal partial melts. When experimental major element compositions for eucritic crustal partial melts are combined with trace element concentrations determined by previous modeling (Barrat et al. ), the Stannern‐trend can be replicated with respect to both major, minor, and trace element concentrations.
- Open Access
- 3 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 53 (3) , 514-546
Mg‐rich harzburgites from Vesta: Mantle residua or cumulates from planetary differentiation?
We describe petrographic, electron microprobe, and laser ablation ICP‐MS analyses of Mg‐rich harzburgite clasts in the Dominion Range 2010 howardites, and conclude that they are xenolithic samples of the vestan mantle. Key chemical and petrologic characteristics of these rocks provide tests for differentiation models. Our results indicate the mantle of Vesta formed through variable degrees of partial melting, which left behind a harzburgite and possibly dunite residuum. The Mg‐rich clasts are composed of orthopyroxene and olivine, with minor clinopyroxene, FeNi metal, and distinctive pyroxene–chromite symplectites. We use mineral chemistry to demonstrate the absence of a genetic link between diogenites and the Mg‐rich harzburgites. We propose a secondary origin for the formation of symplectites: interaction of silicate and metallic melts during primordial differentiation and core formation. The occurrence of FeNi metal containing ~1.5 wt% Cr within the assemblage indicates a very reducing environment during mantle differentiation (≪IW). Our study suggests that Vesta did not experience complete melting early in its history, and instead supports the formation of a shallow magma ocean.
- 3 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 53 (3) , 514-546
Open AccessMg‐rich harzburgites from Vesta: Mantle residua or cumulates from planetary differentiation?
We describe petrographic, electron microprobe, and laser ablation ICP‐MS analyses of Mg‐rich harzburgite clasts in the Dominion Range 2010 howardites, and conclude that they are xenolithic samples of the vestan mantle. Key chemical and petrologic characteristics of these rocks provide tests for differentiation models. Our results indicate the mantle of Vesta formed through variable degrees of partial melting, which left behind a harzburgite and possibly dunite residuum. The Mg‐rich clasts are composed of orthopyroxene and olivine, with minor clinopyroxene, FeNi metal, and distinctive pyroxene–chromite symplectites. We use mineral chemistry to demonstrate the absence of a genetic link between diogenites and the Mg‐rich harzburgites. We propose a secondary origin for the formation of symplectites: interaction of silicate and metallic melts during primordial differentiation and core formation. The occurrence of FeNi metal containing ~1.5 wt% Cr within the assemblage indicates a very reducing environment during mantle differentiation (≪IW). Our study suggests that Vesta did not experience complete melting early in its history, and instead supports the formation of a shallow magma ocean.