Allan McDougall
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Allan McDougall has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Lorelei Lingard
Centre for Education Research & Innovation Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry Western University London ON Canada
4 shared publicationsCatherine Schryer
School of Professional Communication, Ryerson University, London, Ontario, Canada
3 shared publicationsGlendon R. Tait
Department of Psychiatry and Division of Medical Education Dalhousie University Halifax NS Canada
3 shared publications- Lorelei Lingard
Department of Medicine, Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry Western University London Ontario Canada
3 shared publications - Elizabeth Anne Kinsella
McGill University
2 shared publications Joanna Bates
Department of Family Practice Faculty of Medicine University of British Columbia Vancouver BC Canada
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (2) , 98-100
The view from within: Professional identity formation when safety events involve trainees
Given the dangers, complexity and nuance required when dealing with safety events, McDougall outlines how education systems can enable growth rather than worsening wounds.
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 60 (2) , 98-100
Open AccessThe view from within: Professional identity formation when safety events involve trainees
Given the dangers, complexity and nuance required when dealing with safety events, McDougall outlines how education systems can enable growth rather than worsening wounds.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 59 (11) , 1204-1213
From challenge to growth: Exploring physician narratives of patient complaints during residency
Introduction: Patient complaints are an important feedback mechanism for healthcare quality improvement and medical education, and their impact on postgraduate medical trainees (residents) remains under‐explored. This study investigates the narratives of physicians who received formal patient complaints during residency, focusing on how these incidents influenced their professional development and career trajectories.Methods: Using narrative inquiry, we conducted semi‐structured interviews with 35 physicians who experienced formal patient complaints during their residency. We applied Ricoeur's narrative theory to explore the impact of these complaints on physicians.Results: The analysis revealed two main elements of participants' narratives: emplotment and refiguration. During emplotment, participants initially constructed narratives centered on distress and stigma, often positioning themselves as confused and isolated. This process frequently involved a reevaluation of their professional capabilities and identity as an effective physician. Refiguration demonstrated how participants integrated these experiences into their long‐term professional identities, revealing impacts on clinical practices, specialty choices and career paths. Despite initial challenges, many participants reframed their early complaint experiences as catalysts for professional growth, particularly in areas such as communication and collegial support.Conclusions: Patient complaints during residency can have a destabilizing effect on professional identity formation. However, supportive educational environments and adequate mentorship can mitigate these effects and enhance learning. This study underscores the need for medical education programmes to incorporate systems that support residents in effectively addressing and learning from patient complaints while maintaining a focus on patient safety and quality improvement.
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 59 (11) , 1204-1213
Open AccessFrom challenge to growth: Exploring physician narratives of patient complaints during residency
Introduction: Patient complaints are an important feedback mechanism for healthcare quality improvement and medical education, and their impact on postgraduate medical trainees (residents) remains under‐explored. This study investigates the narratives of physicians who received formal patient complaints during residency, focusing on how these incidents influenced their professional development and career trajectories.Methods: Using narrative inquiry, we conducted semi‐structured interviews with 35 physicians who experienced formal patient complaints during their residency. We applied Ricoeur's narrative theory to explore the impact of these complaints on physicians.Results: The analysis revealed two main elements of participants' narratives: emplotment and refiguration. During emplotment, participants initially constructed narratives centered on distress and stigma, often positioning themselves as confused and isolated. This process frequently involved a reevaluation of their professional capabilities and identity as an effective physician. Refiguration demonstrated how participants integrated these experiences into their long‐term professional identities, revealing impacts on clinical practices, specialty choices and career paths. Despite initial challenges, many participants reframed their early complaint experiences as catalysts for professional growth, particularly in areas such as communication and collegial support.Conclusions: Patient complaints during residency can have a destabilizing effect on professional identity formation. However, supportive educational environments and adequate mentorship can mitigate these effects and enhance learning. This study underscores the need for medical education programmes to incorporate systems that support residents in effectively addressing and learning from patient complaints while maintaining a focus on patient safety and quality improvement.
- Open Access
- 25 October 2022
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (2) , 40-50
A qualitative study of Canadian resident experiences with Competency-Based Medical Education
Background: Competency-based medical education (CBME) is an outcomes-based curricular paradigm focused on ensuring that graduates are competent to meet the needs of patients. Although resident engagement is key to CBME’s success, few studies have explored how trainees have experienced CBME implementation. We explored the experiences of residents in Canadian training programs that had implemented CBME. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 16 residents in seven Canadian postgraduate training programs, exploring their experiences with CBME. Participants were equally divided between family medicine and specialty programs. Themes were identified using principles of constructivist grounded theory. Results: Residents were receptive to the goals of CBME, but in practice, described several drawbacks primarily related to assessment and feedback. For many residents, the significant administrative burden and focus on assessment led to performance anxiety. At times, residents felt that assessments lacked meaning as supervisors focused on “checking-boxes” or provided overly broad, non-specific comments. Furthermore, they commonly expressed frustration with the perceived subjectivity and inconsistency of judgments on assessments, especially if assessments were used to delay progression to greater independence, contributing to attempts to "game the system". Faculty engagement and support improved resident experiences with CBME. Conclusion: Although residents value the potential for CBME to improve the quality of education, assessment and feedback, the current operationalization of CBME may not be consistently achieving these objectives. The authors suggest several initiatives to improve how residents experience assessment and feedback processes in CBME.
- 25 October 2022
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (2) , 40-50
Open AccessA qualitative study of Canadian resident experiences with Competency-Based Medical Education
Background: Competency-based medical education (CBME) is an outcomes-based curricular paradigm focused on ensuring that graduates are competent to meet the needs of patients. Although resident engagement is key to CBME’s success, few studies have explored how trainees have experienced CBME implementation. We explored the experiences of residents in Canadian training programs that had implemented CBME. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 16 residents in seven Canadian postgraduate training programs, exploring their experiences with CBME. Participants were equally divided between family medicine and specialty programs. Themes were identified using principles of constructivist grounded theory. Results: Residents were receptive to the goals of CBME, but in practice, described several drawbacks primarily related to assessment and feedback. For many residents, the significant administrative burden and focus on assessment led to performance anxiety. At times, residents felt that assessments lacked meaning as supervisors focused on “checking-boxes” or provided overly broad, non-specific comments. Furthermore, they commonly expressed frustration with the perceived subjectivity and inconsistency of judgments on assessments, especially if assessments were used to delay progression to greater independence, contributing to attempts to "game the system". Faculty engagement and support improved resident experiences with CBME. Conclusion: Although residents value the potential for CBME to improve the quality of education, assessment and feedback, the current operationalization of CBME may not be consistently achieving these objectives. The authors suggest several initiatives to improve how residents experience assessment and feedback processes in CBME.
- 15 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 55 (3) , 387-393
The medico‐legal helpline: A content analysis of postgraduate medical trainee advice calls
Context: Available literature exploring medical liability and postgraduate medical education consistently posits that postgraduate trainees worry about their exposure to medico‐legal liability. This assumption has formed the basis for research and curriculum development. Objectives: The aim of this study was to describe the encounters that lead physicians‐in‐training to seek external medico‐legal guidance. We sought to provide empirical evidence on trends and themes related to medico‐legal advice requests from physicians‐in‐training. Methods: Our primary dataset consisted of records of calls from physicians‐in‐training to the medico‐legal helpline of the Canadian Medical Protective Association (CMPA), a national mutual defence organisation providing medico‐legal advice and liability protection for over 95% of Canada's physicians. We conducted a trend analysis of the frequency of calls for advice over 10 years from physician‐in‐training compared with non‐trainee physicians. Furthermore, we performed a content analysis of calls made over the most recent 2 years (2016‐2017) to elucidate the concerns that led to trainees seeking medico‐legal advice. Results: The 10‐year trend analysis revealed that the annual growth in the number of physician‐in‐training advice calls (8.8%) exceeded other CMPA physician groups and was in excess of trainee population growth over the same period. The content analysis identified four core themes: managing confidential information, complex care situations, academic matters and patient safety incidents. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that trainees are asking questions about their medico‐legal liability with increasing frequency. This study contributes new evidence on the issues that lead to trainees seeking help. We believe that understanding trainees' medico‐legal advice requests will support medical educators to tailor quality improvement education to learners' needs.
- 15 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 55 (3) , 387-393
The medico‐legal helpline: A content analysis of postgraduate medical trainee advice calls
Context: Available literature exploring medical liability and postgraduate medical education consistently posits that postgraduate trainees worry about their exposure to medico‐legal liability. This assumption has formed the basis for research and curriculum development. Objectives: The aim of this study was to describe the encounters that lead physicians‐in‐training to seek external medico‐legal guidance. We sought to provide empirical evidence on trends and themes related to medico‐legal advice requests from physicians‐in‐training. Methods: Our primary dataset consisted of records of calls from physicians‐in‐training to the medico‐legal helpline of the Canadian Medical Protective Association (CMPA), a national mutual defence organisation providing medico‐legal advice and liability protection for over 95% of Canada's physicians. We conducted a trend analysis of the frequency of calls for advice over 10 years from physician‐in‐training compared with non‐trainee physicians. Furthermore, we performed a content analysis of calls made over the most recent 2 years (2016‐2017) to elucidate the concerns that led to trainees seeking medico‐legal advice. Results: The 10‐year trend analysis revealed that the annual growth in the number of physician‐in‐training advice calls (8.8%) exceeded other CMPA physician groups and was in excess of trainee population growth over the same period. The content analysis identified four core themes: managing confidential information, complex care situations, academic matters and patient safety incidents. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that trainees are asking questions about their medico‐legal liability with increasing frequency. This study contributes new evidence on the issues that lead to trainees seeking help. We believe that understanding trainees' medico‐legal advice requests will support medical educators to tailor quality improvement education to learners' needs.
- 1 June 2019
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 11 (3) , 287-294
Faculty and Resident Perspectives on Using Entrustment Anchors for Workplace-Based Assessment
Research suggests that workplace-based assessment (WBA) tools using entrustment anchors provide more reliable assessments than those using traditional anchors. There is a lack of evidence describing how and why entrustment anchors work. The purpose of this study is to better understand the experience of residents and faculty with respect to traditional and entrustment anchors. We used constructivist grounded theory to guide data collection and analysis (March–December 2017) and semistructured interviews to gather reflections on anchors. Phase 1 involved residents and faculty (n = 12) who had only used assessment tools with traditional anchors. Phase 2 involved participants who had used tools with entrustment anchors (n = 10). Data were analyzed iteratively. Participants expressed that the pragmatic language of entrustment anchors made WBA (1) concrete and justifiable; (2) transparent as they explicitly link clinical assessment and learning progress; and (3) align with training outcomes, enabling better feedback. Participants with no prior experience using entrustment anchors outlined contextual concerns regarding their use. Participants with experience described how they addressed these concerns. Participants expressed that entrustment anchors leave a gap in assessment information because they do not provide normative data. Insights from this analysis contribute to a theoretical framework of benefits and challenges related to the adoption of entrustment anchors. This richer understanding of faculty and resident perspectives of entrustment anchors may assist WBA developers in creating more acceptable tools and inform the necessary faculty development initiatives that must accompany the use of these new WBA tools.
- 1 June 2019
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 11 (3) , 287-294
Faculty and Resident Perspectives on Using Entrustment Anchors for Workplace-Based Assessment
Research suggests that workplace-based assessment (WBA) tools using entrustment anchors provide more reliable assessments than those using traditional anchors. There is a lack of evidence describing how and why entrustment anchors work. The purpose of this study is to better understand the experience of residents and faculty with respect to traditional and entrustment anchors. We used constructivist grounded theory to guide data collection and analysis (March–December 2017) and semistructured interviews to gather reflections on anchors. Phase 1 involved residents and faculty (n = 12) who had only used assessment tools with traditional anchors. Phase 2 involved participants who had used tools with entrustment anchors (n = 10). Data were analyzed iteratively. Participants expressed that the pragmatic language of entrustment anchors made WBA (1) concrete and justifiable; (2) transparent as they explicitly link clinical assessment and learning progress; and (3) align with training outcomes, enabling better feedback. Participants with no prior experience using entrustment anchors outlined contextual concerns regarding their use. Participants with experience described how they addressed these concerns. Participants expressed that entrustment anchors leave a gap in assessment information because they do not provide normative data. Insights from this analysis contribute to a theoretical framework of benefits and challenges related to the adoption of entrustment anchors. This richer understanding of faculty and resident perspectives of entrustment anchors may assist WBA developers in creating more acceptable tools and inform the necessary faculty development initiatives that must accompany the use of these new WBA tools.
- Open Access
- 14 February 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 41 (4) , 403-407
Examining the clinical learning environment through the architectural avenue
Medical education has traditionally focused on the learners, the educators, and the curriculum, while tending to overlook the role of the designed environment. Experience indicates, however, that processes and outcomes of medical education are sensitive to the qualities and disposition of the spaces in which it occurs. This includes the clinical education within the patient care environment, termed the clinical learning environment (CLE). Recognition of this has informed the design of some new clinical learning spaces for the past decade. Competency-based clinical education can drive design requirements that differ materially from those associated with general purpose educational or clinical spaces. In this article, we outline two conceptual frameworks: (i) materialist spatiality and (ii) actor-network theory and consider how they can guide the design of spaces to support competency-based medical education and to guide the evaluation and discussion of the educational impacts of the spaces once built. We illustrate the use of these frameworks through discussion of the educational ambitions that underpinned the design of some recent clinical educational spaces. We close with practical points for consideration by educators and designers.
- 14 February 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 41 (4) , 403-407
Open AccessExamining the clinical learning environment through the architectural avenue
Medical education has traditionally focused on the learners, the educators, and the curriculum, while tending to overlook the role of the designed environment. Experience indicates, however, that processes and outcomes of medical education are sensitive to the qualities and disposition of the spaces in which it occurs. This includes the clinical education within the patient care environment, termed the clinical learning environment (CLE). Recognition of this has informed the design of some new clinical learning spaces for the past decade. Competency-based clinical education can drive design requirements that differ materially from those associated with general purpose educational or clinical spaces. In this article, we outline two conceptual frameworks: (i) materialist spatiality and (ii) actor-network theory and consider how they can guide the design of spaces to support competency-based medical education and to guide the evaluation and discussion of the educational impacts of the spaces once built. We illustrate the use of these frameworks through discussion of the educational ambitions that underpinned the design of some recent clinical educational spaces. We close with practical points for consideration by educators and designers.
- 1 September 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Annals of Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 72 (3) , 326-327
Medicolegal Data Empower Better and Safer Health Care
- 1 September 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Annals of Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 72 (3) , 326-327
Medicolegal Data Empower Better and Safer Health Care
- Open Access
- 19 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 40 (1) , 218-233
Beyond the realist turn: a socio‐material analysis of heart failure self‐care
For patients living with chronic illnesses, self‐care has been linked with positive outcomes such as decreased hospitalisation, longer lifespan, and improved quality of life. However, despite calls for more and better self‐care interventions, behaviour change trials have repeatedly fallen short on demonstrating effectiveness. The literature on heart failure (HF) stands as a case in point, and a growing body ofHFstudies advocate realist approaches to self‐care research and policymaking. We label this trend the ‘realist turn’ inHFself‐care. Realist evaluation and realist interventions emphasise that the relationship between self‐care interventions and positive health outcomes is not fixed, but contingent on social context. This paper argues socio‐materiality offers a productive framework to expand on the idea of social context in realist accounts ofHFself‐care. This study draws on 10 interviews as well as researcher reflections from a larger study exploring health care teams for patients with advancedHF. Leveraging insights from actor‐network theory (ANT), this study provides two rich narratives about the contextual factors that influenceHFself‐care. These descriptions portray not self‐care contexts but self‐care assemblages, which we discuss in light of socio‐materiality.
- 19 January 2018
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 40 (1) , 218-233
Open AccessBeyond the realist turn: a socio‐material analysis of heart failure self‐care
For patients living with chronic illnesses, self‐care has been linked with positive outcomes such as decreased hospitalisation, longer lifespan, and improved quality of life. However, despite calls for more and better self‐care interventions, behaviour change trials have repeatedly fallen short on demonstrating effectiveness. The literature on heart failure (HF) stands as a case in point, and a growing body ofHFstudies advocate realist approaches to self‐care research and policymaking. We label this trend the ‘realist turn’ inHFself‐care. Realist evaluation and realist interventions emphasise that the relationship between self‐care interventions and positive health outcomes is not fixed, but contingent on social context. This paper argues socio‐materiality offers a productive framework to expand on the idea of social context in realist accounts ofHFself‐care. This study draws on 10 interviews as well as researcher reflections from a larger study exploring health care teams for patients with advancedHF. Leveraging insights from actor‐network theory (ANT), this study provides two rich narratives about the contextual factors that influenceHFself‐care. These descriptions portray not self‐care contexts but self‐care assemblages, which we discuss in light of socio‐materiality.
- 9 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (5) , 469-470
When I say … gamification
A brief look at “gamification” as a concept in education in an effort to provide clarity and direction to health professional educators.
- 9 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (5) , 469-470
When I say … gamification
A brief look at “gamification” as a concept in education in an effort to provide clarity and direction to health professional educators.
- 1 September 2016
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 164, 108-117
Collaboration and entanglement: An actor-network theory analysis of team-based intraprofessional care for patients with advanced heart failure
- 1 September 2016
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 164, 108-117
Collaboration and entanglement: An actor-network theory analysis of team-based intraprofessional care for patients with advanced heart failure