VSVirgílio Afonso da Silva

Virgílio Afonso da Silva

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Virgílio Afonso da Silva has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Balancing Principles in a World Full of Rules

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    Two central assumptions of Robert Alexy's theory of constitutional rights are that every norm is either a rule or a principle, and that rules are applied by subsumption and principles by balancing. In this article I argue that even if balancing is associated with principles, this does not mean that it only takes place in contexts in which no enacted rules exist. On the contrary, our world is full of rules, and only very rarely are none of them applicable in deciding a legal controversy. True hard cases, in which resorting to balancing is justified by the absence of settled rules applicable to a case, are extremely rare. I therefore argue that the most frequent, important, and complex tasks for balancing are those related to encounters between principles and rules. My central claim is that balancing plays different roles in different encounters between principles and rules. It may be an interpretive, a corrective, or a controlling tool. Defenses of, and objections to, balancing should take these different roles into account.


  • Open Access

    Balancing may be everywhere, but the proportionality test is not

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    The relationship between balancing and proportionality has not always been clear. Because part of the literature falls short of adequately differentiating between the two tools, many people have become conditioned to see an instance of proportionality whenever the word ‘balancing’ is dropped. As a consequence, the ubiquity of balancing brought about the feeling that proportionality is equally ubiquitous. In this article, I show that the proportionality test is necessarily linked to judicial review and how this link is key to understanding why not every instance of balancing is part of the proportionality test and that proportionality cannot be as ubiquitous as many have claimed. This has not only analytical relevance, but also institutional consequences.


  • Standing in the shadows of balancing: Proportionality and the necessity test

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    The necessity test is one of the steps of the proportionality test. However, in the literature on the subject, written both by supporters as well as by critics of proportionality, the role of the necessity test has been frequently downplayed, sometimes plainly ignored. The spotlight has always been on balancing. This article shows that proportionality is not just about balancing, and that the necessity test has a much more important role to play than has been acknowledged so far. Its strengths are emphasized, especially its connection to politics, knowledge from other areas, time, and technological development. The article argues that shedding the appropriate light on these strengths has important implications for several ongoing debates around the proportionality test.


  • The Constitution of Brazil in Context

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva, Thomaz Pereira

    This chapter aims to introduce the fundamental institutional features of the current Brazilian constitutional regime. The 1988 Brazilian Constitution is, simultaneously (i) a product of a continuing history with characteristics that reflect mainstream political ideas that have been part of the Brazilian constitutional debates for more than two centuries, and have been also present in past constitutional texts; (ii) a pragmatic response to past troubling experiences and institutional failures, reacting to some recurrent issues in Brazilian—and, more broadly, Latin American—political history with different institutional design solutions; and (iii) the specific political outcome of a long and negotiated democratic transition and a political diverse Constituent Assembly in which many divergent and, sometimes, conflicting interests were represented.


  • Open Access

    Pauta, público, princípios e precedentes: condicionantes e consequências da prática deliberativa do STF

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    A deliberação em um tribunal ocorre em momentos específicos. Mas há fatores que podem influenciar esses momentos deliberativos que precedem a deliberação propriamente dita. E a forma como um tribunal delibera e decide também tem efeitos que se protraem no tempo e influenciam deliberações futuras. Este artigo ocupa-se de algumas dessas condicionantes e consequências da prática deliberativa e decisória do Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), como a definição da pauta, os princípios e métodos de interpretação constitucional, a formação de um sistema de precedentes vinculantes, as audiências públicas e a relação do tribunal com seu público. Este é o último de uma série de artigos que expõem os resultados de uma pesquisa que pretendeu compreender o que os próprios ministros do STF pensam da prática deliberativa e decisória desse tribunal.


  • The Limits of Constitutional Law: Public Policies and the Constitution*

    by Virgilio Afonso da Silva

    This chapter resolves the apparently irreconcilable dichotomy, and shows that it is possible—and necessary— for both starting points to be respected, and that a discussion about the relation between the law—especially constitutional law and public policies would only become productive from the moment at which the need for such a resolution is taken seriously. In a classical liberal model, in which judges might be considered the ‘mouth of the law’, it is impossible to imagine that the judiciary might intervene, correct, and sometimes even define public policies. The government has priority in the implementation of public policies which carry out social and economic rights, but it is the duty of the judges to control it, complement it and correct it whenever necessary. For instance, by distributing medical treatment individually (that is, without considering government policies), judges may be harming other public policies in the area of health (or other areas), even if they manage to ‘solve’ some isolated cases.

  • The Gender Gap in Brazilian Politics and the Role of the Electoral Court

    by Luciana de Oliveira Ramos, Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    Like many other countries, Brazil has adopted gender quotas in elections for legislatures at all levels of the federation. However, Brazilian gender quotas have been ineffective at increasing women's participation in politics. Authors usually point to reasons related to the electoral system and party structure. This article analyzes a variable that is rarely considered: the role of the Electoral Court. We argue that the quality and intensity of the control exercised by an electoral court, when called upon to decide on the enforcement of the gender quota law, can influence the efficacy of this policy. We show that, in general, the Brazilian Superior Electoral Court tends to foster the participation of women in politics. However, based on two divides-between easy and difficult cases and between cases with low and high impact-we argue that in the realm of gender quotas, this court takes a rather restrained stance in those cases considered both difficult and with high impact.


  • Beyond Europe and the United States: the wide world of judicial review

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    This chapter calls for the abandonment of the simplistic dichotomy currently used to describe any system of judicial review—the “United States” or “European” models of judicial review. Drawing on extended examples from France, Brazil, Portugal, and the United States, as well as a survey of many other countries, the author argues that countries can be classified deceptively under the current schema. And, even when systems are categorized correctly, such a dualistic perspective ignores other, potentially more important, differences between systems such as differences in timing, appointment of judges, composition of the bench, term, access to the court, deliberation and decision-making processes, and effects of the court’s decisions. The chapter concludes by calling for an exploration of typologies which can move from the current dualism to a more expansive classificatory vocabulary in order to foster richness of discussion and research.


  • Big Brother is Watching the Court: Effects of TV Broadcasting on Judicial Deliberation

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    How much of the work of judges is known by the public varies considerably from country to country and even from court to court, in the same country. Institutional designs are highly diverse. Perhaps the most extreme case of publicity in courts is the public being allowed to watch judges debating. Few courts allow such publicity of the most sensitive moments of their decision-making process. Even fewer broadcast their deliberations live on TV. The Brazilian Supreme Court is one of them. This article does not intend to take sides in this debate. It does not intend to argue for or against the model of deliberation adopted by the Brazilian Supreme Court or the TV broadcasting of judicial deliberation in general. Rather, it aims to present a point of view that is sometimes neglected in academic studies on deliberation in constitutional courts or supreme courts: the view of the justices themselves. How much of the work of judges is known by the public varies considerably from country to country and even from court to court, in the same country. Institutional designs are highly diverse. Perhaps the most extreme case of publicity in courts is the public being allowed to watch judges debating. Few courts allow such publicity of the most sensitive moments of their decision-making process. Even fewer broadcast their deliberations live on TV. The Brazilian Supreme Court is one of them. This article does not intend to take sides in this debate. It does not intend to argue for or against the model of deliberation adopted by the Brazilian Supreme Court or the TV broadcasting of judicial deliberation in general. Rather, it aims to present a point of view that is sometimes neglected in academic studies on deliberation in constitutional courts or supreme courts: the view of the justices themselves. "Verfassung und Recht in Übersee (VRÜ)" analysiert die Verfassungs- und Rechtsentwicklung in den Staaten Asiens, Afrikas und Lateinamerikas sowie deren regionale wie internationale Einbindung. Die Zeitschrift widmet sich verfassungsvergleichend Regionen ausserhalb Europas unter Einbeziehung theoretischer und methodischer Grundlagen. Gegründet 1968 und inspiriert von Dekolonialisation und kooperativem Aufbruch veröffentlicht sie nicht zuletzt Untersuchungen zum Entwicklungsrecht. Neben ausführlichen Abhandlungen bietet "Verfassung und Recht in Übersee (VRÜ)" kürzere Berichte zu aktuellen Vorgängen oder Konferenzen sowie Buchbesprechungen. Als besonderen Service enthält jede Ausgabe eine Bibliographie einschlägiger Veröffentlichungen in Deutschland und der Welt, die in Zusammenarbeit mit dem Informationszentrum des Leibniz-Instituts für Globale und Regionale Studien (GIGA) erstellt wird. "Verfassung und Recht in Übersee (VRÜ)" wendet sich an Autoren und Leser von allen Kontinenten und versteht sich als Forum ihres Austauschs. Sie ist offen für Beiträge von Wissenschaftlern aus den Rechts- wie Sozialwissenschaften und von Praktikern aus den einschlägigen Institutionen (etwa der Entwicklungszusammenarbeit). "Verfassung und Recht in Übersee (VRÜ)" erscheint vierteljährlich und veröffentlicht Beiträge in Deutsch, Englisch, Spanisch und Französisch. Homepage: www.vrue.nomos.de "Law and Politics in Africa, Asia and Latin America" analyses legal and constitutional developments in all states or regions outside of Europe as well as their regional and international integration. Founded in 1968 and inspired by decolonization and the idea of a cooperative new beginning, the Journal also promotes a special interest in contributions on 'Law and development'. The journal aims to provide a forum for a variety of perspectives on these fields of interest, be they focused on one country or comparative, theoretical or methodological in nature. Next to extensive articles, the journal publishes shorter reports about current events or conferences as well as book reviews. As a special service, each issue of "Law and Politics in Africa, Asia and Latin America" contains an international bibliography of relevant publications from around the world. This is compiled in cooperation with the Leibniz-Institute for Global and Regional Studies in Hamburg (GIGA). "Law and Politics" addresses authors and readers on all continents and aims to serve as a forum of mutual exchange. The journal is open for contributions from legal and social sciences as well as for analyses from practitioners. The journal is published quarterly and welcomes contributions in German, English, Spanish and French. Website: www.vrue.nomos.de


  • Open Access

    O RELATOR DÁ VOZ AO STF? UMA RÉPLICA A ALMEIDA E BOGOSSIAN

    by Virgílio Afonso da Silva

    Em recente artigo publicado nesta revista, Danilo dos Santos Almeida e Andre Martins Bogossian defenderam interessante tese sobre o papel do ministro relator como unificador das razões de decidir dos acórdãos do Supremo Tribunal Federal. Em boa medida, o artigo dialoga com trabalho de minha autoria, também publicado nesta revista. Nesta breve réplica, pretendo mostrar que, a despeito dos bons argumentos de Almeida e Bogossian, estou convencido de que, ao menos no que diz respeito às decisões mais importantes do STF, a relevância que eles dão ao voto do ministro relator é exagerada. Embora o voto do relator seja de fato aquele que fornece as razões de decidir nos casos corriqueiros e repetitivos, até porque nesses casos muitas vezes o voto do relator é a única peça escrita e articulada, isso não é necessariamente verdade nas decisões mais importantes do STF.