PSPeter Smagorinsky

Peter Smagorinsky

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Peter Smagorinsky has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Play, Games, Schooling, Labor, and Social Trajectories: Vygotsky’s Cultural Continuum of Human Development / El juego, los juegos, los estudios, el trabajo y los itinerarios sociales: el continuo cultural del desarrollo humano de Vygotski

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    This essay focuses on Vygotsky’s attention to long-term, mediated human development, with primary emphasis on the role of play, imagination, and games in the socialization of children and adolescents, and on the role of schooling in shaping the experiences of students toward cultural ends. To Vygotsky, both play/imagination/games and schooling have long-term goals and effects in human development, designed to promote the labor available to Soviet Marxist citizens. Vygotsky is often represented as a daily instructional planner via scaffolding, in spite of its absence in his writing. Vygotsky’s attention to cultural development is quite different from the short-term teaching and learning for which he is primarily, and erroneously, referenced in much educational writing. Furthermore, his view of play is often treated as an immediate experience rather than as a key facet of a lifelong developmental process. This essay is designed to interrogate such misconceptions and integrate two areas of his work that are not ordinarily treated as a continuum in educational writing.

  • Open Access

    Exploring Intradisciplinary Rhetorical Variation in the Introduction Sections of Applied Linguistics Research Articles: The Case of Qualitative and Quantitative Research Paradigms

    by Elyas Barabadi, Amanollah Arghavan, Zahra Fotuhabadi, Peter Smagorinsky

    The cross-disciplinary rhetorical variation of the research article (RA) genre, especially in the Introduction section, has been extensively studied because of pedagogical relevance. However, this body of research has not systematically explored intradisciplinary rhetorical differences that are sensitive to both disciplinary requirements and epistemological and ontological commitments. Addressing this gap, the present study investigates the rhetorical structure of Introduction sections in Applied Linguistics RAs. Through detailed manual annotation of 64 articles published in four leading Applied Linguistics journals (32 qualitative, 32 quantitative), we identified a four-move rhetorical repertoire shared by both paradigms. However, the realizations of these moves and their constituent steps were paradigm-sensitive. While moves one, two, and three were highly conventional, move four was optional but more frequent in qualitative RAs. Particularly, quantitative writers often discuss variable relationships, measurement, and empirical specification, whereas qualitative writers focus more on contextual and theoretical positioning and previewing findings. This study can provide a grounded framework for teaching paradigm-sensitive RA Introduction writing.

  • Play, Imagination, Emotion, and Art in Literary Interpretation: Revisiting Old Work Through a New Lens

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    In this article, I revisit research published in 1995 during the early stages of my efforts to understand and apply Vygotskian concepts to my studies of school literacy. The research analyzed two teenaged girls in an alternative high school for recovering substance abusers as they interpreted William Carlos Williams’ short story “The Use of Force” through an interpretive dance. In this article, I revisit the study with a greater theoretical emphasis on the students’ emotional states and growth through choreographing their interpretation, evidence of which was in the original data but overlooked in theorizing. The article reviews the genesis of the original article, explores its theoretical shortcomings, introduces a new theoretical apparatus oriented to emotional life as central to developmental trajectories, and applies this theory to the data in ways that my developmental state 30 years ago was not capable of providing.

  • Mediated memory of a mentor teacher / Los recuerdos mediados sobre un profesor mentor

    by Peter Smagorinsky, Stacia L. Long

    This study analyses the ways in which Caitlin, a high school English 1 teacher in the Southeastern US, recalled her mentor teacher (MT), Travis Mann, at different points in her developmental trajectory. (All names of people and places are pseudonyms.) Our focus for this inquiry is on Caitlin’s mediated memory of Travis. These memories, we argue, were subject to mediated activity in schools that changed how she recalled their relationship. To study Caitlin’s mediated memory of Travis, we inquired into the following research questions: (1) What memories did Caitlin report of her relationship with Travis and his influence on her teaching over the course of the study? (2) What mediators appear to account for the ways in which she remembered her relationship with Travis over time and incorporated those memories into her quest for equilibrium?


  • Writing and Reading Qualitative Characters

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    This essay concerns the ways in which qualitative social science research characters are constructed, and in turn read, by others. The persuasiveness of narratives is based as much on the reader’s response to the character—similar to the ways in which readers respond to literary characters—in emotional ways as it is on the rational presentation of evidence. This essay acknowledges the author’s subjectivity in relation to this topic; reviews the notions of narrative perspective, fidelity, emplotment, and verisimilitude; explores the role of narrative in social science research reports; presents background on how readers respond to literary characters; and applies these understandings to make the case that reading the presentation of social science research characters shares much with the ways in which readers respond to the actions of literary characters. The essay concludes with an argument that the construction of social science research reports includes the selective construction of participants as actors in a drama that in turn has an emotional impact on readers and with a description of the implications of this phenomenon for writers and readers of qualitative social science research reports.


  • Lantolf, Vygotsky, and Learning through and about Languages

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    In this essay I reflect on James P. Lantolf’s contributions to cultural-historical theory and second language learning. I begin with my personal subjectivity and experiences as a limited learner of additional languages beyond English. This anecdotal opening introduces the tension between formal learning in school and everyday immersion in a language system. I conclude that each is important, and that together they produce robust learning. I then review the terms of the immersion-vs-instruction approaches to learning additional languages, here with greater attention to theoretical points than my anecdotes provide. I next digress with attention to translanguaging, which calls into question the notion that there is necessarily an L1 to which other languages may be added. I then review the Marx-Hegel notion of dialectical thinking, central to Vygotsky’s thinking and informative in understanding language learning and cultural experiences. I finally review a troubling problem in educational writing, the tendency to trivialize complex concepts, focusing on how the Zone of Proximal Development has become conflated with instructional scaffolding. I conclude with brief thoughts about Lantolf’s contributions and how they have both been inspired by other people’s thinking, and in turn have enriched the understandings of those who engage with his scholarship.

  • The Relation between Emotion and Intellect: Which Governs Which?

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    This article contrasts two beliefs about the relation between the emotions and the intellect. Each sees emotional responses as fundamental and primary sources of thinking. Each sees a different role for the intellect following emotional responses to worldly phenomena. L. S. Vygotsky, articulating a belief common at his time, sees the intellect as a disciplining force, one that, after a pause or interlude, serves to temper emotions to produce a “catharsis” and what he calls “intelligent emotions,” those subjected to rational thought and a higher plane of cognition than either emotion or intellect could produce alone. Jonathan Haidt, following Vygotsky by nearly a century, asserts that emotions control cognition, rather than as Vygotsky conceives, being subordinated by reason. Haidt, in the tradition of David Hume and with more empirical data than Vygotsky provides for his view, sees the passions ruling human thought and action. Any accompanying reason serves to rationalize gut feelings rather than to control them; reason, Haidt argues, is a “rationalist delusion” that gives emotional thinking the veneer of reason. This article outlines both positions and attempts to reach a synthesis of their views.


  • Top Cited Papers

    The Trouble With Binaries: A Perspective on the Science of Reading

    by David B. Yaden, David Reinking, Peter Smagorinsky

    In this article, we critique the science of reading when it is positioned within the reading wars as settling disagreements about reading and how it should be taught. We frame our argument in terms of troublesome binaries, specifically between nature and nurture. We interpret that binary in relation to Overton’s distinction between split and relational metatheories, with the latter suggesting a more integrative view of nature and nurture. Focusing on the nature side of the binary, which predominates when the science of reading is promoted in the reading wars, we argue that its singular focus limits the range of scientific inquiry, interpretation, and application to practice. Specifically, we address limitations of the science of reading as characterized by a narrow theoretical lens, an abstracted empiricism, and uncritical inductive generalizations derived from brain‐imaging and eye movement data sources. Finally, we call for a relational metatheoretical stance and offer emulative examples of that stance in the field.


  • Literacy in Teacher Education: “It’s the Context, Stupid”

    by Peter Smagorinsky

    This article emphasizes the importance of understanding local contexts to provide appropriate education for teachers about literacy instruction. The author reviews general problems that follow from extrapolating from unrepresentative research samples and the errors and deficit conceptions that follow from assuming that all cognition takes place within the human skull, irrespective of the contexts that shape human development and immediate textual exchanges. The author then demonstrates challenges to his own thinking when he used a book he coedited for U.S. educators in the context of a literacy education program at the Universidad de Guadalajara, Mexico. This narrative relates how the book was rewritten by the teachers in his seminar to have relevance, with extensive adaptations required. The author emphasizes the contextual facets of literacy development, and the need to think in terms of the settings of teaching and learning in university teacher education programs.